Added: 4 years ago
From: Urgelt
Views: 94,367
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (296)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • th wrld's mde fresh w flng sno bt th wds r drk 'n dp 'n lo, wch pth 2 tk? I thk i no, th 1 tht lds to hearth's swt glo~whr hrts r lit n Mithric glo! Frost read for JFK's inauguration right? I remember his hand trembling like autumn's rustling leaves or was it his papers? If I'm recalling this correctly his pages flew away & he recited another poem from memory & not the one he had prepared? Perfect for the Winter Solstice, '...the darkest evening of the year. We are all tested in such a way...

  • Omg i hade to say this in front of my class

  • We had to SING this in our Chorus

  • Whose woods these are I think I know. His house is in the village though; He will not see me stopping here To watch his woods fill up with snow. My little horse must think it queer To stop without a farmhouse near Between the woods and frozen lake The darkest evening of the year. He gives his harness bells a shake To ask if there is some mistake. The only other sound's the sweep Of easy wind and downy flake. The woods are lovely, dark and deep. But I have promises to keep,
  • well, well done. I very much enjoy your way of reading poems with sound effects.

  • /watch?v=XODZV1fvWzA

  • Just a clarification for those who read comments: this isn't a spam link, it's a music video which borrows my voice reading Robert Frost's poem. Generally, I permit creative re-use of my copyrighted videos so long as credit is given and a link to the original content is furnished. Meidrexx is in compliance.

    It's a nice and relaxing video, check it out.

  • omg i love this!

  • a passage in life... the struggle between desire and reason.

    beautiful poem

  • what a beautiful video

    

  • Thank you, so very well done and images of wonder! :)

  • Did you hear me butterfly? Miles to go before you sleep

  • I love the "flavor" i shall call it, that your voice puts into the poem, it completes the poem and the pictures are wonderful.

  • I love your voice in this. It adds the perfect touch to the sound effects. Lovely video of a great poem :)

  • When will you do some more videos, Urgelt?

  • You did a great job putting this together. Thanks for sharing!

  • Eh. Frost is well-known for subtlety, so I would be the last to assert that I know all that was intended by him in this poem.

    Still, I'm skeptical of your interpretation. I took this poem to be entirely human in its scope, and I most assuredly do not see a rational connection between poem, wild mustangs, Congress, and the violent actions of an obvious paranoid schizophrenic.

  • @etbella3

    You're not going to convince many people with that kind of rhetoric. People aren't thinking about the plight of the mustangs now, they're thinking about how you sounded callous towards Congresswoman Giffords.

  • @etbella3 its people like you that killed poetry for todays youth

  • @etbella3 Seems to be a message about life and death to put it simply. The woods represent the beauty of death and God. The owner of the woods is God, his house in the village is presumably a church. The horse represents all animals aside from Man, who only think of necessity in life and never eternity. The traveler I might interpret as someone who had just had a near-death experience or perhaps had been contemplating suicide but has realized he has a purpose to fulfill in life before dying.

  • @SuperDave123123 That is not a good reading of the poem. You seem to be taking the way YOU view the world and assuming that is the way the world is or the way Frost saw the world. Read what is on the page; there is nothing to suggest he is referring to God or a church. The narrator MAY be contemplating suicide (And miles to go before I sleep), but he may also considering just leaving society in general and doing the Henry David Thoreau thing.

  • I always think of this poem on Christmas Eve.

  • this is fantastic & makes me so happy!

  • So beautiful thanks for posting

  • oooh this is fabulous, thank you for putting it together!

  • Beautifully done, with obvious care and love. Warmest congratulations.

  • i love this poem!

  • he sounds like santa taking a break before he has to go around the world (And miles to go before i sleep)

  • @lebronfan705 How adorable is your comment?? I give that a thumbs up..

    love this poem.... love your insight... Love this vid..

  • @karmakomodia my little cousin suggested the idea because it reminded him of christmas

  • beautiful beyond belief

    the wording of a traveling man

    that such a scene can be relief-

    these deep stares of a poet's pan

    and what few pictures underneath

    show low-filled woods under the words

    and though he stood so still and brief

    and left the white night undisturbed

    he left no smile, nod or grief

    and left his story to be stirred

  • @tattoofthesun My your reply seems as Poetic as Frosts :-)

  • @allah998 :) i thank ye

  • THIS IS BEAUTIFUL BEYOND BELIEF

  • Very nice and appropriate presentation. Enjoyed the photography

  • it makes chilly listening - you can feel the cold - and so beautifully, achingly beautifully presented with wonderful photos and horse's bells....

