@mileycyrusmusic979 But...can you explain what exactly her talent is? I mean, Gaga is ugly like hell, but she can sing. And that's a talent. Her clips are epic, which is also a talent to act great in vids. Don't get me wrong, Britney is a very strong woman who had climbed a high mountain to receive all the fame, but she is not talented. Her producers kinda are...And btw, this isnt live
@mileycyrusmusic979 No No no! Aiigh?? i was cool wiff you wit the love u britt but wen yuh fuckiinq said dan stupid lady gaga...dude ...fuckin crossed the line!
omg i saw a video of her singing opera on youtube haha!! it was actually really good! theres also a video of her singing im not a girl, not yet a woman on here with her real voice its really good!
That's why she doesn't like singing live. I wish Jive hadn't interfered. But I don’t know. If they hadn’t, Britney probably wouldn’t be the megastar icon we know today. But if she had waited a while, and hadn’t made her debut till she was 21 or 22, fashions in music would almost certainly have been different and she could have built her career on performing in her natural way. I hope one day she sings with her natural voice live on stage to shut everyone up!
Britney’s friends reported them as saying that Britney’s “real” voice, her natural voice, is bluesy and soulful, and that performing live using the BOMT-style voice was very difficult for her because it was so unnatural. Larry confirmed that when she arrived at Jive her voice was “deep” and “powerful” but not very commercial. This was a time when record companies didn’t want a young white girl soul singer, they wanted a young white girl pop singer to reinvigorate the teenage audience.
im sorry but everything about Britney spears just irritates me...
i give her credit ... she's soooooo successful.. good on her.
but my god... auto tune in every song?!... lip syncing in every performance?!.. when will her record label realise it would be so much easier for them just to get someone who is NATURALLY talented..
and another thing... Everytime is the first song she wrote!??? why is she even famous.. some singers have been wrtiting from the age of 10...
@samiijanee0987 No its not that first song dumb ass? ''In the zone album'' she co-wrote all the songs except ''Toxic''. She wrote a few songs on ''Britney'' and on ''Circus'' and she wrote half the songs on ''Blackout'' and she wrote a song on ''Oops I did it again.'' and she wrote a song on ''Femme Fatale'' and no she don't always use auto-tune so maybe you should get the fuck out and learn your shit. and she don't Lip sync every performance
@samiijanee0987 Um Maybe if you were not such a dumb ass: This ''Song'' came out 2001 when her ''3rd studio album came out. and It was her ''First'' song that she has ever wrote. Then Came '' In The Zone'' which then she wrote half of almost the whole album and few songs on ''Blackout. Then a couple on ''Circus'' which came out in 2008. (Blackout 2007) and then ''Femme Fatale.''
@BritneySpearsFan445 Is that an achievement for you? wow... Well.. like i said.. was just going by WHAT BRITNEY SPEARS SAYS ON THE VIDEO ABOVE! But if its that important to you... you win... shall i send you a medal? whats your address?
She isn't singing live in this, its lip-syncing. I love Britney Spears and she is an entertainer as well as a good singer because she can sing. Its just people saying this is live, it clearly isn't.
Midway through the song, you can hear the backup track. However, amazingly to my suprise, she IS actually singing by herself to start the song. Actually, VERY GOOD.
she lip syncs because she insecure. everyone bashes britney on the littlest things. i bet if gaga missed a not nobody would care. but britney does something and its like the world would end. plus. all you people bashing this, why did you watch it if you hate britney so much? just a thought. i swear people have to much time on their hands.
@iVlogForYouToo she doesn't lip sync because she's insecure. That is the worst reason ever. She lip syncs because for the majority of her songs, she can't sing them well. It has nothing to do with bashing. Lady Gaga can sing, that's the difference. I'm not saying Britney can't sing, but she doesn't do it as well as others.
she did sing this live, but Jive (her record label) told ABC to play the original track over it when it was released onto tv. not because her vocals were bad, but because they wanted to promote the track.
@ninoriskitaufiki she did sing this orginally live, but they dubbed over the live vocals for the abc special. you can find the real vocals on youtube somewhere.
@nataliatju yes it is. dont get my wrong, britneys a sweet girl, and I understand she been going thruogh a hard time, but I just think she needs 2 take some time off singing, and take care of her kids. thats just my opinion.
@carloitao14 hahah noo those are the speakers. the sound is delayed when it comes out of the speakers. her mic goes straight to the camera and her the camera is also picking up the noise from the speakers.
