I also think the air-headed punk who keeps babbling about the cannon crap is the same loser who was babbling about this bullshit on another website. He got his ass blasted there as well. No one is buying the bullshit about a fn loom. In fact the only ones who do are loons. lol
I see there are still a few retards who think they are cleaver but in reality are just a bunch of dicks. I do not have to justify my hatred for the putrid character river slimeball. She is a gross skanky bitch. She has no redeeming qualities. I agree with the aunt! I want to reach into the TV and strangle that bitch everytime her fugly fatass comes on the screen. She does act like a female version of steven moffat. that fatass bastard. his writing is crap. It defies all logic.
I remember when I saw the promo photo's of Matt when he was revealed as being the new doctor. I wasn't certain about him. Now, I actually think he's one of the greatest doctor's there's ever been. I might even have to admit; I think he's better than Tennant.
BTW, feckin' amazing video's seduff, probably the best fan-made stuff of DW I've ever seen on Youtube.
This episode was okay. I actually figured some of this out long ago but then again I'm not 10! And that scene where the Doctor transports back to the Earth with River Song looked a son about to escort his mother somewhere. Unless she IS his mother GROSS!!!! Now if she does turn out to be his mother NOW THAT WOULD BE INTERESTING! It would explain alot! How she knows his real name! How she can read and write ancient Gallifrean! And she would be married now wouldn't she.....To the Doctors DAD!
@sallyjosie lol you don't know much about his species do you?
Gallifreyans are created by something called a Loom. The Loom is a genetic weaving construction created by Rassilon following the Pythia's curse of sterility on Gallifrey. The Loom also kept tally of all the people it birthed, keeping track of how old each one was and how many regenerations each had gone though. Each house (or tribe) had one. If one person died, another would be created by the Loom.
@emROARS Romana and the Rani are way too good for River. River is like that creepy old Aunt no one wants to invite but have to because shes a relative. And I just looked up that Pythia crap and its just some garbage from a book. No one pays any attention to those stupid books. In future try not to sound like such a nerd....please?
@emROARS Anyone who thinks a mega creepy drag queen like River Song is awesome is obviously not playing with a full deck. In fact I strongly suspect some of those who like that fugly piece of sh*t has some serious mommy issues if you know what I mean. And any writer who makes up crap about a FN loom that creates babies needs serious psychiatric help. That's about as plausible as saying babies come from cabbage patches or the stork brings them. Grow UP!
you like that feeling when doctor who began years ago the word bad wolf was ligering around and like the idea they doing it again only it's a crack in the wall a crack that follows
Having seen the entire new series, it's ok,not great. Smith is ok . The series is interesting enough that I'd watch whoever was the Doctor. The writing for the 2 part finale was not as good as I'd expected. It's a bit jumbled and frankly Smith acts likes he's having an epileptic fit in his silliness. He's amusing sometimes, but he's over doing it. If the companions get any younger, they'd be doing an after school special. I'm not 'anxiously' awaiting the next series, but I'll watch it.
Perusual your stuff is awesome! Made me feel as if I hadn't already seen the episode and had no idea what as going on! >,< Always fun watching your stuff! Keep up the great work! XD Thanks for it!
"the little girl who still believes in stars" is amy as a kid.a few questions-how did the doctor comes out of the pandorica? if amy saw the doctor only 12 years after the first meeting, how come she meets him before? how will amy come back to life(she has to, she's in the next series)?who exploded the tardis and said "silence will fall"?how did river song survived? what happend to the alliance?is rory really exists? and why the hell the doctor's enemies want to save the universe suddenly?
this episode was amazing. it kicked ass! i will admit the episodes following the weeping angels were kind of poorly done and i got kind of bored watching them, but THIS blew me out of the water!!!
Wow this actually makes the show look good! *shock horror* lol I see your bit about the cracks and I'm like, "wow, that's such a cool idea!" whereas usually, I'm like "oh please just give it a rest already. There's cracks in the universe, I get it, you don't have to be so bloody obvious about it!"... that's a point. Why *are* they being so obvious about it?...
With RTD you didn't realise what the running theme was until the series finale, letting the fans have much more fun trying to work it out. And then, once you'd found out that it was "torchwood" or "bad wolf" you'd instantly want to go back to watch all the previous episodes again. You see, that's another reason why this series isn't as good as the rest.... but I digress. lol. Great teaser Sarah. Now I'm actually looking forward to seeing the ep! XD
@THEpowerOFme Hehe, glad you liked it Soph. So did you like the episode itself? I'll have to email you in the morning, but if you can't wait, I've seen it so you won't spoil anything if you want to vent or just comment ... ;) x
@1066gull Well, I can certainly admit that there have been some very nice moments this season. I found *something* to like about nearly every episode. But I do miss what I guess you refer to as the "drama", as it took that final moment in the Vincent episode for me to feel a modicum of emotion for anything that had happened up to that point. That's a lot of ho-hum stuff to go through for one minute of "aw...[sniff]". Can't we have both our hearts AND our heads engaged? That would be perfect DW.
@rachel68620 Thanks so much but sadly I don't think they're interested in some chick from Australia. ;) Would love to one day though. My UK passport is all ready to go...
