Miley Cyrus sings on American Idol!!!

[JustinBieberLove6731]

she looks pretty

[jweames1]

poop poop poop poop poop o and poop

[beachbabebee]

we record american idol coz we cant make the time that its on and we fast forwarded her singing...

[skullbreaker105]

u have gotta admit..she does have nice vocals...i'm not a fan of hers but gotta gave her credits....no one is perfect....=)

[magy21120007003636]

it looks like she's having a seizure O.o but I like her hair

[dieOllevonNebenan]

cool song :D

[laderalovesyou]

looks like her arm was broken. lmfaoo

aint no thang but a chicken wang.

[alexp9ify]

hate miley

[dancekitten22]

you people are crazy she can't sing !!!!!!! can't you here i love her songs but not her voice iiiiihhhhh

[ashlynnm13]

i like miley but i think she's stuck up some times and if i were her id donnate $ 2 animals and people that need help cuz her dad , brouther , sister('s) have money from bands , tv, singing!!!

[Soccerchiky890]

I think miley is the only singer that sounds good in the studio and on stage, i don't like her but i have to give her credit for that.

[StapStam]

@Soccerchiky890 I don't think she is the "only" one Hayley Williams from Paramore is amazing live

[Revolution982]

@StapStam i agree hayley williams is amazing live. in my opinion, miley compared to hayley is a peace of crap live... just saying.

[StapStam]

@Revolution982 hahahaa, yeah, I think so too

[beachbabebee]

@Soccerchiky890 you obviously have NEVER seen anyone live or been to a concert coz people sing to perform so if they cant perform live they dont normally, i mean yh sure some ppl do and they suck at it but lots of ppl fucking rock at it!! Like ppl said before hayley williams is amazing live ive seen her once and im going again and another good person is lady gaga christina aguilera beyonce and it goes on!

[mileyrockz100]

I love her and all disney singers and country singers. People say she sings bad cuz' their jeouls.

[Arockstargirl101]

whats the song?

[alyanncam]

shes like friggin throwing the mike stand all around the stage lmao

[ChaseeTaylor]

I love miley cyrus so much its unbelievable

[apocalypseponi13]

she always sounds that bad.

ugh,

hate her.

[HollyAugoodx]

was she famous here????

[princess98amidala]

LA DUHH!!!!!!

[MrYEAY55]

fjortis

[gustavalmius]

emo

[MrYEAY55]

i just listen to REAL music thats all

[mssongburd]

wow u can really tell she's sick!

[mingle324]

wow she still sounds great even with a cold!!

[MrYEAY55]

wow i thought she always sounds that bad

[songsearcherx123x]

why does she get all the fame its her dad hwo writes all the songs and he's a singer too.

she should tie a chain around her body jump off a cliff into molten lava but shes still alive and thenn every one in the world atttacks her with bats and mallets i even want to say more but i cant cause little kids watch this give me a thumbs up if you agree.

[mingle324]

her dad doesn't write all her songs

[IQthacreator]

sup up i bet you cant sing your self because if she did need some she wolud not be making any money hater!!!!!

[funkayylove]

she sucks.

she needs singing lessons.

i've heard sooo much better.

[BAYsiclyTheBest]

ok that was totally spazish in everyway!!!

[dan660800]

she needs some singing lessons... i hope she knows she cant sing!!!

[Jonas1444girl]

awsum vid......especially for it bein ur furst

[hiyamsul]

miley u suck

i almost puked

what a horrible voice!!!!!!!!

[DucksAreHot]

she moves around on stage a little too much i think :|

[Gosselins4ever8]

awesome!

[annjhe29]

she have a sick.. but nothings change

[peacelbohm]

She sound sick )-:

[MileyDerChilligeKeks]

she was ill at this day ;(

[xPandaxBearx]

imagine if she were on american idol and hannah montana didnt exist. i wanna what comment simon would make :D

[pwettyangel123]

i love this video so much its great

[cleverheart123]

come one guys, i love hannah montana, i'm a fan of her, but here.. she's bad :(

her voice is shaking and she's not singing good at all!

[morganrk94]

She is amazing, and it would be "she's not singing WELL" not "good"

[cleverheart123]

well, you've got a point, i'm a fan of her since i saw her, but to be honest, she doesn't sing live "well" sometimes, she can, like best of both world tours, but here she's not good at all

[morganrk94]

She apparently had a cold here, that may be the reason you don't feel she sang well. Personally she will always be amazing in my mind. Go Miley!

[meiranisa]

cause in best of both worlds,

she was lip snyching.

