I have to disagree FMA:Brotherhood was great it stuck to it story the way the author wrote it and the art was magnificent! I had watched the first FMA(not Brotherhood) the ending never made sense and then i watched the movie still didn't make sense it's good and everything but not what full metal was suppose to be. but i guess it comes down to opinion.
Can somebody explain all thr things that happened I'm new to the shows I've never saw this wrath is bradley in BH I got to episode 18 in fullmetal alchemist I can't watch rest because the user that uploaded was banned and why is Ed dead
@whitneyr97 It's from the FMA movie which was the conclusion to the old FMA series. It takes place after the final episode, so it's best you don't watch the movie without watching the series.
@TheWalrusface What I mean is that I would have loved FMA1 to be straight and faithful to the manga, but not panel from panel like BH was. Like I said, add it's own screenplay like it did so well before. Now speaking of the manga's plot. Is the reason why Bradley is unable to regenerate because Father only gave him one soul for his philosopher's stone? And is that why he can age, because Ling got a stone put inside of him just like Bradley did, but he can regenerate, or could he not?
@Kakorat009 Bradley and Ling age because they are human based Humonculi. A concept NOT in the first FMA. Ling Regenerates because he willingly accepted Greeds soul into him. Bradley does not regenerate because when the stone was put into him he fought it and killed off all the souls but one. Whether that was his original soul or one from the stone he doesn't know. And BH wasn't panel by panel. They added in shit and left it out. The final fight with Father is different->
@Kakorat009 And Bradley chasing the tank up the pathway didn't happen in the Manga. Also in the Manga for a long time it was left unclear whether or not Father and Hoenhiem were the same person. BH completely removes those scenes and pretty much flat out shows they are not the same person. Which is something I don't understand. If you're going to make the manga into an anime. make it into a fucking anime. don't change anything. just copy and paste. bam. done.
@TheWalrusface Copy and paste? I guess that can go for a lot of mangas made into anime. But FMA should get an exception since the writers were so damn good at telling the manga story, you know like the first season. The way the writers put the manga story in FMA1 was well done, but since they couldn't use the rest of the material, that's were all the holes came in. But the producers were able to take even smaller things in the manga and make them so huge and masterpiece like.
@Kakorat009 Copy and Paste as in. You're going to translate the Manga into an Anime. Then do so. Why did they over blow it and make Bradley chase the tank? Why did they completely remove the scenes of Father and Hoenheim to leave it a mystery if they are one and the same? Why did they change the final fight with Father? Things like that I don't understand. If you want to put a spin on it like FMA did. Fine. If you want to make the manga into an anime. Why leave things out or change it?
@TheWalrusface I wouldn't have left things out either, but another question. What do you mean by Hohenheim and Father being the same? I mean, I know Father used Van's blood to make a baggage that looks like him. But Father is a monster from the gate right?
@Kakorat009 Father and Hohenheim look exactly the same. In the Manga for a long time it's set up so you don't know if Hohenheim and Father are different people. Or the same person. In the anime it doesn't do that at all.
@TheWalrusface About Bradley. Does he have two ultimate eyes, or cam his eye switch sockets or something. Because Ling blinded him in one eye, but it was like it switched to his socket where the eye patch covers.
@TheWalrusface Ok, but remember when Ling blinded his ultimate eye with the flash grenade. It worked, but then he took his eye patch off and the ultimate eye appeared there.
@Kakorat009 Right. I"m in a raid on WoW and skimmed over what you said. That's because he covers his Ultimate eye with the eye patch. What's the problem you're having? His Ultimate Eye is the one with the ouroboros Tattoo and it's always under his eye patch. When he was blinded he removed his eye patch and was able to see. that eye apparently can't be blinded unless it's gouged out or something is blocking it's line of sight. like the eye patch. or a wall.
@TheWalrusface Now as I was saying. Hughes played a bigger part in the old FMA,one thing that the manga/bh lacks. Another thing is that FMA actually gave a great story on to how Ed became a State Alchemist. In BH/manga,the military just let a 12 yr old take the exam. Nina's story was used better and Scar's bloody start as well. I could go on and on,but they're are a lot things that bother me with BH. It's just not perfect.The style it was made in is just so plain. FMA was written to be an anime
@Kakorat009 But FMA is far from perfect as well. I'm fine with you liking FMA or FMAB. But calling FMAB Mediocre? Please. FMA is riddled with far far more problems. "the reason why Dante probably didn't know how to make the stone was bc,one she can't pull off the heist of getting a mass of people for ingredients by herself," But she can pull off making the leader of the entire country a Homuncules. Are you joking? And the circle? Ed made it in Lab five. in front of Lust and Envy and Shou.
@Kakorat009 It doesn't even make any sense the more I think about it. The slaughter in Liore. Isvhal. Dante knew to cause mass murder and she was capable of orchestrating it. Your entire reason that she couldn't make no sense and goes against what happens. The only reason I see is she needed someone else to transmute it. But why? She can do Alchemy. Very well. Lust and Envy and Shou saw the Circle in Lab five when Ed made it. They also used it to make Red stones. just. it makes no sense. explain
@Kakorat009 Oh and again speaking of Wrath. He can do Alchemy. That's fine. He has Edwards limbs. I understand that. I'll buy it. But no motion alchemy like Father? Uhh...why? Needing a circle is the basic rule of Alchemy. Even those who have seen The Gate need a circle. They make one by clapping their hands and using their body as one. Wrath does none of that. No circle. No clapping. Just no motion alchemy like Father. Why? Are those two limbs of Eds just magical?
@TheWalrusface Actually you make sense. Some of the plot holes you mention can't be fixed. Though I still believe that FMA1 had the right idea. It's just that manga wasn't coming out fast enough, so they needed to quickly find a plot to feed the fire. I'm sure if FMA told the manga story, it would have went so far because of the team. They still did interesting things in this anime, like the parallel universe and what not. But you win on the point that FMA did have too many holes.
@Kakorat009 Don't even get me started on the parallel universe. just. Edward vs Hitler. just no. just. stop it. right now. just stop it. Using our World as part of a story is the fucking laziest plot mechanic there is. I mean. Beast Master 2. He-Man Masters of the Universe. The Smurfs. What do all those movies have in common? They all had our world as a Parallel universe. and they all fucking sucked. I did like however Hughes involvement in FMA1 and I like how Edward was forced to kill.
