I'm not a beginner but I love how nice and simple this look is. Everyone should have a few simpler techniques in their make up bag of tricks, just for those days when you're rushed or don't want to spend too much time making up but still want to look nice. Great video. But which manufacturer is it that makes easily accessible pencil brushes? I'm having trouble finding one... That and I'm also looking for eye pencils that accommodate someone with oily eyelids... :D
@yupyupyup012345 i'm irish so i'm really pale and have blonde hair and blue eyes, and they still look good on me, but i use different shades of brown instead of greys/blacks and only use black for the mascara.
@yupyupyup012345 yes darling, Smokey Eyes are meant to Enhance and bring life to your make up look as a whole. You can make it super smokey,or you can play it down, A smokey eye is a universal flattering look for every body. It's all in the blending technique you use to make it super dark and vampy, or just slightly smokey and sexy.
@yupyupyup012345 actually you know what I think a smokey eye can look good on anyone it just depends on the shade of the colour you're using. That's my opinion
ATTN: Beginners! YOU CAN afford the same (but different brand) brushes! They sell them at target or eyes lips face .com/makeup/brushes/single-brushes !!!! They are super awesome. I am a professional make up artist, and E.L.F not only has cheap products, but they work well and are very affordable for someone starting out. As far as her going fast, pay more attention to the strokes that she uses and follow her technique rather then what she says. Good luck!
Im sorry, but this is NOT a video for beginners. You speak so fast, and dont tell what you do, and you fast forward. I didnt learn anything from this video.
@botdflover143 you dont have to have an eye primer. you can use foundation, just take your ring finger and apply it lightly onto your whole eye and brow bone, and the bottom if your applying eyeshadow there too :)
Its a really pretty tutorial..Um i dont get why some of you people are getting so mad? like its a SMOKEY EYE for beginners! and who cares if it has black,alot of smokey eyes do.
Know wat u should do? Hmm say wat ur usin I had no fckin clue wat u were using nd too much brushes make it simpler! Nd sorry if I seem hatin but it's js confusing ok
@kellymowuvsyou im just saying a begginer isnt going to know what your talking about when it comes to professional brushes...they will most likely use the wand that comes with the eyeshadow.
Why would you use eyeliner WITH glitter pieces on the waterline? Sorry, not smart. A little glitter particle can get lost lost under one of the lids & it scratches the cornea. Been there. Took hours to get locate the little sucker & get it out.
Cant you just use tape for the sides of the eyes? It's more precise and you dont have to use a foundation brush to "clean off the fallout" its only gonna blend it in more.Other than that good video :)
I love this!! im a beginner i don't wear make up often at all and this was the only vid i found on here out of hundreds that was really easy to understand :P
@raiton0523 I've noticed even in professional stage makeup tutorials the models tend to look miserable. Maybe it's because they are trying to keep their face 100% immobile for the tutorial or wait for movement instructions from the artist, or maybe it's just not fun to have your face messed with for someone else to learn. Then at the end, they usually give a big fake smile. Lol.
some of you guys are so fucking negative you must rate these guys they try so hard and some of you guys dislike it thats hating you dont have nothing to say negative just go on i like this vid alot
My mother never bothered to teach me how to wear makeup, and I want to wear make up to school and not look like a clown, but this went way to fast for me
I've never worn make up before and you went so fast.. I coudln't keep up..
I have to admit I'm with the viewers that state this isn't very good for beginners. Most beginner makeup is not easily blended ... and while blakc smokey eyes are nice, there are some skin tones these color combos (and teqchnique) just won't work on. As for the brushes, she just convinced me NOT to buy sigma brushes. Every brush she used shed all over her model :/
This is a nice look. However, I was wondering if you could do a tutorial on someone with brown skin? That would be awesome. I've already seen a couple of tutorials for people with brown skin but the makeup just looks piled on.
You guys dont have to buy that exat brush to get the result so why complain? I used some random pallete that happend at have blaks and greys and they brushes it came with. Use what you have and use this video as inspiration:)
you know what im new at this and i dont really have those colors or brushes(just have black) and i tried this and i ended up makin a mess..this is not a good video.
@Pty1980 It's not the video , it's you . It's not her fault you made a mess. It's yours haahaa & also if you don't have the brushes go buy some at Wal-Mart or Walgreens. & also if you don't have those colors go buy them , ya trickk !!!
