Supernatural Very Sad Dean,Sam And Cas Scene Episode (5x16) Dark Side Of The Moon

[theatermajor101]

Awww..... That was the necklace Sam gave to Dean for Christmas.  :(

[CommentWriter95]

how i wanted the episode to end: dude we just motherf*cking died and came back! man it was great to see ash and pam and mom again! lets hunt down those sons of bitches walt and roy now like we promised! HURRAH

how the episode ended: god literally doesnt give a damn about us. sam doesnt love dean as much as he should and now dean doesnt love him. THE WORLD IS GOING TO END

this made me so depressed -_-

[chriscjclancy]

anyone know the music thats paying in the background in this?

thanx

[Corina1988]

Dang, thanks for clarifying @marissolguerra. I've been trying to figure that ova everytime I see a re-run why Dean threw away the necklace. But yea I KNOW Sammy picked it up lol.

[562jOnAsLoVeR]

The samulet :(

[MsVampirefiction]

I'm still thinking that Sam only had those Memories because the angels made him :P

[TheArbiter707]

after seeing this episode i still hope that eventually god will reveal himself in the series. there must still be a part of him that cares

[TheSouthernGenevieve]

Sam .. I WILL give you a hug , just call me . xDD

This show is just the best one that's ever been on air . <33 Whenever it ends .. my world will fall apart , part of my heart will literally just die .

[gab2912]

love the look on deans face at 1:35

[argetlamgirl711]

Can we all just take a moment to appreciate the flawlessness that is Misha's performance here? Castiel's entire world has just come crashing down around his ears, the Father he loved and trusted and believed in despite everything has just pretty much abandoned him, and Misha just portrays all of that beautifully.

[deviMCC]

Hahahahaa Sam: GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAS­SSSSSSSSPPPPPPPPP

Awhh Cas! I wuv you!<3 do you need a hug?

[gab2912]

i love the fact that there's no music at the background when he throws the necklace. Makes it more dramatic!

[dragonbliz]

Well i hope someone knows the song :] sounds nice and i really want to have it ;D ! that would be nice :]

[creedfan1985]

What's the name of the song playing on the background?

[lilsister2]

For the sake of my sanity, I must believe Sam picked up that necklace..

[Meashayshay2]

@lilsister2 Same here.. ;__;

[ashli674]

@lilsister2 God, I hope so. That is so sad. I just wish that Sam had said "hey!" when he did that.

[Live4TV22]

them whole waking up makes me LAUGH...the rest makes me CRY!

[chrisanthie23]

The necklace is not coming back??? :(

Please someone aswer meee!

[chrisanthie23]

The necklace is not coming back??? :(

[lovelydiva06]

@chrisanthie23 at a supernatural panel kripke jokingly said the necklace is gone and ain't coming back but kripke is no longer on the show so perhaps gamble will bring it back some how, idk but i think there's hope, after all, she's bringing _ _ back, fill in the blank cause i don't wanna spoil it for anyone, the one person with a two letter name, i'm still scratching my head on how she's gonna make that happen

[chrisanthie23]

@lovelydiva06 i hope so... I want it to be back... :)

[argetlamgirl711]

Misha and DEM EYES at full hurt-puppy look capacity, then Dean throwing away the necklace....

WHAT IS THIS DOING TO ME my heart = broken.

seriously, somebody better fucking find that necklace and bring it back pronto.

[trixie105]

When does the necklace come back?

[OutsidersFreak101]

If this show ends and their is no conclusion with that necklace coming back, I'm gonna be sooooo pissed!!! It belongs around Dean's neck. It like symbolizes their bond!!

[Pheonixcub]

dissapointed Dean, pissed off Castiel and sad sammie :(( *cries*

[lagolindari]

Sam's heaven was... weird though. Come on, surely Jessica would be there?And Dean too. I doubt that heaven was very authentic...

[lovelydiva06]

kripke i hope you made it so sam picked that necklace up outta that trash can cause i wanna see sam give that necklace back to dean before the show ends, he was pissed then but i know he'd be happy to have it back cause it meant alot to him, it was priceless, i was so pissed when he threw away that necklace, it was like he was throwing away apart of himself and sammy

[MonsterleinEmily1234]

I have the amulet! ((:

and I'm wearing it!

@CanKaNRey, your right, watching Sams memories hurts Dean, but Sam loves Dean, even if heaven is everything else than his family.

