Yes - I can imagine she does appeal to certain Metal Fans. Reckon she likes her males subserviant though. At 6ft 3 she's entitled to! So watch your step. However, I don't see any comparisons with any other Metal Vocalists I've heard so far. Pretty pointless making them really.
Tarja enloquecio a la gente!!! espero que esto te llegue (floor y lisa) es que recien se las estan conociendo en sudamerica con disco anteriores gracias---- perfectbuena ---- argentina.
Es la mejor pero deseo que no tenga diferencias con la banda after forever(me gusta!, es muy buena las mezclas de sonidos y arreglos que le fueron dando a todos los discos y eso es lo mas dificil de llegar), y que vuelva!!! lo mismo con lisa en xandria!!! molesta que siempre aparece alguien o algo y que desarme lo bueno!!! y otra cosa que me molesto es un poco mas de difusion para cuando esten en argentina o mejor combinar con bandas como Rata Blanca como hizo nightwish!!!
I love you too, madly the three goddesses (Tarja, Floor and Simone).
Floor is fire, punch, power ... Tarja is water, stone, storm ... Simone is the wind, flight and drive ... the three together are the owners of the world!
She's better than any other metal singer, we all know that. But the best thing of floor is that she's not a "diva" she's no used by her band like just an image with nice voice. It seems like she loves to sing and anything else.... She's the best in any sense !!!!
Nope, she doesn't have a daughter or son. And she isn't with Sander anymore. Seems that she is in a relationship (as her status on myspace) but none know who he is.
We can't compare tarja and floor, they are so different, Who is the best is a personal opinion... But In "MY" opinion floor is super versatile and has a beautiful voice... tarja always sings the same but has a stunning voice too... so they both are amazing, Don't judge them cause I'm pretty sure we all want to sing like they do ;-)
In the movie business for example they compare actors that perform in movies that aren't even the same genre when they're considering giving the awards for best actor or best actress at something like the Oscars.
So why can't we compare Floor and Tarja? They both sing in metal bands; they're both sopranos and use classical elements in their singing.
Trying to appease everyone is nice, but being able to state and justify an opinion while respecting others' arguments for theirs is much better.
It's fun that this song is even used to make bodybuilding video's even more bombastic or anything that freaking kicks but, this song is used :) Awesome! Floor is one of my favourite allround singers. It's maybe naive to compare her with ppl like Celine Dion, but they share one thing, and that's they both can sing in so many styles. True talent!
hmmm well tarja is better in lyrical singing...(she's awesome i love her!) but that's everything she can sing, she can't sing grunts or not-lyrical and floor can. So Floor is a more complete singer xD
omg of course I did! I mean I love Tarja!! when My winter storm came out I was the first one to buy it! (ahaha well maybe not the first one) yeah she is amazing but i really think that there's only a beautiful voice in the album, the music is missing :S anyway
I talked about technique xD and that is not about taste, Floor's a more complete singer and Tarja is the best lyrical singer in metal stuff
Floor Jansen es muy potente y es mas metalera que Tarja, pero ambas son geniales y me es dificil decidir quien es mejor, las dos son increibles, sus voces de otro mundo
Floor's voice is much more dynamic than Tarja's, Tarja only sings in soprno without any variations, Floor can change her style while singing without problems, also, Floor does not has that diva attitude.
'apprentice'... Tarja is the only apprentice here! She may look better (and that's why you all, 'Tarja fans', say fake bullshit like 'Tarja is better') but no one can beat Jansen's perfect vocals! Ask an expert, you goof, and I promise you they'll say I'm right! Jansen has more skills than any other singer in Metal! Tarja can't belt high notes cuz her range is very limited (F2-F5) & her voice is deep, and that's why she only sings low notes with operatic vocals!
I bet you don't even know Jansen so STFU cuz you're just making fun of yourself!
Jansen is the most versatile singer ever, her breath control & vocal technique are perfect, her vocal timbre is beyond fantastic, plus she sounds live as amazing as on the studio CD's!
Obviously Tarja could never sing After Forever songs since they're outside her vocal range!