@Pty1980 Don't say thank you to her. The video was horrible. You can find way better info from a way better guru. Chin up girl. Keep practicing & you'll realize how easy a smokey eye is to do :)
i dont think beginners would have sigma brushes....??? i really wanna get a perfect smokey eye for a dance and im only 15. im not a professional and i dont have these sorts of brushes yet.
gd job but not so much 4 beginners... beginners mite b younger ppl and i dnt tink they no or hve the sigment or watevr eye shadow. try simple drug store makeup
i actually think this is one of the best tutorials for beginners i have watched on youtube. you explain thoroughly, this is a very easy technique. you may just want to work on your blending a bit other than that keep it up this is totally one of my best watched makeup vids. not to complex just fast and easy. thanks for that.
As a "beginner", it would be useful for me to know exactly what you used to apply the eye makeup (you spoke very quickly so it was difficult to note). I would have loved to see, either at the beginning or the end, a layout of all the tools you used (at one point, it felt like you had 10 brushes on the go - lol - don't forget ... I'm a beginner so it sounded like a lot when it likely wasn't - lol). Great video. I'm saving it for when I try my hand at the smokey eye. :)
This is a really great simple, just getting started smokey eye tutorial!
makeupbyalsenio 4 days ago
I'm not a beginner but I love how nice and simple this look is. Everyone should have a few simpler techniques in their make up bag of tricks, just for those days when you're rushed or don't want to spend too much time making up but still want to look nice. Great video. But which manufacturer is it that makes easily accessible pencil brushes? I'm having trouble finding one... That and I'm also looking for eye pencils that accommodate someone with oily eyelids... :D
BrianShine7582 5 days ago
if you're really pale, will smokey eyes still look good on you?
yupyupyup012345 6 days ago
@yupyupyup012345 i'm irish so i'm really pale and have blonde hair and blue eyes, and they still look good on me, but i use different shades of brown instead of greys/blacks and only use black for the mascara.
thatshannongirl07 3 days ago
@thatshannongirl07 Thanks(:
yupyupyup012345 3 days ago
@yupyupyup012345 yes darling, Smokey Eyes are meant to Enhance and bring life to your make up look as a whole. You can make it super smokey,or you can play it down, A smokey eye is a universal flattering look for every body. It's all in the blending technique you use to make it super dark and vampy, or just slightly smokey and sexy.
NicolesMakeUpChair 2 days ago
@yupyupyup012345 actually you know what I think a smokey eye can look good on anyone it just depends on the shade of the colour you're using. That's my opinion
ultimatkickinitfan 2 days ago
I Didn't Notice You Were Doing Someone Else's Makeup For This Tutorial Untill You Revealed Her =O
Craziisadiia54 1 week ago 2
nice job
sunrise556 1 week ago
does this work for blue eyes?
SuperChef1984 2 weeks ago
yeah....cant do this...I tried and looked liked I got punched in the face...probably the shitty makeup I have though..
srich83 2 weeks ago
ATTN: Beginners! YOU CAN afford the same (but different brand) brushes! They sell them at target or eyes lips face .com/makeup/brushes/single-brushes !!!! They are super awesome. I am a professional make up artist, and E.L.F not only has cheap products, but they work well and are very affordable for someone starting out. As far as her going fast, pay more attention to the strokes that she uses and follow her technique rather then what she says. Good luck!
TheShroomiedoomable 2 weeks ago
@TheShroomiedoomable Eco tools also has some nice brushes, reasonably priced and I like them better than e.l.f. brushes.
lilysregards 1 week ago
what do we do if we don't have eyes
productions011 3 weeks ago 9
@productions011 HAHA! funnyyy
LiliSings12 2 weeks ago
thank u^^ that's perfectly worked!
tornada406 1 month ago
The only thing I would suggest since it is for beginners is to use a slanted eye liner brush for the lower lash line. Much easier to apply neatly.
Keithsangel 1 month ago
Great job this helped so much
jfishies 1 month ago
1. we don't care about other parts on her face or her lips...
