I wonder if this is a less gory version of 復仇者之死(2010), which stars both Juno and Sora Aoi. Anyways I prefer this disturbing MV after watching the trailer for 復仇者之死.
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
不是很明白歌词。为什么这首歌要拍到那么「悬疑」?大同的比较舒服,也很浪漫。这首也好听。加油!
gehmyung 2 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
一首係廣東話一首係英文
兩隻係同音唔同MEANING
咁都可以合埋泥比 唔好咁無聊
鍾意邊隻咪聽邊隻多D囉
唔洗迫其他人一定要覺得你所認為好既VERSION係最BEST
koyi123123 1 month ago
Comment removed
koyi123123 1 month ago
我覺得2個版本都好好聽
sze1416 1 month ago
屌!!!
ericforlan 1 month ago
我覺得超生培欲歌詞既意境更好,Rosy感覺只系普通情歌
不過攞歌手去比較就有D多餘,khalil唱juno既然歌未必會好聽,juno亦然
geminitoni 1 month ago 2
Rosy 就好聽好多,有feel D, 容易觸動人心. 禁室就MV 正, 話唔好聽又未至於, 亦都唔係唱編曲, 因為唱同編曲係配合番背後既故事. 當然喇, 我諗Juno 可以再唱得有 feel D.
aisleyk 1 month ago
2首歌個意思同情況根本唔同 咁仲有咩野好比??
TKROOS1994 1 month ago
死喇!而家自己唱唱下唱左
rosy if you hear me 誰 想漫步 誰想步入殊途
誰Rosy if you see me說話未及擁抱
聽不到控訴 不必懊惱
DaRinTG 1 month ago 14
Comment removed
DaRinTG 1 month ago
唔同歌詞, 唔同風格, 唔同歌手, 各有各好
我唔覺得方大同唱到超生培慾, Juno亦唱唔出Rosy既style
Rezavin 1 month ago in playlist My Songs 19
可能先入為主掛...我覺得我鍾意JUNO呢種FEEL多D....
TheStellarsok 2 months ago
魔鬼蛋糕?!!!
blankNateRiver 2 months ago
JUNO 浪費左首好歌
kyle1986kyle 2 months ago
@kyle1986kyle 何以有此想法呢?
blankNateRiver 2 months ago
@blankNateRiver
你自己聽番方大同唱..差很遠...原本我覺得方大同作得好難聽..原來係演繹方法的問題
kyle1986kyle 2 months ago
@kyle1986kyle 依....咁你似乎都有聽rosy喎~
blankNateRiver 2 months ago
@kyle1986kyle 我反而覺得係編曲ge果個問題....我更喜歡大同ge編曲....然而佢轉有人編....
blankNateRiver 2 months ago
個MV真係好有心 好有意思
taurusja1111 2 months ago
@XQMe299 : 我都想知!
alialison 2 months ago
I prefer Rosy!
chauman10102004 2 months ago
听听方大同版本吧!!!!!
youtube.com/watch?v=6f9zNhJqiY4&list=FL11q2vF0CwwWr94cM_pB0WQ&index=8&feature=plpp_video
kingfayou 2 months ago 3
其實呢首歌係邊個編? Jerald定係ALLAN LAU?
XQMe299 2 months ago
聽完方大同的Rosy,果然......
kwannyava 2 months ago 13
裡面竟然有蒼井空!!!
chihtw2010 2 months ago
曾經,e首係我最鐘意既歌~
waiwai3406 2 months ago
Should be 不會需要玫瑰彼此都不會受傷
MrLittlexx26 3 months ago
太正了...JUNO你係得既
kelvin8246 3 months ago
個媽媽叫咩名><我想知
cc20032 4 months ago
@cc20032 HK Model called Afa(Affa) lee, she is friend of leanne ho (陽光妹) ;)
winyingyeah 4 months ago
@cc20032 in most of commerical/ modelling work, she named as 'Affa Lee', i forgot her chinese name, u could go to search her english name instead;)
winyingyeah 4 months ago
@cc20032 AFA LEE
obeyb127 2 months ago
SORA AOI!
