why is it on nearly every industrial music video on youtube there are always arguments such as "which band is true industrial and which is not" or "damn reznor, he sold out industrial to mainstream" or shit like that....we should all unite against MTV, emos, dance music artists - the ones who are really destroying music. :))
I wish I had been older when this and the good Bad seeds stuff first came out. I've been listening to it for getting on 10 years, but to have been older when they were doing it, to go and see them live would have been mind blowing. *sigh* music is just not the same any more. EN over NIN and Ministry any bloody day.
LOL why flaming Trent,,His album year zero is prolly the best industrial music ever made,,but then comparing US vs German EU music is like comparing Front 242 with Ministry..
Good fucking keerist. I like NIN, EN, FNM, RATM et fucking cetera. Why all the rabid need to pigeonhole? Original schmoriginal. If it's decent tunage, it's decent tunage. Even M.I.A. kicked some arse sampling directly from the Clash who kick no small amount of arse themselves.
Just enjoy what you like and leave the rest to the rest. Peace be with you.
correct me if i'm wrong, but didnt they end up on Nothing Records? and if memory serves me correctly, last time i checked, that i was owned by trent reznor
My favourite style is EBM, yet as a lover of originality i love this song and many of their others. I prefer to listen to Front 242 or Nitzer Ebb for an evening, but i always have a place in my heart for this band and their fantastic sound which many inferiors have tried and failed to replicate.
this flamewar is pathetic. obviously many are very intense about their favourite artist, and since NIN make alternative rock with industrial influences while EN count as a true industrial band noone can possibly appreciate both equally.
you guys are fighting over who has the better taste in music, not which band is better! if you wanna express your love for Emmerich's "singing" and dont care about meaningful lyrics, dont mask it with pretentious music theory ;-D
This is the song that got me addicted to Neubauten. too bad i have never found a version of the music video that isn't so pixelly and low quality though, haha. but oh well. :'(
You know, it really isn't necessary to attack Nine Inch Nails just to promote Einstürzende Neubauten. Both are extremely talented, and the fact that Reznor's sound was influenced by EN should by no means be looked at as a bad thing.
Aw, the final appearance of Mark Chung - I miss him. Oh, and I never noticed what gorgeous, womanly eyes Blixa has - I wonder if he's wearing mascara in this vid?
correct me if I'm wrong, but the album TABULA RASA is made in 1993, so I think NIN were before that one, and since this is the only song that sounds like them...
I'm sorry to break it to you but these guys were around many years before NIN. even if you don't like it they should be shown respect for being one of the founders of Industrial
I do show respect for them... I didn't say that all of their stuff sounds like NIN, only that one, which I think people will agree. other songs are anything but NIN.
Bands like Depeche Mode were sampling Neubauten over a decade before that corporate poseur Reznor was even out of short-pants. He owes his entire sound to EN and to Jim Thirlwell, and isn't fit to lick their boots.
@orchidtender they are amazing but man don't insult reznor he is good in his own right. and look at Year Zero great album with a great message. ART IS RESISTANCE!
@W4RW017 there are dozens of EN samples throughout the "Some Great Reward" album. The most obvious ones are on "People are People". There are others, but I can't think of them off-hand.
@orchidtender Reznor ruined the goth/industrial scene :( There was a drastic change in the clubs when "The Crow" and Reznor got out: they brought the trendy mass in through the doors, and it just hasn't been the same since. (Remember the 'clown' makeup...the black line across the eye from forehead to cheek? And all the NIN shirts...)
Even though i'd say Reznor took his sound from EN, Depeche mode took the sound from SpK. And when spk went to become something similiar (synthpop), they were called Depeche mode, test dept and EN-ripoffs.
Not only that, take into account Reznor's constant whining: in his music, his interviews, his general opinion on everything. Industrial music isn't about whining, and it isn't Pretty Hate Machine.
@KingOfUm yeah, the "angry lonerman" schtick kind of loses its edge when one becomes an accepted, admired multimillionaire living his fantasy day in, day out. Maybe he's still so angry because one of his lackeys forgot to remove the blue M&Ms from the bowl in his vast, groupie-filled dressing room.
His whole bit is so contrived, too. Like how he claimed he "didn't know" that the house he bought to convert into a studio was one of the Manson family murder sites.
Amen to that; I mean, Reznor does have some good material, but his potential value as an artist is undermined by his self-indulgence. Personally, I love his Ghosts album, but I think that'll be the very last good thing he'll do. Funny though, Reznor's fans can wait half a decade for a new album and once it's out call him a genius no matter the outcome. Lucky, lucky man.
