Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (324)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Is

  • I think what ruins this song is basically there is too much going with mariah and jb..i cant really enjoy each one of their voices and was unable too enjoy the harmony...kinda killing the christmas spirit..i think...its just my opinion

  • Mariah Carey was the one that actually suggested this song. So really i don't see why everyones hating on bieber.

    I enjoy listening to any christmas song because it's my favourite holiday. But yeah sorry but I do like the original alot better.I can hear the autotune alot in this track. But still it's a Christmas song, so who really cares x)

  • My fav singer - Justin + my fav Christmas song - all I want for Christmas = AMAZING!!! -3

  • This is so adorable!

  • That's sooo goood! wow xoxoxox

  • Soooooo awesome!!!!!!!!

  • @BeliebeInBeiber6 Actually Justin requested Mariah, and tracked her down.

  • Ugh. Justin ruined it.

  • I love this!<3<3<3<3<3

  • Guys relax! all the proceeds will go to charity. (Mariah has said) so its for a great cause.

  • Oh yeh and isn't christmas all bout the love ;)?

  • Just because we don't like it doesn't mean we are hating. We just prefer the original.

  • @KJAllen75 I assume that was at me, lol? Or not. But so do I prefer it. I was refering to other comments, btw.

  • This is quite a cute version... no need for hate. It's not that bad IMO. She's done a remix of it before too, and this is one of those songs that everyone loves anyway so big deal. If this was the first time you heard this song you'd probably think it's great. I love the whistles at the end. :)

  • Not feeling the collaboration. Mariah how could you let this happen? Love you still.

  • Comment removed

  • I don't want Justin Bieber just for Christmas, but for my whole life! <3

  • He... ruins the song... OMG!!!!

  • Miriah she is amazing but dissing on the biebs? Gawd please do something in life.. read a book, make some fucking lemonade. -'-

  • Really LOVE IT!! :DDD

  • JB sucks

    He can't sing!!!

    Mariah Carey sings this song way better alone than with JB

    JB is f*cking gay!!!!!!!!!

  • @superspydey1998 if you dont like it dont listen to it and stop being such a f*cking twat

  • shut the fuck up

    go fuck yourself

    i can post whatever i want

    JB sucks and is gay

  • @superspydey1998 Then why do you watch his videos?

  • @JustinBieberLounge

    Why wouldn't i

    then i can jell at you fags

  • dude worste move she could do, he sounds Horibble!!!! Mariah is the only good thing about this version of the song, this is her song people need to stop try to get a peice of the greatness the queen mariah has created

  • He just sounds like an auto-tune machine. Disappointing is an understatement.

  • Obviously Justin's gonna get alot of hate when dueting with a ledgend like Mariah, especially on this song. Just get over it, SHE'S the one who suggested to Justin they do this song on his christmas album anyway.

    And.. I don't know where yer hearing auto tune ?

  • I LIKE THIS VERSION MORE <3

  • I love it I love it, its up beat and cheery :) nicely done JB and Mariah (",)

  • i love this song! Belieber what is your favorite song off Justins Christmas album?? :-)

  • loooove this song, do you Beliebers have an favorite song off Justins Christmas album? :-)

  • @multiJbieberlove I know Falala isnt out yet but I watched his webisode and it sounds nice, so I think that will be my fav :) urs?

  • why does everybody think hes being autotuned...it doesnt even sound like it. LEAVE JUSTIN ALONE. it sounds fine...

  • @xStarlyn101x i know!! it isnt autotune!!

  • @TheJPE06 its like ppl try soooo hard to make justin look bad. they try to find SOMETHING they can criticize him about but its all unnecessary

  • leave justin alone, I'd like too see all you haters singing a duet with Mariah Carey. yeah thats what I thought :)

  • @DNA2919 exactly :)

  • mariah shines as usual

  • love this song ♥

  • Comment removed

  • OK ITS MARIAH CAREY FT. JUSTIN BIEBER AND HE FUCKED IT UP =/ IT WOULD OF BEEN BETTER IF ONLY DID THE SONG AND NOT HAVE MARIAH ON IT AND HE SOUNDS LIKE A ROBOT

  • Comment removed

  • <3

  • looooooove it :))

  • you're so updated... where did you get this ?

