You Should Have Lied • Reinette/Doctor/Rose AU

[thelinkinparkfan504]

I got here from ponies. But I don't care.

[kayjedi379]

Reinette is not only a character I hate from Doctor Who. She was the historical figure that was pretty much solely responsible for the dreadful Rococo period in France. She didn't really make sense, as she was not the type of person the Doctor is usually receptive to. Very out-of-character of him.

[AsarathWitch]

@kayjedi379 Yes, I do agree that the GitF was a very OOC moment and a HUGE blip in the D/R storyline, (Never mind her factual history to boot), but at least we don't have to worry about her anymore. :)

[supahsnuffy]

@kayjedi379 I know you posted this 8 months ago but it's Moffat's writing. He didn't like rose and you could tell.

[Lillian13123]

LOVED IT so good

[anikasaotome]

That was just beautiful and sad and... perfect! Your editing is amazing. I love it!

[AsarathWitch]

@anikasaotome Awww, wow! :D What a lovely comment! ^^ Thank you so much, you just made my night. xx

[DoctorWhoLoveGirl]

Tears are running down my face. This is so well done. Faving.

[AsarathWitch]

Oh, thank you so much! :D I'm glad you enjoyed it. ^^

[DoctorWhoLoveGirl]

@AsarathWitch its the least I can do. I want to thank you for entering my contest as well. You got 3rd place. Still pretty good

[xangryyemmiix158]

brilliant! i never really like reinette, i like this video!

perfect.

[AsarathWitch]

@xangryyemmiix158:

Thank you so much for the wonderful comment! :D And sorry for the late repy!

[heroestwdw]

This is an amazing vid! I love your editing. Great storyline. I love how you gave it an angsty end. Beautiful job! I love the sped up clips with the hand holding overlay. I love the song choice. Who's the artist?

[AsarathWitch]

@heroestwdw:

Thank you very much for the brilliant comment! :D Really made me smile. ^^ The artist is in the description, after the Story. :) Thanks for the comment!!!

[VinDaLegend]

This is such a sweat video, it really sums up how rose must have been feeling. All of the clips and audio fit in perfectly with the song. Amazing video =)

[AsarathWitch]

Thank you so very much! :D Wow, that's an amazing comment! ^^ I'm glad you thought so much of it.

[sandymg]

Beautifully edited.

[AsarathWitch]

Thank you very much! :D

[analeian]

That was brilliant hun !

You have such a great imagination ! You fit the lyrics PERFECTLY . Perfect storyline, everything made sense !

5* ('missed you)

[AsarathWitch]

I missed you too! *hugs*

Thank you so much! ^^ You're so wonderfully nice! Thank you for the amazing comment! As always, your opinion means so much to me!! xoxoxox

[Doctorwhofan001]

Ahhhh! That is so brilliant! Unique! And sooooo clever! Well done, the manips were fabulous, I haven't seen any of them before. It was very creative, you showed how Rose must have been feeling perfectly! Silly Doctor..

[AsarathWitch]

Wow! Really?! :D That's such a compliment coming from you, because I'm a huge fan of your videos! ^^ I'm glad you thought so highly of my video! Thank you so much for the wonderful comment!

And yes, very silly, silly Doctor. xD

[Doctorwhofan001]

Hehe, I've always looked up to you! I love your videos, they're fabulous!

You're welcome! :)

[CrazyBoutBillie]

OMG! That was too amazing!

The storyline was brilliant and some of the editing was gorgeous! You didnt use many effects but thats what made this work! I did feel a little sorry for The Doctor but I still loved this! ;) x

[AsarathWitch]

Oh, hun, you are too sweet for words. :) Thank you so much for the amazing comment! I was really worried the video might be boring, but I'm thrilled you didn't think so! :D

And yeah, admittably, his "come with me line" broke my heart a little bit, but I had to let Rose make her decision. :) Thanks so much for the wonderful comment! *hugs*

[XMemoryProductionsX]

Wow. That Was Really Amazing. I Enjoyed That Quite A Lot. Well Done :-)

[AsarathWitch]

Thank you so very much! ^^ I'm glad you enjoyed it!

