Give them a little break, everybody who got something to do with music knows it's playback. So freakin what? That's just the way it goes, TV shows often REQUIRE that, because of the costs and time-saving.
At least those girls don't make such a fuss out of it. Look at frikkin Madonna and her Sweet&Sticky Tour, not all songs are from playback, but some definitely.
this is playback, its in perfectly sync with the original song, and thats quite impossiable to get the right beats per second down live lol either that or they are the best live performers ive ever seen to sound exactly like the record.. lol
@66ALicEiNCHaiNS06 actually the drummer could just have a physical metronome or click track in an earpiece, but yes lol, it's definitely lip synched and not live instruments
am i the only one who doesn't care whether or not the damn thing is playback? like honestly who gives a shit -_- there are other videos of them actually singing live if this particular video bothers you so much. geez.
@painfullydeath .. Na they're not lesbian, they just pretended to be back then for more attention. Yulia has 2 children. It's weird they pretended for extra attention though cause they were only 18 and 19 years old back then and were smoking hot.
@painfullydeath ...Feeling satisfied with his choices, Shapovalov signed Yulia and Lena to t.A.T.u., but the contract with Shapovalov also demanded that the girls present a lesbian image. After breaking away from Shapovalov in 2004, the girls came clean and stated that Shapovalov had created the lesbian image, and that they were even told what to say in interviews and parted ways with Shapovalov..this was taken from wiki as proof they were not lesbian. They're still hot though =)
@xAnnaVelvetXx ... Many singers don't sing live these days. Tatu has more of an excuse than the others though. You have to remember these ladies are Russian and English isn't their first language. Maybe they didn't feel comfortable/confident singing live in English as in the Studio obviously you can have alot of tries to perfect the English
@MissMessi1 They faked being lesbians for attention. Their first ex-manager forced them to. And what's so gross about being homosexual or bisexual or pansexual? I'm heterosexual (straight) but I love them for their individuality! They disbanded this year.
@CatholicKnight428 Would you care to show me proof of these so called "leading psychologists"? The worlds scientists are in agreement that sexual attraction is fixed and cannot be chosen, you can choose your behavior, but not your attraction. Dr. Qazi Rahman of the Queen Mary University of London School of Biological and Chemical sciences conducted a study and have found the homosexuality is not a choice, supporting what scientists already say. You have nothing but fake religious propaganda.
What ever happened to toleration? It's the darn religious idiots who are poisoning your minds with the lies about the gay/lesbian/transgendered people. They are like you and me, a human being. I was raised Catholic and I was taught to hate gays, but I don't hate. That's why I left the Catholic Church. I have a gay friend, does that make me a sinful person? So, we've all made bad decisions at one time or another. That still doesn't give religious idiots to bash them. Way to go, Tatu.
Okay to everyone out there that are fighting saying that you are not born gay. First of all you are not born gay. People make choices in life right. Right. So then when people say that they were born that way. Its wrong they were not born that way. They made the CHOICE to experiment. With the same gender. Yeah okay I am thinking people dont realise that they are choosing that choice but once its done its done. They made the choice to be gay. And when they made that choice
@narutoxhinata98 That's not true. Proof? When the hell do you ever choose who you love? Nobody simply chooses, love is like an instinct, you can't simply choose to be homosexual or heterosexual.
You have a very eschewed view on sexuality. Yes, the choice to have date someone or have sex with someone of the the same gender is a choice, but people don't choose to HAVE sexual attraction to the same gender!! Sexual attraction and having sex are two completely different things! Nobody makes the choice to BE gay, but they make the choice to be happy and be who they are. You have NO right to say stuff like this when you are so obviously uneducated about human sexuality.
@narutoxhinata98 I've never experimented with guys, nor had any gay influences growing up, I've always been attracted to guys for seemingly no explanation other than it was something I was born with. You have no evidence or proof to back up your claims either. While there's a mountain of evidence supporting mine.
@CatholicKnight428 You didn't answer my question. And I don't care what your fucking science is saying, I know that gay people are born gay, can't do anything about it and NEED to be treated just like anyone else. There is nothing abnormal about that.
@CatholicKnight428 Really? A choice...C'MON THINK A LITTLE! Do you know what gay/bi people have to go through? Not just people making fun of them, they're also bullied and some are even KILLED! So why would ANYONE choose to be gay? Tell me.
@CatholicKnight428 Ok, say what you wanna say, but this is what I say: they have nothing to be sorry for!!! They're BORN THAT WAY! They can't help it! GOD made them like that! And God wouldn't want people to live with no chance at love, now would He?
@CatholicKnight428 Age doesn't matter. I know everything I need to know. And one of the things I know is that God made us all equals and loves everybody no matter what.
@CatholicKnight428 Being gay is NOT a sin! Anyone has the right to love whoever they want! There isn't a difference between heterosexual and gay couples, it's LOVE! And it's not wrong! If you love someone, you love someone and that's it!
@XChocolateCuttieX THIS. Even though I'm a straight girl, I love this song and band for being who they are (even though they were acting). I even have a lesbian friend, bi friend, and pan friend.