[CanKaNoRey]

I thought it was sad Dean threw the amulet in the trash, but really what reason did he have to keep it at that point? As for the people claiming he didn't see Sam's perspective: this episode showed neither did Sam ever consider Dean's . Hell, all his memories were about getting away from his life, from his dad. He didn't even seem to think of Dean. It's indifference that hurts way more than hate. All Sam saw was how wrong John did, but never how hard Dean tried to provide sth resembling family.

[Da1337Man]

wtf is wrong with dean, that amulet ment everything to him next to things like the impala >.<

[FrancaisRose]

This scene breaks my heart. After seeing Sam's version of Heaven, Dean is distraught and following Cas's comment about his amulet being worthless, he trashes it. I really wanted Sam to reach in and grab it and keep it for Dean. But I don't think he did. And according to Kripke we won't be seeing the amulet again, but it was supposed to make a guest appearance on One Tree Hill ;)

[LizzardArmstrong]

Oh God Sam's hair when he wakes up. UNF UNF UNF

[Perfectsymmetry18]

I miss this cas!!

[000000poizen000000]

Does anyone know the name of the song playing in the background? I love the guitar. Such a moving scene.

[Amarouq]

Wth, Dean? I love him for being awesome most of the time, but it's times like this when I really want to punch some sense into him... :(

[euginam91]

only in supernatural is the concept of dead people waking up somehow not creepy

[almostfamousgurl16]

I think they were trying to show that Dean is like his father and when he gets mad he overreacts like at the end of the fourth season when he told Sam that if he walked out to not bother coming back

[Reflectinglight18]

I'm sure the amulet is going to come back. I bet it will come back on like, the series finale or something. Who knows? Maybe Dean will finally meet God and he'll be the one to give it back to him.

[Vaidria]

@Reflectinglight18 I want to see it come back as well and I think that would be a great way to end the show. But there are no plans to bring the amulet back. Kripke himself said it won't be...maybe if we storm the studio they'll get the message and bring it back rotfl.

[emilyannangelpie]

Awww Castiel

[Tiffyangel77]

LMFAO at Sam's face from being alive again

[Amarynthine]

@Tiffyangel77 I know I laughed so hard at that moment

[williammoseleyfan101]

I said to the screen right when Dean was about to throw the pendant away

"Dean? What are you.. Wait, WHAT? Stop! Damn it!"

I got so pissed off at Dean... to make Sam watch him throw something away that his little brother got for him when they were children? That broke my heart in so many way's

[mdeschayn]

I'm not saying it's Sam's responsibility, and yeah, I know that Dean has been overbearing and overprotective of Sam. However, tt's not a one-way deal. Yeah, Dean is more family oriented, but both brothers have repeatedly said and shown that they would do anything for each other. The flashbacks in Swan Song showed them being incredibly close since childhood. So Dean realize that Sam's BEST memories excluded him would hurt. That's all i'm saying.

[LordAniline]

@marissolguerra. No Dean was NOT justified, and he didn't have the right to crap all over Sam's heaven by bringing up his own hurt and didn't try to see it from Sam's point of view. Sometimes Dean, it's not all about you.

The last scene has to be one of the the lowest point in all of SPN series. Can't believe Dean threw the amulet away in front of Sam. I'm a fairly hard hearted person myself but that actually caused pang in my heart. Damn you SPN writers!

[mdeschayn]

@LordAniline Can you blame Dean though? Sam is the most important person in Dean's life...seeing Sam's *happiest* memories involve him would hurt like hell. I'm not saying he should've thrown away the necklace, but it's not hard to understand what Dean was feeling.

[LordAniline]

@mdeschayn It is not Sam's responsibility to be Dean's world, no person has the capacity to be everything for another person. It's like those nightmare parents who can't let their adult children go. Dean repeatedly fails to realize that Sam is an individual, not an extension of himself. Dean's demand on Sam's familial love and loyalty as an all-or-nothing deal is unrealistic and cruel, symbolized by him throwing alway the amulet.

[Luster21]

@LordAniline he didn't throw the amulet away because of Sam, because like Sam told him, he didn't have the same family life that dean had. He threw it away because he's given up. this whole season we've seen him lose hope bit by bit and him throwing away the amulet is just him finally saying that he's done.

