张靓颖Jane Zhang— Listen 现场版live

[kingkong24680]

that's not even close to her capability.... I am disappointed...

[g12366666]

我覺得在某些極高音或是極低音的句子,收尾太急促了,有種隔靴搔­癢的感覺,可是在最後面Ending部分(轉音),控制氣又相當­的有層次,可能這是他的表現方式,不過我聽了沒啥感覺....

[x2x5x0x]

她的聲音在這首歌上演釋不夠圓滑...(某些歌詞上)

[velvetea100]

pls search VELVETEA GULFAN LISTEN

[velvetea100]

nice

[youjoker1]

還聼~而且還很漂亮~~漂亮都上豪艇的~

[victorvictor771]

我是張的歌迷,這首歌是唱得不夠好,但也很不錯了,符的確幾好聽­,但我聽佢現場

走音囉..走音已經係無得比..



[beck520520]

@victorvictor771 請問是哪場走音 我聽瓊音這麼多場 沒聽過她listen走音~

[shannondoahminiskirt]

很難唱的一首歌

[NANAaiko]

it's not the original key... still, most talented chinese singer ...

[stanl3y040601]

Jane Zhang, Beyonce & Melanie Amaro are the world's talent. They have their own color of voice. So we couldn't compare them each other. JBU all

[lhhoyc]

she makes this song sound so easy...even beyonce herself struggles with her vocals on live performances...

[bananang]

i hate to say this.. but i felt the performance was a little choppy :/

[Sessa333]

I think she's good...great range. BUT I'm chinese and we have a TON of people. I just kinda expected better.

[ritz1622]

@Sessa333 i was thinking the same thing and im not chinese ;p

[1992chaster]

i know jane zhang is a good singer, but charice is a gifted and good. Pls don't compare charice and jane "We are all Asian" don't slander and don't compare each other. Because charice is a pride of Asian that's why i said now i'm proud to be Asian.

[ritz1622]

@1992chaster sweetheart, they compare not becoz of we want to know who's better but jane the acknowledgement jane recieved is too much so people expected a big big talent from her that will totally blown us away. jane is talented YES! but not big of a talent.I even see better singers who makes covers of this song in youtube who sounds better.dont get me wrong im not against jane,just kind of curious how she got famous like that.

[Shmily533]

@ritz1622 admittedly, this kind of song is not Jane's strongest suit, but it's worth noting that she finished performance after she had sung more than 30 songs already.

PS: Jane is so great because she is soooooooo versatile...There are loads loads of other music type other than the big songs like "listen" that Jane excels in...

[upallhours9]

Nice sound she has.

[HDsharp]

Jane sings better high notes and is more conservative in her style but Charice is a true performer and gifted in areas where no other performer can match, there lies the difference, even tho Charice sings loud at times, she shouts with melody and its motionally stuff and it works for her... Im chinese.

[derektor082208]

@HDsharp Im a Filipino and there is a thousand Charice in the philippines...She is just a common one just lucky given a break from youtube...Her talent is to scream which is too much already and not soothing to listen anymore...Jane Zhang I admire coz she is hitting the right notes and not that irritating shout...Actually Jane killed the song Loving You and Charice wont even hit that note...

[spawnkiddo]

@derektor082208 TANG INA MO! eto pala yung sinasabi mong JANE ZHANG. wlang talent. LETSE MAKA COMPARE LANG> GAGO!!>:)

[derektor082208]

@spawnkiddo wahaha di mo matanggap???eto pa type mo Loving you by Jane Zhang wahaha para matulkala ka...bobo..

[HDsharp]

@derektor082208

Well, i think Charice is world class and beyond, easily the best singer in the world right now, she can carry notes so clearly that others cant match, you say she screams but she never ever sounds too harsh to the ear despite that and never sounds strained, providing she can produce notes that are clear it will work, those are her qualities, even here when Jane sings hard you can detect some strain in her voice, but never with Charice.

[derektor082208]

@HDsharp If thats what you believe..Dont worry I know you are a pathetic Charice fans...Checked your Channel you are just a dude coming to this channel and compare Charice....I compare too but I prepare Jane...and you say you are Chinese you cant even type a word from Chinese...Stop and you wont Change me I found your bitchy Charice too ugly and too loud to listen...SO fuck yourself asshole pretending to be good just to compare...

[HDsharp]

@derektor082208 Whats wrong with u?, I gave valid reasons why Charice is a far more gifted talent than any1 today, I just discovered Charice so Im no way bias at all, just being totally honest. Theres never been an asian singer embraced by the west largely becos of ignorance and stereotypes, Charice had to be that good to be accepted becos Charice's talent is undeniable, any who knows about singing can tell. 'Lay mo lo' (u got no brain!)

