melina is still a wrestler unlike the other wwe divas who retired, TNA will pick her up soon but hopefully wwe realizes they need her!! Melina > any diva today
Candice's hard work payed off big time...too bad beth had to injure her clavacle...I wanted her to be a 2 time champ....Im glad candice actually earned the title unlike people only having to win one match to get a title shot..
@8Baller1000 mais ka ba??? kasi napaka bobo mo.kawawa ka naman.hindi ka pinalaki ng maayos ng magulang mo.tignan mo kung gaano kang kabobo ngayon.hahahahahaha.wala kang magandang kinabukasan.
@8Baller1000 ok.just a few words i like to share.this may be a bit long so bear with me.i was expressing my opinion.this is what i do.once a hater always a hater.now.when some piglet talk smack about myself.and gets bothered by the fact that i just shared my opinion.you can go eat another meatball and stay the fuck away from me.MIND YOUR OWN LIFE.AND I WILL DO THE SAME.get a life you beach whale.and stop with the gay talk cause fuck i see right through you.
@8Baller1000 and your just pissed cause the rest of us you tried to throw under the bus haven't gained 80 pounds.so happy trails you obvious troll.your just a unwanted moron.I'll be happy living my life while laughing at your poor attempts to make others feel bad.you make yourself look so foolish talking bad about others.get some self confidence.and maybe a diet.you unwanted moron.and don't even think about replying.cause this will be the last minute wasting my time teaching you a lesson.LOL BYE
@spongebob12335 LOL i didnt even bother reading ur paragraphs. get a life faggot and what are you 5? thats the saddest attempt to put someone down ive ever heard LOL wow! you really are a spongebob
@8Baller1000 i know i wasn't supposed to reply but.i do have a life.lol.you on the other hand who needs to get a life and your the faggot.i don't even know what your problem is.i never did anything to you.i think you need to bother somebody else.the one who is defenseless.anyway like i said before mind your own life and i will do the same.anyway just stay the fuck away from me,you unwanted moron.
@tito27l i'm not trying 2 disrespect u or anything ,i'm just telling u that trish stratus could always wrestle,at the beginning of her career she was the best diva wrestler besides Lita n Chyna
melina is a great wrestler one of the best in current wwe along with beth and michelle maccoll mickie is also great but she got release!!! AND THIS CHAMPIONSHIP WAS SCRIPTED SO THATS THE ONLY WAY CANDICE WON
i love how they lillian dint came to announce none of the matches until the end of candice run to the tittle it was only the guy i for got his name it was a nice fued
@qwertyuiopz123 And the powerslam worked only because Melina had the good sense to jump into Candice's arms instead of relying on Candice to lift her into the move (because that would have been a massive fail).
she did one episode of hotel erotica which is soft porn. have you ever seen it??? they barely touch each other and the actors dont actually have sex. but i still love melina though .i miss candice
Do you even know how fucked up you are? Candice wanted to and was improving. It's sad how people like you don't believe in second chances. Karma's going to kick you in the ass.
I love them both but Melina's the better wrestler.
And daisyrulz000, you're right ! Half of the divas can't wrestle. Look at Maria, Kelly Kelly, Bella twins, Layla .. they can't ! I want good wrestlers like Trish, Chyna, Jazz etc. back !
@XMariaKanellisFanX NO MELINA SAYS THAT SHE WOULD NEVER POSE BECAUSE YOU DONT NEED TO BE NAKED TO POSE PRETTY SHE WANTS TO LEAVE SOMETHING FOR THE IMAGINATION
@crembie It depends on the scripted fight on how good the one or the other girl looks so its not nessecarily their skills that are bad but rather the scripting. I admit that ashley was sloppy in performance and that kelly kelly is using only like 5 moves only. All the other girls mentioned though can wrestle very good (including the bellas in match they get to show their real skills).
candice is horrible. she bloches all her moves. Melina doesn not look like a drag queen. You guys just vote for candice because you thinks shes hot. Looks does not matter when it comes to wrestling.
7:03 best moment of the video. Seeing Candice tears make one know that she want a serious carrer and no more modeling. Begining of a new era started her.