@orchidtender Rezno could have taken a sound but his lyrics is not artsy like EN or Bauhaus but rather goes in paranoid/despair/psychological/reflective way. but musically - what the hell, rammstein completely ows its sound to Laibach, some EN songs have strong krautrock influence and so what...
You should tattoo on your forehead "I feel to not think" because if you start the "he owes him for that" your gonna end up with a society culturally bankrupt.
@orchidtender And Neubauten (and Foetus) owe their sound to Stockhausen, John Cage, Pierre Schaeffer and Luigi Rusollo (hell, even Lou Reed's Metal Machine Music). They in turn owe their sounds to others before them. All interesting art makes reference to previous contexts.
I jumped on the bashing Trent bandwagon way back when he was a pup taking over industrial music and turning it into disco, but 20 years later, I now have a respect for his work. He has integrity that many don't.
@orchidtender If you don't like NIN go listen to EN, which I like, but I'm sorry, I prefer Reznor. Music is ALL about getting inspiration from other bands you like and that doesn't make you a poser, YOU need an education. NIN has been one of the best music acts out there in terms of rock and industrial fusion, even in experimental sound (listen to Ghosts or Year Zero), so please, respect. It's like saying oh The Prodigy fucking posers we all know Kraftwerk started it all and... God.
Rammstein is awesome, but so are these guys, and they're kinda in totally seperate genres so they aren't comparable.
I've been a fan of Rammstein for years, and only JUST gotten into these guys, but already, if I had to choose between the two, I'd go absolutely nuts! lol
I laugh at all the people that try to compare EN with NIN.
NIN pushed the genre so far that it killed the genre.
I love SP, KMFDM, Ministry, etc.. all of them are so different, they all have their styles, even Nitzer ebb & front 242 but in my oppinion NIN did more with Industrial than any of those bands.
Anyway, throbbling Gristle were the first and the true pioneers.
Id prefer tihs songi f they used some distorted Skinny Puppy/FLA/Z'EV voice effects, it fits better to the genre than the "rock" version.. buti love idferences, thats y i love Industrial and experimental music, underground, uninvented, mind music, etc. And afterall, it is called Industrial Rock.
I agree and I love both of them too. Reznor never said that he plays industrial music, it's mainstream that says this because they want to label everything. Though he has made music which I would totally call post-industrial. It's not necessarry to hate him just because he made it big, that's what people have to understand.
Although ihs early works+Ghosts-I-IV album is 100% pure (not-anti-music/lyrical version) rhytmic industrial, go check it out! If he wnats to create Industrial he should follow his Ghosts work(thge industrial songs)
tabula rasa ist immer noch meine lieblingsscheibe von den neubauten. was für eine kraft, was für ein sprachreichtum. und das hier - einfach genial: ein stück klang-lyrik, in dem man sich einfach verlieren kann.
idiot....the music of this band was in inspiration to skinny puppy an reznor. you just dismiss the fact that there was a time,where reznor war a noone, sitting in his room and making up his music style....and though trents a genious, he had many influences. and this is one of them. so f*ck you
I'm actually a NIN fan, I was just pointing out that if Trent "ripped off" anyone it's more likely Watts then Ogre because he was at some point a pretty big fan.
@warjunky444 EN push all the envelopes, including their own. Of course it used to be all "clang-clang", but they can be intensely subtle and melodic sometimes, too. CHeck out the Ende Neu album. Stella Maris and The Garden are two of the most beautiful songs you will ever hear. Even my mom - who is 75 - like s them!
They arn't that bad really. A lot of douchebags think they are the most goth thing since Andrew Eldritch listen to them, but a band can't help who likes them. Unless, of course, they dress like a transvestite and pose on girly magazine posters like some bands out there..
EN definately is better, though. They are one of the cornerstones of industrial music, and definately one of the most innovative.
I love these guys. I saw them a couple times in Chicago in the early 90's. I was not goth or industrial, I was just a regular guy who loved music and hung out in the back. They had nothing in the way of lights or special effects, but they were thoroughly creative and entertaining. One thing I respect about them is that, as great as they are, they never sold out.
well, just what the definition states. it seems like it is that vein of german industrial music which I find to be given way to much credit. I wont sit here and say that I know all there is to know about electronic music. but I think there are way better forms of it than this. There is much more intelligent forms of of electro music such as drum and bass or jungle.
