Watching this was a Privalidge. You are all very specail Musicians to be able to pull this song off. Because it is a Showcase of almost everything you need in Music to survive. Do I think 10% of the so called Musicians that are making beats & bass are capable of any of this? No! Because both you & I know why "Exactly" this song is hard to pull off.
All of Pull it off so well though, almost as though it were your own song. It's a shame you didn't go for the Ending. Your Drummer is Amazing btw!
Solid guys ! this is the version with BB...not perfect but I love this pice so much I will do better each time anyway. I was lucky in 1976 to be at the FORUM of Montréal.
@danielhoude Donc, voyons si je me rappel quelque chose en francais .. :-) Cher Daniel, avant tout mercie beaucoup. Je suis absolument sure que la premiere partie de l' instrumentale etait joueè seulment par phil, au moin jusqu' a' quand les autres instruments s'arretent et il reste seulment la batterie..dans ce moment la' bill commence a jouer avec Phil..Je crois que c' est la plus incroyable performance de phil ,qui manifestement voulait montrer a tous qu'il n'etait pas inferieur a Bill
ton français est excellent. quand l'instrumentale débute, y a un roulement de caisse claire comme un appel disons de la part de BB...oui ! jusqu'à la fin BB joue. Écoute, je te jure sur la tête de mon fils. Tu peut entendre d'ailleurs le son particulier de la caisse claire en brass tuné un ton presque + haut que PCollins. Sur et certain que Phil a offert toute une performance lui aussi. D'ailleurs, j'ai en tête de jouer la piece "Nuclear burn" qu'il a composé avec Brand X. ciao! mon ami
@dhoudedrums desolee' pour mon retard..mmm je crois que bill joue de les percussions et puis il commence a jouer de la batterie tu peut voir aussi leur video de cinema show du meme tour avec bill !! de tout facon je sui sure e tu est sure aussi ehhhh ca fait rien mon ami :-) !! mmm nuclear burn c' est assez difficile mais on peut faire ;-)..ciaooo
Oh my god, these guys are awesome!! The drummer is fantastic and the keyboardplayer is amazing! I know the Cinema Show is a very difficult song on the keyboard, very fast and very well played! I have never seen such a significant remake of this song, this is coming dangerously close to Genesis itself! Please keep the Genesis-scene alive!! :)
@gardenwall07 Yeah no problem, guys! I´m sorry, but I don't speak italian.. I wish they would still do this in The Netherlands.. In my opinion, Genesis is the single best band ever existed :) The way in which they can run up to a climax in a musical gem ;) One of the single best is the epic 'Supper's Ready'.. Could you maybe give me a hint on how to learn the fast parts of the keyboard? I'm really having a hard time, getting it in the system :P
I don't like the "Seconds Out" finale, the original finale with the Dancing with the moonlit knight theme reprise and Aisle of Plenty is the only one possible, according to my hears. But that's my personal opinion, don't kill me for this. The performance is great, played very well and close to the original :)
@hogweed89 yeah..i agree with you of course..the real masterpiece is the original...i like it more and more for sure..but i consider the seconds out version like an explosion to satisfy the audience watching two great drummers in a kind of battle ehhhh .....thank you so much !!
@gardenwall07 si si :) ho commentato in inglese (spero corretto) a beneficio di chiunque capiti su questo video...il batterista è davvero bravo a proposito, anche nella parte di quello che sarebbe un drum duet si destreggia bene con le percussioni! (Mi è venuta automatica la piccola critica del finale dopo aver visto un video vecchio dei Musical Box che hanno concluso Cinema Show come l'originale, suonando addirittura Aisle of Plenty, identica all'originale completa di voci)
@hogweed89 beh..allora grazie dal batterista in persona :-)...l'abbiamo suonata diverse volte la versione completa con aisle of plenty..non ricordo se ho un video devo vedere..grazie ancora :-)..p.s. inglese perfetto direi bravo :-)
Man! You guys are great! Just great! Brought some tears of joy to my eyes, really! Thank you for sharing this with us! Would have made Phil, Tony and Mike proud!!
@olorgio63 beh, diciamo che sono tanti gli elementi che non ci consentono di essere al livello dei musical box ;-) grazie mille per l'apprezzamento ! siamo fermi al momento... nessun tour !!
I have to say: as good as the original. Really, you guys have some amazing skills. Solos of the instruments are quite hard in this song, especially moog instrumental after all were played with a great precision. Also vocal was impressive, perfectly following Gabriels style. Well I liked it, it wasn't like most of poor covers on youtube. Keep it going guys, good luck! ;)
@sheiffa Sorry sheiffa, but Tony Banks strickly played ARP synthsizers (ARP 2600 and Pro soloist).. never played a Moog synth or even owned one as far as I know...those are most likely, ARP 2600 patches (horn, etc.) that you hear in the solos in Cinema Show. The key-boardist in Garden Wall does a great job in reproducing the sounds though, on his Yamaha..Great cover..!!!