wilson917wong 4 months ago
個MV隱隱透住變態ge氣息……感覺同歌詞其實唔係好配搭,但又別有一番風味。
Lawliet0815 5 months ago 11
GREAT MUSIC, POOR IMAGE。
邊個幫佢造音樂要攞獎,幫佢包裝要打靶(包括佢自己)。
出道時有咁好PRODUCT,駛鬼請老臨FANS咩!
littletak9 5 months ago
khalil 既demo version都好正, 另一種感覺
wcling723 6 months ago 55
我聽完開始明白啲鍾意收藏玩偶嘅人嘅感愛,有時對住死物,重好過對住人。
harrylcy118 6 months ago 9
方大同作的曲 林夕的詞 加上他的聲調 好!
cwlofl 6 months ago 14
youtube.com/watch?v=6f9zNhJqiY4
Demo version played by khalil;)
vwing0409 6 months ago 29
Comment removed
vwing0409 6 months ago
有錢真係做meh do duck
kathyde 6 months ago
很好的曲!謝謝方大同!
3diwant 6 months ago 18
v.youku.com/v_show/id_XMjk4ODc3NDQw.html
sam023302 6 months ago
交代一句
JUNO做得非常好
但我個人覺得做佢細個果個細路都太強了
asdxw680199 6 months ago 5
個mv勁正!支持!!
Orz1205 7 months ago 2
Comment removed
survivor5457 7 months ago
呢一首歌真係聽極都唔會覺得厭 一路係咁播 聽完又聽 成個mv同首歌都係心機之作
HEIDOGLY 7 months ago
林夕想寫的是"不會需要玫瑰彼此都不會「受想」"吧
( 受蘊, 意譯為「覺」,是「感情」和「感覺」的混合。 想蘊, 是「知覺」或「表象」的意思,亦有取象性之意。)
survivor5457 7 months ago
@survivor5457
我認為兩者皆可,不過閣下嘅解釋更為高明!更可能真係夕爺本意,因為佢本身信佛,又鍾意援佛入詞,用受想呢啲佛家用語,真係唔奇。
harrylcy118 7 months ago
@survivor5457 額......解唔通架啦....咩叫不會需要玫瑰彼此都不會受想?
人地既本意係...唔需要玫瑰呢d懶係浪漫的物去製造氣氛(因為對方係死物,唔似人咁有要求,唔會受世界的價值觀影響而覺得有玫瑰先叫浪漫。當然亦係因為佢根本係死物所以唔會要求任何野),而因為死物冇要求所以死物唔會失望,唔會所謂「因愛受傷」,而歌者一心愛住咁樣毫無反應無感受既死物,亦唔會受傷....
係呢個句子入面用「受想」...我唔知你地可以點樣解得通囉....
唔係林夕信佛佢就寫咩都係為由佛理架...我相信林夕係一定程度上係理智既...唔會夾強入d佛謁入d歌詞度
48DegreeCelsius 7 months ago
麥浚龍你係得既﹑
MrHanghang 8 months ago 7
個MV 好好...但係個細路個樣就... Orz
wingwing0404 8 months ago
@wingwing0404
頂,唔好咁高要求啦,最好搵父子個吳景濤做好無?
harrylcy118 8 months ago
@harrylcy118 都好喎
個樣得意咁多.
wingwing0404 5 months ago
124210687 8 months ago 9
好有方大同的風格...
IsaacSnowfield 8 months ago
曲:方大同
ivanchau819 8 months ago 5
以前,我覺得方文山已經超過林夕,睇番呢首詞,先知一樣嘢:寶刀未老!
