@Carlit0Tit0 I know right :D Still - the way the notes are off key - it makes the song really eerie and haunting. Look up "we all have dark days" by a user named "mm". AWESOME.
@nirewolf0 ironically, you can hear the birds and the sound of the outside while he's playing the piano, which makes you wonder if they recorded this outdoors.
the ending sounds like a foresty beach with a mixture of someone spraying febreze inside. thats genius. a pure feeling of indoors and outdoors at the same time practically corresponding with each other. WOW. thats just genius. thats a beautiful way to end the album. im just, wow. thats brilliant. who can do that? has anyone ever thought of trying to illustrate a feeling of being "in-between doors"? of course a fantastic musician like reznor did
@RetardedAndRandomTV actually, there were two bonus ghosts, Ghosts 37 and 38. The 38 is sort of a remix to demon seed and the other one is quite disturbing actually.
This probably gonna scare y'all a lil but to me it does sound like a ghost story of a little girl a beautiful little girl who had an happy life ended in cold blood. her ghost lingers and the piano is out of tune cause she is so confused on why this world is so cruel even to a small child.
Arguably the best track (along with Ghosts I-I) off the album. "Ghosts I-IV" is arguably the best thing Reznor has publically released to date; along with "The Fragile".
We need more instrumental albums such as Ghosts these days - the method of speaking to listeners through notes alone seemed to have left music after classical music faded from common popularity, and it's something we need back in the music of culture.
agreed! when a lot of people these days say they like music what they really mean is they like words with music. music like this is much more capable that words to convey emotion
@XXdarktheifXX Already have done a while ago my good man, wonderful instrumental peices. Any idea what Mogwai's like? Been told to have a look at them for similar reasons, not quite got round to it.
This is the most beautiful piece of art I have been lucky enough to be a witness to. So introspective, it invokes so many feelings at once honestly it brings a tear to my eye, it reminds me of everything I have ever loved, a calming feeling came over me the first time I listened to this, right when it started sunlight came out of the clouds and illuminated my room with a golden atmosphere... perfect. What an ending to ghosts.... all i have to say is simply magnificent THANK YOU TRENT
To: mypassionfruit From: Akirran WOW!! Thank you for such a beautiful gift. I don't know if Trent&company ever cruises by You Tube, but if so they should invite you over for some video game and autographs. Today you just made a difference in my life. Thank you.
...like an unopened letter, thrown away...
what's inside, is left to be mystery...
Sephiirah 1 day ago in playlist Nine Inch Nails
The end of the world......aftermath.......
hundboi 1 month ago
The off key notes add a special something to this.
It's stunningly beautiful, and very haunting. It's amazing what simplicity can do.
AkanemaruNayuchi 1 month ago
Imagine walking through an abandoned asylum and listening to this. That's pure fear right there.
vanellawii 2 months ago
@vanellawii not really. that would be awesome :D
Carlit0Tit0 1 month ago
@Carlit0Tit0 I know right :D Still - the way the notes are off key - it makes the song really eerie and haunting. Look up "we all have dark days" by a user named "mm". AWESOME.
vanellawii 1 month ago
sounds little like anniversal of an interesting event of deftones
but much better :)
kamiljakubjamroziak 3 months ago
Holy fucking shit, saving up for the 75 dollar limited edition. This is sex to my ears.
phosphor112 3 months ago
piano is out of tune in some parts and in other is ok?
Strange though
andbluesky 4 months ago
@andbluesky well trent reznor doesnt care he said it himself "this isnt music its feel"
rikuXelric 3 months ago in playlist nin ghosts
If only I could control my dreams , I swear, I do this song as a soundtrack ,
grietuke 4 months ago 2
This should be in Minecraft.
deibi23 4 months ago
thank you for uploading this
MagicStationWagon 7 months ago
I'm pretty sure even Mozart will like this
attackman456 8 months ago
Thumbs up if this makes you want to play minecraft
SmittyWerbenjagorman 8 months ago
@SmittyWerbenjagorman no
Siberian16 7 months ago
sitting on your back porch at night in the summertime, watching the fireflies...
such a beautiful, lonely song
nirewolf0 10 months ago 2
@nirewolf0 i hear that! the serenity under the night sky so divine smokin a j [:
rath223 7 months ago
@nirewolf0 ironically, you can hear the birds and the sound of the outside while he's playing the piano, which makes you wonder if they recorded this outdoors.
somethingguy912 6 months ago
similar to ghosts 1..
ExpertiseGamer 10 months ago
this is my favorite one!
ImJasonForever 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if you enjoy ghosts you should give my song a listen:
watch?v=FqphyhJuS8Y
hhlium 1 year ago
the ending sounds like a foresty beach with a mixture of someone spraying febreze inside. thats genius. a pure feeling of indoors and outdoors at the same time practically corresponding with each other. WOW. thats just genius. thats a beautiful way to end the album. im just, wow. thats brilliant. who can do that? has anyone ever thought of trying to illustrate a feeling of being "in-between doors"? of course a fantastic musician like reznor did
RetardedAndRandomTV 1 year ago
@RetardedAndRandomTV actually, there were two bonus ghosts, Ghosts 37 and 38. The 38 is sort of a remix to demon seed and the other one is quite disturbing actually.
somethingguy912 6 months ago
ive been listening through all 36 of these songs and I just new that when I got to 36 its would be a sad piano song.
eammafan1 1 year ago
I absolutely lovee this song. I don't know why. It's just....wow. I love it.
RhymesWithMorgan 1 year ago 2
pleasant sounds.....
but boring imfho
12345652180 1 year ago
simply beautiful.