@Kakorat009 I also liked the episodes of Hughes death in FMA1 more than FMAB. But his actual death scene was better in FMAB. And regarding plot holes in FMAB. I've only noticed 2. Bradley has the Ultimate Eye. He can see everything. Unless his eye is obstructed. Kay. I'll buy that. but then. He blocks bullets with his sword and takes out a tank on his own. While wearing his eye patch. does the eye patch just not count as an Obstruction? Second plot hole I noticed
@Kakorat009 When the nation wide transmutation circle activates. The five labs are the five points on the circle. You can clearly see the circle in Lab five (where Edward fought Slicer) activate. But wait. Didn't Envy and Lust blow lab five up to hide their trail? so did they just blow everything up but that one room? FMAB has its plot holes. but over all it's put together much much better than FMA. Feel free to like whatever you want. But don't look down on one for being mediocre when it's not.
@TheWalrusface I know, but I did like the parallel universe just because it was very accurate and Europeon and typical of nazis to search for occult power.But now thinking about it, FMA doesn't really need a parallel universe to be great. I'm now starting to be in favor of the manga story, though I still don't like BH. I just wish FMA did the entire manga story and added it's own flavor like it did with the first half of its series. Faithful but with am even better put screenplay
@TheWalrusface Like I said. FMA had a greater potential than BH and even the manga. BH just followed every panel in the manga. FMA actually used the material to make a damn amazing screenplay.EX:I hated how in the manga/bh where Ed & Al were just meeting Hughes when they knew Mustang for 4 years. It was better that they helped Hughes daughter be born than just a stranger's baby. That helps the characters and audience bond closer to Hughes. It was even better that Hughes helped them on the train.
@TheWalrusface It's true about Wrath not regenerating, and I can't explain why Pride ages in the first series. They didn't even explain it. Hell,they don't explain why the homunculus regenerate period. Still, I thought that FMA had a better script than BH, and even the manga. It's not the producers fault for giving the the task of ending the show they're own way. They still did a damn good job with the character development, and the drama that makes you want to see what happens next. (continued)
@TheWalrusface Anyhow,the reason why i'm not explaining the other plot holes is because I didn't feel like typing.BTW, the reason why Dante probably didn't know how to make the stone was bc,one she can't pull off the heist of getting a mass of people for ingredients by herself, or she doesn't know how to form the complex transmutation or circle itself. Now, as for Envy being Van's son,I guess it is a coincidence. I mean the original Van in the flashback did have blond hair and resembled Father
@TheWalrusface Don't forget that the red water can play a great role into making red stones. Now getting to Brotherhood. I've seen the entire thing. I didn't like it, not just because I thought of it as mediorce. I also don't like the OST and animation, not to mention the designs. I was so happy when I heard they were making a new FMA series,until I saw the trailer. FMA went from outstanding sharp detailed designing to... you know what FMAB looks like. Not to mention the first season, and etc.
@Kakorat009 Unfortunately I disagree FMA has far too many plot holes. I like how you didn't address the ones you couldn't. Like Envy being Edwards brother. Or the reason for Pride aging. Lets also not forget that Dante's plan was moronic and doomed to fail At least Father had a legitimate plan and reasoning instead of "I want to live forever" I know what FMAB looks like It looks better than FMA The animation is of higher quality. As is the story from what I've seen.
@Kakorat009 Lets also not forget the continuity mess when it comes to Wrath speaking of him. Let's see. Gets stabbed in the head by Lust. Regenerates. Burned when Sloth dies-doesn't regerneate despite it being the same burn wounds Lust and Gluttony get in Liore (which they regenerated from) and he doesn't regenerate when his limbs get ripped off by the gate. Reasons? anywhere? anyone? I'd love to hear it. FMAB has plot holes as well. But not nearly as much.
@Kakorat009 "Anyhow, to make a real legit genuine stone, you nee thousand or more of lives. Incomplete stones can be made from a lesser #. Dante had lab 5 for that." So..is Dante just an idiot. Or what? I mean. She can't figure out she just needs to sacrifice a greater number? Really? I mean. Wow. really? It's not that big of a puzzle. I mean. what did she think Hoenheim was doing this whole time? sprinkling in a secret sauce to get it to work?
@TheWalrusface The the only part of animation in brotherhood that I liked was the fight scenes, but it still doesn't have that amazing sharp detail like the fight scene in this video.One thing I don't like are the character designs. Like the way the characters are designed compared to the old FMA. Remember the first half of FMA that told the manga's story. It even told the manga story better than even the manga itself. I think FMA could have told the full manga better than BH.
@Kakorat009 Whaaaaa-? Brotherhood's animation style is way better, the OST is great, the PLOOOOOT, omg the plot is way more detailed than this one. I like both, and I loved this movie, but since Brotherhood is based entirely on the manga, things are a bit more expanded without fillers and stuff. You get to know the characters far better than in the original, and you actually feel bad for *SPOILERS* Hohenheim's death, which I think is cool.
@omghom The manga story is good, not brotherhood imo. The fight animation was good I guess, but the designs and details..... I suppose the brotherhood artist tries to make the anime resemble the manga, but the 2003 characters look more like the manga than brotherhood. Ed for example. Why is Ed's hair so blond when it's suppose to be gold. Why does Scar look so old and evil than needed? The ost doesn't help but it does have memorable ones, but the anime as a whole doesn't feel right.
@Kakorat009 Actually, Ed's hair was supposed to be blonde from the very beginning. Amestris is a representation of Germany, meaning most people have blonde hair + blue eyes (although Ed's eyes are not). Scar being older and more evil than needed? What do yo mean? :O
@omghom Amestris is not a representation of Germany. The creator even said that she never used a specific nation that Amestris is based off of. A combination of different 20th century industrial Europeon nations,though England is a major influence being her favorite out of them all. The only German relation is their military to an extent. And Ed is half Xersian,who the people had "gold eyes and hair". That's why Ed's hair shouldn't be that blond. Compare Scar from old FMA and Brotherhood
@Kakorat009 Huh... seems you know a lot more than I do. ANYWAYS, I like them both, Brotherhood being my favorite. I haven't watched the new movie, but I hear it's great. Even though there are two different story lines to FMA, it still is the best anime series I've watched so far, nothing compares to it :)
@TheWalrusface Gluttony became mutated like this from eating way too many red stones. Remember when the homunculus are first born, they look like monsters like Ed and Al's mom. But as they ate the red stones that Dante provided they start to form into a more human like resemblance, When Dante erased his ouroburos, Gluttony became a mindless eating machine. He killed Dante and kept eating the red stones as he was alone in the underground city. All of those stones made him to perfect to abnormal
@Kakorat009 And all of these red stones were lying around because? You don't know how they got the 7 deadly sins in the manga? I thought you watched Brotherhood? It's explained very clearly where they're from. Wrath threw tantrums like a kid? Tantrums are related to "Wrath" how? Dante also doesn't know how to create a Philosopher's Stone. A red Stone is just an incomplete Philosopher's stone. How did she know how to create the Red stones again? Also. It's not "fandom" Which does matter.