@CatholicKnight428 I go to school, and I have never seen an activist forcing anything on children. I'm sure it happens, or exists, but its more targeted to adults. Besides, there's bigger issues in the world like the economy possibly crashing again. Also, I find religion a more touchy subject. I went to my SPANISH class with two Christian kids and saw them arguing over and over about their faith. One eventually left the Christian faith, and the other said he was going to hell. Good kids, no?
@CatholicKnight428 Nah, supposedly they weren't even legally married. Yulia called it a ''civil marriage'' as they still lived together but apparently didn't have an official ceremony. I'm not sure if they actually did eventually have one, but I'm sure they separated. On top of that, homosexuality is the SLIGHTEST problem for children these days. Trust me, I just came from school...
@CatholicKnight428 Parviz was FAR from a nice man... He was the reason Yulia went from a naturally gorgeous, passionate, and self-respected young woman to an imitation with a face full of plastic surgery. Also, Ivan destroyed her voice and almost their careers when he was more focused on scandals and not their music. Lena has stayed by Yulia's side for YEARS, and didn't even get mad when Yulia insulted her project. They're actually still good friends and went to an award show together.
wow screew all trying to preach! sarah palin does the same thing but oh wait you havent read the new book saying that she did drugs, promiscuous OOOHHHHH!!!!!
@CatholicKnight428 You don't get it do you? How many times do I have to tell you I DON'T WANT NO STUPID BIBLE THUMPER PRAYING FOR ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I don't NEED it, so get your head out of your butt and read wtf I'm saying. Also, you saying "God" this, "God" that, that is what I mean by shoving your religion down my throat. I DON'T GIVE A CRAP WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY ABOUT YOUR DANG "God" ALRIGHT?! Give it a rest!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@CatholicKnight428 You know it's found that I really don't give a crap what you think? (: I just can't stand being preached to about something I HAVE NO INTEREST IN!!!!
Omg, I DON'T NEED ANYTHING, BUT FOR YOU TO STOP TRYING TO SHOVE YOUR RELIGION DOWN MY THROAT.. HOW ABOUT THAT ONE?!
@CatholicKnight428 I understood what you were saying, but that's not the point. The point is that I don't want a bible thumper praying for me. -_- And I wouldn't pray for anyone if they asked me to anyways. Your life is your responsibility, make of it what you will. Screw your "God" ... "he" can smd. (I'm well aware that I'm a woman and don't have one, it's a figure of speech)
@CatholicKnight428 1st)If you're here for the music, don't read the comments if you don't agree with them okay? Great. 2nd)Re-read... I said, "why would I want you to "pray" for me?!" sooo, you have failed to make any point on that topic. ;) 3rd) I'm not replying violently, I'm making it CLEAR so you will UNDERSTAND it.. though obviously it didn't work. Now, as I said ... leave me alone!! (: Don't care what you have to say to me.
@CatholicKnight428 The fact is that I AM an Atheist, and when some religious NUT tells me, "I'll pray for you," OF COURSE I'm going to get irritated. It's like, HELLO did you not just read the part of me telling you I'm an ATHEIST? Why would I want you to "pray" for me?! It's not anger, it's common sense. Thinking about somebody is TOTALLY different. Just, shh now okay? Already in a bad mood. And if you think gay acts are so wrong, why are you watching this?!
@CatholicKnight428 No judgment is stating an opinion about somebody positively or negatively. Negatively in your case. Okay, here's a little logic for you.. your so called "God" supposedly created everyone (I think it's a bunch of bull). If it's such a "sin" to be gay/bisexual, why did "he" make them gay/bisexual? Obviously it's not as much of a sin as the bible/church makes it out to be. Again, rapist/murderers have NOTHING to do with this topic so stop bringing it up. Don't bother, I hate that
@CatholicKnight428 And no, I can't stand pedophiles or abusers. People screwing animals .. blah blah. That doesn't even RELATE to the subject. You're straight right? Why do you think that is? (rhetorical question) You can't answer even if I wanted you to. And "because I like men/women (idk your gender don't really care to either) isn't an answer. You were BORN that way. Just as gays/bisexuals were born the way they are. It's no worse than being straight. So go preach to someone else.
@CatholicKnight428 WHY is it a mistake to be in love? Just because it's not what YOU want it to be? I don't mean out of marriage, I mean IN GENERAL.. it's wrong for man and man and woman and woman, BUT not for man and woman JUST BECAUSE they can reproduce? That's a double standard. Um, I'm an Atheist.. "God" isn't love, LOVE is love. Two people who feel the same for one another. Gender doesn't matter. It's not wrong, it's right to be supportive of relationships gay or straight.
@CatholicKnight428 What an ignorant thing to say. NOBODY can help their sexual preference. It's just something that you're born with and takes time to figure out. It's people like you who make gays AFRAID to come out. They're afraid of what judgmental people will think of them. You know what? Screw your "God," I don't care if "he" approves of my choices. Don't care if people think it's a "sin." Yet it's not a sin when a man and woman have sex? Just man and man or woman and woman? That's wrong.
