Added: 5 years ago
From: Dawnofthedusk
Views: 70,611
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (280)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • That's just wonderful!

  • this is my fav because it makes me remeber the ones i have lost

  • Within Temptation = Awesome.

  • i love this video itso cool and so sad

  • its been about two years since i first watched this video. its my favourite video on youtube, i just love it!

  • very cool

  • I love the video, but who is the song by? She has such a haunting voice...

  • The song is "Memories" by Within Temptation

  • It's so tender!!!, thank you very much

  • it's GREAT!!!! thank you very much!

  • oehhh, within temptation song!!

  • Wow, this is loverly..! I don't watch DW very often though, and I've been wondering what happened to her. Why is Catherine Tate on DW now, and where'd Rose go..??? Thanks!

  • rose got separted from the doctor in an episode called doomsday

  • Great vid...It goes to favorites. *clickety click*

    And it's so sad. I cried my eyes out.

  • I cried uncontrollable for about 10 minutes before i could control myself and press play

  • oh i just can not belive that they left echother they are the best astinst oh im gonna cry witout rose

  • This is one of my favorite Doctor Who fanvideos. It's so hard to find a good one with the right scenes and the right music.

    **HELP-there was a fan video created by Buffyangelfan titled Doctor and Rose - Our Farewell (song by Within Temptation). This was one of my favorites that was removed from YouTube. Another was Doctor Who - Trouble (song by Coldplay) created by Sp00ky89. If anyone knows how I could get a copy of them is would be appreciated.

  • CRYCRYCRY

  • i luv the show and i luv the song

  • simply beautiful.

  • this is freaking amazing.

  • aww great video, really like the song.

    life is cruel );

  • Lovely video, I didn't want to look away. It's an original song choice! Great job switching between clips.

  • Rose and the Doc 4EVER!!!!! love their story and pray it continues.... just cant let this couple go! to much going for them! Have to hand this to ya, great video of them. THANKS!

  • beautiful

  • whats the name of the song/artist?

  • Watch the credits at the end of the video.

  • I also cried((( it is pity...

  • i remember i cried when rose and the doctor separated T.T

  • so did i and still do

  • me too :(

  • Awesome video, great editing and putting together, a great song too. Well Done, brought tears to my eyes

  • Amazing. (:

  • this is the best rose & doctor video of all!!!

  • This is beautiful!!! It made me get tears in my eyes, I love it! This is one of the best Doctor/Rose videos ever made!

  • this is beautiful well done

    u deserve the nice comments!

    this is great

    love the song =]

  • Amazing!

  • Hah! I finally found this video again! Just a minute ago I finally, after months of videowatching, found a goodbye-Rose video I like just a smidge better than it, but this still remains my second favourite ever. :) It's so lovely...so sad...-sniffles- Must go find something happy to do now...

  • absolutely perfect.

  • that was beautiful!!

  • it made me cry too awesome video

  • Amazing video, thanks very much for it. Lush song too, I hadn't heard it before.

  • Rose Is Coming Back to Doctor Who Yay!!!

  • I love it!!!!! Doctor who is my ultimate favourite show!!! I miss Rose!!

  • your not the only one :(

    great vid!!! :)

  • Wow..this was totally lovely :)

    made me cry ...

  • That was just totally awesome -- bloody well done...

  • it made me cry,

  • wow that was bloody amazing. i love that song too. im a huge fan of that band too and of course the doctor and rose. brillant vid! gonna add to my faves!

  • hey she is the one of the mercado libre's song ..

    i fall in ove with you look it its veeery cool! i love it

  • this is freaking amazing.

  • I'm still coming back to this! Is the best video that I have seen here!!!

  • Perfect choice of music for this subject.

    I also like the black/white vs colored parts, really accentuates the memories, and how they are in the past.

    Long time since I loved a MusicVid so much.

    Cheers!

  • great vid. artfully put together and the music fits perfectly.

  • Loved it. Perfect choice of scenes, awesome timing, lovely music :D

  • i almost forced myself to forget how sad it was for rose to go but now uve made me remember :(

    but shes back!

    i love her and the doctor

  • Wow.

    Just wow.

    That was truly awesome. So incredibly sad and amazing.

    The song fits so perfectly, so yeah. General amazingness.

    *favourites*

  • Wow, it's really awesome... Made me cry a little bit... I love the couple of Rose&the Doctor and the music is simply perfect for them (love WT as well^^). Anyway, great and toutching video. Nedd to watch it few more times...

