Haha I was laughing so hard on #4 Faggot and at McNabbs picture. We watched it in class wen we were done with our midterms an hour b4 we were supposed to be done with them and the boys took over the computer and the projector!!lol
i agree with with all the players on this list exept mcnabb because he is definitely not good enough. his stats arent good but he also doesnt have good accuracy hes pretty bad. i also think the order of this list is messed up but go romo at #5. he is definitely in top 5 of best quarterbacks!! go cowboys
1. peyton manning 2. drew brees 3. tony romo 4. (sad to say) brett favre 5.matt shaub 6.phillip rivers 7. tom brady 8. aaron rodger 9.kurt warner 10. big ben
don't throw an interception! He's come back from behind 7 times int he regular season! And he won 2 MOST VALUABLE PLAYER in a row! He's at leats second best! And I know all you Manning haters, (cause your a Brady fan) will say he threw the game-ending interception against the saints, well, Reggie, who was hurt, stopped on the route, and you know the Colts would have won that game if Reggie doesn't stop on the route, cause they were going down the field with no problems before he stopped!
@PORKINS2: ok i'm not going to adress everyone of your points cause there's a lot, but i'll explain my case. Peyton Manning threw 16 INTs in 2009 you say that this isn't bad, throwing ints costs teams games(usually): with no picks chance on winning is 84% with one pick your chance of winning drops to 53% with another your at 27% then at 3 13%, with 4 less than 5% and 5 0.83%, and more than 5 0%
@PORKINS2: this is why I like QBs that play efficient games without making mistakes, basically there's 2 types of good QBs: Do work QBs- play highly efficient games without many mistakes but don't make too many big plays and due to this win a lot of games(ex: Joe Montana, and Tom Brady), then there's Gun slingers- these guys like to god deep and make a lot mistakes but make a lot of big plays and due to the big plays people think they're super amazing because they're always on sports center
@PORKINS2: ex.(of gunslinger): Brett Favre and Dan Marino, with do work QBs lets say Brady goe 23 of 27 for 258 yards 2TDs and 0 INTs in a win for the Pats, where as Brett Favre goes 27 of 41 for 363 yards and 4TDs and 3 INTs in a high scoring loss, now the difference(in this made up example) is Favre had more TDs and yards but Brady played more efficient and therefore got the win, thats why I value the "do work QBs" over the "gunslngers"
@PORKINS2: and now your like uh ok, but you may be wondering which one is Peyton Manning, well I think Manning is more of a gunslinger, he has games where he's just terrible, worst game of his career he threw 6 INTs and 5 in the first half, worst game of Brady's career he threw 4 INTs, worst game of Favre's career he threw 7 INTs
@PORKINS2: ok now to since you know these things time to adress the Colts season, the reason Manning had 7 4th quarter comebacks is that others teams kinda suck this year and just "give it to them", if your usually down at half time and you throw 3 INTs and 4 INTs 2 week later and win all those games its because the other team sucks, plus the colts have the fastest defense in the NFL, a lot of the Colts success can be attributed to their defense and deep receiving core not just Peyton Manning
@Pandamatrix85:Their defense is not that great aside from Freeney and Mathis. Their defense may be fast but aside from being a very good red zone D, nothing about their Defense was overly impressive last year.
@Pandamatrix85: Powers was a nice addition and Bethea has his moments, but that's about it. They play well aginst one dimensional offenses like the Ravens, Jets, Cardinals, etc. or else really bad teams yet they typically struggle against elite offenses. (see: Patriots game, Superbowl XLIV) They also routinely struggle against Jacksonville for whatever reason.
Okay, I know we've already talked about this, but So what if Peyton threw 6 ints! He's the best qb, or at least second best! he he's a 4 time MOST VALUABLE PLAYER! he got his team to the super bowl and almost won it, he's 15-0 in the regular season, and when he's in the games against the jets and the bills their winning, when he's not they don't score a single point! When he throws interceptions he makes up for them. so stop with that bullshit about you have 80 percent chance of winning when you
calm down bro, I like Peyton's resume he's a great player and at the moment he's second best all-time and could take the #1 spot from Brady with enough time, I've already explained and don't want to further argue why I dislike Peyton's 2009 season and why I think that he's overrated mostly by the media during said season
I mostly just watch game highlights and check stats cause games are too boring from start to finish but i'll watch the Colts/Pats game in 2010, good luck in 2010
Brady's stats were also inflated b/c of two games. (Week 16 vs. Jags, Week 6 vs. Tenn.) You take those two games out and Brady has 3751 yards and 18 TDs in 14 games, and is only completing 63.2% of his passes compared to his 65.7% rate for the season. Even if you take out Manning's two best games, even not including the games he sat, he still crushes Brady. 3481 yards and 25 TDs in 12 games. I know you're a Pats fan but c'mon Manning was better than Brady in 2009.
