Last night I watched Thieves Like Us. It was my first Altman film. It will not be my last. TLU is the finest film I've seen in.... I don't even know how long it's been since I've been so affected by a piece of cinema, so eneveloped in the time and place and characters presented. The best directors, like the best writers, are really magicians at heart, and with TLU Altman performed the greatest trick of all: time-travel. If any of his other films approach TLU's mastery, I'm in for something good.
i love his association of a film being like a painting. A beginning, a middle, and an end. An overall feeling at first view, that leads to an grander, deeper context that is hidden and slippery subjective. intended or not.
I'm not as big on Altman as others, but McCabe and Nashville are complete masterpieces. McCabe is one of the best looking films of the 70's. Nashville was one of the most advanced in terms of story telling. it was decades ahead of its time.
@lamentate07 M'cabe and Mrs.Miller was great for the usual Hollywood Narrative Style. Nashville, The Player, Short cuts etc. are his own style. Washing American dirty linen in public, that no one has done better.
@lamentate07 Sorry you may be right, I haven't seen Mcabe and Mrs Miller since it was made, I remember it was very realistic but lacked the sarcasm of his later work. Where one sees the directors opinion of contemporary society in general. It of course is a matter of opinion. For example I don't like Italian realism in art. To me its more a craftsman ship, I prefer the French impressionists who interpreted it their way.
@RonAlmeida i agree with you that it lacks the sarcasm of his later work, definitely, but the film is apparently meant be a critique of the frontier and modern cut throat capitalism, so Altman is giving his opinion on 'contemporary society'.
@lamentate07 Sorry you may be right, I haven't seen Mcabe and Mrs Miller since it was made, I remember it was very realistic but lacked the sarcasm of his later work. Where one sees the directors opinion of contemporary society in general. It of course is a matter of opinion. For example I don't like Italian realism in art. To me its more a craftsmanship, I prefer the French impressionists who interpreted it their way.
Last night I watched Thieves Like Us. It was my first Altman film. It will not be my last. TLU is the finest film I've seen in.... I don't even know how long it's been since I've been so affected by a piece of cinema, so eneveloped in the time and place and characters presented. The best directors, like the best writers, are really magicians at heart, and with TLU Altman performed the greatest trick of all: time-travel. If any of his other films approach TLU's mastery, I'm in for something good.
CastleRockFan 1 week ago
i love his association of a film being like a painting. A beginning, a middle, and an end. An overall feeling at first view, that leads to an grander, deeper context that is hidden and slippery subjective. intended or not.
randallmckay 2 weeks ago
boom mic operator got fired after this broadcast
slangshotstudios 7 months ago 2
Where was the clip from 'Mash' screened that they had to edit the word 'Tits' out.
How can artists ever work in such censored constrictions? Western freedon is such a myth.
RonAlmeida 10 months ago
He was the greatest of the Hollywood directors, for me.
RonAlmeida 10 months ago
He was the greatest of the Hollywood greats, for me.
RonAlmeida 10 months ago
horrible boom job
kaufmanfan 11 months ago
horrible boom job
kaufmanfan 11 months ago
McCabe may be the best western ever made.
pedonbio 1 year ago
Now this is a true interview
rikicarneiro 1 year ago
I'm not as big on Altman as others, but McCabe and Nashville are complete masterpieces. McCabe is one of the best looking films of the 70's. Nashville was one of the most advanced in terms of story telling. it was decades ahead of its time.
lamentate07 1 year ago
@lamentate07 M'cabe and Mrs.Miller was great for the usual Hollywood Narrative Style. Nashville, The Player, Short cuts etc. are his own style. Washing American dirty linen in public, that no one has done better.
RonAlmeida 10 months ago
@RonAlmeida I don't know, there is plenty of Altman in McCabe. i wouldn't say it's the 'usual Hollywood style'.
I also prefer it to The Player and Short Cuts.
lamentate07 10 months ago
@lamentate07 Sorry you may be right, I haven't seen Mcabe and Mrs Miller since it was made, I remember it was very realistic but lacked the sarcasm of his later work. Where one sees the directors opinion of contemporary society in general. It of course is a matter of opinion. For example I don't like Italian realism in art. To me its more a craftsman ship, I prefer the French impressionists who interpreted it their way.
RonAlmeida 10 months ago
@RonAlmeida i agree with you that it lacks the sarcasm of his later work, definitely, but the film is apparently meant be a critique of the frontier and modern cut throat capitalism, so Altman is giving his opinion on 'contemporary society'.
I prefer more personal/commentary based art too.
lamentate07 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@lamentate07 Sorry you may be right, I haven't seen Mcabe and Mrs Miller since it was made, I remember it was very realistic but lacked the sarcasm of his later work. Where one sees the directors opinion of contemporary society in general. It of course is a matter of opinion. For example I don't like Italian realism in art. To me its more a craftsmanship, I prefer the French impressionists who interpreted it their way.
RonAlmeida 10 months ago
Does anyone know what year this was? I.e., what films had he or hadn't he made? This looks to me like 70s?
iluvnola123 2 years ago
According to IMDB January 21, 1972
studmufinn 1 year ago
Comment removed
pookie67 2 years ago
One of america's greatest directors. We need more people like him. MASH, Short Cuts, McCabe and Mrs. Miller, The Player, Nashville, 3 Women. Greats.
QuatermassMan 2 years ago 7
Altman was/is a true great
DanielBowden1975 2 years ago 11
RIP Robert Altman
peeron 3 years ago 13
yeah man thnx again - love these cavett posts
djpancake 3 years ago 2
Thank you for posting this. Do you have any more of this interview?
TheGoldenPot 3 years ago
Three Women was probably Altman's most indescribable film.
chapaev36 3 years ago
I agree.. like an actual dream magically put on film
rumisays 3 years ago 3
Thankyou for this. If anyone wants more Altman check my playlists.
matt7333 3 years ago