@TheWalrusface Threw tantrums, because he was always angry. He was throwing fits when he didn't get that way. Wrath means anger. 7 deadly sins comes from Christianity. The manga used it, but Christianity doesn't even exist in the manga. Anyhow, to make a real legit genuine stone, you nee thousand or more of lives. Incomplete stones can be made from a lesser #. Dante had lab 5 for that. She provided plenty, and when she was killed, Gluttony was able to get them. (Continued).
@TheWalrusface Because Christianity doesn't exist in the manga, than I don't know how they got the idea of the 7 deadly sins.Regardless Dante names them after the 7 sins as she thinks she's the shepherd of human sin, and takes the stone to prevent people from getting themselves.The homunculi do have things that males Dante name them the way they do. For an example, Dante told Sloth that she didn't have much work for he like the others, so she named her Sloth.Wrath threw tantrums like a kid
I knew wrath was good from the start all he wanted was a family and he thought sloth was his mom but found out Izumi was his real mother and wanted to join here to me wrath is more of a neutral homunculas in the beginning
@poiklpoiuy1 Bradly is Pride not Wrath in the original Fullmetal Alchemist. In Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, Bradly is Wrath while the Wrath you see here is Izumi's son and has Edward's Automail arm and leg.
I like how Gluttony completely ignores Alphonse and goes all out on Wrath. This hints that despite his seemingly mindless, beastial transformation, he still remembers that Edward told him Wrath was the one who killed Lust, the most important being to him.
@elvampe13 How i percieved it was that Wrath was a homunculus who ate the red stones given by Envy way back in the series. Gluttony singled out Wrath because Wrath simply had more power that Gluttonly hungers for. Though your answer could just as well be right. Its all open to interpretation.
@Kyoshiro5411 thats his brother at the end of the original fma he exchanged his alchemy and his whole body to give him his body back, he lives in the other world now. not spoiling the rest. in this series who ever you tried to use human transformation on became a homunculi, this is the teachers son
@Kyoshiro5411 the blond hair one is alphones.in the series that was the brother in the suit of armor.al got his body back because ed sacrifeds his own life to bring him back.the one with the black is wrath one of the seven homunculi, teacher (izumi's) son that died but came back as a homunculi. hope this helped
The first anime (I will not call it the original series because it is not >:l ) Was pretty good but it just wasn't as great as Brotherhood/manga. I'm not being biased either cause the first anime was the one I first watched. I don't like that the Homunculi had feelings, it seemed like the makers were trying to hard to make it seem 'deep'. They are sins; They are not supposed to have reason for doing bad things, they are not supposed to care etc... Brotherhood was great in every way :) that's all
@emokidsfriend666 What and you think the Homunculi from the manga/brotherhood anime didnt have feelings? Greed was all ''i have friends to fill my emptiness'' when he was dying near the end. Pride loved his fake mom and dad (the Fuhrer and his wife) and felt bad when Father left him, and Envy was crying when he admitted he was jealous of humans' potential. So... your point of view of ''Homunculi are not supposed to have feeling and are not supposed to care'' doesnt make sense.
@emokidsfriend666 I seen Brotherhood once. To me, it was mediorce. I thought it was great that the homunculus had feelings in 2003.That way they wouldn't be typical anime villains, including Dante. Father was a typical anime villain. In animes they always have the master villain fighting to become "god tier", more than they already are. FMA is #1 because it was original and unique. It played by its own game and didn't care for having fates in favor of fandom. FMA is legend!
@Kakorat009 It also made absolutely no sense in a number of ways With huge plot holes that FMAB really didn't have Envy is Ed's brother? really? So did Hoenhiem take a cup of his sperm each time he body swapped? Why are the Homunculi named after Sins for no apparent reason? they don't show any signs of their sin Why are they named it? Why do the Humonculi only regenerate sometimes? Why can Pride age? Why did Gluttony become this monster? Father didn't want to become God He wanted to become FREE.
@TheWalrusface I can explain everything. Not all,sense it is too big for one comment. K, Dante and Hoehenheim lived in a time where Christianity dominated almost all of Europe with a iron fist. Because they wiped out huge populations across the continent to make the philosopher's stone,the power of the church was cut down to minors.From century to century Dante thought of herself as the gaurdian of sin. The 7 sins comes from Christianity,(continued)
looks like a mix of ed and envy, similar clothes to envy not to mention long black hair and this dude (wrath?) has automail on his arm and leg plus the same eyes from ed (and notice a little curl at the top? o.O
One thing I didn't like about Brotherhood, but enjoyed in the original, was how many philosopher stones there were. Just kind of lessened the significance of them.
The original only ever had the one philosopher's stone created in the boy's journey, which made it more of an event than in brotherhood where it practically rains philosopher's stones.
@SuperGauss100 The manga (and brotherhood) have the 7 Homonculi be complete cardboard cut-outs of their respective sins. In contrast, the 2003 show actually gave the homonculi character development (the biggest example being Lust's loyalty towards her maker wavering and eventually wanting to be human). Your mileage may vary, but I prefer a story with really interesting villans to bland ones.
@LordManda2 Oh right. The villains are just as developed (actually more so) by the fact that they represent the deepest truths of our sins. Lust was no more deep for wanting to be human, in fact the reasoning for this desire was nothing beyond a "just because" plot point. I too prefer a storyline with less bland villains. I just think brotherhood actually followed a coherent story while delivering just that.
@ebonmaskarade77 I found more investment in the characters of Ed, Alphonse, Lust, and Hughes, in the original series than Brotherhood. However, Brotherhood further developed every other character.
Personally, for me, Bradley steals the show in both versions.
I prefer Brotherhood's plot, because it serves as a better narrative. However, I do think that the original's ending was more poetic.
I say, for the best experience, one should watch the first thirty episodes of the original series and then continue from the thirteenth episode of Brotherhood until the very end.
Those first ten episodes rushed important character development, and definitely failed to explain the functions of alchemy. It really must be a struggle for someone who hasn't read the manga or seen the first series to understand precisely what is going on in those first ten episodes.
@SgtGoste That fight was from 'Brotherhood' and the person they were fighting was the Humonculus Father after he supposedly absorbed 'God'; he then took on the appearance of Ed or a younger Hohemheim. It was easily on of the best fights in the series:-)
Just watched the entire original fma series and shimbala movie. I thought the movie was flipping awesome buy that's my opinion. Also thought this fight was really cool. Secondly, I saw a clip sumwhere where a bunch of people were fighting sum1 who looked sorta like Ed but they couldn't do any damage to him cos he had sum kinda oink force field around him. Was wondering what it was from. I think it was fma but I dno if it was the 2nd movie or from brotherhood which I havnt seen yet
@DarkSoulsOST I agree. The animation in Brotherhood was top-notch and don't even get me started on the fight scenes:-) To tell the truth, I found out about the manga after I started hearing news that the original anime deviated from it halfway.
christ i hate dubbed, every voice actor sounds way too over-exaggerated and it's just not how real english is spoken. that's the reason i like subbed better.
