Added: 4 years ago
From: blondiesarah14
Views: 83,276
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (324)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I showed my girlfriend this scene, and now she is hooked. lol

  • one of the best scenes of this series....really well acted, music was perfect....just everything...total...awesomene­ss

  • Something that dosent make sense is that now in series 7 they dedicteed two different episodes surrounded by a situation where it was so hard for one of the borthers to kill someone close to them although was for the greater good - with Sam/Amy then Dean/amazon daughter... yet here 3 seasons prior he overcome this situation without the whole fuss,,,

    Oh well still made for some great watching by two amazing actors!! :)

  • @MissAnonymuss well those people were closer to them then this werewolf girl was, they hardly knew her but sam had grown fond of her, however the attratcion was romantic but not a close romantic attraction.

  • ... People liked this scene? But it was such crap!

    I mean, the actors all did a fabulous job, but none of it makes sense. They barely scratched the surface of trying to help her. The best they could do was "waste" her? Supernatural writers, you disappoint.

  • my house got flooded when my sister saw the ending of heart

  • jared padalacki was awesome in this one....for one episode atleast jensen wasn't the one i was lookin at....:)

  • does anyone know who sings this song at the end?

    

  • @sabrina3ish Silent Lucidity by Queensryche.

  • *sniffs* It's scenes like this that makes Supernatural such a great show. Season 2 really is heart-wrenching :(

  • :,(

  • awww this broke my heart. To see Dean crying at the end also T3T *sobs*

  • the episode before this with the woman that didn't know she was a ghost,back to back awesome episodes,season 2 is probably the best one imo

  • just going through all the seasons for a 3rd time,and just watched this again..so damn good,Jared/Jensen and Emmanuelle killed this scene...dust flyin' into my eyes here

  • Baaaaaw. just, Bawwwwww. T_T

  • i so love this video it so cool and sweet. i so love this epopines in sason two. i alwys cired during this sceen

  • when i first saw this i legit had tears running down my face..this shows they have real chemistry <3 i love these two and this show !! <3 <3 <3

  • 3.26 the look on sam's face... he was like please, i don't wanna do this, can't i not do this? pleeeeeeease...

    3.39 dean's tears...

    GREAT actings!!!

  • First time I watched this I was like 'aw man this is sad' but then when both Sam and Dean were crying it was like a waterfall on my face.

  • To give ur opinion about anything in life is everyones right. But when you give negative ones towards something that is more liked than disliked.UH this one, just remember if u were to die right now. As ur opinion, ur life would have been worthless. So, find the closest person to u, just asked to be hugged. We dont agree with ur ignorance, we all just understand it.

  • what season and episode is this?

  • @narwatehau010 season 2, episode 17

  • Every time i see this , I cry , one of the 3 saddest moments in Supernatural!!!

  • I believe that Jared Palecki played this to perfection. In his grief, it seemed that everything about Sammy was transformed. Usually, I am more attracted to Dean. However, in his grief, Sam became beautiful.

    For all that "Supernatural" is I think it is foremost the story of Dean's love for his "little" brother Sammy. Despite teasing, pranking, ordering, and occasionally punching, there is nothing that Dean would not do for Sammy. This time the only thing he could do for Sammy was cry.

  • What's the name of the song? ( 1:55 - 3:45 )

  • @Fwteinh1996 Queensryche Silent Lucidity :)

  • this was so funny

  • man when the guitar from "silent lucidity" comes in, its over for me!!!!!!

  • Another innocent woman falls victim to Sam's Penis of Death

    *desperately trying humour to hide the fact that I am crying like a baby, just like every time i watch this frigging episode.*

  • See I've never been a Sam fan but this bit is his finest moment for me!

  • This episode never made any sense. After the last night of the full moon, they find out that she's their pesky werewolf. She has 28 days before it's that time of the month again, which is plenty time to build herself a steel reinforced cage. Instead, she decides to have Sam kill her?? Weak. Plot holes for the sake of romantic tragedy just don't do it for me.

  • @Xiricon they have more sense then the sucky stupid movie twilight and other stuff,twilight a vampire with no soul fell in love?? wtf?? if you don't have soul you can't love!!! or have any feelings

  • @jorgecremexicano92 I definitely agree that they have more sense than Twilight lol. However (no offense at all to Supernatural), making more sense than Twilight isn't saying much.

  • @Xiricon Yeah, because she has the money to do that, and what if she can't? You sir, can go fuck yourself.

  • @CAPCBMERRITT Geez, you sound like more of a Supernatural fan than Becky Rosen lol. Ofc she had the money to build a cage, she worked for a hotshot law firm (which makes sacrificing herself even more strange). If she wasn't able to by some odd chance, she could've had loverboy Sam do it for her.