harrylcy118 9 months ago 8
@harrylcy118
去聽弱水三千,方文山要同林夕比仲差幾皮
geminitoni 8 months ago 6
@geminitoni
方文山寫嘢華麗,但論內涵,重比唔上林夕偉文。
harrylcy118 8 months ago 7
個MV果到佢牙媽隻手成日摸住細JUNO塊面,,所以JUNO最深刻就係呢樣野,,然後先斬人地隻手逼佢地著同一套3同介子,,有一幕JUNO幫佢著完3之後,,跪低用塊面感受佢隻手,,就同佢細個食蛋糕同佢牙媽上吊之後感受佢牙媽隻手果個畫面做個首尾呼應:D 真係拍得幾好
jacky5566556612 9 months ago
@jacky5566556612 係人都知啦
MrKachung 8 months ago
@jacky5566556612 係人都知啦
MrKachung 8 months ago
@jacky5566556612 係人都知啦
MrKachung 8 months ago
歌詞很有意思,今日聽竟令我想起64,想起專制政權~
swissperfection 9 months ago
this is some scary shit
asdfman44 9 months ago
沒有呼吸的你最易抱
最正系呢句
geminitoni 9 months ago
jef
jjohnnyyho1996 9 months ago
實力派被埋沒,偶像派就推紅,依個就係香港
albertlee911 10 months ago
Comment removed
geminitoni 10 months ago
聲線及唱功, juno顯然不是最好~~
腦袋及熱誠, 他絕對是香港樂壇的超班馬~~
babycaca13579 11 months ago 15
唔鍾意佢,但呢首真係一首好歌,寫盡宅男情感
harrylcy118 11 months ago
不知何以, 看著看著, 臉上淌下兩行淚.
Morgana1114 11 months ago 3
佢唱歌真係好聽左好多~
kizkiku 1 year ago
the atmosphere is exceptional
love JUNO's music
hoiningt 1 year ago
佢因為乜野特徵而斬人地隻手出黎?
ILoveChrissie1 1 year ago
@ILoveChrissie1 Juno喺個MV入面明顯係個戀手狂
因為佢呀媽自殺前曾經用隻手摸過佢塊面
所以令佢將對母親既思念寄託左落隻手到
你重新睇番個MV會發現佢所做既野係同佢呀媽自殺前發生既野差唔多
其實係Juno想搵番細個果種感覺
以滿足對母親既思念
而斬手可能只係一種衍生出黎既興趣又或者係滿足對母親思念既其中一個環節
咁講會唔會易明D?
andy123cheng 1 year ago 9
@andy123cheng 明哂,thx
ILoveChrissie1 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
好難聼lo
wongkkable 1 year ago
i dont understand the reason why hes a serial killer
is it because he misses his mom? O____O
123LOLpants 1 year ago
相见恨晚的好歌
idontreadpoems 1 year ago
點解香港既歌手愈係有內涵,就愈被埋沒;愈係得表面,就愈被炒紅
ho0078910 1 year ago 229
@ho0078910 因为有好多香港人都好肤浅。。。。
smellslikebenedick 4 months ago 6
好好地運用了人類的聯想和對未知事物所產生出來恐懼感的佳作
19930914 1 year ago 3
蒼井空 fore sure
check the ending
Sora Aoi
abalonebrush 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
abalonebrush 1 year ago
吉良吉影やん!
Yoshikage Kira by jojo Part4 Diamond is unbreakable ! (JOJO'S BIZARRE ADVENTURE) (LE BIZZARRE AVVENTURE DI GIOGIO)
不滅鑽石 JOJO冒険野郎
ajis9100880Oita 1 year ago
〈超生培慾〉表面上彷彿在談一個人活生生的人戀上死物「她」的故事,但進一步思索的話,便會發現林夕詞中所要暴露的卻是當代都市人精神生活的困境。當〈超生培慾〉愈是用第一身口吻描述愛人「不動不笑」有多好,愈是映襯出有多懼怕面對真實的人和人倫關係。正如詞中疑似宅男的剖白,面對死物「她」不但令他安全感大增,甚至極度享受與死物相處的滿足。在現代都市人的世界裡,虛假的東西(如打遊戲機、抱人形公仔)所帶來的真實滿足絕不遜於真實世界,現實的人與事反倒令人手足無措退避三舍。
〈超生培慾〉最後一段乃是深化全局的關鍵句群 , 乾脆單刀直入剖白寧捨真人,強調與「不會計算變卦」的死物相處反而率性單純。用最簡單的例子來說,就是宅男買來周秀娜的人形攬枕抱抱,遠比費盡心思結織女友談情說愛,來得更省時便捷、更無愁無煩惱。
bedonken 1 year ago 348
@bedonken
轉自網上~
bedonken 1 year ago
@bedonken 同意你既講法, 就好似而家香港寵物業開到成行成市,
人寧願叫一隻狗做仔仔, 老公, 都唔想搵一個真正的仔仔, 老公.
