Most cops do abuse their authority, but for the sake of the show, you gotta remember that Elliot is cop with high moral standards compared to most people.
To touch on something, Elliot is wrong, cops do abuse their authority, including him. Cops in real life would abuse their authority just to nail someone. All to uphold the oath to always catch their prey. If you put a real cop in Stabler's position they damn well would abuse their authority.
I agree.this episode shocked me to no end,it had so many twists and turns,plus i was trying to figure this guy out,like predicting his next move to the point where i almost got a headache.but good show anyway.
As much as I love Law and order SVU, this was the one that blew my mind out totally and as of yet, there has not been a episode that matched this epicness...
Merritt Rook: I didn`t lose them. They were taken from me. I thought there was something wrong with my wife, Julianne. But she said we`re gonna get the baby out. She also said everything was gonna be okay. So if HE`S the doctor, who am I to challenge his authority? So I didn`t. I caved in. You know? And I sat there, and I held my wife`s hand, and I watched her bleed to death. I put my faith on a little guy in a white coat! And he killed my wife and son!! PUSH THE BUTTON!!
What I find funny is that Robin Williams's character uses the Milgram Experiment to threaten the guy, and the guy knows the experiment's name, and yet they fail to address the fact that anyone taking a Psych class knows that the true Milgram experiment was also simply a ruse.
=================
What's different is that he said "this time, it's for real"...So Elliot believed him and who could blame him?
Elliot Stabler: But you killed him, didn`t you? This isn`t about authority or obedience or sheep. You`re just trying to make me suffer like you suffered.
2:32, Stabler should have known what Merritt Rook suffered. He didn`t want to remind him, but he had to. I feel sorry for Merritt Rook, but i`m also sorry for Elliot Stabler, too. Because, he had to inflict pain on Olivia Benson because Merritt Rook told him to and he didn`t want to do that. Poor guys.
Merritt Rook: I put my faith in a little guy in a white coat! And he killed my wife and son!! PUSH THE BUTTON!! Detective Elliot Stabler: No. Detective Olivia Benson: AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!! Merritt Rook: PUSH... THE... BUTTON!!!
What I find funny is that Robin Williams's character uses the Milgram Experiment to threaten the guy, and the guy knows the experiment's name, and yet they fail to address the fact that anyone taking a Psych class knows that the true Milgram experiment was also simply a ruse.
"I sat there, and I held my wife's hand, and I watched her bleed to death. I PUT MY FAITH IN A LITTLY GUY IN A WHITE COAT, AND HE KILLED MY WIFE AND SON." No one deserves that. You just want to hug the guy. There are only a few times when a man can cry. This is one of those times.
Oh my goodness. When I first saw this episode I was shaking to death. Bravo to all the acting and writers. That was intense. It's right up there with "Undercover."
Theres a rumor that robin williams is going to be hugo strange in the next batman movie. When I heard this I automatically thought about how awesome he was in this episode (and how much he looks like the character)
Hats off to Robin Williams! Terrific acting! The villians they have on this show can sometime being dabbling in on material their acting skills can't handle, but Robin hit the nail on the head. Some of the most dramatic scenes and Robin delivered them perfectly.
i love how elliot said "It's not about authority or obidence, you just want me to suffer like you've suffered." he said that at 2:27.
Robin Williams character lost his love. Why would elliot say that if Olivia's the one hooked up to the chair, being tortured (he thinks), not Kathy, Not Dani, OLIVIA!
"There is too much pain in the world already". This is cruelly true.
This episode reads like a variation of the 1963 Milgram Experiment.
In fact, upon doing a little reearch on Wikipedia, it is.
A disproportionate number of us a capable of a lot more cruelty then we might believe. This goes to explain how a lot of nice, clean-cut Christian boys were capable of such horrors in the SS during WWII.
i agree he was testing Elliot to see if he would stand up to him now that he had the authority, when Elliot refused to torture his own partner Merritt saw that he was not one of those who would abuse power, like holding dominion over your own partner, so he released them. Elliot was everything Merritt wished he had been, but he had to make sure, it's a twisted thing, but robins character has had a terrible existence of weakness and pain.
