I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
I just wish people would appreciate music for what it is, this isnt better or worse than NINs , its just Petes version, its artistic, its dark, its just another take on the song. Just enjoy it, it is amazing!
...I don't want to offend NIN in any way as they have written such a wonderful song, but I always had a feeling that no one sang it better than Johnny Cash. Now that heart-wrenching but sweet experience is doubled, as Peter Murphy's version is also quite amazing. My favourite singer of all times and one of my favourite songs of all times...hmmmm, what could be better than that?
As a huge NIN fan, I feel that there are WAY too many awful covers of NIN songs by people very unqualified to sing them. I mean, Linkin Park, Sevendust? Really? That said, there are some good ones. As someone else commented, Bowie did his Bowie thing with it. Cash took a song about a fictional character and applied it to his life. However, this version is my favorite cover. Murphy is an unbelievably talented artist that brings an already dark song and takes it to new, even lower depths.
I think he sounds alot like David Bowie, doesn't he? and don't take me for a fool, know much about both of them :P just some smiliarity in their voices.
@zejnulla They do have some of the same barritone vibrato voice going on. IMO Peter Murphy has more range. He sounds great with the growling dark barritone and also the more high pitched soprano singing he does every now and again. Quite impressive the range he's got. Very talented vocalist.
I have to disagree here. Murphy bring a certain darkness that maybe some people can't handle. NIN make this song in your face, Cash brings a broken, end of life vibe to the song and Bowie just does a Bowie thing to it, but this is really deep and tragically dark.
He should not have tried this....horrible version of a beautiful song....I love Bauhaus & Dali's Car - but Peter Murphy should have quit while he was still good..sad.
I loved Pete Murphy's work from the very early days but this doesn't work for me, just sounds like Pete is over doing it. I do however like the original and Johnny Cash versions.
no matter who sings it? really?? Many, many artists wrote songs they knew they could not bring feeling or meaning to, and would seek out the artist that they knew would be perfect for it , or vise versa.
@wooby33 excuse me, let me rephrase, this is a beautiful song, with much feeling, no matter who sings it. it is my opinion that peter murphy is very talented but this is definitely not my favorite of his vocal performances or covers of trent reznors music.
I started laughing really hard. it almost sounded like he was making fun of Trent Reznor. Cash and Reznor are the best for this song. i wish that he changed the song a little more like other bands do to cover.
HaaaaHaaaa....ouch my side hurts...this song is already LAME!...ekkk Peter....sounds constipated singing this. yeah crown of SHITE! BUT yet the images are quite nice....
Johny cash's version is top simply for being the original version and the person to write and compose this song. it is an amazing song with a strong message to it, all the covers are just as powerful and meaningful as the original.... yes i know i contradicted myself, but point being is this song is simply amazing no matter who has coverd it.
@Sublevare1 ....Trent Reznor wrote this song and Johnny Cash did a brilliant very apt version ...as Johhny realised later on in life what really matters!
I believe you can tune into any youtube channel out there and there are always haters to be found.
It never ceases to amaze me how many people have so much time on their hands to waste that they can get on youtube and basically bitch and bitch and bitch and bitch some more about people liking or loving something they either hate or don't understand. People who do nothing but tear others down around them must be the saddest fucking people on the planet.
@eliotalanis I have a soft spot for Peter Murphy, but I have to agree, Johnny Cash really did something amazing with his cover too. I love them both equally yet differently.
While I am partial to Cash's cover and of course the NIN original, I think Peter Murphy did an amazing job putting himself into the song. Simply amazing
k, i love bauhaus, and thought they were the shit, but if i ever hear peter murphy do this to a nine inch nails song again, i'll probly slit my wrists
lmao!!! "i, hurt myayayay self today!!" LMAO!!! i love it but man sounds like kermit, i've got the one he did for that one session they had but i dont member this
I have really mixed emotions about Murphy's cover of this....I have loved Murphy for years and years, but I prefer Bowie and Reznor singing this. I can sense quite a bit of emotion in Murphy's voice, which is great, but this is definitely not my favorite of PM's vocal performances.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Murphy tries too hard to emulate David Bowie..his looks, the way he dresses..his singing style. btw in my opinion Reznor does the best job and he is the original writer. Peter Murphy didn't sing this til way after the fact so get your facts strait. the second best performance and music video of this song is by the one and only Johnny Cash who really understood the meaning of the words of the song as it really did describe the trials of his life. in and out of prison, dealing with drug addiction
Do your research a little bit. :) If you've ever heard him speak about peoples' comparisons between him and Bowie, you'd know he's simply being himself.