@xEternalSlumberx I approve of xEternalSlumberx's comments. :D I have a friend who is actually bi. She's not that orientation for SEX with both sexes. She simply likes both men and women. She's attracted to men, but she finds women easier to date. I also have a pansexual friend who likes EVERYONE, whether they're a gay male, lesbian, bi, trans, etc. I know I'm a straight girl into guys, but I'm not interested in dating at all. I'm not into girls, either.
@3cheers4Ger I'm glad you're not like these homophobic imbeciles now days. I can't stand when people are rude simply because the person doesn't like what they like. You can't help it.. it just happens that way. I approve of pansexuality, very much. What difference does it make if they're a woman, a man, hermaphrodite, an amputee, crippled, mentally incapacitated, transsexual/transgender, androgynous.. whatever! They're still people and deserve to be treated as such. Am I right?
@3cheers4Ger I'm glad you're not like these homophobic imbeciles now days. I can't stand when people are rude simply because the person doesn't like what they like. You can't help it.. it just happens that way. I approve of pansexuality, very much. What difference does it make if they're a woman, a man, hermaphrodite, an amputee, crippled, mentally incapacitated, transsexual/transgender, androgynous.. whatever! They're still people and deserve to be treated as such. Am I right?
@CatholicKnight428 You know, there's this thing called being bisexual. You know what that is? Liking both men and women. Lena and Yulia are bisexual, not gay. There's your answer. Their love was as real as any other. The fact that their manager made them express it in front of a million people, doesn't make a difference. And actually, gay women could have a kid with a man if they had it BEFORE they realized they were gay. I've seen that happen many times. I know somebody whose mom is gay now.
@sunkissedx21 even if you watch 100 videos of the same song in different places and shows, it is still playback... I've been looking for a real live video and this one is the most decent I've found
@sunkissedx21 No, they have a strict manager who makes them do or act in such a way. I don't really know much but that's what I remember hearing. Look it up (: I thought they were lesbians too .. XD
@brittanyS123 i concur haha.though the other ones not bad at all, like i'd def bang her, but yeah she's not on the same level as the black haired one (Yuli)
@NatsFan18 I don't mean lip syncing, I mean playback. some backing and principals voice are clearly in playback. just listen carefully, and while you listen watch carefully the video. you don't need to be a genius to notice that. sorry for my english
I was only 8 or 9 when I heard this song on the radio all the time! I had no idea what it was about but I sure as hell enjoyed it! I thought it was one girl. Then years later I turned 12 and found All About Us on youtube and found it was t.A.T.u.
I found this song and remembered it from when I was a kid. And that's how I got into the band. Now I have every English song and every Russian song except for Zachem Ya and Lyudi Invalidy.
Listening to the clip closely, I can hear the voices aside from the music. So, IMO, this is not being lip synced. It may look like they're lip syncing but they're not.
they are both bisexual...I am following lena on twitter and she said that she is bisexual and about yulia she said it lots of times...if you don't beleive me search lenakatinax on twitter you will have to find the tweet...good luck it's an old one
@pertonaty2 Took me a while, but I found where she told somebody she is bisexual and if Yulia asked to get back together she would. I hate when people say that it was all an act. You can't fake that kind of love... Yes their manager played a role in the on-stage affection, but they were together at one point and truly in love. Yulia found a guy though and Lena admitted she still loved Yulia and that it's hard for her to be happy for her, but she was trying.
there not lip synching there singing along basically just to give the double voice like in the studio version they didnt lip sync til like 04 and 05 i think mostly because of yulia her voice wasnt as powerful as it is here
Gotta Love them 2
TheDeanpayne 3 days ago
lena is kawaii^^
JuicyLuv100 1 week ago
how did lena get here hair like that
beanlovesledzeppelin 2 weeks ago 3
@beanlovesledzeppelin isnt it pretty?
tailsfox2021 1 week ago
@tailsfox2021 Yeah, it is. :)
beanlovesledzeppelin 1 week ago
@beanlovesledzeppelin i agree 100%
tailsfox2021 1 week ago
1:56 "cum on my face" Lololol
Yes, I know that's not what she really says.
rockanannie 2 weeks ago
the drummer is cute
tailsfox2021 2 weeks ago in playlist t.A.T.u
Its not live but its better than Ashley Simpson
slezy108 2 weeks ago
Its not Live!
Jfracaroli1 2 weeks ago
يـــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــا لبيه بس
ko00on2011 2 weeks ago
y dnt they sing live
przlilbarbie 3 weeks ago
mají pěkné pupíky!
svatapravda 3 weeks ago
Dont care that its not live.. they're so hot my dick starts dancing.
TheGamePube 3 weeks ago 4
they are so cuuute - the song is good as well... emotional
xlRagnarlx 4 weeks ago
POLSKA KUR*A POLACY WSZĘDZIE PRZEJMUJEMY YOUTUBE :D
Adrian21410 4 weeks ago
Give them a little break, everybody who got something to do with music knows it's playback. So freakin what? That's just the way it goes, TV shows often REQUIRE that, because of the costs and time-saving.
