Added: 2 years ago
From: caieu
Views: 114,071
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (477)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i love this videogame *A*

  • Damn. This SH was really awesome. I would have never expected that Sheryl was being analized. Also, in fact this game truly analizes you according to your own answers. damn. PD.: I dindn't know she was Alessa's half part.

  • The story line is good! The game is more of psychological and is unique in the sense that this can be realistic than others cause it could happen in real life actually it really happens in real life if you know what I mean...

  • I love so much this game ! i am a fan the game ♥

  • I really enjoyed this game-- spent a lot of time playing it! I love how you can affect how the people respond to you by your responses- and even how they are dressed and act. However-- I still prefer classic Silent Hill. The Nightmare episodes did not scare me or mess with my head in this game at all. No chill of fear down the back for me! I didn't find them scarier because I couldn't fight back- that just irritated me. But I did love focussing on the story. All in all- a good game!

  • I still like the rusty, bloody alternative world. I especially miss bashing the heads of the monsters and health drinks.

  • definitive one of the best games i ever played. i pass all the other sh games too but in these ones you always knew that there is a way to kill the monsters, you just knew that there is a way to defend yourselve. in shattered memories you can't defend yourselve, your only chance is: run! and because of this, shattered memories is the very first horror game that gave me nightmares and true anxiety states :D

  • graphics arent that bad gawd, many compare to hd games, thats like comparing a planet to a midget, OFCOURSE IT SEEMS RLY DIFFERENT, but it deosnt mean its bad

  • lots of scared assholes say this game sucks

    theyre just pussies who know this game will fuck with their head at night

    u dont need good graphics to make good gamplay

    who wants to play pacman in hd anyway?

    this game is about messing with ur psychology not seeing realistic monsters

  • it doesn't suck it rocks

  • Guys give up Silent Hill aint creepy anymore It lives up to its true name now.None of you prob know the true meaning of this game

  • A good game is not a matter of graphics, its about storyline, gameplay, interface, sound and music. And this game had all of the good game features. I have Silent Hill: Origins which features the rusty bloody otherworld that I have no interest at all. Looks like this frost world beat the otherworld. I'm getting addicted to it and I've played it for 2 times. It also have different story depend on what you decide. 5/5 for this game and 5/5 for this trailer and this video.

  • i love this gme

  • No idea why people hate it!

    It's one of the series' best games!

  • Comment removed

  • my favorite silent hill game

    i absolutely love it

    played through it twice now..

    a must buy for us unfortunate wii owners

    as we dont get too many good games thrown our way

  • @mrtle5 This isn't my favorite Silent Hill game but it was actually done pretty well. Though I do admit that it should only be played on the Wii, especially with what they did with the Wii controls.

  • en este juego no hay nada de violencia no se parece a los demas silent hill... por violencia me refiero a q ya no te puedes enfrentar con zombis solo escapar de ellos... que mal

  • You have to run, daddy! You can't fight them!

  • I just finished playing it - I can see why alot of people might think it sucks - depends on whether or not you let yourself get immersed into it or not - the whole game kinda creeped me out and that was part of the fun (for me anyways). I say buy it.

  • I shit just to see the trailer!

  • I'm putting faith in this game, but I hope it remembers a few things from silent hill 2 that made it SOOOO good and SOOOO successful.

    1) Subtlety. Less is more, and snippets and glimpses of what's going on are far more efficient than well rendered glaring OHHHH LOOK STUFF THAT'S SCARY RIGHT?! moments.

    2) Sound. The ambient noises coupled with a feeling of isolation really put you on edge. Half of what you see is what you hear.

    3) WTF-factor. You need to fuck with some heads.