People like Candice, Christy, maria came into the WWE with no training, and became some of the best entertainers. I love Candice and i am proud of her. She is sexy and she can kick ass and still look like a hottie. Candice is the perfect woman. Love Candice
i heard candice will be a special referee to the upcoming march raw event between melina vs beth for women's championship. i think somethings gonna happen and it might be Candice's heel turn. She might be in wrestmania 25..
Candice make the critics eat their word by wining the championship. Also prove that women could pose for playboy at the same tame be a goo wrestler. I admire her for that.
Lol. KELLY have Candice old Music and old attires.
I think Melina should have won this match and WWE would have built Candice up as a credible & serious competitor before winning the belt, that is the mistake they made with Candice. They rushed it.
Dont get me wrong, I Love Candice, she has great heart, fight, potential & passion, but she just wasnt exposed enough as a top diva contender to hold the belt.
That is why the fans have pushed her away... Unfortunetlyy. I would love to see Candice built up better and rightfully holding the belt.
yea i love candice too, but they shoulda built her up as a competitor b4 they gave her the belt, because even though candice has been around for about 4 yrs it wasnt til about a year ago that she decided to train more, its the same mistake theyre making with maryse
melina is still a wrestler unlike the other wwe divas who retired, TNA will pick her up soon but hopefully wwe realizes they need her!! Melina > any diva today
8Baller1000 1 month ago
Candice's hard work payed off big time...too bad beth had to injure her clavacle...I wanted her to be a 2 time champ....Im glad candice actually earned the title unlike people only having to win one match to get a title shot..
HIPPOSRFAT81 1 month ago
GOOD JOB CANDICEE HARD WORK PAYS OFF
candyswirl1 1 month ago
i like the headbutt, melina is the best
xavideco92 2 months ago
i hate you candice
Diva4Speed 2 months ago
But after all the comments i realized everyone wanted melina to win
167kinggam 3 months ago
She was a better heel from 2001 to 2007 but not in 2011 her attitude is too but whatever 2001 2011 shes still a great diva
167kinggam 3 months ago
Maria and candice were the crappiest divas around the womensdivision that time. Melina god I miss melina. SHe was a great heel.
MyXtreme21 3 months ago
Good Fight Good Fight
deshanell123 3 months ago
nice figth
cvharbor 4 months ago
That was one of my favorite Melina attire. And those puffyboots was so original and fit in perfectly with her gimmick.
jungle10ful 5 months ago
Aww melina lost she is best !!!
wwemelinafanforever 6 months ago 2
I called dat
Go daddy Arm drop
Allstar1862755 6 months ago
Comment removed
Allstar1862755 6 months ago
the glorious days when melina was champ (:
yannickTheGreat 7 months ago
i dont see how you can dislike melina. she is the definition of what a true wwe diva is. and she is hard working
TheTwistedMagician 7 months ago
I am so sad that Melena loose
Guitarherofreak6487 7 months ago
I was shocked 2.
CrossMyMind4u 8 months ago
melina Dominated this match , how could she loose ! :'(
yannickTheGreat 8 months ago
Melina is so flexibel, powerfull and sexy diva.
1995Diogomarques 8 months ago
melina is more victoria's secret quality not playboy
abbe347 8 months ago
melina is the best=*
lovemelinanavaperez 9 months ago
This was when I liked Candice. But over the years I realized that Mickie James is the best!!
cenafan004 9 months ago
@cenafan004 you can still like Candice while knowing Mickie is the best
LegendKillingChain 7 months ago
Candice's top was becoming undone -- that's why they chose to end the match quickly.
flipevent 10 months ago
@flipevent yeah because the divas were gonna beyond 10 minutes on a PPV(sarcasm), quit making up lies fool
RKOyou 5 months ago
candice is better
datniggaDJ95 11 months ago
Melina carried Candice in this match.
7World2 11 months ago 2
Melinaaaaaaa! n_n'
-yeaaah! I love Melina :)
MollyHollyRules33 1 year ago
I wish that melina coulda won.
jazzycouture93 1 year ago
nice match, ugly end.....