And she really sounds like a man since she only sings low notes, although she sounds pretty cool in 'Romanticide' & 'Smells Like Teen Spirit'!
stas envidiosa de su carisma y su belleza y sobre todo esa estatura y voz imponente, why are u so envy about her? cada kien con su gusto pero Floor Is the Best Metal Chick!!
LoL! they have both category! the musical fist of tarja is classical,but this one is sounds like power not classical!in short! tarja was good for classical and floor was great for rock!
I don't care about your proofs. I have the right to say that Tarja is better if thats my opinion. But in this case I do agree with you. Floor's highest notes are much better than Tarja's. But unfortunately I HATE Floor's normal notes (or her normal singing so to say). It sounds really harsh.
So, Floor's high notes= great. Her normal singing = sucks. Thats my personal opinion. We all have our own opinions, right? That my friend, is a fact.
Who cares how 'harsh' is it? It's the vocal color what matters! Tarja might have a 'calm' voice but she sounds like a man & her voice is false & it has no power! Floor has a loud, clear, high, very powerful & beautiful sounding voice, versatility & an amazing range!
You can have your opinion but don't say Jansen's normal singing sucks cuz it's not a fact! And if you think her normal voice (chest voice) 'sucks', then I don't know what kind of ears do you have! Chest voice has the best sound!
BTW, I'm not a Tarja hater! I do listen to her solo album & to all the NW albums & she has a beautiful voice & she's a good singer too but you just can't compare Floor & Tarja since she's just a classical singer! Floor can sing EVERYTHING and sound the way she wants depending on what vocal register she uses, loudness & pitch! Tarja can sing only with operatic vocals & her technique is not too good either! Jansen is obviously superior to other singers!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Tarja is a much better singer than Floor. Floor's voice sounds common to me. Tarja's voice is much more unique, and in my opinion sounds much much better. But you know, that's why EVERYONE knows about Floor. :) (sarcasm)
Not saying Floor is bad, her voice is good. Sorta sounds like the girl from Heart, but Tarja's much better. Floor could never sing songs like Nemo or Ghost Love Score, or Phantom of the Opera.
Tarja couldn't even perform 'Nemo' live herself. Also, Floor can actually sing outside her genre. Tarja can barely perform with her chest voice; let alone belt.
Tarja's operatic vocals are also quite subpar. If you want Opera, listen to Maria Callas, Leontyne Price, and Lucia Popp. Tarja's far from being the best.
You know, what struck me when listening to After Forever covering NW was how similar Floor and Tarja sound. Or at least how similar Floor sounds live to the way Tarja sounds on NW ALBUMS lol.
That being said, in the skill department, Floor beats Tarja hands down. I used to be a huge Tarja fan, but come on man, listen to her live a few times; she's awful half the time. Proof:
watch?v=_rO5ndL7bPo
P.S. Floor is QUITE well known. Not only from AF but also for collaborating with Arjen Lucassen.
Tarja sounds amazing live! It's only natural to have a few bad live performances but I prefer Tarja's live voice to Floor's ANY day. I mean, Tarja sounds practically the same live, if not better. I mostly only watch NW performances live.
=)) it somehow doesn't surprise me you ask who Arjen Lucassen is. Google is your friend. The metal archives are your friend too.
As for Tarja v Floor, I used to be a HUGE Tarja fan; and I'm strongly biased towards her since I like NW a lot more than AF; but after listening to Floor a while I still think she's the better vocalist.
And live, she sounds OK even on her bad days (which Tarja does not), and her stage presence is on a whole different level.
"The only metal I like is Nightwish." -- And the metal you tried and decided you don't like is?
"metal" is a huge genre with dozens of sub-genres that sound nothing alike; from mellow to heavy, from slow to lightning fast, from harmonious to dissonant. Which isn't saying it's the only good genre; just worth a try.
Taste explained
I tried A and B and I like A better - Taste. Can't be argued with. Stay in this area.
I tried A; I'm sure I like it more than I could ever like B - Ignorance.