Just gotta say I love everything you do and this trailer just managed to make me even more excited about tonights episode.. As others have pointed out there has been some piss poor scripts this season. but luckily in my oppinon it has been leveled out with some good episodes as well.. but yeah Episode 3 gotta be one of the worst episodes ever. Really bad re-introduction for the daleks *facepalms* anyway you rock seduff!. If you did the Real trailers Dr Who would be the biggest show in the world!
The trailer is ... well ... just brilliant! Sometime soon The Beeb is going to come knocking at your door, mark my words. :) Your talent and creativity--dare I say genius--is phenomenal and the new vid has been worth the wait. Well done.
The trailer is ... well ... just brilliant! Sometime soon The Beeb is going to come knocking at your door, mark my words. :) Your talent and creativity--dare I say genius--is phenomenal and the new vid has been worth the wait. Well done.
The trailer is ... well ... just brilliant! Sometime soon The Beeb is going to come knocking at your door, mark my words. :) Your talent and creativity--dare I say genius--is phenomenal and the new vid has been worth the wait. Well done.
Ooo, that was awesome! I love the more mysterious feel to it. :D Great job, as always! Not that I needed anymore help being excited for the ep tomorrow but this has *really* got me in proper fangirl mode now! \o/ :D ♥!
I might be in the minority with this group, but I've been pretty disappointed with this season - mainly because of Amy, but partly because of too many poor scripts. (Matt's great, I hasten to add.) But the point I want to make is that you are so talented, you can take any steaming pile of dreck and make it exciting, suspenseful and shiny. Would it be too much to ask if you'd pretty pretty please just re-edit episodes 1-10 and re-upload them? I miss my favorite show. Thanks a bunch...:)
@smlivingstone Hehe. Thank you very much! And I commend you for being brave and saying it how it is. I too have enjoyed Matt over the last few weeks, but the middle of the season had a series lack of good scripts. (and lets just all ignore Episode 3 shall we. *facepalm!*) I do hope the 2 part finale and openers to next season inspire more fans tune back in. :)
@seduff Re: Ep 3 - Anyone associated with that who has an ounce of humility has already turned every extant copy of the script into bum fodder. I've already scheduled the surgery necessary to excise the little piece of my brain that still carried memories of it. It will be worth every penny.
As for the finale, it will have to be almost unimaginably, spectacularly, gobsmackingly brilliant to redeem most of what went before. I mean, there were some lovely highlights, but overall - hit & miss.
@seduff Series 5 wasn't so bad but I drink bleach every time I remember ep 3. The others have been at least decent and better than most of the specials (except water of mars)
@LooseChangePlease Thanks! It's not always popular to go against the tide of love for this new season, but I've encountered more than one person online who agrees that there were some iffy decisions made on it. Still, I'm hanging in, and maybe next year will be better, eh?
@smlivingstone This season, in my opinion, has a lot of unique episodes, in good ways and bad. I freaking looooved Amy's Choice, Vincent and the Doctor, The Lodger, etc. because they were unique and fun.
@someone332 There's always room for unique & fun. That's why I liked "Love & Monsters" , even though it's almost universally reviled. But a whole season of that wouldn't have been a very good idea. I would have been willing to trade clever plotting (RTD's weakness, Moff's strength) for some genuine emotion (RTD's strength, Moff's weakness). Every attempt to tug at our heartstrings has just been an annoying yank (or nonexistent). But Teh Clever - not making up for it. Glad that ur loving it, tho!
@someone332 You're right, as I pointed out in a reply to someone else here, that final moment in Vincent was a truly successful heart tug. I shed a real, live, running down the face tear at that bit. I did think that episode was one of the more likeable ones, for sure!
@smlivingstone I know Girl in the Fireplace is probably Moffat's best job at the emotional stuff, with (probably), massive editing by RTD. RTD is very strict with his editing. Moffat doesn't edit as much, for what I can tell.
@someone332 That could be the problem, right there. If Moff would better oversee what his writers are churning out, and stick in his editorial oar a little more often, the quality might improve significantly. Perhaps he'll learn that lesson for next season? Here's hoping... :)
@smlivingstone Are you serious? You do realise that Steven Moffatt wrote those scripts and I personally think that they were pretty amazing. His storylines have connected and always suspenseful. I personally loved it but you're entitled to your opinion..
@Timba221 Not sure which scripts you're referring to, but SM by no means wrote all the stories we've seen this season. I agree that his were usually better than the ones by other writers, but even his own best scripts from this season haven't been the best he's ever done. Understand that I'm not talking about either today or next week's episode (I hadn't yet seen today's when I first posted here). Glad that you're finding lots to love!
@smlivingstone I'm aware that SM hasn't wrote all the episodes and there have ehhhh episodes but I don't think i agree with your comment that there were 'too many poor scripts' but I will agree that episode has a poor start and middle but it's progressed and it's become better. They've only just had to establish the characters and re-introduce Doctor Who. I mean it's something the progresses and it's needed to have intros. PS. SM may not have written it all but he's basically planned all the eps
@smlivingstone I am with you 100% , amy pond and the lack of charactor development in the high percentage of very poor scripts almost spoiled this series for me.