0rajjr0 1 year ago
good song for a public restroom
the awkwardness would kill everyone inside
Palhota 1 year ago
FYI... The piano is ACTUALLY IN TUNE. It's tuned to 19 EDO, not 12.
slick00x 1 year ago
@slick00x idc
log7871 1 year ago
This probably gonna scare y'all a lil but to me it does sound like a ghost story of a little girl a beautiful little girl who had an happy life ended in cold blood. her ghost lingers and the piano is out of tune cause she is so confused on why this world is so cruel even to a small child.
log7871 1 year ago
@log7871 wow -_-
FlameingAlchemistt 1 year ago
Great end for great album
souleaterEMS 1 year ago
this is the most soft but powerful song on the album, simply stands above the rest and speaks to me the most
carlosspiceyweener54 1 year ago 2
@carlosspiceyweener54 you're not alone; this and Ghosts I-I (the first track off the album) ranks to be two of the best songs off the album.
JesusCristo2002 1 year ago
This album, this track specifically, is so beautiful it brings tears to my eyes.
PKemmerich 1 year ago
All these are shitty quality, I have the CD and it's quality is actually good. You guys should really get it.
eNergizer361 2 years ago 33
it scares me lol
gaywizzy 2 years ago
Arguably the best track (along with Ghosts I-I) off the album. "Ghosts I-IV" is arguably the best thing Reznor has publically released to date; along with "The Fragile".
JesusCristo2002 2 years ago 5
i know that the sound is for effect but it sounds horrible compared to a properly tuned piano
xTobys16 2 years ago
the audio messed up
coldfront999 2 years ago
piano is a bit out of tune
dsyglym 2 years ago
Yeah, I noticed that too.
jim30333 2 years ago
It's on purpose
xCherryPieXx 2 years ago
Are all of the songs on Ghosts this quality?
Johnnycakes9999 2 years ago
I think it's for effect...
Blade3327 2 years ago
No they're not, they sound waay better on CD.
ChristinaMagma 2 years ago 3
NIN isnt really my thing, but i really like this album
moop57 2 years ago 3
We need more instrumental albums such as Ghosts these days - the method of speaking to listeners through notes alone seemed to have left music after classical music faded from common popularity, and it's something we need back in the music of culture.
Preddykins 2 years ago 57
agreed! when a lot of people these days say they like music what they really mean is they like words with music. music like this is much more capable that words to convey emotion
saladlegs 2 years ago 2
Absolutely.
m3talmilitia15 2 years ago
@Preddykins Look up Godspeed you! Black emporer. They are an amazing Post rock group.
XXdarktheifXX 1 year ago
@XXdarktheifXX Already have done a while ago my good man, wonderful instrumental peices. Any idea what Mogwai's like? Been told to have a look at them for similar reasons, not quite got round to it.
Preddykins 1 year ago
@Preddykins YES. I Love Beethoven
ERRORxakaRay 1 year ago
@Preddykins Do think lyrics kinda get in the way sometimes. Like they're being pretentious or something. You know what I mean?
KedViper 1 year ago
@Preddykins especially with the modern creativity we have today
RetardedAndRandomTV 1 year ago
@Preddykins This is very true. I would also like to see Trent do another instrumental album.
PearlJammer07 1 year ago
@Preddykins that would be nice but people today are either to stupid or to closed minded
thesalmonistight 10 months ago 2
@Preddykins So true
DarkGreenGadget 6 months ago in playlist NIN - Ghosts I-IV
@Preddykins look towards boards of canada, ahpex twin, autechre....you'll find what you're looking for.
Dakoder 2 weeks ago
@Preddykins Bacteria are the only organisms left with culture.
TheNightsMoon 1 week ago
I love this
lizXoX2008 3 years ago 2
there is something in this song i just couldn't pick up... it made me feel there's some untold story behind it...
it's really beautiful, thank you for uploading it...
and trent, thank you too for making a beautiful piece of art...
blackavani 3 years ago 3
I love the fact that there is no words yet I still feel it like there is, maybe I'm crazy but this talks to me everytime I hear it.
shinunicron 3 years ago 3
This kinda music is true art!
It adds so much to atmosphere and immersion, especially to video games and home listening!
KillingSpreeFreesBee 3 years ago
This is the most beautiful piece of art I have been lucky enough to be a witness to. So introspective, it invokes so many feelings at once honestly it brings a tear to my eye, it reminds me of everything I have ever loved, a calming feeling came over me the first time I listened to this, right when it started sunlight came out of the clouds and illuminated my room with a golden atmosphere... perfect. What an ending to ghosts.... all i have to say is simply magnificent THANK YOU TRENT
swisher1248 3 years ago 5
understand what ?
chunchilin 3 years ago
what is it all about :P
TourniQueTQ 3 years ago
and what is it about?
Valholm 3 years ago
it makes me think.. and understand
thank you
TourniQueTQ 3 years ago
all ghosts are in my favorites
i cant stop listen
the best album untill now
i came from rap but this was i'm lookin for
eniomanos 3 years ago
i see only a lot of ass in your favs, lol. :P
Valholm 3 years ago
good work trent!
gentoodaemon 4 years ago 2
This song reminds me of Ripe [With Decay] and Another Version of the Truth, except put together.
Lukaara 4 years ago 2
trent is a mastermind, he is what we need in out lives, real music for our soul
clarad001 4 years ago 5
This song remindes me of Another Version Of The Truth. There are some commonalities,but I don't know what they are. Anyway, great song!
heluna 4 years ago 4
To: mypassionfruit From: Akirran WOW!! Thank you for such a beautiful gift. I don't know if Trent&company ever cruises by You Tube, but if so they should invite you over for some video game and autographs. Today you just made a difference in my life. Thank you.
Akirran 4 years ago
what a beautiful gift NIN has given us all
pandazenian 4 years ago 7