I am the only one who thinks Shirley looks like a kid/teen with that hair style and color?? Great version... The only action I saw in the crowd was that one hand giving the devil horns and that 1 dude trying to clap lol .
I want some of what this crowd was on - maybe I could sleep at night.
This was a flawless performance by Shirley, I thought she was lip synching until I heard the obvious differences from the recorded version. Don't know about the band though, sounds like the music may have been playback.
she's amazin live 0_o for an instant even i tought it was playback but then you hear breathing pauses and realize it's real!!! GO BABY GO BABY GO GO!!!
maybe they were too scared by shirleys terrifying bad hair/cut choice? thank god its back to long n red! even androgeny shorter red hair was better but oh know this is scary lol LOVE garbage amd ms.manson though lol
If you pay attention , in concerts where the music is playback , the voice sounds different ...in this case you can hear her breath. Not that this is bad!! This performance of shirley was perfect!
Just because they can sound like the studio version live, doesn't mean they're lip-synching; they're a bunch of producers, and Shirley can bang it out incredibly well live, so there you go...he ain't faking.
I am the only one who thinks Shirley looks like a kid/teen with that hair style and color?? Great version... The only action I saw in the crowd was that one hand giving the devil horns and that 1 dude trying to clap lol .
ColorsBright 2 years ago
this crowd makes me wanna vomit everywhere.
SocialSLAYER 2 years ago
shirley should have just changed the lyrics making fun of the crowd they wouldnt have noticed anyways.
ghostinthefog1666 2 years ago
I want some of what this crowd was on - maybe I could sleep at night.
This was a flawless performance by Shirley, I thought she was lip synching until I heard the obvious differences from the recorded version. Don't know about the band though, sounds like the music may have been playback.
butterandcheese92 2 years ago
I love her hair! That is a real cool style on her. Not many could pull that off.
OKandNOWwhat 2 years ago
Damn, Shirley and the guys played that great and the crowd was on valium... wtf.
tjstevens74 2 years ago 8
did someone die in the crowd, or wtf
sandoval91402 2 years ago 20
Pienso que Garbage es una de las mejores bandas que existen
thehorsepower888 2 years ago 4
this song is about?
about boy or a girl?
larab995 2 years ago
Both, it's a song about a book in which a young boy often is dressed as and looks like a girl.
xSixio 2 years ago
About a transvestite .
brunooracle 2 years ago 3
crowd is LAME!
larab995 2 years ago 4
LOL @ THE CROWD,
VicViperTPS 2 years ago 3
crowd looks about 13! the band suck,shit song,love her hair.
sirenorg 2 years ago
u sucks! how deep u know bout the music? u fucking shit!
mykingmonkey 2 years ago
you obviously don't know garbage bcuz garbage rocks, you don't understand deep music.listen to only happy when it rains. and shirley is amazing.
667amtrrckr 2 years ago
thats like the most inanimate rock concert crowd I've ever seen!
overzealousarborist 2 years ago
the crowd sucks!!
81Kain 2 years ago 4
Hi ! That's pure entertainment ! Well done !
OlympicSong 2 years ago
THIS CROWD SUCKS
FallenExpert 2 years ago
very odd...fantastic vocal performance but the crowd just didn't seem into it
sardinemilkshake71 2 years ago
she's amazin live 0_o for an instant even i tought it was playback but then you hear breathing pauses and realize it's real!!! GO BABY GO BABY GO GO!!!
FairyWings88 3 years ago
Shirley rocks! and her hair lokks good on her too
tsadyan00 3 years ago 3
grande Shirley!!
miawallace312 3 years ago
crowd is dead
manuel2582 3 years ago 5
live sound too :)
miguelbaptista 3 years ago
maybe they were too scared by shirleys terrifying bad hair/cut choice? thank god its back to long n red! even androgeny shorter red hair was better but oh know this is scary lol LOVE garbage amd ms.manson though lol
tartansam 2 years ago
I was wondering the same thing where the origina video went. Instead of all the other crap they've got on youtube.
8MinutesToSunrise 3 years ago
If you pay attention , in concerts where the music is playback , the voice sounds different ...in this case you can hear her breath. Not that this is bad!! This performance of shirley was perfect!
andrea111292 3 years ago
Very good :)
KingIvailo 3 years ago
i <3 this song
blueewoman 3 years ago
i so love them!
4352297 3 years ago
Love the song, great performance, ssssoooo hot~
WyvernRuiner 3 years ago 2
great!!!!
4352297 3 years ago
this is even better than the recorded. amazing.
goldiilockkz 3 years ago 2
God, she's hot!! thks for posting!
Marklewisdes 3 years ago
Go baby go go!!
bella canzone!!
w i garbage!!
nikjoker92 3 years ago
she aint the best lookin bird on the planet but she more than makes up for it by just oozing sex appeal
CreamPie9uy 3 years ago
fuck. they're awesome live.
so rare.
GoScrewYourseIf 3 years ago 30
why rare? shes great and ever will be
newhollywoodense 3 years ago 3
she gasps for air to loud
dingle1673 3 years ago
better than to sound awful live
4352297 3 years ago
true, but i still like it :-)
pumucklinka 3 years ago
she is so great singing live (unlike other singers) I just wish she hadnt dyed her hair :( oh well still pretty xxx
MissWillows 3 years ago 2
I went to see them play when she had dyed hair, and she just WAS sex. i do prefer the red hair though.
jamesyeahbaby 3 years ago 7
Pfft Shirley made the hair look hot. Fucking excellent performance.
PALEGRE3N 3 years ago
Shirley is going overtime here! She's like singing the whole thing with no backup, even when on the CD there's two overlapping parts. Makes it hard.
EWatsonLover 3 years ago 2
i just wish i had been there to eperience the moment,,,,,amazing vibes
mrkaninkalle 4 years ago 2
Sorry to burst your bubble guys. The band is on playback with the exception of shirley.
GarbageandHorrorfan 4 years ago 4
how do u know?
grbgrockme 4 years ago
You can tell.
Shirley is the only one doing anything live up there.
GarbageandHorrorfan 3 years ago
Because Duke isn't even trying to look like he's playing the guitar live.
amazingpersonlol 3 years ago
Just because they can sound like the studio version live, doesn't mean they're lip-synching; they're a bunch of producers, and Shirley can bang it out incredibly well live, so there you go...he ain't faking.
cathoderoy 3 years ago 6
I think one of the guitarists might be playing too, but you can only hear him during the chorus.
EWatsonLover 3 years ago
amazing excellent performance
dspikey 4 years ago 4
Thks!! This is the best live version of this song-Shirley is HoT, see all band members too!!
Marklewisdes 4 years ago
great video!
thanks!
love you shirl!
cyrano7 4 years ago