[LordAniline]

@Luster21 Sure Dean gave up and as usual took it out on Sam (remember their father's death?) Dean was being passive/aggressive when he dropped the amulet, knowing Sam was watching , and was really trying to hurt Sam. The amulet was given to Dean as proof that Sam trusted Dean more than he trusted John at a time where the only people he had been taught to trust were John and Dean. I have a feeling the amulet won't return until Dean trusts and accept Sam as Sam, not as Dean's ideal.

[Luster21]

@LordAniline dean didn't take their father's death out on sam, he was just in a lot of grief because he knew that his dad gave up his life for him. sam and dean are equally dependent on each other its just that dean shows it more because he's the older brother and its always been his job to protect the family. remember when dean died what a mess sam was, he even tried to open the devils gate to get dean back. the only reason he trusted ruby is because she said something that dean would have said

[rutharaya16]

This was soo hard to watch.. Seeing Castiel like tht just made my heart break!! And Dean throwing out his necklace was even more heartbreaking ...

[Selana]

I feel like when Dean threw out the necklace, he was saying "there is no you and me"

[jjs1300000]

you son of a bitch i belived in you

[Bielak999]

If God is like this then fuck him hard

[billphann]

What Sam didnt at least picked it up on the way out and put it in his pocket?

[HiredSoldier]

Anybody know where to find the music? Has Eric Kripke released a cd with this music on it?

[Malsavaidity]

poor sam, that was mean! wehh

[MrsAckles09]

Sorry but.. putting all the angst to one side, am I the only one who pissed themselves at Sam's gasp when he came back to life? :')

[Engel1207]

@MrsAckles09 No you're defenitly not :D and just look at his hair :D I really feel bad for laughing about the really sad moment but Sam's hair in the beginning is hilarious xD

[MrsAckles09]

@Engel1207 Oh God I know. I can't stop laughing. :')

[lolle1996]

Now I'm crying

[TabeaIsabella]

Sam tut mir soo leid!!!

[MsSlashgirl]

Oh I was so pissed.

It's bad enough they're still divided but this to me was pretty much the last straw. I'm hoping Sam has it or he put it somwhere because it was just wrong on so many levels for Dean to have the necklace {and therefore Sam} out with the trash.

[catwomanFL72]

you know uriel is dead. zacharia is dead. rapheal is dead. i think its time for cas to die too. that would be an awesome episode...you could have the other angels meet up with him,' what took you so long assbutt? we've been waiting for you.' haha!

[azu0nyan]

@catwomanFL72 Raphael isnt dead ! Go to the CE supernatural page theres a picture of the 6 season where raphael will kill cas T_T

[catwomanFL72]

@azu0nyan oops my bad. i realized that yesterday when i caught the midnight marathon of supernatural on TNT. that was pretty cool.it was gabriel that was killed. i miss gabriel. i kinda miss uriel. anyway you say rapheal kills cas this season? oooh i find that very orgasmic! good riddance!

[azu0nyan]

@catwomanFL72 Nooo ! i didnt said he kill him definetly , hes just tryin . Yea i want gabriel back too. :) And the old cute sammy

[catwomanFL72]

@azu0nyan did raphael bring sam back from hell?

[JBxFan11]

@catwomanFL72 no, Crowley did :D

[azu0nyan]

yea , was that the episode in that cas beat dean ? I thought come on dean he rebelled for you you have to give a thnaks to him not to throw that shit away !!

[catwomanFL72]

@azu0nyan i really hate that episode where cas beat dean. that was totally fake because dean could have beat the snot out of cas! with all the stupid crap hes had to deal with dean should've kicked cas' ass! now that would be off the charts! off the charts? haha!

[samsgift]

He better have picked it up!

[cmcg712]

I agree Sarafina126, I have to believe that Sam picked up the necklace. Something that bugged me about their time in heaven - with all the bull that they had been going through do you ever wonder the reasons the memories that they experienced in heaven were done by the angels to break Dean? It's almost as if the first scene was supposed to encourage him of the bond that he and Sam had but then the next scenes were specifically meant to break that bond for both of them?

[stinkyeggs]

Oh poor boys. I feel really bad for Sam here and in the end of this season in general because Dean is giving up on saving the world, on Sam, on everything.

At the same time I cant be too pissed at Dean though. He's not purposefully being mean, he just cant take it anymore. Since s.2 he's been "tired" and that was way before hell and everything but he's still been the one holding everyone up, just like he's always held his family up, even though he's falling apart; he's at his breaking point.

[Chanelleml]

omg NO!!!! I didnt know this would be the neckles episode when I clicked ! DAMN IT GIRL you made me cry! ha gosh.