@rebarox85 Sorry to butt in, but he's pretty much replicating the experiment they mentioned at around 1:32. It's a really interesting experiment actually. Some of the best known psych experiments just prove how terrible people can be.
This is what happened...he hid from the detectives and went away to Hollywood to become an actor for his cover up...Robin Williams is a wanted man...LMAO!!!!
I love how Robin Williams is such a dynamic actor. He's just as capable of playing a cartoon character's voice, to playing comedy roles, to playing serious roles like this one, as well as being a tremendous comedian. Certainly one of the best talents out there.
@avenueyay after he ties his shoe he had a remote attached to his leg that he used to blow up the shack and he got away...... he possibly ran in to a lake where he died........XC
Robin williams again proves how great and amazing actor he is!! He got me to tears when he was tallking about his wife's death, such a marvelous performance!
this was a very good episode. i liked the ending to this, how robin williams tries to force elliot to submit to his authority, much like the shock experiment he describes
Most cops do abuse their authority, but for the sake of the show, you gotta remember that Elliot is cop with high moral standards compared to most people.
cowill101 2 weeks ago
To touch on something, Elliot is wrong, cops do abuse their authority, including him. Cops in real life would abuse their authority just to nail someone. All to uphold the oath to always catch their prey. If you put a real cop in Stabler's position they damn well would abuse their authority.
saiyamanGXT 1 month ago
Robin Williams was amazing here!
dixon0023 1 month ago
Happy burgers incident actually happen in real life.
Zo0leemah 1 month ago
robin williams was the truth in this ep! loved every minute of it!
bnatrl88 1 month ago
I agree.this episode shocked me to no end,it had so many twists and turns,plus i was trying to figure this guy out,like predicting his next move to the point where i almost got a headache.but good show anyway.
seras117 3 months ago
This is by far the best episode of law and order i've ever seen! Robin Williams is such an amazing actor!
pianoking53 3 months ago
As much as I love Law and order SVU, this was the one that blew my mind out totally and as of yet, there has not been a episode that matched this epicness...
fallenhackable 4 months ago
Man I got a chill up my sign when he screamed "SIT DOWN". Great freakin acting, this episode was very well done.
drybomber5 4 months ago
That the best law & order show I ever watched.............I remember the day it aired on tv
hlm7511 4 months ago
what asshole tapes his tv screen? oh yeah, you do
MorshuTheShopKeeper 4 months ago
It cut off right b4 the explosion! Damn!
TheCoolestGeekEver 5 months ago
Merritt Rook: I didn`t lose them. They were taken from me. I thought there was something wrong with my wife, Julianne. But she said we`re gonna get the baby out. She also said everything was gonna be okay. So if HE`S the doctor, who am I to challenge his authority? So I didn`t. I caved in. You know? And I sat there, and I held my wife`s hand, and I watched her bleed to death. I put my faith on a little guy in a white coat! And he killed my wife and son!! PUSH THE BUTTON!!
garybic 5 months ago
Detective Elliot Stabler: No.
Detective Olivia Benson: AAAAAHHHHH!!!!!
Merritt Rook: PUSH... THE... BUTTON!!!
garybic 5 months ago
SUV: weak faggots unit
thenfm 5 months ago
True, I did want to see the end cause that was pretty dang good episode of Law and Order, maybe even the best. Robin Williams, one hell of an actor
blackoutcider 6 months ago
you let out the best part
when he blows up the place en escapes !!!!!!
sukruoosten 6 months ago
What I find funny is that Robin Williams's character uses the Milgram Experiment to threaten the guy, and the guy knows the experiment's name, and yet they fail to address the fact that anyone taking a Psych class knows that the true Milgram experiment was also simply a ruse.
=================
What's different is that he said "this time, it's for real"...So Elliot believed him and who could blame him?