  • @spehizle

    the sound as in music is very good and i think just as good as sh2 like acceptance by akira yamaoka which is my new fav song now!!! it also has a better SUPRISE! cutscene than in sh2 when u found out that james killed mary lol , also back to the sounds , i liked when you got near a spirit or watever its called and the lights on your tv kept flickering and made a loud and freaky ass sound which scared the fk outta me :) but you should get it! its fkin good as hell man

  • é um jogo muito maneiro msm

    is a good game thanksss

  • @silenceofthehills

    I wasn't refering to game quality I was refering to their scare tactics and how it's rare that anyone gets the point of "no weapons" lol xD

  • Plus the point of not fighting was to scare you. Wouldn't you be scared if you had to run away from deadly monsters without weapons and the inability to fight back. It's just quite simply a scare tactic

  • @Jim12148

    Well, I played alot of those games and SH:SM doesn't win here to me. None of them have because they are a game. I ran when I first played SH1 when I was a kid as it was easier.

    I mean, you can push them off easily anyhow and realy it just repeats over again. Whil it's a tactic, the theme of SH has been always less to do with the actual monsters to begin with. It's not meant to be an excitment style scare such as a jolt from popping around the corner, something SH:SM does ALOT.

  • @Jim12148

    Well don't get me wrong, it's an interesting play mechanic and would be awsome in a sequel, but it needs not to rely on it as it's only excitment. The others due to the weapons to remove monsters are more silent and low key while here, the otherworld is no more then for an adrenalin rush.

  • I've played the game and beat 3 of the varied endings but I love the twist ending with Cheryl. Made me think "why didn't I think it was her" I'm trying not to spoil too much though. X3

  • me lo podes decir en español

  • "Tienes que correr papá! No puedes pelear con ellos! Corre!" (You have to run daddy, you can´t fight them! Run!)

  • great game with a crazy story =)

  • god i love this game

    the nightmare mode is kinda annoying tho

  • this is a remake of the first game right??

  • Sort of. The basic premise of Harry looking for his daughter is the same, but everything else in the story has been severely altered. The game play also differs because this title is a "pure horror" title, meaning there are no weapons, and thus no way to fight the monsters, you can only run from them.

  • omg the interactive stuff is great but no fighting???!!

  • this game isn't that really scary, the story was well made!

    note i only play this game at night time cause my dad hates to see me playing so i just play most of my game at night time when they're sleeping.

    this game is 10/10, pure awesomeness!

  • this game scares the shit out of me!!!!!

  • Why do people say it sucks.

    Is it cause graphics are bad ?

    Well stfu if ya think that cause a game doesnt need good graphics to be good!

    i for one think its good cause you it turns it around so it makes it scary for you,

    good video btw :D

  • I know, right?! I think this is a fantastic way to change the momentum in the series. All recent Silent Hill games, with exception to this one of course, started stagnating after they moved production from Japan, to the West. Homecoming was awful! It was like they smashed and squashed all the previous Silent Hill ideas into a REALLY short game. I think the shift in focus from fear to pure terror was a great move to re-invigerate the series with some originality!

  • Haha yeah.

  • oh no the game wasnt scary at all but the last time silent hill scared me was sh2 with pyramidhead so i didnt really care homecoming was good but uhhh yea not goin in depth i also like 4 and origins and if they are absolutely horrible gameplay wise i look at the story instead thats wat those games are about anyway good writing

  • i loved this game it wasnt wat i was expecting but it was great and finally a reason for me to be happy to own that wii i had to dust off

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade I don't pesonally believe it has bad graphics in fact is one of the best graphics for a ps2 game...

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade

    actually i loved this one lol it was my favorite one of all of them :) and the ending kicked ass~!!!

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade the graphics are good for a wii very good

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade people always expect graphics to be better than it is before its an important part of development,

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade It's not the graphics They hate it cause it's a rail shooter! they hate it just like they hate the rail shooter resident evil games.

  • @TheScorpionMK37 It's not a rail shooter.

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade it sucks because it doesn't follow the ORIGINAL sequence and it's not scary as the first 4 games. I GIVE SHIT TO GRAPHICS, STORY IS WHAT MATTERS

  • @TheReverantChoir first it"s not a remake it's a reimagining so no it dosen't have to be the exact same story. second that being said wtf were they thinking were on wii so we can sex it up a bit but kill any good seans we do take from the first game?i'm all for reamagen this or the horror games but if you do it do it right.

