Carl/Ellie - Goodbye to You

[cindy3772]

it's good...

i really like it...

:')

[shane13233]

It`s different, but in a way it`s great.

You did a great job on this one.

2 hours of hard work, makes a nice vid.

And, i want to thank you for that.

UP is now one of my favorit movies of all time.

Again, thanks.

[kwsths946]

I love this movie.... The song from the video is Michelle Branch - "Goodbye To You"

[MimiAhmad84]

Who sings this song? This voice reminds me of Michelle Branch. 

[TheLuckyPickle]

are you trying to make fun of up

[teeklu]

i cry because the video and musci

[wimilicous101]

"At the heart of the story of Up is the tragic, yet beautiful love relationship between Carl and Ellie"

Their love is anything but tragic - just beautiful, the sort of romance many people often dream of having. It's sad when Ellie dies, but no tragedy - just life, and that's why it's sad. The fact that they couldn't have kids makes it worse as poor Carl is left a lonely old man :'(

Btw, this song doesn't "embody the feeling of Carl's loss", it just makes it needlessly corny and seem superficial.

[BeaverAru]

@wimilicous101 I'm always VERY happy to see people so passionate about this movie that they call me on my song choice, saying the film is better and deserves more. Because that shows me this film really touched them, like it did me. And I admit, the song choice wasn't the best. At the time it was a song I loved, and I found connections to the movie in it's lyrics. And I agree, the movie is very much about life. Both the good and bad.

Thanks for the very insightful comment!

[urloldude]

the music is ok jerks

[Krazykatjr]

Love this song and love this movie... But they dont mix lol This song is about a break up... more so about the guy wronging the girl and i must admit Carl didnt do a thing wrong :P

[texasmayhem817]

lame i want to see the talking dog next

[mrfelipeist]

@texasmayhem817 LOL

[ludepau]

Thank you so much for this beautiful gift! I loved it.

[groovepossum2000]

if their story is tragic so is everyones. everybody dies. i'd prefer to use the actual definition of "tragedy".

[unfinished8kt]

haven't heard michelle branch in a while. that was nice :)

[princessguardian]

where can i watch this movie online without any download?

[charmander4533]

good thing this shitty music was playing or else I would have been sad watching this

[BeaverAru]

@charmander4533 Ah, well, not for everyone I suppose. We all have different tastes.

[william58515]

@charmander4533 LMFAO LOL

[fadhlanfaiz]

she said she have a great adventure with carl... that is her dream. but going to paradise fall is her another dream...

[SeltzerAddict]

Who are the six heartless people who gave it a thumbs down?

[razymar]

thanks for the video, it's so beautiful , and it made me cry

[Jteamguys]

love the clip. hate the music

[TheDarkNobleOne]

Please don't ruin such a great movie with your crappy music

[BeaverAru]

@TheDarkNobleOne I'm glad to hear you're an Up fan, but my apologies our musical tastes don't line up.

[UnfamiliarPlace]

@BeaverAru I was going to thumbs up the original guy since I don't like this music too much either, but when I read your mature and thoughtful reply I changed my mind. That was a politeness you rarely see on the Internet.

[Gelinika]

I just sooo loved this sweet tender movie...yet, caused a sense of sharp sadness...then, the end...'Thank you for the adventure, now have a new adventure of your own'..soo true..life goes on. thank you for this video!

[LovelyScorpio31]

my grandma just died recently and it was so tragic and hard on the family especially my grandpa. and then i came upon this video..lets just say this didnt exactly help... :'( made me cry. there was actually many similarities between my grandparents and carl and ellie.

i miss my grandmother very much. but i also miss my grandpa. i cant wait to see him soon :)

needless to say i love this video.

[BeaverAru]

@LovelyScorpio31 I'm so sorry for your loss...

I'm glad to hear you liked this video.

[ssolero30]

LOVE the Up isodes! They are so cute! I cant find Upisode 4. Can Russell be any cuter!? The movie is just Perfect!

[vik1304]

Very Good.

[theyellowrose185]

Awe! :'(

Beautiful video.

[kimkumag02]

good job it made me cry

[yuitrrew]

:'(

[ThePrae2]

i'm crying

so beautiful

luv this song

[CHEPELUSA1985]

=,(

[So0mery]

Beautiful!!!!!

I'm Crying

...

[PathOfDistrAction]

this movie made me cry like a bitch wen i saw it in theatres..good thing i was wearing the 3D glasses.......

[dropdeadso1]

what does ellie right at the end in her adventure book, anyone translate that? lol

[Wrecker649]

The DVD footage looks Russian, but what Ellie writes at the end was; 'Thank you for the adventure, now have a new adventure of your own'

All the years as a child I was dragged to Disney Movies in a half-nelson, I hated every f*cking minute of it. Now as a 37 year old man, they produce an animation that blows me away. Fantastic Movie- Carl is my hero!!!

[ssolero30]

@Wrecker649 Absolutely Love this Movie! By Far the Best Disney Pixar Movie ( Or just Disney for that matter) Ever made! This movie is really not for kids! There are cute "kids" parts, like the talking dog, the bird etc. etc. But this movie is an adult concept! LOVE IT!

[Riibbbo]

@Wrecker649 You can't be serious. "Up" was the most random animated movie I've ever seen. To me, it wasn't as emotional as everybody says it is.

[Jonastasticfan]

I love this video, and a great song choice, it made me feel like crying, so sad. But great job =D Great movie and great song 5/5

ps: i just subscribed to your channel =)

[thechosenrabbit]

anyone know where the original clip of this scene can be found?