ThePatriots010304 6 months ago
Elliot Stabler: But you killed him, didn`t you? This isn`t about authority or obedience or sheep. You`re just trying to make me suffer like you suffered.
Merritt Rook: You have no idea what I suffered!
garybic 6 months ago
2:32, Stabler should have known what Merritt Rook suffered. He didn`t want to remind him, but he had to. I feel sorry for Merritt Rook, but i`m also sorry for Elliot Stabler, too. Because, he had to inflict pain on Olivia Benson because Merritt Rook told him to and he didn`t want to do that. Poor guys.
garybic 6 months ago
Merritt Rook: I put my faith in a little guy in a white coat! And he killed my wife and son!! PUSH THE BUTTON!! Detective Elliot Stabler: No. Detective Olivia Benson: AAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH!!!!! Merritt Rook: PUSH... THE... BUTTON!!!
garybic 7 months ago
damn robin williams was awesome in this episode
admarshall617 7 months ago
2 people PUSHED THE DISLIKE BUTTON!
SockMonkey007 7 months ago
they should make an episode where he returns
95Godfather 10 months ago
one of the best svu episodes i have seen
MyDukeduke 11 months ago
Oh yes Robin would be great as hugo strange
PsycReaper 11 months ago
What I find funny is that Robin Williams's character uses the Milgram Experiment to threaten the guy, and the guy knows the experiment's name, and yet they fail to address the fact that anyone taking a Psych class knows that the true Milgram experiment was also simply a ruse.
tredaeci 11 months ago
when he said "push the button!!" his face looked kinda funny
Merlisa92 1 year ago
"I sat there, and I held my wife's hand, and I watched her bleed to death. I PUT MY FAITH IN A LITTLY GUY IN A WHITE COAT, AND HE KILLED MY WIFE AND SON." No one deserves that. You just want to hug the guy. There are only a few times when a man can cry. This is one of those times.
redshieldshatterer 1 year ago 2
@redshieldshatterer he said little god in a white coat actually
vegagundam2 11 months ago
Robin played the sad,tortured madman beautifully.Almost made me have empathy for his character.
artgal80 1 year ago
so what happens with the next hidden gun pills or just jail ?
JESTER588 1 year ago
Oh my goodness. When I first saw this episode I was shaking to death. Bravo to all the acting and writers. That was intense. It's right up there with "Undercover."
xlpieorox 1 year ago
Theres a rumor that robin williams is going to be hugo strange in the next batman movie. When I heard this I automatically thought about how awesome he was in this episode (and how much he looks like the character)
grkpektis 1 year ago
Hats off to Robin Williams! Terrific acting! The villians they have on this show can sometime being dabbling in on material their acting skills can't handle, but Robin hit the nail on the head. Some of the most dramatic scenes and Robin delivered them perfectly.
ProRanting 1 year ago
i love how elliot said "It's not about authority or obidence, you just want me to suffer like you've suffered." he said that at 2:27.
Robin Williams character lost his love. Why would elliot say that if Olivia's the one hooked up to the chair, being tortured (he thinks), not Kathy, Not Dani, OLIVIA!
davidXcatherine 1 year ago 2
I love this ep, the end really demonstrates Elliot's loyalty to Olivia :)
HameronBensler414 1 year ago
it's so sad when he says "I put my faith in a little god in a white coat and he killed my wife and son" D:
ahoyxitsxmichelle 1 year ago
"There is too much pain in the world already". This is cruelly true.
This episode reads like a variation of the 1963 Milgram Experiment.
In fact, upon doing a little reearch on Wikipedia, it is.
A disproportionate number of us a capable of a lot more cruelty then we might believe. This goes to explain how a lot of nice, clean-cut Christian boys were capable of such horrors in the SS during WWII.
upsilon054 1 year ago
2:05-2:15;how true,Robin,how true....
HUSKY57887 1 year ago 2
I dont really undertand this part... was or was she not hooked up to electircity?
Hisgurl942 1 year ago
@Hisgurl942 She wasn't. Her screams was recorded to make it seem as though she was.