2. beginners don't own these brushes
3. you talk to fast
and 4. .. you should of use liquid eye liner.
deemzzren1997 1 month ago
Im sorry, but this is NOT a video for beginners. You speak so fast, and dont tell what you do, and you fast forward. I didnt learn anything from this video.
troldebusk123 1 month ago
check mine out, i'm 4 :)
lillideridder 1 month ago
very pretty!
clschaan 1 month ago
i think the makeup is really nice would look even better if her eyebrows were more neater they could do with a wax lol
barbiegirl370 1 month ago
did anyone else hear Selena Gomez paying in the background? :)
lizziereynolds98 1 month ago 2
these are way too many steps for a beginner!!
lindaolwan80 1 month ago
Comment removed
lindaolwan80 1 month ago
#stupid question , but where can i buy primer ?
botdflover143 1 month ago
@botdflover143 I buy mine from kmart
darkglamour02 1 month ago
@botdflover143 you dont have to have an eye primer. you can use foundation, just take your ring finger and apply it lightly onto your whole eye and brow bone, and the bottom if your applying eyeshadow there too :)
goddessathotmail 1 month ago
jennifer lopez voice!
mimata180094 1 month ago
Why don't all you chill yeah? This is a very good tutorial.
LiliSings12 1 month ago
I hate her eyebrows and the make up too!! If it's for beginners don't use all kinds of brushes!!
Rubibella90 1 month ago
Its a really pretty tutorial..Um i dont get why some of you people are getting so mad? like its a SMOKEY EYE for beginners! and who cares if it has black,alot of smokey eyes do.
beegirl98 1 month ago
The camera is awesome..:D
emeraldseye22 1 month ago in playlist More videos from stillGLAMORUS
i can see the video camera in her reflection of her eyes
bricutie25 1 month ago
thanks 4 that foundation trick thanks
evelyn11942 1 month ago
she did great job the models was looking beatifull!
ruthiana1 1 month ago
Know wat u should do? Hmm say wat ur usin I had no fckin clue wat u were using nd too much brushes make it simpler! Nd sorry if I seem hatin but it's js confusing ok
louisemoore111 1 month ago
this was a good video stop hating haters
CORNFEDSRT4 1 month ago
if you're gonna do a beginners video then DONT use black..
you a color that is more...hmm.. common..
black is common but common... thats stupid.
ourfreckles 1 month ago
"And blend it up into the crease" Um no, all you did was add more product to cover the whole eyelid. There was no blending at all.
SoUrLookinHuh 1 month ago 4
makeup is very suitable for model :)
TheMISSbubbles93 2 months ago
really nice!
TheBelladonnaMorte 2 months ago
i like it! lots of haters on this wall!
carolvillacis2001 2 months ago
I love this look :) <3 Idk why this video is getting so much hate. all i can say to the haters is " Boo, you whores!!!"
spaceala 2 months ago 2
she has to fix her eye brows
Mayso0o 2 months ago
Your eyebrows are horrendous !
2liveonly 2 months ago
My vid has tips for BIGINNERS!chek it out:)
mireina13 2 months ago
Chek out my channel to learn how ro do a simple n cheap smk. I:)
mireina13 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THE BACKGROUND MUSIC IS SELENA GOMEZ, A YEAR WITHOUT RAIN!! FROM 3:45 3:54
Olivi41 2 months ago
Comment removed
Olivi41 2 months ago
Important thing to do this is to have good - perfect brushes!
Ketrin702 2 months ago
too dark .
zoeyifly 2 months ago
Comment removed
songbabe5732 2 months ago
@songbabe5732 um no if you don't follow the shape she shows its going to look like you just splashed black on your face
pinkfantasy9699 2 months ago
i was expecting a nice tutorial, this seemed very messy and unfinished .... poor camera quality and just a big grey mess :(
AnFChick85 2 months ago
People why not just get a set of brushes there only five bucks and decent for the price heck the ones from the dollar store get the job done
ulovemeandihateu 2 months ago
this is sloppy it looks like a big blob of charcoal. doesnt show different shades. anybody could do this.
prettynpinkfashion93 2 months ago 2
Why must they always have fancy brushes -__-
julienne202 2 months ago
this looks more like a dusty eye...
stretchy1nipples 2 months ago
A beginner only have brushes that they get from the eye shadow quad they bought...
KatharinePierce 2 months ago 124
@kellymowuvsyou im just saying a begginer isnt going to know what your talking about when it comes to professional brushes...they will most likely use the wand that comes with the eyeshadow.