@h2theibrid lol..i've watched more then 200 episodes of bleach in jap. only at first cause it stopped being dubbed up untill 164 so i just got use to subtitles.
The original anime is and always will the one I remember fondly; Brotherhood may follow the manga to a 't', but the original is the one that pretty much established everything FullmetalAchemist:'-)
@Zomochi Even though the original FMA has some sort of a nostalgic value, I thought that Brotherhood was much better. Since the ending of Conqueror of Shamballa pretty much ruined the original series IMO. It was good until the end.
@Zomochi the first was nothin compared to brotherhood, too many people died and the ending wasnt that great, while as brotherhood had everyone come together at the end to beat father and had a good ending
Blimey, I thought they fucked up Ed's voice.
zoraxpower 3 days ago
@zoraxpower that's Al...not even his voice is similar to ed's.
Jayjangle 16 hours ago
@Jayjangle May I interest you in some comprehension lessons?
zoraxpower 14 hours ago
@zoraxpower I meant to say his personality is not similar.
Jayjangle 11 hours ago
what is the movie called
darkhearted101 5 days ago in playlist Favorite videos
@darkhearted101 Full metal alchemist : Conqueror of shamballa
Andreas16375 1 day ago
@Andreas16375 thanks :)
darkhearted101 11 hours ago
SPOILER ALERT
AM I THE ONLY ONE THINKING POOR GLUTTONY... like dante did this to him, because he was becoming more human than her :(
mastadon1111 5 days ago
Tags: not, gay, amv
(Y)
malakaki111 6 days ago
Wow, this video has persuaded me to watch the series and movies!
xXthexXxreverendXx 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@1:43-1:58
BONES animation studio at it's finest!
JAMurida1 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
JAMurida1 2 weeks ago
lol that's al am I right not Ed so what is this movie called?
darkphoenix669 2 weeks ago
@darkphoenix669 it's in the description. "Conqueror of Shamballa"
and yeah that's alphonse.
AsHeS2SweLL 2 weeks ago
Wrath doesn't even sound remotely like a boy. Terrible dubbing as usual.
Atomsking 2 weeks ago
I like the original but brotherhood my second
xXrandom69dudeXx 2 weeks ago
You like brotherhood,
You like the original,
Shit, I just like ed and al :)
youpee43 2 weeks ago
Al sounds like Finn from adventure time
whitneyr97 2 weeks ago
I liked the origanal fma more because it has more of a moral like this movie did.
spartonater5678 3 weeks ago
When I watched the original FMA, then watched brotherhood, I didn't like FMAB.
Once I read the entirety of the Manag then watched FMAB and I enjoyed the "real" story line from the manga.
PandasPenguins 3 weeks ago
I have to disagree FMA:Brotherhood was great it stuck to it story the way the author wrote it and the art was magnificent! I had watched the first FMA(not Brotherhood) the ending never made sense and then i watched the movie still didn't make sense it's good and everything but not what full metal was suppose to be. but i guess it comes down to opinion.
ToruToruChannel 3 weeks ago
Can somebody explain all thr things that happened I'm new to the shows I've never saw this wrath is bradley in BH I got to episode 18 in fullmetal alchemist I can't watch rest because the user that uploaded was banned and why is Ed dead
xXpokemaster661Xx 3 weeks ago
WTF THAT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE ED AT ALL
MeisterDaniel564 4 weeks ago
@MeisterDaniel564 That's Al.
Sadisticfang 3 weeks ago in playlist More videos from Peeareoh
@Sadisticfang wtf that looks like ed
MeisterDaniel564 3 weeks ago
Is this brotherhood or FMA? And what episode please?
whitneyr97 4 weeks ago
@whitneyr97 It's from the FMA movie which was the conclusion to the old FMA series. It takes place after the final episode, so it's best you don't watch the movie without watching the series.
Kakorat009 4 weeks ago
Can someone tell me why Gluttony is like that?
Is it because he ate Dante or something?
nunsofpoison 1 month ago
@nunsofpoison Ate too many red stones as you can see them spewing out of them
Kakorat009 4 weeks ago
@Kakorat009 Where did he get the red stones though!?
nunsofpoison 4 weeks ago
@nunsofpoison Dante provided the stones remember? When Gluttony killed Dante he had access to the rest.
Kakorat009 4 weeks ago
@TheWalrusface What I mean is that I would have loved FMA1 to be straight and faithful to the manga, but not panel from panel like BH was. Like I said, add it's own screenplay like it did so well before. Now speaking of the manga's plot. Is the reason why Bradley is unable to regenerate because Father only gave him one soul for his philosopher's stone? And is that why he can age, because Ling got a stone put inside of him just like Bradley did, but he can regenerate, or could he not?
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Bradley and Ling age because they are human based Humonculi. A concept NOT in the first FMA. Ling Regenerates because he willingly accepted Greeds soul into him. Bradley does not regenerate because when the stone was put into him he fought it and killed off all the souls but one. Whether that was his original soul or one from the stone he doesn't know. And BH wasn't panel by panel. They added in shit and left it out. The final fight with Father is different->
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 And Bradley chasing the tank up the pathway didn't happen in the Manga. Also in the Manga for a long time it was left unclear whether or not Father and Hoenhiem were the same person. BH completely removes those scenes and pretty much flat out shows they are not the same person. Which is something I don't understand. If you're going to make the manga into an anime. make it into a fucking anime. don't change anything. just copy and paste. bam. done.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Copy and paste? I guess that can go for a lot of mangas made into anime. But FMA should get an exception since the writers were so damn good at telling the manga story, you know like the first season. The way the writers put the manga story in FMA1 was well done, but since they couldn't use the rest of the material, that's were all the holes came in. But the producers were able to take even smaller things in the manga and make them so huge and masterpiece like.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Copy and Paste as in. You're going to translate the Manga into an Anime. Then do so. Why did they over blow it and make Bradley chase the tank? Why did they completely remove the scenes of Father and Hoenheim to leave it a mystery if they are one and the same? Why did they change the final fight with Father? Things like that I don't understand. If you want to put a spin on it like FMA did. Fine. If you want to make the manga into an anime. Why leave things out or change it?
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface I wouldn't have left things out either, but another question. What do you mean by Hohenheim and Father being the same? I mean, I know Father used Van's blood to make a baggage that looks like him. But Father is a monster from the gate right?