    LOVE THIS - thank you so much for this beauty!

    I think we should listen also to another tube here: watch?v=Xh0J-bP5ClE

    there is SO much beauty in all those related and unrelated works!

  • You are one Amazing Guy.

    Not only did i like this poem but your nice soothing Voice made me relax and the sounds of the snow hitting the leaves. :-)

    God Bless You. Be Well :-)

  • This is my favorite poem of all time. So much so, that I have it tattooed on my feet. Thanks for the wonderful reading.

  • The last two lines always get to me, I want him to be free in the woods, but his promises keep him from it. Great job on really taking the time to capture the mood. This is a slow somber poem, and your pacing was perfect for the tone.

  • The last two lines always get to me, I want him to be free in the woods, but his promises keep him from it. Great job on really taking the time to capture the mood. This is a slow somber poem, and your pacing was perfect for the tone.

  • Many thanks Urgelt . Beautifully done!

    My favourite line is "The only other sounds the sweep of easy wind and downy flake" A teacher I was very fond of once pointed out to me that the repeated "ss" sounds in the line is the sound of the wind itself! I've always thought that was wonderful and a reminder that this seemingly "easy" poem is far more complex than it first appears.

  • This was very lovely. I just closed my eyes and listened. Thank you!

  • Comment removed

  • Dreamcatcher brought me here

  • I have listened your presentation of this piece many times... it is my favorite interpreatation above all... even the author's own words do match my love of your cadence falling through these images delighting the eyes and the soundscape enchanting the ears...

  • beautiful poem about contemplating suicide

  • This is such a beautiful poem, by far my favourite. I love the gentle atmosphere and genre of this peice.

  • I attended a Robert Frost reading many years ago, in Grand Rapids, MI. After the rather pompous introduction by a local business official, showing off his literary knowledge, Frost took the podium and said: "I can see by your hand-clapping that the introduction is over, so I will turn on my hearing aid." That totally set the tone. A great poet, and a subtle man.

  • anyone knows who has copyright of the poem?

  • I believe all copyrights for the poem have expired. It's in the public domain.

  • @Urgelt i think actually it expires in 2038.

  • The web site Old Poetry (a search engine can turn up the address) specializes in presenting the full text of poetry which is no longer protected under copyright, according to US law.

    I'm relying on their expertise to keep me out of hot water, since I'm not an expert in copyright laws.

  • @Urgelt ah well i read in some CD sleeve notes for Sleep that Frost's estate refused to allow the poem to be connected to Whitacre's setting, and so he had to commission someone to write some new lyrics. so it seems Frost's estate still have some authority to wield, and that they have a bad taste in music.

  • Some of Mr. Frost's poetry may still be under copyright - the poems he wrote later in life.

    Every year that goes by, I imagine that more of them fall into the public domain.

    Sorting all of that out and keeping current on the legal status of his body of work is a larger task than I care to pursue, personally.  Which is the reason I rely on the web site Old Poetry to sort out which is, and which is not, in the public domain at any particular moment.

  • @Urgelt ah well i read in some CD sleeve notes for Sleep that Frost's estate refused to allow the poem to be connected to Whitacre's setting, and so he had to commission someone to write some new lyrics. so it seems Frost's estate still have some authority to wield, and that they have a bad taste in music.

  • @soCtra

    yes,Urgelt is right; you can just search for lyrics and you'll find the words - beautiful!

  • Such an inspiration!

  • I really like wgat you are doing so i subscribed

  • whose woods these are i think i know his house is in the village though he will not see me stopping here tho watch his woods fill up with snow my little horse must think it queer to stop without a farmhouse near between the wood and frozen lake the darkest evening of the year he gives his harness bells a shake to ask if there is some mistake the only other sounds the sweep of easy wind and downey flake the woods are lovley dark and deep but i have promises too keep ...
  • Beautifully well done. Your voice fits the mood very well and the photos and crunching tread are very appropriate.. Thanks for posting.

  • i used to sit on my mother's lap and she would read out of this poem book we had. this was always my favorite poem she would read

  • Very nicely done.