Plus Brady had a double digit lead in the 4th Quarter of games 5 times and lost the lead each time. The only team that Brady made plays against in the 4th Quarter to win the game during the Regular Season was the Buffalo Bills. Manning, when given the opportunity, led fourth quarter comebacks 7 times in 7 tries. Manning had more yards, more TDs, a higher passer rating, etc. His stats would've been even better if Caldwell hadn't sat him in Week 16.
Ok first of all Manning almost never makes mistakes retard he wouldve went 16-0 in of if they didnt decide to put painter in.. MAtt Shuab should be number 5. Dude he lead the leaue in yards...tis is how my list would be. 10.Matt Stafford(look what did for a 0-16 team) 9.Donovan McNabb 8.Tom Brady 7.Tony Romo 6.Ben Roethlisberger 5.Matt Shuab 4.Brett Favre 3.Aaron Rodgers 2.Peyton Manning 1.Drew Brees I agree with most of yyour list But dude Peyton Manning doesnt cost games at all..
btw Colts lost to Bills 30-7 and Manning played entire first half and got picked off on very first pass, Manning makes too many mistakes if he didn't make many mistakes he would probably be #1 all-time also his win percentage would be higher, but he does choke a lot in post season so there's that holdig him back also
@Pandamatrix85: He played a quarter not a half. Plus he only played so that Clark and Wayne could each get 100 catches. Second, he doesn't make too many mistakes. 16 picks in 571 attempts is not bad at all. Plus none of those picks cost his team a win, when his coach allowed him to play, during the regular season.
@Pandamatrix85: Also, holding Manning's postseason record against him when your list is about the Top 10 QBs of the 2009 REGULAR SEASON makes no sense at all. Anyone who actually thought Brady was better than Manning in 2009 has to be full of it. While the topic of whose the better QB career wise is debatable, there is no question that Manning was better in 2009. Manning won every game in which he played all 4 quarters during the Regular Season.
You base your rankings to much off stats. For example look at the talent around Manning this year. He made two first year starters look good. You cant just base things off stats.
Colts played the 8th toughest schedule in the NFL according to FO, compared to Brees and the Sainst who played the 23rd toughest schedule. So that argument is stupid. The only reason you have him 7 is b/c you're a Pats fan.
Sanchez should be on the list. He played good toward the end of the year but come on. The running game and defense got the jets to the AFC championship game. Sanchez cost them a few games this year.
@titox87 he was the best QB this season and should've gotten MVP since MVP only goes to the teams with playoff bye or super bowl favorite, but I think if voters were smart CJ2K would get MVP
he's won more MVP's than any other player in the history of the nfl! He won more games than anyone this decade and he's about to win his second super bowl. Every quarterback throws interceptions! Brett Favre is one of the greatest quarterbacks ever (even though you hate him) he has more interceptions than any other quarterback. but he also has the most touchdowns than any other quarterback and more yards than any other one. you obviously know nothing about quarterbacks!
@guysdave1 uh buddy I know a lot you have no idea, MVP goes to best player on best team or best player on super bowl favorite or the guy media likes the best, the media likes Manning, for example they never tell you the bad stuff like 16 INTs and that the league kinda sucks this year so no one can finish so its like nah you win... ok, basically everyone sucks this year except for a few individuals(CJ2K, Brees, Revis, Woodson, Asante, etc.)
haha for a second I thought you said I have no idea...wow.
Anybody that has played the QB position will tell you that what Peyton does is incredible! Because he is probably the only guy that will throw 3 ints in a game and win it! He can read blitzes better than anybody. MVP stands for most valuable player...there's a reason he got 39 of 50 votes, you take Peyton away from the colts, they'd most likely be 2-14, not 15-2! They'd be watching the sb instead of playing in it in two weeks!