  • @Xiricon If you don't like this scene in Supernatural, then why did you take the time to look it up on youtube and diss it? To make yourself look like an asshole, which you probably are?

  • @CAPCBMERRITT I looked this scene up because I was curious what other Supernatural viewers thought of it. There have been many moments in the show that were both heartbreaking and inevitable (like Ellen and Jo's death), but this wasn't one of them. Sad moment, but unnecessary.

    As far as "probably being an asshole," I haven't told you to "go fuck yourself" or that you're "probably an asshole," so there's still a chance that I'm not :) .

  • @Xiricon Why don't you just go make go play some more bad songs for your fake little record label you've got going on your youtube channel?

  • was she sams gf or?

  • @joelandbenjimadden Sam and Dean were working a werewolf case, and Sam fell for her.

  • omg :,(

  • This scene always always always makes me cry buckets.

  • watching this for 2 years and still crying omg :( my poor sammie im turning 12 in 4 months! YAY

  • This is SUCH a brillaint scence right? The music is perfect, Jared out does himself and then Jensen completely steels it with his emotion - WoW *AWESEOME*

  • Well Jensen, way to steal the show...

    AGAIN.

  • There's so much depth to this scene which is why it will probably always go down as my favorite end to a SPN episode (and there's been many endings that I love). Sam making the decision to kill Madison because she's a danger to society even though she's really not evil and Dean realizing that he may be forced to someday kill Sam for the same reason. Also, Dean realizing that Sam is actually capable of killing Madison, while he himself knows he could never kill Sam but would kill himself first.

  • @lollypop2414 That's exactly what got me was Dean realizing that Sam was so much stronger than he was. That he was able to do exactly what he couldn't. Dean is always trying to be so capable for his brother. He wasn't able to help him and then finds out that Sam is 'the bigger man' in some essence.

  • When Dean cries, I swear, my heart breaks just a bit more. I wanted Sammy to end up with her too... damn.

  • It's so sad cause they just cant catch a break.

  • did he flinch BEFORE the gun went off?

  • @Star2Bear I think the audio is a little ahead of the screen so it appears he's flinching before the gun went off.

  • Poor Sammy! Such a sad episode :(

  • That flinch is amazing. All the sobbing and talking, I was fine. Then Dean, the badass, lets go of one tear and flinches at a sound he's heard his whole life and it's just...amazingly powerful.

  • the besteeeeeeee

  • The flinch at the end kills me every time...

  • i like supernatural, but big fail, that looks more like a vampire than warewolf

  • my heart is aching

  • wat song is that at the end?

  • @homegirl1651 Silent Lucidity by Queensryche

  • @lexigermain thnx

  • @lexigermain it's such an amazing song. and perfect for this part.

  • dean's OPT here was perfect :(

  • OF ALL THE SONGS TO PLAY, THEY PLAY SILENT LUCIDITY! as if i didnt have a hard time holding in my tears as it is

  • Where's my tissue?

  • I'm surprised that I didn't cry. Huh...

  • This moment really set this show apart from a lot of the other horror/fantasy types that are out there. The episode itself is well written and I don't care who you are, guy or gal, you couldn't help but feel for Sam after everything that had happened to him up to this point in the series. I mean, even Dean, the tough-as-nails, badass of the show, even gets weepy.

  • I cryed when I saw this scene for the first time.

    And I still do

  • I cryed when I saw this scene for the first time.

  • I need a tissue.........

  • I cried right along with Sammy. The first good thing since Jessica and he had to kill her. I don't think I would have been able to do that.

  • LOVE that scene

  • I love this moment, it has to be one of my favourites just because it's so sad, it makes me cry loads, Sams crying is so good, he really is upset. and Dean's single tear...it's like he's sharing Sam's pain, he always seems to get pretty upset when Sam is probably cause he's so close to his brother. What I don't get is that i think he cries more here with Madison than he does when Dean dies, he just looks so much more upset...

  • Comment removed

  • Wow, just an amazing episode.Jared is an an incredible actor. I rarely cry during TV episodes or movies but at the end of this episode i cried so much...and I'm a guy.

  • The tears, the song, the gunshot. They made this scene so heart wrenching, I love it. I just found out about this show less than 2 months ago, Im all caught up... but it's like... how didn't I know about this show!?!

  • the only girl he properly falled in love with after Jess died  and he needs to kill her , poor sam :'(

  • I think I might've actually cried when I watched this for the first time if it wasn't for the song. I was so surprised and happy to hear Silent Lucidity. Queensryche in Supernatural? FANTASTIC!

  • sammyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy­yyyyyyyyyyyyyy! :'(

  • man, jarred is one fuckin hell of an actor!!!

  • I cried so hard during this episode!!! I *RARELY* cry during tv shows or movies. . . This made me cry. He loved her so much then had to kill her :(

  • lol poor sammy. every girl he sleeps with ends up either dead or evil. :(

  • @argetlamgirl711 I think I would take that risk...but probably with Dean...but if not...Sam will do! :))

  • @argetlamgirl711 Well then I guess its a good thing he didn't sleep with Sarah from 'Provenance'

  • damn sam,you ever catch ah break.

  • The best show yet..I was in tears.. My heart was hearting. the girl did a great job as an actor as well. They are all very great actors.

  • Comment removed

  • The life of a soldier is never without great pain...

  • That looks he gives at 3:27 .... it breaks my heart every time.

  • So sad this ep was so great amazing acting by Jared and Jensen

  • When Dean crys at the end when he sees Sam crying... man thats when the water works are really let lose. Dean and Sam care so much for eachother

  • The song is called "Look at you" by Screaming Trees

  • @RuthlessAlpha No, actually it's not. It's called "Silent Lucidity* by Queensryche.

  • @timbelialbeelzebub Yup, you're right. My bad.

  • @RuthlessAlpha Holy crap, foor once, I corrected someone on Youtube without having it turn into some apocalyptic showdown. Balls to you, sir/madame

  • @timbelialbeelzebub Not everyone on Youtube is an asshole, just the majority lol

  • @RuthlessAlpha Agreed, sir.

  • There are 100 moments in supernatural that you just want to give sam or dean a hug to make them feel better and this was one of those moments...

  • this is my favorite episode!!! Sammy looks so beautiful in bed sleeping. God, i wish it was me next to him!!

  • i love a good cry

  • THIS IS JUST SO BEAUTIFUL

  • oh my god, why did you play that last part again? it was so hard watching it the first time D':

  • personally i think dean shouldnt have let him do it. i know sam would feel better knowing he did her a favor but at the same time, sam saw first hand the reason why dean would never kill him, even after he asked him to.so if dean wouldnt kill sam, then i dont think he should have let sam kill her. but you know, she wanted him to (which i dont get. if you love someone why would you ask them to go through so much pain? its so selfish) -cry- i hated this episode sooo much D:

  • @ShadowDwellerXXX she asked him because she loves him, and she doesnt want any other person to do it, because face it, shes about to die and she would never see sam again, it would be the last few mometns they would have together, and ya its sad as hell, but its called love

  • @1337mania if you really love someone, i dont think you would ask them to kill you.....

  • @ShadowDwellerXXX im sure if you dig deep down, you would understand why she asks him

  • @ShadowDwellerXXX If you really loved someone, then you would...it's the hardest, gut wrenching thing, but you don't want it to be someone else, you want to end the way you came in, with love, with someone's hand doing it because they loved you THAT much, that they couldn't let it be a stranger who did it...

  • The song is "Silent Lucidity" by Queensryche

  • @BrettWBProd

    Thank you so much

  • @BrettWBProd Gracias

  • What's the name of the song,could someone tell me?

  • The ironic part is in the show, Dean crys because of the pain Sam is in. In real life Jared made himself cry by thinking about having to put down one of his dogs and Jensen got emotional thinking about how much that would hurt Jared. So both Dean/Jensen shed a tear because of the pain Sam/Jared is in. It's funny how life imitates art.

  • I can't believe that there were people that disliked this.

  • Just finished watching this episode....it's really powerful, and so sad

  • Comment removed

  • I read where to get so upset Jared thought about having to put down one of his dogs and Jensen had the tear because he was so upset for Jared being so upset. Great acting with real feeling.

  • OMG and this with one of the best songs ever! heartbreaking!!

  • as a brother i know how dean feels. you never want to see your brother go through so much pain.

  • It's VERY rare, that any scene - in anything in life(!), that i break a tear. But, when i saw this on tv, i did in fact break a tear - and, the day today, this is one of my favorit tv-show episodes, of all time. It's just.. Amazing.

    Supernatural, you are simply fantastic.

  • This is so effing sad.. Everytime when I see this, I have to cry.. I really can watch this over, and over, and still I'm crying.. Everytime!

  • This is such a heartbreaking scene! ='C

    I here holding my tears...

    But how can we feel the scene if youtube turned off the audio?! Ò_Ó

    Those bastards...!

