Truthfully, I feel bad for the fellow who felt the need to pretend this was his performance. I mean, what possible benefit is there to such a charade? You're only an Internet moniker, Horowitz123, so what are you getting out of it? I do congratulate you on your good taste however. If you're going to steal a performance, you might as well pick a really good one...
How cheap can one get just to be able to get more subscribers? This performance is by somebody else.. see: w w w,piano world.com/forum/ubbthreads.php/topics/1750188/the%20middle%20section%20of%20Chopin%27s.html#Post1750188
This performance is IDENTICAL (when I say identical, I mean identical) to this one by the concert pianist named Andrei Ivanovich. (Take out the 2 spaces near the beginning of the web address.)
BTW, the reason I suspected something was because of HOW GOOD this performance is -- way, way better than we'd usually expected to find from someone who says something like "This piece took me 5 months to learn in order to get it perfect" -- not that there's anything wrong with the 5 months, just that someone this good wouldn't usually consider it any issue how long it took, plus they wouldn't say something like "get it perfect."
@BasileusR -- It's under "Artist," to the right of the description.
But the really weird thing is, I assume that whatever it says next to "Artist" was put there by whoever posted the video! (Right??) So, that would mean that this guy, who supposedly is trying to fool us, put the pianist's actual name there!
I don't get it. :-)
Anyway, I can't believe that so many people did these comments without ever suspecting that a person who wrote such a description would hardly ever really play like this.
What's the deal about Andrei Ivanovitch being the performer (he's a lot older than 25, and he's an internationally-known pianist) but you say it's by you?
Vladimir Horowitz is one of the greatest virtuoso pianists of the last century. I'm surprised you haven't bumped into one of the myriad of videos posted of his performances! I particularly like him, Arthur Rubinstein & Ashkenazy's interpretations of Chopin's works. I should mention Martha Algerich as well.
Your performance of this nocturne is the most beautiful I've ever heard. Amazing work! This is probably my most favorite nocturne, and you play it so wonderfully! Thank you, and keep up the good work!
very nice... i would like to hear more from you. how about posting few more videos of you playing? and give us a hint on who you are! who is vhorowitz123?
You play this beautifully, I love the way you play the grace notes and the ending is beautful, good job. It sounds like a concert-pianist is playing, so you should be very proud of your success in this piece.
Truthfully, I feel bad for the fellow who felt the need to pretend this was his performance. I mean, what possible benefit is there to such a charade? You're only an Internet moniker, Horowitz123, so what are you getting out of it? I do congratulate you on your good taste however. If you're going to steal a performance, you might as well pick a really good one...
plogthesmith 6 months ago 3
liszt85 and larchmontmark are correct.
OrangeSodaKing 6 months ago
Fakeeeeeeeeeee. :)
OrangeSodaKing 6 months ago
How cheap can one get just to be able to get more subscribers? This performance is by somebody else.. see: w w w,piano world.com/forum/ubbthreads.php/topics/1750188/the%20middle%20section%20of%20Chopin%27s.html#Post1750188
liszt85 6 months ago 2
OK FOLKS, HERE YOU GO. :-)
This performance is IDENTICAL (when I say identical, I mean identical) to this one by the concert pianist named Andrei Ivanovich. (Take out the 2 spaces near the beginning of the web address.)
ww w.ama zon.com/Nocturne-F-Sharp-Minor-Op-48/dp/B001VSM5DK
larchmontmark 6 months ago 6
OK, vhorowitz, we're calling BS. What's the story? :-)
larchmontmark 6 months ago 3
BTW, the reason I suspected something was because of HOW GOOD this performance is -- way, way better than we'd usually expected to find from someone who says something like "This piece took me 5 months to learn in order to get it perfect" -- not that there's anything wrong with the 5 months, just that someone this good wouldn't usually consider it any issue how long it took, plus they wouldn't say something like "get it perfect."
larchmontmark 6 months ago 2
@larchmontmark I only see Chopin on the description, I can't see the Andrei Ivanovich you mentioned
BasileusR 6 months ago
@BasileusR -- It's under "Artist," to the right of the description.
But the really weird thing is, I assume that whatever it says next to "Artist" was put there by whoever posted the video! (Right??) So, that would mean that this guy, who supposedly is trying to fool us, put the pianist's actual name there!
I don't get it. :-)
Anyway, I can't believe that so many people did these comments without ever suspecting that a person who wrote such a description would hardly ever really play like this.
larchmontmark 6 months ago
HEY, WAIT A MINUTE! :-)
What's the deal about Andrei Ivanovitch being the performer (he's a lot older than 25, and he's an internationally-known pianist) but you say it's by you?
larchmontmark 6 months ago 3
Awesome!