Simpleplanqueen5 2 months ago
you shouldn't use eyeliner with glitter into the waterline!
LIVXX29 2 months ago 4
im eleven, and i still have almost all of thoughs brushes!!!
tweetNlee101 2 months ago
@tweetNlee101 what could 11 year old possibly need those brushes for. Are you sure their not your mums haha
Hattie1994 2 months ago 2
@tweetNlee101 Thoughs!? It's spelt THOSE!!!?
maya221985 2 months ago
Um, what if you don't have these brushes :b... I guess we're like screwed
MooMooMuffins1 3 months ago 5
u should be a make up artist. if u are then i want ur card or number or something cuz i definitly want u to do my makeup!!!!!
hotchixrule23 3 months ago
Shes So Pretty :DD
marisela14montez 3 months ago
Why would you use eyeliner WITH glitter pieces on the waterline? Sorry, not smart. A little glitter particle can get lost lost under one of the lids & it scratches the cornea. Been there. Took hours to get locate the little sucker & get it out.
summerblu 3 months ago
Ur model is pretty.... But video is too complicated but thanks anyways :)
jennisawesome000 3 months ago
thanks :)
ReesesDelux45 3 months ago
Pshhh. i didn't even know there were sizes of brushes. HAHA.
austinmahone3 3 months ago 4
@austinmahone3 haha dont feel bad all i knew were big and small brushes
twlighter1000 3 months ago
Cant you just use tape for the sides of the eyes? It's more precise and you dont have to use a foundation brush to "clean off the fallout" its only gonna blend it in more.Other than that good video :)
79julissa 3 months ago
your friends beautiful :)
weasel4ups20 3 months ago
I love this!! im a beginner i don't wear make up often at all and this was the only vid i found on here out of hundreds that was really easy to understand :P
Pineapplex1990x 3 months ago
too advance for a beginner like me...lol...too many layers..but i do loveeeeee the result <3
lintuxable 3 months ago
Your friends brow does not look natural it's supposed to look natural
Lululover122 4 months ago
wow...i wish you could do my make up
dancesonpoles 4 months ago
Great look but your friend looks miserable...
raiton0523 4 months ago 2
@raiton0523 I've noticed even in professional stage makeup tutorials the models tend to look miserable. Maybe it's because they are trying to keep their face 100% immobile for the tutorial or wait for movement instructions from the artist, or maybe it's just not fun to have your face messed with for someone else to learn. Then at the end, they usually give a big fake smile. Lol.
RachelHealthnut 3 months ago
100% Gorgeous...! An Absolute perfect beauty treatment..!
TheGoLdenEyedBeauty 4 months ago
i've watched a lot of smokey eye tutorials on here (mainly as i can never get the technique) and yours is by far the best! thank you :)
MissClaraLucy 4 months ago
the carbon doesnt look like it blends to well
liseebaby 4 months ago
Awsome :)
IngvildElise 4 months ago
Did anyone els relize she's listening to a year without rain by Selena gomez? Around 3:11 :)
NicholeLayne123 4 months ago
i wrote for the eyebrows before i saw the finally result so i was wrong!
msenallax 4 months ago
Comment removed
msenallax 4 months ago
Everytime I attempt this I look like I have a black eye.
GabrielaSparx 4 months ago 7
@GabrielaSparx same over here.
xxFameMonster 4 months ago
great job! at one point i thought you were overdoing it with the blush instead you blended it in so well in the end it looked natural. brava!
TheHummingOwl 4 months ago
some of you guys are so fucking negative you must rate these guys they try so hard and some of you guys dislike it thats hating you dont have nothing to say negative just go on i like this vid alot
sedorkbutterfly 4 months ago 3
veryyy niceee
badbidzi 4 months ago
I wish you actually did the makeup you have in the thumbnails
CoRtNZ1 4 months ago 2
The girl getting her makeup put on in this video, is soooo, soooo beautiful!
sunnylilme 4 months ago
what brand of make up do you use?
HookedOnVirginHair 5 months ago
what brand of make up do you use?