I think she is singing? but the backing track is definitely playing, and very loudy, you can hear her voice, she can't sing just live. there isn't much of a voice there.
I don't know for sure, but I think she is singing live with the original track playing with it. She's singing along with the original track. If you listen very carefully you can hear the echo of her real voice in the background.
Right this does my head in because it is a slow song so why on earth couldnt she sing it live loads of people pay money to go and see her in concert and all she does is dance round a stage with a head mic on with a track playing lipsyncing to it !!!!!! i love her songs like but just wish one day she would surprise everyone and actually sing live cos you can see she is good by listning to her songs
Im sorry i wish she were singing, but listen to everytime at the onyx hotel tour, its live there, every concert from the in the zone dvd isnt live including this one...
Shes singing along to it u can hear i little bit of her real voice but its mostly a recording which is okay shes a great performer and singer when she tries :)
It's live. You can tell it's from the actual mic feed because you can hear the lisps in the s's and c's and the reverberations in the b's, d's, and t's -- sounds that are not picked up in a recording.
Excuse me? Why the title of the video is live singing if it isn't actually live singing. I like Britney but we have to be honest.
DHaNiTy 2 weeks ago
She prob thinking about Justin Timberlake here...
J+B a&f!
MariJenn267 1 month ago
why is she fat here?
MariJenn267 1 month ago
hey guys, thank u for watching my video !
This video is the combination between playing back and her real voice
So why ? She just wants us listen her song in high quality sound,
all u know that live singing made the sound of song goes bad ,and Britney so !
kingoflove2901 1 month ago
hey guy !dont mind if she is sing or just playing back.she is our fav singer so love her means love all thing about her :)
kingoflove2901 3 months ago 5
she sounds like something is dying
k2262991x 4 months ago
i love this song, but i just wanna know if she is actually singing. I love britney so dont get misunderstood.
IndigoStreetLights 5 months ago
i can't wait to see her next new song !
kingoflove2901 5 months ago
fav singer :)
neebs4lfe 6 months ago
I LOVE YOU BRITNEY,
britney has more talent than stupid Lady GaGa
mileycyrusmusic979 6 months ago
@mileycyrusmusic979 very right
ank24ravel 6 months ago
@mileycyrusmusic979 But...can you explain what exactly her talent is? I mean, Gaga is ugly like hell, but she can sing. And that's a talent. Her clips are epic, which is also a talent to act great in vids. Don't get me wrong, Britney is a very strong woman who had climbed a high mountain to receive all the fame, but she is not talented. Her producers kinda are...And btw, this isnt live
Mitsiooh 3 months ago
@mileycyrusmusic979 No No no! Aiigh?? i was cool wiff you wit the love u britt but wen yuh fuckiinq said dan stupid lady gaga...dude ...fuckin crossed the line!
MariJenn267 1 month ago
She looks beautiful, but she is so not singing live here, shes singing quietly along to a recording.
Pinkles666 7 months ago
Live??? Go to 2:25 HAHAHAHAHAHA! BRITNEY IS TRASHY : )
renataglamstar 8 months ago
@renataglamstar SHUT THE FUCK UP BEADY HESD ASS
kennethstops 2 months ago
Lol at 2:25 you can still hear her when she puts the mic down
JordanJSalem 9 months ago
I AM PISSED! I was at this taping and she sung live! YOU PUT THE STUDIO ON TOP OF HER VOICE >:(
willaboi07 10 months ago
like this if u love britneys voice is nice and you feel shes wonderful.!
FarhanaKay 10 months ago 2
she cant sing this is terrible
shoshoflo 10 months ago
she cant sing
shoshoflo 10 months ago
omg i saw a video of her singing opera on youtube haha!! it was actually really good! theres also a video of her singing im not a girl, not yet a woman on here with her real voice its really good!
CreepyboyProductions 10 months ago
That's why she doesn't like singing live. I wish Jive hadn't interfered. But I don’t know. If they hadn’t, Britney probably wouldn’t be the megastar icon we know today. But if she had waited a while, and hadn’t made her debut till she was 21 or 22, fashions in music would almost certainly have been different and she could have built her career on performing in her natural way. I hope one day she sings with her natural voice live on stage to shut everyone up!
TheBoomboom120 10 months ago
Britney’s friends reported them as saying that Britney’s “real” voice, her natural voice, is bluesy and soulful, and that performing live using the BOMT-style voice was very difficult for her because it was so unnatural. Larry confirmed that when she arrived at Jive her voice was “deep” and “powerful” but not very commercial. This was a time when record companies didn’t want a young white girl soul singer, they wanted a young white girl pop singer to reinvigorate the teenage audience.