[BloodyDeath11]

wow hunnie as i said it's really really awesome

[AsarathWitch]

Thank you, sweetie! :D You really are too kind. *hugs*

[RoseOnGallifrey]

OMG I Loved it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

it's like dr who had turned into Eastenders (british t.v series)

I Loved every moment, I really loved the storyline, 1 of the best AU's in a while

lol i've also loved Rose and this time I understanded her decision

thanks for the vid!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

5 star and favourite

[AsarathWitch]

Yay! :D I had worried I made The Doctor look a bit like the victim, but I'm so glad you loved Rose! *hugs*

I'm really happy you enjoyed it so much! ^^ I started it a while back, but when you said was your b-day a while back it simply had to be finished. :) I'm so flattered you think so highly of it!!!

Thank you very much!

[RoseOnGallifrey]

Just added you too a birthday treats playlist

now when's you're birthday, i'm making you a vid!

[AsarathWitch]

Oh, thank you so much! ^^ And you really don't have to. :)

[RoseOnGallifrey]

Yes I am!!!!!!!!

when your b'day!

[AnonymousCatt]

WOW! No outline of the story needed, the video speaks for itself. That was absolutely beautiful and heartbreaking... thanks for sharing this!

[AsarathWitch]

Thanks! :D That's a great compliment. I'm glad you enjoyed it and I'm very happy you thought it so emotional too. ^^

[Nyah86Production]

Wow. I adored the editing, the storyline...well simply everything.

5 stars and I put it into my Doctor Who Awesomeness Playlist!

[AsarathWitch]

Thank you so much!! :D You really are too wonderful! *hugs* I'm glad you enjoyed it so much! ^^

[geekchick1013]

Which episode did the "Come with me" line come from? I've been trying to figure that out for ages...

LOVELY work, BTW :D

[AsarathWitch]

Thanks very much. :) It's from "The Runaway Bride", the very end when The Doctor asks Donna to go with him. Hope this helps! ^^

[geekchick1013]

Ooooh! Thank you so much!

[gigo518]

In a weird, messed up way, this video makes me feel a lot better about what went down in "The Girl in the Fireplace"....

Anyway; brilliant video! Amazing job with the voice overs, and much love for 9 during the flashbacks. I also love how you included lots of Jackie and Mickey.

[AsarathWitch]

Yes, showing Rose have some response to it made me feel better. xD In my opinion, Rose's reaction, (or lack of one), was completely OOC on Moffatt's part.

Thank you very much though! :D And how could I not add 9? ^^ I love 9. Thanks very much, I really wanted to incoperate a third party to the video, I'm glad it worked well.

Thanks for the fabulous comment!

[8redDevil8]

this was so beautiful and sad at the same time. I loved the storyline and the voiceovers made it perfect. =)

faved and 5*

[AsarathWitch]

Thank you so very much! :D I'm glad you enjoyed it so much and thanks for the comment on the audio, it took ages to find the right pieces. xD Thank you for the wonderful comment! ^^

[misscynthia17]

second part of the comment ^^

I think he acts quite harsh towards her, she loves him but not everything is forgiveable...

Of Course I am still a Doctor-Rose shipper, but this time I totally understand Rose's choice... Poor her, I kill her and you break her heart, hugs Rose !

[AsarathWitch]

Oh wow, cherie! :D

As always, your comments mean so very, very much. I can't believe how highly you think of this video! :D I was petrified it was too boring, but I'm thrilled, absolutely thrilled you like it so much!

*hugs*

Yes, I was trying to show how desperate The Doctor was to try and get her back, and it often ended with him shouting at her. :( Poor Rose indeed. lol

Thanks so much for the utterly amazing comment! xoxoxoxoxox

[misscynthia17]

Wow Adele, now it's you who make me cry with your video ! that was HEARTBREAKING !!!!!!! and OMG what a brillant storyline !!!!

I totally loved every seconds of it ! seriously it's amazing, and that fast paced sequence was brillant ! great choice for the song ! Poor Rose, for once I don't say poor Doctor, he wants everything with Rose but desn't make any effort to get her back (sorry for me calling all the time is not what he should have done)

[TheBrokenCircuit]

I love your manipulations :D gr8 video 5/5 favs

[AsarathWitch]

Thank you very much! :D It took a lot of time and I'm really happy you enjoyed it so much! Thanks for the amazing compliment.

[TheBrokenCircuit]

your welcome :D