In spite of the fact that this was used in a movie about Sarah Palin--that ridiculous, ignorant, hypocritical, substance-free epitome of what the American electorate has become--the performance here is not only worthwhile, but cheering...nice to know at least a few younger people are carrying it on.
The begining isn`t the Minstrel boy at all, it is The Son Of God Goes Forth To War, a cheap British rip off of the Minstrely boy. None the less beatuiful singing girls.
what I like to do with this vid is to open 3 browsers of it a sec after each other and listen to it in chorus.....
secondly..a big FCUK U youtube...theyve put a caution against it cos it apparently is potentially breaching copyright...WFT was written by Thomas Moore and he died in 1852. How the fuck can it be breaching copyright!
Wow love it , beutiful harmonics beutiful attitude, fair dues to your Mam and Dad for sharing their feelings with you, and to you for absorbing them and taking them as your own. Again wow, truly innocent. Thanks
I know Ive commented in the past, but you girls are well better than the first on the list for this search. You girls are so solemn and emotionally exact on the song that you girls should get first spot on search. I love you girls for this.
cannot find the scene, where sean connery is singing this song in the film "the man who would be king" . whould like to hear his version again..-)) i thought it is a scottish song, cause connery is a true scot!)) but it´s an original irish air!
Best version of this song ever. Much as I like Amhrán na bhFiann, I think Ireland missed out not making this their national anthem. Out of curiosity, why did you attach that verse from "The Son of God Goes Forth to War" on the beginning?
Found ths video after hearing the song in the film The Undefeated. Beautiful rendition of a beautiful song. God bless and bring success to the work of your hands.
I got a chance to see Stephen Bannon's movie about Goveror Sarah Palin, "The Undefeated" and this song was very moving as they showed scenes of the young Sarah Palin and her family.
@Sapwolf I'm glad you like the song. Would you be able to tell me whether a different version of the minstrel boy was used in the movie or whether the director used our version as played above?
@shuber I saw the film. It was similar, but not exactly like yours. Everyone has been trying to find the exact version, so that's how some of us found you. God bless you girls. Beautiful voices.
Lady's awesome!!!!! that is all I can say. You two are Awesome. I have saved all the vids you two have up on my computer! I love ya! Please do more!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Well done Ladies, your arrangement has inspired my brothers and I to cover your cover. I particularly like the tribute to the movie "The Man Who Would Be King"( one of the greatest movies of all time IMHO). Keep it up. do you think you'll ever do a cover of "Foggy Dew"? If so I'd love to hear it.
Awesome work!!! I hadnt heard the first few verses before, I do a cover of this song as well. Its so much fun to play!! Keep up the good work. Gave you a like to boost your ratings!
You girls are not only gorgeous but also so talented. I am so glad you got a CD out, I am on iTunes getting it right away.
You girls are inspiring! I can see how different you both are and even so, you come so well together when singing! I wish you so much success!!! God Bless!!!
Here, there and everywhere by the both of you got to sound awesome!
Wow. You 2 young ladies do this song better than ANYONE I have ever heard before!Do YOU HAVE A CD?--IF NOT, WHY NOT?! IF I WERE RICH I would pay for you to cut one.Where can we hear more of you?? Your voices, facial expressions, tones, EVERYTHING about you 2 just meshes with this song... (it makes my cry when I hear it is the only thing I don't like about it!)PLEASE KEEP SINGING!!!!!our email is pdlhunt@gmail.com
@deerhunterp Madaket is the name of a beach on Nantucket island, where my sister and I spend a week every summer. A lot of our happiest memories growing up were made on Nantucket, and some of the most fun musical times we've had happened there, so when we were thinking of names for our band we wanted something to do with the island. :)
i know u dont do requests but the bonny boy is a beautiful tune not the version in the minor key BUT the superior working in the majorkey(all the lassies sing the minor one)
if u are interested type in phil coulter bonny boy
In real life, do they actually play the "Son of god goes forth to war" to the Minstrel Boy, or was it only in the movie "The Man who would be king" that they got it from?