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Father and Hohenheim look exactly the same. In the Manga for a long time it's set up so you don't know if Hohenheim and Father are different people. Or the same person. In the anime it doesn't do that at all.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface About Bradley. Does he have two ultimate eyes, or cam his eye switch sockets or something. Because Ling blinded him in one eye, but it was like it switched to his socket where the eye patch covers.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 You may have been watching a mirrored video. He only has one Ultimate eye and it's only his left eye.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Ok, but remember when Ling blinded his ultimate eye with the flash grenade. It worked, but then he took his eye patch off and the ultimate eye appeared there.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Right. I"m in a raid on WoW and skimmed over what you said. That's because he covers his Ultimate eye with the eye patch. What's the problem you're having? His Ultimate Eye is the one with the ouroboros Tattoo and it's always under his eye patch. When he was blinded he removed his eye patch and was able to see. that eye apparently can't be blinded unless it's gouged out or something is blocking it's line of sight. like the eye patch. or a wall.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Yeah, I see now. Thanks
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Let me know if you need info on anything else you're confused about. I seem to be knowledgeable on this
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Now as I was saying. Hughes played a bigger part in the old FMA,one thing that the manga/bh lacks. Another thing is that FMA actually gave a great story on to how Ed became a State Alchemist. In BH/manga,the military just let a 12 yr old take the exam. Nina's story was used better and Scar's bloody start as well. I could go on and on,but they're are a lot things that bother me with BH. It's just not perfect.The style it was made in is just so plain. FMA was written to be an anime
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 But FMA is far from perfect as well. I'm fine with you liking FMA or FMAB. But calling FMAB Mediocre? Please. FMA is riddled with far far more problems. "the reason why Dante probably didn't know how to make the stone was bc,one she can't pull off the heist of getting a mass of people for ingredients by herself," But she can pull off making the leader of the entire country a Homuncules. Are you joking? And the circle? Ed made it in Lab five. in front of Lust and Envy and Shou.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 It doesn't even make any sense the more I think about it. The slaughter in Liore. Isvhal. Dante knew to cause mass murder and she was capable of orchestrating it. Your entire reason that she couldn't make no sense and goes against what happens. The only reason I see is she needed someone else to transmute it. But why? She can do Alchemy. Very well. Lust and Envy and Shou saw the Circle in Lab five when Ed made it. They also used it to make Red stones. just. it makes no sense. explain
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Oh and again speaking of Wrath. He can do Alchemy. That's fine. He has Edwards limbs. I understand that. I'll buy it. But no motion alchemy like Father? Uhh...why? Needing a circle is the basic rule of Alchemy. Even those who have seen The Gate need a circle. They make one by clapping their hands and using their body as one. Wrath does none of that. No circle. No clapping. Just no motion alchemy like Father. Why? Are those two limbs of Eds just magical?
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Actually you make sense. Some of the plot holes you mention can't be fixed. Though I still believe that FMA1 had the right idea. It's just that manga wasn't coming out fast enough, so they needed to quickly find a plot to feed the fire. I'm sure if FMA told the manga story, it would have went so far because of the team. They still did interesting things in this anime, like the parallel universe and what not. But you win on the point that FMA did have too many holes.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Don't even get me started on the parallel universe. just. Edward vs Hitler. just no. just. stop it. right now. just stop it. Using our World as part of a story is the fucking laziest plot mechanic there is. I mean. Beast Master 2. He-Man Masters of the Universe. The Smurfs. What do all those movies have in common? They all had our world as a Parallel universe. and they all fucking sucked. I did like however Hughes involvement in FMA1 and I like how Edward was forced to kill.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 I also liked the episodes of Hughes death in FMA1 more than FMAB. But his actual death scene was better in FMAB. And regarding plot holes in FMAB. I've only noticed 2. Bradley has the Ultimate Eye. He can see everything. Unless his eye is obstructed. Kay. I'll buy that. but then. He blocks bullets with his sword and takes out a tank on his own. While wearing his eye patch. does the eye patch just not count as an Obstruction? Second plot hole I noticed
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 When the nation wide transmutation circle activates. The five labs are the five points on the circle. You can clearly see the circle in Lab five (where Edward fought Slicer) activate. But wait. Didn't Envy and Lust blow lab five up to hide their trail? so did they just blow everything up but that one room? FMAB has its plot holes. but over all it's put together much much better than FMA. Feel free to like whatever you want. But don't look down on one for being mediocre when it's not.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface I know, but I did like the parallel universe just because it was very accurate and Europeon and typical of nazis to search for occult power.But now thinking about it, FMA doesn't really need a parallel universe to be great. I'm now starting to be in favor of the manga story, though I still don't like BH. I just wish FMA did the entire manga story and added it's own flavor like it did with the first half of its series. Faithful but with am even better put screenplay
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Like I said. FMA had a greater potential than BH and even the manga. BH just followed every panel in the manga. FMA actually used the material to make a damn amazing screenplay.EX:I hated how in the manga/bh where Ed & Al were just meeting Hughes when they knew Mustang for 4 years. It was better that they helped Hughes daughter be born than just a stranger's baby. That helps the characters and audience bond closer to Hughes. It was even better that Hughes helped them on the train.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface It's true about Wrath not regenerating, and I can't explain why Pride ages in the first series. They didn't even explain it. Hell,they don't explain why the homunculus regenerate period. Still, I thought that FMA had a better script than BH, and even the manga. It's not the producers fault for giving the the task of ending the show they're own way. They still did a damn good job with the character development, and the drama that makes you want to see what happens next. (continued)
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Anyhow,the reason why i'm not explaining the other plot holes is because I didn't feel like typing.BTW, the reason why Dante probably didn't know how to make the stone was bc,one she can't pull off the heist of getting a mass of people for ingredients by herself, or she doesn't know how to form the complex transmutation or circle itself. Now, as for Envy being Van's son,I guess it is a coincidence. I mean the original Van in the flashback did have blond hair and resembled Father
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Don't forget that the red water can play a great role into making red stones. Now getting to Brotherhood. I've seen the entire thing. I didn't like it, not just because I thought of it as mediorce. I also don't like the OST and animation, not to mention the designs. I was so happy when I heard they were making a new FMA series,until I saw the trailer. FMA went from outstanding sharp detailed designing to... you know what FMAB looks like. Not to mention the first season, and etc.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Unfortunately I disagree FMA has far too many plot holes. I like how you didn't address the ones you couldn't. Like Envy being Edwards brother. Or the reason for Pride aging. Lets also not forget that Dante's plan was moronic and doomed to fail At least Father had a legitimate plan and reasoning instead of "I want to live forever" I know what FMAB looks like It looks better than FMA The animation is of higher quality. As is the story from what I've seen.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 Lets also not forget the continuity mess when it comes to Wrath speaking of him. Let's see. Gets stabbed in the head by Lust. Regenerates. Burned when Sloth dies-doesn't regerneate despite it being the same burn wounds Lust and Gluttony get in Liore (which they regenerated from) and he doesn't regenerate when his limbs get ripped off by the gate. Reasons? anywhere? anyone? I'd love to hear it. FMAB has plot holes as well. But not nearly as much.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 "Anyhow, to make a real legit genuine stone, you nee thousand or more of lives. Incomplete stones can be made from a lesser #. Dante had lab 5 for that." So..is Dante just an idiot. Or what? I mean. She can't figure out she just needs to sacrifice a greater number? Really? I mean. Wow. really? It's not that big of a puzzle. I mean. what did she think Hoenheim was doing this whole time? sprinkling in a secret sauce to get it to work?