  • ah...uh...freakin...freakin holy crap...that just about made me cry...again...every time i watch it...dang. it's so beautiful. so sad, so beautiful. nice job. i still like to live in my fantasy realm where the season 2 finale and anything afterwards never happened...and yet, i keep watching this...because it's awesome...

  • Wow. Noo seriously wow.

    ive watched the doomsday episode loads of times and even though theyve made me really sad, i never cried (i neva cry at tv or films) but that video actually made me properly cry! it was so nice! i luved how it kept flashing back in black and white and when it comes back to the beach it actually looks like they are remembering it because they look really sad : (

  • Me cont. lol i know rose is cumin back for the new series (i saw her in the knew episode and i so wanna know whats goin on!!) but i hope the doctor and her like get together again or sumthin, like they were in series 2 cuz i like martha/donna obv. but there just not the same! i hope its not wierd when rose and the doctor meet again.Anywayz, soz for the rambling X D but i needed to get it out , ur vid was bril; : )

  • I was crying SO hard.

    No other music video has produced tears that fast-I think 10 seconds in they were already running down my face. I'd forgotton about this song, and it just fits so damn perfectly.

    But Billie's coming back, and she IS in the finale, Doctor and all. And he better be able to FINISH HIS SENTENCE this time, or else RTD's gonna have a million shippers trying to stab him with sharp implements. Including myself, and I'm sure, many of you. :D

    Cheers!

  • everytime i watch this video i cry. i screemed noooooooooooooooooo at the tv when i saw daoomsday! i cried for weeks and weeks after, i was in such denil! they are a very big and important part of my life and have helped me through some tough times.

  • bloodmoon101 comment cont: i know how sad this vid is so even before the words start i cry. i love within temtiation and have all there songs on my mp4 play, i especially love memories and our farwell.

  • this is amazing! i love the fact that it always flashes back to the same scene. it always makes me cry at the end were the doctor is about to say 'i love you' anyways, great video, 5* favourited, and subscribtion

    wow, aren't you lucky xD

    emzy

    xx

  • that is true i suppose.. i was v. upset during all of that and actually screamin at the tv!!... i have this feelin that things arnt gonna be the same wen she does return.. that they wont actually tlk about what happened on tht beach.. like wen the doctor dismisses stuff in general.. also all three assistants will be there probably and it'll be like they have no chance to say things...after all it has been such a long time.

  • welling up.. .:why did he take so long to say what he was gonna say.!!!. and its even worse she couldnt touch him..

  • i know, but it'd make me cry even more if she was huggig him and then he just disappeared.

  • this was the first video i ever saw on youtube-seriously. and i loved it it was so sad and so heartfelt!

  • wow, this was the first video I ever saw on youtube too!! I never even knew youtube existed until I was given the link to this video. Still makes meh cry :(

    xx

  • me too, i was positively wailing by the end!!! XD why couldnt he just say it really quickly? for god sakes, he's a time traveller who cares about messing up time just get back to her!

  • I know!! God, he's such an idiot!! lol, I cannae wait till she comes back series four -squees- xx

  • i know! XDD i cant wait either--i mean i like martha but rose is sooooooo much better!!! ive been really bored since they stopped filming so i just watch the old ones over and over and over and over and over and....

    again!

  • I'd forgotten how much I love this song/vid!!

    xx

  • Great vid!!! Great song!!!

  • who sings this... what an amazing video!! they are one of the greatest couples ever!!!!

  • It's in the credits at the end of the video.

  • It's by within temptation

  • reli sweet vid

  • Like a few of you said, made me cry aswell when i watched it!

    Brilliant Vid, keep it up!

  • absolutely FANTASTIC i love this video, it made me cry the first time i watched it

    Brilliant job!!

  • I love this song and it works great the way you put it in the vid amazing Doctor/Rose all the way i can't wait till their reunited

  • I LOVE this song. It's so perfect for Doctor/Rose

  • i love docter who i hate my brother and i love this song nice vid!!!!!!! out of 100/100

  • wow.

    amazing video.

    i love the doctor and rose .

    they are by far the greatest couple in the universe :]

    xXxXx

  • love your name.!

  • thanks :):)

  • TOTALLY AGREED!!!!!

  • Great vid!!! Great music!!!

  • Made me cry! And that was amazing she said I love you with the music! LOL! Great editing.

  • rle gr8 vidd !!! can i jst ask where d yo get yur cips from t oput in th video ? x

  • Amazing vid.I just can't wait for the reunion! The writers had better not stuff it up though, the Doctor and Rose deserve the very best. Thanks!

