Added: 4 years ago
From: kfpmadonna
Views: 774,200
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (283)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • GAVIN DEGRAW IS SOOOOOOO BEST

  • IMHO, It is rare that a cover is better than the original, especially if the original was written by the artist who first performed it, not delivered to them to sing. I liked Phil Collins with Genesis, and I liked him solo before Genesis, but I have disliked just about everything he's done since Genesis. I am not a huge Mariah fan, though I do recognize her incredible talent. I prefer her version to the original. She just seems to identify so strongly with this song, she made it her's.

  • a minha cantora pra vida toda! i love mariah forever.

  • prefer the phil collins version!! she ruined a great song...

  • @footy319

    No, this is about quality. You're just expressing your opinion. I also prefer the original, but in fact this is a very good cover. You know... some people just do a copy. This is a -performance-

  • good good future up up

  • nipple at 2:21

  • God i love her <3

  • That girl was so talented. too bad that she met those "rappers".

  • I think that when an artist covers another artists' song, it is NOT to prove that they can sing it better than the original...To me, it just means that the covering artist is singing an original to give their version, flavor, feeling of the song. Many artists cover songs & add their touch to it. And many have a special connection to the original song. I happen to like all of the songs MC has covered, inc this one.

    Some songs should not be covered IMO; Or maybe only on singing competitions.

  • The end part is Unreal... absolutely amazing! I miss this mariah carey . . Thumbs up if you agree x x

  • mariah's version is so epic lol. please please check out my short acapella version if you get a chance!

  • really . it's a great voice, or must say the best of the best. but nobody does it like phil collins.

  • @guillerugna Exactly what i thought. The perfect version is the one where we can hear them two at the same time.

  • It's beautiful

  • I love this song, and i love you mariah, i liked you when you started, like you now and i will like you tomorrow, you have given a lot to me through your music and I thank you for that. Always I will love you!

  • Comment removed

  • @78nikki1 Well your fault for being weak and dependent on people for emotional support, learn your lesson.

  • "and you comin back to me is against the odds and that's what i gotta face"

  • I like this version. It's great in it's own right, and yes, i prefer Phil Collins version only because it's one of my favorite songs from all music ever written, hearing it for the first time when I lived in east Anglia and recorded him playing it live from Wembley Stadium. Mariah does it justice. Personally, I'd like to hear a Phil Collins and Mariah Carey do a duet of this song before the master gets too old to sing. Thumbs up.

  • Mariah is a beast!

  • I wish she didn't have to use sex appeal so much. 

  • For all those who say Phil Collin's version is better why bother to comment on Mariah's version then?

  • TEMASO ;)

  • wow,i love this song.

  • Beautiful... but Phil Collins's version is way better

  • i miss you b.a.s

  • my music

  • hav always loved this song, but come to think of it its so sad

  • beautiful women beautiful song nice video

  • me more :) :P

  • Good song! <3

  • essa música é umas das melhores que eu ja escutei

  • Mariah Carey makes everything sound better!!! :)

  • youll always be in my heart Sylvie. Mat from France

  • You never aspired like this kind, so be nice. She is all she ever was in what is called human and furthermore, a rare beauty that we treasure. Leave Britany alone. Oh, god. So funny. Yeah good, Chris. You're the next fame of America. The appeal o, "It's just us." America is capitalism. Works for all, has a coldness, but it does elicit greatness. Love anyway. A country boy (or girl) can survive. That's America. I love Mariah. She's so unbelievably dreamy in her artisticness.

  • phil collins is alot better didn't denjy it.

  • Yeah...I think I like Phil Collin's version better. This particular version doesn't seem to have any feeling in it all. :/

  • @Anatinea You have shit taste if you do not think this version has any feeling.

  • @YankeeGirl226

    *eyeroll* Dislike of one song does not a bad taste in music make. I repeat my earlier statement and add that this version sounds like it's being sung in one note and that Ms. Carey is straining her voice in order to sing as low as she is in this song.