  • this version IS NOT AMAZING AT ALL, except the whistles of MC at the end, GREAT

  • I think it's safe to say that the song has divided listeners into three groups. First group is made of the lambs - they hate JBs singing. The second group are the beliebers - who haven't heard JB's voice on such a good tune since Baby. Naturally, they are excited out of their minds while the lambs lament to no end. The third group is of Lambs/Beliebers who like/hate the song. I belong to this. I am a lamb and I love it.(hate her small voice in this new version though)

  • JUSTIN BIEBER MAKES THIS SONG 10 TIMES BETTER I WILL LISTEN TO THIS SONG FOR DECADES AND DECADES TO COME THANK YOU JB!!!

  • @Robber323 crazy

  • Oh my God! No...!!!!! Such an EPIC failure! I mean.. what the hell? .i used to like this song. Now that fu*ker, destroy my child memories, YOU FUCK! -.-"

  • @zoofun13 no need to be so dramatic, even if you don't like it :L

  • @MarieAGx Yes i do need! ..well, maybe not so much (;p), but it's still true :S

  • i find that this song that there's a lot going on. @_@

  • I love Mariah Carey, but this is such an epic failure!

    I didn't even understand why MC decided to pair up with JB in the first place. He's so not her match. 

  • All I want for Chrismas is Justin Bieber , Please Santa make my wish come true

  • Luv this version , mater or a fact every singel one of JB <3

  • this is cool! but i like more btr's version of this song :3

  • mariah, the best singer of all time, feat the best singer with A LOT of autotunes...

  • I love Mariah's extra whistles at the end!

  • Comment removed

  • they are in the process of making a music video for this song...that should be cool... it'll help showcase whose singing what parts cause at times its hard to tell.

  • But its fun times and i like it!

  • It's pretty cool to hear Mariah resing this Christmas standard 16 years later and she totally kills Justin on this remake... then again, why wouldnt she. He sounds like a background singer gone wrong...lol.

  • @collegestudent81

    You're right

  • @collegestudent81 He sounds like a fucking pro singer they have Mariah's old version and its bullcrap.Mariah should record it again...

  • Mariah sounds so amazing! I love how her and Justin scat in the beginning. She always does it up on jazz style records. Plus "All I Want" will forever be a classic Christmas standard. #SeasonsGreetings

  • justin made the song horrible, sorry, but mariah once again shined ..

  • AUTOTUNE!!!! it hurts my ears!

  • to much autotune

    

  • this has graced my family for years, ever since my first christmas, i have videos of me dancing to this song.. Sorry justin but if my little sister thinks this version will play while we get ready on christmas, your wrong, love your music even though im into screamo, but no mariah n u dont sound good 2gether

  • & there vocals don't mix well.. I'm a fan of both of them. but a bigger fan of Mariah. so I'm not "hating" on Bieber (:

  • Shouldn't it be Mariah Carey Ft. Justin Bieber since this IS Mariah Carey's song.. Jussaying.

  • atrocious!!! 

  • I don't mind Justin but this is only something Mariah can touch..it's just not suited for him stick to "Mistletoe" bro.

  • OMG THIS IS PROBABLY THE BEST CHRISTMAS SONG I HAVE EVER HEARD!!!!!!!!

  • @Robber323 i think u meant OMB

  • Justin you have been on my wishlist the past 4 years. <3

  • the two of them mde this song AMAAAZING! :))

  • amazeing!

  • MARIAH SAVED THE SONG....i mean it is HER song

  • christmas in october?? i think so! now i cant wait til christmas! i love jb and i love christmas, my two favorite things combined?? AMAZING! :)

  • Obessed with this song!! Mariah Carey is the queen of Christmas! And All I Want For Christmas Is You is the best christmas song ever recorded! #teamMC

  • On Christmas, this song is going to be playing everywhere! 97.1, tv elevator music.....lol

  • Now this is the perfect christmas song to dance to in a slow dance!

  • This is my new favorite Christmas song!!

  • I am not trying to hate on Justin but this is awful! Nothing says one is out of their league when singing like using auto tune to cover up not being able to sing the notes required. I do not think they even recorded together because when he comes in, the song fades out a bit. Whomever did the mixing for Justin did a terrible job. I know she wanted the song in the original key but he should have recorded something new that would blow her away to make her change her mind. Sorry, this fails! :(

  • How DO you avoid copyright?? cuz every time i post a video it says it matches 3rd pary content): HELP PLEASE

  • Yay MC!

