your all forgetting this is live of course other singers sound slightly better t pre-recorded and edited for quality no one can really sing as perfect as in music videos or soundtracks. so compared to that canned shit she is very good :D
sometimes they make singing sound slightly bad in films on purpose to make it more natural. her imperfect singing in POTC was absolutely PERFECT for the film. the dullness in her voice, the way it was slightly off tune... i was amazed at how perfect all the singing fit into the film. thumbs up to Hans Zimmer!
She sounds amazing here as well. she really is an actress. she acts with her singing voice as well... fabulous.
So true...I don't see how one could even compare the two! I've seen that a lot of people seem to be complaining that Keira's not a 'great' singer, but the vocal performance is perfect for a role like this...I mean, they preferred women's voices to be much higher and clearer then, didn't they? Tastes change, after all.
Alright, so I've concluded 2 things after watching this:
1) Keira is just drop dead gorgeous....holy cow
2) That girl can SING!
It sounds like these songs don't show exactly how much talent she has, but it's definitely there! I love it when stars like her turn out to be multi-talented. :)
RIGHT before they clap. Close your eyes and listen for a country voice...Wow..she's amazin-CLAPING! You gotta listen really closely. Right when she finished.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i doubt that's her. somebody who has never sung before in her life can't sing that well. plus it doesn't even sound like her, it sounds way to high-pitched.
Yeah it is her. I know for sure in the first clip she sang it live, but I don't know about 2nd one. But it is her. And I agree. She has an amazing voice!
Woah...Didn't know she could sing!
velvetsnape 2 years ago
i think her voice suits the time this movie is set in :)
goldentuna 2 years ago
your all forgetting this is live of course other singers sound slightly better t pre-recorded and edited for quality no one can really sing as perfect as in music videos or soundtracks. so compared to that canned shit she is very good :D
grimess66 2 years ago
she has a very nice voice. keira roxxxx!!!!!
OceanOfTwilight 2 years ago 2
cool
lostblackpantie 2 years ago
is she really singing or is it lypsincin b'cause in pirates it dousn't sound too well, not that it has to se's not a singer..!
lostblackpantie 2 years ago
She said she sang live.
dramaangelPirates 2 years ago
sometimes they make singing sound slightly bad in films on purpose to make it more natural. her imperfect singing in POTC was absolutely PERFECT for the film. the dullness in her voice, the way it was slightly off tune... i was amazed at how perfect all the singing fit into the film. thumbs up to Hans Zimmer!
She sounds amazing here as well. she really is an actress. she acts with her singing voice as well... fabulous.
OperaNotes 2 years ago
She's actually singing, she said she had to have a few shots to get the courage to ;)
katyburg 2 years ago
anyone know if you can get audio of the songs she sings? like are they on the soundtrack? (if there is one)
ExAxLxPx12 2 years ago
They are on the soundtrack!! WHICH REMINDS ME I HAVE TO BUY IT!! i forgot..
Love these song :D
Lucifer150 2 years ago 2
she sounds good
teziiii 3 years ago 2
i dont like, better to be an actress
annamiracle 3 years ago
She's so much better than Britney Spears.
zacattack214 3 years ago 11
So true...I don't see how one could even compare the two! I've seen that a lot of people seem to be complaining that Keira's not a 'great' singer, but the vocal performance is perfect for a role like this...I mean, they preferred women's voices to be much higher and clearer then, didn't they? Tastes change, after all.
EireDahlia 3 years ago 3
Alright, so I've concluded 2 things after watching this:
1) Keira is just drop dead gorgeous....holy cow
2) That girl can SING!
It sounds like these songs don't show exactly how much talent she has, but it's definitely there! I love it when stars like her turn out to be multi-talented. :)
ags072889 3 years ago 8
she actually can sing so shut up. keira is the messiah. she is the chosen one.
and LOL at shes amazin !
georgeehurricane 3 years ago 5
lol. At 2:28 listen closely. one dude said, 'Wow. She's amazing!'
X-D
PirateGirl247 3 years ago
i cant hear it!! :) ha good listening tho!!!
Krs21705 3 years ago
RIGHT before they clap. Close your eyes and listen for a country voice...Wow..she's amazin-CLAPING! You gotta listen really closely. Right when she finished.
PirateGirl247 3 years ago
haha i hear it now :D!!!! thats funny!!!
Krs21705 3 years ago
I KNOW!!! ISN'T IT?!!! X-D
PirateGirl247 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i doubt that's her. somebody who has never sung before in her life can't sing that well. plus it doesn't even sound like her, it sounds way to high-pitched.
Haflor 3 years ago
It is her. There is a whole article about. But she said that she had a few singing lessons when she was younger.
dramaangelPirates 3 years ago
She had a voice coach, Claire Underwood. She worked with her for this movie. Keira's jsut naturally talented. Amazing huh?
PirateGirl247 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not really, she's not that good.
Haflor 3 years ago
Then you don't know talent.
dramaangelPirates 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i do, that's why i know this is a bad performance. :)
Haflor 3 years ago
Like I said you don't know talent.
dramaangelPirates 3 years ago
Hear, Hear.
PirateGirl247 3 years ago
is it actually her?? if it is then she is really good :P:p
misswolfie07 3 years ago
Yeah it is her. I know for sure in the first clip she sang it live, but I don't know about 2nd one. But it is her. And I agree. She has an amazing voice!
dramaangelPirates 3 years ago
She sang live in all her singing scenes.
PirateGirl247 3 years ago
I prefer the second one, but both sound great.
LoveHowardBanister 3 years ago