That's amazing!!! Cathrine Tate was asking to be on Sarah Jane apparently so maybe she someday can remember and then be on DW again! DT and Cathrine were amazing in series 4.
Ok! That was amazing! I was skeptical at first, but I loved it. i really REALLY loved it. What is amazing is that it is similar to a fan fic I always wanted to write. Now I can just watch this instead! Oh it made me so happy! Five stars and favorited!
This is so incredibly well done and such a wonderful concept (that I would dearly love to see on the tv, not just my computer screen >.>) - I just love it. Totally impressed.
That was truly amazing ! One of the best vids I have seen in a long time, Is this a fanfic? If so I'd love the link, or if not, it would make a brilliant story !
I've always wondered why Rose said "he thought you were brilliant"-- she uses past tense. How did she know? Maybe there's an explanation, but I like to think that somehow Rose went to warn Donna AFTER Journey's End.
I really love this video because the collaboration of the video clips, the music,and the story line are amazing. Love your videos. I bloody love them.
This is amazing! It's good to've heard that Donna's returning at the end of this year: I doubt it'll be what happens, but I'd love for her to come back and regenerate (since the human doctor can't, it seems logical she could).
I love Donna ...and Rose... Couldn't Donna remember somehow! This was really good... I sort of attributed the sound distortion with wobbely bobbly timey wimey effects. :-)
I was wondering if you could possibly put a transcript up because for some reason the sound has started to warp on my comp and I'm pretty sure there are some less obvious little bits of dialogue you've included that I've missed. That's be great.
Love the vid by the way! Especially the end when the Human Doctor is rushing about his lab intercut with shots of Rose.
The audio has always been a bit shotty on this, and I apologize. I didn't notice until I uploaded it, and then it already had some views and comments I didn't want to lose by taking it down and re-uploading it. My bad. I should've done a transcript earlier, so thanks for reminding me! I'll get that up soon!
I love the purple suit. i saw that episode i wish i saw Dr who from the first episode with Cristopher Eccleson in it i love Dr Who i want to act as the doctor one day. i'm aspiring to it David Tennant is my hero :)
Actually, if you want to see Doctor Who from the first episode, you need to look back about 40 years - William Hartnell was The Doctor in the very first episode "An UnEarthly Child."
That was pretty amazing. My jaw and eyes were wide open. I simply adore this video! great flipping job!! Oh gosh I'm so excited about this haha. 5 stars!
Wow...I'm speechless that was incredible. Such a wonderful idea and the editing was flawless, the whole video flowed smoothly it was almost as if that's really what happened in the show. Also, I can't resist saying this, but the scene with the genetics laboratory and Rose smiling as she watched him work was adorable I couldn't stop grinning. Excellent job with this video!
Of course! I would love to read some fiction surrounding this. I'd try my hand at it personally, but I haven't the time, so I'd love for you do use this story line. Let me know how it goes!
I'm doing it for a big bang challenge, so it will be a month or two before I can post it but when I get the chance I somehow send you the link, I promise.
GASP!! Everything about that was just perfect!! personal canon from now on! love it to death!! Did it take a long time, it must have the clips and the audio were perfect! 5/5
WOW *is speechless* That was spectacular! I loved the part with John Smith coming up with a way to bring Donna's memory back and the way you had Rose's reaction to it. You've seriously made something amazing here, well done! 5* and *faved*
That was absolutely fantastic. All of it was brilliant. The editing, the sound clips, the music and the story. I was in awe. Awesome job with the suit tinting in the beginning by the way, I loved it. 5 stars!
OMG! Hun this is amazing! The storyline is just brilliantly thought out, and every bit of it fits perfectly! I loved the song, the audio, the clip matching, especially at the end when Doctor 10.5 and Rose saved Donna!! Aww, this made my day :) Brilliant editing, everything you make is just breath-taking!! *featured* :))
What an excellent idea!!! It's so well done too with fantastic editing. As others said it's smart how you made his suit look blue. I love that you had it seem like we were seeing Rose's reactions to the Human Doctor. And what great quotes to end it with. :D Five stars. I would like to see this in full!!!
Omg Caitlin! That was BRILLIANT! All those manips were so clever- how you made his suit appear blue i nthe first couple of scenes...and I absolutely love that music too- wicked job! 5 stars and favourited:)
I felt my heart break for "John Smith". I started crying, when I saw his face when Rose left. Oh my God... No Rose, it was not fair!