0alex 1 year ago
Go candice show melina up
Noobiesnack 1 year ago
Loving Melina's attire it's A-mazing!!!!
brittbratt1291 1 year ago
melina & candice... the best!
very nice match!
i miss candice in the ring!!!
katly1406 1 year ago
1:16 Jail Melina with Paris Hilton :D
Spatulinaaa 1 year ago
@rouma94 Toi nique la tienne Candice et meilleure que Melina =D
SoBe4utifulCandice 1 year ago
spongebob12335 YOU SUCK
BROWNNOT 1 year ago
candace marie <3's candice michelle :)
plyrangelbaby 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
candice is so beautiful at 8:18 - 8:25
ChristianSoftley 1 year ago
Comment removed
ChristianSoftley 1 year ago
I'm actually surprised. Only one dickhead comment on the page below about "fuck ya man she's fit as fuck bras boobies fannies yay i'm a boy"
:P
DingoEmo01 1 year ago
hey at least we get to see candice's bra. even tho i dont find her attractive
Melinafan2 1 year ago
At spongebob watever ur rite
violet61098 1 year ago
CANDICE YOU ROCK .melina you suck
spongebob12335 1 year ago 4
@spongebob12335 haha they both rock and YOU SUCK
8Baller1000 1 month ago
Comment removed
spongebob12335 1 month ago
@8Baller1000 mais ka ba??? kasi napaka bobo mo.kawawa ka naman.hindi ka pinalaki ng maayos ng magulang mo.tignan mo kung gaano kang kabobo ngayon.hahahahahaha.wala kang magandang kinabukasan.
spongebob12335 1 month ago
@spongebob12335 wtf u loser i dont understand a word u fuckin said LOL!! ahaha stupid fuck learn english thanks. stupid idiot
8Baller1000 1 month ago
@8Baller1000 ok.just a few words i like to share.this may be a bit long so bear with me.i was expressing my opinion.this is what i do.once a hater always a hater.now.when some piglet talk smack about myself.and gets bothered by the fact that i just shared my opinion.you can go eat another meatball and stay the fuck away from me.MIND YOUR OWN LIFE.AND I WILL DO THE SAME.get a life you beach whale.and stop with the gay talk cause fuck i see right through you.
spongebob12335 1 month ago
@8Baller1000 and your just pissed cause the rest of us you tried to throw under the bus haven't gained 80 pounds.so happy trails you obvious troll.your just a unwanted moron.I'll be happy living my life while laughing at your poor attempts to make others feel bad.you make yourself look so foolish talking bad about others.get some self confidence.and maybe a diet.you unwanted moron.and don't even think about replying.cause this will be the last minute wasting my time teaching you a lesson.LOL BYE
spongebob12335 1 month ago
@8Baller1000 oh wait.p.s.how can you think when your brain doesn't even exist????hahahahaha lol.
spongebob12335 1 month ago
@spongebob12335 LOL i didnt even bother reading ur paragraphs. get a life faggot and what are you 5? thats the saddest attempt to put someone down ive ever heard LOL wow! you really are a spongebob
8Baller1000 1 month ago
@8Baller1000 i know i wasn't supposed to reply but.i do have a life.lol.you on the other hand who needs to get a life and your the faggot.i don't even know what your problem is.i never did anything to you.i think you need to bother somebody else.the one who is defenseless.anyway like i said before mind your own life and i will do the same.anyway just stay the fuck away from me,you unwanted moron.
spongebob12335 1 month ago
@8Baller1000 so suck someone else' dick gettho trash
spongebob12335 1 month ago
i hate candice go melina
RoseyRosy1 1 year ago
at 6:29 you can barely hear melina say are you ok? candice yeah
TorrieWilsonFan456 1 year ago
@tito27l i'm not trying 2 disrespect u or anything ,i'm just telling u that trish stratus could always wrestle,at the beginning of her career she was the best diva wrestler besides Lita n Chyna
jmaxx2614 1 year ago
LMFAO! melina is a way better wrestler candice is fn hot but she cant wrestle for shit!!!!
TheRKOLegand 1 year ago
Candice rocks
mrpat1 1 year ago 4
candice improved that year, and deserved the championship, go candice
smartiew88 1 year ago
The wrestling doesn't start until 2:30
sos00123 1 year ago
Maricella24 sucks
candice is way better than melina.i mean candice beat melina alot of times.what so cool about melian anyway?
takim14 1 year ago
@takim14 what so cool about melina really really?? i mean candice is great but melina is wayyy better!!!
shicole98 1 year ago
see melina succs nd how many time did candice beated her!!!!???