Seduff 's fantastic vid showed me why i have stuck with it , matt smith is brilliant and the first part of the series end was excellent.
@topliff12345 Thanks for sharing, topliff! I've now watched The Pandorica Opens & still am not sure there will be a big enough rabbit pulled out of the hat to make up for what's gone before, but there are 55 minutes to come before I'm allowed a final judgment on Amy. And I expect I'll stick around even tho she'll still be whining around the TARDIS next year, just because I refuse to give up on the show for a temporary character! Wish they'd let Seduff do the editing. Things might improve.
@smlivingstone You are not alone in your assessment of this current season. Though I disagree with you on Amy, she is perhaps not the best companion the doctor has ever had but she is by far not the worst. I can name 3 that were far more annoying and boring. Adric, Tegan Jovanka, and Peri Brown. I too hope the writing improves as I find myself struggling to keep my interest in finishing some episodes.
@AgGrad2007 Yeah, and Mel was no great shakes either. Maybe they just set the bar so high since the resurrection of the show that anything falling below it has become unacceptable to we spoiled fans! I always found *something* to like about every episode in the old days, even the utter crap ones, that I'm sure I can do it now too. I'm just so so sorry I have to see it that way, after such a nice long run of nearly undiluted delight in the show.
Brilliant! Why are your videos always better than the original trailers? Because you're awesome, that's why! =) I love this trailers far more than the original! Kudos, as always! =) (From Ms_Me_)
Its been so lovely to hear that you have actually missed my videos. (^^,) I've missed making them and hearing from all you wonderful people. *hugs* to you all. x
@seduff Your absolutely brilliant. Nothing in the world makes Doctor Who more awesome than a person willing to create such masterpieces from something already with masterpiece status. So. Kudos to you and I hope that you get anything and everything you want in the word ever. Because. You deserve it.
@KoriAliztairLahrcan .... *pauses* Well, I don't really know what to say to that. I am so honoured you feel that I add something extra to the fandom, no matter how small it may be. Thank you, so very much. x
AMAZING! You're the best and BBC should hire you to say the least! You make WAY better trailers then they do, that's probably why they don't like you! Anyway, beautiful as always!
What can I say that hasn't already been said? You're the best, this is great and I can't wait to see this on Saturday. Ah...I see...Even though this has probably been said a thousand times already, it's still true, thanks. : )
I absolutly anticipate the arrival of your videos Seduff. The editing, the genius, the one and the only! You take so much time with your videos and editing HD tv audio (im guessing that's how u do it) But loved it! Another splendid job! Amazing... I think i've run out of adjectives....
Absolutely stunning work Seduff! Loved it to bits. Brilliant choice of music and great selection of clips! Can't wait for more videos based on the finale :)
I tried making one a couple of days ago and uploaded it, but mine is just a poor excuse compared to yours. This is fantastic so much more tension created and so epic.
hese two episodes are huge, I think the only major monsters and villains from the last 47 years not to make an appearance in this are the master and the rani. Everything and everyone is in here. Fantastic
Woooo! Although, I'm in America so I haven't even seen Cold Blood yet, but I tried to watch this without really taking in any possible spoilers and just admire the editing, which was amazing as always.
I was already crazily excited for this episode but now I can't wait! Oh wow, it looks so cool and exciting. I loved all of the audio you used, some I've never heard before.
I especially liked the use of "The Doctor in the TARDIS doesn't know" - because that phrase just fascinates me and freaks me out in equal measure.
what music have you used? great trailer btw ;)
stupidig 2 weeks ago
You should work for BBC ^^ Your trailers are ten times better than theirs :)
TheStarbender 7 months ago
I also think the air-headed punk who keeps babbling about the cannon crap is the same loser who was babbling about this bullshit on another website. He got his ass blasted there as well. No one is buying the bullshit about a fn loom. In fact the only ones who do are loons. lol
friedasmith 1 year ago
I see there are still a few retards who think they are cleaver but in reality are just a bunch of dicks. I do not have to justify my hatred for the putrid character river slimeball. She is a gross skanky bitch. She has no redeeming qualities. I agree with the aunt! I want to reach into the TV and strangle that bitch everytime her fugly fatass comes on the screen. She does act like a female version of steven moffat. that fatass bastard. his writing is crap. It defies all logic.
friedasmith 1 year ago
I forgot how good you were!
mrwho995 1 year ago
I remember when I saw the promo photo's of Matt when he was revealed as being the new doctor. I wasn't certain about him. Now, I actually think he's one of the greatest doctor's there's ever been. I might even have to admit; I think he's better than Tennant.
BTW, feckin' amazing video's seduff, probably the best fan-made stuff of DW I've ever seen on Youtube.