I love how you gave Rose and "John" an adventure of their own! I love 3:16 and onwards because it made me feel like, not only do they save Donna, (YAY!), but Rose and "John" finally connect fully and become what the original Doctor wanted them to be.
Thank you SO much! I'm really glad you enjoyed it. It does kind of do a 180 at the end--Rose is quite cruel to "John" in the beginning, but they do get a chance to bond at the end. I wanted to do something that gave them a chance to really be the Doctor and Rose Tyler, you know? And I wanted Donna to get a bit of a better ending (even though it's still vague in my video, it's supposed to be better than her other ending). Again, thank you!
wow...i loved so much your video
the team doctor-donna were my favorite and your video is brillant!!!!!
TheStonewhiteclown 6 months ago
love it now sub to you
ladylake2004 1 year ago
this is amazing and very believable!!
saraebeth9891 1 year ago
That was amazing, love to read the story, if there is one.
SashalovesErik 1 year ago
You truly talented.
firelightjen 1 year ago
Really nice. Donna deserved so much better.
themadwriter 1 year ago
That's amazing!!! Cathrine Tate was asking to be on Sarah Jane apparently so maybe she someday can remember and then be on DW again! DT and Cathrine were amazing in series 4.
Monsourpleut 1 year ago
NICE! Where do you get your HD clips?
tensandtens 1 year ago
I just came back to rewatch this brilliant video and I have to say - it's still in my top 5 of the best Doctor Who videos, ever!
Nyah86Production 1 year ago
That was absolutly brilliant
edakocak123 1 year ago
Ok! That was amazing! I was skeptical at first, but I loved it. i really REALLY loved it. What is amazing is that it is similar to a fan fic I always wanted to write. Now I can just watch this instead! Oh it made me so happy! Five stars and favorited!
flightlessphoenix 1 year ago
this is soo amazing, it must of taken you ages, well done :)
davidtennantlovers 2 years ago
Beautiful!
HaydenWiddows 2 years ago
great job. simply stunning.
mikillero 2 years ago
i hope that there is some way for Donna to remember in the 5th series and not die from it.
TwilightFanatic113 2 years ago
really cool video. i like that they have the whole Rose comes to save Donna thing.
TwilightFanatic113 2 years ago
Well edited
lecagot2 2 years ago
this is amazing, great video. I wish donna gets her memory back soon, and without burning up :)
flowerdancer2741 2 years ago
what's the music from used in this?
Desniettegenstaande 2 years ago
Music courtesy of:
John Powel ("Death and Transfiguration" from Hancock OST)
fasfsfgs 2 years ago
This starts of pretty good and then gets better as you go through it. Well done!
thumpaholden 2 years ago
very clever! *****
cymroambyth201296 2 years ago
that is amazing!!
harrysexgirl3 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thats way fake the vids are from diferent series
TheConizere 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow. Very impressive!
stlouisphile 2 years ago 2
Totally love this. And the use of the one piece of dialogue from Secret Smile ("Enough! Do you understand?!") was brilliant! Great job.
easilyjaded2 2 years ago 2
This is so incredibly well done and such a wonderful concept (that I would dearly love to see on the tv, not just my computer screen >.>) - I just love it. Totally impressed.
thelymachy 2 years ago 2
Wow! Gorgeous! It fits so well! Brilliant!
TheChrnosMiko 2 years ago
that is so believeable! and a great idea! well done!
timetraveler900 2 years ago
This is a great plot.
doodylover 2 years ago
Absolutely brilliant concept!!! I love Donna and was heartbroken when her memory was wiped. The Doctor and Rose saving her would be fantastic.
theatre2film 2 years ago
Very nice vid. The only flaw I can think of is that you wrote "Powel" instead of "Powell" in the end credits.
KjellBrel 2 years ago
This is epic.
SecretSmile90 2 years ago
That was truly amazing ! One of the best vids I have seen in a long time, Is this a fanfic? If so I'd love the link, or if not, it would make a brilliant story !
Good luck with anymore in the future !
xxxx
RavenFairy15 2 years ago
wow this would make a fantasic stroy
animegurl45 2 years ago
WOW!
This was brilliant, fantasic! lol
I really love how you've done this. I wish this could/would actually happen in the series.
Great Job!