At least those girls don't make such a fuss out of it. Look at frikkin Madonna and her Sweet&Sticky Tour, not all songs are from playback, but some definitely.
magikbezdupy 4 weeks ago
i kinda like the russian version better XD
DarkBloodTyrant 1 month ago
gotta tell ya they are awesome! they did sing this. probably not this performance but they sing every single song.
DarkBloodTyrant 1 month ago
great song
rkyddd 1 month ago
oh my good beatiful ...speak english ? please.. =)
xXAuditionXx 1 month ago
سبحان الله و بحمده سبحان الله العظيم
iiABoSaLe7 1 month ago 3
is that a lip sync?
Leeanmarjon 1 month ago
3:09 she gets the tripod out of the way
Leeanmarjon 1 month ago
Best Playback ever! :D
andresmd06 1 month ago
this is playback, its in perfectly sync with the original song, and thats quite impossiable to get the right beats per second down live lol either that or they are the best live performers ive ever seen to sound exactly like the record.. lol
66ALicEiNCHaiNS06 1 month ago
@66ALicEiNCHaiNS06 actually the drummer could just have a physical metronome or click track in an earpiece, but yes lol, it's definitely lip synched and not live instruments
thedexterbros 1 month ago
The men in the crowd....dirty little pervs XD
HelloImBrownie 1 month ago
Ok, are using playback, which is totally obvious.
BarbaraKaulitzManson 1 month ago
thumbz up if u see it at 2011!
eitan45 1 month ago 9
uhh.. why is the top comment say 2011...its 2012 people!
JuicyLuv100 1 week ago 13
@JuicyLuv100 lmaoo
tailsfox2021 1 week ago
for all guys here they are'nt rlly lesbiens that was a sell trick but they was good at pretending.
eitan45 1 month ago
am i the only one who doesn't care whether or not the damn thing is playback? like honestly who gives a shit -_- there are other videos of them actually singing live if this particular video bothers you so much. geez.
prototyperick1 1 month ago 4
GOD, SO MUCH F***ING PLAYBACK!!!
saderlan 1 month ago
they really didn't kiss in that but they do kiss in real life and they love each other so stop saying they don't b/e they do!!
TeamDraco2 1 month ago
@TeamDraco2 ya know i do agree with you
assassinzrgamerz 1 month ago
I love this song and that is proof that all pop music is not crap ...... !!!
armandojuan64 1 month ago
the same dude has both Top Comments... thats impressive
dizon96 1 month ago
all the fishies sad
JessickaWithNoK 1 month ago 3
@JessickaWithNoK hahahahaha omg
hochrotex 3 weeks ago
Are they lesbian?
painfullydeath 1 month ago
@painfullydeath .. Na they're not lesbian, they just pretended to be back then for more attention. Yulia has 2 children. It's weird they pretended for extra attention though cause they were only 18 and 19 years old back then and were smoking hot.
gunnerforever89 1 month ago in playlist tATu Live
@gunnerforever89 they were actually 14. their manager made them pretend for publicity.
hochrotex 3 weeks ago
@painfullydeath ...Feeling satisfied with his choices, Shapovalov signed Yulia and Lena to t.A.T.u., but the contract with Shapovalov also demanded that the girls present a lesbian image. After breaking away from Shapovalov in 2004, the girls came clean and stated that Shapovalov had created the lesbian image, and that they were even told what to say in interviews and parted ways with Shapovalov..this was taken from wiki as proof they were not lesbian. They're still hot though =)
gunnerforever89 1 month ago in playlist tATu Live
they're sexy lol, loved it when they kissed :D
coralsummer1993 2 months ago
son las mejores .no saben cuanto las adoro.las dos hacen una hermosa pareja
vivianita380 2 months ago
It's so clear that this is not live... But whatever.
xAnnaVelvetXx 2 months ago 44
@xAnnaVelvetXx ... Many singers don't sing live these days. Tatu has more of an excuse than the others though. You have to remember these ladies are Russian and English isn't their first language. Maybe they didn't feel comfortable/confident singing live in English as in the Studio obviously you can have alot of tries to perfect the English
gunnerforever89 1 month ago in playlist tATu Live
@xAnnaVelvetXx i think it is live. but they don't sing sometimes.
berzerker123123 1 month ago 2
God, they're so beautiful!
bokii93 2 months ago 2
lol on fox no less
MrJumbolegz 2 months ago
i miss 98-2004 time of awesomeness. All i see now on tv is bruno mars and nicky minaj -__-
youxfail 2 months ago 2
@youxfail
Ditto.
EmotionIsMyFriend 2 months ago
surprisingly this sounds EXACTLY like the recorded song.
PerplexityStudios 2 months ago 4
perfect voice
is they're broak up or somthing ?
and wait a miunte
eew is they're a Lesbians ?