PFCboi1 1 year ago
this maybe a little bit late but who noticed the bit of the tardis the doctor found has the same shape as the crack in amy's wall! 0:18
tekkenrulez97 1 year ago
@tekkenrulez97 im not seeing it... maybe if it was only the bottom but even then its not quite there
hobbesrs 1 year ago
WOW THAT WAS BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL NEXT TIME TRAILER well done!:)
baaboo999 1 year ago
This episode was okay. I actually figured some of this out long ago but then again I'm not 10! And that scene where the Doctor transports back to the Earth with River Song looked a son about to escort his mother somewhere. Unless she IS his mother GROSS!!!! Now if she does turn out to be his mother NOW THAT WOULD BE INTERESTING! It would explain alot! How she knows his real name! How she can read and write ancient Gallifrean! And she would be married now wouldn't she.....To the Doctors DAD!
sallyjosie 1 year ago
@sallyjosie lol you don't know much about his species do you?
Gallifreyans are created by something called a Loom. The Loom is a genetic weaving construction created by Rassilon following the Pythia's curse of sterility on Gallifrey. The Loom also kept tally of all the people it birthed, keeping track of how old each one was and how many regenerations each had gone though. Each house (or tribe) had one. If one person died, another would be created by the Loom.
emROARS 1 year ago
@emROARS Romana and the Rani are way too good for River. River is like that creepy old Aunt no one wants to invite but have to because shes a relative. And I just looked up that Pythia crap and its just some garbage from a book. No one pays any attention to those stupid books. In future try not to sound like such a nerd....please?
friedasmith 1 year ago
@friedasmith i can't help it if it's been ony my family's tele since it started. :)
And why hate river? I think she's awesome.
And even if it is in a book, it's still canon since the BBC stated it was canon.
Just calm down honestly, bloody hell.
emROARS 1 year ago
@emROARS Anyone who thinks a mega creepy drag queen like River Song is awesome is obviously not playing with a full deck. In fact I strongly suspect some of those who like that fugly piece of sh*t has some serious mommy issues if you know what I mean. And any writer who makes up crap about a FN loom that creates babies needs serious psychiatric help. That's about as plausible as saying babies come from cabbage patches or the stork brings them. Grow UP!
friedasmith 1 year ago
@friedasmith: Jesus.
Loom = Their version of IVF, it's not that hard to understand. It's a metaphor.
River = I would have though you would be able to give me a proper explination about how you don't like her. Guess I was wrong.
And I haven't got a 'mommy' actually, I have a 'mum' or 'mam'. :)
emROARS 1 year ago
you like that feeling when doctor who began years ago the word bad wolf was ligering around and like the idea they doing it again only it's a crack in the wall a crack that follows
500AndiE 1 year ago
I really enjoyed this! You make great changes! :)
GallifreyanVideo 1 year ago
@seduff
Thought something was different lol. Pretty good.
TEHEmmie 1 year ago
@seduff
Isn't this the actual next time trailer? Excuse me if I'm wrong but I swear this looks like the next time trailer.
TEHEmmie 1 year ago
@TEHEmmie I have changed quite a few things about it. Please see the info for further details, thanks. :)
seduff 1 year ago
As usual, absolutely superb!
Calavicci9 1 year ago
OMG!
Beautiful, awesome, fantastic, hallucinant !
I love the original trailer but yours is even better!
You're brilliant! You make the best Doctor Who videos on Youtube! :o
Fantastic job! Vraiment fabuleux !
Primevalwho.
Primevalwho 1 year ago
Having seen the entire new series, it's ok,not great. Smith is ok . The series is interesting enough that I'd watch whoever was the Doctor. The writing for the 2 part finale was not as good as I'd expected. It's a bit jumbled and frankly Smith acts likes he's having an epileptic fit in his silliness. He's amusing sometimes, but he's over doing it. If the companions get any younger, they'd be doing an after school special. I'm not 'anxiously' awaiting the next series, but I'll watch it.
Jumpinflashjack 1 year ago
Oh man this is super amazing :D
MutantMixes 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
does amy really die???
plz tell me..
dalbhattarkali 1 year ago
does amy really die???
plz tell me..
dalbhattarkali 1 year ago
@dalbhattarkali no she lives
jzthereaper100 1 year ago
Perusual your stuff is awesome! Made me feel as if I hadn't already seen the episode and had no idea what as going on! >,< Always fun watching your stuff! Keep up the great work! XD Thanks for it!
moonlight1314 1 year ago
finally you've made something new, and a great job u have done of it well done seduff
kidchaos725 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"the little girl who still believes in stars" is amy as a kid.a few questions-how did the doctor comes out of the pandorica? if amy saw the doctor only 12 years after the first meeting, how come she meets him before? how will amy come back to life(she has to, she's in the next series)?who exploded the tardis and said "silence will fall"?how did river song survived? what happend to the alliance?is rory really exists? and why the hell the doctor's enemies want to save the universe suddenly?
100regel 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what program you use to remove alternate music from the clip?
ZHURAFILMS 1 year ago
this episode was amazing. it kicked ass! i will admit the episodes following the weeping angels were kind of poorly done and i got kind of bored watching them, but THIS blew me out of the water!!!
katebien 1 year ago
So happy to see a new video from you! It was brilliant, as always. :)
thescribbler06 1 year ago
once again... inspired..... check mine out for the final episode?
RBproductions10 1 year ago
SPOILER BELOW!
HOW COULD THEY KILL AMY!