Someone told me to go look at Floor Jansen and compare her to Tarja.. so I did it on this vid.. That's why I'm here. I was on a Tarja video until I checked my comments and it brought me here..
"I mean, Tarja sounds practically the same live, if not better. I mostly only watch NW performances live."
Haha, are you deaf?
Tarja sounds even more like a man live, she sings much lower. Floor sounds just like on the studio CD, or even better, as someone else said before.
I do prefer the live versions for "Dead Boy's Poem" and "Come Cover Me", but for the other songs the studio versions are much better. At least, she sings them higher in the studio and she's not out of breath.
"Floor's voice sounds common to me. Tarja's voice is much more unique, and in my opinion sounds much much better."
Floor can sound like Tarja, but Tarja can't sound like Floor cuz she's not versatile, she sounds like a man and her range is very limited. Floor is truly unique and her vocal color is amazing. She can use every vocal register and sound the way she wants. ---->
----> Opera" and her version is the best, of course.
I can see you're a Tarja fan, but don't state YOUR OPINION as a fact.
And skill in singing is NOT an opinion, so Floor is obviously MUCH better than Tarja. One can't even compare, LOL!
If YOU prefer Tarja, ok, but it doesn't change the fact that Floor is the best, one of the most amazing sopranos ever! Her voice is just magical & very powerful too.
I know she has but Floor's version sounding like crap compared to Nightwish's. Not anyone could sing the songs... especially not Floor. Yeah, After Forever sounds so bad.. Tarja can't sink that low.
We have different opinions if you haven't realized that by now. You're not changing mine.
What I said is a fact, proved with arguments, for skill in singing/music is NOT an opinion.
You may prefer Tarja or not... but it's only a matter of personal taste.
One has to be very open-minded to see the reality, though.
"Floor doesn't have more skill... Tarja does."
Tarja can only sing low notes, mainly in mixed voice, while Floor can reach very high notes in pure chest voice. If, to you, Tarja has more skills then Floor, then you are lost.
Tarja is the best singer from any point of view.
Leaving aside her superior technique and skill.. she could throw them away and still remain the best, solely on her natural voice and ears.
I admire Floor but frankly I cannot stand such malicious and half intellectual remarks regarding this and that.
alessia79twnsnd 1 month ago 7
2:05 and 4:09 is pretty damn hot ^.^
2001mrwiigamer 9 months ago
What's the name of this song?
NtinaWoW 9 months ago
Yes - I can imagine she does appeal to certain Metal Fans. Reckon she likes her males subserviant though. At 6ft 3 she's entitled to! So watch your step. However, I don't see any comparisons with any other Metal Vocalists I've heard so far. Pretty pointless making them really.
jezkn 1 year ago
I've met floor, shes huge! must be over 6 feet tall.
Dungarth 1 year ago
why does everybody compare floor and tarja? Is there something i'm missing here?
nwawallace 1 year ago
Tarja enloquecio a la gente!!! espero que esto te llegue (floor y lisa) es que recien se las estan conociendo en sudamerica con disco anteriores gracias---- perfectbuena ---- argentina.
perfectbuena 1 year ago
Es la mejor pero deseo que no tenga diferencias con la banda after forever(me gusta!, es muy buena las mezclas de sonidos y arreglos que le fueron dando a todos los discos y eso es lo mas dificil de llegar), y que vuelva!!! lo mismo con lisa en xandria!!! molesta que siempre aparece alguien o algo y que desarme lo bueno!!! y otra cosa que me molesto es un poco mas de difusion para cuando esten en argentina o mejor combinar con bandas como Rata Blanca como hizo nightwish!!!
perfectbuena 1 year ago
I've met her while practicing an action She is very nice
mazzzie27 1 year ago
lol, 'floor'? Funky name
stina2711 1 year ago
floor is the best <3
luifer0814 1 year ago
Follow her and her band REVAMP!!
DaRkSymphoniCa 1 year ago
I love you too, madly the three goddesses (Tarja, Floor and Simone).
Floor is fire, punch, power ... Tarja is water, stone, storm ... Simone is the wind, flight and drive ... the three together are the owners of the world!
othervision 1 year ago
Love u Floor!