MissMessi1 2 months ago
@MissMessi1 I think we only understand english not gibberish. Try spelling.
peacelovehope12345 2 months ago
@MissMessi1 They faked being lesbians for attention. Their first ex-manager forced them to. And what's so gross about being homosexual or bisexual or pansexual? I'm heterosexual (straight) but I love them for their individuality! They disbanded this year.
3cheers4Ger 2 months ago
Ta bom de comer pra engordar um pouquinhoo... :P
nanamariamota 2 months ago
SOOOO BETTER THAN SEX!!
iluv777kstewart 2 months ago
if you watch....they never kissed
CatUmino 2 months ago 3
@334niyka Everyone forgets how extremely gorgeous and talented she is. I mean, look at her!
Gaaralver2damax 2 months ago
Comment removed
TrainToAlaska 2 months ago
Oh, I love this song, old music is better than music actually :C
DeeiLoveEvanescence 2 months ago
awesome simply awesome i dont know how to describe it any other way...
2121Anime 2 months ago
galera duas minas gostosas si bejando e o cumolo
kakatjf10 2 months ago
O pOr diOs ChiiCas las amOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOo ! ME ENCANTAN . . es Que sOn tan riCas :D y su vOs es tan waaaaaaaaaaO :)
karinaa43 3 months ago
@karinaa43 Fucking lesbiana, por eso las amas xD jejejeje
DalcFoxZero 3 months ago
i love them but they did lip sync on this one.. :(
korn8706 3 months ago 3
oe ta xvr el video pz,, no lo nieguen ..... ta rechido...pz...
llchessull 3 months ago
Comment removed
Awesomegals90210 3 months ago
Why are a lot of famous female singers lesbian...? :/ Just woundering, hope this didn't offend anyone.
Rinabu72 3 months ago
@Rinabu72
The same reason why male singers turns gay. It doesn't apply here.
GeorgeAzur 3 months ago
isn't there any act live of this song in which they don't do playback?
Lauuuris20 3 months ago
you guyz are starting to getting annoying with your bullshit talk, go take it some where else, we dont want to read your stupid azz comments
udizzle92 3 months ago 35
@CatholicKnight428 Would you care to show me proof of these so called "leading psychologists"? The worlds scientists are in agreement that sexual attraction is fixed and cannot be chosen, you can choose your behavior, but not your attraction. Dr. Qazi Rahman of the Queen Mary University of London School of Biological and Chemical sciences conducted a study and have found the homosexuality is not a choice, supporting what scientists already say. You have nothing but fake religious propaganda.
loveless3138 3 months ago
JUST ENJOY THE MUSIC isn't that why it's up here in the first place?
tobiitachishow1 3 months ago
Comment removed
tobiitachishow1 3 months ago
They are clearly hot as fuck. Please quit singing and pose nude.
wesbrownyeah 3 months ago
Comment removed
wesbrownyeah 3 months ago
What ever happened to toleration? It's the darn religious idiots who are poisoning your minds with the lies about the gay/lesbian/transgendered people. They are like you and me, a human being. I was raised Catholic and I was taught to hate gays, but I don't hate. That's why I left the Catholic Church. I have a gay friend, does that make me a sinful person? So, we've all made bad decisions at one time or another. That still doesn't give religious idiots to bash them. Way to go, Tatu.
TheViperDX 3 months ago
Okay to everyone out there that are fighting saying that you are not born gay. First of all you are not born gay. People make choices in life right. Right. So then when people say that they were born that way. Its wrong they were not born that way. They made the CHOICE to experiment. With the same gender. Yeah okay I am thinking people dont realise that they are choosing that choice but once its done its done. They made the choice to be gay. And when they made that choice
narutoxhinata98 3 months ago
@narutoxhinata98
That is a matter of debate. I've know homosexuals whom have tried to be straight but can't. Truth is we don't know, and honestly who cares.
TheJosephPrice 3 months ago
@narutoxhinata98 That's not true. Proof? When the hell do you ever choose who you love? Nobody simply chooses, love is like an instinct, you can't simply choose to be homosexual or heterosexual.
StarTrekkie1996 3 months ago
@narutoxhinata98
You have a very eschewed view on sexuality. Yes, the choice to have date someone or have sex with someone of the the same gender is a choice, but people don't choose to HAVE sexual attraction to the same gender!! Sexual attraction and having sex are two completely different things! Nobody makes the choice to BE gay, but they make the choice to be happy and be who they are. You have NO right to say stuff like this when you are so obviously uneducated about human sexuality.
luv4Aerith 3 months ago
@narutoxhinata98 I've never experimented with guys, nor had any gay influences growing up, I've always been attracted to guys for seemingly no explanation other than it was something I was born with. You have no evidence or proof to back up your claims either. While there's a mountain of evidence supporting mine.
loveless3138 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@CatholicKnight428 You didn't answer my question. And I don't care what your fucking science is saying, I know that gay people are born gay, can't do anything about it and NEED to be treated just like anyone else. There is nothing abnormal about that.
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 Really? A choice...C'MON THINK A LITTLE! Do you know what gay/bi people have to go through? Not just people making fun of them, they're also bullied and some are even KILLED! So why would ANYONE choose to be gay? Tell me.