DALEK2626 1 year ago
hi can someone tell me what happend in tonights episode i live in slovenia so i can't watch it
slogirl666 1 year ago
not your best but still good.
what did you think about the episode? For me, it was too good for words
housefan95 1 year ago
Fantastic :D
Much better than the original next time trailer :)
I think I speak for your viewers that we are not disappointment after all this time :)
Keep on making brilliant videos :D
oemj1 1 year ago
Wow this actually makes the show look good! *shock horror* lol I see your bit about the cracks and I'm like, "wow, that's such a cool idea!" whereas usually, I'm like "oh please just give it a rest already. There's cracks in the universe, I get it, you don't have to be so bloody obvious about it!"... that's a point. Why *are* they being so obvious about it?...
THEpowerOFme 1 year ago
@THEpowerOFme
With RTD you didn't realise what the running theme was until the series finale, letting the fans have much more fun trying to work it out. And then, once you'd found out that it was "torchwood" or "bad wolf" you'd instantly want to go back to watch all the previous episodes again. You see, that's another reason why this series isn't as good as the rest.... but I digress. lol. Great teaser Sarah. Now I'm actually looking forward to seeing the ep! XD
THEpowerOFme 1 year ago
@THEpowerOFme Hehe, glad you liked it Soph. So did you like the episode itself? I'll have to email you in the morning, but if you can't wait, I've seen it so you won't spoil anything if you want to vent or just comment ... ;) x
seduff 1 year ago
..I'm betting its The Rani who has returned and is framing the Doctor in the second part and has managed to grow her own Tardis lookalike. ^_^
scufflerz 1 year ago
@1066gull Well, I can certainly admit that there have been some very nice moments this season. I found *something* to like about nearly every episode. But I do miss what I guess you refer to as the "drama", as it took that final moment in the Vincent episode for me to feel a modicum of emotion for anything that had happened up to that point. That's a lot of ho-hum stuff to go through for one minute of "aw...[sniff]". Can't we have both our hearts AND our heads engaged? That would be perfect DW.
smlivingstone 1 year ago
Sefuff You are bloody FANTASTIC! its better then the BBC'S xD
- x
RaggedyDoctor 1 year ago
@RaggedyDoctor **Seduff
RaggedyDoctor 1 year ago
Oh that makes it even more exciting to wait for. And why exactly is it you don't have a job with the BBC yet? As always Amazing
rachel68620 1 year ago
@rachel68620 Thanks so much but sadly I don't think they're interested in some chick from Australia. ;) Would love to one day though. My UK passport is all ready to go...
seduff 1 year ago
Oh look! Amy's actually wearing pants! Go Amy!
BotheringTrees 1 year ago
Just gotta say I love everything you do and this trailer just managed to make me even more excited about tonights episode.. As others have pointed out there has been some piss poor scripts this season. but luckily in my oppinon it has been leveled out with some good episodes as well.. but yeah Episode 3 gotta be one of the worst episodes ever. Really bad re-introduction for the daleks *facepalms* anyway you rock seduff!. If you did the Real trailers Dr Who would be the biggest show in the world!
Nikmi 1 year ago
Your trailers are always so much better than the actual BBC ones. Makes tonights ep seem even more exciting! :) Well done! xx
Rheasilva17 1 year ago
AMAZING as always... Congratulations
callyboy82 1 year ago
The trailer is ... well ... just brilliant! Sometime soon The Beeb is going to come knocking at your door, mark my words. :) Your talent and creativity--dare I say genius--is phenomenal and the new vid has been worth the wait. Well done.
akalily 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The trailer is ... well ... just brilliant! Sometime soon The Beeb is going to come knocking at your door, mark my words. :) Your talent and creativity--dare I say genius--is phenomenal and the new vid has been worth the wait. Well done.
akalily 1 year ago
The trailer is ... well ... just brilliant! Sometime soon The Beeb is going to come knocking at your door, mark my words. :) Your talent and creativity--dare I say genius--is phenomenal and the new vid has been worth the wait. Well done.
akalily 1 year ago
I have really missed your videos.
Can't wait for the new ones!
Oh by the way awesome re-cut!
oliviaaa23 1 year ago
Yeah okay. Once again, I prefer yours. DUDE THAT WAS AWESOME.
Have missed your videos loads, and this was great to come back to =D Love it!
AzureFalls64 1 year ago
Ooo, that was awesome! I love the more mysterious feel to it. :D Great job, as always! Not that I needed anymore help being excited for the ep tomorrow but this has *really* got me in proper fangirl mode now! \o/ :D ♥!
Aislynn815 1 year ago
@Aislynn815 Haha, thanks hun, so lovely to hear from you. So did you enjoy the episode? :) ♥
seduff 1 year ago
@seduff Oh, I really did; I loved it! And then there was that ending! O_O *taps foot, waiting for part 2 to get here* ;) How about you? :D ♥!