Luiz3581 1 year ago
Yeah, Discord. <3 One of my fav. After Forever songs. <3
Floor is coming with her new band.. <3
turkey9494 1 year ago
She's better than any other metal singer, we all know that. But the best thing of floor is that she's not a "diva" she's no used by her band like just an image with nice voice. It seems like she loves to sing and anything else.... She's the best in any sense !!!!
aLeInPiNk 1 year ago
I love her!!!
xxxmaite666xxx 2 years ago
i cnt believe she wud b single if i eva had the chance id get wid her!
210rockerchick 2 years ago
I can't belive you are that bad in english!
Lasset89 2 years ago 2
what?! sorry if you dont understand slang!dont read it if u dnt like it.
210rockerchick 2 years ago
Floor you're the best forever and after!
Rosana6 2 years ago 2
3:29 OMG <3
She's beautiful, talented and adorable!
fairyxcorpse 2 years ago 3
I read in someplace that she will join at The MFVF with Doro Tarja and Liv kristine. It would be amazing, awesome , great ! :D.
CrsTTn92 2 years ago 2
oh yes she did wid doro and liv and epica it was amazin!!
210rockerchick 2 years ago
how tall is she? she's so tall! taller than her after forever bandmates!
dazzitboy 2 years ago
I'm 6" and she's taller than me, because I stood next to her during a guest's performance.
methalys 2 years ago
for real? damn dude.
dazzitboy 2 years ago
im 5'11 and she taller then me i thought we wud b the same height she got gawjus figure tho
210rockerchick 2 years ago
THE BEST, SHE´S THE BEST
patrot9 2 years ago 2
does any one know if floor in a relationship wid a guy?or has a daughter?saw pix of her on facebook thought she was single??xx
210rockerchick 2 years ago
I thought she was with Sander from the band.
wishofthenightnicky 2 years ago
i thought that was her brother or is he frm epica? she must be with that guy in her pics on fb and the girl luks like her too.xx
210rockerchick 2 years ago
@210rockerchick
Nope, she doesn't have a daughter or son. And she isn't with Sander anymore. Seems that she is in a relationship (as her status on myspace) but none know who he is.
ThaisDecipher 1 year ago
@ThaisDecipher
Apparantly she has a daughter on facebook called Frozen Angel?!
An di know she not with Sander but can see she in a relationship, hmm wonder if its a musician maybe even Russel Allen thats going to annoy me now...
210rockerchick 1 year ago
@210rockerchick
No, I'm sure she doesn't have a daughter, nor son. I've been her fan since she was very young (when the band started).
ThaisDecipher 1 year ago
We can't compare tarja and floor, they are so different, Who is the best is a personal opinion... But In "MY" opinion floor is super versatile and has a beautiful voice... tarja always sings the same but has a stunning voice too... so they both are amazing, Don't judge them cause I'm pretty sure we all want to sing like they do ;-)
Hail Floor, I <3 her =D
misshotbeauty 2 years ago 6
agreed.
flyleaf1982 2 years ago
In the movie business for example they compare actors that perform in movies that aren't even the same genre when they're considering giving the awards for best actor or best actress at something like the Oscars.
So why can't we compare Floor and Tarja? They both sing in metal bands; they're both sopranos and use classical elements in their singing.
Trying to appease everyone is nice, but being able to state and justify an opinion while respecting others' arguments for theirs is much better.
moneymail002 2 years ago
Metal, rock, pop, Opera... she can sing everyting!
I realy love her, she's my favourite singer between female fronted metal bands.
I cannot wait until 2010 for her return with the new band she founded with Waldemar Sorychta!
Sorciolo 2 years ago 4
She's coming back? Wow I didn't know that!
wishofthenightnicky 2 years ago
they both have an amazing voice but i like Tarja more because im used to listen to Nightwish xD ptiy she left.
stop comparing them just relax and listen to their beautiful voices ;D
kowenses 2 years ago 2
It's fun that this song is even used to make bodybuilding video's even more bombastic or anything that freaking kicks but, this song is used :) Awesome! Floor is one of my favourite allround singers. It's maybe naive to compare her with ppl like Celine Dion, but they share one thing, and that's they both can sing in so many styles. True talent!