But just look at the guy. his facial expressions and the muddled camera shots. it all just seems cliche to me. I guess Im not hip.8)
Ya can't judge EN by a few videos. Blixa (the vocalist) is a dramatic persona. maybe too dramatic at times?EN have very intelligent lyrics, they make their own instruments, I could go on. Look them up a bit before you write them off. I will say however, They aren't as intriguing as they once were. Avoid their cd "the jewels" if you can. A tad over hyped. Good night.
this video isn't typical Neubauten. it's strange how it is almost like a pop video, but this is far from a typical. certain shots of Blixa dancing are very unique & would not be imitated by other artists. anyway, you say that "vein" of German industrial music but the fact is, industrial music was invented by Neubauten. they are music pioneers. as well, the lyrics are incredible. "the guy" as you call him, Blixa, has even taught creative writing. how many rock stars do that? read the lyrics!
why is it on nearly every industrial music video on youtube there are always arguments such as "which band is true industrial and which is not" or "damn reznor, he sold out industrial to mainstream" or shit like that....we should all unite against MTV, emos, dance music artists - the ones who are really destroying music. :))
rude1987 1 month ago
that logo is lame, too
sucklingfatty 2 months ago
i thought this band was supposed to be 'experimental', this looks plenty 90's cheese to me
sucklingfatty 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hi there,somebody knows if there is today any other band that play like them?like under a indie label..thank you!
83papple 3 months ago
Rammstein and NIN borrowed a lot from this band. Fantastic stuff, no wonder they did. If I had a band I would.
celticbryan 4 months ago
Golliwogg APPROVES of this song.
GolliwoggMusic 4 months ago
Sooooo sexy.
Kyrindattara 5 months ago
Das macht mich wollen, um Deutsch zu lernen. Blixa hast du es wieder!
bloderme 5 months ago
Such a brilliant song and video.
jgg017 5 months ago
Interesting to note that no one mentioned here how much Reznor was influenced by Coil. Oh well.
sfmattyd2 6 months ago
good song, great band !!!
selamlarvi 7 months ago
I wish I had been older when this and the good Bad seeds stuff first came out. I've been listening to it for getting on 10 years, but to have been older when they were doing it, to go and see them live would have been mind blowing. *sigh* music is just not the same any more. EN over NIN and Ministry any bloody day.
kittenclaire 8 months ago
fuck, blixa is sooo sexy.
correcttech 9 months ago 4
Okay, the only North-American groups that could be considered comparable to the European Industry, Ministry or Revoltingcocks only.
Any other underground group to consider.
But NIN is good, but sounds that are commercial, therefore, ENB RULES ....
dexosiribunucleico 9 months ago
LOL why flaming Trent,,His album year zero is prolly the best industrial music ever made,,but then comparing US vs German EU music is like comparing Front 242 with Ministry..
MurderMetal69 9 months ago
great clip, wish the video quality was better
bolicsoundz 9 months ago
かっこいいね。今５０代なんですよね。
spanaria 9 months ago
かっこいいね。今５０代
spanaria 9 months ago
Me too man!I can listen this song every days and every hours !! :-)
fgcia 9 months ago
Me too man!I can listen this song every days and every hours !! :-)
fgcia 9 months ago
I honestly, even as a fan of Einsturzende Neubauten, I still respect Reznor, possibly because he's a local hero.
ohiogrinder 10 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i could make this song in fuckin 15 minutes
danielhl22 1 year ago
@danielhl22 but you didn't.
theclockworkgnome 1 year ago 3
@danielhl22 go on then
1jcanham 1 year ago
@danielhl22 Why don't you????
aleksoraven 1 year ago
Blixa ist der einzige Mann, den ich heiraten würde!! <3
Sraz 1 year ago 3
Good fucking keerist. I like NIN, EN, FNM, RATM et fucking cetera. Why all the rabid need to pigeonhole? Original schmoriginal. If it's decent tunage, it's decent tunage. Even M.I.A. kicked some arse sampling directly from the Clash who kick no small amount of arse themselves.
