American Idol season 4 Top 10 Song AI4

[kellytaylorjenegarth]

CARRIE IS AMAZING!!!!!!!! She's the best Americasn I dol to ever win ever

[carriefan0001]

I think this season was by far the bast because Carrie won :)))

[Thesilviajo]

This was the best season and it is because of Carrie

[CrazyDiamond5321]

The best season of American Idol Bar None!

[sarawilson06]

I AGREE COMPLETELY!!!!

[SteelAVic18]

Season 5 was the BEST sorry!!

*Kat McPhee

Chris D.

Paris

Mandisa

Kellie P.

Taylor

Elliot!

Oh YES!!!

[katherineoa]

..thanks!!

[kathyfmp64]

all depends on what you into. Carrie is where she fits. I love Bo. Sadly he's Souther Rock. That's what I like. Marshall Tucker, Lynyard Skynayrd plus the others. There just isn't a market for Southern Rock. Bo's doing what he loves. He's getting by loving life. .

[abranson89]

why are you comparing carrie to every one? Constantine i honestly think wasnt even that good. If she wasnt doing country? Carrie IS country and shes going to stay there so u just need to move on and get over it. Carrie is here to stay

[sexyshy3000]

he wasnt dat great but he was much more of a performer den dat country singing robot like i said he wasnt gonna win but he was still better den savol n federov i dont care for carrie is not about constant douche maroulis vonzell had way better vocal range and credibility having gon through stuff and as far as her being country its called playin it up for da camera and dats wat she did you can be a singer and sell for 10 years it doesnt mean dat ur good its about gimmicks and album sales

[ashgirl47]

whos the guy with the short blonde hair??

[maychen]

Anthony Fedorov

[Vixypr07]

AI Season 4, Best Season In American Idol History :)

[minwoei]

Yes, I agree with you. I did enjoy watching... coz there was Carrie....

[teeftaller7]

Constantine was never gonna win idol what has he done that is so big???? Carrie won b/c she was the best look at everything she has done awards millions of records sold # 1's everything an idol is supost to do...

[sexyshy3000]

first of all the producers only picked her bcuz it was the perfect cinderella story for their rating and no constantine was never gonna win BUT he should have been in the final four instead of savol and carrie is just a manufactured second rate leann rhimes and every1 knows it if she wasnt doin country she wouldnt even be on the map i jus had to get that out and if u dont believe me look at da ratings and past seasons compare lean s vids vs carries

[prettyinpinkx04]

I'm sorry that you don't like Carrie Underwood, but she defines what country music is today. She is not a second rate Leann Rimes, COMPARE THEIR AWARDS. Carrie Underwood is the MOST talented Idol winner to date and she won because she deserved it!!

[doubleDdog09]

i love carrie. shes the best.

[gc14rocks]

scott savol sucks so bad. We should sue!

[Teeftaller]

To inforaride blame vote for the worst.

[inforaride]

Constantine was robbed.

[evilwillow19]

scott should die in a fire.

[jaymejean28]

why would you say that about someone? I couldnt stand scott but to wish someone dead is awful.

[Lisa3604]

I love Carrie Underwood! She's the best person to ever come from American Idol!!! <3

[angiehey19]

nadia was robbed......by anthony and scott

[sarahdarlin101]

i love jessica sierra's voice...

[Maura2735]

ah, carrie's my girl! jessica sierra was also amazing that season though. but carrie..woww<3

[VonzellSolomon38]

Carrie Bo Jessica Constantine Nikko Vonzell Nadia Scott Anthony Anwar

[Godzillaman]

Why is the audience waving their arms? That looks unusual.

[jaymejean28]

hahaha its so cheesy haha.

[scubbotno]

And it looks gay, too. Why do people do that?

[dajdawgzaccount]

its 2005 guys thats what we we're doing

[marinapuselja]

wow. i have never heard or seen any of them. besides Carrie Underwood. i love her!

[lvu16]

fantastic