SinisterSkip 2 years ago 2
Floor jansen can do so much with her voice. She's in a category all her own.
She Rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Romingwitherness 2 years ago 3
my favorite Tarja and Floor
Floor very good but Tarja the best!!!!
Tarja is the queen:)
Xen313 2 years ago
The Quuen
Sonorensee 2 years ago 2
I love AF! And Floor gets me hot!
DoomNGloom13 2 years ago 3
I love her in see through clothes XD
Very beautiful!
Tajwisher 3 years ago 2
iam so gonna miss after forever especailly floor best singer eva!!hope she comes bk
NO1AmyLee 3 years ago
Happy Birthday, Floor!
violentorgasms 3 years ago
yeahh dude, i love her voice
met4lhe4d666 3 years ago
floor's the best!!
floor is obviously better than tarja!!
!!!!!
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago 19
2.29 and 2.39 best pic!! i must admit floor was better then tarja although i luv sharon just as much
NO1AmyLee 3 years ago
Yeah, Sharon also has a magical voice! :)
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
@DaRkSymphoniCa she's not better than tarja:-o
tarja is the best of all
but floor can really good sing:-o
xVanDaaltjex 1 year ago
@xVanDaaltjex
hmmm well tarja is better in lyrical singing...(she's awesome i love her!) but that's everything she can sing, she can't sing grunts or not-lyrical and floor can. So Floor is a more complete singer xD
DaRkSymphoniCa 1 year ago
@DaRkSymphoniCa i don't now or you now listening tarja when she begon singing alone but here new album ''my winter storm'' is amazing
i more love tarja but that's just a taste what you likexD
xVanDaaltjex 1 year ago
@xVanDaaltjex
omg of course I did! I mean I love Tarja!! when My winter storm came out I was the first one to buy it! (ahaha well maybe not the first one) yeah she is amazing but i really think that there's only a beautiful voice in the album, the music is missing :S anyway
I talked about technique xD and that is not about taste, Floor's a more complete singer and Tarja is the best lyrical singer in metal stuff
and i guess we love both of them xD!!
DaRkSymphoniCa 1 year ago
awesome video!Floor is one of the best singers ever!
i love the pictures with her and Sharon:)
XxfrozenbutterflyxX 3 years ago
Awesome vid, wishofthenightnicky!
5/5
FrozenMermaid666 3 years ago
Floor Jansen is an incredible amazing singer!!!
She´s the best!!! better than tarja.
Griefshire16 3 years ago
Floor Jansen es muy potente y es mas metalera que Tarja, pero ambas son geniales y me es dificil decidir quien es mejor, las dos son increibles, sus voces de otro mundo
divaandreasth 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
tarja is very very very very better....this girls is a apprentice
WEREWOLFCORPORATION 3 years ago
Floor Jansen is much more better than tarja!!!
The best singer in metal!
Griefshire16 3 years ago 5
Floor's voice is much more dynamic than Tarja's, Tarja only sings in soprno without any variations, Floor can change her style while singing without problems, also, Floor does not has that diva attitude.
belisario1985 3 years ago 3
How old are you, stupid retard?!
'apprentice'... Tarja is the only apprentice here! She may look better (and that's why you all, 'Tarja fans', say fake bullshit like 'Tarja is better') but no one can beat Jansen's perfect vocals! Ask an expert, you goof, and I promise you they'll say I'm right! Jansen has more skills than any other singer in Metal! Tarja can't belt high notes cuz her range is very limited (F2-F5) & her voice is deep, and that's why she only sings low notes with operatic vocals!
FrozenMermaid666 3 years ago
I bet you don't even know Jansen so STFU cuz you're just making fun of yourself!
Jansen is the most versatile singer ever, her breath control & vocal technique are perfect, her vocal timbre is beyond fantastic, plus she sounds live as amazing as on the studio CD's!