TheBoomboom120 10 months ago
im sorry but everything about Britney spears just irritates me...
i give her credit ... she's soooooo successful.. good on her.
but my god... auto tune in every song?!... lip syncing in every performance?!.. when will her record label realise it would be so much easier for them just to get someone who is NATURALLY talented..
and another thing... Everytime is the first song she wrote!??? why is she even famous.. some singers have been wrtiting from the age of 10...
shes a lucky lady.
samiijanee0987 10 months ago
@samiijanee0987 No its not that first song dumb ass? ''In the zone album'' she co-wrote all the songs except ''Toxic''. She wrote a few songs on ''Britney'' and on ''Circus'' and she wrote half the songs on ''Blackout'' and she wrote a song on ''Oops I did it again.'' and she wrote a song on ''Femme Fatale'' and no she don't always use auto-tune so maybe you should get the fuck out and learn your shit. and she don't Lip sync every performance
BritneySpearsFan445 8 months ago
@BritneySpearsFan445 does she not say in this video that its the first song she wrote? do you know here better than she knows herself ?!?! woaaah!!!!
samiijanee0987 8 months ago
@samiijanee0987 Um Maybe if you were not such a dumb ass: This ''Song'' came out 2001 when her ''3rd studio album came out. and It was her ''First'' song that she has ever wrote. Then Came '' In The Zone'' which then she wrote half of almost the whole album and few songs on ''Blackout. Then a couple on ''Circus'' which came out in 2008. (Blackout 2007) and then ''Femme Fatale.''
So Get your facts Right
BritneySpearsFan445 8 months ago
@BritneySpearsFan445 your cute. Britney says so, so dont get so defisive ho bag :)
samiijanee0987 8 months ago
@BritneySpearsFan445 aww your cute.. Just listening to britney.
samiijanee0987 8 months ago
@samiijanee0987 ''What your mad at the fact I just owned you? So your gonna act like nothing happened
BritneySpearsFan445 8 months ago
@BritneySpearsFan445 Is that an achievement for you? wow... Well.. like i said.. was just going by WHAT BRITNEY SPEARS SAYS ON THE VIDEO ABOVE! But if its that important to you... you win... shall i send you a medal? whats your address?
samiijanee0987 8 months ago
@samiijanee0987 Yh you Shall :D
BritneySpearsFan445 8 months ago
@BritneySpearsFan445 thats makes sense.
samiijanee0987 8 months ago
@BritneySpearsFan445 that makes sense.
samiijanee0987 8 months ago
she actually has a beautiful voice!
willthacheerleader18 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
at 0:42 u can hear britneys real voice :-P
rachelxoxlovsxox 11 months ago
at 0:46 u can hear britneys real voice :-P
rachelxoxlovsxox 11 months ago
I am a Britney fan but this is obviously not her singing because it sounds exactly like the studio version I have on my iPod...
titanicgrl97 11 months ago 2
love it love it love it!!!
aww <3
nad18mcr 11 months ago
she's singing but the track is a bit louder.
OffWithYourHead97 11 months ago
AMAZING! OMG crazy.. Bitch is queen.
lukinh1990 11 months ago
she didn't need the playback she sounded so much better without it.
extraordinary2k1 11 months ago
shes nice to look at
julie101rox 1 year ago
She isn't singing live in this, its lip-syncing. I love Britney Spears and she is an entertainer as well as a good singer because she can sing. Its just people saying this is live, it clearly isn't.
lewisomar 1 year ago
i like britney but she sounds exactly like the track
VJSpaceCowboy 1 year ago
it´s not play back! OMG WAKE UP!
Billka1 1 year ago 2
fav song by her
ChiGirlBeauty 1 year ago
Midway through the song, you can hear the backup track. However, amazingly to my suprise, she IS actually singing by herself to start the song. Actually, VERY GOOD.
gmsoftball2009 1 year ago
play back....
cidlatino 1 year ago
Such a beautiful song..
xoxowicked 1 year ago
We can hear the second voice lol, fail !
6981487 1 year ago
she lip syncs because she insecure. everyone bashes britney on the littlest things. i bet if gaga missed a not nobody would care. but britney does something and its like the world would end. plus. all you people bashing this, why did you watch it if you hate britney so much? just a thought. i swear people have to much time on their hands.
iVlogForYouToo 1 year ago
@iVlogForYouToo she doesn't lip sync because she's insecure. That is the worst reason ever. She lip syncs because for the majority of her songs, she can't sing them well. It has nothing to do with bashing. Lady Gaga can sing, that's the difference. I'm not saying Britney can't sing, but she doesn't do it as well as others.