[1992chaster]

@derektor082208 pare siraulo ka nga talaga ahaha

[1992chaster]

@derektor082208 pare adik ka ba ahaha

[1992chaster]

@derektor082208 you wrong not a thousand, a million fans in the philippines and all around the world..you are so pathetic ahahaha

[spawnkiddo]

@HDsharp You def right @HDsharp . Comparing those two wouldn't give you anything but a headache. But if you would compare Charice t other singers THERE in the PHILIPPNES, no one could bet her but her SELF.:)

[TiminingTinglY]

继续加油

[leidee0220]

OMG! i can see her veins in her neck,,she sometimes had a flat note,,but nice try,,

[beck520520]

去聽符瓊音 河岸版 拜托拜托~

[janiceeey]

咬字爛透了

[Andoyanyan]

爛透了.



[z19237]

普普通 沒爆發力倡這首 太吃虧了 ~ HOID不太住

[kakafish18]

love jane's voice

[fanfy419]

Vabbè,lei canta non solo le canzoni cinesi,ma anche tante le altre occidentali....jane zhang e charice pempengo sono veramente di 2 tipi diversi. adoro tutte e 2!!! XD

[fanfy419]

@hfxxj007, you're right that charice is more brave to sing this song.bcause she has more power,but jane is very brave and talented to sing the chinese song.if you are not a chinese e don't know appreciate the orientale culture,you will never know how fantastic e talented jane zhang is!! non so se mi sia spiegata o no,perchè non so parlare bene la inglese....XD

[archidexterous20]

Jane Zhang is a very talented singer and she's hot Lol XD but i have to say Charice Pempengco of the philippines sang this song 100000000x times better , and YES ! even better than beyonce did..

Remember: There's so many talented singers in the world but very few are GIFTED !!!

[Sibunagleek]

@archidexterous20

you're right, charice is better ;)

[attn0618]

去聽聽李佳薇的拜託

[biligeuyanga]

还是去听 CHARICE唱的吧

[biligeuyanga]

没有力度，没有感觉。咬字不清。她真的不适合唱英文歌。还是唱中­文的吧。画皮多好听。

[c76h]

less powerful? maybe, if comparing to someone or two. however, Jane is even more skillful. She well presented her talent in controlling her colourful charming voice. Hitting high notes is not all for this and every music. how it flows between low and high notes matters. That's why i prefer jane's performance rather than some more "louder" singer's.

[nightsucks]

@c76h

agree , charice just 's screaming , jane is a soulful singer , much much more versatile

[hfxxj007]

@nightsucks

Do you even know singing? Everyone screams at high notes, but the difference is the power. Charice has a very powerful voice. You think Jane could do that?

[derektor082208]

@hfxxj007 Well yes she can...Its easy to learn how to scream with the melody but do Charice will hit the notes of Highest Pitch of Loving you????Dont think so....

[chocolatemontero]

@c76h if your jane is good ... where is she now ? and where is charice ? charice is international now... do u think your jane can become inter. ?

[Brakballe]

@chocolatemontero Ehh... China is 1.3 billion people, sometimes care more grow "Home market" than bother outside. A classical example is Faye Wong, a one that have NO competitors in Asia, then why bother with West pigs?

[c76h]

@chocolatemontero hi, i 1st heard charice when she was 13 yrs old and fell in love with her voice ever since. though, i don't think it will ever be a problem for me to love miss jane zhang's talent meanwhile. well, my answer to your question, where is jane now? in the hearts of millions.

[HDsharp]

@chocolatemontero The west are too ignorant to take asian musicians seriously, until they see a talent that is undeniable like Charice, its always been that way, this alone proves Charice is a much better performer.

[nickytl]

可以去聽他唱的loving you ， 這樣就知道他的實力在哪? 別批評了

[m155341]

撐不住這首歌!!

[ashley0825288]

I don't think this was her best performance, she kinda messed. nevertheless, still love her

[astraphille]

hmm...i guess she' s okay...

[dorothy148]

@astraphille agreed. too sweet and less grooving and not enough power.

[liudukaiying]

@3.17，偷偷換氣，真聰明！！

[liudukaiying]

咬字比日本人還要糟

[futurefighter2008]

@liudukaiying

oh yea? biased biatch.

[ashley0825288]

@liudukaiying 开什么国际玩笑

[tcp5359]

爆发力不够，听起来怪怪的。好像很没力...