    I've loved this poem for, OMG, nearly half a century!

    Refreshing to hear more than the famous 4 lines.

    Evocative background and images.

  • ..and miles to go before i sleep.

  • my favorite poem of all time.thanks for posting!

  • Excellent.

    You really captured it.

    The strong desire to walk away from it all.

    The longing of the human soul to get out.

    Thank you for creating this.

  • I can recite this

  • Thank you for creating such a beautiful presentation of this Frost classic. You did an outstanding work! Frost is my favorite poet in the English Language. (In Spanish it is Pablo Neruda....)

  • You have excellent taste!

  • This poem's meaningful for me in that it's my mother's favourite poem, one that she quotes all the time.

  • Nicely done; thank you.

  • Beautiful. Just beautiful.

  • i have always loved this poem you have really added to it nicely with the lovely winter vid and your reading of it. lovely.

  • An especially powerful evocation of this Frost classic.

    Best wishes for your blessings this Christmas.

  • I loved this very much....

    I love this poem so much... and you did a great job in making this!!!!

    GREAT JOB!

    :-D

  • Bliss. Thank-you

  • I cried. Frost would be honored I am sure at your interpretation of his beautiful words, PERFECTION! Than you.

  • Sounds beautiful dude *.*

    5/5

  • Great version of one of my favourite poems.

    This, along with Frost`s `The Good Hours`, really express everything I love about winter

  • This video and this poem means a lot to me right now.

    Thank's for making it. You did a great job.

  • I enjoy hearing what you have to say, Urgelt. This is my favorite poem by Frost...you read it well.

  • I"m sure Mr. Frost would have said, "Yeah, I like his version, I think!" And his comment would have been that short and that succinct:) Cheers and good job!

  • Really nice video I think, it really adds to the poem, one could imagine actually being there. The strange affection I have for snow, combined with this beautiful poem and the evocative imagery provided here is a treat for my senses. Could have done without the extended credits though.

  • Shame on you for disabling embedding and hiding beauty.

  • It wasn't an easy decision. A fair number of people asked me to allow embedding.

    What decided me, finally, was this: people who view my videos on other sites will not see comments, nor be in a position to contribute their own.

    I came here for the conversations, not to promote myself in public.

  • Well, yes, but please rethink it, because I assure you when I see true art and beauty on a site, I almost always click through to see what else the person has done. Many people do that surely. Congratulations at any rate.

  • Amazing work my friend!

  • The little patch of hell I live in has been in the high 80s and high 90s since April. Your beautiful video helps to keep me going.

  • Well read. Love your voice and it really connects with the landscape I can visualise when it is read out. I found the longer pauses a bit too long and the sound fx aren't very necessary - just your voice and it speaks volumes. Thanks for uploading.

  • pprrrr, Where I live it is 98%, and I feel the cold breeze coming from a digital screen. I begin to feel my cold feet beg, for a warm blanket in a 98%.

  • Thanks. I'm not an avid poetry fan but I do turn a verse or two now and then. I'm in New Mexico when I heard saw/heard your video I was in my office at my desk peering out the window into the deserts scorching heat, I found the video so refreshing it inspired me. I have not lived around snow for quite awhile we get it here, always in the mountains and occasionally here in the valley. I grew up in Indiana and the sound of squeaky foot steps in the snow made me think of my childhood, I thank u. :)

  • Winter forest sleeps

    Gentle snow falls on my desk

    Arid summer day

  • Very nice, Seamus.

    I don't know if Mr. Frost would have been flattered or not. Perhaps not. But it's my judgment he ought to have been, had his fans responded thus to his poetry when he lived.

  • You are simply amazing ! Robert Frost is one of my all time favorite poets.Even though I am only 17 years old I want to be a poet someday,any advice that you could give me to help me get started?

  • Writing poetry is easy.

    Writing good poetry is hard.

    Take courses and workshops. Cultivate friends who share your interest. Read, read, read... discover which poets speak to your soul, and figure out how they did it.

    And, of course, compose your own. Learn how to tell if what you wrote is compact, insightful, moving, original. Ruthlessly discard your rejects.

    At the end of all that, you may or may not be a good poet. But you'll sure know a lot about how hard it is to write a good poem.

  • This video is simply fantastic. This is among my very favorite poems, and this reading of it trumps all others that I have heard. I thank you wholeheartedly for recording this, and I fully intend on perusing more of your videos.