@TehCheese: This tune WAS used by the British army, though under the name of "The Son of God Goes Forth to War," as can be seen in the film The Man Who Would Be King (starring Michael Caine and Sean Connery - perhaps the best 'buddy picture' ever made).
It was commonplace for an old melody to have new lyrics added at the time (basically up until the late 19th century). "God Save the [Queen]" turned into "My Country 'Tis of Thee." "To Anacreon in Heaven" turned into "The Star Spangled Banner."
@amy930 Ehhh what? I think you'll find its an Irish song, about an Irish Rising against the British Empire. And if the British did sing it, its the HEIGHT of hypocrisy and I'd expect nothing less from the British
@amy930 Its an irish song fool, and we have lots of patriotic songs Proud to Be an american, battle hymn of the republic, america the beautiful, anchors aweigh, Ballad of the green berret, Stars and stripes forever, Marine hymn, ect.
These two great ladies are absolutely excellent! I love this combination of the two fantastic songs! I have never heard a better version of each song and love their voices. It would be great if they could sing a complete version of "The son of God goes forth to war" utilizing this melody. I would love to buy a CD. Nevertheless, I am truly grateful for this video and it is number one on my favorite list - very good for inspiration and self-motivation. All the best to "Shuber" and her sister!
Beautiful. Just beautiful. I haven't been able to hear this song since it was performed with full military honors at my father's funeral many years ago, but your version has brought it back into my life.
oddly enuff you two are the best cover of this ive found on Utube- deep space 9, man who would be king, blackhawk down, firefly - all miss the essence of the song
Absolutely beautiful, Please do another with both songs sung in their entirety. I would really like to hear "The Son of God" sung to the "Minstrel Boy" tune.
When I first heard this song I was pretty young. My best friend, my brother send me this song when I had a pretty ruff time..
The first girl I really loved who was cheating on me.
When my friend sent me this song I had this feeling.. A strange feeling. I cant really explain it, but I get the same feeling when I hear you sing. Thank you, very much.
Great Job!!! i'm a police ofificer and i've heard that many times at funerals... beautiful voices and i would be honored to have you sing that for a fallen officer
Outstanding!!!!! my pipe band plays this tune and my celtic band does an acoustic version. None of us sing it as well though. Great nod to an incredible movie.
Well done! Celtic music and Christ, my two passions put together! The Son of God goes forth to war...and to victory, even on a cross, for me, His one-time enemy! I also like Hail the King, done to the tune of the Jacobite tune in honor of Prince Charlie. The White Cockade, I think.You two would do a great job on that, I think.
i am irish and i can tell u this song is very deer to us my mother tought me this when i was young with another song called LET ERIN REMEMBER. you girl sing it perfect thank you and well done!!
You have good voices and this is over all lovely to listen to, but it seems you're not doing the best you can, if I may say so. As it is now you just kind of sing the song and you both look a bit deatched (especially the right one). You could work on the musical phrasing of your song a bit more to make it sound more "professional", but then again, the slight bohemic, everyday feel to your performance is also what makes it so good!
the son of god goes forth to war a king lay crowned to cain his blood red banner streams afar who follows in his trail.... supposeing if i were to ask you as a stranger going to the west to seek for that which was lost, what would you say then?
YO YO YO! THAT WAS THE DOPEST SONG EVER!!! I WOULD TOTALY MARRY THAT GIRL IN THE FUNNY HAT!!!! I have a friend that is really good at singing and stufff... but the girl on the left would totaly kick her ass
for some reason whenever I hear a good rendition of this song it puts me in the mood to scrap. of course I could say the same about Fields of Athenry, and most rebellion songs LOL. You girls sounded great.
I hate to say it but most of the best Irish songs are songs of rebellion. Maybe because they spent 700 years under the British foot. but then again I absolutely love living history, I spent several years in an Irish group and then started in with Imperial German. You might expect Germen songs to be Darker, but most are so much more light hearted than Irish stuff. If you want to read some disturbing lyrics to a German war song look up " look out farmer here I come". Damn the "character count".
got to agree and i hate to say it but i am against english troops been in ireland. but thts my feelings. i dont know any german songs i know irish english scottish and australian folk music as these are popular and also because they are countries that have influenced me by their history.