"Among a multitude of strengths his singular flaw is that he fits another man's shoes poorly. " This was your point proven wrong. Your comment wasn't directed at this song, but at Mr. Murphy. Once again. Point Proven.
Among your deleted comments you accuse me of being 17 (you're 21, Jeremy, there's not a big difference), of being a pseudo-intellectual, and being a NIN lover. At no point can you nor did you attempt to "prove" anything.
The only thing you said that made any sense is that it is my opinion. Has it really taken you so long to figure that out?
Whats funny about shadowgeek101 is that a lot of people consider Trent Reznors voice to be special. That is why he sales records idiot! It is a very bold statement to say that someone has a bland voice. do you sing? Peter Murphy has a unique voice, but Trent Reznor sings HIS song way better than Murphy any day man....I dont know how people like you feel the need to negatively criticize artists and think that people want to hear it, or are even somewhat interested. Ha, get a life dude...
some of you guys are either incredibly stoned or incredibly stupid.
Peter Murphy has a SUBLIME voice even for his old age. I dare any of you to try singing in your 40's/50's, cunts.
And I've heard the Reznor version... it's meh. The man has a run-of-the-mill silky smooth yet masculine voice. Peter's invigorating vocals, from the past or in the present, can outmatch Reznor any day of the week.
I'll betcha this... when Reznor's in his old age, his voice wont be as in tact as Peter's.
I agree that Murphy's voice is still incredibly good (I'd even go so far as to say it's better than it was in his youth), however, calling the original version bland is just silly. It was good enough to be covered by three legends in completely different genres.
Oh ,Eva ME ENCANTA LO QUE HACES!.Es en verdad hermoso como unes imagenes en movimiento y fotos ,para luego darles ese toque elegante del blanco y negro.Hay tantas canciones de Bauhaus que carecen de videoclip y otras de Peter que si lo tienen pero son desilucionantes.SIGUE SALVANDO ESAS CANCIONES CON TU TRABAJO,ERES UNA ARTISTA DEL VIDEO!!.Me inclino en reverencia ante ti pues 'Hurt' y 'King volcano' me conmovieron.
Personally Ive never liked peter murphys vocal style. Can any of you tell me why you enjoy peter murphys voice?
I know you are going to hate on this comment for me saying this, but I currently have the video on mute, because I love the Reznor and Cash versions so much, I dont want them tainted.
Man, I AGREE with you SISTER!!! You and me have a SIMILAR MENTALITY about a lot of things concerning Peter Murphy!!!... A "vampire" should STOP ageing at fucking "30"!!!! Lol!!!
LOL these comments are %$@# WACK! HAHAHA Leave it to Peter Murphy to bring out the tainted and sometimes best of us!!! WE LOVE YOU PETER!! SOME MORE THEN OTHERS!! LOL
Peter Murphy IS EXTREMELY FUCKING TALENTED and HIS VOICE IS PHENOMENAL and IT DOESN"T MATTER THAT HE'S 51 and GAINED A LOTTA WEIGHT, blah, blah, blah. AND EVEN AT 80 HIS VOICE WILL STILL BE INCREDIBLE, OK??? Now myself I"M INFATUATED WITH THE 24 YEAR OLD PETER MURPHY and I FUCKING THINK HE WAS A FUCKING VISION back then, and HE GIVES ME A MIND-BLOWING RUSH!!!! I"M 100% FUCKING HONEST, IF PETER HADN"T LOOKED THAT GORGEOUS BACK THEN I WOULDN"T HAD TURNED INTO A PETER MURPHY FREAK AT ALL, ALRIGHT??
not that it matters but Pete hasn't gained weight when was the last time you saw him?.....he was his usual boney assed self last I saw him....it's the guy from the Cure who got tubby, Robert Smith........
I've never seen Peter in concert ( unfortunely!!! ) , but ever since joining "You Tube" I've been exposed to some of his MOST recent concert clips from like just last year , and he's become a fucking PORKER!!!! He hasn't actually really been "bony" in my opinion when he was "younger", he was just "slender" ( at about 155lbs.) and supposedly 6ft., so he was "proportioned" right!!! And his "succulent" bubble ass was anything but BONY!!! He used to have the right "lean" "athletic" physique...
really?! Well I gotta go see that as I can't imagine him fat! I've met them all and seen them in concert as Bauhaus, Pete on his solo tours and Love And Rockets and he's no 6 footer, 5'9 maybe 5'10 but Kevin is tall though!
no my commenting about meeting them seems fine to me but you didn't say not to post comments to the others making remarks about his cum and having his kids...hmmm, sex crap is fine but not comments on meeting them, weight or height?...odd!