  • Bravo! You really made this brilliant poem shine to its best!

  • hey do u know any secrets to memorizing things xan u tell me plz XD

  • Well, I hate memorizing as much as you do. I didn't memorize the materials I presented on YouTube; I read them from a script.

    My advice? Break it down into two line groupings. Read each grouping aloud over and over. Reading aloud and repetition will get you there.

  • thank u so much man ohh i got a b for reciting i choked along the poem and thnxs 4 the advice

  • Hey, a "B" for doing something you hate is good!

    Now, we need to take that teacher aside and whisper: memorization isn't learning. How about, instead, teaching how to interpret poetry?

  • yeah that what we r doing learning how to interpret poetry and yes all i learned was a poem

  • i have to learn recite this by tommorrow ..fuckin lame in tryin every possible way to memo it buts its yes my teacher is in luv wit Robert frost and shes gonna make us memo the raven i hate memorizing dammit but you have a memorizing vioce so thats pretty cewl and makes it easier to learn

  • sir, this is a delicious, crunchy cold salad of sound. I'm thoroughly enjoying your channel!

  • What a wonderfully poetic expression!

  • im from pakistan.there was my teachr during my schl life.and ths poem was in my course n when my teachr use to gve lcture about ths poem i really lovd this poem with my teachrs method also.

  • hey im doing a final essay abut poems and i love this one i was wondering if this is the orginal robert frost poem

  • Yes.

    If you expand the text box you'll find a link to this poem on the Old Poetry web site. I have not changed any of the words.

  • Bravo! Beautiful! Well done!

    Thank you for posting this. I thought Western Civilization was no longer to be found anywhere out there...

  • I *would* have said it was on life support. But the friendly reception to poetry readings on YouTube suggests otherwise.

    Thanks for your comment, Laz.

  • Thank You Urgelt for this wonderful post. I come back and view it from time to time. I find it very calming! Peace and love to you!

  • I'm glad you find it calming, Rspae. That's exactly how Robert Frost's exquisite poem strikes me, too.

    Thank you for your lovely comment.

  • Well-done.

    Is Frost your favorite poem?

  • * poet *

  • One of my favorites, certainly. I've never really settled on a single favorite.

  • Scenes of winter mixing with white snow there are beautiful. Robert Frost wrote "And miles to go before I sleep," How his used words [deep meaning]

    Thanks to posted this video.

    Dalat Vietnam May 28, 2009

  • I grew up in Michigan. When it snowed heavily, it was like a great blanket covering over all flaws, as though the world were made new again, Eden returned.

    Many poets have tried to capture that feeling, but none so well as Robert Frost, I think.

  • Isn't this poem about Robert Frost's

    overcome of the thoughts of suicide?

  • On one level, it is, certainly. The deep, dark woods symbolize death.

    This isn't about a youthful, impulsive wrist-slasher, though. I get the feeling the speaker is old and feeling the burdens of his age. The death he contemplates isn't frightening, but peaceful, even beautiful. And he'll get around to it. He just has to finish the journey of his life first.

    Good advice, if you ask me.

  • mark Frost words, thou cold they are not

    on a path along the sun I walk

    my Revenge Of Birth, Existence thou you know it, be a Ratinal Token.

    R O B E R T Frost, his name was

    Shall we repeat the line?

    Miles we all have to go before sleep

    MIles we all have to go before sleep

    So the prostitute next door can stfu and wait, because we're not sleepy yet. Live on

  • Death as a prostitute next door... heh. I get synesthesia just contemplating that image next to Frost's gentler seduction.

    Only a poet can so thoroughly confound with words.

    Careful where you point that thing; I think it's loaded.

  • That was just beautiful!!! I'm sitting here on a very warm, sunny day in Southern California in a pair of shorts and light tshirt...watching this and hearing the "crunch" of the snow..I had to put on a long sleeve shirt and socks!!! lol. GREAT IMAGERY!!!

    The reader has a very soothing voice...perfect!

  • wow, it's gorgeous...I'm familiar with the poem, and you do a lovely job reading it:)

  • Are you Santa Claus?

  • I love this. What a beautiful little video!

  • great job! i love this poem its so lovely.