Obviously Tarja could never sing After Forever songs since they're outside her vocal range!
And she really sounds like a man since she only sings low notes, although she sounds pretty cool in 'Romanticide' & 'Smells Like Teen Spirit'!
FrozenMermaid666 3 years ago 2
Tarja is the apprentice,Floor is the best!!
Floor is really versatile,she has a beutiful voice,and she uses a lot of types of singing,
tarja just sing like an average soprano!
Griefshire16 3 years ago 3
No es tan linda pero si tiene muy buena voz
AnaPrincess89 3 years ago
stas envidiosa de su carisma y su belleza y sobre todo esa estatura y voz imponente, why are u so envy about her? cada kien con su gusto pero Floor Is the Best Metal Chick!!
misshotbeauty 3 years ago 2
of course she´s better than tarja!!
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago 7
of course!!!!!!!!!!!! much more power!!!
RocioBeuz 3 years ago 6
I love Floor! she is soo seexy and she has a very beautiful voice!
sashadith513 3 years ago
sdfgadfgsadfhadh
rycessromance 3 years ago
LoL! they have both category! the musical fist of tarja is classical,but this one is sounds like power not classical!in short! tarja was good for classical and floor was great for rock!
rycessromance 3 years ago
Floors high notes are fucking amazing as well. Almost better than Tarja.
Visse90 3 years ago
Good said Visse90, just replace 'Almost' with 'Way' and make me happy ;)
F355 3 years ago
'Almost better than Tarja.'
WTF? Tarja can't hit high notes, LOL! Floor Jansen = THE BEST! Everyone who says she's not obviously knows nothing about voices/singing!
Everyone can sing like Tarja but no one can sing like Floor! It's a fact!
BTW, you should listen to all the AF songs so you could see how amazing & versatile Floor is! You offend her if you compare her to Tarja!
She can belt and SUSTAIN much higher notes than Tarja's highest falsetto note! Plus her vibrato is perfect! :D
FrozenMermaid666 3 years ago 3
I don't care about your proofs. I have the right to say that Tarja is better if thats my opinion. But in this case I do agree with you. Floor's highest notes are much better than Tarja's. But unfortunately I HATE Floor's normal notes (or her normal singing so to say). It sounds really harsh.
So, Floor's high notes= great. Her normal singing = sucks. Thats my personal opinion. We all have our own opinions, right? That my friend, is a fact.
Visse90 3 years ago
Who cares how 'harsh' is it? It's the vocal color what matters! Tarja might have a 'calm' voice but she sounds like a man & her voice is false & it has no power! Floor has a loud, clear, high, very powerful & beautiful sounding voice, versatility & an amazing range!
You can have your opinion but don't say Jansen's normal singing sucks cuz it's not a fact! And if you think her normal voice (chest voice) 'sucks', then I don't know what kind of ears do you have! Chest voice has the best sound!
FrozenMermaid666 3 years ago
BTW, I'm not a Tarja hater! I do listen to her solo album & to all the NW albums & she has a beautiful voice & she's a good singer too but you just can't compare Floor & Tarja since she's just a classical singer! Floor can sing EVERYTHING and sound the way she wants depending on what vocal register she uses, loudness & pitch! Tarja can sing only with operatic vocals & her technique is not too good either! Jansen is obviously superior to other singers!
FrozenMermaid666 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tarja is a much better singer than Floor. Floor's voice sounds common to me. Tarja's voice is much more unique, and in my opinion sounds much much better. But you know, that's why EVERYONE knows about Floor. :) (sarcasm)
Not saying Floor is bad, her voice is good. Sorta sounds like the girl from Heart, but Tarja's much better. Floor could never sing songs like Nemo or Ghost Love Score, or Phantom of the Opera.
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
Tarja couldn't even perform 'Nemo' live herself. Also, Floor can actually sing outside her genre. Tarja can barely perform with her chest voice; let alone belt.