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade

    for me it was nothing to do with the graphics, it was just so bad in terms of the rest of Silent Hill.

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade

    Play the original games developed by Konami's 'Team Silent' and you notice why.

  • @ShiningWolf1992 I think I have, but im just saying. Im studying games development in college and I think games can be scary with bad graphics, you just need to be in the right atmosphere.

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade

    The story and athmosphere really is the keyword here.

    Seems like the Japanese can create a scarier athmosphare than Americans can.

    Honestly, Silent Hill for PlayStation 1 is better than this game by far.

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade

    Again, no one gives a damn about the graphics.

    Better graphics do not make a better game, as I said the first Silent Hill for the 32-bit Sony PlayStation 1 is by far better.

  • @ShiningWolf1992 Actually, I know alot of people who wont play if graphics arent up to date.

  • @BredonUrieLovesJade

    What!? O_o

    It's their loss...

  • Good game. I liked it

  • I supose that in this game there is only one kind of enemy, those little creppy monsters that looks like monkeys.

  • does this come out on the ps3?

  • No, just for Wii, PS2 and PSP. Sorry.

  • that sucks

  • No.

  • already been informed but thanks anywasys

  • Don't like the frost, I prefered the rusty bloody otherworld.

  • @CC856

    me too lol i only like this games underworld cause you had to run from the monsters and it got really competative after a while!!! :)

  • @CC856

    Yeah! But it was still a nice change! I didnt know that it could be so damn good even if there isnt rusty otherworld but the frosty one !

  • @CC856

    Yeah! But it was still a nice change! I didnt know that it could be so damn good even if there isnt rusty otherworld but the frosty one !

  • @CC856 yeah the other version reminded me of the movie jacob's ladder and of course a marilyn manson video.

  • @CC856 Well this game was a Winter based season

  • I loving the game!

  • i just bought this game yesterday i started play last night ( horrible idea) it freaks me out i kno this is dumb but it scares me creature chase part iscream every time one jumps on me over all its a good game if ur into monsters and horror but im 13 and disnt realize tht it was gonna b that scary yes i do lno its rated R

  • corrrect me if im wrong i would really like to hear other ppls opinions thanks :)

  • bet it wont be as good as the first

  • This game isn't a remake of Silent Hill, you play the role of Harry Mason in Therapy. Harry (who is in 1st person to give it a more personal feel to the game) talks about the events that happened in the first game.

    You quickly realise the characters are not the same and it's not the same story at all. But you have to get to the end to figure it all out...

  • Yeah I know... I've beaten the game. I was trying not to spoil it, but looks like you took care of that...

  • i dont' mind spoilers for silent hill, especially when im too scared to play myself, and I want to know what's gonna happen

  • ty man, yu da best

  • Comment removed

  • you dont play as harry when he is in therapy thats cheryl this game is just a re imaging of what could of happened in the first silent hill in which spolier alert harry dies in the car crash an cheryl dreams of all the events in silent hill thus in her eyes making harry a hero but in fact harry was dead that whole time so she goes to therapy not believing her father had died an for 18 years she still sees him as if he is still alive but it was all in her head he wasnt just an image in her head

  • Just finished this game and it is AWESOMEEE. It has some very hard puzzles though, some took me over 45 minutes just to figure out, but it was very fun, very creepy too. I re-played the game from the beginning and discovered that the game tracks every choice you make and characters and dialogue will change depending on what paths, actions, and other choices you make. I recommend this.