Glad i found this, one of my fav genesis tracks. why would the audience not shut up and appreciate the brilliance playing in front of them. I would so have loved to have been there. well done great job
You're telling me the drummer couldn't take a break from smoking for an hour? Listen when he kicks from cancer call me I'll do the show and with a bit more class.
Oh hell yeah boys...that was very tasty! I liked it a lot. I have never heard anyone do a remake of this before, yet pull it off as well as you guys have. Right on! Give me more!!!!! I want to meet everyone of you and treat you to a beer sometime. Come to Denver and I will make good on the brew!
very nice, you must be enjoying some very well writting music for a life time, i'm 42 years old , been listen to genesis since i was 5. sad cant see them live anymore, ty for your performance, and also for staying on tract to the sounds, very very nice good for you.
Finally they're inducted into the Rock 'n Roll Hall of Fame. FUSE Channel on March 15th 2010 LIVE from the Waldorf Astoria in NYC- DON'T MISS IT -- GENESIS LIVES FOREVER !!
vraiment je vous felicite pour cette magnifique et fidele interpretation..je suis le plus grand fan de la terre de genesis depuis 35 ans et j'aimerai savoir si vous faites des concerts dans le sud de la france en tribute a genesis.. je serais tres heureux de faire votre connaissance...je suis pret de toulon ! pour finir il est dommage que vous jouiez devant un si petit public à tres bientot j'espere !!
merci bien mon ami...je suis tres heureux de tes mots..vraiment..en effet il fut un beau concert de garden wall.. c'est vrai..il est dommage..maintenant nous sommes arretès..et de toutes facon je croi qu'il est tres difficil pour nous de venir jouer en france :-)....mais tu peux prendre un vacance et venir ici la prochain fois que nous avons un concert .. ehhhhh.. :-) merci beaucoup encore...
Two days ago we watched The Watch. You'll know them I guess. Was a great performance I even recorded some vids on my mobile. Check my channel.
For you guys I think you play the Genesis songs more precise. I agree with GiuseppeGazerro You really deserve a better theater and a better audience. 9:18 is a bit strange isn't it.. The Music of Genesis is GREAT! and everyone who puts effort in playing it like you deserves RESPECT!
yes we know The Watch..they're a very good band and of course we respect them and i'm sure they do the same... how i envy them for their organization and management and because the play a lot ehhhh....:-)...mmm.. you find 9.18 a bit strange? ..mmm i don't know..thanks a lot for your respect and for commenting and watching...!! :-)
What a treat!! You guys take a beautiful, yet technically difficult song and make it look EASY!! (though I know it's not) As usual your percussion was outstanding, and Bruno was in GREAT voice that night! The Audiance is not really appreciating how tough this music is!!
You commented on my drum cover of this a few days ago, and I have finally had the chance to watch your version!
Wonderful stuff guys! Very accomplished. I have seen lots of Genesis Tributes, including Musical Box, and I think you guys are great.
Impressed at how relaxed your drummer is during this. As you saw from my video, I tend to be a lot more physical! Was that a fag hanging out of his mouth? How relaxed is that lol!
thanks a lot for your generous comment... :-)..well ..yes that was a fag..it became famous and very criticized...ehhhh..actually not elegant by my side, but the venue and the audience were so informal..ahhh..yes i usually play relaxed.. i finally learnt to play this way after many years..when i can hear what i'm playing there's no need to be phisical..this sometimes happens when i play in a little club, when electric instruments put a wall of sounds on me !!!... thanks again !!
You guys have it down pretty well...genesis has been a favourite of mine since i was 14 years old and went to see them many, mnay times...i am impressed with your group...
mon ami..nous sommes une petite tribute band de l'italie ..nuos jouions surtout a naples ou pres de..donc Québec c'est trop loin de nos moyens..merci beaucoup pour ton interet ! :-)
Very nice...keep up the good work...the Seconds Out version drumming can be somewhat more difficult to cover because both Collins and Bruford played on the middle and end instrumental sections - but the drummer here captured it well (for just being one drummer)...kudos to all the musicians and vocalists here...
Do you know the sticking pattern (right hand, left hand) of Phil's drumming on the studio/SEBTP version? I can do the time signature - it's the specific pattern that I don't know...
I really admire Phil's 70's drumming - sometimes it sounded like his sticks were "dancing" in his hands...of course, Bill himself was technically proficient...I had read that he was not fond of Genesis music...
sorry bud ..i can read music but i find more difficult writing..it took me time and dedication that currently i don't have..try to learn it by ear..it's not so hard as pattern though wonderful !!..phil in the 70's was an incredible drummer...bill has always been acid and critic..but nowdays he admit that then he was young and a bit arrogant and now he gives genesis the right value...