Just enjoy what you like and leave the rest to the rest. Peace be with you.
pang5 1 year ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
I'd love if Blixa and Trent were sitting together having a cup of tea, reading these comments and basically laughing their arses off. :-P
therewasnonameleft 1 year ago
I'd love it if Blixa and Trent were sitting together with a cup of tea, reading these comments and basically laughing their arses off. :-P
therewasnonameleft 1 year ago 7
correct me if i'm wrong, but didnt they end up on Nothing Records? and if memory serves me correctly, last time i checked, that i was owned by trent reznor
meimtwiztid420 1 year ago
@meimtwiztid420 Only one CD pressing of Ende Neu.
orchidtender 1 year ago
Comment removed
meimtwiztid420 1 year ago
Sooooo looking forward seeing them in a month!
smattraensalva 1 year ago
Went to see them in Amsterdam last week, brilliant !
trollfinger 1 year ago
Einsturzende Neubaten rules forever!!!
crapula777 1 year ago
Whether EN is doing experimental or pop, Blixa is always an amazing frontman.
KatarinaSu 1 year ago
I have always loved this song but never saw them.......COOL!!! I like Blixa...
AlouaisA 1 year ago
this REALLY REALLY REALLY sounds like a foreign trent reznor
MansonNiles11 1 year ago
BLIXA BARGELD IST KRIEG!!
meestafeesh 1 year ago
Anyone else think he sounds like he's rapping a little? At the end?
*crickets*
Ok, ok, I'll keep my opinions to myself.
roadsideflowers 1 year ago
music is good but vocals are too pop-ish.
Killnine90 1 year ago
it isn`t bad
Morpheeeene 1 year ago
It figures in the end they would turn into a pop wantabe band.
woogado2 1 year ago
FYI, they cut this one to ribbons...gotta be a snob and say the album versions better.
The shattered glass solo is easily one of my favorite Moments In Experimental Music.
T_T
kikuchiyo77 1 year ago
This thing makes me think that these guys had a Daoist mental breakdown.
:D
Genial, keine Frage...
kikuchiyo77 1 year ago
I juz heard like 4 seconds of the song and I was like,''OMFG THIS IS SO GOOD!''
hahah
CactusScreamO 1 year ago 2
@CactusScreamO ...lil' boy... get out with your "screemo"... this is not for u...
jjajajaja
loas55 1 year ago
@loas55 uh I Started a YT-account when I was like eleven, that's why my user name is how it is..
CactusScreamO 1 year ago
Oh, my god. I here NIN here. I guess, Trent Reznor was quite unoriginal after all.
blacklightfreakout 1 year ago
@blacklightfreakout , @blacklightfreakout , I just realize this is Trent Reznor/NIN Terrible Lie as well.
blacklightfreakout 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@orchidtender I certainly wouldn't call Trent a poseur - his first album was good. The rest have been lackluster.
LibertineObscene 1 year ago
costalima72@ neubauten is simply wonderfull and this music has all the ritm necessarilly to be one off the best
joaobcuricas 1 year ago
They are just as perfect as The Blue Man Group.
Xziz10ths 1 year ago
@Xziz10ths Uhhh....ok...wait--WTF?!
jimwit008 1 year ago
This is special music
ooo0hz 1 year ago 2
My favourite style is EBM, yet as a lover of originality i love this song and many of their others. I prefer to listen to Front 242 or Nitzer Ebb for an evening, but i always have a place in my heart for this band and their fantastic sound which many inferiors have tried and failed to replicate.
steve666b 1 year ago
wow, long time !! love you tube, my original cd of EN is dead.. thanks
baracunatana17 1 year ago
I haven't listen this band before, it's awesome :D!!
manuelalejandro2501 1 year ago
this flamewar is pathetic. obviously many are very intense about their favourite artist, and since NIN make alternative rock with industrial influences while EN count as a true industrial band noone can possibly appreciate both equally.
you guys are fighting over who has the better taste in music, not which band is better! if you wanna express your love for Emmerich's "singing" and dont care about meaningful lyrics, dont mask it with pretentious music theory ;-D
SuckItLily 1 year ago 4
EN can not be discussed with the words reznor involved. Blixa will be rembered for centuries. What was trents band called?
vars666 1 year ago
obsessed!
CinnamonLonka 1 year ago
This is the song that got me addicted to Neubauten. too bad i have never found a version of the music video that isn't so pixelly and low quality though, haha. but oh well. :'(
FlockaLorenzzz 1 year ago 2
Ach! The garbage truck just pulled up out front...how musical! It makes me want to pen bad poetry.
giddle12 1 year ago
@giddle12 you truelly are an idiot. piss off and die of cancer you scumbag
vars666 1 year ago
This song is very sexy.
etherealheigh 1 year ago 5
@orchidtender Amen. I agree
etherealheigh 1 year ago
You know, it really isn't necessary to attack Nine Inch Nails just to promote Einstürzende Neubauten. Both are extremely talented, and the fact that Reznor's sound was influenced by EN should by no means be looked at as a bad thing.