@guysdave1 if weren't for the INTs Manning's winning percentage(career) would be the highest in NFL history however he makes mistakes and it costs his team games, f it weren't for the mistakes and surprisingly low career win percentage then he would be the best of all-time
@Pandamatrix85: No it wouldn't. If he had a defense that could stop the other team on third down and get him the ball back then he'd have the highest winning percentage in NFL History. Plus 7 of his 16 picks came on tipped passes, and 2 others came on plays where Wayne ran the wrong route.
He has the highest TD:int ratio in NFL History. What are you talking about??? 16 ints. when every single team knows you're going to throw the ball is not that bad at all. That's like 1 int a game. big deal.
i dislike him because where I live everyone thinks he's the best ever and constantly put me down cause i like Brady, Favre actually isn't the best ever infact he's nowhere close he's one of the biggest chokers in NFL history when I think Favre I think INTs pick sixes and choking late in games and he's all-time INT leader
lol # 4 1:18
TheNATHANDOUCET 7 months ago
Haha I was laughing so hard on #4 Faggot and at McNabbs picture. We watched it in class wen we were done with our midterms an hour b4 we were supposed to be done with them and the boys took over the computer and the projector!!lol
Mikaykay009 1 year ago
bad rankings
SportsBlogs 1 year ago
mcnabb shit no!
the1999s 1 year ago
akk111866 1 year ago
yo this troyb 1984 down at the bottom gets it. i agree with his list. mine is the same
thedallascowboyfann 1 year ago
i agree with with all the players on this list exept mcnabb because he is definitely not good enough. his stats arent good but he also doesnt have good accuracy hes pretty bad. i also think the order of this list is messed up but go romo at #5. he is definitely in top 5 of best quarterbacks!! go cowboys
thedallascowboyfann 1 year ago
Romo is a BEAST!! LMAO!!!@ #4 "Faggot" and #3 Phillip Rivers picture
MrJNEW82 1 year ago
Brett Favre has gotta b at least #2....and cmon Aaron Rodgers
nabria96 1 year ago
Gay. favre was awesome this year. he threw the most touchdowns, besides drew brees, dude, come on. number 2 for sure.
ShibbyMaster42 1 year ago
this top 10 is just stupid, i mean im not the biggest fan of peyton, but he's the best in NFL at QB, and has been for the past 3-4 years.
#1 Peyton Manning #2 Drew Brees #3 Aaron Rodgers #4 Brett Frave #5 Tony homo, I MEAN romo *cough* #6 Ben Roethlisberger #7Philip Rivers #8 Tom Brady #9 Matt Schaub #10Donovan Mcnabb
icantthinkofaname335 1 year ago
i say tony romo is #1 ima cowboy fan
midtowndirtdogs 1 year ago
@midtowndirtdogs I know me too, should have at least be #2.
Mikaykay009 1 year ago
I don't really disagree with any of the people on the list, but I think you gotta put Manning at #2 and definitely in front of Brady for this season.
PHILLYfan1518 1 year ago
1. peyton manning 2. drew brees 3. tony romo 4. (sad to say) brett favre 5.matt shaub 6.phillip rivers 7. tom brady 8. aaron rodger 9.kurt warner 10. big ben
troyb1984 2 years ago
don't throw an interception! He's come back from behind 7 times int he regular season! And he won 2 MOST VALUABLE PLAYER in a row! He's at leats second best! And I know all you Manning haters, (cause your a Brady fan) will say he threw the game-ending interception against the saints, well, Reggie, who was hurt, stopped on the route, and you know the Colts would have won that game if Reggie doesn't stop on the route, cause they were going down the field with no problems before he stopped!