HookedOnVirginHair 5 months ago
@HookedOnVirginHair she uses "Still Glamorous Cosmetics"
DominiquesUniques 4 months ago
u made it so easy!
haneefah16 5 months ago
i heard selena gomez song in the backround
HEYitsAlexBest 5 months ago
very nice!
sosofine06 5 months ago
Blech. This video was overly complicated. Smoky eyes do NOT have to be that much work. Ridiculous.
Lexxieable 5 months ago
I'm sorry, but your friend Renee has terrible eyebrows.
highnotelownote 5 months ago
@highnotelownote are u crazy?? i actually loved her eyebrows o:
GrannyCannibal 5 months ago 5
im a beginner and i thought it was confusing with all the blending, different colors and brushes and the contouring. but very pretty :)
charleesedg 6 months ago
a beginner doesnt really care about the brushes
Simpleplanqueen5 6 months ago 180
@Simpleplanqueen5 Then how else do you do your make up , finger ?
kellymowuvsyou 2 months ago
@Simpleplanqueen5 nor do that have MAC makeup lol
Sassygirl7018 2 months ago
@Simpleplanqueen5 If you don''t care about the brushes, you'll allways be a beginner.
ThePammylife 1 month ago 42
um did no one else notice the look from the picture of the video is totally different than this one.
mckennawilsonmarlow 6 months ago 64
That was the BEST smokey eyes I've ever seen! :) But wow, eye liner pencil looks PAINFUl:(
Luisinthehouse 6 months ago 2
My mother never bothered to teach me how to wear makeup, and I want to wear make up to school and not look like a clown, but this went way to fast for me
I've never worn make up before and you went so fast.. I coudln't keep up..
dustymew 6 months ago 2
I have to admit I'm with the viewers that state this isn't very good for beginners. Most beginner makeup is not easily blended ... and while blakc smokey eyes are nice, there are some skin tones these color combos (and teqchnique) just won't work on. As for the brushes, she just convinced me NOT to buy sigma brushes. Every brush she used shed all over her model :/
vbodimer 6 months ago 2
It's really hard for me because I can only see with my left eye but this actually helped! thanks a lot! <3
SweChic1997 6 months ago
This is a nice look. However, I was wondering if you could do a tutorial on someone with brown skin? That would be awesome. I've already seen a couple of tutorials for people with brown skin but the makeup just looks piled on.
Ashkizzy 6 months ago
This is awesome i did it!
im only 14.. :D
it was so easy!
You guys dont have to buy that exat brush to get the result so why complain? I used some random pallete that happend at have blaks and greys and they brushes it came with. Use what you have and use this video as inspiration:)
pinkeelou 6 months ago 3
your "S" eco! lol.
OhWowLovelyXx0 7 months ago
the only thing i paid attention too really besides this awesome turtial was the music in the back round playing a year without rain selena gomeez(:
dezilulu08 7 months ago
you know what im new at this and i dont really have those colors or brushes(just have black) and i tried this and i ended up makin a mess..this is not a good video.
Pty1980 7 months ago
@Pty1980 It's not the video , it's you . It's not her fault you made a mess. It's yours haahaa & also if you don't have the brushes go buy some at Wal-Mart or Walgreens. & also if you don't have those colors go buy them , ya trickk !!!
BahahaItsMe 6 months ago
@BahahaItsMe thanks hahahaha i guess i just didnt get the vid i guess.:)
Pty1980 6 months ago
@Pty1980 Don't say thank you to her. The video was horrible. You can find way better info from a way better guru. Chin up girl. Keep practicing & you'll realize how easy a smokey eye is to do :)
tknicol 6 months ago
@Pty1980 I sent you a message with a link to a WAY better tutorial....enjoy
tknicol 6 months ago
@tknicol thanks.:D
Pty1980 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE CHECK OUT MY CHANNEL, IM NEW,, THANKS DOLLS <3
makeupbysasha 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
please check out my page guys,, im new and i need views (:
makeupbysasha 7 months ago
i dont think beginners would have sigma brushes....??? i really wanna get a perfect smokey eye for a dance and im only 15. im not a professional and i dont have these sorts of brushes yet.
claire2shae9696 7 months ago
absolutley GORGG! Love it! Subscribed! sub to miine?
Jennalenna8 7 months ago
you have colored eyes..........just sayn
ayeshalakhani1 7 months ago
I love that you are so effective in this video, but yet you explain everything well :):) Nice tutorial :):)
95elisabeth 7 months ago
NEW SUBSCRIBER!