Boom2thaBap 1 year ago 19
I cant understand that feast of equal 5-seconds samples and bass. This song has no idea for me. Mb I do not speak German simply.
usakennedy 1 year ago
God, this song's so good! Is it possible that I love all the EN songs?! <3
QueenCrimson1969 1 year ago
@queencrimson1969 as true as that may be can you sit through the entirety of nnnaaammm
fiend1669 1 year ago
just love it!
HeroinBleeds 1 year ago
Nick cave of germany?
yhtakkiak 1 year ago
@yhtakkiak Hah, you realise Blixa was in the Bad Seeds?
RowanTE 1 year ago 3
grande...
fede7mengo 1 year ago
Aw, the final appearance of Mark Chung - I miss him. Oh, and I never noticed what gorgeous, womanly eyes Blixa has - I wonder if he's wearing mascara in this vid?
BabysGotTheRabies 2 years ago 6
@babysgottherabies He looks a bit like Boy George!
Perrickan 1 year ago
@Perrickan look more like the Bug Eyed Earl comic
Schutzraumtechnik999 1 year ago
@Perrickan look more like the Bug Eyed Earl comic
Schutzraumtechnik999 1 year ago
This album gives me the horn, big time.
Tchutney 2 years ago 4
OH my goodness. The german version of interimlovers. Geez... just took me 30 seconds of the song... haha.
Placebo4baby03 2 years ago
oh god this is great! and Blixa's movin is turning me on
Gpoet6 2 years ago 9
I doubt if I even find something more ecstatic than this
halcyondiz 2 years ago 4
This video makes me want to sing in German and move like Blixa while my bandmates are playing instruments and makind industrial noises
AFirmKickInThePants 2 years ago 58
* making
Damned keyboard
Oh well what other can I say, this is incredibly addicting
AFirmKickInThePants 2 years ago 6
a unique and genious bandproject. forever.
antissimo 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry to break it to you but this one sounds exactly like NIN.
gendolfgel 2 years ago
Comment removed
squeaka67 2 years ago
sure, but they were ten years ahead of nin. reznor never had an original thought.
squeaka67 2 years ago 2
correct me if I'm wrong, but the album TABULA RASA is made in 1993, so I think NIN were before that one, and since this is the only song that sounds like them...
gendolfgel 2 years ago
I'm sorry to break it to you but these guys were around many years before NIN. even if you don't like it they should be shown respect for being one of the founders of Industrial
sexbringsdeath 2 years ago 11
Comment removed
gendolfgel 2 years ago
I do show respect for them... I didn't say that all of their stuff sounds like NIN, only that one, which I think people will agree. other songs are anything but NIN.
gendolfgel 2 years ago
OMG. You need an education.
Bands like Depeche Mode were sampling Neubauten over a decade before that corporate poseur Reznor was even out of short-pants. He owes his entire sound to EN and to Jim Thirlwell, and isn't fit to lick their boots.
orchidtender 2 years ago 70
@orchidtender
corporate poseur? come down, the music is still good
sickboyduke 1 year ago
@orchidtender they are amazing but man don't insult reznor he is good in his own right. and look at Year Zero great album with a great message. ART IS RESISTANCE!
dark18dean18jasper 1 year ago
@orchidtender Hm, now I'm interested. In what song/s did EN get sampled?
W4RW017 1 year ago
@W4RW017 there are dozens of EN samples throughout the "Some Great Reward" album. The most obvious ones are on "People are People". There are others, but I can't think of them off-hand.
orchidtender 1 year ago
@orchidtender Reznor ruined the goth/industrial scene :( There was a drastic change in the clubs when "The Crow" and Reznor got out: they brought the trendy mass in through the doors, and it just hasn't been the same since. (Remember the 'clown' makeup...the black line across the eye from forehead to cheek? And all the NIN shirts...)
808jpj 1 year ago
@orchidtender
Even though i'd say Reznor took his sound from EN, Depeche mode took the sound from SpK. And when spk went to become something similiar (synthpop), they were called Depeche mode, test dept and EN-ripoffs.
gombie 1 year ago
Comment removed
LibertineObscene 1 year ago
Not only that, take into account Reznor's constant whining: in his music, his interviews, his general opinion on everything. Industrial music isn't about whining, and it isn't Pretty Hate Machine.