SapphireShell91 2 years ago
Amayaing ♥
RoseAndDoctor94 2 years ago
Love it. It's brilliant.
gigo518 2 years ago
I just love this! It's a great story, even if I do get a little lost. :) Great job!!! 5 stars!
painful2part 2 years ago
I've always wondered why Rose said "he thought you were brilliant"-- she uses past tense. How did she know? Maybe there's an explanation, but I like to think that somehow Rose went to warn Donna AFTER Journey's End.
sorcha425 2 years ago
Wow how did you do that?
5 stars
icewormie 2 years ago
I really love this video because the collaboration of the video clips, the music,and the story line are amazing. Love your videos. I bloody love them.
HoleyMaster7 2 years ago
That was unbelievable !
xXxXxcozzaxXxXx 2 years ago
Really lovely work Well done Is this video downloadable anywhere?
Keep up the good work (please!)
pagecrawler 2 years ago
This is amazing! It's good to've heard that Donna's returning at the end of this year: I doubt it'll be what happens, but I'd love for her to come back and regenerate (since the human doctor can't, it seems logical she could).
thedoctor1812 2 years ago
absolutely stunning
hailnick6789 2 years ago
wow that was totally amazing
i love ur storyline
just genius
well done!
DaYoghurtQueen 2 years ago
this was so beautiful.
fandomoverload 2 years ago
OH my David!!!!
This is beyond words, like i can't even EXPLAIN how brilliant this is!!! Damn, this deserves a big smooch from Ten-Inch!!! XD
KittyLOZgurl 2 years ago
Can't I just give you ten stars?
Servena2 2 years ago
This is really brilliantly well done - congratulations! Fascinating. :)
samf88 2 years ago
That was very touching just shows how much of an impact donna and rose are on his life. Brilliantly edited! Loved it rated 5 stars!
Seathicle 2 years ago
Oh My Goodness!
That was Indescribably brilliant!
100/5
welld done
RavenFairy15 2 years ago
I love Donna ...and Rose... Couldn't Donna remember somehow! This was really good... I sort of attributed the sound distortion with wobbely bobbly timey wimey effects. :-)
Hrimfauxie 2 years ago
Wow, this is absolutely amazing!
5 stars
This is so brilliantly done!
Thetenwhos 2 years ago
I was wondering if you could possibly put a transcript up because for some reason the sound has started to warp on my comp and I'm pretty sure there are some less obvious little bits of dialogue you've included that I've missed. That's be great.
Love the vid by the way! Especially the end when the Human Doctor is rushing about his lab intercut with shots of Rose.
startledsunshine 2 years ago
The audio has always been a bit shotty on this, and I apologize. I didn't notice until I uploaded it, and then it already had some views and comments I didn't want to lose by taking it down and re-uploading it. My bad. I should've done a transcript earlier, so thanks for reminding me! I'll get that up soon!
I'm glad you enjoyed the video <3
nolaespoir 2 years ago
I posted it up in the video description, if you're interested.
nolaespoir 2 years ago
wow that was much better than i expected 5/5
TheFinalTimelord2 2 years ago
That's kind of a back-handed compliment, hah. I guess it's good you had low expectations, so you could be pleasantly surprised!
Thanks for the rating! I'm glad you enjoyed it, in spite of your expectations :)
nolaespoir 2 years ago
VERY. NICE.
Shifterred 2 years ago
I love the purple suit. i saw that episode i wish i saw Dr who from the first episode with Cristopher Eccleson in it i love Dr Who i want to act as the doctor one day. i'm aspiring to it David Tennant is my hero :)
SPENCER2001600049579 2 years ago
Actually, if you want to see Doctor Who from the first episode, you need to look back about 40 years - William Hartnell was The Doctor in the very first episode "An UnEarthly Child."
sixstanger00 2 years ago
oh, wow! this is an excellect vid! good work, nolae! :^D
MelPhleg65 2 years ago
Bloody good idea, that one - well done that person!
AlextheSuperfly 2 years ago
Thank you so mutch for this video!!!!!
It's wonderful!!!!
DushikaClover 2 years ago
clever idea, these vids keep me going until the doctor comes back onto the tv, brilliant !
topliff12345 2 years ago
Simply brilliant. I don't think anyone else had this idea. Great editing!
littleshit2507 2 years ago
That. Was. Brilliant!!
