hmm. listened to both versions, can't really pick a winner. for some reason gabriel's voice just blends better with the accompany, but the song stretches for a bit too long. on the other hand i can't think of a song that uses a pipe organ that i have ever not like, and the goosebumps at the 2min 10 sec mark are just awesome. i guess i enjoy this one for the darker tone , and gabriel's for the dramatic lighter tone. just a great song by any means though
Peter Gabriel's version is most certainly NOT the better version. He butchered this song into a monotonous overly artsy pulp of a song. He was just trying too hard to make it the saddest song ever.
@tauruslatino You could of easily just clicked off the page instead of posting a rude comment that would offend people. You are the winner of the Jack Ass award today.
Thumbs up if you think people shouldn't openly admit, much less be proud of the fact, that they first heard of a critically acclaimed song/band through a popular TV medical drama. I mean are there posts on like, classical music tracks on here where people say "Thumbs up if you came here after watching Looney Tunes"?
The Peter Gabriel cover of this is dog shit designed specially to fool pretentious people with bad taste, who think any time an old singer with a gravelly voice whisper-sings a song it's automatically high art.
Of course my opinions are facts. Why would I state them if I didn't think they were true, or weren't sure they were true? If you state anything, you should be reasonably sure it's true - or else why say it?
Also, thumbs up if u came here after watching house, going on utube and finding the Peter Gabrial version, and finally reliezing that it was originally an Arcade Fire song
@Vendetta1886 I have to say, I sorta like his version better, but I think both versions are anazing! There really is no reason to get into a big debate about it or start arguments. It's an amazing song, and we should just appreciate them for what they are.
@88976hi LOL wut? What a shitty song for a strip club. It's so sad and philosohpically heavy and emotionally overwhelming. how am I supposed to enjoy tits when the music is lamenting about the very nature of struggling with one's own mortality in the face of uncertainty?
It really isn't at all. People saying it is betray their own complete lack of taste. Peter Gabriel just sings it in a super dramatic gravelly old man hoarse whisper. There are people who think anything sung in that voice is automatically "authentic" and deep and great, and better than any other version of the song. But no - this is the better version of this, just as NIN's original version of Hurt was superior to Johnny Cash's sad old man cover version. You're easily duped is all.
@cauchamar I don't think you understand. That IS Peter Gabriel's voice. Have you ever heard "Don't Give Up"? He has that sort of gravelly tone to his voice. A song with lyrics like this one needs to be a more solemn/sad song. More like Gabriel's version and not at all like AF's version.
....takes me on a mystical, magical carpet ride~
sleeping2dr3am 5 hours ago
Don't get me wrong, I really like this, but I prefer Peter Gabriel's orchestral version just a bit.
Seththebeaver 2 weeks ago
self esteem theme song?
LordOfYahoo 2 weeks ago
the part with the crash gives me shivers.
meviscool 2 weeks ago
transgender theme song?
DylanTroy898 3 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos 7
can anyone else imagine this going along with the scene in the deer hunter when christopher walken blows his brains out?
buddythecow 1 month ago
@buddythecow
Not as easily as I can imagine the Christopher Walken character from Annie Hall saying something like you just did.
cauchamar 6 days ago
this. is. music. not comercial shit. love them
Lauue0 1 month ago
penis
crockalotadizero 1 month ago
@crockalotadizero Mines quite large, I'm aware.
killerbumble 20 hours ago
Masterpiece of a song.
AnnaxBear 2 months ago
Brilliant song. My favorite off Neon Bible.
08TheJanitor 2 months ago in playlist Arcade Fire Discography 6
This has been flagged as spam show
“People say that your dreams are the only thing that saves ya” W.B.
How do you like the cover version I did of this song?
BenAuris 2 months ago
low qauilty
WallaceKeysXperiment 3 months ago
my body was a cage, but i ate an orange and it was k.
oromisszane 3 months ago 19
@oromisszane What the fuck did I just read?