Aislynn815 1 year ago
I might be in the minority with this group, but I've been pretty disappointed with this season - mainly because of Amy, but partly because of too many poor scripts. (Matt's great, I hasten to add.) But the point I want to make is that you are so talented, you can take any steaming pile of dreck and make it exciting, suspenseful and shiny. Would it be too much to ask if you'd pretty pretty please just re-edit episodes 1-10 and re-upload them? I miss my favorite show. Thanks a bunch...:)
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@smlivingstone Hehe. Thank you very much! And I commend you for being brave and saying it how it is. I too have enjoyed Matt over the last few weeks, but the middle of the season had a series lack of good scripts. (and lets just all ignore Episode 3 shall we. *facepalm!*) I do hope the 2 part finale and openers to next season inspire more fans tune back in. :)
seduff 1 year ago 8
@seduff Re: Ep 3 - Anyone associated with that who has an ounce of humility has already turned every extant copy of the script into bum fodder. I've already scheduled the surgery necessary to excise the little piece of my brain that still carried memories of it. It will be worth every penny.
As for the finale, it will have to be almost unimaginably, spectacularly, gobsmackingly brilliant to redeem most of what went before. I mean, there were some lovely highlights, but overall - hit & miss.
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@seduff Series 5 wasn't so bad but I drink bleach every time I remember ep 3. The others have been at least decent and better than most of the specials (except water of mars)
Ihavealife100 1 year ago
@smlivingstone I so love your comment, absolutely everything you said was spot on! From Amy, to the poor scripts and even to how amazing Seduff is!
Kudos!
LooseChangePlease 1 year ago
@LooseChangePlease Thanks! It's not always popular to go against the tide of love for this new season, but I've encountered more than one person online who agrees that there were some iffy decisions made on it. Still, I'm hanging in, and maybe next year will be better, eh?
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@smlivingstone This season, in my opinion, has a lot of unique episodes, in good ways and bad. I freaking looooved Amy's Choice, Vincent and the Doctor, The Lodger, etc. because they were unique and fun.
someone332 1 year ago
@someone332 There's always room for unique & fun. That's why I liked "Love & Monsters" , even though it's almost universally reviled. But a whole season of that wouldn't have been a very good idea. I would have been willing to trade clever plotting (RTD's weakness, Moff's strength) for some genuine emotion (RTD's strength, Moff's weakness). Every attempt to tug at our heartstrings has just been an annoying yank (or nonexistent). But Teh Clever - not making up for it. Glad that ur loving it, tho!
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@smlivingstone Well Vincent and the Doctor was emotional... to the half who liked it. :/ My friend almost cried.
someone332 1 year ago
@someone332 You're right, as I pointed out in a reply to someone else here, that final moment in Vincent was a truly successful heart tug. I shed a real, live, running down the face tear at that bit. I did think that episode was one of the more likeable ones, for sure!
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@smlivingstone I know Girl in the Fireplace is probably Moffat's best job at the emotional stuff, with (probably), massive editing by RTD. RTD is very strict with his editing. Moffat doesn't edit as much, for what I can tell.
someone332 1 year ago 2
@someone332 That could be the problem, right there. If Moff would better oversee what his writers are churning out, and stick in his editorial oar a little more often, the quality might improve significantly. Perhaps he'll learn that lesson for next season? Here's hoping... :)
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@smlivingstone Are you serious? You do realise that Steven Moffatt wrote those scripts and I personally think that they were pretty amazing. His storylines have connected and always suspenseful. I personally loved it but you're entitled to your opinion..
Timba221 1 year ago
@Timba221 Not sure which scripts you're referring to, but SM by no means wrote all the stories we've seen this season. I agree that his were usually better than the ones by other writers, but even his own best scripts from this season haven't been the best he's ever done. Understand that I'm not talking about either today or next week's episode (I hadn't yet seen today's when I first posted here). Glad that you're finding lots to love!
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@smlivingstone I'm aware that SM hasn't wrote all the episodes and there have ehhhh episodes but I don't think i agree with your comment that there were 'too many poor scripts' but I will agree that episode has a poor start and middle but it's progressed and it's become better. They've only just had to establish the characters and re-introduce Doctor Who. I mean it's something the progresses and it's needed to have intros. PS. SM may not have written it all but he's basically planned all the eps
Timba221 1 year ago
@smlivingstone I am with you 100% , amy pond and the lack of charactor development in the high percentage of very poor scripts almost spoiled this series for me.
Seduff 's fantastic vid showed me why i have stuck with it , matt smith is brilliant and the first part of the series end was excellent.
there is still lots to love............
topliff12345 1 year ago
@topliff12345 Thanks for sharing, topliff! I've now watched The Pandorica Opens & still am not sure there will be a big enough rabbit pulled out of the hat to make up for what's gone before, but there are 55 minutes to come before I'm allowed a final judgment on Amy. And I expect I'll stick around even tho she'll still be whining around the TARDIS next year, just because I refuse to give up on the show for a temporary character! Wish they'd let Seduff do the editing. Things might improve.
smlivingstone 1 year ago
@smlivingstone You are not alone in your assessment of this current season. Though I disagree with you on Amy, she is perhaps not the best companion the doctor has ever had but she is by far not the worst. I can name 3 that were far more annoying and boring. Adric, Tegan Jovanka, and Peri Brown. I too hope the writing improves as I find myself struggling to keep my interest in finishing some episodes.