  • No, the storyline is TOTALLY different. Basically same names and locations but different events. In fact, this game has a lot of references to all Silent Hill games. But, it's not really like any of them at all. The end of it is sad... T.T

  • Just beat it yesterday (got it yesterday). It's VERY short, but one of the best games out there. Certainly one of the best Silent Hill games in a long time. Only part I didn't like were the nightmare sequences... to me they just got in the way of exploration and storyline in some parts. They're also way too easy. Other than that... this game is great, despite its REALLY short length (I can't stress this enough). Go pick it up... NOW! Be warned... the ending is sad though x.x

  • cool, i always thought the first silent hill was the best.

    gotta try this.

  • q tranqueira

  • Imo, this isn't a remake of Silent Hill 1, but rather playing the game through the way Harry Mason recalls all of the events.

  • @keithtuber yes xD

  • is this a remake of Silent Hill 1?

  • Sorta.  Reimagining would be a better term for it.

  • @PhoenixWright56784

    yes, is this remake ^^

  • Dude i got wii, and its crap !

  • I got wii and it's awesome.

  • Meh.....im gunna wait and get it for psp or ps2..I have a wii but I have a bad feeling about it.....wii is an ok console but I would rather play a silent hill game on the console that brought us all the others.....

  • @ihavenonameeva

    You'll lose much. Motion control here is the best of non-sports games on Wii.

  • Yea....motion control is better on the other games but I still gunna go with the ps2

  • And what are you making that judgment on? Your experience in playing all of the games for the wii? I'm sure you haven't played the wii, or you've only played wii sports. Yes, the wii does have bad games, but it does have good games too. The wii is very fun, and you shouldn't be so quick to rate the console.

  • just got this for wii and im wondering why the silent hill games are allways ruined by running in the snow!...always running in the snow for a long time?

  • You didn't run in the snow in any other game aside from the very first one.

  • the only good thing about the wii is that better games like this actually brings them back to the PS2.

  • remake of sh1?

  • For once the wii doesn't get the shitty end of the stick.

  • I miss the other world of the older SH Games, but the other world transformation is amazing oO

  • it looks better than the frankly awful, Silent Hill Homecoming.

  • yeah, i read in a magazine instead of focusing on combat, this game focuses on running away from a scary enemy. that sounds a lot scarier.

  • i HATE WII damn u i got ps3 what the fuck and i gotta wait for it to come out jan

  • @finigin8 @skatejin

    Are you fully aware that the game comes out on the PS2, Wii and PSP?

  • dude it comes out for ps2 also -.-

  • awesom! i want to play it! fucking Wii

  • Have you seen a little girl?

    I wonder how many times Harry will say it in this game...

  • No screaming air raid siren in the background between worlds? That was a signature of the original Silent Hill. Still, I will get this and it will be scary.

  • Is Silent Hill a hard game or your fear just makes it a hard game??????Please respond!!!!!Thankyou!!!!!!!

  • It's both. Some of the old Silent Hill games are difficult because you need to find hidden objects and combine them to move along the story. It just makes it EVEN HARDER with groups of deformed creatures lurking behind every corner. know what i mean?

  • Oh, come one, people! It won't be too bad. Actually, considering all of the awesome stuff they're putting in this game, it'll be great!

    Sure, it might not be as got as the other Silent Hill games (although I'm willing to bet it'll be better that 4; the Room) but bashing it before you've even played is an insult to all of the time and effort the creators have put into it, in hopes that we will enjoy it.

    Just think; customized gaming experience! Awesome graphics! NO MORE BROKEN LOCKS!

  • is an insult to the series and the original story, would you prefer to be a different story, not harry manson

  • i bet most people will get only because the new dahlia looks cool

  • You can't use weapons all you can do is run!

  • This Game raped Silent Hill!!!!

    I want to smack the creators with a pipe!

  • @MsAnimelover13

    And you know that because you've played the game or just watched the trailers? I would say that the movie raped the game series more than these trailers.

  • how do you know it will it's bad? have you played it? please don't give the reasons "because its on the wii" or "because you cant fight".

  • Harry looks too much like Vincent (SH3). And Cybil's tight clothes are gone.

    Do not want.

  • nothing wrong with that vincent is sexy

  • ooookay... i didnt really see vincent as "Sexy" but... thats just my oppinion.