[BeaverAru]

Which scene?

[thechosenrabbit]

When Carl reads the album when he landed at the Paradise place before rescuing Russell.

[BeaverAru]

I'm not sure...I haven't seen it if it has been posted.

Sorry....

[ChaosNadine]

Thanks for this wonderful video! It gives a wonderful impression of what real love means.

Can somebody tell me who's the singer of this song?

[BeaverAru]

You're very VERY welcome! Always nice to recieve such kind comments.

This is the accoustic version of "Goodbye to You", sung by Michelle Branch. It was featured on an episode of Buffy.

[brookfields100]

ellie is cute when she is young

[watchboy71]

I hate when people do this. The origional song for this movie is wonderful and makes me so happy and sad at the same time but when people take it out and edit in this CRAP it makes me hate this movie and everything about it. Stupid people.

[BeaverAru]

Oh, I'm sorry you didn't care for it.

I love Up. This wasn't intended as any mark against it, just a way to express my appreciation for it.

[nielsdejong]

Don't mind him :) i love the fact that you made a tribute to that part.

I mean, how they portraited them meeting as kids, and then that married life scene...

Serieusly: how can anyone not get emotional? :)

[prettyspoken2007]

I LOVE ur video!! and it doesn't make me hate the movie..i loved it even more!

When ppl leave angry/hateful comments on sweet beautiful videos ..it's just because they so angry..or not happy with things around in general that they won't appreciate the good stuff!

[VysetheTard]

Or they could just think that amateur music videos are a terrible idea.

Not everything needs to be second-guessed, you know.

[mearnest2]

The best movie I've seen this year. Good editing BTW.

[Vikramthewhite]

imo this isnt pixar's best. But this is probably the only movie that made me get tears in my eyes.

[marymayqt]

this so sweeett!!! sigh.. good cry

[cmej73]

Does anyone know what it's written on their album?? I don't know what language it is!!! everytime he reads it he gets so sad! ='(

[BeaverAru]

"Thanks for the adventure--now go have a new one! Love, Ellie."

It is pretty sad, isn't it?

[mrRa012]

the movie is a masterpiece this is the first time that an animation film touch me a lot..

[pirateboy2]

Pretty sad.. You kiddin'?

I almost FREAKING CRIED. Actually i teared.

Still, IT"S A AWESOME MOVE!!!!!

[ferretkids]

I love it, even though it's really sad.

It has such a great lesson.

Life is the adventure.

Carl was waiting for that 1 big adventure, but didn't realize he was having it already.

Just like Rustle said

" For some reason, its all the boring stuff I remember."

Pixar hasn't disappointed us with any movie, this movie just kept it going, this movie was wonderful.

[Shadowmarktiger]

When you purchase the movie, can you upload it please?

[clementcoolguy]

yeh =D

the cover just says "my adventure book" i think

[renzyrenzyrenzy]

mannn....

im crying now.

there! ive said it!

[ffdude1906]

Wow, really great job. I like the use of black and white on some of the parts. I cried so hard watching this. Up has some of the most touching and beautiful moments in movie history. Most notably the part with the Adventure Book. I cant help but bawl at that part every time. Pixar did a killer job with it, really.

[azulkatie]

i cried....... :'(

[Littlecheffan15]

I cried seeing this scene in the theatres. I loved Carl and Ellie's relationship.

[JediGal101]

This is sooo sad. Great job! ^^ Woah..you started at 5am? lol nice xD

I have a Carl/Ellie vid idea, but i don't have the vids. I'll wait till it comes out on dvd ^^,

Once again, great vid! Song is perfect too! 83

[KenjiTheKunBear]

watched this with my gf, we both cried

[razzledazzle41191]

Wow. Just wow. This video is absolutely fantastic- the clips match the song perfectly, and it all flows so naturally. Adding to favorites, no doubt!

[criminalmastermind8]

amazing job with this video! the clips worked great with the song and it really captured carl and ellie's relationship. :)

[aizome1]

I'm crying. LOL. Because it's a great video tribute from a great story.  *faves*

[pequiscarter]

Amo esta historia... Lloré como una Magdalena en el cine cuando Carl recordaba a su Ellie... :-(

[LionsLamb5]

loved the movie, loved the video, great job!

[PixarkA113]

Pixar.... :) Forever in my heart

[mrslordbeckett]

That was beautiful!

[chron5007]

what is the message that Ellie leaves for Carl in the album?

[BeaverAru]

"Thanks for the adventure, now go have a new one! Signed, Ellie".

[stylish267]

If i still remember cuz i watched it 2 days ago.. she wrote "Thank you for giving me a good adventure. Now go have another one! -Ellie"

[MizunoMirai]

man it was that part that made me cry like a baby when i saw it! i couldnt help but cry a lot in this movie.

[KataraxGirl]

.....................*bursts into tears*

[BeaverAru]

Aww! I'm sorry *hugs*

[Avquest2]

i was with my girlfriend when i watched this movie... i nearly burst into tears :'(

not my greatest momment :P

[LionsLamb5]

Aww, it's ok. most girls like it when guys cry every now and then.

[Avquest2]

thankss

also im a very emotional guy

:'(

[raveb0y3]

i really loved, keep going!

[musicrocksursox]

I really loved that. I especially liked how in the end when it started singing "goodbye to you" you added the clip of Carl pushing the furniture out. I really thought that fit the song well. Nice job. ^_^