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface The the only part of animation in brotherhood that I liked was the fight scenes, but it still doesn't have that amazing sharp detail like the fight scene in this video.One thing I don't like are the character designs. Like the way the characters are designed compared to the old FMA. Remember the first half of FMA that told the manga's story. It even told the manga story better than even the manga itself. I think FMA could have told the full manga better than BH.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 you mean this one fullmetal alchemist the sacred star of milos?
MageDb0w 2 weeks ago
@Kakorat009 Whaaaaa-? Brotherhood's animation style is way better, the OST is great, the PLOOOOOT, omg the plot is way more detailed than this one. I like both, and I loved this movie, but since Brotherhood is based entirely on the manga, things are a bit more expanded without fillers and stuff. You get to know the characters far better than in the original, and you actually feel bad for *SPOILERS* Hohenheim's death, which I think is cool.
omghom 2 weeks ago
@omghom The manga story is good, not brotherhood imo. The fight animation was good I guess, but the designs and details..... I suppose the brotherhood artist tries to make the anime resemble the manga, but the 2003 characters look more like the manga than brotherhood. Ed for example. Why is Ed's hair so blond when it's suppose to be gold. Why does Scar look so old and evil than needed? The ost doesn't help but it does have memorable ones, but the anime as a whole doesn't feel right.
Kakorat009 2 weeks ago
@Kakorat009 Actually, Ed's hair was supposed to be blonde from the very beginning. Amestris is a representation of Germany, meaning most people have blonde hair + blue eyes (although Ed's eyes are not). Scar being older and more evil than needed? What do yo mean? :O
omghom 2 weeks ago
@omghom Amestris is not a representation of Germany. The creator even said that she never used a specific nation that Amestris is based off of. A combination of different 20th century industrial Europeon nations,though England is a major influence being her favorite out of them all. The only German relation is their military to an extent. And Ed is half Xersian,who the people had "gold eyes and hair". That's why Ed's hair shouldn't be that blond. Compare Scar from old FMA and Brotherhood
Kakorat009 2 weeks ago 3
@Kakorat009 Huh... seems you know a lot more than I do. ANYWAYS, I like them both, Brotherhood being my favorite. I haven't watched the new movie, but I hear it's great. Even though there are two different story lines to FMA, it still is the best anime series I've watched so far, nothing compares to it :)
omghom 2 weeks ago
@omghom ok.
Kakorat009 2 weeks ago
@Thewalrusface So yeah, you can see the red stones spewing out of Gluttony. K,you asked a lot of questions, I tell you the rest later
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Gluttony became mutated like this from eating way too many red stones. Remember when the homunculus are first born, they look like monsters like Ed and Al's mom. But as they ate the red stones that Dante provided they start to form into a more human like resemblance, When Dante erased his ouroburos, Gluttony became a mindless eating machine. He killed Dante and kept eating the red stones as he was alone in the underground city. All of those stones made him to perfect to abnormal
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 And all of these red stones were lying around because? You don't know how they got the 7 deadly sins in the manga? I thought you watched Brotherhood? It's explained very clearly where they're from. Wrath threw tantrums like a kid? Tantrums are related to "Wrath" how? Dante also doesn't know how to create a Philosopher's Stone. A red Stone is just an incomplete Philosopher's stone. How did she know how to create the Red stones again? Also. It's not "fandom" Which does matter.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Threw tantrums, because he was always angry. He was throwing fits when he didn't get that way. Wrath means anger. 7 deadly sins comes from Christianity. The manga used it, but Christianity doesn't even exist in the manga. Anyhow, to make a real legit genuine stone, you nee thousand or more of lives. Incomplete stones can be made from a lesser #. Dante had lab 5 for that. She provided plenty, and when she was killed, Gluttony was able to get them. (Continued).
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface Because Christianity doesn't exist in the manga, than I don't know how they got the idea of the 7 deadly sins.Regardless Dante names them after the 7 sins as she thinks she's the shepherd of human sin, and takes the stone to prevent people from getting themselves.The homunculi do have things that males Dante name them the way they do. For an example, Dante told Sloth that she didn't have much work for he like the others, so she named her Sloth.Wrath threw tantrums like a kid
Kakorat009 1 month ago
Thats just bad ass
loginanout 1 month ago
He's not called Wrath for nothing.
dogribgamer 1 month ago
wrath deserved to feel gluttonys pain, after all he killed Lust and lust meant a great dead to gluttony
iluvpickles99 1 month ago
he shouldent have made wrath wait, putting him through so much pain, he should had listened to wrath and knew he was a badass
brandan6559 1 month ago
I knew wrath was good from the start all he wanted was a family and he thought sloth was his mom but found out Izumi was his real mother and wanted to join here to me wrath is more of a neutral homunculas in the beginning
FalconTomahawk 1 month ago
Who agrees that Bradly would have fit more with Pride than Wrath for Fmab
shadowninja8246 1 month ago
1:13 gluttony put his rape face on, then proceeded to dominate wrath :P
TheWillszy 1 month ago
@TheWillszy hey Wrath was pretty badass he was hurting Gluttony pretty bad :).At end he sacrificed on purpose only.
Mariose123 1 month ago
i thought wrath was bradley o.0
poiklpoiuy1 1 month ago
@poiklpoiuy1 Bradly is Pride not Wrath in the original Fullmetal Alchemist. In Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, Bradly is Wrath while the Wrath you see here is Izumi's son and has Edward's Automail arm and leg.
shadowninja8246 1 month ago
@poiklpoiuy1 Oh and he is the only homunculi that does alchemy.
shadowninja8246 1 month ago
@shadowninja8246 wait so this guys from the first one or what? o-o
poiklpoiuy1 1 month ago
@poiklpoiuy1 yes he's from the first anime
MrInuhanyou123 1 month ago
@poiklpoiuy1 i thought envy was bradley o.O
liveyourlife5x5 1 month ago
@liveyourlife5x5 envys the dude that transforms into people
poiklpoiuy1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm starting to hate gluttony all over again...T_T well atleast wrath is happy with his mother finally :')
XPandaGaaraX 1 month ago
Comment removed
XPandaGaaraX 1 month ago
i hate gluttony so much wrath was awsome and he should have lived.