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 Ok, say what you wanna say, but this is what I say: they have nothing to be sorry for!!! They're BORN THAT WAY! They can't help it! GOD made them like that! And God wouldn't want people to live with no chance at love, now would He?
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 Age doesn't matter. I know everything I need to know. And one of the things I know is that God made us all equals and loves everybody no matter what.
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 It's not any different than when a man and woman do it!
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 Being gay is NOT a sin! Anyone has the right to love whoever they want! There isn't a difference between heterosexual and gay couples, it's LOVE! And it's not wrong! If you love someone, you love someone and that's it!
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
@XChocolateCuttieX THIS. Even though I'm a straight girl, I love this song and band for being who they are (even though they were acting). I even have a lesbian friend, bi friend, and pan friend.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
@3cheers4Ger Me too :D And I have a pan friend too!
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
@XChocolateCuttieX...It IS a sin. But you are correct we do have the right to love whoever we want.
joshiesgirl26 4 months ago
@joshiesgirl26 How is it a sin?
XChocolateCuttieX 4 months ago
i wached this when i was 6 now im 16 and i still love this song
Shur1k3n5h0ts 4 months ago
Filth :)
ryanbird82 4 months ago
julia has a voice of an angel :D,\ plus she hot , i remember watching this on tv when it came out.....dam i feel old now and im still in my teens lol
udizzle92 4 months ago 36
@udizzle92 They're not actually singing.. gogo auto-tune and lipsyncing.
slntdrknss 2 months ago 2
@slntdrknss well they are doing a damn good job of it...wink...wink
purpleking15 2 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 I go to school, and I have never seen an activist forcing anything on children. I'm sure it happens, or exists, but its more targeted to adults. Besides, there's bigger issues in the world like the economy possibly crashing again. Also, I find religion a more touchy subject. I went to my SPANISH class with two Christian kids and saw them arguing over and over about their faith. One eventually left the Christian faith, and the other said he was going to hell. Good kids, no?
Gaaralver2damax 4 months ago
God, I love them! I was just 8 when I heard this and now I'm 17. I love Yulia just throws the mic.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 Nah, supposedly they weren't even legally married. Yulia called it a ''civil marriage'' as they still lived together but apparently didn't have an official ceremony. I'm not sure if they actually did eventually have one, but I'm sure they separated. On top of that, homosexuality is the SLIGHTEST problem for children these days. Trust me, I just came from school...
Gaaralver2damax 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 .....Really? Parviz was the second guy who she had a kid with.
Gaaralver2damax 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 Parviz was FAR from a nice man... He was the reason Yulia went from a naturally gorgeous, passionate, and self-respected young woman to an imitation with a face full of plastic surgery. Also, Ivan destroyed her voice and almost their careers when he was more focused on scandals and not their music. Lena has stayed by Yulia's side for YEARS, and didn't even get mad when Yulia insulted her project. They're actually still good friends and went to an award show together.
Gaaralver2damax 4 months ago
wow screew all trying to preach! sarah palin does the same thing but oh wait you havent read the new book saying that she did drugs, promiscuous OOOHHHHH!!!!!
udizzle92 4 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@CatholicKnight428 You don't get it do you? How many times do I have to tell you I DON'T WANT NO STUPID BIBLE THUMPER PRAYING FOR ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I don't NEED it, so get your head out of your butt and read wtf I'm saying. Also, you saying "God" this, "God" that, that is what I mean by shoving your religion down my throat. I DON'T GIVE A CRAP WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY ABOUT YOUR DANG "God" ALRIGHT?! Give it a rest!!!!!!!!!!!!!
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 You know it's found that I really don't give a crap what you think? (: I just can't stand being preached to about something I HAVE NO INTEREST IN!!!!
Omg, I DON'T NEED ANYTHING, BUT FOR YOU TO STOP TRYING TO SHOVE YOUR RELIGION DOWN MY THROAT.. HOW ABOUT THAT ONE?!
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 I understood what you were saying, but that's not the point. The point is that I don't want a bible thumper praying for me. -_- And I wouldn't pray for anyone if they asked me to anyways. Your life is your responsibility, make of it what you will. Screw your "God" ... "he" can smd. (I'm well aware that I'm a woman and don't have one, it's a figure of speech)
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 1st)If you're here for the music, don't read the comments if you don't agree with them okay? Great. 2nd)Re-read... I said, "why would I want you to "pray" for me?!" sooo, you have failed to make any point on that topic. ;) 3rd) I'm not replying violently, I'm making it CLEAR so you will UNDERSTAND it.. though obviously it didn't work. Now, as I said ... leave me alone!! (: Don't care what you have to say to me.
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 The fact is that I AM an Atheist, and when some religious NUT tells me, "I'll pray for you," OF COURSE I'm going to get irritated. It's like, HELLO did you not just read the part of me telling you I'm an ATHEIST? Why would I want you to "pray" for me?! It's not anger, it's common sense. Thinking about somebody is TOTALLY different. Just, shh now okay? Already in a bad mood. And if you think gay acts are so wrong, why are you watching this?!