FreddieTheYeti 2 months ago 5
@oromisszane i didn't get it.
deadlyhandsomegirl 5 days ago in playlist arcadefire
This has been flagged as spam show
Sounds like the black keys.
bmx3r101 3 months ago
GOD DAMMIT DUNKEY, START UPLOADING SOMETHING ALREADY
FatHunter106 3 months ago 7
ocean right ?
TheEmerald92 3 months ago 5
@TheEmerald92 ....BOOOOSH!
keaton223 3 months ago
did the John Carter trailer bring you here?
QueenofDiamonds1391 3 months ago 2
@QueenofDiamonds1391 Hellz yeah!
Evahrab 2 months ago
dunky
Canofwhoopass1000 3 months ago 11
ssas
MsLacrossefreak 3 months ago
My mind is a bitch.
deadlyhandsomegirl 3 months ago
My body is a cage, and my heart is an apple
aerosmith01234 3 months ago
This version is FAR BETTER! Peter Gabriel's version is too boring and nitpicked. This is just RAW and just feels right.
01AlPal01 3 months ago 2
Liking Peter Gabriels' version more is fine, saying that you like it more on Arcade Fires' version means you're a douchebag though. Sorry.
SBV123 3 months ago
@SBV123 I like this version better.
I hope you don't have a problem with that =]
100KillStreak 3 months ago
My body is a...OH YEAH! XD
goldenskullrose 3 months ago
Macklemore brought me here, but I like this better.
BillSwift4 3 months ago
Pipe organ=Epic
vankirwin30 3 months ago
hmm. listened to both versions, can't really pick a winner. for some reason gabriel's voice just blends better with the accompany, but the song stretches for a bit too long. on the other hand i can't think of a song that uses a pipe organ that i have ever not like, and the goosebumps at the 2min 10 sec mark are just awesome. i guess i enjoy this one for the darker tone , and gabriel's for the dramatic lighter tone. just a great song by any means though
goffuncensored 3 months ago
I'm the only one who think that this song talks about Platon philosophy? xD
victorriesgo 3 months ago
Personally I like PeterGabriel's version better than this.But I enjoy both.
sadiebabie123 4 months ago
Peter Gabriel's version is most certainly NOT the better version. He butchered this song into a monotonous overly artsy pulp of a song. He was just trying too hard to make it the saddest song ever.
pwnerinator 4 months ago 8
2:10- 2:37
Sounds like a cage. Or something flying around inside a cage.
creativewriter1000 4 months ago
To be honest, Peter Gabriel's version is so much better. Much more menacing and diverse.
jordan19roberts 4 months ago
im crying !
Erich8101 4 months ago
screw peter gabriel. no offense.
TheZachabby02 4 months ago
A song with many great covers...but non can touch the original. How could they? It's perfect.
TheSlevinCalevra 4 months ago
its dark, its sad, sometimes its the truth and its all arcade fire :)
imazebra1234567 4 months ago 5
pickles
1Foggia 4 months ago
2:10
vankirwin30 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It took me days, weeks, even months. If you have 4 minutes and 16 seconds, check out the tribute version I did for "My body is a cage."
BenAuris 4 months ago
bury me to this song.
chiodos001 4 months ago 4
Arcade Fire, peter Gabriel, and the orchestra that played with him should team up and play this song. It would be the most epic thing ever
LostRed33 5 months ago 2
Why didn't they just use Arcade Fire's version on the John Carter's promo? :(
oneshotofcoffee 5 months ago
!!!!!!!!! PINCHE CHINGADERA !!!!!!!!!!!!
tauruslatino 5 months ago
@tauruslatino TROLL FAIL! PINCHE CABRON!!!
4demon9 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
!!!!!THIS SONG SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!! BETTER I GO BACK LISTENING LADY GAGA !!!!!!!!!
THIS MUSIC IS FOR RETARDED PEOPLE!!!
tauruslatino 5 months ago
@tauruslatino wow lady gaga? you must have horrible music taste. you don't deserve to listen to this stuff.
Mynameismeganx4 5 months ago 3
@Mynameismeganx4 I'd also rather listen to Lady Gaga than this. Maybe you'd like to tell me I have no taste, as well.
imperiumdiaboli 5 months ago
@imperiumdiaboli yup pretty much.