TraceCub 2 years ago
omigosh, I love this!!!! :D:D It's brilliant!!
doctorwholuvr 2 years ago
Oh now that was just brillant another five star deal that one was...Fantastic Hit!!
LostTimeGirl 2 years ago
Just as amazing a second time round- brilliant:)
gracefulangel47 2 years ago
Your imagination is superb! And then to be able to pull it off like this! That is talent!
lifathross 2 years ago
Wow...that was..brilliant! The editing was so flawless! WOW! Subbing!
HeartPhantom 2 years ago
That was pretty amazing. My jaw and eyes were wide open. I simply adore this video! great flipping job!! Oh gosh I'm so excited about this haha. 5 stars!
TimeLady628 2 years ago
I love 2.59 !
Kroepkoek2 2 years ago
Fantastic! This is so creative and wonderful! So original! And it looks very real. What movie maker thing do you use?
HoleyMaster7 2 years ago
Thank you so much!
I use Sony Vegas Pro 8.0 to edit all of my videos :)
nolaespoir 2 years ago
does that work on mac and pc? And is it good, easy to use?
HoleyMaster7 2 years ago
Brilliant and so creative!!!! I love it!!
X5421 2 years ago 2
Ohh, clever you nolaespoir, simply brilliant!!
merihaikara 2 years ago
Brilliant! Just amazing!
MacGyverrocks 2 years ago
I swear i was on the verge of tears. You ARE AMAZING! *sigh* So brilliant. 5 stars of course and Faved.
seduff 2 years ago
I don't think *wow* is a strong enough word. :) Amazing vid. Fantastic editing!
KatieKat527 2 years ago
*Screams* My god this is perfect! Spectacular work and ingenious editing! 5/5 stars and favourited. :-D
EllenRebecca3 2 years ago
Total genius. That's all I can say.
ChristineRuud 2 years ago
dude, this is absolutly BRILLIANT!!! omg, I had to watch it like 5 times! and it's still AWESOME!!
5* and Favorited!!!
RainWsker 2 years ago
Wow just wow, that is great.
ClintWhittiker 3 years ago
That's the best fanvideo i see thank you
coolmel93 3 years ago
Ultimate Wowness... that was amazing.... I love it, Great job xD
RockOnLancashire 3 years ago
Wow. That was utterly fantastic. Really well edited. Great job. :)
daydreamxx 3 years ago
Can you be addicted to a video?
If so than I'm totally addicted to this one. Brilliant. :-)
Nyah86 3 years ago
Wow...I'm speechless that was incredible. Such a wonderful idea and the editing was flawless, the whole video flowed smoothly it was almost as if that's really what happened in the show. Also, I can't resist saying this, but the scene with the genetics laboratory and Rose smiling as she watched him work was adorable I couldn't stop grinning. Excellent job with this video!
PirateTillTheEnd 3 years ago
*bows before you* this was AMAZING! Truly spectacular! completely loved it. :D
SoulRythm 3 years ago
very good job, 5 stars well done, very imaginative storyline
Itunesbabe 3 years ago
Amazing editing. :D
iluvsoaps 3 years ago
Can I try my hand at putting it to paper well word document? It's your storyline, I just want to try my hand at writing it, if that's okay with you.
surferchica8604 3 years ago
Of course! I would love to read some fiction surrounding this. I'd try my hand at it personally, but I haven't the time, so I'd love for you do use this story line. Let me know how it goes!
nolaespoir 3 years ago
I'm doing it for a big bang challenge, so it will be a month or two before I can post it but when I get the chance I somehow send you the link, I promise.
surferchica8604 3 years ago
*gasp* woooooooooow!
totallyDT 3 years ago
OMG !!!!!
THAT WAS ... can't find the word I'm completely speechless !!!
reall that was just AMAZING !!! and I was so impressed by the storyline !
misscynthia17 3 years ago 2
GASP!! Everything about that was just perfect!! personal canon from now on! love it to death!! Did it take a long time, it must have the clips and the audio were perfect! 5/5
paigehobo 3 years ago
Absolutely brilliant! I'm speechless, which doesn't happen often. AMAZING!
scissorhandslove9 3 years ago
That was AMAZING!!! Or as the Doctor would say...Brilliant!!!! =D
thedoctorsdonna 3 years ago
yay thanks for this :D
brilliant work
congrat :D:D
adearerane 3 years ago
WOW! Just WOW! I'm speechless! Fantastic work!