guysdave1 2 years ago
@PORKINS2: ok i'm not going to adress everyone of your points cause there's a lot, but i'll explain my case. Peyton Manning threw 16 INTs in 2009 you say that this isn't bad, throwing ints costs teams games(usually): with no picks chance on winning is 84% with one pick your chance of winning drops to 53% with another your at 27% then at 3 13%, with 4 less than 5% and 5 0.83%, and more than 5 0%
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@PORKINS2: this is why I like QBs that play efficient games without making mistakes, basically there's 2 types of good QBs: Do work QBs- play highly efficient games without many mistakes but don't make too many big plays and due to this win a lot of games(ex: Joe Montana, and Tom Brady), then there's Gun slingers- these guys like to god deep and make a lot mistakes but make a lot of big plays and due to the big plays people think they're super amazing because they're always on sports center
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@PORKINS2: ex.(of gunslinger): Brett Favre and Dan Marino, with do work QBs lets say Brady goe 23 of 27 for 258 yards 2TDs and 0 INTs in a win for the Pats, where as Brett Favre goes 27 of 41 for 363 yards and 4TDs and 3 INTs in a high scoring loss, now the difference(in this made up example) is Favre had more TDs and yards but Brady played more efficient and therefore got the win, thats why I value the "do work QBs" over the "gunslngers"
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@PORKINS2: and now your like uh ok, but you may be wondering which one is Peyton Manning, well I think Manning is more of a gunslinger, he has games where he's just terrible, worst game of his career he threw 6 INTs and 5 in the first half, worst game of Brady's career he threw 4 INTs, worst game of Favre's career he threw 7 INTs
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@PORKINS2: ok now to since you know these things time to adress the Colts season, the reason Manning had 7 4th quarter comebacks is that others teams kinda suck this year and just "give it to them", if your usually down at half time and you throw 3 INTs and 4 INTs 2 week later and win all those games its because the other team sucks, plus the colts have the fastest defense in the NFL, a lot of the Colts success can be attributed to their defense and deep receiving core not just Peyton Manning
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@Pandamatrix85:Their defense is not that great aside from Freeney and Mathis. Their defense may be fast but aside from being a very good red zone D, nothing about their Defense was overly impressive last year.
P0RKINS2 1 year ago
@Pandamatrix85: Powers was a nice addition and Bethea has his moments, but that's about it. They play well aginst one dimensional offenses like the Ravens, Jets, Cardinals, etc. or else really bad teams yet they typically struggle against elite offenses. (see: Patriots game, Superbowl XLIV) They also routinely struggle against Jacksonville for whatever reason.
P0RKINS2 1 year ago
Okay, I know we've already talked about this, but So what if Peyton threw 6 ints! He's the best qb, or at least second best! he he's a 4 time MOST VALUABLE PLAYER! he got his team to the super bowl and almost won it, he's 15-0 in the regular season, and when he's in the games against the jets and the bills their winning, when he's not they don't score a single point! When he throws interceptions he makes up for them. so stop with that bullshit about you have 80 percent chance of winning when you
guysdave1 2 years ago
calm down bro, I like Peyton's resume he's a great player and at the moment he's second best all-time and could take the #1 spot from Brady with enough time, I've already explained and don't want to further argue why I dislike Peyton's 2009 season and why I think that he's overrated mostly by the media during said season
I mostly just watch game highlights and check stats cause games are too boring from start to finish but i'll watch the Colts/Pats game in 2010, good luck in 2010
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
favre is no faggot
GrandTheftChevelle 2 years ago
@GrandTheftChevelle I didn't mean it literally I just don't like him
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
Brady's stats were also inflated b/c of two games. (Week 16 vs. Jags, Week 6 vs. Tenn.) You take those two games out and Brady has 3751 yards and 18 TDs in 14 games, and is only completing 63.2% of his passes compared to his 65.7% rate for the season. Even if you take out Manning's two best games, even not including the games he sat, he still crushes Brady. 3481 yards and 25 TDs in 12 games. I know you're a Pats fan but c'mon Manning was better than Brady in 2009.
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
Plus Brady had a double digit lead in the 4th Quarter of games 5 times and lost the lead each time. The only team that Brady made plays against in the 4th Quarter to win the game during the Regular Season was the Buffalo Bills. Manning, when given the opportunity, led fourth quarter comebacks 7 times in 7 tries. Manning had more yards, more TDs, a higher passer rating, etc. His stats would've been even better if Caldwell hadn't sat him in Week 16.
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
Oops I spaced Phillip Rivers In my List he Would be number 5 Bumb everone back one
bleachnose 2 years ago
bleachnose 2 years ago
btw Colts lost to Bills 30-7 and Manning played entire first half and got picked off on very first pass, Manning makes too many mistakes if he didn't make many mistakes he would probably be #1 all-time also his win percentage would be higher, but he does choke a lot in post season so there's that holdig him back also
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@Pandamatrix85: He played a quarter not a half. Plus he only played so that Clark and Wayne could each get 100 catches. Second, he doesn't make too many mistakes. 16 picks in 571 attempts is not bad at all. Plus none of those picks cost his team a win, when his coach allowed him to play, during the regular season.