正正因為寵物會對你絕對忠心, 唔需要好似對人咁多猜疑.
令人對動物既感情反而比對人更加親切
其實最終問題都係人與人之間信任既問題.
社會越進步, 人的心反而會退步
mchei 1 year ago 7
@bedonken good job explaining this song, thank you ^_^
derek400004 10 months ago
can anyone tell me the name of the actress?
aa13642956 1 year ago
@aa13642956 looks like sora aoi
94656747 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
個女仔係李蘊黎架:-0
mandy0417 1 year ago
@mandy0417
女仔係afa....廣告女王...好多廣告都係佢拍
ritacy92 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm curious in knowing how does 方大同 feel about his song being made into a story about a serial killer with Oedipus complex...
Coolicy1987 1 year ago
Im curious in knowing how does Khalil feel about his melody being made into a song of a serial killer with Oedipus complex...
Coolicy1987 1 year ago
mtvcmh 1 year ago 6
juno可能系人地心目中吾系最好;)
但系佢系我心目中系第壹的歌手;)
依首歌既mv,,詞,,曲,,歌手我都好中意;)
好有feel;)
kiloveking 1 year ago 3
令我覺得唔好既地方 只有一個=.=
係個細路 食野食到好....核特...
leockc1991 1 year ago 5
I wonder if this is a less gory version of 復仇者之死(2010), which stars both Juno and Sora Aoi. Anyways I prefer this disturbing MV after watching the trailer for 復仇者之死.
missnoctambule 1 year ago
法拉好妖艷!!!!個妝
kl15946 1 year ago
@kl15946 法拉係邊度= =?
ryan2929 1 year ago
@kl15946 個嗰喺蒼井空嚟。
telthedog 1 year ago 10
@kl15946 嗰個係李思汝唔係陳法拉
cookingfa 1 year ago
都唔明點解有人會話呢個同jj ge殺手mv 相似
極其量只可以話兩個mv畫面相似, 例如個女仔坐ge chair, 支針筒, 牛奶, 幫個女仔換衫
但係成個故仔ge concept跟本就差天共地
究竟有冇認真睇 ?
helloben2808 1 year ago 8
what kind of mv is this...w/ a calm melody but a freaky video!!!!!!!!
lueisadude 1 year ago
Comment removed
nofeetseagull 1 year ago
wow, a fucking serial killer. Children will get scar for life after watching this shit...
darkaznlordx 1 year ago
呢D先係歌黎架嗎 依加手手歌都講情情愛愛 JUNO快D出多D呢類既歌丫 支持你
a71595939 1 year ago
比人綁個個..= =我眼花?? 蒼井空??
pkppkpkpkpk 1 year ago 3
@pkppkpkpkpk 你無眼花
edwardxdon 1 year ago
@pkppkpkpkpk 下...之前新聞都有講話請左啦...
banzaofking 1 year ago
he mustve paid alot to get sora aoi to take part in this mv
dimseeeen 1 year ago
Awfully chocolate 個蛋糕真係好好食架hahaa
rachelmeizi 1 year ago 6
@rachelmeizi 個chocolate cake 咁plain就係awfully chocolate 既style :p
babyroxy666 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
係因為有蒼井空先聽e首歌 XD
friensddogdog 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
我完全覺得係抄JJ[林俊傑]首殺手囉= =
l0VeChl0E 1 year ago
@l0VeChl0E 其實兩個由mv拍攝手法和色彩,至歌詞內容和背後動機都很有差異。說似可能有點,但我覺得說不上是抄吧
dawn010 1 year ago
@l0VeChl0E 邊忽似呢 林俊傑 JJ 殺手冇咁恐怖囉唔該
a71595939 1 year ago
@l0VeChl0E 洗撚抄佢咩!
hang299 1 year ago
@l0VeChl0E 你都on99 兩個主角背景都唔同啦 完咩全?
ryan2929 1 year ago
我覺得有D似 林俊傑-殺手 個mv ge
pipipika1126 1 year ago
有冇人知個老母係邊個黎?
lerayo 1 year ago
第一次睇呢個MV睇唔到, 今次睇, 原來先知個媽媽係走左去吊頸自殺...
billyma2009 1 year ago 2
@billyma2009 我都係- -
lerayo 1 year ago
其實我唔係幾明
點解佢慶祝生日
會攪到喊曬咁....