Nyah86 3 years ago
3:16 the end were just so magical... :)
The rest of it was pure brilliance, one of the best things i've ever seen, i think its even going in my top 3 :D
5* definately, and your going in my subscriptions :D
IXIrandomIXIgirlIXI 3 years ago
WOW *is speechless* That was spectacular! I loved the part with John Smith coming up with a way to bring Donna's memory back and the way you had Rose's reaction to it. You've seriously made something amazing here, well done! 5* and *faved*
THEpowerOFme 3 years ago
OMG ... Fantastic ... and what a amazing work ^^
duam78 3 years ago
amazing
englishstudent01 3 years ago
That was incredible. I absolutely loved your whole storyline. Very creative. Could it be a movie for real ?! 5/5.
analeian 3 years ago
OMG ! Sure Brilliance.
I Loved it i want to marry it .
All the editting was perfect.
It was sureeeeee SUPERB
xxx
xxelm0xx 3 years ago
wow...awesome!that's all I can say! loved it!
great great job!
meryltennant 3 years ago
OMG that was just totally amazing !!!!!
You did one of the best vid ever post "Journey's End"!!!!
I can't imagine how much time you must have spent on doing this but that worthed it !!!
WOOOW !!!!!
WELL DONE !!!!!
5* and fav' !
lott35 3 years ago
this is really brilliant.
love it :D
callhercath 3 years ago
Bloody brilliant! :-P
Krystleb7 3 years ago
Oh wow wow wow! Utterly fantastic work. Pure genius 5/5 and faved! :)
sirius136 3 years ago
WOW! This was incredible! XD Such an awesome idea, I wish it was turned into a movie/episode!! :D
myorli29 3 years ago
fantastic trailer!! 5* and faved
RosetylerProductions 3 years ago
That was absolutely fantastic. All of it was brilliant. The editing, the sound clips, the music and the story. I was in awe. Awesome job with the suit tinting in the beginning by the way, I loved it. 5 stars!
abstractvmilk 3 years ago
Aw...
I'm gonna cry! That was incredible!
Best Donna comeback ever!
: )
TheDoctorsRose2 3 years ago
Awesome!!!:D
raykia2000 3 years ago
awesome! I like this. Way to go and making it! :D
5*s
bohemianhysteria 3 years ago
OMG! Hun this is amazing! The storyline is just brilliantly thought out, and every bit of it fits perfectly! I loved the song, the audio, the clip matching, especially at the end when Doctor 10.5 and Rose saved Donna!! Aww, this made my day :) Brilliant editing, everything you make is just breath-taking!! *featured* :))
HarryDoesntKnow 3 years ago
Oh wow! Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it, and I'm honored that you featured it on your page!
nolaespoir 3 years ago
What an excellent idea!!! It's so well done too with fantastic editing. As others said it's smart how you made his suit look blue. I love that you had it seem like we were seeing Rose's reactions to the Human Doctor. And what great quotes to end it with. :D Five stars. I would like to see this in full!!!
KLady3 3 years ago
Holy CRAP! That was too awesome.
dbvixxen 3 years ago
This is fantastic!
nscara2 3 years ago
Omg Caitlin! That was BRILLIANT! All those manips were so clever- how you made his suit appear blue i nthe first couple of scenes...and I absolutely love that music too- wicked job! 5 stars and favourited:)
gracefulangel47 3 years ago
That was cruel, having Rose say that...
"The proper Doctor..."
I felt my heart break for "John Smith". I started crying, when I saw his face when Rose left. Oh my God... No Rose, it was not fair!
I love how you gave Rose and "John" an adventure of their own! I love 3:16 and onwards because it made me feel like, not only do they save Donna, (YAY!), but Rose and "John" finally connect fully and become what the original Doctor wanted them to be.
Just, loved it. Pure brilliance. I want more
AsarathWitch 3 years ago
Thank you SO much! I'm really glad you enjoyed it. It does kind of do a 180 at the end--Rose is quite cruel to "John" in the beginning, but they do get a chance to bond at the end. I wanted to do something that gave them a chance to really be the Doctor and Rose Tyler, you know? And I wanted Donna to get a bit of a better ending (even though it's still vague in my video, it's supposed to be better than her other ending). Again, thank you!
nolaespoir 3 years ago
You never fail to amaze me
Tarka98 3 years ago