[riaFR]

she's really taking the stage yo!!

[SDwomanNTIT]

where did she crab her but ??

[NewWowHobbs]

now theres some good moves ^^

[starhorse56]

wow she did grab her but

[mlsad]

Miley sure has a bad voice but thats what makes her singing bad. but she trys her best then any other person and sings good just not gr8. she works really hard and miley has a fine voice.

[PerfectMiley14]

her voice keeps shaking

[9cgx]

u are awsome i love u :]

[KirstenRaeW]

did she grab her butt at 3:47?!?

[GumDr0pz94]

yah she did WOW SHEZ GOT PROBLEMZ! big time

[jonasbrosxx]

Nice Performance! And who cares if she does lip sync its still her voice!!!! I wanna See u dance and Sing perfect at the same time!

[wldeaglesyes]

she isn't lipsyncing lol

[nnaattlliiee]

ughh idk shes alright but i like demi way better!!!!!!!!!!miley is like ugghh

[MileyHannahObssesed]

demi sucks, at least miley doesn't scream like an idiot

[myjonasbrothers101]

she alway has the same mic stand

[jjain221]

ok so i dont really like miley that much and you can tell she has a cold but i really admire her for singing even when she is ill and these two songs i do like

[myjonasbrothers101]

yeah me 2

i love her shirt

[musicroxx10]

She sings HORRIBLE!!!No offense.. and if your going to spam cause i have my own opion thats just stupid!

[xchazzaamazedx]

And yeah - at least you can tell she isn't lip syncing like a lot of celebs do =]

[adamlevinex3er]

What obvious celebs that lip sync are there? Lol, I don't know any.. I don't pay attention

[xchazzaamazedx]

Britney Spears to start with. She mimed on there.

And a lot of celebrities mime =] lol

[adamlevinex3er]

Now that I think of it, It is kinda obvious.

Like who else?

[xchazzaamazedx]

A lot of celebs. It depends on who they are - some don't .. others do lol.

[adamlevinex3er]

Oh. Lol. Does Hannah Montana?

[xchazzaamazedx]

If Miley doesn't, then Hannah Montana won't lol - being the same person =D Lol?

[adamlevinex3er]

Well, Its like. Hannah Montana moves around a lott and a lot of people say she does so Idk. Just thought I'd ask lol

[xchazzaamazedx]

I dunno to be honest. Lol. You can pretty much tell when someone's lipsyncing.

Like on here, you can tell Miley isn't.

On the X Factor show, you can tell that Britney Spears WAS lipsyncing lol.

[xchazzaamazedx]

If she can get on that stage and still give it her all when she's ill - that just proves that she's awesome =D

[mileyxcyrusxrocks1]

yea u can tell she had a cold but shes still amazing

[popper9876]

2 words love it

[123sparkle321]

miley rocks

[lbujenni18]

Aww she's sick... wow NOT lip-syncing..

[flys11rcool]

omg guys she had a cold or strep throat i cnt remember wen she did this so id like 2 c u get up there wen ur sick . gosh stop h8ion coz shes better than ul ever be.

[shaddy30]

miley had a cold but i still love her

[krivera88]

She rocks big time

[phillychick090]

noe she iss not horrble she roks u get up there and move around u run out of breath and she sounds as good as b 4 so dont talk if u dont speak the truth cuz u just jealous miley u rokin keep on rokin i no u here this slot im your biggest fan but i want to be more then a fan i want to be a friend hope it happens 1 day we all love u inside but some r to jealous

[iloveverything6]

she sounds kind of wierd!!!!

well its still pretty good!!!!

[pickles0477]

Love this video.

[IdolPJAFreak4Life]

shw was way better on good and broken u got to admit!

~~CaRlY~~

[TaylorChloe821]

wow she cant sing!

[quinnettesupersite]

I agree!!

[oopsitsjonas]

she's amazing at singing (:

way better than Demi lavato.

miley would beeat her by 100%

miley's amazing!

[MileyHannahObssesed]

I AGREE!! :D

[SychoProductions]

She sounds fine, no one is going to be perfect live & its better then lipsynching and shes moving alot so shes going to be out of breath but she sounds fine. she is a really good singer when shes not moving and just sitting and singing. great video. i love miley !!

[xxchan15xx]

yeh i think the same!!people need 2 understand no1 can sing perfect when they are moving around the place!!

GO MILEY!!!

[quinnettesupersite]

I noe! She sounds better on the records!

[stephie4112]

she is horiible here

[quinnettesupersite]

Thank you !

[crzee4mileycyrus]

love it!!!!!!!!!