Excellent! Reminds me of when My sister and I sang such songs while doing the dinner dishes many years ago, alas. Keep singing!!
cgculprit 1 week ago
OMG Yes!!! Love it up to death. I love it.
KingDingaLing090 3 weeks ago
Just wonderful--do you have this on your CD? And have you ever performed all of the song as it appears in _The Man Who Would Be King_?
HughHDavis 3 weeks ago
In spite of the fact that this was used in a movie about Sarah Palin--that ridiculous, ignorant, hypocritical, substance-free epitome of what the American electorate has become--the performance here is not only worthwhile, but cheering...nice to know at least a few younger people are carrying it on.
emncaity 1 month ago
The begining isn`t the Minstrel boy at all, it is The Son Of God Goes Forth To War, a cheap British rip off of the Minstrely boy. None the less beatuiful singing girls.
1798Greenflag1916 1 month ago
my favourite movie is the man who would be king... and EVERYONE disagrees that the minstrel boy is the last song sean connery sings!
VolatileChe 2 months ago
is this not the same tune as minstrel boy?
VolatileChe 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what I like to do with this vid is to open 3 browsers of it a sec after each other and listen to it in chorus.....
secondly..a big FCUK U youtube...theyve put a caution against it cos it apparently is potentially breaching copyright...WFT was written by Thomas Moore and he died in 1852. How the fuck can it be breaching copyright!
NapalmTheElf 2 months ago
they sing so nice :) but i am sure their voice remind me middle age musics
U574 2 months ago
Beautiful job ladies, thanks for sharing
shamrock4500 3 months ago
nice voices :)
what makes the vid awesome is the tobagen the girl on the right is wearing, lol.
C0wb0yBebop 3 months ago
@C0wb0yBebop the hat is called a toque, a toboggan is a wooden sled.
shamrock4500 3 months ago
Great job ladys!.Love this old tune..and it brought a tear to my eye.
radwayb 4 months ago
What a sweet way to end my evening. I'm so glad i found this. Like and subscribe I think :)
leahcimrac 4 months ago
Good effort. Seriously,
leonardbullhock 5 months ago
Wow love it , beutiful harmonics beutiful attitude, fair dues to your Mam and Dad for sharing their feelings with you, and to you for absorbing them and taking them as your own. Again wow, truly innocent. Thanks
dustysailor1 5 months ago
I know Ive commented in the past, but you girls are well better than the first on the list for this search. You girls are so solemn and emotionally exact on the song that you girls should get first spot on search. I love you girls for this.
Kaldhore 5 months ago
cannot find the scene, where sean connery is singing this song in the film "the man who would be king" . whould like to hear his version again..-)) i thought it is a scottish song, cause connery is a true scot!)) but it´s an original irish air!
72traker 6 months ago
Best version of this song ever. Much as I like Amhrán na bhFiann, I think Ireland missed out not making this their national anthem. Out of curiosity, why did you attach that verse from "The Son of God Goes Forth to War" on the beginning?
utlariakor 6 months ago
eye and ear candy.
yawningpheonix 6 months ago
You both have lovely, clear voices. Keep singing.!
77elleb 6 months ago
Found ths video after hearing the song in the film The Undefeated. Beautiful rendition of a beautiful song. God bless and bring success to the work of your hands.
ExVoto63 6 months ago
This song was on The Undefeated ya know the movie about Sarah Palin
votefortrigsmommy 6 months ago
Only matched my Miles O'Brien in the Wounded, truly magical.
Lerathe 6 months ago
I got a chance to see Stephen Bannon's movie about Goveror Sarah Palin, "The Undefeated" and this song was very moving as they showed scenes of the young Sarah Palin and her family.
Nice.