LACEandSHOES 7 months ago
i dont have alot things u used in this video such as the brushes and primers
BarbieeBeautyy 7 months ago
lalalalal
nena1OK 7 months ago
Really disappointed in this vid... it turned out to be nothing more than a very cheap and porrly done infomercial for your cosmetics.
aussiedonna50 9 months ago
awww she looks so pretty!!!!
nettibetti4 9 months ago
excellent!
hameedahmajeedah 9 months ago
gd job but not so much 4 beginners... beginners mite b younger ppl and i dnt tink they no or hve the sigment or watevr eye shadow. try simple drug store makeup
xZzLoLzZx 9 months ago
Wow lovely eyebrows! Gorgeous arch!
ColorMeVicious 9 months ago
i actually think this is one of the best tutorials for beginners i have watched on youtube. you explain thoroughly, this is a very easy technique. you may just want to work on your blending a bit other than that keep it up this is totally one of my best watched makeup vids. not to complex just fast and easy. thanks for that.
Ngaenkaf 9 months ago 58
this is great to learn from - thank you! x
yourdarkangel95 10 months ago
excellent tutorial!!
great tips and easy to follow!!!
101lizzo 10 months ago
I wish I had your eyebrows. Amazing amazing amazing. :D
iinaaiin 11 months ago
im from arizona too!!!
anime1lvr 11 months ago
love the look but that crease of concealer under her eye bugs me hahaa,
SymphonySun 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she looks beautiful
yellybell04 11 months ago
that is SO pretty :)
BeatleBiter 1 year ago
I don't like this "smoky eye" because the shadow looks too "greenish" and don't know what color it is.......
jvaldesmonge 1 year ago
yu're gud
deepikafan1 1 year ago
I'm sorry, but it's somewhat annoying to hear "Still Glamorous Cosmetics" over and over in each video.
enj0ythesiIence 1 year ago 3
Lizette762 ik ook! Mooi!
bluemonkey1999 1 year ago
dit ga ik proberen!
lizette762 1 year ago
lol...a year without rain in the background
it looks great on her kasey
AaAmInA1998 1 year ago
thumbs up if u tried this look after tha video!!!:D
DairyOfAnEmoGirl 1 year ago
Haha your model looks like my friend Sonia. lol
sparkyskooter911 1 year ago
As a "beginner", it would be useful for me to know exactly what you used to apply the eye makeup (you spoke very quickly so it was difficult to note). I would have loved to see, either at the beginning or the end, a layout of all the tools you used (at one point, it felt like you had 10 brushes on the go - lol - don't forget ... I'm a beginner so it sounded like a lot when it likely wasn't - lol). Great video. I'm saving it for when I try my hand at the smokey eye. :)
WithTheseCurls 1 year ago 72
@WithTheseCurls watch michelle phan's videos...they are easy to understand...
liimepva 8 months ago
Very well blended and gorgeous glam
TheBresee 1 year ago
too much work
MrsJenovaStrife 1 year ago
I wish I had a makeup artist like you to do my makeup for me :D
maikor3 1 year ago
Don't take this the wrong way, but she's pretty for her size
She's gorgeous
Kasspyr 1 year ago
The model is very very pretty :)
gianellaaaa 1 year ago
great job!!
Jadaline001 1 year ago
Seriously! Anybody ever told you you look just like Angelina Jolie!!!
destinysliter 1 year ago
Great look. I love the closeup as well.
Helpful2You 1 year ago
Love the vid! It helped alot.
What mascara did you use?? I think it works really well! Plz reply :)
Inuyashalover921 1 year ago
Very pretty just wondering if the cream eyeshadow creases?
vampiresiren2 1 year ago
She is stunning
XxiloveGWxX 1 year ago
Models really pretty ...
xxxxumairaxxxxx 1 year ago
It is kind-of creepy cause u see the whole skin moving.. lol
but very nice make up !! [=
FabuLols 1 year ago
I sometime looks creepy cause u see the skin moving.. LOL :D
FabuLols 1 year ago
love the tutorial really helped me with my smoky eye alot
HelloMinaa 1 year ago
niice video,liked the close-ups and how u explain things... gonna check out yur sites
tylerdeja 1 year ago
loveeee this look
Jeyika 1 year ago