SaNiMaTa1 1 year ago
Iam glad Candice Michelle is gone.
Maricella24 1 year ago
@Maricella24 congrarulations you won the stupid fucking whore award
spongebob12335 1 year ago
melina is a great wrestler one of the best in current wwe along with beth and michelle maccoll mickie is also great but she got release!!! AND THIS CHAMPIONSHIP WAS SCRIPTED SO THATS THE ONLY WAY CANDICE WON
123randombabe 1 year ago
i love how they lillian dint came to announce none of the matches until the end of candice run to the tittle it was only the guy i for got his name it was a nice fued
songglases 1 year ago
i love them both! but candice will always be my first fave diva <3
JeffLover7 1 year ago 2
Candice really came a long way. Before, she was USELESS.
rovert40 1 year ago
@Mikeferrari69 really, is it nice?
04bia 2 years ago
melina is working her entrance to the max cause she knew this was her last time holding the title
MoonlightMasters 2 years ago
5:08 god job mel.
SuperBeautifulgirl12 2 years ago
BITCH< U SUK!
R9f931 2 years ago
CANDICE IS GOOD!!! MELINA SUCKS hahaha
bestcousin111 2 years ago
both of em r good but i luv CANDICE!!!
MelPerezEsquire 2 years ago 2
But you love Melina more!!Haha jerry!
mnm20098 2 years ago
hahahahahaha VITYY!!!! u lil funny bitch lmao
MelPerezEsquire 2 years ago
shut up u suck
2010rawVSsmackdown 2 years ago
what year was dis in
jeffhardy4ever97 2 years ago
2007
meragan12487 2 years ago
candice rules!!
Melina is a big bat ugly bitch who is jeling :)
JordanScottMathis12 2 years ago
No honey,that's your mother.Melina is just awesome,you can't even lie right.
mnm20098 2 years ago 2
"Playboy quality" he said.
GacktNoKoibito 2 years ago
I was a big candice fan in 07 but now my all bew idol is melina but both of em rock..but ii think melina was more enterning to me than candice
xXxCandiiDiivaxXx 2 years ago 22
Menlena Is NIce But I go For Candice Wanna Be FRendis
prettykeria 2 years ago
the death of women's wrestling jk
stacykeiblerfreak 2 years ago
Candice was so lucky she wore a bra that night or else her boobs would have popped out at the end of the match.
TangyRice 2 years ago 10
botched end...actually all candices moves were botched except the powerslam
qwertyuiopz123 2 years ago
@qwertyuiopz123 And the powerslam worked only because Melina had the good sense to jump into Candice's arms instead of relying on Candice to lift her into the move (because that would have been a massive fail).
modelspiceboi 1 year ago
Melina is the best.then candice...then Maria :)
TheFixedEmo 2 years ago
just just shut up idiot i mean u got ur opinion but maria not trish victoria or mickie ur retarded yet melina is the best
daekwon9000 2 years ago
That round house kick by Candice was weak.
faithfulgirl82 2 years ago 3
how did melina get tha champion ship ??
punxroxerz 2 years ago
Beat Mickie
TangyRice 2 years ago
Candice is the best WWE diva in History
lyoko1012 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
candice is gone yes!!!!!!!! nasty slut hahahhaha! go back to porn melina 3 time champ soon to be 4 :D
RkoandMelinaFan 2 years ago
she did one episode of hotel erotica which is soft porn. have you ever seen it??? they barely touch each other and the actors dont actually have sex. but i still love melina though .i miss candice
kellykellyfan15 2 years ago 2
Do you even know how fucked up you are? Candice wanted to and was improving. It's sad how people like you don't believe in second chances. Karma's going to kick you in the ass.
TangyRice 2 years ago 3
wghat I liked about Candice is that when she did a good move she always went for the pin fast rather than wait for it.
cjgj1991 2 years ago 3
@RkoandMelinaFan you suck like your mother
spongebob12335 1 year ago
wwe is missed up that they released candice omg............. she was making her return too wwe grrrrrrrr.
hahaitzhaha 2 years ago 4
Candice is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!
0576juan 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
0576juan 2 years ago
Oh yeah! Candice won!!!
