Beyonce - He Loves Me live in Oberhausen 17.05.07

[EdwinElChulo]

I could listen to this all day n night

[EdwinElChulo]

That end note is def my fave

[EdwinElChulo]

Wow. Sooo calming and soothing is her voice

[marsvsbounty]

gooooooood job

[MsSupreme92]

das is so beleidigend weil jill scott is einfach unvergleichbar!! was ne harte verletzung der ehre tssss

[ncladler]

TERRIBLE

[SoulRebelRising]

NO One like Jill!!! But mimic=flattery, and she doesnt even change it that much, so she obviously just really likes the song...If I had a set I'd probably do it too!

[monreaux123]

why is she always covering someone elses songs, can't she sing her own

[EmoraChan13]

She likes the song, is all. That's what covers are, after all... Though, I will admit she has stolen a few songs...

[Diava101Reloaded]

@monreaux123 It's not like she's copying. She sings it well. We can see now with all the success B has that she obviously can sing her own songs as well. For real no disrespect, but B is just talented and she can sing what she wants. I'm not saying B is better than Jill Scott, but it's okay to be a fan and sing one of her songs..it's not a big deal. No diss though. Just saying.

K

[monreaux123]

@Diava101Reloaded yeah you are right, she can sing what she wants..but once you do it more than once, it gets REPETITIVE, and i never said it wasn't ok for her to be a fan??

[monreaux123]

@Diava101Reloaded yeah you are right, she can sing what she wants..but once you do it more than once, it gets REPETITIVE, and i never said it wasn't ok for her to be a fan??

[diiggas]

I dont know why some jill fans act like it was blasfemy everytime someone says that he/she likes more this version and why they feel like they have to bash every cover of the song or the artist who covers it. They're both great. Jill is the best singing in her style and Beyoncé is the best singing in hers. You dont need to hate one to love the other.

[kp1fan08]

STOP!!!

[kp1fan08]

ok i have heard almost all of the videos and im trying to see what Beyonce did that was so horrid. Trust and believe i am the biggest jill scott fan u will ever meet. i not saying beyonce did it better but she is not as godawful as yaw make it sound. B did her thang however we know she will never beat jill on jill's own music come on now ppl. no one does it better than the org. so give her some credit. Atleast she tried and didnt get out here like some ppl on this site. u need to go tell them to

[Beefan3]

Oh Please..Beyonce Knowles is the greatest female vocalist of all time.

[monreaux123]

not really but she is good

[hansonmaniaco]

Amo Vc Bey

[queenray1]

oH MY SHE SHOULD BE SHOT, THIS IS PAINFUL, I FEEL GUILTY FOR WATCHIN, AND FOR ALL THE IGNORANT PEOPLE ON THIS PANEL THAT BIG UP BEYONCE FOR SINGIN THIS, JUST GOES TO SHOW HOW STUPID PEOPLE HAVE BECOME WHEN IT COMES TO KNOWING TRUE ART AND I'M NOT A HATER , WHEN BEYONCE WAS DOIN HER THING ON HER ALBUM, THAT WAS COOL, BUT SHE DEFINITELY CROSSED THE LINE HERE, JILL SCOTT SHE BUST HER FACE UP

[xxtashaaxxx]

amazinggggg ; )

i saw her ! on this date ! singing there ! i was in that rooommm omg she was amaziiiiiinggg

[kives1985]

It's a lot better than her awful Etta James covers. It's not that bad. It's not nearly as awesome as Jill Scott's version, though.

[Cseplesz]

They are not the same league with JS.

Beyonce suffers badly with the tidada in the middle...maybe she shouldn't cope with a song, that's far over her abilities IMHO.

[2hitwndr]

b did good but i feel like Jill Scott was going threw this when she wrote it making her sing from the soul. Therefore singing it waaaaay better than b.So much better that the person listening to it feels it.

[daphnechase]

the original is usually better but i like Mrs. Knowles version as well.