Sapwolf 6 months ago
@Sapwolf I'm glad you like the song. Would you be able to tell me whether a different version of the minstrel boy was used in the movie or whether the director used our version as played above?
shuber 6 months ago
@shuber I saw the film. It was similar, but not exactly like yours. Everyone has been trying to find the exact version, so that's how some of us found you. God bless you girls. Beautiful voices.
NiteOwlMom3 6 months ago
@Sapwolf ditto !!!
Curling12341 5 months ago
Excellent Job Girls! I love this song! Do you all know In the Gloaming?
res57 6 months ago
Excellent Job Girls! I love this song!
res57 6 months ago
I cry every time..... just cant fight the irish in me..... probly just at well.
Slapchop8 7 months ago in playlist Feel Good
Lady's awesome!!!!! that is all I can say. You two are Awesome. I have saved all the vids you two have up on my computer! I love ya! Please do more!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kafreem 8 months ago
super
icepriceman 8 months ago
Well-done Bailey! Sung with true passion (I’m Irish)
Loved it will Google the CD and buying it if its available.
You should get yourselves over to the emerald isle (just like the English Queen)
We love good band and singers you would be sure of a fine welcome
May the road rise to meet you both
mocatx 8 months ago
wowww ....i like that
IndoCommunist 10 months ago
may i start by staying splendid show by both of you trully excellent.
but i am curious why you started by singing "the son of god goes to war" from halfway through at the begining of the video?
5* show though.
clsteele 10 months ago
love this song! great voices! beautiful ladies!
72traker 10 months ago
Well done Ladies, your arrangement has inspired my brothers and I to cover your cover. I particularly like the tribute to the movie "The Man Who Would Be King"( one of the greatest movies of all time IMHO). Keep it up. do you think you'll ever do a cover of "Foggy Dew"? If so I'd love to hear it.
Pirateshipred 10 months ago
Well Done Version of Thomas Moore's Classic Melody !!! Also, Check out John McCormack's Version on You Tube !!!
VMA225 11 months ago
Great!Your version of this song is the closest to how i think it's better to be executed,among the many i've heard.
KurtAngle89 11 months ago
that is so beautiful
bubridge 1 year ago
i awaited some sort of bs, but this is outstanding
beidlgsicht 1 year ago
Lovely song - beautifully sung. You both seem so happy. :)
scottseelman 1 year ago
Can you put this song on Itunes? I love this match up, and a cappella Intro is awesome, gave me chills
pairshorty411 1 year ago
Awesome version of Minstrel Boy! Especially the a cappella intro.
hardtackjack 1 year ago
Awesome work!!! I hadnt heard the first few verses before, I do a cover of this song as well. Its so much fun to play!! Keep up the good work. Gave you a like to boost your ratings!
RoryMacRury 1 year ago
You girls are not only gorgeous but also so talented. I am so glad you got a CD out, I am on iTunes getting it right away.
You girls are inspiring! I can see how different you both are and even so, you come so well together when singing! I wish you so much success!!! God Bless!!!
Here, there and everywhere by the both of you got to sound awesome!
47967 1 year ago
i love the part when she looks at u all akward and u keep a straight face
MrAmericaRules 1 year ago
Comment removed
HHDavis13 1 year ago
Do you have plans of recording this version of "The Minstrel Boy," with the verse at the start?
HHDavis13 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow. You 2 young ladies do this song better than ANYONE I have ever heard before!Do YOU HAVE A CD?--IF NOT, WHY NOT?! IF I WERE RICH I would pay for you to cut one.Where can we hear more of you?? Your voices, facial expressions, tones, EVERYTHING about you 2 just meshes with this song... (it makes my cry when I hear it is the only thing I don't like about it!)PLEASE KEEP SINGING!!!!!our email is pdlhunt@gmail.com
sparrow7ful 1 year ago
Thanks for singing the first verse. Most don't.