  • i was crying when she left

  • Yup, Forsaken is from their album "Silent Force". V lovely video! Memories is my absolute favourite song of all time. Smooth editing; I teared up watching it.

  • Beautiful... *Wipes away tear*

    Still peeved with the Christmas Special, though. I wish the Doc would just stick with Rose (Who he is obviously in love with. It occured to me a while ago that Russel T Davis wanted to show the beauty of this couple by having sweet moments insted of them kissing willy nilly. I prefer it like that xD)But apparently the re-unitation of The Doctor & Rose will be really worth watching Donna throughout the eppisodes (Sorry, I'm not keen on her.)

  • No it's a band called Within Temptation.

  • your vid is really good, how do u get the clips cause i want to make a doctorwho vid. thanx u.

  • wow awesome vid...i hope i can make vids as good as that at some point in my life lol

    well done

    xXx

  • ;-; amazing vid.

    I love what you did with the 'darling you know i love you till the end of time' line, it was vair impressive you got her to 'say' it x]

  • my boyfriend loves this show and i was wondering if you could tell me what season/episode it was when the doctor had to leave rose?

    thanks.

  • Season 2 last episode 181 "Doomsday"

  • aww awesome video :)

    loved it loadss!

    Doctor + Rose = Match made in heaven! ;]

    xx

  • Best video ever!!!

  • oi, you lot! *waves like a loon* Rose is coming back! seriously, check out the BBC official site :D but gah, still choking up with this vid... so lovely. id fave and 5-star it again if itd do any good hehe

  • i cried when i saw the last one it was so down to earth!

  • amazing love this video!¬!! who sings this?

  • It's in the credits at the end of the video.

  • oh this is so sad that ep was so sad i cried so bad i love dr who best series in the universe swear ta god but rose was perfect though i didnt reallly like martha she was a bit...annoying...but rose was so perfect for him they could have had mini doctors! :)

  • mini doctors... ooh, now thats an image :D

  • this video is soooooooo sad

  • wow i made a video with this song i got so used to mine that it feels different to urs thats just because i have seen mine alot more but urs is really great i do like it and please see and comment mine

  • Wow....that made me cry....a lot.

  • All of my memories keep you near..

    Omg I miss Rose so much, she was perfect fro the doctor. GREAT vid. Best ive watched all day. GREAT song and GREAT ship.

  • cries right from the start and the whole way through. sits cluching doctor (david tennant) and rose tyler (billie piper) dolls. i really quiet everytime i watch this video am like it for the rest of the day. last time i tried to watch it i got like a minute in a could not watch the rest. yer they really affected me and my life. i just relate to them so much and love them so much. i really hope rose comes back cos the docter needs her. he cant be without her.

  • faved and 5*ed... *crawls into a dark corner and wails like a banshee army*

  • omfg! i cant bare to wach this cos its so sad and i have just wached our fairwell so im really depressed! check out my comment on that video and you will see wat i mean. i have watch this vid many times b4 thoough and cry everytime. i do the same as what i said in the comment for our fairwell.

  • of all the "tv couples" they were my fav. nice vid:)

  • Where did you get the clips?

    Wonderful job! This couple is my favorite ever!

  • *cry* i want rose back :(

  • What is the music for this?

    LOVE THE VID AMAZIN

  • It's in the credits at the end of the video.

  • Really different choice of song. :) I like it... I think we all miss Rose. She was just fantastic! I have already made so many Doctor and Rose vids, and i can't seem to stop! Such a great story.... :)

  • i don't think there's been a unanimous love for a doctor who girl, like there was for Rose. Everyone wants her back. i know i do.

  • sob sob sob every time i watch. check out my other comments.

  • ASOME!!!!!

  • Never get tired of this vid.

  • Is it weird that i watch this video about 50 times a day [not exaggeration] and i cry everytime i watch it? lol i don't care if it makes me the most pathetic person in the world, i love it!! =']

  • Amazingly timed, great pick of song, and well put together!

    ...excuse me while I go cry

  • this is so brilliant by the way =]

  • i always burst into tears when Rose says "I love you" ='[

    how do you make these videos anyway?

  • A programme called 'Windows Movie Maker'.

  • =O thanks! =D

  • Where can I get some clips, I'd be so grateful if you could let me know where there are some availible. Thanks.

  • What a fantastic piece of sound and picture artwork, it's like the trailer for some epic must-see movie! It made me cry as it suits so perfectly the genius writing of the Dr Who storyline which it represents. I should think even Russell T Davies himself would be delighted with it - he couldn't find a better compliment if he tried. And I've had to seek out more info about Within Temptation... Fantastic!!