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
@Pandamatrix85: Also, holding Manning's postseason record against him when your list is about the Top 10 QBs of the 2009 REGULAR SEASON makes no sense at all. Anyone who actually thought Brady was better than Manning in 2009 has to be full of it. While the topic of whose the better QB career wise is debatable, there is no question that Manning was better in 2009. Manning won every game in which he played all 4 quarters during the Regular Season.
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
The receiver fell down as he came out of his break on that pass. Watch the replay. How is that Manning's fault?
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
You base your rankings to much off stats. For example look at the talent around Manning this year. He made two first year starters look good. You cant just base things off stats.
Niners8016 2 years ago
@Niners8016 I also based it on who they played and what they had to work with and miscellaneous things as well
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
Colts played the 8th toughest schedule in the NFL according to FO, compared to Brees and the Sainst who played the 23rd toughest schedule. So that argument is stupid. The only reason you have him 7 is b/c you're a Pats fan.
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
Mark Sanchez should be on this list because he'll be the one holding the ultimate prize in the end. Stay HUNGRY Gang Green!!!
Qnz1kim 2 years ago
Sanchez should be on the list. He played good toward the end of the year but come on. The running game and defense got the jets to the AFC championship game. Sanchez cost them a few games this year.
Niners8016 2 years ago
@Niners8016 Sanchez had 12 TDs and 20 INTs this season he did well for a rookie but he still needs to improve to be a great NFL QB
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
Drew Brees all day
titox87 2 years ago
@titox87 he was the best QB this season and should've gotten MVP since MVP only goes to the teams with playoff bye or super bowl favorite, but I think if voters were smart CJ2K would get MVP
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
PEYTON MANNING NUMBER 7?????
guysdave1 2 years ago
@guysdave1 he threw 16 INTs that is terrible he throws too many INTs he barely has a 2 to 1 TD to INT ratio in his career
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
he's won more MVP's than any other player in the history of the nfl! He won more games than anyone this decade and he's about to win his second super bowl. Every quarterback throws interceptions! Brett Favre is one of the greatest quarterbacks ever (even though you hate him) he has more interceptions than any other quarterback. but he also has the most touchdowns than any other quarterback and more yards than any other one. you obviously know nothing about quarterbacks!
guysdave1 2 years ago
@guysdave1 uh buddy I know a lot you have no idea, MVP goes to best player on best team or best player on super bowl favorite or the guy media likes the best, the media likes Manning, for example they never tell you the bad stuff like 16 INTs and that the league kinda sucks this year so no one can finish so its like nah you win... ok, basically everyone sucks this year except for a few individuals(CJ2K, Brees, Revis, Woodson, Asante, etc.)
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
haha for a second I thought you said I have no idea...wow.
Anybody that has played the QB position will tell you that what Peyton does is incredible! Because he is probably the only guy that will throw 3 ints in a game and win it! He can read blitzes better than anybody. MVP stands for most valuable player...there's a reason he got 39 of 50 votes, you take Peyton away from the colts, they'd most likely be 2-14, not 15-2! They'd be watching the sb instead of playing in it in two weeks!
guysdave1 2 years ago
@guysdave1 if weren't for the INTs Manning's winning percentage(career) would be the highest in NFL history however he makes mistakes and it costs his team games, f it weren't for the mistakes and surprisingly low career win percentage then he would be the best of all-time
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
@Pandamatrix85: No it wouldn't. If he had a defense that could stop the other team on third down and get him the ball back then he'd have the highest winning percentage in NFL History. Plus 7 of his 16 picks came on tipped passes, and 2 others came on plays where Wayne ran the wrong route.
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
He has the highest TD:int ratio in NFL History. What are you talking about??? 16 ints. when every single team knows you're going to throw the ball is not that bad at all. That's like 1 int a game. big deal.
P0RKINS2 2 years ago
what do you have against favre
mark12345671 2 years ago
i dislike him because where I live everyone thinks he's the best ever and constantly put me down cause i like Brady, Favre actually isn't the best ever infact he's nowhere close he's one of the biggest chokers in NFL history when I think Favre I think INTs pick sixes and choking late in games and he's all-time INT leader
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago
touche
mark12345671 2 years ago
haha its only fitting that favre ended the viking's season w/ an interception
Ralenissocold 2 years ago
good list i think ryan leaf is a good QB
mark12345671 2 years ago
@mark12345671 I think you mean Matt Ryan but his stats weren't very good this year, he was better as a rookie
Pandamatrix85 2 years ago