KingOfUm 1 year ago
@KingOfUm yeah, the "angry lonerman" schtick kind of loses its edge when one becomes an accepted, admired multimillionaire living his fantasy day in, day out. Maybe he's still so angry because one of his lackeys forgot to remove the blue M&Ms from the bowl in his vast, groupie-filled dressing room.
His whole bit is so contrived, too. Like how he claimed he "didn't know" that the house he bought to convert into a studio was one of the Manson family murder sites.
Basically he's Pat Boone.
orchidtender 1 year ago
Amen to that; I mean, Reznor does have some good material, but his potential value as an artist is undermined by his self-indulgence. Personally, I love his Ghosts album, but I think that'll be the very last good thing he'll do. Funny though, Reznor's fans can wait half a decade for a new album and once it's out call him a genius no matter the outcome. Lucky, lucky man.
KingOfUm 1 year ago 2
@orchidtender Funny you say that. The first thing taht came to mind the second this song started was NIN
jaymanleonard 1 year ago
@orchidtender I LOVE YOU
Glowb0t 1 year ago
@orchidtender Rezno could have taken a sound but his lyrics is not artsy like EN or Bauhaus but rather goes in paranoid/despair/psychological/reflective way. but musically - what the hell, rammstein completely ows its sound to Laibach, some EN songs have strong krautrock influence and so what...
skutratufahija 1 year ago 4
@orchidtender I agree with you, but dont forget Test. Department!
NovemberSong28th 1 year ago
@orchidtender Amen!
deannadeadly 1 year ago
@orchidtender
You should tattoo on your forehead "I feel to not think" because if you start the "he owes him for that" your gonna end up with a society culturally bankrupt.
Trollawk 1 year ago
You're*
Trollawk 1 year ago
@orchidtender And Neubauten (and Foetus) owe their sound to Stockhausen, John Cage, Pierre Schaeffer and Luigi Rusollo (hell, even Lou Reed's Metal Machine Music). They in turn owe their sounds to others before them. All interesting art makes reference to previous contexts.
I jumped on the bashing Trent bandwagon way back when he was a pup taking over industrial music and turning it into disco, but 20 years later, I now have a respect for his work. He has integrity that many don't.
sizone 10 months ago 3
@orchidtender If you don't like NIN go listen to EN, which I like, but I'm sorry, I prefer Reznor. Music is ALL about getting inspiration from other bands you like and that doesn't make you a poser, YOU need an education. NIN has been one of the best music acts out there in terms of rock and industrial fusion, even in experimental sound (listen to Ghosts or Year Zero), so please, respect. It's like saying oh The Prodigy fucking posers we all know Kraftwerk started it all and... God.
beniguma3000 9 months ago
I have a headache now, but that was delicious, so it was worth it.
moosikerin 2 years ago
666
<3
Imthefuckingdevil666 2 years ago
EN isn't industrial.
It simply is.
EN=EN.
cm2dude 2 years ago 13
i dont know if you understand german, but do you know their song "was ist ist"?
derWalter 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sehr schwach
ManhattenLove 2 years ago
just pure industrial.
pure genius
blix looks so hot
gothfesttour 2 years ago
1993 are the date of my birth... wow!
Kml79x 2 years ago 4
Holy shit, Blixa's eyes are insane.
I love this song, so, so much.
technicolordisko 2 years ago 10
da ist nichts was sich so in meinem kopf ergiesst wie es blixa mit den neubauten "tut" !!!!!!!!
74mw 2 years ago
there`s nothing like EN!!!
the best ever!!!
alderaan25 2 years ago
@ beer2257
Rammstein is awesome, but so are these guys, and they're kinda in totally seperate genres so they aren't comparable.
I've been a fan of Rammstein for years, and only JUST gotten into these guys, but already, if I had to choose between the two, I'd go absolutely nuts! lol
Lost4ubabe 2 years ago 3
Agree!
PrinzVidar 2 years ago
"they are kinda in totally separate genres"
very articulate...
intersheet 2 years ago
wait... are you... replying to my sarcasm with sarcasm? lol
Ok, THEY ARE IN SEPERATE GENRES, THEREFORE INCOMPARABLE.
Better? :p
Lost4ubabe 2 years ago
FWIW Bargeld hates Rammstein.
