This song is in 4/4. Listen more closely. The lead is mostly in 16th notes, with some 32nd note embellishments, and the backup chords change every measure, each of which is 4 beats long.
I've danced many, many reels. This is most definitely a reel.
Don't worry- being relatively new to Irish traditional music myself, I know exactly how the confusion arose. There absolutely IS a jig in 6/8 also called the Swallowtail, and though it turns out to be an entirely different tune the identical titles cause them to be mixed up all the time. The further you get into this music the more you'll find that there are actually a lot of different Irish tunes that share names, and even more confusingly, many that have different names but identical melodies!
@PEIDanielScott An Irish reel would be played on a fiddle not a violin, theres a difference, don't come on here acting the expert. I bet your a feckin yank...
Actually, if you look at my other comments it will state that I've only been playing for a few months, Never claimed to be an expert. Also, a Fiddle and a Violin are the exact same instrument.
@Drunkcox707 I'm with you on the Jameson :) However, don't forget the good old Bushmills distillery on the north coast of Ireland. A close second in my opinion!
@Emmettdoyle1 Who give's a damn no one's an expect compared to barney so pay your respects and keep yer mouth shut. Ireland, american, russia there's no difference we're all human and your whinning won't change that
@Emmettdoyle1 Whats wrong with americans i don't understand why you hate us, we are the most diverse country, which means we definitly aren't all alike. Im as irish as they come here an im damn proud of it.
@Drunkcox707 you live in america, yet you're "as irish as they come"? righto mate. no issue with your sentiment, just think about what you're saying next time, or you'll make yourself look like an ass... again.
@MrThedalaillamaknows an how do i make myself look like an ass by being proud of where my blood comes from. YOU i believe look more of an ass. So what, am i not supposed to care the least bit about where my family came from? Well fuck you buddy. You may be fine an dandy growin up in ireland but here all we got to be proud of is where our blood came from because i dont agree with alot of what my country does. get off your high horse!
@MrThedalaillamaknows an how do i make myself look like an ass by being proud of where my blood comes from. YOU i believe look more of an ass. So what, am i not supposed to care the least bit about where my family came from? Well fuck you buddy. You may be fine an dandy growin up in ireland but here all we got to be proud of is where our blood came from because i dont agree with alot of what my country does. get off your high horse!
@Drunkcox707 You can be proud all you like, i have no objection to this, infact, i think it's great to be proud of your heritage. It is important now more than ever to keep in mind traditional cultures and heritage. But going around and saying "i'm as Irish as they come" when you're clearly not, will achieve one of two things, you'll either end up being laughed at, because you'll look like an arse or you'll get your teeth knocked out. Depends on who you say it to. So try "I have irish heritage".
@MrThedalaillamaknows im clearly not irish? lol Ive got a sliver of german an just bout completely irish i have close family who live in ireland in the county meeth you can kiss my ass an try to knock my teeth out but i highly doubt it.
'traditional irish mandolin' always cracks me up, along with the traditional irish bazouki.. ah they make me giggle. (yeah yeah i know they really were re-made etc etc to become irish)
The5th- The mandolin and bazouki were picked-up on the shores of the mediterranean by the traditional irish people, who came out of africa about 80,ooo years ago, on their way to the Puck Fair. Barney McKenna was one of them!!!
any one know the name of the second reel
fergwaggle 2 days ago
Wonderful!! :D :D
EdoardoBedogni 4 months ago
Why is theres always a row going on in the comments to a lot of these traditional tunes - lads can't you just enjoy the music???
soop67 5 months ago
Great Music
26odonnell 7 months ago
American, Irish or whatever, you can't doubt the superbness of his playing
xlbottomlx 8 months ago 5
WOW it sounds like STRONGHOLD 2!!
lumthegreat 10 months ago
penis
Collinffs 11 months ago
hmm, this makes me want to pick up the banjo again.
fringer6 11 months ago
excellent! *****
acerb45666555 1 year ago
MAGNIFICENT
cant spell but you know what i mean!!
Crombienation17 1 year ago
Banjo Barney from Donnycarney, in full flight.
angelf1re 1 year ago
Barney plays a 4-string
spunnek75 1 year ago
McKenna plays the so called Irish Tenor Banjo,wich he truly self-invented.
He puts a GDAE tuning on an ordinary 19 or 17 frets 4 string banjo.
spunnek75 1 year ago
@spunnek75 Wait, so he tunes it like a violin? Odd. Cool, but still odd. Aren't banjos tuned usually in fourths instead of fifths?
Epidemic52 1 year ago
@Epidemic52 the irish tenor banjo can be tuned the same as a fiddle, but an octave down.
neilhosey 1 year ago
I really hate to nit-pick about this...but Swallowtail is in 6/8 time so it would be a Jig, not a reel. Reels are in 4/4 time.
Only reason I know this is because I've recently started taking Violin lessons.
PEIDanielScott 1 year ago
@PEIDanielScott
This song is in 4/4. Listen more closely. The lead is mostly in 16th notes, with some 32nd note embellishments, and the backup chords change every measure, each of which is 4 beats long.
I've danced many, many reels. This is most definitely a reel.
Flatcap4 1 year ago
@Flatcap4
I stand corrected. Thanks much Flatcap.
PEIDanielScott 1 year ago
@PEIDanielScott
I hope your lessons will devote a bit more time to recognizing key signatures -- this is most definitely in 4/4 time, not 6/8 time.
Whistlecelt 1 year ago
@Whistlecelt
I agree. I still have so much to learn. I admit I was wrong.