[sensualsusan]

Good effort Bey. I still love the original.

[Myknowledge2true]

I just have to say.... for once there is an artist that can top Beyonce... and that is JIll ScoTT!!!!... She explodes on this song... However, B didn't do to bad of a job tho...

[notthefather]

why are people hating? I'm not a Beyonce fan, but she did this song justice and Jill would be proud and honored. Stop hissing at each other like stray cats!!

[lilcocobutta]

that is true

it was pretty good

shes no jill but shes a good singer

[Whoelsedammit]

Jill will be honored! B has exposed the young artist of soul to the ones that never heard. Even if B aint a soul artist! Don't like B but I do like her efforts...when positive and selfless.

[sapphirediva1]

jillllllllllllll!!!!

[Usacho]

too weak for jill sott -  not this leauge- sorry

[beyonceandzoe]

beyonce did this song very good well done beyonce!

[beautifullhunnii]

oh please.... bee aint shit when jill sings HER OWN SONG!!

[imwutsup]

beyonce is great at every thing she does God has trully blessed her with a talent that is so undescribable she leaves me breathless live and on record she has an astonishing voice and i am so grateful she share her gift with the world

[Joelissaschar]

I was there

[mwansabob88]

perfect :D

[younghovnb1]

she is incredible...ppl just hatin

[SexiFac3]

she did the song no justice, this woman is no where near jill scott!

[aubrey1015]

Why can't she just sing the damn song? No one saied she was Jill Scott....why can't black people support one another instead of performing the crab syndrom......pulling each other down when one gets to the top.........you need to stop hating....I bet you don't compare white singers to each other

[pjchic84]

she did well, considering that Jill Scott is so phenomenal on her original version. I think she could have done a little better though. And that daggone wind machine- OH MY STARS!! Does she ever let it rest!!??

[kikirich]

yes beyonce did good but no one can ever compare to jill scott when it comes to her song especially being that she wrote it for her husband so you know it came from something deep within herself and inspired by love but nevertheless beyonce did do a good job

[shisam88]

KILLED IT!!!!!!!! LOVE THIS SONG!!

[ZaireRWT]

well beyonce kill this song no t just stop hateing and give her what she deserves okay bitches damn can anyone just fucking admit that shes good at what she do

[absolumentmadonna]

Beyonce is nicely doing on the song and I enjoy the tribute... but anyone who dares to compare her neat version to the ones Jill Scott has been able to deliver through time, is just a mindless fool ! It's like comparing a Dom Perignon Champagne to some supermarket bubbly wine...

[bebebebovo]

And yes, this is YOUR opinion.

[jarbon5]

Me, I didn't compare Beyonce's performance to Jill's, I let it stand on it's on and I found it to be very nice. I liked it a lot. But, that's just me.

[hollywoodsbesttalent]

I love beyonce she did fabulous on this song.but wat people dont understand is that beyonce did a imitation or not even that she did a karoke of Jill Scott so that means that she wasnt' going to come out and remix it!!! She was going to come out and do it big like Beyonce do! She was great!Now The Real Question that is going around on youtube is did beyonce preform it better than Jill Scott

[bootyliciousyaz]

sum1 said that this song was written by beyonce originally for destinys child and its actually dangerously in love part 2? :-s either way both versions give me goosebumps they both sing it gorgeously

[jagrady4]

what i really like is that she is above just about all the other performers today. you don't see many who dance and sing at the same time like that now.

[jagrady4]

if you think this is good, then you don't have any taste in music. she lacking the range needed for this song. she should stick to the ghetto girl music she normally does.

[YOGIBOI]

well, if u think that. jill scott is great dont get me wrong she is. but jill is 1D shes not versatile at all. its the same type of music and singing all the time, typical. beyonce has great range if u havnt noticed. she on the other hand is versatile there isnt any type of music she hasnt done. allways doing something different and still being great at it. her voice is soft and strong, she ranges form a tenor to a soprano. her voice is very colorful. need i go on?