Zardoz215 1 year ago
what i the yr name(s) and the cd?
ramron333 1 year ago
@ramron333 My name is Bailey (the one on the left) and my sister is named Piper (the one on the right). Our CD is called "Madaket" :)
shuber 1 year ago
@shuber thanks the cd sounds great i wouldnot hve recognised you from the cd cover photo tho
hope you dont mind the song suggestion
all the best from scotland
ramron333 1 year ago
@shuber What does Madekat mean?
deerhunterp 10 months ago
@deerhunterp Madaket is the name of a beach on Nantucket island, where my sister and I spend a week every summer. A lot of our happiest memories growing up were made on Nantucket, and some of the most fun musical times we've had happened there, so when we were thinking of names for our band we wanted something to do with the island. :)
shuber 10 months ago
i know u dont do requests but the bonny boy is a beautiful tune not the version in the minor key BUT the superior working in the majorkey(all the lassies sing the minor one)
if u are interested type in phil coulter bonny boy
just a suggestion from a scottish fan
ramron333 1 year ago
Great voices, but a little more stage presence!
larrybud 1 year ago
Wondrous fine ladies! Bravo!
GanarfGeorgie 1 year ago
Beautiful!!!!
fethard1 1 year ago
I would like to know more what these women feel about about what theyre singing
Kaldhore 1 year ago
Thank you ladies very well done!
Georgiastonewall 1 year ago
I have heard many versions. Yours is the most simple, most pure, and I believe the most in keeping with its original intent. Well done indeed.
ecostevenc 1 year ago
beautiful
Thank you
Kaldhore 1 year ago
In real life, do they actually play the "Son of god goes forth to war" to the Minstrel Boy, or was it only in the movie "The Man who would be king" that they got it from?
esh325 1 year ago
Beautiful singing!
AndrewTheShort 1 year ago
This is beautiful. I thank you for all Irishmen. This song is one of the most irish things ever written.
112smosquito 1 year ago
I Loved your performance.
The man who would be a king is one of my favorites too.
wladmyrdr 1 year ago
Comment removed
wladmyrdr 1 year ago
terrific job!
shaynapulley 1 year ago
Beautiful song ladies. Thank you.
Duke898 1 year ago
made me shiver
doggerdoh 1 year ago
@TehCheese: This tune WAS used by the British army, though under the name of "The Son of God Goes Forth to War," as can be seen in the film The Man Who Would Be King (starring Michael Caine and Sean Connery - perhaps the best 'buddy picture' ever made).
It was commonplace for an old melody to have new lyrics added at the time (basically up until the late 19th century). "God Save the [Queen]" turned into "My Country 'Tis of Thee." "To Anacreon in Heaven" turned into "The Star Spangled Banner."
NamesForDogs 1 year ago
Absolutely beautiful rendition, ladies. You've brought a tear to an Irish man's eye.
MykeFoo 1 year ago
Do Yankees have ANY patriotic song that wasn't stolen from the British Empire???
The original version of this song, written by Thomas Moore, was sung while the White House was set ablaze by the British and Canadian Army in 1814.
But I have to admit.... it is a very nice rendition. :-)
amy930 1 year ago
@amy930 Thy songs were made for the pure and free.
MykeFoo 1 year ago
@amy930 Ehhh what? I think you'll find its an Irish song, about an Irish Rising against the British Empire. And if the British did sing it, its the HEIGHT of hypocrisy and I'd expect nothing less from the British
TehCheese 1 year ago 2
@amy930 Its an irish song fool, and we have lots of patriotic songs Proud to Be an american, battle hymn of the republic, america the beautiful, anchors aweigh, Ballad of the green berret, Stars and stripes forever, Marine hymn, ect.
flake121 1 year ago 3
@amy930 If anything it's an ANTI-British song written about an Irish Rebellion against the British Empire in the late 1700's.
like2surf 1 year ago
These two great ladies are absolutely excellent! I love this combination of the two fantastic songs! I have never heard a better version of each song and love their voices. It would be great if they could sing a complete version of "The son of God goes forth to war" utilizing this melody. I would love to buy a CD. Nevertheless, I am truly grateful for this video and it is number one on my favorite list - very good for inspiration and self-motivation. All the best to "Shuber" and her sister!
777torch777 1 year ago 2
Beautiful. Just beautiful. I haven't been able to hear this song since it was performed with full military honors at my father's funeral many years ago, but your version has brought it back into my life.
