Yes, he definitely sings a minor 3rd, C# to E like the previous poster said. Now I think that you need to realise that Hans is not a singer, so he doesn't necessarily have a perfectly tuned voice, but he essentially does sing C# to E nonetheless, although the way he sings that 3rd is verging a bit between E and F, that is why it may seem a major 3rd to some, but it is a minor 3rd. Anyway there is no need to debate so much about it, people make mistakes.
Hans Zimmer is one of the best Soundtrack Composers ever; I studied music(piano most) since I was 7 so but I cannot say that if you sing wrong an interval you're cursed or something this. It's not about the very genius in music theory but the very genius in musical imagination, embedding the right music in the movie, as he does. WHEN YOU BECOME LIKE HIM(a great composer) THEN JUDGE. TILL THEN, SHUT UP!
he actually sang a mayor 3rd... great to see how the people who we admire so much are also humans that commit errors like us, hehe... very nice video, Zimmer rocks!!
Only a composer can understand..?? Minor thirds?!!!! DUD-
C to E-flat = a minor third! C to G = perfect cadence! BASIC COMPOSITION fundamentals people! STOP kissing so much ass!!!! GOOD GRIEF!!!! Any little 'new' thing amazes imbeciles who have no education and/or knowledge. Enough is enough already! Get off your lazy asses and learn something! Good Grief....
I dunno...it sounds like Mr. Zimmer is kind of UNSURE what he's talking about. It almost seems like Music composition is something new to him..? Or maybe he's just tired...
Anger can have it's benifits.. it can make music work! If handled well, it can also bring solutions for troublesome relationships and situations. Hans must have a great friendship now with that director! ;)
Pretty sure he sang a major 3rd. He sang from C# to E# (en-harmonically it would be C# to F, which would be a diminished 4th)
Not taking a credibility from him though. He's a brilliant composer and a scholar!
Xibalba28 8 months ago
which song is he talking about?
anmjbfilm 1 year ago
Yes, he definitely sings a minor 3rd, C# to E like the previous poster said. Now I think that you need to realise that Hans is not a singer, so he doesn't necessarily have a perfectly tuned voice, but he essentially does sing C# to E nonetheless, although the way he sings that 3rd is verging a bit between E and F, that is why it may seem a major 3rd to some, but it is a minor 3rd. Anyway there is no need to debate so much about it, people make mistakes.
Well, I wish you all a happy New Year. =)
moleroge 2 years ago
Oh my gosh! To shut all of you up who think it's a major 3rd. He sings a C# to an E. This interval is clearly a minor 3rd. 0:40
PrestonandShaffer 2 years ago
Hans Zimmer is one of the best Soundtrack Composers ever; I studied music(piano most) since I was 7 so but I cannot say that if you sing wrong an interval you're cursed or something this. It's not about the very genius in music theory but the very genius in musical imagination, embedding the right music in the movie, as he does. WHEN YOU BECOME LIKE HIM(a great composer) THEN JUDGE. TILL THEN, SHUT UP!
softman88 3 years ago 2
Well... i think as the other post. He sings a major 3rd.
jesusfranco 3 years ago
he actually sang a mayor 3rd... great to see how the people who we admire so much are also humans that commit errors like us, hehe... very nice video, Zimmer rocks!!
sergeidave 4 years ago
Only a composer can understand..?? Minor thirds?!!!! DUD-
C to E-flat = a minor third! C to G = perfect cadence! BASIC COMPOSITION fundamentals people! STOP kissing so much ass!!!! GOOD GRIEF!!!! Any little 'new' thing amazes imbeciles who have no education and/or knowledge. Enough is enough already! Get off your lazy asses and learn something! Good Grief....
godadameve 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I dunno...it sounds like Mr. Zimmer is kind of UNSURE what he's talking about. It almost seems like Music composition is something new to him..? Or maybe he's just tired...
godadameve 4 years ago
....your joking right
Disasster 4 years ago
Anger can have it's benifits.. it can make music work! If handled well, it can also bring solutions for troublesome relationships and situations. Hans must have a great friendship now with that director! ;)
Adelaartje 4 years ago
the thin red line is hans best work, i think he knows that too...
drchepa 5 years ago
What a fantastic clip! Fascinating how he approached that. I assume, that this is specifically Journey to the Line he's talking about?
aviazn 5 years ago 2
This is a great, great video...only a music composer can really understand what thos 3rd minors chords and those 5th purely perfect chords meant.
afterglow2009 5 years ago