@gardenwall07 ...thanks for your response...most of my own sticking patterns tend to include a bridge (to produce what I call a "rolling rhythm")...one particular pattern involves inverted paradiddles...one reason I can't readily define Phil's sticking (on the studio version) is that - at his low volume playing - his snare sounded similar to his hi-hat and cymbal...you confirmed what I had sensed about Bill's (previous) attitudes - but I appreciate his (attitude)change(s)...thanks, again...
I appreciate any band covering Genesis Classic Early tunes but this reminds me of Spinal Tap playing at the US AIRFORCE BASE- The audience looks like a retirement party for the CEO of some cheap plastics company- Good Job though
thanks for the advice dear gardenwall... the drummer, yes is certain that I always have the need of writing... is because I become appasionated when of Genesis is about to talk...!
I ll try to write less , but let me tell you that I am impressed with gardenwall band...
veo que entiendes varios idiomas... amo Cinema Show , es mi tema favorito del Selling... de todas maneras , a pesar que Firth of Fifth es el tema que se aplaude como si fuera lo superior en ese album , pero Cinema es belleza , es dulzura , es como algo que abre en mi un espacio cada vez totalmente distinto en cada ocasion que lo escucho ... mi primera pintura en acrlilico con temas de Genesis fue precisamente inspirada en The Cinema Show, hace mas de 27 años... I don t belong here....!
primero quiero aclarar que este comentario que aparece con el nombre sel usuario macharimbe , lo hice yo, lo que paso es que a mi amigo macharimbe se le quedo abierto su user name y yo no me di cuenta y segui en youtube,,,ja, ja ... y el no comenta sobre genesis...
Beautiful. Finally I can listen to a band which respectfully and faithfully sings and plays Genesis. You are a great band, and my mind goes back to those fantastic years. You make me feel so young, you make me dream, Garden Wall! But why do those silly people talk, instead of listenining?
really clean and great cover however you just really invent in a mellotron or at least a portable oen because the keyboard isnt really meant for this the rest of it was spot on and perfect thou....bass tone was sooooo good!!!
hey bud..thanks a lot for your comment..concerning the mellotron..mmm i don't remember if our keyboardist had a version of M-TRON or some sample of mellotron that night..but anyway as you can see, you don't have to pay too much attention to the sound you hear from our clips..it's horrible and recorded with the cam mic..so you can't expect nothing better unfortunately...
ANOTHER EXCELLANT RENDITION!!!! Thank you for keeping Genesis alive!!! Your vocals are GREAT, and your keyboards guy, WOW!!! The k=board solo was truly a phenom! Do you guys have any CD's out?? Love to have some of your stuff to go!!
dear bud...thanks a lot for your appreciation.. :-) ...no..we have no cd out..but you can download for free the dvd of all our show of the lamb lies down on broadway.. if you are interested send a p.m. .. :-)
Ascoltavo i Genesis gli Yes quando avevo 15 anni, e già suonavo...ora a 46 anni, sentirvi e rendermi conto che c'è ancora chi senza magari tirarsela, SUONA DI BRUTTO come voi portando avanti un genere che credevo ormai sorpassato! In bocca al lupo ragassi !!!
I have to admit...you are Génesis twins! I am A pro musician & i send you my congratulations. All the best from Spain!
MADAMEMEDUSSA 3 months ago
@MADAMEMEDUSSA ohhh thanks a lot Madame !!!
gardenwall07 1 month ago
It's truly a pleasure to see cover bands do really spot-on versions of these classics.
It make us appreciate the brilliance of the original song & band.
Thank You!!
YYZDRUMR 4 months ago
@YYZDRUMR thanks a lot for your appreciation :-) !!
gardenwall07 4 months ago
Excellent cover of one of my favorite Genesis songs!
scifiwriter98 4 months ago
@scifiwriter98 thanks a lot !!
gardenwall07 1 month ago
Watching this was a Privalidge. You are all very specail Musicians to be able to pull this song off. Because it is a Showcase of almost everything you need in Music to survive. Do I think 10% of the so called Musicians that are making beats & bass are capable of any of this? No! Because both you & I know why "Exactly" this song is hard to pull off.