Jenna424 1 year ago
@Jenna424 so he was just tormenting Elliot
rebarox85 1 year ago
@rebarox85 Yes. He was testing Elliot in a cruel way.
Jenna424 1 year ago
@Jenna424
It's called a Milgram experiment, simple yet amusingly effective heh heh heh
okamireader5 4 months ago
@Jenna424
i agree he was testing Elliot to see if he would stand up to him now that he had the authority, when Elliot refused to torture his own partner Merritt saw that he was not one of those who would abuse power, like holding dominion over your own partner, so he released them. Elliot was everything Merritt wished he had been, but he had to make sure, it's a twisted thing, but robins character has had a terrible existence of weakness and pain.
MAnnaconduit1 3 months ago
@rebarox85 Sorry to butt in, but he's pretty much replicating the experiment they mentioned at around 1:32. It's a really interesting experiment actually. Some of the best known psych experiments just prove how terrible people can be.
Look into the "Stanford Prison Experiment".
nintendiehard 1 year ago
This is what happened...he hid from the detectives and went away to Hollywood to become an actor for his cover up...Robin Williams is a wanted man...LMAO!!!!
Eric70065 1 year ago
Really love the episode but hate the mystery at the end. I want to know where he went damnit!
spaceguy284 1 year ago
"PUSH THE BUTTON!!!" lol great episode
DeliriumD31 1 year ago
He was so creepy here-in a good way :D, amazing how well he pulled this off
mindylinky 2 years ago 3
i dont even watch cop shows like this but wheni changed and seen robin williams I started watching and his performance is fuckin amazing
nutti3fl3xx 2 years ago 4
fucking brilliant performance by robin. one of the best episodes ever too. chilling
lilbrowstalker 2 years ago 2
what are the odds me too just watched this
rafael196912 2 years ago
I'm watching this now :D
I actually laughed at this.
David12King 2 years ago
I love how Robin Williams is such a dynamic actor. He's just as capable of playing a cartoon character's voice, to playing comedy roles, to playing serious roles like this one, as well as being a tremendous comedian. Certainly one of the best talents out there.
Marksman230591 2 years ago
aw come on!!!!!! what happens after he ties his shoe!
avenueyay 2 years ago
@avenueyay after he ties his shoe he had a remote attached to his leg that he used to blow up the shack and he got away...... he possibly ran in to a lake where he died........XC
xXSVULOVERXx 2 years ago
I want to see this whole episode
nsgress 2 years ago
Robin williams again proves how great and amazing actor he is!! He got me to tears when he was tallking about his wife's death, such a marvelous performance!
Awsome!!!!
pauchancilla 2 years ago
One of the greatest SVU episodes ever
OwnagePlayer740 2 years ago 3
This was the best episode of the show by far. Robin Williams should be considered one of Hollywood's greatest actors.
BlackHallow55 2 years ago 35
he is a great actor. this proves it.
starkiller20293 2 years ago 2
@BlackHallow55 I thought he already was lol
TheLightningmikester 1 year ago
@TheLightningmikester i was just saying if they ever made a list of great actors they should put robin towards the top of the list.
BlackHallow55 1 year ago
@BlackHallow55 He is. He even won an award for his role in this Law and Order episode.
jwbartle 10 months ago
I LOVE this episode :D
urbanslang 2 years ago 2
Aww... you didn't show the blast at the end...
clemenceau16 2 years ago
I saw this episode it was awesome
genesisoutlaw 3 years ago
best episode ever robin willaims is a great actor
crimsonblade111 3 years ago 2
can't wait for robin willaims to return for the 300th episode.
MikeMJPMUNCH 3 years ago
@MikeMJPMUNCH How do you know for sure that Robin Williams gonna return to svu on the 300th episode
garybic 6 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i liked this one he was fuckin funny
bigstan503 3 years ago
this was a very good episode. i liked the ending to this, how robin williams tries to force elliot to submit to his authority, much like the shock experiment he describes
5master11111 3 years ago 22