  • i love this song, i heard it was difficult for him to do because he had to do it in the original key

  • Mariah Carey version is better.

  • @PatrykVEVO

    obviously lol

  • aww my babyee!!

  • follow @imjustonbieber on twitter if u r a true belieber and proud of justin makin it this far

  • OMG my school choir is singing this song and I'm in it..... now every time I'm gonna remember this :( I really don't like Justin Bieber

  • f*** you beibarianshow can you like this trash trash? jusin you ruined this song

  • @Artistifiy

    First of all we're not Beiebarians. We're Beliebers.

    And second, his name is Justin. Not Jusin

    Third of all, if you dont like him, why are you watching this.

    Fourth of all, your comment makes no sense.

    Fifth of all: YOU JUST GOT OWNED BY A 13 YEAR OLD GIRL.

    I love you Justin<3 :)

  • @MrsBieber012

    5) What is WITH your username? your not married to him and you never will be. He probably doesn't even know you exist. I don't care if you have an "I'm Justin's favorite girl favorite girl" sticker anywhere, that makes NO difference because it is just a cheap, meaningless sticker

    6)How can you like Justin Beiber? All he even ever sings about is girls. It just shown how chauvinistic he is.

  • @MrsBieber012

    7) I powned you. So you were wrong. You can't own me. You thought is was easy to own me, but it isnt, even if i replied in three comments, IN YOUR FACE. I think you should go drink you milk out of a baby bottle like your inaginary husband, and head on to bed in your crib

  • @Artistifiy

    1) I call call you guys whatever i WANT to call you, and i CHOOSE to call beibarians because in MY opinion, i think its MORE SUITABLE. plus, not calling you guy what everyone else is and coming up with something else is MORE original

    2) Secondly, NOBODY likes a spelling Nazi, especially since this is the internet, and not school

    3)My comment DOES make sense, and little Justin DID IN FACT ruin the song

    4)Justin is a little boy and i cant wait till he hits peuberty and looses talent

  • @Artistifiy she really did own you. she's even ignoring your your comments. Lol I suggest you stop before you make a fool of your self on the Internet, have fun!

  • this is horrendous .. their voices are so incompatible.... messing with a classic!

  • They did and awesome job on this song together. Never thought they would do a song together, glad they did tho!! Love them both!! :)

  • This is my favorite xmas song ever and I LOVE MC and I like JB but this is just not my favorite. I like the original best *obviously*, MCR version second and this takes 3rd.

  • I don't particularly like or dislike Justin Bieber, but I do think that he is a talented singer with an enviable voice. But then why autotune it? It makes this song absolutely crappy. He should've just left it alone. Mariah's version is and always will be the classic and the favourite.

  • Wow. Its really sad to see that you Beliebers think that this song is really good. Honestly it sucks. He ruined Mariah's classic and everyone else thinks so too. I do like Justin by himself but he messed up Mariah's song totally. His voice doesn't mix with Mariah's AT ALL. This is a disgrace. People need to stop covering this song and doing a horrible, bleak job of it. Smh.

  • @Tammie082 i get tht the voices dnt mix...

    but its still not THAT bad...

    its iight.....

    except at the end when they are tryin to harmonize...

  • @Tammie082 *beibarians

  • @Tammie082 this song and remix was already done by Mariah herself, she just offered for Justin to sing some of the verses because she found of he was going to do a cover of it. She had already had the remix done herself, so if anyone ruined the classic it was herself...it's not ruined its just different, more up to date.

  • @Jemma10xx Ha and who told you that shit? Obviously you don't know ANYTHING about Mariah's artistry and it shows. Why the CRAP would she make ANOTHER version of this song if she already DID an Extra Festive Version of Merry Christmas II You last year!? My point proven. FAIL.

  • @Tammie082 I'm pretty sure that's what I just said? She made a remix of it...and then offered for Justin to sing on it with her because she found out he was doing a cover of it? They both sound the same except this has Justin Biebers voice on it...

  • @Jemma10xx Check this out. Okay. If anything, Mariah NEVER ruins her songs. This one SINGLE AMAZING song tops the Christmas charts EVERY YEAR and HAS SINCE 1994. So don't go telling ME how Mariah screwed and ruined her own song. Justin needs to step it up. Obviously he couldn't for Mariah and vocally it shows.