Thank you.
A10thunderbolt 1 year ago 5
@A10thunderbolt This
KingOfNormans 2 months ago
Pretty! : )
lachimiksworugh 1 year ago
you guys are amazing i loved this cover keep it going
playswithdrums 1 year ago
Beautiful rendition of a magnificent song.
waluum 1 year ago 2
The Minstrel Boy, one of my favorite songs ever. Written by Thomas Moore for three of his friends and set to an ancient tune called the Moreen.
There's a monument to him at The Meeting of the Waters near my house on the spot where he wrote... 'The Meeting of the Waters.'
This is excellently sung, well done ladies. Pat each other on the back.
Cool hat by the way.
cameramanAL 1 year ago 2
Bravo. I can't say how swell this is.
neonbelly 1 year ago 3
tears beautiful
hooper1972 1 year ago 2
oddly enuff you two are the best cover of this ive found on Utube- deep space 9, man who would be king, blackhawk down, firefly - all miss the essence of the song
kayjay83 1 year ago
very nice you gals got confidence
SS13E3 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
the minstrel boy is my favorite song! thank you so much for covering this!
NBBrown86 2 years ago
Comment removed
NBBrown86 2 years ago
I love your harmonies on this song do you sing at sessions in your area if you do not you should!
do8ey 2 years ago
Wow !! You are both so talented,beautiful music, beautifully played and sung,thank you for sharing.
mark9780 2 years ago 2
Beautiful! I hope to hear this song sung so beautifully on my death bed someday.
Silentbob77772002 2 years ago
I echo bobcat395
Your father must be very proud of you both - I'm sure I would be.
JimRudman 2 years ago 4
Absolutely beautiful, Please do another with both songs sung in their entirety. I would really like to hear "The Son of God" sung to the "Minstrel Boy" tune.
bobcat395 2 years ago 8
When I first heard this song I was pretty young. My best friend, my brother send me this song when I had a pretty ruff time..
The first girl I really loved who was cheating on me.
When my friend sent me this song I had this feeling.. A strange feeling. I cant really explain it, but I get the same feeling when I hear you sing. Thank you, very much.
sek8 2 years ago 3
Nice work, MWWBK is an awesome film too ;)
Tomyris 2 years ago 3
:O this makes me feel a bit weepy.
You're both excellent singers- the girl on the right is a fantastic alto! Great harmonies. :)
fireyeyedtyrants 2 years ago 8
BEAUTIFUL beyond words! By far, my favourite version of this tune...EVER. Great harmonies, gals!
StooTV 2 years ago 11
I usually don't expect much when people sing on Youtube....but I have to say. This was simply amazing. You've got talent!
Luftwaffels 2 years ago 12
Most heartfelt rendition of this I have ever heard.
Arachapooch 2 years ago 13
Great Job!!! i'm a police ofificer and i've heard that many times at funerals... beautiful voices and i would be honored to have you sing that for a fallen officer
ardoyne85 2 years ago 13
absolutly amazing 5/5 you both have lovely voices
Enjoi4659 2 years ago 13
Great! If I wouldn't miss my bus, I would listen to you ladies for the evening! Totally enjoyed your performance.
TouchOfGreatness 2 years ago 13
Wow. Really nice!
rorinator101 2 years ago 15
great job
keep up the good work
drumman360 2 years ago 8
Complimenti, siete veramente brave e fra non molto verrete sicuramente notate e scritturate da qualche discografico..............
pisolinos 2 years ago 5
Outstanding!!!!! my pipe band plays this tune and my celtic band does an acoustic version. None of us sing it as well though. Great nod to an incredible movie.
aball218 2 years ago 2
id love to meet these chicks and just say hi. pretty and talented.
reelg964 2 years ago 13
Nice nod to the Man who Would be King my favorite movie. Nice to see people my age can appreciate not only the Movie but the tune as well. Nice job.
ktperson30 2 years ago 2
Beautfully sung by two beautiful girls -- the most lovely version available, IMHO.
jpb06080 2 years ago 32
I still love this video! 5/5!!! No if, ands, or buts about it!
knowm5 2 years ago 29
i think the girl on the right was nervous she kept moving
jeff72496 2 years ago
Ladies, you are a fantastically talented pair with a bright future in music if you wish it
britlo 2 years ago 21
Very nice thank you
marcibb 2 years ago 20
It feels vaguely disturbing when people named Jack the Ripper comments on female beauty... Not sure why, though.