  • 03.36 i know someome that looks like david tennant

  • We want Rose back! Sign the petition for a Doctor Who movie with Rose and the Doctor (we'll be sending it to the BBC when we get enough signatures):

    w-w-w dot petitiononline dot com / rosie111

  • oh god you made me cry how sad is that!! This is a brillinat video..nice editing, well done!

  • -bawls-

  • david tennant is well fit!!!

  • Really nice video, really matches the music! :)

  • im not usually a soppy person but wen i wathin doctor who u'd fink i was a complete soppy git its soo good it makes me cry!

  • Amazing! And good choice of song! So perfect for it!

  • A beautiful vid for such a beautiful ship.

  • If I could, I'd trade both the birth and death of the universe and earth, respectively, for Rose to have stayed with the Doctor for all eternity...

  • I lkOVE THSI VIDEO IT ROCK AND LOVE THE SHOW

  • *crys* there such a good couple :'(

  • That was so beautiful...I miss them together ;___;

  • *Cries hysterically*

    That is so awesome, but sooooo sad.

    And when she sang "darling I love you" and you put Rose slowed down crying and saying I love you, it was the worst and yet the best thing ever.

    Awesome. One million out of five stars. Shame I can't rate it that high on youtube XD.

  • I completly agree! I was going to write a long, soppy comment on this vid but then I saw your comment and I realized that you had written what I was going to say, I didn't bother!

  • This is really good.

    Such a sad song but it works beautifully.

    I like Martha but I will forever miss our dear Rose and I agree with the others what made Rose's love for the Doctor special is that it was devloped other time.

    Martha just met him,receievd a kiss and that was it she was instantly in love with him.

  • Stunning. I love this! bring back Rose!!

  • I like Freema but she's just no Rose. I really hope the Doctor never really gets over Rose, they belong together. I agree, her character IS too perfect. And she just "fell in love with him" or just crushes on him, yeah? (No offense to Freema-she's a great actress) But Rose and the Doctor's love grew over time, and that's what made it so special.

  • All of my memories keep you near!!!!!! ;-]

  • I agree, such good combo of song and vid. So awful and sad but at the same time one of the best things I've ever seen on Doctor Who. Well Done!

  • Uh-oh. I said I wasn't going to watch anymore Doctor Who vids until after I finished watchong the second season. -_- I just ruined it. Oh well!

    That was beautiful, I barely held back tear and held my breath while I watched it. This song is sad on its own. Add it with the sorrow at that scene, you've got the Tearjerker Queen. Ah-maz-ing.

  • Omg...

    I know a lot of people just say it because the video was so good... but this must of been brilliant, because I actually AM crying :'[

    I love this :'] 5/5 perfect song too x

  • very nice! I love WT and Doctor Who, so this is an awesome video!

    I can tolerate Martha a bit better now, but I still am loyal to Rose; always have and always will be. True Martha does seem a bit too perfect, which is y I couldn't stand her that much. I could relate to Rose better because she was ordinary like me, and yet had so much to offer. The only reason I can stand Martha a bit better is after the episodes Human Nature and Family Of Blood.

  • I totally agree. I feel the exact same, she's a little more ok now that the family of blood episodes.

  • This so sad! Great work.

  • <3..Beautiful...<3 x x taa 4 de upload very emotional :( x x

  • =......[ I wish Rose was still here 2day =[ I have grown to love this song now. =[

  • this was amazing!

    xxxheatherxxx

  • *sigh* I miss doctor who...they stopped airing it in my country...

  • Perfect song for the best Doctor Who episode ever.. Very moving (5 stars)

  • apparently kylie isnt going to be in the christmas special rose was the best waayy nicer with david tennant than freema agyeman they had more chemistry

  • the stuff of legend

  • i miss rose

  • Lovely song...Memories by Within Temptation!!

  • omg apparently freema aygeman isnt gonna be in series 4 yay! hopefully *fingers crossed* rose will come back

  • I heard about that as well! :-(

    I think that Kylie will be the companion in the Christmas Special, and Rachel Stevens might be joining at the beginning of Series Four. :-?

  • I don't think there's any way Billie would want to come back, at least, not as a regular. Wouldn't mind seeing her one more time just to give her story a decent conclusion, but having her back permanently would be a big step backwards, especially with Martha around now. What's wrong with Freema, anyway?

  • she just isnt as good an actress as billie piper....

  • True very true, ;-]

  • I'm ok with Freema but Billie was much better I think. =]