  • when does this game come out?

  • "T was funny, Harry and I went "Oh my god" at the same time; different reasons though : P

    Anyways, I am pretty excited for this game. I LOVED Silent Hill 1 and now that it is being remade I am so much more happier and in love with it.

  • I like the psychology aspect and how choosing different things will alter the games appearance and outcome.

    But how many times will they try to re-hash the first games story?

    It's getting tiring to see the same thing over and over with just a different wrapper.

    At least homecoming was trying to be it's own story, not shamelessly trying to squeeze money out of a done-to-death plot.

    And the gameplay seems interesting, but only time will tell if it actually adds some scares.

  • to be fair silent hill 1 was on the ps1 and we all know how that thing controlled

    as for silent hill 2 it was one of the early ps2 game and i'm guessing the developers didn't know how to program controls for ps2 very well

  • people say that treible controls make horor games scary thats bullshit play eternal darkness on the gamecube perfect controls but still scary has shit

  • I hope this game comes out for PC too

  • Compared to Silent Hill 2, Silent Hill: Shattered Memories looks average. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories is supposed to be 2010. Silent Hill 2 came out in 2001. In the space of 9 years, Silent Hill should have progressed, instead it's gone backwards. Silent Hill Psone looks more impressive, and that came out in 1999. Who ever suggested the idea of removing weapons should be shot. Its the dumbest thing ever. The whole ice thing sucks too.

  • You are absolutely right.

    Silent Hill Shattered Memories doesn't look so good.

    Silent Hill 1,2,3 was masterpiece, specially Silent Hill 2.

    Am the big Silent Hill Fan but Shattered Memories doesnt look good.

    I Hope Konami will Remake Silent Hill 2 on PS3

  • What Silent Hill 2 had:

    -stiff controls

    -horrible combat mechanics

    -puzzles that didn't make any sense

    What Shattered Memories will have:

    -smooth controls

    -puzzles that you could face in reality

    The only reason you think a PSone game looks more impressive than this, is because you're either A: angry about the ice thing, or B: you want combat back.

    And speaking of combat, Homecoming sucks balls. Having an option to fight your enemies doesn't change this fact. This new approach is much better.

  • the terrible combat and stiffness of the game is half of what made the game horrifying. The idea behind it was that if you fight the enemies, you're going to struggle because you aren't the strongest fighter, but if you try to escape, you're just as fucked.

    The fear that one would have in the situation is going to make you disorientated, and make you struggle. All of the controls of the likes of Silent Hill 1, 2, and 3 were completely thought out in a way that amplified the fear.

  • Yup, I know that very well. And I have nothing against that, I'm a huge fan of Silent Hill 1 and especially 2.

    But, if you think about the very concept of FEAR, then even fighting wouldn't make any sense. Because encountering any kind of monster in real life would result in, you guessed it, running away. What did you do in most of the nightmares you saw as a child? Right, ran for your life and never looked back.

    So these new game mechanics make a lot of sense, if you stop and think for a while

  • yea but there some kids out there that would stop and fight the monster.

    But everyone's different some would fight the fucking monster some would run for the hills and some times the one that at would run fight because they have something to fight for like a loved one ...or there wife that happens to be died but get a letter form them like James did and he did a lot of things a sane person would not do like jump in to a hole that went for who know how far down

  • Removing combat is an idea you'd think they would have had at LEAST after the third game. Monsters are less scary when you're looking at them from the safe end of a shotgun. Finally they've got a Silent Hill game that's not an ammo-conservation horror.

  • What happened to the fog??? I sure hope that there is fog somewhere along the game!

  • There better be fog otherwise I call bull.

  • mmmm at the end sounded like bioshock's little sister :B

  • NOOOOOOOOO harry with glasses sucks

  • I guess the glasses is supposed to give him more of a writer's look since that was his occupation

  • Team silent =God!