All of Pull it off so well though, almost as though it were your own song. It's a shame you didn't go for the Ending. Your Drummer is Amazing btw!
therealKINDLE 5 months ago
@therealKINDLE you're really kind tanks a lot !!
gardenwall07 5 months ago
I close my eyes and see Genesis, your production is so faithful to the original in every detail! A Majestic performance...........Grazie!
wraithy65 6 months ago
@wraithy65 very glad you appreciated ! thanks a a lot !!
gardenwall07 5 months ago
Solid guys ! this is the version with BB...not perfect but I love this pice so much I will do better each time anyway. I was lucky in 1976 to be at the FORUM of Montréal.
danielhoude 6 months ago
@danielhoude Donc, voyons si je me rappel quelque chose en francais .. :-) Cher Daniel, avant tout mercie beaucoup. Je suis absolument sure que la premiere partie de l' instrumentale etait joueè seulment par phil, au moin jusqu' a' quand les autres instruments s'arretent et il reste seulment la batterie..dans ce moment la' bill commence a jouer avec Phil..Je crois que c' est la plus incroyable performance de phil ,qui manifestement voulait montrer a tous qu'il n'etait pas inferieur a Bill
gardenwall07 6 months ago
ton français est excellent. quand l'instrumentale débute, y a un roulement de caisse claire comme un appel disons de la part de BB...oui ! jusqu'à la fin BB joue. Écoute, je te jure sur la tête de mon fils. Tu peut entendre d'ailleurs le son particulier de la caisse claire en brass tuné un ton presque + haut que PCollins. Sur et certain que Phil a offert toute une performance lui aussi. D'ailleurs, j'ai en tête de jouer la piece "Nuclear burn" qu'il a composé avec Brand X. ciao! mon ami
dhoudedrums 6 months ago
@dhoudedrums desolee' pour mon retard..mmm je crois que bill joue de les percussions et puis il commence a jouer de la batterie tu peut voir aussi leur video de cinema show du meme tour avec bill !! de tout facon je sui sure e tu est sure aussi ehhhh ca fait rien mon ami :-) !! mmm nuclear burn c' est assez difficile mais on peut faire ;-)..ciaooo
gardenwall07 6 months ago
This is fantastic. The musicianship is incredible
LedZeppelinFan25 7 months ago
@LedZeppelinFan25 thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 7 months ago
muito bom mesmo.. como o amigo alí embaixo falou .... melhor que vocês só o Genesis mesmo... OTIMOOOOOOOO !!!
TheViniciusjovemfla 7 months ago
@TheViniciusjovemfla thank youuuuuuu !!! :-)
gardenwall07 7 months ago
@DrAvantajado sorry, don't speak portuguese, but i caught the sense of your words...OBRIGADO !!!
gardenwall07 7 months ago
would be perfect to a tee if the organ chords were slightly louder-- a 10/10.
chordsequencer001 7 months ago
@chordsequencer001 ...ehhhh would be almost perfect if everything had a better audio sound !!! thanks a lot bud !! :-)
gardenwall07 7 months ago
You guys are damn good, hope to see you in the states someday soon.
ssllsskk 7 months ago
I would like to have those guys on my next Birthday party!!!
Noopz 9 months ago
@Noopz ehhhh..thanks a lot for your appreciation !
gardenwall07 8 months ago
bravo!
KholmovKulishevsky 9 months ago
@KholmovKulishevsky thank you !!
gardenwall07 9 months ago
I've been a Genesis fan since 1970 and this is absolutely briliiant, nice work guys
Eldomina22 9 months ago
@Eldomina22 i'm very late, but i wish to thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 7 months ago
for a moment i really thought this was genesis until i saw the word 'tribute' ;0
funtasyu1 9 months ago
@funtasyu1 i'm very late but i wish to say that you've been very kind !! thank you !!
gardenwall07 7 months ago
Incredibile.... vi ho trovato per caso...pelle d'oca a manetta !!!!! Bravi veramente bravi...Grazie
kaludio60 10 months ago
@kaludio60 scusa per il ritardo e grazie infinite !!! :-)
gardenwall07 7 months ago
Oh my god, these guys are awesome!! The drummer is fantastic and the keyboardplayer is amazing! I know the Cinema Show is a very difficult song on the keyboard, very fast and very well played! I have never seen such a significant remake of this song, this is coming dangerously close to Genesis itself! Please keep the Genesis-scene alive!! :)
DjKata 10 months ago
@DjKata thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 10 months ago
@gardenwall07 Yeah no problem, guys! I´m sorry, but I don't speak italian.. I wish they would still do this in The Netherlands.. In my opinion, Genesis is the single best band ever existed :) The way in which they can run up to a climax in a musical gem ;) One of the single best is the epic 'Supper's Ready'.. Could you maybe give me a hint on how to learn the fast parts of the keyboard? I'm really having a hard time, getting it in the system :P
DjKata 10 months ago
Absolutely Superb! Very nice work :)
saturnfive 10 months ago
@saturnfive thank you !!