AgGrad2007 1 year ago
@AgGrad2007 Yeah, and Mel was no great shakes either. Maybe they just set the bar so high since the resurrection of the show that anything falling below it has become unacceptable to we spoiled fans! I always found *something* to like about every episode in the old days, even the utter crap ones, that I'm sure I can do it now too. I'm just so so sorry I have to see it that way, after such a nice long run of nearly undiluted delight in the show.
smlivingstone 1 year ago
Brilliant! Why are your videos always better than the original trailers? Because you're awesome, that's why! =) I love this trailers far more than the original! Kudos, as always! =) (From Ms_Me_)
LatinFox 1 year ago 2
@LatinFox AHA! *points and smiles* It's YOU! =D Thanks hun, so lovely to hear from you over here.
seduff 1 year ago
Thank you to everyone for their amazing comments!
Its been so lovely to hear that you have actually missed my videos. (^^,) I've missed making them and hearing from all you wonderful people. *hugs* to you all. x
seduff 1 year ago
@seduff Your absolutely brilliant. Nothing in the world makes Doctor Who more awesome than a person willing to create such masterpieces from something already with masterpiece status. So. Kudos to you and I hope that you get anything and everything you want in the word ever. Because. You deserve it.
KoriAliztairLahrcan 1 year ago 2
@KoriAliztairLahrcan .... *pauses* Well, I don't really know what to say to that. I am so honoured you feel that I add something extra to the fandom, no matter how small it may be. Thank you, so very much. x
seduff 1 year ago
@seduff Your very very welcome from a good old fashioned British fan of doctor who. @)
KoriAliztairLahrcan 1 year ago
Brilliant as always! :)
kryptonitegrace 1 year ago
AMAZING!!!
BlacksGodDaughter 1 year ago
Where have thou been? We've missed you!!!!
WhirledSol 1 year ago
so excited for this episode!!
cassiebella314 1 year ago
Better than the BBC.
mowingthefrontlawn 1 year ago
Great work.
balistik94 1 year ago
You will never fail to amaze and inspire me. You are truely one of the best editors I'm subbed too. ^_^
Thank You so much for posting this...how long does it take roughly for you to make a video like this?
FantasiesGhost 1 year ago
It's more original than the BBC versions which just makes me think 'epic movie' stereotype. Yours has more soul and excites me even more.
rocketboom324 1 year ago
I like your teaser better as always!!! i've missed your work! this is brilliant:)
urGUARDIANangl98 1 year ago
LOVE LOVE LOVE
Tonksdora 1 year ago
Yay sarah we missed you :) hehe
Stuff0fLegend 1 year ago
This is simply fantastic!
kalishaka 1 year ago
AMAZING! You're the best and BBC should hire you to say the least! You make WAY better trailers then they do, that's probably why they don't like you! Anyway, beautiful as always!
mwsjunior 1 year ago 11
Nice to see another video from you. Very epic! :)
timegirl95 1 year ago 2
Always good to see something new, and I'm liking the improved pace of this trailer, awesome. :D
ITheDarkestOneI 1 year ago
Amazing job! Liked your re-cuts. Just like how a real trailer should look.
FairyKingdom86 1 year ago
Great, as always! :)
roxyqueen2 1 year ago
klklkl <3 it
Amzzz101 1 year ago
I've missed seeing your videos. They're always so crisp, clear, and amazingly well-done.
dbvixxen 1 year ago
Very Very Cool
ScareMeSexy71 1 year ago
You're back - and your brilliant! Love the editing and the suspense you bring to the clips... When do you start your job at BBC?...
Again - flippin' awesome mate!
scubadogg 1 year ago
YOu are amazing!!
Selana 1 year ago
awesome!
blue35pink 1 year ago
What can I say that hasn't already been said? You're the best, this is great and I can't wait to see this on Saturday. Ah...I see...Even though this has probably been said a thousand times already, it's still true, thanks. : )
LoriCiani 1 year ago 2
Ohmygoodness! This made me even more excited! :DD
HeartPhantom 1 year ago
Very nicely done Sarah!
PirateTillTheEnd 1 year ago
I absolutly anticipate the arrival of your videos Seduff. The editing, the genius, the one and the only! You take so much time with your videos and editing HD tv audio (im guessing that's how u do it) But loved it! Another splendid job! Amazing... I think i've run out of adjectives....
Well done :)
Dalekdom 1 year ago
Aww i've missed you! This is awesome! x
xXxXxcozzaxXxXx 1 year ago
sarah, you never cease to amaze me! you were just born for this sort of thing. :) what do you think of the new doctor? :D
tardis360 1 year ago
Your re-cuts are always better than the original! This one is no different. :)
TheOrangeDream 1 year ago
wow so cool! i cant wait 4 this episode 2moz!
sweetdream242424163 1 year ago
A-may-zing. I have been waiting for ages for you to upload something! Youtube has been so boring without you! :D
vivialyn14 1 year ago
another brill trailer from you seduff :)
stupidig 1 year ago
At last! I've been waiting so long for a new video from you! You never let me down and please bring us more in glorious HD!!