[bruce820213]

不過有一點 演唱會需要的體力跟選秀只要唱一首的體力差蠻多的



[tidus1804]

如果我在現場的話,我一定起立鼓掌大喊安可,別無選擇

[jstcuzimvicory]

聲音不適合這首歌 沒爆發力 

[candiclin]

唱的太好聽了

[yuhua1234]

讲说实话，这首歌论唱功和连贯性，靓颖比符和alin都好，但是­好像2007的她还有mariah carey的影子在

[beck520520]

@yuhua1234 說實話 符瓊音明顯好很多 ~而且alin也比靓穎唱的好...個人還是最推符瓊音版

[yuhua1234]

@beck520520 我倒觉得低音部分靓颖唱的最有感觉，不得不说，高音部分真的没有­符琼音好。 话说回来，这首歌重点还就是那个高音，呵呵

[yuhua1234]

@beck520520 不过如果让靓颖现在来唱，肯定会很好，当年她的高音的确算是很薄­

[wcc010487]

平平无奇。。。符的真的好很多

[beck520520]

我覺得張靓穎和ALIN都沒有符瓊音唱的好...另一個朱俐靜版­本也是不錯選擇

[ejsionan]

@beck520520 我覺得 都很好^^

[aa80082818]

不適合的曲風，聲音稍扁，沒有強烈表達的感覺，或許他有點累了。­

[avantyavanty]

蠻特別的版本 好聽

很多高音沒有唱到

[proudhao]

这是演唱会最后阶段了，张靓颖有点累了，所以没发挥出最佳水准。

什么付琼英、朱丽静的，我只有笑笑，半吊子歌手，不是一个级别。

特别是付琼英，唱loving you跟要她命似地，哈哈

[gary21956]

林育群還趕搬出來說 林育群唱的這麼爛 丟臉丟到國外去了。 誰敢說張靓穎唱得不好 有誰去走過格萊美的紅地毯阿 ?跟安德烈.波切利。譚盾。喜多郎合作過的又是誰阿。別在那自以­為聽過幾首歌就在那隨便批評。他這首歌的確唱的不是非常好。但也­不差阿。演唱會總是這樣的。張靓穎又是一位喜歡即興發揮的歌手，­現場的本版跟原版當來有弱差，什麼又叫走音，只要音順就不叫走音­，別亂說人因抓不準。但是又有哪些歌手每首歌都適合呢???

[ejsionan]

@gary21956 嗯~!沒錯，靚穎的真誠，大家都聽得到。如此真誠的歌手，有幾個­歌星做的到?? 不管怎麼樣，我就是喜歡聽靚穎唱歌^^..

[jenderstar77]

跟樓下說的一樣

真的該去聽聽看Charice - Listen 她的現場

她超強 比原唱還要強

[Joows]

不好听！！！

[beck520520]

建議聽聽朱俐靜還有符瓊音的版本^^

[ajoe999]

還有我想說說的是 一場演唱下來 有哪位歌手不是唱三四十首歌曲 

難道那些歌手 MC .Celine Dion WH .甚至華人實力歌手 一場演唱會都唱一兩首而已嗎

狀況還不是好的很 又不是只有張靓潁而已

有的歌手整場不停歇 快歌唱跳連飆好幾首 抒情難度又高的歌手造樣還不是整場三十多首唱的好的不得了

[cssmylove]

@ajoe999 嗯 也不知道你听过几场演唱会, 搞笑, 下巴佬就不要装

[ajoe999]

@cssmylove

你說她在美國很出名?  才讓我覺得你是活在自己的世界

[ajoe999]

聽聽這位菲律賓女孩唱的吧

搜尋以下文字 --

Charice Pempengco Listen (Beyoncé)

[ajoe999]

在麻煩你去搜尋 家家 這位卑南族歌手 或是她姊姊 紀曉君

光是寬廣厚實又高低自如的 實力唱功 真的連外國人都說好

好的歌手

不是只有對岸的這位而已好嗎!

[bearbear1717]

音不算隱

在一分鐘時的"I am"二字差一點有音準問題

加上Key有點低

不是最好的演出

[edwardqiu]

唱得真好！！！！！！　我听过最好的版本，府算什么，还想跟靓颖比！！　唱完３０几首歌以后还能有这样的表现才叫有实力。

[Vincent512768]

這首澎湃的大歌唱的很平，聲音聽起來很乾。實在稱不上是一個好的­演出。

[m155341]

如果是唱了三十首之後這樣我可以原諒她!音真的很......不­夠好!