gardenwall07 10 months ago
I don't like the "Seconds Out" finale, the original finale with the Dancing with the moonlit knight theme reprise and Aisle of Plenty is the only one possible, according to my hears. But that's my personal opinion, don't kill me for this. The performance is great, played very well and close to the original :)
hogweed89 10 months ago
@hogweed89 yeah..i agree with you of course..the real masterpiece is the original...i like it more and more for sure..but i consider the seconds out version like an explosion to satisfy the audience watching two great drummers in a kind of battle ehhhh .....thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 10 months ago
@hogweed89 p.s. ...in tutto questo... sei italiano anche tu ahhhhhhh ! :-)
gardenwall07 10 months ago
@gardenwall07 si si :) ho commentato in inglese (spero corretto) a beneficio di chiunque capiti su questo video...il batterista è davvero bravo a proposito, anche nella parte di quello che sarebbe un drum duet si destreggia bene con le percussioni! (Mi è venuta automatica la piccola critica del finale dopo aver visto un video vecchio dei Musical Box che hanno concluso Cinema Show come l'originale, suonando addirittura Aisle of Plenty, identica all'originale completa di voci)
hogweed89 10 months ago
@hogweed89 beh..allora grazie dal batterista in persona :-)...l'abbiamo suonata diverse volte la versione completa con aisle of plenty..non ricordo se ho un video devo vedere..grazie ancora :-)..p.s. inglese perfetto direi bravo :-)
gardenwall07 10 months ago
PERFECT !
klaritavital 10 months ago
@klaritavital thank you !! :-)
gardenwall07 10 months ago
Man! You guys are great! Just great! Brought some tears of joy to my eyes, really! Thank you for sharing this with us! Would have made Phil, Tony and Mike proud!!
combatvf24 10 months ago
@combatvf24 thanks a lot to you..you're too much kind !
gardenwall07 10 months ago
Guys you did a great job. I am reliving my childhood with this one!
ocdabiz 10 months ago
@ocdabiz thank you so much !
gardenwall07 10 months ago
It's a shame that so many people there talk while you play this wonderful piece of music!!! GREAT
madmagirus 11 months ago
@madmagirus thank you !!
gardenwall07 11 months ago
excellent.
jketteridge 1 year ago
@jketteridge Thank you !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Sorry ParanormalLight: Tony Banks played a PolyMoog on the song "Many too Many"...
NCMountainDavis 1 year ago
Simply astounding, I´m a great fan of Classic Italian Progressive Rock, from Banco to PFM to Celeste to Goblin to Museo Rosenbach
ferfret68 1 year ago
@ferfret68 thank you !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Ragazzi, siete fenomenali, forse non a livello dei canadesi "musical box", ma quelli sono maniacalmente perfetti...comunque, SPACCATE DAVVERO!
Ma ad Ascoli Piceno? MAI????
olorgio63 1 year ago
@olorgio63 beh, diciamo che sono tanti gli elementi che non ci consentono di essere al livello dei musical box ;-) grazie mille per l'apprezzamento ! siamo fermi al momento... nessun tour !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
I have to say: as good as the original. Really, you guys have some amazing skills. Solos of the instruments are quite hard in this song, especially moog instrumental after all were played with a great precision. Also vocal was impressive, perfectly following Gabriels style. Well I liked it, it wasn't like most of poor covers on youtube. Keep it going guys, good luck! ;)
sheiffa 1 year ago
@sheiffa you're very nice !! thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
@sheiffa Sorry sheiffa, but Tony Banks strickly played ARP synthsizers (ARP 2600 and Pro soloist).. never played a Moog synth or even owned one as far as I know...those are most likely, ARP 2600 patches (horn, etc.) that you hear in the solos in Cinema Show. The key-boardist in Garden Wall does a great job in reproducing the sounds though, on his Yamaha..Great cover..!!!
ParanormalLight 1 year ago
@ParanormalLight thank you !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Glad i found this, one of my fav genesis tracks. why would the audience not shut up and appreciate the brilliance playing in front of them. I would so have loved to have been there. well done great job
AyFrame 1 year ago
@AyFrame thank you so much ! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Frigging Awesome!!!
You have done some sort of justice to the piece. It is so ALL THERE. It does Hackett, Banks, Gabe, Collins proud.
Truly overwhelmed.....
kgvander 1 year ago
@kgvander thank you so much..i can feel your true appreciation in your words..and that makes us very happy !! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
like Le Orme
PalotaiPeti 1 year ago
@ste662009 grazie mille a te :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Wonderful music and great musicians on stage!
funklover24 1 year ago
@funklover24 thank you so much !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Very nice, organic feel, spot-on to the spirit of the piece.