BleakDisc 1 year ago
very well done, seduff! I feel it gives a better vibe of the intensity of the upcoming episode. thumbs!
iMattCi89 1 year ago
Absolutely stunning work Seduff! Loved it to bits. Brilliant choice of music and great selection of clips! Can't wait for more videos based on the finale :)
vortexguyz934 1 year ago
Woah, jus-... woah, just... epic
Antworkk 1 year ago
epic epic EPIC, been a while but was worth the wait, now the question is what is the most feared being in the cosmos?
scottytheboy 1 year ago
This is better than the real BBC trailer
LilyCh23 1 year ago
Wow !!! looks so professional and so much better than the actual teaser, you're too good for them XD
Amazing job on that one !
misscynthia17 1 year ago
Why the hell are you so good? hahaha
This is better than the original.
I tried making one a couple of days ago and uploaded it, but mine is just a poor excuse compared to yours. This is fantastic so much more tension created and so epic.
Can't wait to see more from you soon hopefully
X
Bex19 1 year ago
Incredible trailer Seduff. The BBC needs to hire you, I for one will happily sign a petition to get you that job.
ThomasWadeFraser 1 year ago
@ThomasWadeFraser this is made by the BBC
mandawander 1 year ago
@mandawander
Ofcourse, but it was cleverly recut and editted by Seduff.
ThomasWadeFraser 1 year ago
I think that the doctor is in the pandorica
elmo1371 1 year ago
I have goosebumps! O_O :-D You rock!
EllenRebecca3 1 year ago
Great Work...!!!!
So what do you think is in the big blue box ??????
spaceman300 1 year ago
hese two episodes are huge, I think the only major monsters and villains from the last 47 years not to make an appearance in this are the master and the rani. Everything and everyone is in here. Fantastic
Barneystudioz 1 year ago
Great video,i cant wait for tomorrow's finale .
dwho19901 1 year ago
Oh wow, you did a video! That alone made me happy, then I watched it and got happier :)
"The most feared thing in the cosmos..." That's gotta be the Doctor, right? I actually can't wait til tomorrow.... :D
appleXinkling 1 year ago
Woooo! Although, I'm in America so I haven't even seen Cold Blood yet, but I tried to watch this without really taking in any possible spoilers and just admire the editing, which was amazing as always.
idefine777 1 year ago
LOVE IT :D
RBproductions10 1 year ago
Okay - how do you do it?
I was already crazily excited for this episode but now I can't wait! Oh wow, it looks so cool and exciting. I loved all of the audio you used, some I've never heard before.
I especially liked the use of "The Doctor in the TARDIS doesn't know" - because that phrase just fascinates me and freaks me out in equal measure.
Well done, genius.
1SHAZ1 1 year ago
Seduff great to have you back! Can't wait for this to be shown! I agree this IS better then the bbc's version! :)
doctorwhofreak4890 1 year ago
OMG!! ::squees!:: This is made of wonderfulness! I'm so glad you're back! Thanks for making my night :) Did you have a fabulous time in the UK?
propertyofranger 1 year ago
I like the lighting on bbc logo in bottom right at end
moriaty123 1 year ago
Woa. I liked your trailer better then the one done by BBC.
daevilfortuneteller 1 year ago
OOH, you got me shaking with excitement. I seriously cannot wait until Saturday and you increased it by 1000 percent ahah! :D Just amazing!
bohemianhysteria 1 year ago
You always do these so much better than the beeb. GREAT WORK!
JudyWasAPunk 1 year ago
I am so ready for this!! :O
And my mom made custard...all I need is FISH.
terror0earth 1 year ago
cool, can't wait for tomorrow night now! As always, exceptional work from Seduff!!
ChrisCreamUK 1 year ago
wowowowowowo!! 10/10 :DDD
CardClashersHub 1 year ago
Amazing trailer, as always!
CaptainAndyman 1 year ago
Ahahahaha, Omega anyone?
SilverAmphithere 1 year ago
Brilliant once again! I'm looking forward to more Series 5 vids!
mizzi1908 1 year ago
Another fantastic video! Well done!
antony492 1 year ago
You're back!
Let the royal rumble begin!
kurikuribebi 1 year ago
Amazing ^^ How do you get so damn good?
DW934 1 year ago
Nice!
Distinct lack of Cybermen though, any reason why?
Aquatics64 1 year ago
I always LOVE your work. Really. This was no exception. :)
jenskii 1 year ago
Makes me even MORE excited for this week's ep:D
gracefulangel47 1 year ago
To quote Captain Jack Harkness, 'Oh, I've missed this' XD
NaomiPhoenix 1 year ago
As per usual, lovely work! Can't wait to see what you do with all of series 5!
shadowoftime01 1 year ago
fantastical
TheFinalTimelord2 1 year ago
Ohhhh I've missed you! =]
The video is brilliant as always...you are crazy if you think that you could ever be a disappointment!!Cant wait for your next video!!!
lana118 1 year ago
very well done! whats the music?
browni 1 year ago 4
@browni Thanks! :) The music is Captivate by Brand X
seduff 1 year ago
WOW. Amazing Trailer Seduff - however I would never expect anything less from you! :)
sleepyhollowchrissy 1 year ago
Amazing! Seriously brilliant update to the original and makes me 10 times more excited for this weeks episode!
FacePimpd 1 year ago