Different strokes, I guess.
orchidtender 2 years ago 4
I laugh at all the people that try to compare EN with NIN.
NIN pushed the genre so far that it killed the genre.
I love SP, KMFDM, Ministry, etc.. all of them are so different, they all have their styles, even Nitzer ebb & front 242 but in my oppinion NIN did more with Industrial than any of those bands.
Anyway, throbbling Gristle were the first and the true pioneers.
Su shut the fuck up!
lacrahuntington 2 years ago 2
nin is the mc donalds of industrial.
Hrimfauxie 2 years ago
I think NIN is to Industrial what MC Hammer is to rap/hip-hop.
angelforfreedom 2 years ago 2
NIN is no industrial, stop making weird comparisons.
Taq0dotrar 2 years ago 8
Blow me.
angelforfreedom 2 years ago
That's the most accurate description I've ever heard. You just won several decade worth of argument.
badluckshadow13 2 years ago
you're right, throbbing gristle did start it. EN perfected it though...
uberNurd 2 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
rammstein is much better :)
beers2257 2 years ago
Id prefer tihs songi f they used some distorted Skinny Puppy/FLA/Z'EV voice effects, it fits better to the genre than the "rock" version.. buti love idferences, thats y i love Industrial and experimental music, underground, uninvented, mind music, etc. And afterall, it is called Industrial Rock.
MagnitudePerson 2 years ago
oh boy I love Blixa moves.
WeAllFaulter 2 years ago 12
Brown noise
i like it:)
it rocks:D
denisdautovski666 2 years ago
When I'll understand why people keep bashing Trent Reznor for no fucking reason I'll be glad.
I love both Einsturzende Neubauten and Nine Inch Nails. Do you know the difference between inspiration and rip off?
AFirmKickInThePants 2 years ago 9
I agree and I love both of them too. Reznor never said that he plays industrial music, it's mainstream that says this because they want to label everything. Though he has made music which I would totally call post-industrial. It's not necessarry to hate him just because he made it big, that's what people have to understand.
z91tora 2 years ago 5
Although ihs early works+Ghosts-I-IV album is 100% pure (not-anti-music/lyrical version) rhytmic industrial, go check it out! If he wnats to create Industrial he should follow his Ghosts work(thge industrial songs)
MagnitudePerson 2 years ago
I agree on that. Also if you check out the Quake theme songs he composed it's obviously industrial to me.
z91tora 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I agree on that. Also if you check out the Quake theme songs he composed it's obviously industrial to me.
z91tora 2 years ago
erinnert mich immer an udo
jonastronic 2 years ago
tabula rasa ist immer noch meine lieblingsscheibe von den neubauten. was für eine kraft, was für ein sprachreichtum. und das hier - einfach genial: ein stück klang-lyrik, in dem man sich einfach verlieren kann.
CaptainFootos 2 years ago 2
These guys were the first show i ever saw, fucking amazing!
churzz21 2 years ago
können kein wort deutsch un tun so als wüssten sie alles von der band xD ohh man dabei wissen sie noch net mal warscheinlich was der name bedeutet ^^
legolas1w 2 years ago
Nine Inch Nails isn't even industrial!
TRENT IS POSEUR
HE RIPPED OFF OF SKINNY PUPPY!
EN fucking rules
XjimmyXdarknessX 2 years ago
There's more evidence to support that Trent ripped of Raymond Watts actually...
badluckshadow13 2 years ago
He didn't rip off either band. He sounds NOTHING like Skinny Puppy and Watts' earlier stuff sounds NOTHING like Reznor did. It's just silly.
DiarrheaDan1 2 years ago 2
idiot....the music of this band was in inspiration to skinny puppy an reznor. you just dismiss the fact that there was a time,where reznor war a noone, sitting in his room and making up his music style....and though trents a genious, he had many influences. and this is one of them. so f*ck you
sickboyduke 2 years ago 4
I'm actually a NIN fan, I was just pointing out that if Trent "ripped off" anyone it's more likely Watts then Ogre because he was at some point a pretty big fan.
badluckshadow13 2 years ago 2
don't forget Swans song "in my garden" .