至於厚度~個人覺得唱很厚不等於好~可是薄聽起還很膽戰心驚

張小姐應該會家多練一下再來唱這首歌

[aabbone]

....怎麼感覺他唱這首歌有點痛苦 音扁扁的...

[kagowoo]

有些单字的发音很有问题，有点乱来。

整个表演我只喜欢ending那几句。

[ally1201]

除了原唱，我还是比较喜欢符瓊音的版本。

[pi1617]

這板的盲毛評論太多了,不評也吧

[ajoe999]

她低音中頻聲音唱的不錯 但她真高音真的不行

海豚音很穩很漂亮沒錯 但這首歌她唱的很免強 尤其不用海豚音的高音 她唱起來就是很免強

這首歌她唱的不好也不動人 可以看出她有很多破綻

[edwardqiu]

@ajoe999 你少来ＴＭＤ黑。　去看看她音域的视频知道她的真音比Beyonce, MC, and Celine Dion 都高！！　有本事你也唱完３４首歌来唱这个，　看你能怎么样。

[ajoe999]

@edwardqiu

她唱這首歌 真的不好 有許多破綻 比他掌握這首歌的選秀或在線歌手好的 不在少數

當然我承認她有她的優勢 並不全然推翻這位歌手的實力 好嗎!

這首歌麻煩你去~搜尋Alin的版本 唱的比她好太多了 看官自有定論!

[wmb13579]

@ajoe999

隔離有個二萬幾點擊唔睇？

同A.LIN的版本一樣現場收音

明顯是張靚穎唱得較好

我覺得靚穎唱這首歌感情連貫，又有個人風格，很好

靚音色加洽到好處的爆發力，現場聽一定好正。

[victorvictor771]

@wmb13579 Jcxzero 於 2009-01-20 上傳 3:38 28xxxx點擊果首2:51走左,我有馬上去睇第二個版,係好­好聽,無刻意扁低佢,咁啱第一個版就睇到e個

[ajoe999]

@edwardqiu

聽你說張女 唱的比國際級的 MC. Celine Dion .Beyonce 還要好還要高 我真的想笑了

不好意思 你要不要在加 她比惠妮休士頓還強

這麼說 好像全世界張姓歌手最強最力厲害是神了是嗎 (笑..) 真是自我感覺良好

[cssmylove]

@ajoe999 不好意思,张在日本很出名,现在美国也很出名, 她现在也在慢慢的变国际级.

以海豚音位标准的话她是比很多歌手高吧, 还有这个版本效果不好还有个原因是录制不好,现场听感觉会不一样

[ajoe999]

@cssmylove

笑話 她在美國日本很出名 林育群在美國也很出名阿 其它歌手就沒有嗎? 你別活在自己的世界了

別上個國外節目就以為是多出名了?

不知你在美國很出名的定義是什麼?

是有在美國出唱片名震全世界嗎? 那李玟在美國上過多少節目出了英文專輯 又證明了什麼???

[roy99048]

不少音準飄掉了

但是高音部份的音色表現是很不錯的

符的聲音則是高因缺乏厚度  兩者都各自有優缺點

但是以華人來說能唱到這樣的程度已經值得嘉獎了

[ajoe999]

她高音若沒用海豚就是很刻意免強有點不穩的上去

如果你去聽聽她其他仿效歌曲 不用海豚音表現的時候 她的高音很刻意很危險

她最佳的表現在於音域寬度 中低音頻的好聽 還有海豚音控制的精準穩度 但唱一首歌不是只能賣弄花腔 沒深入內心的詮釋

[typhooon003]

非常勉強耶

[judoyiji]

不適合,都沒有在pitch 上

[supportamiee]

不是吧！

[raikage90]

hao ting

[joe80914]

沒有符瓊音來的到位.聲音不適合這首.不夠厚實.唱到好像快死了­==''

[nightsucks]

符瓊音唱到很像一头牛这样,逼到头要爆了.T.,T

张靓颖的声音高贵多了又够细腻,真假转音好过太多了,后者唱过很­音乐大师写的歌,如(我用所有抱da ai)

kitaro de impress of the west lake

[supportamiee]

not really!

[raytw888]

很舒服的版本～ 是另一種不同的味道～ 華人就屬靓穎和瓊音把這首歌詮釋的最好^ ^

[evezcl]

演唱会30几首歌以后的最后一首歌唱成这样。。厉害！

[highburycatherine]

靓颖 · 好棒啊~

[aiki0914]

唱的真輕鬆= =