Anywho... You girls rock!
GKraften 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the one on the right is pretty hot
jacktheripper534 2 years ago
amazing voices
spellbinding
wonderful harmony
in one word... WOW
ceilidh169 2 years ago 18
What a beautiful voice. I got chills.
russianguyovich22 2 years ago 15
Thats great! I have great respect for anyone who's willing to go in-front of a camera and sing to thousands. Great singing, well done.
trizzo1234 2 years ago 15
I commend your song choice. It's clear you appreciate it.
waluum 2 years ago 3
what a babe
beerkat88 2 years ago 3
We play this at the reenactments cause we are the Irish Brigade. I have heard some good versions, but this is the best of the best.
GREAT WORK!
MinstrelBoy54 2 years ago 12
Really great song, and great voices!
moniaczek84 2 years ago 16
Beautiful. I loved it. we play that song all the time at civil war reenactments and this is the best ive ever heard it done
AMCamporeale 2 years ago 13
You two sisters are doing so fine! I know you're sisters!
Regards
Brandtstifter
Brandtstifter1 2 years ago
Siblings harmonize so well together.
oakpianist 2 years ago
WOW!!!you're beutiful!!! keep it up...
RANDYMARKWEIGEL 2 years ago 5
beautiful
claycallaway 2 years ago 11
Maggoli Prince Charlie was terrible he cheated all the scottish covenanters
tailgunnermario 2 years ago 4
Well done! Celtic music and Christ, my two passions put together! The Son of God goes forth to war...and to victory, even on a cross, for me, His one-time enemy! I also like Hail the King, done to the tune of the Jacobite tune in honor of Prince Charlie. The White Cockade, I think.You two would do a great job on that, I think.
maggoli67 2 years ago
You're awesome!
prodos8 2 years ago 5
wow. you guys are perfect. happy st. paddy's
reelg964 2 years ago 5
i am irish and i can tell u this song is very deer to us my mother tought me this when i was young with another song called LET ERIN REMEMBER. you girl sing it perfect thank you and well done!!
celtfin1 3 years ago 16
amazing...
very beautiful harmony,
I was really moved by your song.
thank you for the your good song.
Dolosel2 3 years ago 18
Sometimes I dream that I got a girl friend just like you two,maybe...never
well done
I enjoy it a lot ,I frist know this song is the end of the movie "Black Hawk Down" a moved movie...
pcaimar16 3 years ago 18
aww this is lovely!
Your voices are beautiful :)
I did the minstrel boy for my grade 7
x x x
sianybobs 3 years ago 17
Nice job ladies!
lowmazda626 3 years ago 16
I've listened to this 8 times in a row now and that's only since I started counting.
It's so beautiful. I'm actually crying. Just incredible.
Bitnd12 3 years ago 17
my brother thinks your both hot and you sing pretty
Irishqueen88 3 years ago
A nice performance of a nice song.
You have good voices and this is over all lovely to listen to, but it seems you're not doing the best you can, if I may say so. As it is now you just kind of sing the song and you both look a bit deatched (especially the right one). You could work on the musical phrasing of your song a bit more to make it sound more "professional", but then again, the slight bohemic, everyday feel to your performance is also what makes it so good!
Bcutter 3 years ago 14
Awesome songs, both of them. Also, that is a great movie. It has recently become one of my favorites.