  • ...=/ Shattered Memories = fucking shit the tue silent hills are the games were made by team silent...the best games of silent hill are silent hill1 2 and...the 3 i like it ^^ but the silent 4 origins and homecoming....=/ are a shit...

  • I think this could be quite good, thought I am a bit worried about the Wii version...the Wii, while a great system, never seems to his a good middle ground with it's control system for multiple-system games, either performing horribly, or beautifully.

  • What have they done to Silent Hill? Wow that looks nothing like Silent Hill I know...hmmm, whatever. Might give this a try on a PS2.

  • harry has glasses?

  • in the first game no...

    btw wtf is happening to Silent hill?

  • DELAYED until January :(

  • I like the new aspects of gameplay they're adding, but they got rid of Otherworld. Silent Hill is not Silent Hill without Otherworld. The story makes no sense when you set it in some frozen alternate dimension. Otherwise, this game looks like it would be a solid remake. I will probably play it anyway, but I still think it's a stupid idea to change a major plot device like Otherworld.

  • That snow and icestuff IS the otherworld ^^

  • No, not really. The original game was set in a winter setting, and it's sort of redundant to go from snow to colder snow and ice. Otherworld is a darkly surreal realm that's basically a reflection of different people's minds. In the original it was a place where Alessa had power, and the creatures were symbolic of her fears and discomforts. This new icy setting is sort of a cop out, and it feels like they're watering the story down to appeal to the non-gamers who liked the movie.

  • i think, as long as the old Team doesn't return, Silent Hill will never get it's old fame back ...

    Since Homecoming i only buy it, because there's Silent Hill on the package ... and because of Akira :D

  • But the snow and ice thing IS the other world. The creators of the game said so. They wanted to change the concept of the Otherworld, add in a little change.

  • but for Otherworld we understand "hell"

    and for "hell" we understand "fire,dead bodies, lots of blood, arms legs, and stuff" not ice!

  • My view is that they could have had this as a verient of otherworld from a dark one coming to town. To redo the series in this instead, is bad..

    Otherworld isn't a hell and all have their own devient. After that, remember that only two explores a dark one coming to town as 1,3 and 4 all has them tied to a ritual or cult event.

    If they are so into 2 as they say, they need to quit posting 2 over everything where its the protagonists mind & actually do more of the dark ones coming into town.

  • Oh and got to love their phychological aspect, visual verients of characters and other tiny things that you already know for checking the tabs on a chart.

    If TS did it, or the team transition comminicated better then now, we would have full otherworld devients or other.

    Also, if Alessa isn't there, Silent Hill will be uninspired as it will be the cliche of "it's real?" to just "oh, in his head, as usual".

  • Maybe Samael accidently left the freezer open one night. and when he woke up, the whole town had frozen over...lol its possible. but seriously don't judge just becuase its now ice doesn't mean it won't be scary.

  • coming out?

  • silent hill is really changing from the first one but im so gettin this game only cuz im in love with silent hill :]]

  • this is a 'reimagining' of the remake. they're just revisiting the story cuz they luv it so much or something. and srsly. if that's the best they can do with graphics... guy's come on. the wii is not THAT bad. nice try.

  • at the end itsounds like this "you have to run daddy you can't fight them run"

  • Needs a graphic makeover

  • coool is in the snow XD

  • i got rid of my wii last spring and this game is the only reason im getting another wii. And to all u idiots, This is remake of the original.

  • This is not a remake!!!! it has a different story than the original!!! Dumbass!!!!! although I do think that you are right about gettin' another wii...

  • i loved the silent hill 1 but i think the remake is actually going to open our eyes. it looks like events in the first game are going to be shown from a new perspective in that perhaps not everything harry experienced is exactly as he saw it.

    certain stuff he may have made up. almost like the car crash ending in his mind from the original. i think its a great idea. hell yeah

  • ohhh in psp too yeah...

  • There's only so much you can do with going forward with the Silent Hill story. It only makes sense to go back and tell it again from the beginning.

  • click me for a new trailer!!!