Hatchwork 1 year ago
@Hatchwork Watch Not a girl not yet a Woman at the AMA's, she can sing but she just cant do heavy dancing and singing at the same time.
Dylantog 1 year ago
you can tell she's actually singing live..ish. either way, beautiful performance.
BriBurns19 1 year ago
the 1st song she ever written, shame, i thought she wrote so much more before this, :/
TheBooZar 1 year ago
@TheBooZar Wrong she had writing credits on her 2nd album i think the song was dear diary.
poppykock1 1 year ago
@TheBooZar She's written a heap since this song, if that helps lol.
Outrajess 1 year ago
@TheBooZar does it really matter :/ as long as her songs are good, i dont even look up who writes it.
tinaford101x 1 year ago
love u brit!!!♥♥♥
mariadelux17 1 year ago
she did sing this live, but Jive (her record label) told ABC to play the original track over it when it was released onto tv. not because her vocals were bad, but because they wanted to promote the track.
xoflesh 1 year ago
@xoflesh excuses, excuses.
PurpleTheDog 1 year ago
@PurpleTheDog lol no. facts, facts.
xoflesh 1 year ago
@xoflesh Looolll... okay. wt evs. i think they would have promoted the track just as well if it was her normal voice.
PurpleTheDog 1 year ago
did anybody notice how big her ass is. omg
MyBritt17 1 year ago
@MyBritt17 YEEESSSS hahahahahahaha failwhale.
lolmumma 1 year ago
what a body what legs what thighs what voice what face what a lover what a Mom I love you Britany You are a Goddess love your voice and words
rddbba 1 year ago 2
One of her best songs ever
carliian 1 year ago
she is one hell of a lip syncer
dianasaurr 1 year ago
@dianasaurr She's not lipsynchin though se's singing along to the track
thebritneyfan09 1 year ago
we love it britney
britneydalenumber1 1 year ago
SHE LYPSINC THIS ISN'T SING LIVE!!! POOR HER.. I FEEL SORRY FOR HER...
HAHAHHAHAHAHA
ninoriskitaufiki 1 year ago
@ninoriskitaufiki she did sing this orginally live, but they dubbed over the live vocals for the abc special. you can find the real vocals on youtube somewhere.
speedobar 1 year ago
is it just me, or is the piano really load? also the guy playing its an idiot...
PenguinHairBalls 1 year ago
@PenguinHairBalls stupid. that wasnt the piano. its the harp...
PurpleTheDog 1 year ago
@PurpleTheDog What are you talking about? look at him at 1:36
MonkeyKing20I2 1 year ago
i never knew how pretty she was
NYRx0h 1 year ago
its such a simple song, and yet she lipsyncs. thats really slack brit
toocuteaaraj 1 year ago
@toocuteaaraj trust me, this isn't a simple song 2 sing! britney is the best! even if she doesn't sing live
nataliatju 1 year ago 2
@nataliatju yes it is. dont get my wrong, britneys a sweet girl, and I understand she been going thruogh a hard time, but I just think she needs 2 take some time off singing, and take care of her kids. thats just my opinion.
toocuteaaraj 1 year ago
@nataliatju I'm a singer, that song is really easy to sing lol
lostchild06 1 year ago
i've heard her sing live and she does sound kind of good!
why doesnt she just sing live-a lot of people do it regardless of how bad they sound!
BridgetHearts 1 year ago
they only put the real song to cover the real vocals for the tv broadcast but live on the set
crazyazncentral 1 year ago
this is not alive i'm sorry brit looks pretty though
stormieknight07 1 year ago
britney spears is a talentless woman
cant sing for shit
no talent
liob1611 1 year ago
@liob1611 oh fuck you
crazyazncentral 1 year ago
@crazyazncentral
go fuk urself u pathetic little cunt rash
liob1611 1 year ago
a back-up track was played and her voice was behind it... She was singing not that loud...
carloitao14 2 years ago 32
@carloitao14 hahah noo those are the speakers. the sound is delayed when it comes out of the speakers. her mic goes straight to the camera and her the camera is also picking up the noise from the speakers.
CAROxx33 8 months ago
I think she is singing? but the backing track is definitely playing, and very loudy, you can hear her voice, she can't sing just live. there isn't much of a voice there.
danmillerscotland 2 years ago
YEPE!!!
Geo7814 2 years ago
lip syncing so badly
InimashiTazuya 2 years ago
nOPE!!!