Mynameismeganx4 5 months ago 3
@Mynameismeganx4 How intellectual!
imperiumdiaboli 5 months ago
@tauruslatino You could of easily just clicked off the page instead of posting a rude comment that would offend people. You are the winner of the Jack Ass award today.
bugglink1922 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
pinche chigadera!!!!!!!!!!!!
tauruslatino 5 months ago
pinche chigadera!!!!!!!!!!!!
tauruslatino 5 months ago
this already sounds like a peter gabriel song , no surprise he would cover it, and do it even better.
unabonger777 5 months ago
Thumbs up if you think people shouldn't openly admit, much less be proud of the fact, that they first heard of a critically acclaimed song/band through a popular TV medical drama. I mean are there posts on like, classical music tracks on here where people say "Thumbs up if you came here after watching Looney Tunes"?
cauchamar 6 months ago 5
The Peter Gabriel cover of this is dog shit designed specially to fool pretentious people with bad taste, who think any time an old singer with a gravelly voice whisper-sings a song it's automatically high art.
cauchamar 6 months ago
@cauchamar
God save people who think their opinions are facts.
AFiestOfFriends 6 months ago 4
@AFiestOfFriends
Of course my opinions are facts. Why would I state them if I didn't think they were true, or weren't sure they were true? If you state anything, you should be reasonably sure it's true - or else why say it?
cauchamar 6 months ago
@cauchamar you seem confuse
jdbi 5 months ago
5 peep's bodies are a cage but their mind doesnt hold the key
bloodw01f 6 months ago
@bloodw01f OMG SHUT THE FUCK UP
wookiemania94 5 months ago
Also, thumbs up if u came here after watching house, going on utube and finding the Peter Gabrial version, and finally reliezing that it was originally an Arcade Fire song
kingdavidtrialruns 6 months ago
Thats it. Im getting every arcade fire album now.
kingdavidtrialruns 6 months ago 2
F@#! Peter Gabriel
860joejoe 6 months ago 3
LRG!
thealexperkins 6 months ago in playlist Music
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Peter Gabriel does Arcade Fire better than Arcade Fire
Vendetta1886 6 months ago
@Vendetta1886 NOPE
rockyrigby 6 months ago in playlist Arcade Fire - Neon Bible 8
@Vendetta1886 I have to say, I sorta like his version better, but I think both versions are anazing! There really is no reason to get into a big debate about it or start arguments. It's an amazing song, and we should just appreciate them for what they are.
tarjay35 6 months ago
@Vendetta1886 nah..
Steven23CrazyBassist 6 months ago
@Vendetta1886 Peter Gabreil does everything better than everyone.
jonbar18 6 months ago in playlist Peter Gabriel "Scratch My Back
Comment removed
DurrennV2 6 months ago
Near the end of this song, my heart is beating so fast... no song has the same effect on me as this one. It's so powerful.
AlannahClaire 7 months ago 6
Comment removed
AlannahClaire 7 months ago
Comment removed
AlannahClaire 7 months ago
Simply brilliant song
TheBarkingGnome 7 months ago
How is it possible for anyone not to like this?
PILCH032790 7 months ago 14
@PILCH032790 they mad
LardTardProductions 3 months ago
is a copy...is very OVVIA !
bbjmm 7 months ago
The Batman Complex sent me
Skybaby79 7 months ago
herd this at a strip club once, nice song
88976hi 7 months ago 2
@88976hi LOL wut? What a shitty song for a strip club. It's so sad and philosohpically heavy and emotionally overwhelming. how am I supposed to enjoy tits when the music is lamenting about the very nature of struggling with one's own mortality in the face of uncertainty?
Cropduster777 7 months ago 3
@Cropduster777 the hell if i know. its not the strangest song i herd there. but the customers never seemed to notice.
88976hi 7 months ago
Peter Gabriel's version shits on this.
chaosinorderrr 7 months ago
i wanna go and like dance in the rain or do something epic (like walking in slow mo toward a camera with a semi-automatic on my shoulder) =D
brmcdeathcab44 7 months ago 5
Peter Gabriel's version is so much better.