CrusaderSven 3 years ago 13
the son of god goes forth to war a king lay crowned to cain his blood red banner streams afar who follows in his trail.... supposeing if i were to ask you as a stranger going to the west to seek for that which was lost, what would you say then?
transitcampervan 3 years ago 9
you guys have great voices man! awesome song too
lordofmyarse 3 years ago 8
beautiful song,voices and girls. is there an album?
ramron333 3 years ago 4
Yep, there's one in the works. :) I post updates every now and again with new videos.
shuber 3 years ago
Beautiful. But I have a feeling that youtube's audio still doesn't do you two justice. You should really get some good studio gear.
daltonultra 3 years ago
Thats a fantastic version!
quimmygustafsson 3 years ago 2
I can't stop listening to this. You two have beautiful voices.
KyraShangea 3 years ago 2
The Minstrel Boy is one of my favourite songs. When I am on patrol in our Armoured Carrier I sing this to the lads. Nicely done ladies.
stuntmonkey16 3 years ago 2
nice job! - Frank Shekosky
CMAKarate 3 years ago
Very good, suuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuper, Grüße aus Deutschland!!!
carioca62 3 years ago
I LIKE!!!
bravissimo!
=D
12warface12 3 years ago
ai theres talent there alright
fenian08 3 years ago
The voices of angels. I cried so much at the end of that movie. Can you get me a mp3 of the song by you guys or someone else?
Ace11235813 3 years ago
Very well done. Performed, no doubt, for the sake of a widow's son.
lborchardt 3 years ago
Sounds great ladies...THANK YOU for this cause it's from one of my favorite 'oldy' films, Connery & Caine. I play this for my son in the morn...
nickynoodle2007 3 years ago
Wbat beautiful harmonies! You are both very gifted. Keep singing! :) Marina
JLSTaylor 3 years ago
fantastic
BaileyRocks 3 years ago
YO YO YO! THAT WAS THE DOPEST SONG EVER!!! I WOULD TOTALY MARRY THAT GIRL IN THE FUNNY HAT!!!! I have a friend that is really good at singing and stufff... but the girl on the left would totaly kick her ass
bencattley 3 years ago
Benji, you're a moron but I love you.
shuber 3 years ago
What? He's not a moron! That's the nicest thing i've ever heard!
Anyhow, let's do that one song from almost famous. Guess which one of us is going to be Pete Droge! :)
Love!
maidmarion1523 3 years ago
Piper, his message began with the phrase "YO YO YO." Not the greatest indication of intellectual aptitude.
And for ONCE could I PLEASE be the GIRL when we do a duet? Poop.
shuber 3 years ago
well the lower harmony is a bit trickier than the higher one. and the man also gets more verses. I'd be willing to trade!
maidmarion1523 3 years ago
HA! I bet you would.
shuber 3 years ago
Amazing.
cjthomas730 3 years ago
You girls rock! Seperetly you are awsome but together you left me spechles! Great job an God bless you all! Erin Go Bragh!
knowm5 3 years ago
One of the best version I have heard.
goob67896 3 years ago
for some reason whenever I hear a good rendition of this song it puts me in the mood to scrap. of course I could say the same about Fields of Athenry, and most rebellion songs LOL. You girls sounded great.
Skincrafter 3 years ago
hate to tell you its a song of war and it was meant to raise moralle so u just listening to it. well done.
girls beautifully sang i love it.
brotherdevil 3 years ago
I hate to say it but most of the best Irish songs are songs of rebellion. Maybe because they spent 700 years under the British foot. but then again I absolutely love living history, I spent several years in an Irish group and then started in with Imperial German. You might expect Germen songs to be Darker, but most are so much more light hearted than Irish stuff. If you want to read some disturbing lyrics to a German war song look up " look out farmer here I come". Damn the "character count".
Skincrafter 3 years ago
got to agree and i hate to say it but i am against english troops been in ireland. but thts my feelings. i dont know any german songs i know irish english scottish and australian folk music as these are popular and also because they are countries that have influenced me by their history.
brotherdevil 3 years ago
sooo beautiful, too !
Hope you soon will do more vids together. Its so refreshing
prosepp 3 years ago
Wow! You two are awesome! Great job on the harmony
drummerguy920 3 years ago
10 out of ten get on telly!!
kingbleah 3 years ago