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 "I'll pray for you" crap. I can take care of myself, I don't need the help of your "God."
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 No judgment is stating an opinion about somebody positively or negatively. Negatively in your case. Okay, here's a little logic for you.. your so called "God" supposedly created everyone (I think it's a bunch of bull). If it's such a "sin" to be gay/bisexual, why did "he" make them gay/bisexual? Obviously it's not as much of a sin as the bible/church makes it out to be. Again, rapist/murderers have NOTHING to do with this topic so stop bringing it up. Don't bother, I hate that
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 And no, I can't stand pedophiles or abusers. People screwing animals .. blah blah. That doesn't even RELATE to the subject. You're straight right? Why do you think that is? (rhetorical question) You can't answer even if I wanted you to. And "because I like men/women (idk your gender don't really care to either) isn't an answer. You were BORN that way. Just as gays/bisexuals were born the way they are. It's no worse than being straight. So go preach to someone else.
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 WHY is it a mistake to be in love? Just because it's not what YOU want it to be? I don't mean out of marriage, I mean IN GENERAL.. it's wrong for man and man and woman and woman, BUT not for man and woman JUST BECAUSE they can reproduce? That's a double standard. Um, I'm an Atheist.. "God" isn't love, LOVE is love. Two people who feel the same for one another. Gender doesn't matter. It's not wrong, it's right to be supportive of relationships gay or straight.
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 What an ignorant thing to say. NOBODY can help their sexual preference. It's just something that you're born with and takes time to figure out. It's people like you who make gays AFRAID to come out. They're afraid of what judgmental people will think of them. You know what? Screw your "God," I don't care if "he" approves of my choices. Don't care if people think it's a "sin." Yet it's not a sin when a man and woman have sex? Just man and man or woman and woman? That's wrong.
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago 2
@xEternalSlumberx I approve of xEternalSlumberx's comments. :D I have a friend who is actually bi. She's not that orientation for SEX with both sexes. She simply likes both men and women. She's attracted to men, but she finds women easier to date. I also have a pansexual friend who likes EVERYONE, whether they're a gay male, lesbian, bi, trans, etc. I know I'm a straight girl into guys, but I'm not interested in dating at all. I'm not into girls, either.
3cheers4Ger 4 months ago
@3cheers4Ger I'm glad you're not like these homophobic imbeciles now days. I can't stand when people are rude simply because the person doesn't like what they like. You can't help it.. it just happens that way. I approve of pansexuality, very much. What difference does it make if they're a woman, a man, hermaphrodite, an amputee, crippled, mentally incapacitated, transsexual/transgender, androgynous.. whatever! They're still people and deserve to be treated as such. Am I right?
xEternalSlumberx 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@3cheers4Ger I'm glad you're not like these homophobic imbeciles now days. I can't stand when people are rude simply because the person doesn't like what they like. You can't help it.. it just happens that way. I approve of pansexuality, very much. What difference does it make if they're a woman, a man, hermaphrodite, an amputee, crippled, mentally incapacitated, transsexual/transgender, androgynous.. whatever! They're still people and deserve to be treated as such. Am I right?
xEternalSlumberx 3 months ago
@CatholicKnight428 You know, there's this thing called being bisexual. You know what that is? Liking both men and women. Lena and Yulia are bisexual, not gay. There's your answer. Their love was as real as any other. The fact that their manager made them express it in front of a million people, doesn't make a difference. And actually, gay women could have a kid with a man if they had it BEFORE they realized they were gay. I've seen that happen many times. I know somebody whose mom is gay now.
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago
Yulia is so beautiful...
Journalisticdynamite 4 months ago
Yulia is a perfect work of art!
dallasguts77 4 months ago
*----* i love youuu!!
sanguidepotito10 4 months ago
they're so pretty!!! they make me jealous....
sademogirl423 4 months ago
this dont sound live xx
sunkissedx21 4 months ago
@sunkissedx21 even if you watch 100 videos of the same song in different places and shows, it is still playback... I've been looking for a real live video and this one is the most decent I've found
nenaermoza 4 months ago
are they real lesbians xxxx
sunkissedx21 4 months ago
@sunkissedx21 No, they have a strict manager who makes them do or act in such a way. I don't really know much but that's what I remember hearing. Look it up (: I thought they were lesbians too .. XD
Belldandy722 4 months ago
I bet Yulia's baby will grow up, watch this and be like.. "Wow, my mother liked women ;)"
Vip3rV1 4 months ago
the black haired one is hott as fuck. :P
brittanyS123 4 months ago 82
@brittanyS123 omg agree she is hot ! XD
johnringo1960 4 months ago
@brittanyS123 How can you say that? She looks ana...
shadows0614 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@brittanyS123 How can you say that? She looks ana...
shadows0614 4 months ago
@brittanyS123 The red-head one gots a fucking beautiful Booty haha
PimpinOnDaDaily 4 months ago
@brittanyS123 i concur haha.though the other ones not bad at all, like i'd def bang her, but yeah she's not on the same level as the black haired one (Yuli)
NatsFan18 3 months ago
@brittanyS123 Correction: was hot as fuck.