TheDannyj4 7 months ago
@TheDannyj4
It really isn't at all. People saying it is betray their own complete lack of taste. Peter Gabriel just sings it in a super dramatic gravelly old man hoarse whisper. There are people who think anything sung in that voice is automatically "authentic" and deep and great, and better than any other version of the song. But no - this is the better version of this, just as NIN's original version of Hurt was superior to Johnny Cash's sad old man cover version. You're easily duped is all.
cauchamar 7 months ago
@cauchamar I don't think you understand. That IS Peter Gabriel's voice. Have you ever heard "Don't Give Up"? He has that sort of gravelly tone to his voice. A song with lyrics like this one needs to be a more solemn/sad song. More like Gabriel's version and not at all like AF's version.
TheDannyj4 7 months ago
Comment removed
2112nico 7 months ago
Welcom to Quebec! :D yaaaaa!!!!
Radiohead6992 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Peter Gabriel's version is like 9000 times better IMO
Shady32 9 months ago
Then go listen to it and stop wasting time listening to a version you think vastly inferior, ya fucking twerp.
cauchamar 8 months ago
@cauchamar Oh, don't worry about my time being wasted, it was only three minutes.
Shady32 8 months ago
@Shady32
Remember that when you're down to your last three minutes.
cauchamar 8 months ago 4
Comment removed
nichelleSeizures 8 months ago
Mesmerizing...
iLateralGX 9 months ago
bomba
Riskius 9 months ago
...
CardingtonLZF 9 months ago
This guys are amazing!!!!!!!!!!!
filipegoncalves1 9 months ago
No words...
filipegoncalves1 9 months ago 2
My body is a... *SHIT GETS REAL*
Best part of the song.
SweetOblivion23 10 months ago 29
@SweetOblivion23 hahaha you described that so well.
JonJury 3 months ago
I LOVE the pipe organ in this coupled with snare and choir. GREAT combo.
kilderok 10 months ago 3
So glad this was included in the curfew, perfect soundtrack to a perfect game
catpower009 10 months ago
did they write this themselves?
ollierodgers1 11 months ago
original is 100% better
cfriedman16 11 months ago
@cfriedman16 This is the original.
nerdysmile67 10 months ago
@nerdysmile67 i realized that after I made the comment, I meant peter gabriel. Sorry.
cfriedman16 10 months ago
Comment removed
cauchamar 10 months ago
omfg 2:08 fucking amazing
rhomcy 11 months ago 4
peter gabriel's version is much better. much more soulful
xFallenAnjelx 11 months ago
Thumbs up if you came here after watching House
jackstone1261 11 months ago 98
@jackstone1261 no.
itzoverninethousand 6 months ago
@jackstone1261 im in austria i watched house 2 hours ago i cant forget that song!
Erich8101 4 months ago
Hauntingly beautiful
Luccia91 1 year ago 5
I remember seeing a beautiful lyrical dance to this in the Vegas KAR Competion
igriselstar 1 year ago
Love this song!!
garfieldcomicgrl2 1 year ago 24
@garfieldcomicgrl2 I agree completely xP
Zynukthoom 1 year ago 5
@Zynukthoom :D
garfieldcomicgrl2 1 year ago
@Zynukthoom Yeah, this song rock
filipegoncalves1 9 months ago
@garfieldcomicgrl2 Ur right this is a pretty good song. Sami was so wrong.
MCCoutryGirl3 1 year ago
@MCCoutryGirl3 I know! I love the lyrics! I want to choreograph a dance to it :D
garfieldcomicgrl2 1 year ago
@garfieldcomicgrl2 I know we should so do that.
MCCoutryGirl3 1 year ago
@MCCoutryGirl3 It's going on my list of songs that I might dance to for my grad solo :)
garfieldcomicgrl2 1 year ago
LOL im the only one that gave it a thumbs up (:
ThuyNguyen 1 year ago
@ThuyNguyen lol yaaaay!
Zynukthoom 1 year ago 2