[mrsmcmillen]

Ok now lets be real. I am a fan of both and to say that Jill Scott has no range in my opinion is so wrong. Have you heard her. Operatic, Jazz, Soul, Rap, R&B Rock need I go on! Check out Jill for real before slamming her for not being versatile. Beyonce is kool but as Jill Scott says..."I got on all my clothes and I can still sing"

[YOGIBOI]

R U SERIOUS? I HOPE SHE DOESNT TAKE HER CLOTHES OFF. lol!!!

[mrsmcmillen]

Wow aren't you just hilarious. The mere thought of a person having talent and beauty and not being small is funny. Jill Scott is a beautiful woman and to many she is sexy. So what if she doesn't parade around in gold lame underwear. She should be ashamed because she is heavy? Jill parades around in her own skin with confidence. It's sad to think that the only way a person is considered pretty or talented is if they can show skin. Shame

[monreaux123]

jill has done more than one type of music so i don't know what your talking about

[TeutoniasNummer1]

scheiße

[akashadoll1988]

she's the best

[dwayneoukid]

GO BEYONCE!!!

[brand929]

I like Beyonce, but Jill sings this much better. Do a youtube search "Jill Scott He Loves Me" to see what I mean.

[bebebebovo]

So what? Why do we have to compare? She sings it great enough and the song is a part of an incredible show with amazing vocals... I'm perfectly satisfied with her performance! :)

[YOGIBOI]

do u think jill scott could do one of beyonce's songs better. nah How bout jill sing ring the alarm, or speechless or dangerously in love or dejavu.

[brand929]

I get what you guys are saying, and I agree that Beyonce does a fine job. I guess I'm so in love with the original that I get a little defensive. Jill's version just touches my heart, and it's hard for anyone else to deliver this song in that same fashion. But yes, Beyonce IS a great singer :)

[jagrady4]

Maybe you should check out jill's live album. I'm not knocking her for trying, but don't just take someone elses song unless you are truly better at it. B is so very creative, why sing someone elses? I'm pretty sure jill can do b's songs, but it wouldn't fit her style.

[Bevaine]

Yes Bitch!!!

[GAVINLUVSBEYONCE]

oh it's a jill scott song...i hope beyonce does not get sued for this...lol...i don't even have to listen to jill scott's version...anything beyonce sings over i luv it better

[monreaux123]

in this caseNO jill's version is way better

[Photoshoplilli]

uiii... ich liebe dieses lied! hab es direkt bei itunes gekauft, jetzt wo ich weiß das es von jill scott ist :-)

[lilesra]

oh gott ich war asuch da aber ich kann mich kaum an ihren liedern erinnern da ich voll in trance war loooooooooooooooooooolllllllll­lllllllllllll

[SerdarsLadii]

ok thanks a lot

[SerdarsLadii]

ein Jill Scott song???

[bebebebovo]

Yes, I believe it's a Jill Scott's song.

[SerdarsLadii]

hey HAT JEMAND DAS LIED HE LOVES ME??? WENN YA BITTE BITTE SAGT MAL BESCHEID! ICH SUCH ES SCHON SEIT DEM KONZERT IN FRANKFURT :(

[bebebebovo]

It's not a Beyonce song.

[jonathan31140]

Talalilalallaaah! I love when she does that!

[Ashley1580]

Wunderschön, ich liebe Beyonce!

Ich war auch auf dem Konzert in Oberhausen, da hat sie ja sogar geweint.:)

Deine Kamera ist echt gut und du saßt auch voll weit vorne. Wie geil.

[whatever1985]

awesome camera.. which brand of camera u used?

[bebebebovo]

It's my aunt's camera, so all I can say is that it was sony. :)

[beyoncebaby007]

es war so geil in oberhausen :) cooles video! hab auch welche on gestellt^^

[empathboy]

ich war auch in Oberhausen es war hammer

[Photoshoplilli]

great! just great!

[judeaw]

Another perfect delivery :D