StarTrekkie1996 3 months ago 2
@StarTrekkie1996 ;; was? what does she look like now?
brittanyS123 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@brittanyS123 You don't want to know :S
StarTrekkie1996 3 months ago 3
something is clearly in playback.
littledrummer1994 4 months ago 43
@littledrummer1994 lip syncing? if that's what you mean, how can you tell?
NatsFan18 3 months ago
@NatsFan18 I don't mean lip syncing, I mean playback. some backing and principals voice are clearly in playback. just listen carefully, and while you listen watch carefully the video. you don't need to be a genius to notice that. sorry for my english
littledrummer1994 3 months ago
Are you sure that they're straight?
Bloodmagician32 4 months ago
@Bloodmagician32 Julia Volkova is bi.
Lena Katina is straight.
ExcellenceOfInnova 4 months ago
AWASOME!!! The keyboardist is a fuckin genius!!!! 1:25 - 1:48
AndyParty100 4 months ago 3
Lena!
RanKudou1 4 months ago
holy shit this takes me back when i 10
lilman9321 5 months ago
1:51 Just perfect.
StarTrekkie1996 5 months ago
я бы Юльке вдул...
MrTitanic22 5 months ago
Gosh...Sven has been with the girls for SO LONG!!! xD
Good he's still with Lena! <3 Sven!
SillehChar 5 months ago 2
I love Yulia Volkova ... miss her a lot
Rrodriguec 5 months ago
@Rrodriguec
Ikr? So much plastic over the years. I liked this face best. D:
SillehChar 5 months ago 2
lol i love this lesbes
danielle22389 5 months ago
El tecladista es otro pedo!!!
AndyParty100 5 months ago
I was only 8 or 9 when I heard this song on the radio all the time! I had no idea what it was about but I sure as hell enjoyed it! I thought it was one girl. Then years later I turned 12 and found All About Us on youtube and found it was t.A.T.u.
I found this song and remembered it from when I was a kid. And that's how I got into the band. Now I have every English song and every Russian song except for Zachem Ya and Lyudi Invalidy.
3cheers4Ger 5 months ago
Thumbs up if it hit the keyboard=)
hotasyellowsrt4 5 months ago
i LIKE this more than the video lol. very nice! (borat voice)
Chipocheet 5 months ago
gotta love the days before the earth's anus crapped out justin bieber and fucked up the music world
irongut12345 5 months ago 2
@irongut12345 THIS. t.A.T.u. was super original and started a trend. Katy Perry's "I Kissed a Girl" for example.
3cheers4Ger 5 months ago
THIS IS JUST STRAIGHT WRONG!!!!!!!!!!
DREAMCRAFTMOVIES 5 months ago
Straight, bi, whatever. This is amazingly hot.
LazyLosLobos 5 months ago 4
Listening to the clip closely, I can hear the voices aside from the music. So, IMO, this is not being lip synced. It may look like they're lip syncing but they're not.
HQHitmanPayne 5 months ago
they are both bisexual...I am following lena on twitter and she said that she is bisexual and about yulia she said it lots of times...if you don't beleive me search lenakatinax on twitter you will have to find the tweet...good luck it's an old one
pertonaty2 5 months ago
@pertonaty2 Took me a while, but I found where she told somebody she is bisexual and if Yulia asked to get back together she would. I hate when people say that it was all an act. You can't fake that kind of love... Yes their manager played a role in the on-stage affection, but they were together at one point and truly in love. Yulia found a guy though and Lena admitted she still loved Yulia and that it's hard for her to be happy for her, but she was trying.
xEternalSlumberx 4 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
ＳＨＵＴ ＵＰ ＡＮＤ ＥＮＪＯＹ ＴＨＥ ＭＵＳＩＣ！
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
Jayden1995 5 months ago
did they really sing this cuz' it sounds a lot like the clip.... a lot like the clip
truenight1000 5 months ago 2
it sounds like it's just the last verse sung live, or am I wrong?
Megamajz 5 months ago
there not lip synching there singing along basically just to give the double voice like in the studio version they didnt lip sync til like 04 and 05 i think mostly because of yulia her voice wasnt as powerful as it is here
OrangeCounty92 5 months ago
is it me or did are they lip syncing the song?
Luffymon88 5 months ago
i sooo wanna drop a finger in
rodnos76 5 months ago
im gettting a stiffy huhuh-huhuh
eddiemunster23 5 months ago
the song is Awesome... but you can tell they r str8... any homosexual ppl would kissed if they got that close (1:36) but its still an awesome song
littleguy15100 5 months ago
This was the first time I heard one of their songs when I saw this on TV.
PurpleNinjaCJ 5 months ago
good lip syncing...
mikehayz0 5 months ago 2
playback is wonderful
PedoPungPaaTur 5 months ago
all the guys getting turnt on by this..............lol
OrangeCounty92 5 months ago