Bunnies3595 2 years ago
there some of my fav divas
tert238 2 years ago 2
THE WORST MOMENT IN WWE HISTORY!
moorer1012 2 years ago 4
MELiiiNA iiS THE BEST ii LOVE U MELiiNA
nickjonasfan2106 2 years ago 32
It have been 2 years since this momment.
Johnyfaction3 2 years ago
Yeah thats true but too bad they released Candice!
wrestlingfan1616 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
MELINA PEREZ 4 LYFE BITCHEZ!!
Bajan55 2 years ago
What a huge pop 7:03
Johnyfaction3 2 years ago
go go go melina
TRESOR321 2 years ago 5
GO CANDICE
lyoko1012 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
candice is such a bimbo. she shouldnt have won the tile from melina. Melina should have had a fued with victoria.
poopaloop099 2 years ago
i know! damnit! lol
jillfan1 2 years ago
melina is better than candice << lesbian
aanDhiiee 2 years ago
melina carried this bimbo all the way and all she does is that lame half ass spinning kick.
xkube3 2 years ago 3
I love them both but Melina's the better wrestler.
And daisyrulz000, you're right ! Half of the divas can't wrestle. Look at Maria, Kelly Kelly, Bella twins, Layla .. they can't ! I want good wrestlers like Trish, Chyna, Jazz etc. back !
crembie 2 years ago 26
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well there not commign back and kelly has improved
tonytugg 2 years ago
@crembie Kelly Kelly Can Wrestle
U Just Like They Old Bitches
Candice Is A Playboy Cover Girl And She Wayyy Better than Melina
Melina Just Wants To Be Like Playboy Divas
XMariaKanellisFanX 1 year ago
@XMariaKanellisFanX that is not true melina is better and she didnt wanna be like the playboy divas she didnt like the playboy divas you idiot
kalanylove 1 year ago
@kalanylove Whatever Candice Is A Wayyy Better Wrestler Than Melina
Also Kelly Kelly Bella Twins Mickie James Katie Lea Alica Fox And
Wayy More. If U C A macth With Melina Vs ashley U Can C That All Melina Wanted Was 2 B A Playboy , Its True. Hands Down
XMariaKanellisFanX 1 year ago
@XMariaKanellisFanX no its not true and the divas you said that wore better arent better then melina im laughing
kalanylove 1 year ago
@XMariaKanellisFanX melina is way better wrestler!
Inluvwtaylor 1 year ago
@XMariaKanellisFanX hahahahaha wow
mo6live 10 months ago
@XMariaKanellisFanX NO MELINA SAYS THAT SHE WOULD NEVER POSE BECAUSE YOU DONT NEED TO BE NAKED TO POSE PRETTY SHE WANTS TO LEAVE SOMETHING FOR THE IMAGINATION
123randombabe 1 year ago
@crembie layla can wrestle, now she got the womens TITLE she will be stronger
GRomance0804 1 year ago
@GRomance0804 but she can't wrestle, that was all luck
smartiew88 1 year ago
@crembie trish couldn't wrestle, she was all show. towards the end she could. deff not in the beginning though.
tito27l 1 year ago
@crembie yea ikr and micki but the NXT Naomi Night she is really good
ChristianSoftley 1 year ago
@crembie hey kelly kelly is good including ashley.
commitsuicide1234 1 year ago
@crembie It depends on the scripted fight on how good the one or the other girl looks so its not nessecarily their skills that are bad but rather the scripting. I admit that ashley was sloppy in performance and that kelly kelly is using only like 5 moves only. All the other girls mentioned though can wrestle very good (including the bellas in match they get to show their real skills).
fm95master 1 year ago
cuando paso eso responde =|
icemelina 2 years ago
candice candice candice candice candice candice!
shaarang566 2 years ago 5
candice says she helps kids. but then again she goes and has sex on hotel erotica. whore
daisyrulz000 2 years ago
heel or not heel melina rox! plus half of the divas can't wrestle
daisyrulz000 2 years ago 4
yeah very true the only one's i can name is
Melina Mickie James Gail kim beth Maryse
the ones that are out Eve Kelly kelly and alica fox
gamerchico 2 years ago 3
candice is horrible. she bloches all her moves. Melina doesn not look like a drag queen. You guys just vote for candice because you thinks shes hot. Looks does not matter when it comes to wrestling.