[MrsAckles09]

To be honest, the only reason he did it was cause he wasn't part of Sam's Heaven at all.

[kylexylover122]

i was like no dean plz dont! but i think sam took it out of the trash.

[Chanelleml]

@kylexylover122 sure he did! little sentimental sammy!!! I GOT TO BELIEVE THIS!!!! UH! okay this thing means way more to me then it should. ... oups i dont care SPN POWER

[kylexylover122]

@Chanelleml lmao! ikr! i was like noooooo dean i know ur upset but nooooo! lol! and dnt wry im just like u wen it comes to stuff like tht and supernatural!

[Chanelleml]

@kylexylover122 ahahah. you gotta luv every damn supernatural fans ! We are great hahaah!

[kylexylover122]

@Chanelleml yea we are lol!

so are you a dean fan or a sam fan.

im a dean<3 but i still love sam<3 just not as much lol

[Chanelleml]

@kylexylover122 hum, I do i explain this... I dont understand how Sam can be someone's favorite ahahah. So yeah Dean girl here. Cas girl to. then comes Sam.

Though I saw some spoilers and I think I'm gonna love sam in season 6. Dean will still be num 1 though hahaha

[kylexylover122]

@Chanelleml wait what spoilers have u seen and why will u love sam? sory i feel so behind now lol!

[Chanelleml]

@kylexylover122 he is gonna be more like dean was in season 1. and he is not the same sam anymore. Dont wanna ruin it by my lame explanation lol. but like when dean ask why sam didnt tell him he got out of hell and that he was drinking and trying to get him out sam only says well im sorry but i told you to let it go.. you didnt listen. you know still in a sam way. gosh. wait i can try to find the article. its not big spoilers anyway

[kylexylover122]

@Chanelleml lol ok if u can find it send me the link in a message. and its sad i loveeeeeed how dean was before hell. but now (i still loveeee him) hes more careful and less fearless :(. and i want more of sam from season 1. i want them both the way they each were in season 1.

[thenameless615]

What is the music in the video?

[punkstoper]

Why don't they Fudgeing swear anymore pagan gods? lol thumbs up.

[gemrock07]

Throughout this season i keep getting the strong urge to either slap or hug Dean. Sometimes i feel sorry for him other times he's just being a dick. : /

[Yellowbulma]

I know Dean's upset but there was no need to do that.....but it's ok Sam pick it up ;)

[987ashley654]

All you people who wonder whether or not Sam picked up the necklace, come on of course he did. You just watch, towards the end or maybe even the end scene Sam will give it back to him. It's symbolism, so they will end up bringing back the necklace, maybe not soon but when things get better they will bring it back.

[xcassxx]

I wanna know if Sam grabbed it \o

[AlwaysRainsOnTheHero]

Loved this episode. Kripe has yet to fail us! Amazing. I love it when Dean stands up and turns around going about as normal nd has blood and holes all over the back of his shirt! lol x <3

[Pnut123e4]

Anyone know what is that music track ? Sounds awesome.

[rocklove021]

@Pnut123e4 I think it's  Jesse Turnbow/Black Toast Music - "What a Way to Go"

[rocklove021]

@Pnut123e4  sorry man.. it wasnt that song,im still lookin it 2

[SaSiTaH]

Oh Cas :(

[oywidapoodles]

Fucking music. :/

[Alegreta122]

Cas gave the amulet back to Dean because GOD doen't want to be found so the amulet was worthless to Cas' task.

Dean being unable to offer any consolation to Cas because he is broken too.

In Heaven, Dean saw that his worst nightmares are Sam best memories.

Sam confirmed it "Family doesn't mean to me what it does to you", but Sam love's you Dean.

[sxcsaint]

only 5 more episodes....BUT there is gonna be a season 6 now apparently...i'm not sure having another season would be the best idea...but it could be good ?

[TsingaDark]

That was sooo sad. :(

[Ashamtly]

We have to see things from Dean`s side too.

I´m the oldest too and my brothers, my family are the most precious thing for me, I don´t know what I`d do without them and it hurts like hell to find out that you may not mean the same for them, to be as important... anyway you get tired after so many years and you just decide to give up, so it doesn´t hurt that bad.

Anyway... I think Sam picked up the necklass and since is a Tv show, I´m sure that Sam and Dean are gonna be ok .