SanFernandoJym 1 year ago
@SanFernandoJym thanks a lot for appreciating !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
I cannot believe that the audience wont SHUT UP!! An excellant performance (AGAIN)!!! On of my favourite G+ songs!!
bigwo56 1 year ago
@bigwo56 thanks a lot big !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
superbe reprise!!!!!! felicitations.....
wizzzo83 1 year ago
@wizzzo83 merci bien !! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
absolutely perfect!!!!!!!
diogobobsin 1 year ago
@diogobobsin thanks a lot for your appreciation !! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
@diogobobsin you're too much generous !! :-)...thanks a lot !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
you are better beyond original,drummer is perfect-many greetings from me,
i´m drummer of led zeppelin revival prague,
led-zeppelin-revival.cz
ahoy tom
tomaskejr 1 year ago
@tomaskejr thank you collegue :-) !! thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
absolutly genial cover-bravo!!!!
tomaskejr 1 year ago
@tomaskejr thank you !! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
@tomaskejr you are better beyond original,drummer is perfect-many greetings from me,
i´m drummer of led zeppelin revival prague,
led-zeppelin-revival.cz
ahoy tom
tomaskejr 1 year ago
You're telling me the drummer couldn't take a break from smoking for an hour? Listen when he kicks from cancer call me I'll do the show and with a bit more class.
He's got chops that much I'll give him.
Great job guys:)
IAGFOREX 1 year ago
@IAGFOREX .....mmmm...(scratch scratch scratch)..very kind of you...thanks a lot...The drummer.
gardenwall07 1 year ago
What a cover!!!!!!
Amazing, great musicality, technically successful!
Thanks for posting.
bronilide 1 year ago
cover!!!!!!
wow, what a cover!
thank you so much, nice musicality and technically successful
bronilide 1 year ago
@bronilide thanks a lot :-) !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
What a shame the singer sings so bad! But hats off to the others!
pascal27able 1 year ago
@pascal27able actually that night our singer was not on the top , but i don't find vocals are too bad here..anyway many thanks for your comment
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Oh hell yeah boys...that was very tasty! I liked it a lot. I have never heard anyone do a remake of this before, yet pull it off as well as you guys have. Right on! Give me more!!!!! I want to meet everyone of you and treat you to a beer sometime. Come to Denver and I will make good on the brew!
sexybisquit 1 year ago
@sexybisquit thanks a lot for your kind words !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
very nice, you must be enjoying some very well writting music for a life time, i'm 42 years old , been listen to genesis since i was 5. sad cant see them live anymore, ty for your performance, and also for staying on tract to the sounds, very very nice good for you.
caridadroberto 1 year ago
@caridadroberto thanks a lot for your kind comment !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Very good.The old man smoking drummer is very good also. Cheers.
glennw53 1 year ago
@glennw53 thank you so much! ... especially for calling me "old man"...ahhhhh ...
p.s. i'm not so old..just some white hairs :-) bye bye
gardenwall07 1 year ago
A lovely performance. I love this piece--it has so much emotion in those amazing chords and time signatures. Very well done.
neamers 1 year ago
@neamers i agree :-) ...thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
cool
maxthetax 1 year ago
@maxthetax thank you !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
this is quite amazing..soooooo realistic
barryeaton 1 year ago
@barryeaton thanks a lot ! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
I grew up with this music like so many others. It still means a lot to me.
You are very good indeed!
chanctonbury63 1 year ago
@chanctonbury63 very kind of you ! thanks a lot :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
oh yeah,i liked,defenitly
orion777temp 1 year ago
@orion777temp thank you so much !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
nice job!
chyrd 1 year ago
@chyrd glad you liked..thank you !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
cojonudos!!!
thyzzar 1 year ago
@thyzzar Gracias !!! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Excelente interpretacion
suena identica
buen video
:)
saludos!
rockschisim 1 year ago
@rockschisim thank you !!! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
@rockschisim thank you !! :-)
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Finally they're inducted into the Rock 'n Roll Hall of Fame. FUSE Channel on March 15th 2010 LIVE from the Waldorf Astoria in NYC- DON'T MISS IT -- GENESIS LIVES FOREVER !!
BigBadBobby1234 1 year ago
vraiment je vous felicite pour cette magnifique et fidele interpretation..je suis le plus grand fan de la terre de genesis depuis 35 ans et j'aimerai savoir si vous faites des concerts dans le sud de la france en tribute a genesis.. je serais tres heureux de faire votre connaissance...je suis pret de toulon ! pour finir il est dommage que vous jouiez devant un si petit public à tres bientot j'espere !!
chrisgenesis83 1 year ago
merci bien mon ami...je suis tres heureux de tes mots..vraiment..en effet il fut un beau concert de garden wall.. c'est vrai..il est dommage..maintenant nous sommes arretès..et de toutes facon je croi qu'il est tres difficil pour nous de venir jouer en france :-)....mais tu peux prendre un vacance et venir ici la prochain fois que nous avons un concert .. ehhhhh.. :-) merci beaucoup encore...
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Fair Play !!!! ;]
bionicpineapple 1 year ago
thank you so much !
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Super cover, great job!!
patricksweat 1 year ago
oh..thank you so much :-) !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
Top class...well done
vroom82box 1 year ago
you're very kind..thanks a lot !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
wow they are good!