@dfarmbrough Great spot! Murphy has had a penchant for humming (quite hilariously) at least as far back as the Daiis Car record. Murphy's voice has become increasingly silly with the years. It started out as an occasional humourous device but has now almost completely taken over, to the extent that I find it difficult to even listen to him now! I remember thinking years ago how much the singer from Crash Test Dummied sounded like Peter Murphy!
@MisAnnThorpe Yes. He obviously has some talent and some charm, but it's probably mis-directed. He is one of those artists who has a load of sycophantic fans who can't see any wrong in what he does, and so ends up becoming more and more pretentious as the years go by. He probably considers himself an 'artist' rather than a singer.
I like all 3 version for different reasons. Trent's cuz it's his song and his lyrics. Cash's because it's timeless and poignant. Murphy's because he might have the strongest vocal performance of the three, and unless like Cash, who was introduced to Rez and his song by Ric Rubin for commercial reasons, Peter is actually a friend of Trent's.
So don't bash any of them. They all rule in their own way. It's like a good Dylan song - many people can cover it and there can exist many great versions.
in the moment you said... "similar voice"... isn't that comparing?... and, dont worry, the stuff of "who is beter than who"... inst about of your opinion... its about the orher one... "Not bad...but nothing will ever beat Trent Reznor. Not even Cash"
sehr gute version hab ich aber von peter und NIN erwartet
Gänsehaut pur^^
Hermundure89 1 day ago
I didn't like this cover when I first heard it(And I love Murphy!)
But im really liking it now...Hrm
Skeletonwitharaygun 1 week ago
SO UNDERATED!!!????
SuperPaulieh 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
DeliveryManBoy 4 months ago
Bauhaus is one of my favorite bands.
Peter Murphy is a god.
But this cover....Uh.no.
I like it more that NIN's version.
But I think Johnny Cash still does this song best.
Skeletonwitharaygun 4 months ago
this has nothin with joy division to do !!!
thx for uploading !
so dark , so emational , so murphy ...
trent69marc 5 months ago
I just wish people would appreciate music for what it is, this isnt better or worse than NINs , its just Petes version, its artistic, its dark, its just another take on the song. Just enjoy it, it is amazing!
wvumab 6 months ago 7
beautiful pter murphy
silverwolf2061 6 months ago
Peter Murphy brings this song to a hole new dimension
jimjimtrains 7 months ago 3
Wow what a great cover.
DerrEinzige 8 months ago
...I don't want to offend NIN in any way as they have written such a wonderful song, but I always had a feeling that no one sang it better than Johnny Cash. Now that heart-wrenching but sweet experience is doubled, as Peter Murphy's version is also quite amazing. My favourite singer of all times and one of my favourite songs of all times...hmmmm, what could be better than that?
ArtCrimeLog 8 months ago
Beautiful cover...
itwasonlytwoyearsago 8 months ago 2
As a huge NIN fan, I feel that there are WAY too many awful covers of NIN songs by people very unqualified to sing them. I mean, Linkin Park, Sevendust? Really? That said, there are some good ones. As someone else commented, Bowie did his Bowie thing with it. Cash took a song about a fictional character and applied it to his life. However, this version is my favorite cover. Murphy is an unbelievably talented artist that brings an already dark song and takes it to new, even lower depths.
atalders 9 months ago 3
I LOVE his voice.... he is so talented. really a magnifisant singer.
MemoryOfTheRose 9 months ago
Amazing. Thanks for posting. Oh to have seen Bauhaus in the early 80s
clayguy33 10 months ago
this is amazing i was at a concert where he sung it live and it was amazing :)
jimjimtrains 10 months ago
Comment removed
mimiskatr 11 months ago
wow..this is beautiful!!!!