Gamerjoe987 2 years ago 5
thats hot
H3LLMAN777 2 years ago 3
I think Candice is way hotter than Melina..To me melina kinda looks like a drag queen
mrpat1 2 years ago
no that is so wrong
daisyrulz000 2 years ago
:'''''''] I wish they'd give her another title reign... and not that butterfly crap either..
tris16hardy 2 years ago 3
That is my fav out of all melina's outfits it's 2 colors White and Black
mickiefan123 2 years ago
That;s right Candice!! Candice is sexy and a decent wrestler. Go get it.
Fucka Melina
imahottdude109 2 years ago
jerry keeps saying that melina is jealous..but melina has nothing to be jealous about ..she is 1000 better than candice
jjst1994 2 years ago 3
7:03 best moment of the video. Seeing Candice tears make one know that she want a serious carrer and no more modeling. Begining of a new era started her.
Johnyfaction3 2 years ago 2
Melina haven't pin Candice since 2007.
Johnyfaction3 2 years ago
People like Candice, Christy, maria came into the WWE with no training, and became some of the best entertainers. I love Candice and i am proud of her. She is sexy and she can kick ass and still look like a hottie. Candice is the perfect woman. Love Candice
mrpat1 2 years ago 5
candice only proves that a playboy cover like her can be champion
jayjayjay15 2 years ago
Well, Sable and Chyna did that before her.
aerlyn2 2 years ago 4
Melina is so the best! Candice too! Woooohhhoooooo! Womens Championship!
heyheyshawty23 2 years ago 4
candice waz train by ledgends, trish stratus,cm punk . SO SHUT THE FUCKING HELL UP 4 GOD SAKES!!!!!
degeneratesharingan2 2 years ago
i wish candice stil had hair like she did here. She looks so much beterwith that long blondish brownish hair. i luv it
vTronz 3 years ago 7
What?
heyheyshawty23 2 years ago
wow still cant believe that melina lost to candice
jjst1994 3 years ago
look at the matches before this one Candice beat Melina three times the first two tag when she pinned Victoria then the rest she beet Melina.
wrestlerboy500 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
i heard candice will be a special referee to the upcoming march raw event between melina vs beth for women's championship. i think somethings gonna happen and it might be Candice's heel turn. She might be in wrestmania 25..
freewaymichael16 3 years ago
go candice go candice
go daddy go
bail3006 3 years ago
Yeah candice won in my now hometown of Houston Texas I was so happy Good for Candice
chrisxlita 3 years ago 4
i beat melina
CMIchelle14 3 years ago
luv candice
albertLUVScandice 3 years ago
That was a fast win for candice, melina could have escaped that attack! CHEAP!
IsmaelProductions 3 years ago 2
Melina is the new Womans Championesse *-*
AshleyLovesMexiko 3 years ago
This Match was very inspirational.
Candice make the critics eat their word by wining the championship. Also prove that women could pose for playboy at the same tame be a goo wrestler. I admire her for that.
Lol. KELLY have Candice old Music and old attires.
Johnyfaction3 3 years ago 4
this only proves that you can take your clothes off and get a championship push
examples: ashley, christy hemme, maria
sdfgilgfc 3 years ago 2
Don't forget to add Trish. She was Vince's personal slut if I recall.
OMGitsTangy 3 years ago
lol jr n the king r funny especially the king
XXKING91 3 years ago
melina and candice rocks!
xILOVEHARDYANDCENAx 3 years ago 4
Oh Ok, that is Good.
hammybaby13 3 years ago
yea well lets hope her reign is good lol
TGSchannel 3 years ago
I think Melina should have won this match and WWE would have built Candice up as a credible & serious competitor before winning the belt, that is the mistake they made with Candice. They rushed it.
Dont get me wrong, I Love Candice, she has great heart, fight, potential & passion, but she just wasnt exposed enough as a top diva contender to hold the belt.
That is why the fans have pushed her away... Unfortunetlyy. I would love to see Candice built up better and rightfully holding the belt.
hammybaby13 3 years ago
yea i love candice too, but they shoulda built her up as a competitor b4 they gave her the belt, because even though candice has been around for about 4 yrs it wasnt til about a year ago that she decided to train more, its the same mistake theyre making with maryse
TGSchannel 3 years ago