LOL this is such BS... LUX in general is BS... every manufacturer has their own definition of LUX. I own both of these cameras and the only way to really tell is to compare the settings on each camera that generate the same amount of image noise, then determine which image looks better/brighter!
Are you trying to get the camera to solve lighting problems instead of setting up lights? Are there cameras out there good enough to digitally enhance the scene and do a truly professional production without a lighting kit?
@zenmachinefilms May Be not be my review was pretty accurate the Canon is actually closer to 1.5 stops slower than the EX1 from the reviews that I have read of the production model on DVinfo and other sites.
I would get the EX1, if I had to, when somebody gave me the cash.....you cant beat physics....the bigger sensor always wins....Airy Spot Effect.....Now, if they dropped the ridiculous 8K price down to around 3-4K, then maybe....but for now, Im staying with a full shutter on my XH A1....
The Video was shot in 1920x1080 24p 50mbps with the canon and 1920x1080 24p 35mbps with the Sony. The Rez and color chart was shoot on a different Canon XF300 cam at 60i
@FindMeInTheH oh haha. sorry for the misunderstanding. Yeah, I was looking in to the XF's but the quality doesn't seem as good or "bright" as the DSLR HD line. I'm sure you can edit presets with the level of customization like the XH series (which I adore)
Keep in mind those were preproduction models the cam is not out yet. I am sure it will be a great cam when it gets to final production.The price point will be the onlything keeping me from getting one $6777.99. I already own a EX1 and EX3. I was hoping for the $4000.00 range on the Canon XF300
4) - They are real Canon EX-1 and Sony XF in this test??? Demonstrate!
5) - It 's not the way to do a real test! We need a third camera that frames all that proves conclusively that the two camera are completely equal, that 'both with the factory setting to zero!
This demo was done a NAB in Vegas the canon XF300 was on a short leash that type of set up would not be possible at a trade show. I am trying to get a demo cam from Canon so I can do a proper shoot,
where was the controversy here ?
Demetris85 8 months ago
LOL this is such BS... LUX in general is BS... every manufacturer has their own definition of LUX. I own both of these cameras and the only way to really tell is to compare the settings on each camera that generate the same amount of image noise, then determine which image looks better/brighter!
guywhosfly 11 months ago
canon has a fake iris wheel, don't kid yourself it's not a pro grade camera
or maybe they forgot a professional functioning lense???
craigmaui 1 year ago
Are you trying to get the camera to solve lighting problems instead of setting up lights? Are there cameras out there good enough to digitally enhance the scene and do a truly professional production without a lighting kit?
PatzerKing 1 year ago
Not a reliable test at all, the white balance is all wrong on the XF300.
eurodestination 1 year ago
canon is shit in video period
steliber 1 year ago
Settings aside, this isn't the best way to do such a test. At all.
zenmachinefilms 1 year ago
@zenmachinefilms May Be not be my review was pretty accurate the Canon is actually closer to 1.5 stops slower than the EX1 from the reviews that I have read of the production model on DVinfo and other sites.
FindMeInTheH 1 year ago
ex1 winner
Costi554 10 months ago
MAHHHHHHH
3334109329KARL 1 year ago
That's it... I've lost hope in Canon... HELLO SONY :)
SuperSpoofStudios 1 year ago
can you tell me what song this is? thanks!
DrNibbert 1 year ago
@DrNibbert Its A Local Houston group I will look for the CD tonite...
FindMeInTheH 1 year ago
@FindMeInTheH Did you find the cd??
GanEdenAustralia 1 year ago
No way to do a test
3dfilmmakers 1 year ago
Paying double for a rolling shutter......
I would get the EX1, if I had to, when somebody gave me the cash.....you cant beat physics....the bigger sensor always wins....Airy Spot Effect.....Now, if they dropped the ridiculous 8K price down to around 3-4K, then maybe....but for now, Im staying with a full shutter on my XH A1....
shdwsclan2 1 year ago
haha, well one other thing you might want to add. You were shooting in 60i. You should have tried some of the progressive formats! haha
RoundTheBendMI 1 year ago
@RoundTheBendMI
The Video was shot in 1920x1080 24p 50mbps with the canon and 1920x1080 24p 35mbps with the Sony. The Rez and color chart was shoot on a different Canon XF300 cam at 60i
FindMeInTheH 1 year ago
@FindMeInTheH oh haha. sorry for the misunderstanding. Yeah, I was looking in to the XF's but the quality doesn't seem as good or "bright" as the DSLR HD line. I'm sure you can edit presets with the level of customization like the XH series (which I adore)
RoundTheBendMI 1 year ago
@RoundTheBendMI
Keep in mind those were preproduction models the cam is not out yet. I am sure it will be a great cam when it gets to final production.The price point will be the onlything keeping me from getting one $6777.99. I already own a EX1 and EX3. I was hoping for the $4000.00 range on the Canon XF300
FindMeInTheH 1 year ago
you didn't white balance the xf300, at least it appears that way!
ferlonjrTV 1 year ago
@ferlonjrTV
Please read the review as state in the review the white balance was not working on the preproduction model that I shot with.
FindMeInTheH 1 year ago
@FindMeInTheH oh I see, my bad boss! ;-)
ferlonjrTV 1 year ago
The shutter speed of the ex1 is clearly lower then the canon. This is a bogus test.
kareldc2 1 year ago 2
@kareldc2 its extactly the same shutter 48 the Canon is at leat 1 to 1.5 stops slower than the EX1.
FindMeInTheH 1 second ago
FindMeInTheH 1 year ago
4) - They are real Canon EX-1 and Sony XF in this test??? Demonstrate!
5) - It 's not the way to do a real test! We need a third camera that frames all that proves conclusively that the two camera are completely equal, that 'both with the factory setting to zero!
Sorry again for the translation.
By.
meteorite65 1 year ago
@meteorite65
This demo was done a NAB in Vegas the canon XF300 was on a short leash that type of set up would not be possible at a trade show. I am trying to get a demo cam from Canon so I can do a proper shoot,
FindMeInTheH 1 year ago
Sorry for the automatic translation of Google.
This test is' absolutely wrong, and I would say that makes me laugh!
1) - The two camera not have the equal perspective!
2) - You see very well that the Sony EX-1 has an iris wide open ....... while the Canon has a iris very closed!
3) - Shutter speed is equal to the Sony and Canon?? Not,for me!
meteorite65 1 year ago
looks like the sony is better...
latasha221 1 year ago