41275jason 11 months ago
I think he sounds alot like David Bowie, doesn't he? and don't take me for a fool, know much about both of them :P just some smiliarity in their voices.
zejnulla 11 months ago
@zejnulla They do have some of the same barritone vibrato voice going on. IMO Peter Murphy has more range. He sounds great with the growling dark barritone and also the more high pitched soprano singing he does every now and again. Quite impressive the range he's got. Very talented vocalist.
ronnysoeberg 9 months ago
sing on Peter, sing on...beautiful...
jannadeane 11 months ago
i like peter murphy's singing, but NO ONE can sing this song like trent
alesanarocksyou 1 year ago
This song always makes me cry! It just reminds me of all the terrible sadness in this world.
charlottevard 1 year ago
GOD IS PETER MURPHY HE CAN SING AND DESTROY WHATEVER HE WANTS
MrJulioberne 1 year ago
I have to disagree here. Murphy bring a certain darkness that maybe some people can't handle. NIN make this song in your face, Cash brings a broken, end of life vibe to the song and Bowie just does a Bowie thing to it, but this is really deep and tragically dark.
echorich 1 year ago 25
@echorich
Agreed, Cash's version is tragic, whereas Murphy's version is much darker, much more rending.
treserious 10 months ago
What have I become... my Swedish friend...
sinistar99 1 year ago
He should not have tried this....horrible version of a beautiful song....I love Bauhaus & Dali's Car - but Peter Murphy should have quit while he was still good..sad.
kristine129 1 year ago
How about Johnny Cash??!
ChomoCholo 1 year ago
It's... Decent i guess...
ShadowOps58 1 year ago
I loved Pete Murphy's work from the very early days but this doesn't work for me, just sounds like Pete is over doing it. I do however like the original and Johnny Cash versions.
MaverickMediaUK 1 year ago
no matter who sings it? really?? Many, many artists wrote songs they knew they could not bring feeling or meaning to, and would seek out the artist that they knew would be perfect for it , or vise versa.
wooby33 1 year ago
je l'aime,depuis des siècles...
piekipu1 1 year ago
I am pleased about this version, it is so cautionary and expressive at the same time, a perfect voice for a perfect song.
wooby33 1 year ago
he is trying way too hard.
mrdalga5 1 year ago
@mrdalga5 really??? ha! try looking into a mirror until you feel something about what other people may have gone through.
wooby33 1 year ago
@wooby33 excuse me, let me rephrase, this is a beautiful song, with much feeling, no matter who sings it. it is my opinion that peter murphy is very talented but this is definitely not my favorite of his vocal performances or covers of trent reznors music.
mrdalga5 1 year ago
@liquidspearwaltz6 I am guessing Trent was playing piano.
magneteye 1 year ago
Merci! J'en ai les poils qui se hérissent...
flothanify 1 year ago
This and all other NIN and Raznor songs are in the album, called "where darkness doubles, where light pours in (the radio sessions)".
BlessedDeviant 1 year ago
Jesus, NIN sucks balls. But Peter.. well, I love him. That's why I'm listening to this.
MarinoXDesun 1 year ago
I love his voice
Maroj94 1 year ago
Auf dieses Video antworten... NINE INCH NAILS SONG!!!
manfredboehlke 1 year ago
i dont like the way he sing -.-
izzo4lp 1 year ago
I started laughing really hard. it almost sounded like he was making fun of Trent Reznor. Cash and Reznor are the best for this song. i wish that he changed the song a little more like other bands do to cover.
lol it sounds like hes making fun of this song!!
0PsychoSamurai0 1 year ago
I personally don't like this cover . I understand why people would. It's cool that he put his own little twist on it.
SHITVIDEOSCARNEY93 1 year ago
awesome!
stevabus 1 year ago
HaaaaHaaaa....ouch my side hurts...this song is already LAME!...ekkk Peter....sounds constipated singing this. yeah crown of SHITE! BUT yet the images are quite nice....
mscardiomegaly 1 year ago
great cover!
SmokiBeba86 1 year ago
Whatever.
37Satellite 1 year ago
Johny cash's version is top simply for being the original version and the person to write and compose this song. it is an amazing song with a strong message to it, all the covers are just as powerful and meaningful as the original.... yes i know i contradicted myself, but point being is this song is simply amazing no matter who has coverd it.
Sublevare1 1 year ago
@Sublevare1 actually... the original version is NIN's...
alphaslay 1 year ago
@Sublevare1 It wasn't Cash do wrote the song, its a really early Nine Inch Nails song. Cash just covered it.
0PsychoSamurai0 1 year ago
@Sublevare1 ....Trent Reznor wrote this song and Johnny Cash did a brilliant very apt version ...as Johhny realised later on in life what really matters!
rael1999 1 year ago
Awesome!
philmia123 1 year ago
ahahahahahah :D:D:D:D
zaratustrascarlett 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I believe you can tune into any youtube channel out there and there are always haters to be found.
It never ceases to amaze me how many people have so much time on their hands to waste that they can get on youtube and basically bitch and bitch and bitch and bitch some more about people liking or loving something they either hate or don't understand. People who do nothing but tear others down around them must be the saddest fucking people on the planet.