  • PROUD OF YOU JUSTIN! I LOVE it. Justin, all I want for Christmas is you! ♥

  • ughghg this song blows, im not saying this cause im a jb hater, im saying it because this song just sucks

  • god it's obviously autotune in bieber's part !

  • It was good until bieber opened up his mouth and started "singing"

  • baby all i want for christmas is justin<3 !!

  • Justin should have done a duet with selena for this song haha!!(:

  • -pretending justin is singing this to me. xD

  • like like like LOVE <3

  • He sounds terrible lol at least one thing will come out of this ridiculous collab is mariah will rake in more money for this single due to his fans

  • marih should have sung this with michael bublé, snm.

  • AWSOME! #NoWords

  • Comment removed

  • Dis is crap , only good fing is Mariah carey xx

  • love ittt

  • justin, all i want for christmas is YOU!

  • @LilMissSunshine747 i think you should wish for something more realistic

  • @LilMissSunshine747 Well, you can keep on wishin all you want, but you sho aint gonna get him...

  • all i can say is; LUCKY SELENA. 'nuff said. 

  • This is ah-maz-ing...OMB! <3 Good job with lyrics :)

  • AMAZING hatez just no .. this is amazing .. love yaa bieber xxxxxxxx<3

  • You are A-W-E-S-O-M-E SO CUTE !

  • So Hot! I love you Justin #Belieber4ever 

  • Wowso Hot!

  • BILEBER FOREVER <3 <3 <3

  • *BELIBER@kklewis15

  • its clever for mariah to attach herself to one of the most relevant artists out there...she was starting to be forgotten

  • I <3 JUSTIN BIEBER

    Christmas songs in October hahaha

  • Listening To Christmas Songs In October? Justin Made Us Do this... BELIEBERFOREVER.

  • WHY ID YOU HAVE TO LEAK IT FOR!

  • bigest shit in the hole wide world

  • AWSOME SONG ! fuck u haters

  • Lol the lambs and the beliebers are the tow most epic fan groups ever!

  • Are you fucking kidding me?

  • WOW AWESOME LOVE U JUSTINNNNNNN<3BELIEBER FOREVER

  • You wouldn't youtube this if you didn't want to hear it, so its honestly your own fault. Clearly, you wanted to see if Justin's voice had changed to your liking, so you could join our epic family of beliebers. ;D

  • This is such a feel good christmassy song, I can't wait to play it while I open my presents :)

  • Bieber is poor

  • muito bom so falta ao vivo

  • muito bom ficou a versao.sø

  • love it, mariah is a true singer, beginning is lovely

  • I just gotta say...

    FUCK YOU HATERS!!!!!

    BELIEBERS&JUSTIN ARE THE BESTT FAMILYYYYYY!!!!!!♥♥♥

    Beliebers&Justin are forever as one!!!!♥♥♥

  • The song is just too much for Justin Bieber...

    The Legendary Mariah Carey sounds Great as always!

    Justin sounds like a back-up singer on this duet, Peace Yo!

  • Kiss My Beliebers Ass ♥ This song ROCKS <3 :'D

  • even if the original is THE song for Christmas,this one is good too...

    but the original is hymn!

  • omg yes all i want for christmas is u xxxxxxxx

  • Whatever you people think, I love the song with Justin in it =)

  • this is my second comment on this video, im furious, this is wrong from the begging till the end, i will kill myself this Christmas if they play this song like a mad whore on the radio..................

  • i love it! proudbelieber

  • Just because their voices are on different levels , doesn't make the song any different. The song was amazing overall .

  • hate this version...this is a bad idea...bieber go to hell

  • Christmas this year is coming soon ;) ♥

  • I actually LOVE their voices together <3

  • love love love want the album !!!!!<3<3<3

  • the worst duet mariah ever did...... it should be done with beyonce or neyo....... bieber doesnt give justice for this song

  • I want the album so bad

  • Justin's voice matured, and in some note it doesn't blend with Mariah's. She also used the same pitch with that of the Merry Christmas II You that's why Justin's seems to be overpowered . . . may be next time, I suggest, they should make it more of a ballad to be something new.. new for Bieber's music and new vocal acrobatics for Mariah, the songbird supreme.

  • SORRY JUSTIN BIEBER... WELL THIS WILL BE MARIAH'S SONG FOREVER AND EVER. and it should be MARIAH CAREY FT JUSTIN BIEBER! HHAHA!

  • wauw their awesome!!!!