  • Qué Hermosísima Voz: La De: Mariah Carey, Qué Falcetes, Es SOPRANO, Con Tonos Altísimos,Emociona su Voz, Acaricia el Oído...."Against All Odds" Le Quedó igual de Bella Que A : Phill Collins... Ojalá Mariah Carey Hubiese Tenido Un Hijo(a) Con : El Cantante Mexicano Luis Miguel, Para Ver Si Salía Un Tenor U Otra Soprano en Su Voz Y Talento Artístico,,,

  • She must be doing something right to be the second most successful female artist of all time worldwide. All I gotta say!

    Watch my vids~

  • wow...id love to see mariah on her dark brown hair....

  • One of the last connects you'll hear of new school and old school Mariah you'll ever hear.

  • I swear she's beautiful in every way

  • is there a fast version of this song? either mariah's or someone else;s?? thanks!

  • Beautiful song!

  • i love this song! wether its sung my Mariah or Phil. But i like Mariah's version by her self than the duet with Westlife..

  • She's still got that amazing voice, even to this day. This is a great tribute song to an amazing legend.

  • I think you're a disgrace to people with opinions. If you don't like this version for whatever reason, why do you feel you need to voice that opinion and get on the nerves of the thousands of people who enjoy it? Do we go on Phil Collins' videos and say "no... didn't sing it as well as Mariah"?

  • @gloomyoutlook thx i hate when ppl judge others

  • i just love this song..and the mariah's version is perfect...

  • @MoNyBrItNeY you should probably commit suicide

  • no honey, shakira looks like her, Mariah is the original one, remember?

  • i love mariah carey so much!!!

  • Such a beautiful song!

  • great song

  • One of the saddest songs I can think of.

  • ohmmgee imm feelin disz. all in my soul nd caint nobdy toucch it

  • love sucks the life right out of you and chews you up and spits you back down to the ground like nothing...gotta love this freaking song. never ever ever again will i do that. yuk

  • Mariah's version is amazing!!! I felt hers

  • I never thought any one other than Phil Collins could sing that song... I stand corrected... or should I say "he stands erected!" hahaha

  • if sexy had a name during the rainbow period it would've been mariah! dang nick (cannon) know his wife used to be sexy back then!

  • phil collins did  a beautiful job with this song but i think mariah owned it

  • same at 2.34..

    and 2.45, on the left pic. doesnt she look a little bit like alyssa milano in brown hair?

  • 2.24

    :"DD

  • you don´t like porn stars?? :D

  • che fica!

  • she looks better burnette :D

  • ΚΟΜΜΑΤΑΡΑ !!!<3

  • what a voice! but i think most people will agree phil collins is miles better

  • I like Phil's Version

    But hearing this made me cry cuz I love Mariah's voice :')

  • Man, she looks like a porn star in some of those outfits! Put some clothes on!

  • 2:47 shes beatiful!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Simply Amazing

  • I think Mariah Carey has one of the best voices ..... but I have to be honest in saying that I'd prefer Phil Collin's version over this one.

    Not that she ruined it or anything .... but the original sounds a tad better.

  • @watevafilms gavin degraw did a really good rendition too

  • @watevafilms I disagree. Mariah's version has more emotion. It touches the heart.

  • beautifull

  • are you out of your mind? She kicks Phil Collins' butt on this song!!!!!!

  • it's good but gavin de graw's version is waaay better! her voice is beautiful tough :)

  • NO, IT ISN'T BETTER

  • It's kind of sad how much she has grown.

    it make's me miss the past more :(

    "So take a look at HER now" :)

  • @xTwilightluFFerrx cv é quéh

    mmmmm

  • @xTwilightluFFerrx oh yeah you're right

    "Let's take a look a her now

    Cos we'll be all standing here

    And her coming back to us

    Is against all odds

    That's a chancewe've got to taaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaake!"