Thank God it's all about to end...
prayfortheplan 1 year ago
I love all versions of this great song, perhaps original (NIN) I love the most!
But mr Murphy is fantastic here:))))
RibbonsForever 1 year ago 2
My God this is a delicious cover!
RogueGirl74 1 year ago
It's a good cover, but I still prefer the one by Johnny Cash
eliotalanis 1 year ago
@eliotalanis I have a soft spot for Peter Murphy, but I have to agree, Johnny Cash really did something amazing with his cover too. I love them both equally yet differently.
RogueGirl74 1 year ago
This version of the song should be played before every NFL football game.
kirkindysolospock 1 year ago
great another hurt cover.
When are those Joy Division songs done by Trent Reznor/Peter Murphy coming out?
foggie 2 years ago
Joy Division ? I don't think, uhm, I don't know...
intraveineuse 2 years ago
@foggie go to a joy division site then dumb ass." Trent"does not mean validation of all music. Please research b 4 driveling.
wooby33 1 year ago
@foggie Dead Souls??
ElloKattt 9 months ago
just love this, his voice just draws you right in,great cover
braveharty 2 years ago
He was fantabuliuos in concert!!! My 1st time to see him 2006, would luv to see hin again & again & again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sheywey 2 years ago 2
sur ....it's peter !!!! hehehe
junglindus 2 years ago
MAGNIFIQUE !!!!!!
beau travail merci !!!!!!
junglindus 2 years ago
looks and sounds like david bowie
savioroftehuniverse 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i'm no expert but i do not believe this is peter murphy. i believe it is a bad attempt to sound like him.
robdela0 2 years ago
It's Peter Murphy! I'm sur!
intraveineuse 2 years ago 4
@intraveineuse It's not Frank Sinatra?
veloboy 1 year ago
Whaaaat? That is 100% PM
hurly000 2 years ago
@robdela0 yeah, you are definitely NOT an expert... have you heard his voice at all... like ever??
tbwannab 1 year ago
@robdela0 Definitely Peter Murphy since he played this song last year when I saw him. And he and Trent are currently working together.
deathrocker616 1 year ago
@robdela0 You're retarded.
slayerrules114 10 months ago
I love Peter Murphy, but he sounds a bit like Cartman on this one...
splattergirl72 2 years ago
Urgh, not one of Petes better performances..
Kerrigan66 2 years ago
While I am partial to Cash's cover and of course the NIN original, I think Peter Murphy did an amazing job putting himself into the song. Simply amazing
CoveSinful 2 years ago 3
k, i love bauhaus, and thought they were the shit, but if i ever hear peter murphy do this to a nine inch nails song again, i'll probly slit my wrists
chemicalmarch2 2 years ago
@chemicalmarch2 then it worked
clod8 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
lmao!!! "i, hurt myayayay self today!!" LMAO!!! i love it but man sounds like kermit, i've got the one he did for that one session they had but i dont member this
moonbeam6927 2 years ago
peter murphy has so much emotin behind this version.......
acantwell72 2 years ago 2
It's much Better Johnny Cash version
Mrpapito88 2 years ago
really good work with the video!
CactusScreamO 2 years ago 14
Thank You :)
intraveineuse 2 years ago
Is there a mp3 of this available anywhere?
prestito87 2 years ago
havent find one, but ive heard of a programm called atubecatcher, try out ;D
julian73de 2 years ago
I don't know, sorry :s
intraveineuse 2 years ago
@prestito87 you can make an mp3 of this video. google "youtube to mp3 converter" then paste this videos url and it makes an mp3 for you. :)
magneteye 1 year ago
@prestito87 the album is on thepiratebay or just buy it.
CCtjehh 1 year ago
I've listened to this song live by NIN and Peter Murphy. Peter Murphy's version was way better...
MikeMoldao 2 years ago
I have really mixed emotions about Murphy's cover of this....I have loved Murphy for years and years, but I prefer Bowie and Reznor singing this. I can sense quite a bit of emotion in Murphy's voice, which is great, but this is definitely not my favorite of PM's vocal performances.
bauhaus77 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Comment removed by author
diskord4 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Murphy tries too hard to emulate David Bowie..his looks, the way he dresses..his singing style. btw in my opinion Reznor does the best job and he is the original writer. Peter Murphy didn't sing this til way after the fact so get your facts strait. the second best performance and music video of this song is by the one and only Johnny Cash who really understood the meaning of the words of the song as it really did describe the trials of his life. in and out of prison, dealing with drug addiction
coolbeans278 2 years ago
It seems nobody gives a fuck about your opinion.
jraia06 2 years ago 3
Was that directed at me?
changeismydesign 2 years ago
Comment removed
jraia06 2 years ago
Do your research a little bit. :) If you've ever heard him speak about peoples' comparisons between him and Bowie, you'd know he's simply being himself.