16blacknight 2 months ago
I like how Gluttony completely ignores Alphonse and goes all out on Wrath. This hints that despite his seemingly mindless, beastial transformation, he still remembers that Edward told him Wrath was the one who killed Lust, the most important being to him.
elvampe13 2 months ago 8
@elvampe13 How i percieved it was that Wrath was a homunculus who ate the red stones given by Envy way back in the series. Gluttony singled out Wrath because Wrath simply had more power that Gluttonly hungers for. Though your answer could just as well be right. Its all open to interpretation.
TheJeffersonE 1 month ago
@elvampe13 Maybe he could smell any leftover Stones in Wrath.
Hiveslayer18989 4 weeks ago
Who's the blonde haired dude?
Is it Elric?
Or his brother? After the transformation.
And who's the black haired one that reminds me of Lust?
Please respond.
Kyoshiro5411 2 months ago
@Kyoshiro5411 thats his brother at the end of the original fma he exchanged his alchemy and his whole body to give him his body back, he lives in the other world now. not spoiling the rest. in this series who ever you tried to use human transformation on became a homunculi, this is the teachers son
CodeRedPb 2 months ago
@Kyoshiro5411 the blond hair one is alphones.in the series that was the brother in the suit of armor.al got his body back because ed sacrifeds his own life to bring him back.the one with the black is wrath one of the seven homunculi, teacher (izumi's) son that died but came back as a homunculi. hope this helped
bensonbone 2 months ago
@Kyoshiro5411 both brothers last names were elric that was al
scoopy1917 3 weeks ago
The first anime (I will not call it the original series because it is not >:l ) Was pretty good but it just wasn't as great as Brotherhood/manga. I'm not being biased either cause the first anime was the one I first watched. I don't like that the Homunculi had feelings, it seemed like the makers were trying to hard to make it seem 'deep'. They are sins; They are not supposed to have reason for doing bad things, they are not supposed to care etc... Brotherhood was great in every way :) that's all
emokidsfriend666 2 months ago
@emokidsfriend666 What and you think the Homunculi from the manga/brotherhood anime didnt have feelings? Greed was all ''i have friends to fill my emptiness'' when he was dying near the end. Pride loved his fake mom and dad (the Fuhrer and his wife) and felt bad when Father left him, and Envy was crying when he admitted he was jealous of humans' potential. So... your point of view of ''Homunculi are not supposed to have feeling and are not supposed to care'' doesnt make sense.
elvampe13 2 months ago 3
@emokidsfriend666 I seen Brotherhood once. To me, it was mediorce. I thought it was great that the homunculus had feelings in 2003.That way they wouldn't be typical anime villains, including Dante. Father was a typical anime villain. In animes they always have the master villain fighting to become "god tier", more than they already are. FMA is #1 because it was original and unique. It played by its own game and didn't care for having fates in favor of fandom. FMA is legend!
Kakorat009 1 month ago 12
@Kakorat009 Brotherhood followed the Manga, not fandom. FMA didn't even follow the original story.
NarutoNinjaSensei 1 month ago
@NarutoNinjaSensei That doesn't mean anything.
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 I like your use of "god tier" in your sentence lol
Gamerjuana 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 It also made absolutely no sense in a number of ways With huge plot holes that FMAB really didn't have Envy is Ed's brother? really? So did Hoenhiem take a cup of his sperm each time he body swapped? Why are the Homunculi named after Sins for no apparent reason? they don't show any signs of their sin Why are they named it? Why do the Humonculi only regenerate sometimes? Why can Pride age? Why did Gluttony become this monster? Father didn't want to become God He wanted to become FREE.
TheWalrusface 1 month ago
@TheWalrusface I can explain everything. Not all,sense it is too big for one comment. K, Dante and Hoehenheim lived in a time where Christianity dominated almost all of Europe with a iron fist. Because they wiped out huge populations across the continent to make the philosopher's stone,the power of the church was cut down to minors.From century to century Dante thought of herself as the gaurdian of sin. The 7 sins comes from Christianity,(continued)
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 THAT'S WHAT I'VE BEEN SAYING FOR YEARS! You are smart!
MySushiBear 1 month ago
@MySushiBear Thanks my friend
Kakorat009 1 month ago
@Kakorat009 I applaud you sir.
Brennen938 3 weeks ago
also is that why ed's voice is wierd
ROFLCOOKI3Z 2 months ago
@rwmroy how does that work. is al in ed's body or something?
ROFLCOOKI3Z 2 months ago
Brothrhood wraith would have kicked both of there asses
brooklyn560 2 months ago 2
looks like a mix of ed and envy, similar clothes to envy not to mention long black hair and this dude (wrath?) has automail on his arm and leg plus the same eyes from ed (and notice a little curl at the top? o.O
Isecretus1191 2 months ago
Ed looks weird in this one
ChromeGhost0219 2 months ago
@ChromeGhost0219 That's because that isn't Ed, it's Al .
rwmroy 2 months ago
@rwmroy o_O
ChromeGhost0219 2 months ago
@ChromeGhost0219 I believe you haven't seen episode 51 or the movie of FMA. -_-;
LoopyPanda11 2 months ago
@LoopyPanda11 you be correct
ChromeGhost0219 2 months ago
who the fuck is wrath? fma:b FTW!
xRxexLx 2 months ago
Wrath's voice actor is amazing for the English dub
vomoka121313 2 months ago
Gluttony in the 2003 series creeps the shit out of me...so hideous and discussing, and especially in this particular battle, he really got fucked up.
On the other hand, the Gluttony in 2009 series...is sort of cute (perhaps the way he acts and talks?) if u know what I mean. No homo :p
jason1919spezza 2 months ago
One thing I didn't like about Brotherhood, but enjoyed in the original, was how many philosopher stones there were. Just kind of lessened the significance of them.
The original only ever had the one philosopher's stone created in the boy's journey, which made it more of an event than in brotherhood where it practically rains philosopher's stones.
Damon242 2 months ago
@Damon242 I know right. It was like everyone in their grandma had a stone in Brotherhood.