Tarja's operatic vocals are also quite subpar. If you want Opera, listen to Maria Callas, Leontyne Price, and Lucia Popp. Tarja's far from being the best.
violentorgasms 2 years ago 4
You know, what struck me when listening to After Forever covering NW was how similar Floor and Tarja sound. Or at least how similar Floor sounds live to the way Tarja sounds on NW ALBUMS lol.
That being said, in the skill department, Floor beats Tarja hands down. I used to be a huge Tarja fan, but come on man, listen to her live a few times; she's awful half the time. Proof:
watch?v=_rO5ndL7bPo
P.S. Floor is QUITE well known. Not only from AF but also for collaborating with Arjen Lucassen.
moneymail002 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tarja sounds amazing live! It's only natural to have a few bad live performances but I prefer Tarja's live voice to Floor's ANY day. I mean, Tarja sounds practically the same live, if not better. I mostly only watch NW performances live.
O.o Who's Arjen Lucassen?
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
=)) it somehow doesn't surprise me you ask who Arjen Lucassen is. Google is your friend. The metal archives are your friend too.
As for Tarja v Floor, I used to be a HUGE Tarja fan; and I'm strongly biased towards her since I like NW a lot more than AF; but after listening to Floor a while I still think she's the better vocalist.
And live, she sounds OK even on her bad days (which Tarja does not), and her stage presence is on a whole different level.
But it IS a question of taste I guess.
moneymail002 2 years ago
I like every live performance from Tarja and think they're all very good! :D I love her!
The only metal I like is Nightwish. :)
It is a question of taste xD That's why it's pointless to argue. People like who they like xD
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
"The only metal I like is Nightwish." -- And the metal you tried and decided you don't like is?
"metal" is a huge genre with dozens of sub-genres that sound nothing alike; from mellow to heavy, from slow to lightning fast, from harmonious to dissonant. Which isn't saying it's the only good genre; just worth a try.
Taste explained
I tried A and B and I like A better - Taste. Can't be argued with. Stay in this area.
I tried A; I'm sure I like it more than I could ever like B - Ignorance.
moneymail002 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't like metal.. except for Nightwish. I've tried a lot of different metal bands... Nightwish is the best IMO.
I've tried After Forever, Epica, Floor, many more. Just don't like them.
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
"It is a question of taste That's why it's pointless to argue."
Then what are you doing here, arguing?
Go post your opinion on a Tarja vid if you love her so much, and leave us (the ones who listen to Floor) alone.
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Someone told me to go look at Floor Jansen and compare her to Tarja.. so I did it on this vid.. That's why I'm here. I was on a Tarja video until I checked my comments and it brought me here..
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
Yes, you're right! :)
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
"I mean, Tarja sounds practically the same live, if not better. I mostly only watch NW performances live."
Haha, are you deaf?
Tarja sounds even more like a man live, she sings much lower. Floor sounds just like on the studio CD, or even better, as someone else said before.
I do prefer the live versions for "Dead Boy's Poem" and "Come Cover Me", but for the other songs the studio versions are much better. At least, she sings them higher in the studio and she's not out of breath.
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Those are just your opinions... Tarja sounds better live to me.
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
"Tarja is a much better singer than Floor."
It's not true, obviously. Floor is the best.
"Floor's voice sounds common to me. Tarja's voice is much more unique, and in my opinion sounds much much better."
Floor can sound like Tarja, but Tarja can't sound like Floor cuz she's not versatile, she sounds like a man and her range is very limited. Floor is truly unique and her vocal color is amazing. She can use every vocal register and sound the way she wants. ---->
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
----> After all, "unique" isn't really a quality.
"But you know, that's why EVERYONE knows about Floor. :) (sarcasm)"
Judging musical beauty and talent by the record sales is probably the biggest mistake ever.
"Floor could never sing songs like Nemo or Ghost Love Score, or Phantom of the Opera."
Bullshit. Those songs are so damn easy that even a regular girls could sing them. Tarja could never sing any After Forever songs, hahaha.
By the way, Floor has already sung "Phantom Of The ---->
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
----> Opera" and her version is the best, of course.
I can see you're a Tarja fan, but don't state YOUR OPINION as a fact.