Great minds do think alike, after all.
changeismydesign 2 years ago
Peter Murphy is good, dont get me wrong, but Reznor sings this way better. Comon..... Murphy is a bit off.
terriblyill 2 years ago
@terriblyill
Agreed, it's just not Peter's song. Among a multitude of strengths his singular flaw is that he fits another man's shoes poorly.
JoeyMisanthropy 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Really? I could prove you wrong.
See: Reptile by Peter Murphy. He makes Trents shoes too big for even Reznor himself to fit....
JeremyFnScars 1 year ago
No, the subject at hand is this song. What can you prove regarding it?
JoeyMisanthropy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"Among a multitude of strengths his singular flaw is that he fits another man's shoes poorly. " This was your point proven wrong. Your comment wasn't directed at this song, but at Mr. Murphy. Once again. Point Proven.
JeremyFnScars 1 year ago
If my statement were incorrect this song would be better, now wouldn't it?
Go argue with a fencepost, seems to be your style.
JoeyMisanthropy 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
JeremyFnScars 1 year ago
Comment removed
JeremyFnScars 1 year ago
I think you ARE a fencepost, so I'm doing fine. Get out more....
JeremyFnScars 1 year ago
Among your deleted comments you accuse me of being 17 (you're 21, Jeremy, there's not a big difference), of being a pseudo-intellectual, and being a NIN lover. At no point can you nor did you attempt to "prove" anything.
The only thing you said that made any sense is that it is my opinion. Has it really taken you so long to figure that out?
JoeyMisanthropy 1 year ago
this man is so insane good vocal !
gardini100 2 years ago
peter murphy is trent reznor's hero. he's said that in interviews
brownstoned74 2 years ago 2
Whats funny about shadowgeek101 is that a lot of people consider Trent Reznors voice to be special. That is why he sales records idiot! It is a very bold statement to say that someone has a bland voice. do you sing? Peter Murphy has a unique voice, but Trent Reznor sings HIS song way better than Murphy any day man....I dont know how people like you feel the need to negatively criticize artists and think that people want to hear it, or are even somewhat interested. Ha, get a life dude...
MrFrogjuice9 2 years ago
some of you guys are either incredibly stoned or incredibly stupid.
Peter Murphy has a SUBLIME voice even for his old age. I dare any of you to try singing in your 40's/50's, cunts.
And I've heard the Reznor version... it's meh. The man has a run-of-the-mill silky smooth yet masculine voice. Peter's invigorating vocals, from the past or in the present, can outmatch Reznor any day of the week.
I'll betcha this... when Reznor's in his old age, his voice wont be as in tact as Peter's.
shadowgeek101 2 years ago
I agree that Murphy's voice is still incredibly good (I'd even go so far as to say it's better than it was in his youth), however, calling the original version bland is just silly. It was good enough to be covered by three legends in completely different genres.
That said, I do like this version.
CharlesMans0m 2 years ago
the song was good, yes. not the artist.
Trent Reznor's voice is bland at best. Anyone could name 30 different bands who sound just like him... he's nothing special.
he wouldn't be recognized just by his voice the way someone like Andrew Eldritch, Peter Murphy, Johnny Cash, or Axel Rose would be.
i'm not saying his work's bland... he's bland. there's a difference.
I didn't bother to see PM with NIN when they came 'round california
shadowgeek101 2 years ago
I think everyone can recognize any NIN song just by Trent Reznors voice :S
hobo8 2 years ago
Oh ,Eva ME ENCANTA LO QUE HACES!.Es en verdad hermoso como unes imagenes en movimiento y fotos ,para luego darles ese toque elegante del blanco y negro.Hay tantas canciones de Bauhaus que carecen de videoclip y otras de Peter que si lo tienen pero son desilucionantes.SIGUE SALVANDO ESAS CANCIONES CON TU TRABAJO,ERES UNA ARTISTA DEL VIDEO!!.Me inclino en reverencia ante ti pues 'Hurt' y 'King volcano' me conmovieron.