SephynnXx 1 year ago
thanks a lot !!
gardenwall07 1 year ago
veramente straordinari...grazie ragazzi...la musica resta viva se chi la ama la spinge...grazie...
sharakkone 2 years ago
grazie mille a te! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Two days ago we watched The Watch. You'll know them I guess. Was a great performance I even recorded some vids on my mobile. Check my channel.
For you guys I think you play the Genesis songs more precise. I agree with GiuseppeGazerro You really deserve a better theater and a better audience. 9:18 is a bit strange isn't it.. The Music of Genesis is GREAT! and everyone who puts effort in playing it like you deserves RESPECT!
a51stef 2 years ago
yes we know The Watch..they're a very good band and of course we respect them and i'm sure they do the same... how i envy them for their organization and management and because the play a lot ehhhh....:-)...mmm.. you find 9.18 a bit strange? ..mmm i don't know..thanks a lot for your respect and for commenting and watching...!! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
What a treat!! You guys take a beautiful, yet technically difficult song and make it look EASY!! (though I know it's not) As usual your percussion was outstanding, and Bruno was in GREAT voice that night! The Audiance is not really appreciating how tough this music is!!
bigwo56 2 years ago
ehhh thanks as usual BIG... :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Genesis would be proud of you
MrProgrock 2 years ago
ahhhhh..oh my god...that would be nice !!! at least we try to do our best for not offending them..ahhhh..thank you so much!! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
That was terrific... The audience doesn't do you justice!!
mlew44 2 years ago 5
thank you so much !!!
gardenwall07 2 years ago
You commented on my drum cover of this a few days ago, and I have finally had the chance to watch your version!
Wonderful stuff guys! Very accomplished. I have seen lots of Genesis Tributes, including Musical Box, and I think you guys are great.
Impressed at how relaxed your drummer is during this. As you saw from my video, I tend to be a lot more physical! Was that a fag hanging out of his mouth? How relaxed is that lol!
Good stuff :-)
jouxplan 2 years ago
thanks a lot for your generous comment... :-)..well ..yes that was a fag..it became famous and very criticized...ehhhh..actually not elegant by my side, but the venue and the audience were so informal..ahhh..yes i usually play relaxed.. i finally learnt to play this way after many years..when i can hear what i'm playing there's no need to be phisical..this sometimes happens when i play in a little club, when electric instruments put a wall of sounds on me !!!... thanks again !!
gardenwall07 2 years ago
great!
you deserve much better theatres
GiuseppeGazerro 2 years ago 7
giuse'..guarda che siamo italiani ehhhhh...grazie mille per il commento :-)..ciao
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Well done guys!
kc0dxf 2 years ago 2
@kc0dxf thank you !!
gardenwall07 2 years ago
You guys have it down pretty well...genesis has been a favourite of mine since i was 14 years old and went to see them many, mnay times...i am impressed with your group...
kayreive 2 years ago
thanks a lot bud!! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Faites-vous encore des tournée au Québec, si oui j'ai hâte d'allé vous voir ...vraiment exceptionnel
DanBitoy1 2 years ago
mon ami..nous sommes une petite tribute band de l'italie ..nuos jouions surtout a naples ou pres de..donc Québec c'est trop loin de nos moyens..merci beaucoup pour ton interet ! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Very nice...keep up the good work...the Seconds Out version drumming can be somewhat more difficult to cover because both Collins and Bruford played on the middle and end instrumental sections - but the drummer here captured it well (for just being one drummer)...kudos to all the musicians and vocalists here...
davss5 2 years ago
very glad you liked the way i tried to cover Phil and Bill..thanks a lot for your appreciation!!
gardenwall07 2 years ago
@gardenwall07 ...you're welcome...
Do you know the sticking pattern (right hand, left hand) of Phil's drumming on the studio/SEBTP version? I can do the time signature - it's the specific pattern that I don't know...
I really admire Phil's 70's drumming - sometimes it sounded like his sticks were "dancing" in his hands...of course, Bill himself was technically proficient...I had read that he was not fond of Genesis music...
davss5 2 years ago
sorry bud ..i can read music but i find more difficult writing..it took me time and dedication that currently i don't have..try to learn it by ear..it's not so hard as pattern though wonderful !!..phil in the 70's was an incredible drummer...bill has always been acid and critic..but nowdays he admit that then he was young and a bit arrogant and now he gives genesis the right value...
gardenwall07 2 years ago
@gardenwall07 ...thanks for your response...most of my own sticking patterns tend to include a bridge (to produce what I call a "rolling rhythm")...one particular pattern involves inverted paradiddles...one reason I can't readily define Phil's sticking (on the studio version) is that - at his low volume playing - his snare sounded similar to his hi-hat and cymbal...you confirmed what I had sensed about Bill's (previous) attitudes - but I appreciate his (attitude)change(s)...thanks, again...
davss5 2 years ago
great job on this guys. too bad the venue you were at wasn't so appreciative.
drapo1966 2 years ago
thank you so much...!