J1UHJ2UH 7 months ago
Love Chopin and love your performance :)
Greets from Poland - country of the greatest pianist ever :)
MaciejasPL 11 months ago
Comment removed
mwu42251 1 year ago
Hey dude i was really suprised! A Lot of people can play this piece, but just a very Few As good As you did it!
Congrats
expectio 1 year ago
Fantastic!
jonoroxxx 1 year ago
ITS NOT PERFECT! YOU LIAR!
totollol 1 year ago
Beautifully done vhorowitz123....from a non-player with a musical ear.
Beev60 1 year ago
Nice performance!
thegoldfinch1 1 year ago
шикарное исполнение!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! мне очень нравится!!!!
Molly11990 1 year ago
Amazing job! Wow!
davidrockstheworld 1 year ago
beautiful
videofreakmanic123 2 years ago
really good! :) with feeling and delicacy... whithout precipitation....good!
sarxemy 2 years ago
Comment removed
signindea 2 years ago
I have this played and recorded as my main vid.
callenishss 2 years ago
Beautiful! Played with feeling, which people don't always do! :)
heatherhuath 2 years ago 3
very nice... beautiful playing.. (:
bobadybooX 2 years ago
very good!!!
urobos 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
knassiri 2 years ago
Very good.
astronomy60 2 years ago
Спосиво вольше, владимир...
mariaqgrimau 2 years ago 3
Vladimir Horowitz is one of the greatest virtuoso pianists of the last century. I'm surprised you haven't bumped into one of the myriad of videos posted of his performances! I particularly like him, Arthur Rubinstein & Ashkenazy's interpretations of Chopin's works. I should mention Martha Algerich as well.
jecian1978 2 years ago
Lovely
Anduril000 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This version is base and pedantic.
ludachris475 3 years ago
Chopin shit out masterpiece after masterpiece.
ludachris475 3 years ago 22
haha thats exactly what i was thinking
jongun92 2 years ago
Very good :) 5*
Thomas
thomandy 3 years ago
Magnifique ! J'aurais cru que c'était un CD !
Orangananas 3 years ago 2
Wow!!I really love you interpretation!it sounds very professional.
nousernamewhatsoever 3 years ago 2
Your performance of this nocturne is the most beautiful I've ever heard. Amazing work! This is probably my most favorite nocturne, and you play it so wonderfully! Thank you, and keep up the good work!
swim4ever77 3 years ago
very nice... i would like to hear more from you. how about posting few more videos of you playing? and give us a hint on who you are! who is vhorowitz123?
MaksutovCG 3 years ago
Очень красиво играешь. Я так обожаю Шопэна.
IrishaKonstantinovna 3 years ago
very nice.
PhilipLu3 3 years ago
I agree with everyone else. Very very good. I like to hear a little more bravura in the middle but I accept your more reserved interpretation.
sasha42196 3 years ago
Congratulations! Your sound of piano really sing. Melodic line is smooth and even - beautiful.
mziel53 3 years ago 3
Summer at a secluded lake watching the sunset!!!!!
jtmoney2000 3 years ago
why doesnt anyone play this?
celpiano2 3 years ago
Absolutely wonderful! Keep up the good work.
nimbalo 3 years ago
uhhh
this is absolutely beautiful!
vvvmmm 3 years ago
Highly admirable interpretation and style, very pleasant listening, thanks.
BarNuun 3 years ago
great job!, i love it, congratulations!!
gpowdbl5 3 years ago
omg,thats perfect...love ya for posting!!
2Iryni 4 years ago 5
Thanks 2Iryni, glad you like it!
vhorowitz123 4 years ago
You play this beautifully, I love the way you play the grace notes and the ending is beautful, good job. It sounds like a concert-pianist is playing, so you should be very proud of your success in this piece.
teh1337meister 4 years ago 10
Thanks teh1337meister for the nice comments.
vhorowitz123 4 years ago
@teh1337meister Because it is, this is fake.
Vesivian 6 months ago
Sure.
vhorowitz123 4 years ago
Can you upload some other Chopin nocturnes too?
fongpayman123 4 years ago 4
Thanks, I'm 25 and have been playing the piano since I was 8 years old.
vhorowitz123 4 years ago
You're awesome. One of the best i've heard.
How old are you?
fongpayman123 4 years ago 4