IsabelDhampir82 2 years ago
Muchas gracias! Es agradable los comentarios como el tuyo :)
intraveineuse 2 years ago
Je sui fan de Peter Murphy et Bauhaus. Je aimer ton travail.Est belle et elegant.Merci!. [ PARDON POUR MONTRES MAUVAIS FRANCES!].
IsabelDhampir82 2 years ago
Personally Ive never liked peter murphys vocal style. Can any of you tell me why you enjoy peter murphys voice?
I know you are going to hate on this comment for me saying this, but I currently have the video on mute, because I love the Reznor and Cash versions so much, I dont want them tainted.
HumanOnTheWeb 2 years ago
I don't speak english very well, but his voice it's so perfect for my ears, my heart & my mind & that's all.
intraveineuse 2 years ago
one of the best men in the world. He s so carismatic and his voice is magic.I will always love him.
SayuriNitta84 2 years ago
In my opinion he ruined it.
He just don't fit.
(Even tho he's a great singer - from what I saw and heard)
JonPL 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
kallysto999 2 years ago
Comment removed
kallysto999 2 years ago
Man, I AGREE with you SISTER!!! You and me have a SIMILAR MENTALITY about a lot of things concerning Peter Murphy!!!... A "vampire" should STOP ageing at fucking "30"!!!! Lol!!!
petermurphreak 2 years ago
PETER EST MUSULMAN DEPUIS 1990
sabronn 2 years ago
MAGIQUE
qpqpnn13 2 years ago
not my favorite version of the song, but its nice to know Murphy would try it.
he should stick to Bowie songs ;)
deadboys1010 2 years ago
It's one of my favourite songs and one of my favourirte singers and it's such an amazing combinance!
johnnygraveness 2 years ago
not really my style of singer, but very nice! have you seen the work he's done with trent reznor? The videos are all over youtube
fishyellis 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this song is fucking horrible. leave it to trent or johnny cash... who the fuck is this guy itd be better if weird al did it.
jordangoody 2 years ago
Peter actually does it much better live. And...if you don't know who Peter Murphy is...you've been living under a rock since 1978.
moonbatt 2 years ago
Empire of Dirt. Aren't they all?
zee339 2 years ago
This is a good cover.
Chad0980 2 years ago 2
nine trent does it better but his voice is nice lack of emotion which is huge.
crimmy0204 2 years ago
nine
crimmy0204 2 years ago
This is a really nice cover of a good song, Peter sings it well I think :)
Nice video intraveineuse, there are some nice pictures and video clips there!
Can anyone find me a link to the picture at 1:01 though, please?
I've seen most of the photos/clips in this video, but I've not seen that one before... :)
LikkleLuie 2 years ago
Just print screen in then paste and edit?
q28s1 2 years ago
I've found the picture now, but thanks for helping. :)
LikkleLuie 2 years ago
LOL these comments are %$@# WACK! HAHAHA Leave it to Peter Murphy to bring out the tainted and sometimes best of us!!! WE LOVE YOU PETER!! SOME MORE THEN OTHERS!! LOL
rexfollett 2 years ago
Peter Murphy IS EXTREMELY FUCKING TALENTED and HIS VOICE IS PHENOMENAL and IT DOESN"T MATTER THAT HE'S 51 and GAINED A LOTTA WEIGHT, blah, blah, blah. AND EVEN AT 80 HIS VOICE WILL STILL BE INCREDIBLE, OK??? Now myself I"M INFATUATED WITH THE 24 YEAR OLD PETER MURPHY and I FUCKING THINK HE WAS A FUCKING VISION back then, and HE GIVES ME A MIND-BLOWING RUSH!!!! I"M 100% FUCKING HONEST, IF PETER HADN"T LOOKED THAT GORGEOUS BACK THEN I WOULDN"T HAD TURNED INTO A PETER MURPHY FREAK AT ALL, ALRIGHT??
petermurphreak 2 years ago 3
not that it matters but Pete hasn't gained weight when was the last time you saw him?.....he was his usual boney assed self last I saw him....it's the guy from the Cure who got tubby, Robert Smith........
moogme68 2 years ago
I've never seen Peter in concert ( unfortunely!!! ) , but ever since joining "You Tube" I've been exposed to some of his MOST recent concert clips from like just last year , and he's become a fucking PORKER!!!! He hasn't actually really been "bony" in my opinion when he was "younger", he was just "slender" ( at about 155lbs.) and supposedly 6ft., so he was "proportioned" right!!! And his "succulent" bubble ass was anything but BONY!!! He used to have the right "lean" "athletic" physique...
petermurphreak 2 years ago
really?! Well I gotta go see that as I can't imagine him fat! I've met them all and seen them in concert as Bauhaus, Pete on his solo tours and Love And Rockets and he's no 6 footer, 5'9 maybe 5'10 but Kevin is tall though!
moogme68 2 years ago
It's really important ?!