  • @xTwilightluFFerrx Is she not meant to grow as a person?

  • @xTwilightluFFerrx its becouse you miss your won past

  • sweetest voice

  • Comment removed

  • is very beutiful video !!!

  • mariah carey wg mnie ma jeden z najlepszych glosow na swiecie :)))))) uwielbiam jej sluchac :))))))

  • don't understand a word of yours except"mariah carey "

  • that's because this person speaks a different language. english is not the only language in the world, you realize.

  • Love you Christian...

  • Such a beautiful song=))

  • beautiful

  • This song is very cool. Mariah Carey is smart and lovely woman.. I like it :)

  • she's so sexi

  • Ahh U Cant Beat Phil Now ahaha

  • Wow! Phil Collins was great, but pales in comparison to Mariah's version... absolutely stunning.

  • word.

  • lovee this song

  • What a lovely pair of... lungs.

  • I am glad that Mariah did this cover and Benosag and Jennifer Holla, didn't do it, because if they tried, the song would be ruined! But, Phil would save it and put it down, on record and live!  Peace and thanks for posting!

  • such a beautiful voice

  • piękne

  • this song is sooo sad ,but i love it...i

  • strangley i love her eyebrows lol

  • lol So do I!!!!

  • I know what you mean haha

  • 2:44 to 2:47 she looks stunning

  • she definitely looks soooooooo much better as a brunette.

  • great cover. for all the people saying she isn't as good as phil collins. it's a cover. :p

  • better than the original!

  • perfect =D

  • está lindooooooooooo

  • w0w.>!! amAzing..!!

    sUka..

  • this song is so touching i want to cy when i hear it

  • no offense to mariah, she did a good job covering this song from phil collins. but to be honest she cant reach phil :)

  • Exactly

  • the words on this song are so touching, listen!!! :')

    xx

  • my heart just dies for the moment..

  • LGT-Wow,this is a angel voice.I Love her...

  • i dont think they look like cobie

  • colbie caillat is what mariah would like if she was full white.....

  • mariah is voll hübsch *.*

  • Fuk shes hot !

  • She sings this so beautifully

  • wow! This song is so wunderful!

  • fantastic song!!! x

  • ROFL @ the guy's post below mines.

  • a beast ov a tune x x x

  • I would say that Colbie Caillat looks like Mariah, lol, but I would totally agree. When I saw Colbie in concert, she even had some of the same mannerisms and stage technique, and all you could think of was how much she's like Mariah.

  • ich liebe diesen song...einfach beste :-)

  • GUD SONG....

  • Love dis song ! (l)

  • stupenda qst kanzone..................nn c'è che dire....semplicemente spettacolare...

  • this song really gets to me in my heart

  • the most beautifull woman in the world

  • She's so pretty, and she has a really lush voice

    X !

  • nice collection

  • cant believe she wore such slutty outfits at 2 events, i thot ppl were exaggerating...wow

  • V Nice Song

  • beautyful song ---- awesome !!!

  • Luv this song..mariah has a beautiful voice x

  • for some reason i think when she started out she was alot prettier then she is now it looks like shes had cheek implants which kinda makes her look chipmunky lol still beautiful talented vioce.

  • a memory of ur FACE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

  • I hate to admit it...but this song hits me hard.

  • omg 2:45, she looks amazing ! i think her hair there really suits her ( Y )

  • Wooh...pause at 00:59 Damn. And I thought I had a good amount of her albums...NOPE.

  • i love her version of this song .

    ♥♥♥♥

  • omg i love this song,

    she totally makes it perfect, love it :)

  • 2:23

  • perv .

  • sooooo schönes lied...

    sie kann so toll singen..

    =)

  • shee looks awsome at 1:53

  • what does FIM mean in the end?? is it possible that you ment FIN??

  • i will always love you Valentino...and I know you coming back to me is against all odds...But I will always be here waiting for you

  • i love this song

    its very wonderful

  • excellent cover and song :D