  • your so awesome that i wana higher u to read me a poem every night before i go to bed :]

  • we sang this in a song for my quior itz waz my favorite now i love to listen to it =D

  • I'm glad, Erica.

  • A true master it takes to evoke such emotion with so few words...

  • Agreed!

  • There is something about looking at a snowy landscape that enchants me. I love the snow. The sounds and the reading were just as enchanting as the photos used. Wonderful video! Thank you.

  • I'm glad you enjoyed it, Rhonda9.

  • beautiful poem. I have to write an 1500 essay on this poem, wish me good luck!

  • I will wish you good luck, then.

    And good enjoyment, too. It's a wonderful poem to analyze.

  • I love this poem. Read it 40 years ago..it's even more magical now..

  • Me, too. It's beautiful, with dark undertones and even a hint of the heroic. Frost was truly a master.

  • thank you

  • Very nice. You would make a good story teller.

  • That was wonderful. Thank you, Urgelt.

  • i cannot hear the sound at all

  • Hmm, it's working on my computer.

  • Excelent visiuals, I think im doing this poem for poetry out loud haha

  • Nice pictures. Great reading. Thanks.

  • Nicely presented.

    I've always found this to be an extremely evocative poem.

    Thanks for the pleasure of hearing (and seeing) it "your way".

  • Hey Urgelt, have you ever heard of The Moth? Its a national group of story tellers and I think you would be perfect for that sort of thing. They're on iTunes and have a website if you're interested.

  • Interesting group. No, I hadn't heard of them, but I visited their web site at your suggestion.

    My videos thrust in a different direction. I'm not telling original stories, just narrating existing expired-copyright works. Or presenting original essays of my own (which aren't truly stories; more like opinion pieces).

  • how can I get this on an mp3? I would listen to this over and over again.

  • Drop me a note and include your e-mail address, and I will have an mp3 delivered to you.

  • Your images and Frost's prose helped me make it though another horrible Florida summer. Thanks to both of you.

  • Right about now, Florida's summer heat would feel pretty good, I think!

  • this is my all time favorite poem

  • It's a good 'un, true enough.

  • Our school sang this as a Christmas carol

  • i had to memorize this song at school and i hated it. but after i heard you say site it, its one of my favorites!

  • I never much enjoyed memorizing, either.

    Fortunately, there is more to a good poem than the requirement to memorize it.

  • very true

  • hey i never heard your age i watched all vids i can see some stuff from schizophrenia point of view i love these vids i love science i love you vids

  • I'm 56.

    I don't know much about schizophrenia, I'm afraid.

    Glad you enjoyed the videos, Rob.

  • Yeam these videos are truly amazing,

    I have watched every one and i think we all have a lot to gain from them

  • .....beautiful...Thank you, Urgelt. ....Thank you, Frost. And for our gifts in life, thank you Lord.

  • This was amazing.

    5/5 for sure.

    ive watch a few of your videos, they are neat, they really open the mind.

  • Very well made video, the sound effects, photographs and voice over blend to create a great story...well done!

  • I really like this video. It is so well done, Urgelt. Nice ambiance. Excellent!

  • Thank you, Urgelt. Peace and happiness to you, too. Hey, what about a little Whitman?  I'd love to hear you do Crossing Brooklyn Ferry.

  • The impact few words can make.

    Im speechless

  • Robert Frost sure knew how to throw together a few words, that's for sure.

  • well done... man.. well done

  • Thanks, SB.

  • There is such grandeur in stillness.

  • Indeed there is, Belloi.

  • i'm getting chilly- I've been in these woods in winter. Wonderful reading.

  • Thanks, Peg, I'm pleased you liked it.

  • One of my all-time favorites, this is just lovely. It's about 90 degrees here and it's only 8 a.m. so this video is not only relaxing but mentally puts me in another place entirely. I just love this. Well done.

  • That's part of Robert Frost's genius, agreed. He could change your mood with a few lines, and he could take you so solidly into an imagined scene that you can feel the cold prick of a snowflake landing on your wrist.

    If that doesn't beat the heat, you could always run through the sprinkler a few times. :-)

  • I had never heard this piece of poetry before viewing this video, but I have taken a strong liking to the piece.

    It is very unassuming and unpretentious, and that is excellent. Too many poems "try too hard", but this one simply... is. Makes little sense, I'm know, but the point remains: lovely poem! Excellent reading!