[sxcsaint]

dean must be PPIISSEDDD at sam!

just because of the things he learnt about him in heaven doesnt mean he should just disown him like that...=(

[blissfullycat02]

I was so unexplainably pissed at Dean at the end, I mean no matter how 'useless' it was in Cas' task, it should mean somethig for him. Sam got tat for their father, but when he dissapointed them, again, he gave it to Dean because e was the one person he could always count on, and you don't throw something like that away. That's like throwing away the last of Sam's innocence, mean he has been pretty mean and shunning toward Sam lately, its almost like he is telling Sam to f*ck off in some way.

[Haley452]

@blissfullycat02 yeah, the necklace itself surely means a lot to Dean, he has been wearing it all the time since Sam gave it to him, but come on, his friend was crushed and everybody lost their hope partially because of this thing. Wearing it would only remind him of how hopeless their situation was and of all the pain they all experienced. I totally understand Dean here. I mean, I'm sure he'll go back to wearing it eventually, but hey, wouldn't you throw it away seing Cas suffering that much?

[Chanelleml]

@blissfullycat02 well yeah I saw it as like he gave up hopes for Sam too. I mean he doesnt believe in him, he did try to be mickeal vessels. gosh i only want 2 things for season 6. Castiel and this damn neckles and how the f do you write that word? necklace... sorry lol

[NiQuEdsl99]

@blissfullycat02 i know what you mean. this is in the season where Dean starts to give up and want to toss in the towel and say yes to michael. but what he doesnt realize is that sam is relying on Dean. sam even says this in the episode 99 problems. "you can't do this to me" they are both resisting together and if Dean gives up what is sam suppose to do? he cant say yes to lucifer. i mean if Dean throws in the towel hes just giving into heaven but sam doesnt have an easy way out.

[NiQuEdsl99]

@blissfullycat02 i don't think Dean realizes what he is putting sam through. i love Dean but i don't think he is thinking about sam right now at this point. i mean i know where he is coming from but he is considering what sam is going through. he's going through worse shit than Dean. Dean is resisting Heaven. sure the angels are ass holes. but they are the lesser of two evils. sam is resisting Lucifer and his darkness. way worse. sorry if i'm rambling. and yes i agree i was mad too.

[marissolguerra]

@blissfullycat02 Dean was justified, though. Sam didn't have a single memory of him on Heaven, while the first happy memory Dean had was simply of MAKING SAM HAPPY. That hurts, you know. It's like realizing the person you do everything for may not really give a damn (like Cas and God, hence the parallel). When Cas says the necklace is worthless, Dean takes it on his own way. Sam broke his heart, even if it wasn't his intention. It was obviously painful for the both of them.

[lilsister2]

@marissolguerra It's insane how Dean can say nothing at all, and speak more than words could ever say.

[lovelydiva06]

@blissfullycat02 idk, i think it kinda broke dean's heart that any of the moments in sam's life that meant the most to him and made him the happiest, didn't involve him, i mean he loves his little brother and has been protecting him and looking out for him most of his life, i think he thought, he would've been in at least one of sam's memories that made him happiest

[makeupismypassion31]

@lovelydiva06 To be fair, we didn't get to see all of Sam's Heaven moments. Dean could have very well been in there, but it was never showed. However it could be possible that Sam's happiest moments are with Dean right now as opposed to when they were growing up. I wish they would have at least showed a good memory like the Christmas memory they had when drinking egg nog. That would have been nice to see. :-D

[lexi219]

@blissfullycat02 I think that's really unfair. I think Dean was so unbelievably heartbroken that he couldn't see where Sam was coming from. For Dean, the one relationship that means more to him than anything is his relationship with Sam. And then for him to realize that not only did Sam's favorite memories not involve him, but also showed him being happy with other families and getting away from his. I'm not saying that Sam was wrong, but you really have to think about how heartbroken Dean was.

[LordAniline]

@lexi219 Dean has a habit of throwing hissy fit every time Sam's life wasn't what Dean wanted it to be. It's almost a normal reaction since Dean is more of a father to Sam than a brother. Still, Dean rarely empathize with Sam or see things from his perspectives, if he did he would have understood why Sam wanted one normal Thanksgiving meal or why he ran away from a revenge-filled drunken father and a life of monsters to find solace in a dog or daring to want to go to college.

[Sarafina126]

Sooo sad!! :( :(

I am convinced Sam picked up the necklace out of the trash. He must have!!

[heartflower111]

@Sarafina126 I'm convinced he picked it up as well.