Fuckof1f1f 2 years ago 2
wow, this isnt what Id generally associate with EN.
really rythmic compaired to the clang-clang-bang-scream Im used to.
its still very industrial though, no question!
as someone else mentioned, these guys kick Trent Reznor's arse raw!
warjunky444 2 years ago 3
@warjunky444 EN push all the envelopes, including their own. Of course it used to be all "clang-clang", but they can be intensely subtle and melodic sometimes, too. CHeck out the Ende Neu album. Stella Maris and The Garden are two of the most beautiful songs you will ever hear. Even my mom - who is 75 - like s them!
orchidtender 1 year ago
NIN sucks
EN are absolutely the best
Merluzz 2 years ago 2
They arn't that bad really. A lot of douchebags think they are the most goth thing since Andrew Eldritch listen to them, but a band can't help who likes them. Unless, of course, they dress like a transvestite and pose on girly magazine posters like some bands out there..
EN definately is better, though. They are one of the cornerstones of industrial music, and definately one of the most innovative.
DerPoltergeist13 2 years ago
I love these guys. I saw them a couple times in Chicago in the early 90's. I was not goth or industrial, I was just a regular guy who loved music and hung out in the back. They had nothing in the way of lights or special effects, but they were thoroughly creative and entertaining. One thing I respect about them is that, as great as they are, they never sold out.
marcoalfi 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Die deutschen Nine Inch Nails?
MaitreyaHatha 2 years ago
Alter, besser, grösser!
Ich persönlich mag NIN - bis the Fragile - mehr als EN... aber die zweiten sind sicherlich (IMHO) wichtiger für die Musikgeschichte.
Monstercapo 2 years ago 3
i cant say the bands name 4 the life of me =D
evilfetus4 2 years ago 2
I LOVE BLIXA!
southerncoldwind 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sucks.
oevermoerkavann 2 years ago
what?
CircusOfHeaven 2 years ago
God, I never know what the hell Blixa is doing in any of his videos but whatever it is, it's amazing. xD
He's all like, "Whoooooshy hand motions!" o3o
Oh, Blixa... you're so beautiful. x3
silviakitsune 2 years ago 6
:D yeah, Blixa could probably prop up a picture of himself in front of a camera, records for a few hours and release it on DVD, and we'd all buy it.
badluckshadow13 2 years ago 2
geiles lied...aber das video ist viel zu unoriginell für deren stil..wenn man es z.B. mal mit dem von Sabrina vergleicht.
aber die vids ham ja auch nen großen zeitunterschied.
Upflamoer 2 years ago
einstürzende neubauten, tolle musik
Nickname778 2 years ago
Ive watched several of these videos upon the request of my friend and it all just seems a little pretentious.
mcfartson 3 years ago
Undoubtedly mcfartson, undoubtedly.:D
aerugo49 3 years ago
i did like the garden though.
zadig08 3 years ago
pretentious: attempting to impress by affecting greater importance, talent, culture, etc., than is actually possessed?
I don't think pretentious describes EN. They are out - there & very surreal at times
FranklenWylder 3 years ago
Thank you for the definition....I knew what i was saying.
It just seems pretentious to me and I think many others.
Im glad you like it.
I just find it to be pretentious. I dont think they are that talented.
mcfartson 3 years ago
Folks just throw the word "pretentious" around a bit Hence, why I wrote the definition. Most folks casually say it without knowing what it means.
Maybe I misunderstood you? What do you find pretentious about them?
I'm not being an ass I'm seriously curious.
I'm sorry if I rubbed you the wrong way.
FranklenWylder 3 years ago
well, just what the definition states. it seems like it is that vein of german industrial music which I find to be given way to much credit. I wont sit here and say that I know all there is to know about electronic music. but I think there are way better forms of it than this. There is much more intelligent forms of of electro music such as drum and bass or jungle.
But just look at the guy. his facial expressions and the muddled camera shots. it all just seems cliche to me. I guess Im not hip.8)
mcfartson 3 years ago
Ya can't judge EN by a few videos. Blixa (the vocalist) is a dramatic persona. maybe too dramatic at times?EN have very intelligent lyrics, they make their own instruments, I could go on. Look them up a bit before you write them off. I will say however, They aren't as intriguing as they once were. Avoid their cd "the jewels" if you can. A tad over hyped. Good night.
FranklenWylder 3 years ago
this video isn't typical Neubauten. it's strange how it is almost like a pop video, but this is far from a typical. certain shots of Blixa dancing are very unique & would not be imitated by other artists. anyway, you say that "vein" of German industrial music but the fact is, industrial music was invented by Neubauten. they are music pioneers. as well, the lyrics are incredible. "the guy" as you call him, Blixa, has even taught creative writing. how many rock stars do that? read the lyrics!
aerugo49 3 years ago