23492727 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Is it really 蒼井空 ? because she look awefully like her
AQUARIUMHOBBY 1 year ago
lol mv is creeeepy
Maxcloudy 1 year ago
好不安呀頂
jilljillmak 1 year ago 4
最初以為好好,原來這個idea也是抄別人的........
pig616 1 year ago
@pig616
抄邊個?
jilljillmak 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
睇完mv 覺得首歌好聽左^^ 蒼井空好靚 JUNO好幸福
短髮女又係邊個 唔識wo
tsang3503 1 year ago 2
香港樂壇有這樣的mv才值得驕傲
aesopp42299 1 year ago 6
好有 B 片風格﹐ 好正
axcrobat 1 year ago
歌正,mv正~~
tubejusthk 1 year ago
果位短髮女士叫咩名
mrptf711 1 year ago
蒼井空
wukaifu 1 year ago 4
真係百聽不厭
支持JUNO
wsadzxcwsadzxc 1 year ago
係咪好掛住阿老母呢?
manman19fwd 1 year ago
曲:方大同
詞:林夕
y2keith2005 1 year ago 5
BanagherLinks 1 year ago 16
BanagherLinks 1 year ago 4
首歌真係正到不行,
但自從睇左一篇評篇之後,
一聽就諗住宅男同吹氣公仔XX-(
devilfire1975 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
他媽媽的 很有趣的故事
absolutechicken 1 year ago
他媽媽的 很有趣的故事
absolutechicken 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
他媽媽的 很有趣的故事
absolutechicken 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
他媽媽的 很有趣的故事
absolutechicken 1 year ago
他媽媽的 很有趣的故事
absolutechicken 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
他媽媽的很有趣的故事
absolutechicken 1 year ago
他媽的很有趣的故事
absolutechicken 1 year ago
砍女人d手用黎做咩-,-
mrptf711 1 year ago
十卜 蒼井
zq2731879 1 year ago
堅覺得似JJ首殺手個MV
mr2shueking 1 year ago
@mr2shueking 一D都唔似
雖然都係殺女人
但個故事一D都唔同
拍出嚟完全唔一樣:)
hihi1718 1 year ago
蒼井!!!!
chickeyton1 1 year ago
有d變態-_______-;
MrKinjai 1 year ago
支持蒼井空
rt2156 1 year ago
尋找媽媽的故事
cccsskit 1 year ago 2
曲很有大同的味道
kiteria0817 1 year ago
@kiteria0817
佢作= =
stupidvolarasz 1 year ago
It is very creepy.
et1428 1 year ago 2
MV講戀手
但係我覺得首歌似講戀物 --- figure-.-
rhodeslun 1 year ago 4
城市喜歡快。
最好不懂反應、不懂反抗,做甚麼也不會受傷。對人對事自我中心最緊要。
在方大同甜蜜的旋律中道出的「箭豬」理論--箭豬愈想將自己的溫暖傳給別人,愈會傷害別人--最好就沒有溫暖、沒有交流,就這樣做人。感覺好像Evangelion的道理,用在一首"Komm Susser Tod"興奮、愉快地道出自己做人的失敗然後導致甜蜜的死亡。
dicksonflying 1 year ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
symlam 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
symlam 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
symlam 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is a good MV. The idea is beautiful. Both actress are lovely.
The short hair one has model feel and she did a good job on sad expression with tear dropping.
蒼井空 is more than a traditional MV actress. She did excellent facial expression when Juno did injection (see her eyes and forehead reaction!) and unbuttoning (her eyes tell the story). I think she attended drama training class before.
symlam 1 year ago
好鐘意首歌!
唔知點解睇完個 mv 好想喊!T_T
chufun 1 year ago
個mv好似林俊傑首"殺手"個mv x_x 都係咁恐怖t3t
cherrycherry0218 1 year ago