Geo7814 2 years ago
I don't know for sure, but I think she is singing live with the original track playing with it. She's singing along with the original track. If you listen very carefully you can hear the echo of her real voice in the background.
mitsura92 2 years ago 6
if you listening you can hear her voice behind the music
luispires1990 2 years ago
lip syncing
elegg111 2 years ago
ughhh, i really really wish she'd sing live, this makes the performance boring when she does this.
xbritneyxspearsx 2 years ago
i like this song but was she really singing? n not lipsing?
girlin7 2 years ago
lip syncing
BennyMetal7 2 years ago
shes not really singing thats BS!
chantallaforealla 2 years ago
she should write all her songs
anukik 2 years ago 3
nice playbacked go brit haha
Carta82 2 years ago
Right this does my head in because it is a slow song so why on earth couldnt she sing it live loads of people pay money to go and see her in concert and all she does is dance round a stage with a head mic on with a track playing lipsyncing to it !!!!!! i love her songs like but just wish one day she would surprise everyone and actually sing live cos you can see she is good by listning to her songs
Kylesinging4life 2 years ago
She was singing, listen to the reverb in the background and you can hear its different to the vocals that were dubbed over afterwards.
exmk000 2 years ago
Comment removed
Kylesinging4life 2 years ago
asabiia
still have doubts?
the best was to little face of 'trick you easy' on the end of the video.
LOL³
Liimoncella 2 years ago
is she singing alive? or playback?
asabiia 2 years ago
*live not alive LMAO
asabiia 2 years ago
she wrote this song for Justin Timberlake its the answer to cry me a river
laloms27 2 years ago 63
"The 1st song that I've ever written" ?
No wonder why it touched me a lot more than her other songs.
IMO only 70% of the performance was live.
28% was sing a long and 2% was
lip synching =)
Love Britney - Pop Princess!
Blueknightex 2 years ago 2
2:26 enough said, she can make breath sounds with mike away from her mouth?
yutopia88 2 years ago
I'm not obsessed with her lypsinging or whatever.. but this is not live?
feeensi 2 years ago
yes this is her singing.. and its not bad... surprisingly. and she probly ahs the background singers/track on. but yuo can here its her.
XAmandaXSotherlandX 2 years ago
she isnt lypsinging.
She lypsings because she is dancing and there would be alot of puffing but she is stayng steaady so she is proably singing with a back track
joeyx4x 2 years ago
Im sorry i wish she were singing, but listen to everytime at the onyx hotel tour, its live there, every concert from the in the zone dvd isnt live including this one...
RuuBjAh1 2 years ago
great Video, but she isn' t singing live ...
waltropica 2 years ago 4
yea i see her donk =]
datboywitdemvocals06 2 years ago
shes singing along. i love her to death but she is. you can hear the dubbing.
xohaylzxo 2 years ago 3
whatever.....
singing or not...
she is AMAZING....
o0jhAs0o 2 years ago 3
SHE IS REALLY SINGING LIVE
907869879 2 years ago
You can hear her singing, but the recording is louder than her.
HANDFRIER 2 years ago 3
Shes singing along to it u can hear i little bit of her real voice but its mostly a recording which is okay shes a great performer and singer when she tries :)
dylanray17 2 years ago
It's live. You can tell it's from the actual mic feed because you can hear the lisps in the s's and c's and the reverberations in the b's, d's, and t's -- sounds that are not picked up in a recording.
NindotJud 2 years ago
I dunno wa she actualy singing it thought??? It was defo wrote 4 justin tho!
dannyoxox 2 years ago
thats not live thats exactly the same like on her cd
irinasoflyy 2 years ago
2:26. you can hear her breaths but her mouth isn't near the microphone. she's lip synching
Cheezfuz92 2 years ago 4
sometimes youtube can mess up the audio when you download it so it might not be perfect but she isnt lipsycinig
actress4ever12 2 years ago
lmfao. 1:44. the guy's not even playing piano
Cheezfuz92 2 years ago
I think she's lip syncing. It sounds exactly the same on her cd. But I still love her.
POtriSHa89 2 years ago 4
she is
Cheezfuz92 2 years ago
she's singing along with the album track
GLGNicNatTiffChrys 2 years ago
*-* Love you Britney!!!^_^
pedrohsp2 2 years ago 3
yea they were such a gorgeous couple
thejerseygirl818 2 years ago
Britney and Justin reunite! It will never happen. But what if it did? All would be right in the universe.
smglvr13 2 years ago