Dattebayo04 2 months ago
English dub is so incredibly obnoxious
dragonsder 2 months ago
@dragonsder which is of course why it's regarded as one the best english dubs ever done for any anime
Fullmetal Alchemist may be the rare anime in which the majority lean towards the english version over the japanese
Damon242 2 months ago
Super Saiyan 3 Envy
TheAwesomeDarkNinja 2 months ago
AHHHHHHHHH Y U MAKE ME CRY MY ASS OF AGAIN!? ლ(ಠ益ಠლ
JaycoubbRulez 2 months ago
what is the difference between manga and anime
SuperGauss100 2 months ago
@SuperGauss100 The manga (and brotherhood) have the 7 Homonculi be complete cardboard cut-outs of their respective sins. In contrast, the 2003 show actually gave the homonculi character development (the biggest example being Lust's loyalty towards her maker wavering and eventually wanting to be human). Your mileage may vary, but I prefer a story with really interesting villans to bland ones.
LordManda2 2 months ago
@LordManda2 Oh right. The villains are just as developed (actually more so) by the fact that they represent the deepest truths of our sins. Lust was no more deep for wanting to be human, in fact the reasoning for this desire was nothing beyond a "just because" plot point. I too prefer a storyline with less bland villains. I just think brotherhood actually followed a coherent story while delivering just that.
ebonmaskarade77 2 months ago
@ebonmaskarade77 While delivering WHAT? more 1-dimentional cardboard cut out villans? >_>
LordManda2 2 months ago
@LordManda2 All I'm hearing is: "I don't like change!"
ebonmaskarade77 2 months ago
@ebonmaskarade77 I found more investment in the characters of Ed, Alphonse, Lust, and Hughes, in the original series than Brotherhood. However, Brotherhood further developed every other character.
Personally, for me, Bradley steals the show in both versions.
I prefer Brotherhood's plot, because it serves as a better narrative. However, I do think that the original's ending was more poetic.
Damon242 2 months ago
@ebonmaskarade77
I say, for the best experience, one should watch the first thirty episodes of the original series and then continue from the thirteenth episode of Brotherhood until the very end.
Those first ten episodes rushed important character development, and definitely failed to explain the functions of alchemy. It really must be a struggle for someone who hasn't read the manga or seen the first series to understand precisely what is going on in those first ten episodes.
Damon242 2 months ago
@Damon242 I guess that's a fair point. I kinda moved over the first few episodes of brotherhood since they were mostly recap.
ebonmaskarade77 2 months ago
Is it Al and who is the other one with the black hair?! O.O It can't be Edward
DarkBlue123123 2 months ago
Gluttony really let himself go...
Stripeify 3 months ago 2
@Stripeify LOL!
rubberduckyrox1 2 months ago
what season is this
nightfangpheonixwolf 3 months ago
@nightfangpheonixwolf its from the movie, Conqueror of Shambala
ryok345 2 months ago
DAMN IT GLUTTONY!!!! IM GONNA KILL THE SHIT OUTA YOU!!
Bakugan090501 3 months ago
NNNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO WRATH!!! I LOVE YOU!!!!!.
ps. WRATH IS MINE!!
Bakugan090501 3 months ago
"I just have one thing to say...PIE TRUCK!!!!" 0:57
MrWerehog23 3 months ago
Was gluttony sweating blood?
kp142010 3 months ago
@kp142010 It's not blood, it's the philosopher's stone - remember that Al was turned into the Stone and Gluttony ate part of him.
OroborusFMA 3 months ago
@kp142010 Actually I think that was a part of the philosophers stone. :0 Not too sure, though.
LightOrangeFur 3 months ago
@LightOrangeFur yeah it was philosephers stone.
Osolagolpe 3 months ago
Por Wrath, why is it that the Humunculi that look like kids are always the best...
In FMA: Wrath
In Brotherhood: Pride
hmph fuck it then both kicked ass :D
Just10L 3 months ago
;A; Wrath...I LUVEDED YOUUUUUUUU!!!!!!!!
XInuYashaLoverxxX 3 months ago
The fma dubbed is one of the best im sorry but hearing jap gets kinda annoying afterall esp since you don't really have to listen to it..
mynameisvirdal 4 months ago
@mynameisvirdal
1. FMA
2. Soul Eater
3. Samurai Champloo
Best Dubb ever hands down
PnOyMaN101 4 months ago
@SgtGoste That fight was from 'Brotherhood' and the person they were fighting was the Humonculus Father after he supposedly absorbed 'God'; he then took on the appearance of Ed or a younger Hohemheim. It was easily on of the best fights in the series:-)
Zomochi 4 months ago
Just watched the entire original fma series and shimbala movie. I thought the movie was flipping awesome buy that's my opinion. Also thought this fight was really cool. Secondly, I saw a clip sumwhere where a bunch of people were fighting sum1 who looked sorta like Ed but they couldn't do any damage to him cos he had sum kinda oink force field around him. Was wondering what it was from. I think it was fma but I dno if it was the 2nd movie or from brotherhood which I havnt seen yet
SgtGoste 4 months ago
@DarkSoulsOST I agree. The animation in Brotherhood was top-notch and don't even get me started on the fight scenes:-) To tell the truth, I found out about the manga after I started hearing news that the original anime deviated from it halfway.
Zomochi 4 months ago
@Zomochi Couldn't agree more : )
DestroyedSanity 4 months ago
that shit seem like it hurt
19superfrost 4 months ago
christ i hate dubbed, every voice actor sounds way too over-exaggerated and it's just not how real english is spoken. that's the reason i like subbed better.
h2theibrid 4 months ago
@h2theibrid i'll never watch Naruto in english..Narutos voice in that is annoying.
theLOWation 4 months ago
@theLOWation if avoidable, i would never watch anything in english ever again lol.
h2theibrid 4 months ago
@h2theibrid lol..i've watched more then 200 episodes of bleach in jap. only at first cause it stopped being dubbed up untill 164 so i just got use to subtitles.
theLOWation 4 months ago
@theLOWation sakura's is worse
Lostprophetzzz 4 months ago
@Lostprophetzzz yeah it was pretty bad. atleast this series didn't suffer from bad English voice overs.
theLOWation 4 months ago
@theLOWation yeah....
FMA dubbed is fantastic,
funimation are the kings of dubbing.
Lostprophetzzz 4 months ago 2
The original anime is and always will the one I remember fondly; Brotherhood may follow the manga to a 't', but the original is the one that pretty much established everything FullmetalAchemist:'-)
Zomochi 4 months ago 25
@Zomochi Even though the original FMA has some sort of a nostalgic value, I thought that Brotherhood was much better. Since the ending of Conqueror of Shamballa pretty much ruined the original series IMO. It was good until the end.
DarkSoulsOST 4 months ago
@Zomochi
True that xD I'm know it was because my younger childhood revolved around the original anime that I just can't love anything else as much
ChasingDestination 3 months ago
@Zomochi the first was nothin compared to brotherhood, too many people died and the ending wasnt that great, while as brotherhood had everyone come together at the end to beat father and had a good ending
VinoVash1234 2 months ago