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Genesis forever !
Zadran61 2 years ago
I appreciate any band covering Genesis Classic Early tunes but this reminds me of Spinal Tap playing at the US AIRFORCE BASE- The audience looks like a retirement party for the CEO of some cheap plastics company- Good Job though
amazrand 2 years ago
thanks!
gardenwall07 2 years ago
PERFECT. THANKS.
philippelereveur 2 years ago 2
mercie beaucoup !!
gardenwall07 2 years ago
thanks for the advice dear gardenwall... the drummer, yes is certain that I always have the need of writing... is because I become appasionated when of Genesis is about to talk...!
I ll try to write less , but let me tell you that I am impressed with gardenwall band...
genesisinsideme 2 years ago
veo que entiendes varios idiomas... amo Cinema Show , es mi tema favorito del Selling... de todas maneras , a pesar que Firth of Fifth es el tema que se aplaude como si fuera lo superior en ese album , pero Cinema es belleza , es dulzura , es como algo que abre en mi un espacio cada vez totalmente distinto en cada ocasion que lo escucho ... mi primera pintura en acrlilico con temas de Genesis fue precisamente inspirada en The Cinema Show, hace mas de 27 años... I don t belong here....!
marachimbe 2 years ago
primero quiero aclarar que este comentario que aparece con el nombre sel usuario macharimbe , lo hice yo, lo que paso es que a mi amigo macharimbe se le quedo abierto su user name y yo no me di cuenta y segui en youtube,,,ja, ja ... y el no comenta sobre genesis...
genesisinsideme 2 years ago
man this is good stuff i realy enjoyed listenin to it as much as the original ..
91schumacher 2 years ago
thank you so much bud..so glad you appreciated.. :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Cavolo! Bravissimi e complimenti! La mia canzone ultrastrapreferita! :)
TrishaZurigo 2 years ago 3
beh..grazie mille :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
genial, simplemente genial, que buen cover; felicidades, les quedo muy bien.
saludos.
TheSongjune 2 years ago 2
muchas gracias !! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Beautiful. Finally I can listen to a band which respectfully and faithfully sings and plays Genesis. You are a great band, and my mind goes back to those fantastic years. You make me feel so young, you make me dream, Garden Wall! But why do those silly people talk, instead of listenining?
IntuitionDigression 2 years ago 5
i can see you're young enough!! 30years! ehhhhh..anyway we appreciated your words a lot!! thank you so much!! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Actually. I am 44!
IntuitionDigression 2 years ago
I five starred this vid all the way:)
Satori1800 2 years ago
Absolutely fantastic. Prog on man. One of the best renditions I've seen. I think is that good, that is going to my Genesis w/out Gabriel play list.
vivelavidarocka 2 years ago 4
wow!!! this is such an honor to us ..thank you so much!! :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
really clean and great cover however you just really invent in a mellotron or at least a portable oen because the keyboard isnt really meant for this the rest of it was spot on and perfect thou....bass tone was sooooo good!!!
SRNF 2 years ago 6
hey bud..thanks a lot for your comment..concerning the mellotron..mmm i don't remember if our keyboardist had a version of M-TRON or some sample of mellotron that night..but anyway as you can see, you don't have to pay too much attention to the sound you hear from our clips..it's horrible and recorded with the cam mic..so you can't expect nothing better unfortunately...
:-)...thanks again..
gardenwall07 2 years ago
ANOTHER EXCELLANT RENDITION!!!! Thank you for keeping Genesis alive!!! Your vocals are GREAT, and your keyboards guy, WOW!!! The k=board solo was truly a phenom! Do you guys have any CD's out?? Love to have some of your stuff to go!!
bigwo56 2 years ago 4
dear bud...thanks a lot for your appreciation.. :-) ...no..we have no cd out..but you can download for free the dvd of all our show of the lamb lies down on broadway.. if you are interested send a p.m. .. :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
Ascoltavo i Genesis gli Yes quando avevo 15 anni, e già suonavo...ora a 46 anni, sentirvi e rendermi conto che c'è ancora chi senza magari tirarsela, SUONA DI BRUTTO come voi portando avanti un genere che credevo ormai sorpassato! In bocca al lupo ragassi !!!
dryrats 2 years ago 3
Signori, tanto di cappello, a portare fuori brani così, ci vogliono un bel paio di P___e...
dryrats 2 years ago 4
mmm..scusa non ho ben capito ..un paio di che?? ehhhhhh..scherzo ..grazie mille per aver guardato e commentato :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago
complimenti veramente bravi
baronericciardi 2 years ago 2
grazie mille :-)
gardenwall07 2 years ago