PEIDanielScott 1 year ago
Don't worry- being relatively new to Irish traditional music myself, I know exactly how the confusion arose. There absolutely IS a jig in 6/8 also called the Swallowtail, and though it turns out to be an entirely different tune the identical titles cause them to be mixed up all the time. The further you get into this music the more you'll find that there are actually a lot of different Irish tunes that share names, and even more confusingly, many that have different names but identical melodies!
shadowsongs914 1 year ago
@PEIDanielScott An Irish reel would be played on a fiddle not a violin, theres a difference, don't come on here acting the expert. I bet your a feckin yank...
Emmettdoyle1 1 year ago
@Emmettdoyle1
Actually, if you look at my other comments it will state that I've only been playing for a few months, Never claimed to be an expert. Also, a Fiddle and a Violin are the exact same instrument.
By the way, I'm Canadian.
PEIDanielScott 1 year ago
@PEIDanielScott i apologise on behalf of that arsehole emmettdoyle1. we are not all like that..
neilhosey 1 year ago
@neilhosey I didnt think so, I cant wait to have the chance to visit ireland i can already hear her calling...
What would be a great place for an american to go over there? I would really like to go to the Jameson distillery
my favorite whiskey ever ;)
Drunkcox707 10 months ago
@Drunkcox707 I'm with you on the Jameson :) However, don't forget the good old Bushmills distillery on the north coast of Ireland. A close second in my opinion!
DrQTron 10 months ago
Comment removed
vandaylen 1 year ago
@Emmettdoyle1 ... your an arsehole... and an incorrect arsehole. keep quiet, ur making the rest of the irish look like brainless cunts.
neilhosey 1 year ago
@Emmettdoyle1 Who give's a damn no one's an expect compared to barney so pay your respects and keep yer mouth shut. Ireland, american, russia there's no difference we're all human and your whinning won't change that
funkwolf1 1 year ago
Comment removed
vandaylen 1 year ago
@Emmettdoyle1 Whats wrong with americans i don't understand why you hate us, we are the most diverse country, which means we definitly aren't all alike. Im as irish as they come here an im damn proud of it.
Drunkcox707 11 months ago
@Drunkcox707 you live in america, yet you're "as irish as they come"? righto mate. no issue with your sentiment, just think about what you're saying next time, or you'll make yourself look like an ass... again.
MrThedalaillamaknows 10 months ago
@MrThedalaillamaknows an how do i make myself look like an ass by being proud of where my blood comes from. YOU i believe look more of an ass. So what, am i not supposed to care the least bit about where my family came from? Well fuck you buddy. You may be fine an dandy growin up in ireland but here all we got to be proud of is where our blood came from because i dont agree with alot of what my country does. get off your high horse!
Drunkcox707 10 months ago
@MrThedalaillamaknows an how do i make myself look like an ass by being proud of where my blood comes from. YOU i believe look more of an ass. So what, am i not supposed to care the least bit about where my family came from? Well fuck you buddy. You may be fine an dandy growin up in ireland but here all we got to be proud of is where our blood came from because i dont agree with alot of what my country does. get off your high horse!
Drunkcox707 10 months ago
@Drunkcox707 You can be proud all you like, i have no objection to this, infact, i think it's great to be proud of your heritage. It is important now more than ever to keep in mind traditional cultures and heritage. But going around and saying "i'm as Irish as they come" when you're clearly not, will achieve one of two things, you'll either end up being laughed at, because you'll look like an arse or you'll get your teeth knocked out. Depends on who you say it to. So try "I have irish heritage".
MrThedalaillamaknows 1 month ago
@MrThedalaillamaknows im clearly not irish? lol Ive got a sliver of german an just bout completely irish i have close family who live in ireland in the county meeth you can kiss my ass an try to knock my teeth out but i highly doubt it.
Drunkcox707 4 weeks ago
@Drunkcox707 Were you born in Ireland? Were you raised in Ireland?
MrThedalaillamaknows 3 weeks ago
@Drunkcox707 Don't worry there's only one person looking like an ass on here and it's not you. Most of us really like Americans :)
tony10396861 9 months ago
Best reel!!
beatmark 2 years ago
is the second tune Ivy leaf ???
In irish music i prefer mandolin but this video just might change my mind .... realy nicely played
Aljazhhh 2 years ago
Nope. 2nd tune is "The High Reel". It's fairly often played with "Ivy Leaf".
Barney still plays both tunes from that recording. I'll be seeing the lads on 16 March. Can't wait!
buddhUU 2 years ago
Baaaaaaaaarneeeeyyyyyyyyy!!!!!!!
EUGENIOS87 2 years ago
Wow, Thanks for posting this!
Barney does it again! :-)
BoudiccaBlanc 2 years ago 7
great stuff and you dont play superspeed like a lot of clowns.
grrdconroy 2 years ago
pinacoladathe5th-
Thank you for sharing your opinion about mandolins and bozoukis. What exactly does this have to do with the banjo you're listening to?
shadowsongs914 2 years ago 3
'traditional irish mandolin' always cracks me up, along with the traditional irish bazouki.. ah they make me giggle. (yeah yeah i know they really were re-made etc etc to become irish)
pinacoladathe5th 3 years ago
The5th- The mandolin and bazouki were picked-up on the shores of the mediterranean by the traditional irish people, who came out of africa about 80,ooo years ago, on their way to the Puck Fair. Barney McKenna was one of them!!!
jimbutler1950 3 years ago 26
@jimbutler1950 some crac too
BarryChuckle9 1 year ago
Awesome! None better.
ScottInVa1760 3 years ago
as clear and bright as raindrops in the sunlight. :)
MCD77 3 years ago 5
the second tune here is "The High Reel"
Cluin 3 years ago
great tune, Brilliant Barney.
killiekentman 3 years ago 2