My videos ar not posted for talking about that... it's stupid.
intraveineuse 2 years ago
no my commenting about meeting them seems fine to me but you didn't say not to post comments to the others making remarks about his cum and having his kids...hmmm, sex crap is fine but not comments on meeting them, weight or height?...odd!
moogme68 2 years ago
Sorry, I'm french I don't understand all, & I don't make answer at everybody.
intraveineuse 2 years ago
HAhahahhaha... He probably got to sad and eat a bunch of chocolates.
I love Robert though.
q28s1 2 years ago
Oh the old Maxell cassettes advert man :-)
Here sounding like the Crash Test Dummies, I think.
dfarmbrough 2 years ago
@dfarmbrough Great spot! Murphy has had a penchant for humming (quite hilariously) at least as far back as the Daiis Car record. Murphy's voice has become increasingly silly with the years. It started out as an occasional humourous device but has now almost completely taken over, to the extent that I find it difficult to even listen to him now! I remember thinking years ago how much the singer from Crash Test Dummied sounded like Peter Murphy!
MisAnnThorpe 1 year ago
@MisAnnThorpe Yes. He obviously has some talent and some charm, but it's probably mis-directed. He is one of those artists who has a load of sycophantic fans who can't see any wrong in what he does, and so ends up becoming more and more pretentious as the years go by. He probably considers himself an 'artist' rather than a singer.
dfarmbrough 1 year ago
Superbe !
merci !
snancy2008 2 years ago
I do too! He has the best voice ever, so hunting so sexy...the forever Mr. Murphy.
tanker301 2 years ago 2
Oh, god, I want to bear litter after litter of his babies.
girlchild0aglow 2 years ago
Comment removed
petermurphreak 2 years ago
And I want to have liter after liter of his cream!!!!
petermurphreak 2 years ago
Gross....
posmacofficial 2 years ago
drop the sweetest drop..LOL
moogme68 2 years ago
classic ...
clitorisbombardeado 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
his voice really sucks
hallenbeck84 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It sounds too David Bowie-ish.
Death2Bigots 2 years ago
their voices are simular thats why Bauhaus did a cover of Ziggy' but Pete has more range and is deeper.
moogme68 2 years ago 4
I like all 3 version for different reasons. Trent's cuz it's his song and his lyrics. Cash's because it's timeless and poignant. Murphy's because he might have the strongest vocal performance of the three, and unless like Cash, who was introduced to Rez and his song by Ric Rubin for commercial reasons, Peter is actually a friend of Trent's.
So don't bash any of them. They all rule in their own way. It's like a good Dylan song - many people can cover it and there can exist many great versions.
dukeon 2 years ago 2
Great song, interesting photos. Lyrics? It could be about me. Anyway, PM's voice is avesome.
argento69 3 years ago
:)
great
DarkMusa014 3 years ago
I can't believe i'm gonna see peter murphy!i'm so excited!
GothSaku 3 years ago
I loved the radio show sessions the band had with Murphy in 2006. :D
NothingFanboy 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
NO! "hurt" was a Johnny Cash song!!!! get your facts straight
laurauhlig86 3 years ago
Hey wtf is wrong with you 'laurauhlig86'??? Hurt is a NIN song not Johnny Cash!
amen2u 3 years ago 6
laurauhlig86, you're a fuckin moron! Get YOUR facts straight bitch!
amen2u 3 years ago 4
Yup, Hurt was written by Trent Reznor/NIN, Johnny Cash loved the song and made his own version.
Xithon 3 years ago 2
ahaha
asshole..
hurt = Trent Reznor :)
DarkMusa014 3 years ago
lol lol lol What's that photo at 1:12? I laughed so hard I almost fell from my chair! lol
Actresspt 3 years ago
I don't understand all... because I'm french, but, it's a photo of Peter Murphy...
intraveineuse 3 years ago
Peter Murphy with laces in the 80s...I´ve been shocked too,but it´s ace! Love him!!!
sweetlavinia 3 years ago
in the moment you said... "similar voice"... isn't that comparing?... and, dont worry, the stuff of "who is beter than who"... inst about of your opinion... its about the orher one... "Not bad...but nothing will ever beat Trent Reznor. Not even Cash"
elGeorgedeguanabos 3 years ago