  • Why does this always happen to him? Poor Sammy :(

  • I don't usually cry with entertainment but when that single tear came down Dean's face my eyes watered. It was so sad! This show is amazing and I'm starting to love these brothers!

  • They are EXTREMELY Powerful actors; This was a very solid performance to the MAY they gave on this show. AMAZING Scene; I almost broke down myself; especially as an older brother

  • Extrait from John Winchester's journal:

    ''Every morning when I wake up, Dean is inside the crib, arms wrapped around baby Sam. Like he's trying to protect him from whatever is out there in the night.''

    Dean is crying at the end because he sees his little brother truly broken. Dean wants to protect Sam, but he knows that it's something Sam has to do and it kills him to see him that hurt.

  • Comment removed

  • @LydiaMadelaine Yeah, it's because Sam is upset. Dean knows that it's going to be extremely painful for Sam to kill someone he cares about, and being the protective big brother that he is, Dean wishes he could do something to prevent Sam from having to kill Madison. But he can't and it's killing him :(

  • give me a break..they muted the audio?! wth..its tv for petes sake...oh well i have the dvd series i will watch it there and rest assured wmg will never get business from me...still mad though....must have temper tantrum

  • OMG I WANNA HEAR THE SOUNDDDD! This is The Best Scaene In The Whole Season, I Was Watching This With Like Three Other People And We Were All Bawling :`( It was so saddd

  • yes pls....i need loads of tissues TTT___TTT

  • why is there no sound?

  • their tears.. really sad. dean is totally an awesome big bro, he cares and he cries with sam, he flinched when he heard the gunshot.. i'm dying in happiness if i have such a nice brother like him.

  • SAMZ SUH CYOOT WHEN HE CRIES!!!!! IT GIVEZ MEH GOOSEBUMPS! ha ha ha! XD

  • Great frickin scene! And the music is perfect... well I did research to find the song and although this was the first link I found it did not help AT ALL due to the disabled audio... BS man. But it's a perfect ending to the episode and really highlights how much Dean cares for Sam... he tries to carry all the burdens of the job and takes them from Sam when he can, now Sam bears this burden it's truly emotional and Dean bears the burden of what Sam has done as well.

  • it sucks they had to kill her she was hot

  • These two guys are going to be the death of me. This show is just amazing. I love when Jensen does that single tear thing when he cries. Supernatural is going down as my favorite all time show.

  • naww poor sam  :(

  • Sound?

  • what made me cry what when dean flinched at the gun shot, i dont know why that bit just really got to me.

  • The look on his face at 3:27 is so devestating =(

  • what name this song in the end

  • Queensryche - Silent Lucidity

  • Since WMG likes to deny their audio on simple fan videos... I think I will make sure that no song I purchase is ever a WMG song.... I have bought many many many songs because I like a fan video that uses it. Now, I guess I need to research what artists are included with this WMG.... They suck!

    This used to be a great video, but the visuals are still great.

  • @rsvredGranMa Couldn't agree more...

  • i hate this episode , the scene where sammy cries just makes me weaaaaap

  • No audio T.T

  • oh my god its sad even without the audio :(

  • There's no audio -_-

  • he kills her??

  • Yes.... Unhappily, yes....

  • Such a powerful scene. I love this episode!

  • *crying* B-but Dean never cries! Such a good big brother. sniff. Poor Sammy. I wunna give him a hug and say "everything will be ok". =*(

  • i wana wipe sammy's tears!!

    poor baby =(

  • oh no. no sound.

    :(

  • i see so many that use Silent Lucidity, wtf lol...

  • Its too bad Silent Lucidity is copyrighted (I know, I tried to make a video with the song.... gah!) I love this scene so much!

  • omg... i know sam is pure full on sobbing like xD

    but dean's tear...

    ONE FECKING TEAR D;

    -sob.

    i love him so much.

    i always cry when he is.

  • why bother keeping this on when there's no sound

  • maddison's real name is Emmanuelle Vaugier

  • anyone knows the name of maddison? her real name.

  • who sings this song

  • Queenschrye silent lucidity. Beautiful scene, gotta have a heart of stone not to get a lil teary eyed.

  • Stupid Madison.

  • tears everytime...

  • it is so sad *tear* but also so beautiful. *tear* it doesn't matter how many times you see it, that is with the most video's of supernatural. perfect music choise...

  • The thing that breaks my heart the most about this scene is Dean's tear. He finally realizes what he could have to go through if Sam goes to the dark side and he has to kill him. I think that Sam will go to the dark side this season but I really hope that Dean can save him. This tops my all time favorite Supernatural scenes

  • oh my god..this is horrible :(

  • Yo I can't help but cry everytime i see this.....

    -Drea-