And skill in singing is NOT an opinion, so Floor is obviously MUCH better than Tarja. One can't even compare, LOL!
If YOU prefer Tarja, ok, but it doesn't change the fact that Floor is the best, one of the most amazing sopranos ever! Her voice is just magical & very powerful too.
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
How good a voice sounds is an opinion.. Tarja's sounds better. Floor doesn't have more skill... Tarja does.
Tarja is the best...
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
I know she has but Floor's version sounding like crap compared to Nightwish's. Not anyone could sing the songs... especially not Floor. Yeah, After Forever sounds so bad.. Tarja can't sink that low.
We have different opinions if you haven't realized that by now. You're not changing mine.
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
Yours is an opinion, based on stereotypes.
What I said is a fact, proved with arguments, for skill in singing/music is NOT an opinion.
You may prefer Tarja or not... but it's only a matter of personal taste.
One has to be very open-minded to see the reality, though.
"Floor doesn't have more skill... Tarja does."
Tarja can only sing low notes, mainly in mixed voice, while Floor can reach very high notes in pure chest voice. If, to you, Tarja has more skills then Floor, then you are lost.
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago
Tarja doesn't sound like a man and I've NEVER heard any song where Floor has sounded like Tarja. Her voice is too rough.
Besides, Tarja doesn't need to sound like Floor. Sounding like herself's gotten her farther than Floor will ever go.
Tarja has a wide range..
TarjaTurunenRocks 2 years ago
Judging by vocal skills, Floor is MUCH better than Tarja and any expert would say the same.
Now, you prefer Tarja and I prefer Floor, but even if I'd prefer Tarja, like you do, I'd have to admit that Floor is MUCH better. :)
FrozenMermaid666 2 years ago 5
We don't care who's the best, we only can willing having 2 so nice singer :D
samueldoubez 2 years ago
I agree :) Stop wasting time judging who's better, we have a couple of fantastic singers and this is great
Spretzel1 2 years ago
holy shit. i can't choose between her and tarja. someone put me out of my misery! lol xD
sexy6vamp 3 years ago
Come on! She sounds (and looks) 100 times better than Tarja!
CarlOlav 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
asshole -.-
Punkgiryl88 3 years ago
Hey! I just stated my opinion! Come on!
CarlOlav 3 years ago
Floor and Tarja are both absoloutely AMAZING in their own ways - Please don't compare them ;) They both ROCK!!!!!!!
tinydragonwings 3 years ago 2
lol, i like the picture with sharon XD
sjokkendedog61 3 years ago
Lindaaaa!!!
Brunoheavybaby 3 years ago
The song is Discord from their latest album "After Forever"; in my opinion their best album and this si my fav song
belisario1985 3 years ago
Which song is this?
themustardrebellion 3 years ago
OMG!Her smile is pretty!!!!!!!!!!!
sinsofchrist 3 years ago
She's foxy.
sinsofchrist 3 years ago
Floor and vibeke are the best in my opinion
mytouniquet 4 years ago 5
Both Floor and her voice are beautiful! beautiful doesnt begin to describe her..phenomenal!!
it would be so nice to meet her in real life!
she's one of metal's BEST singers!
Floor, Henriette, and Vibeke =D
AeonBloom 4 years ago 5
OMG! Did Floor and Sharon sing together? That must've been awesome!
FullmetalxFool 4 years ago 4
yeah they sang together on an albu too, the song is called Beyond Me, it's awesome :D
wishofthenightnicky 4 years ago
Thanks, I'm gonna have to get that album! :)
FullmetalxFool 4 years ago 3
cool wow ! what album ??? after forever album???
Unkyp 4 years ago
I believe it is their first studio album, "Prison of Desire".
orthodontistfrenzy 3 years ago
do u mean the song that's playing? it's called Discord, from their latest album "After Forever" :)
aftloh 3 years ago
She's beautiful!
sinsofchrist 4 years ago
I love floor
mytouniquet 4 years ago 2
I'd TOTALLY hit that.
VladimirSkaletsky 4 years ago