Added: 6 years ago
From: hsjtree
Views: 1,513,953
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (617)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • oh nicky nicky nicky nickyyy nicky nicky nicky nicky nicky nicky nicky nicky nicky nickynickynickynickynickynicky­nickynickynickynickynickynicky­nickynickynicky NICKYYYYY! ii take one look at him and want to quote shakespeare?!

  • Westlife r the best forever

  • Duk Out Girl ! Nicky's Mine ;D

  • am i the only one who thinks "she ruined it"!!!!

  • who is she????? She don't deserve to be there

  • How dare you take the mic from my Shane like that!!!!!!!!!!!

  • We can do without the girl, leave the boys alone.

  • i wish it was only westlife and no girl

  • Omg me too hate this girl,would be better if she were not there!!

    Grrrrrr

  • Ai, que inveeeeeeeeeja!! Odeio ela!! - I envy her! I would be better dressed for it!!! rsrsrsr I wanna be her there!! I love them so much!!

  • This song was written in the 30s....great music is timeless :)

  • Westlife r much better than the girl

  • Westlife are amazing

    Love u boys forever

  • I still hate that Mark is gay. How the heck am I supposed to marry him now? Grrrrrrrr. T.T

  • Shane's voice suits this song very well,ahhh <3

  • can i marry her?

  • maoman...

  • I'm so disappointed when Mark admits that he is a gay... because i have a big crush on him since i was in college, i used to play and look at their pictures... most especially him....anyway i think the reason why mark staring at this girl,coz he said to himself, if were a girl i'm more prettier than you!!! lol! love u still Mark!

  • i really love you west life

  • Mark is cute ,but gay lol

    She awful and she has to shout to get her words out, not the sign of a good singer!

  • Mark is cute ,but gay lol

    

  • damn i hate this girl.huhh.

  • I'm jealous when Mark's part cause the way he looked tht girl makes me sooooo jealous!>,<

  • lol what's with all the jealousy? <3 WL foreverrr

  • Who's that girl?!

  • westlife can sing a lot better than her 

  • One girl wooed by Westlife and singing and dancing with them! What a lucky girl!

  • Love Westlife and she has a great voice...besides Westlife picked her to sing with them so i am sure they like her as well....

  • OMG mark is so sexy in the suit <3

  • i like mark voice

  • mark is gay i think his disgusted from her:P

  • OMG the beautiful song got murdered in this version

  • as much as i hate her for getting to be so close to them, i can't stop listening to this song. it's amazing. i love you, westlife <3

  • i love you Westlife

  • tone a little high for her, but sing well. clapping, is good for small people of culture. missing someone say: "shut up their asses, they're singing".

  • MARK IS SO HOT !! WOW !

  • just one word.....WOW!

  • ini featuring siapa nih?

  • OMG, I wish i am that lady and have a small dance with Shane!!! Jealous~~~ haha

  • Well look it up, or is it too much trouble? retard/ lol

  • Who is she actually????

  • @majorstrings Look it up u idiot,  A girl who got lucky and who sings well

  • this is supposed to be a sweet song! I agree, the girl screamed through it! I believe the guys sang very nicely though!

  • @maryannesteiner You can alaways find those guys here in the Philippines :)

  • i wish one day someone will sing this for me....someone i can be with ....hmmm i hate being single ....

  • Amazingly classic song. Westlife is awesome and truely will always be the best boy band.

    This song was performed amazingly. Shane voice is awesome.

  • Definitely not a clap song! lol!

  • nothing wrong with how this grl sang this song..their all great singers.

  • BRAVO BEAUTIFUL! WESTLIFE :))

  • Awsomly Beautiful

  • amazing

  • I'm 58 and the older I get the more I just like having fun with alll the imperfections

  • There is nothing wrong with her voice. she sang fine. L2 sing and then comment.

  • i hate the girl cause it's not me...hahaha...i dont like her..

  • @TheAngelheart03 neither do i :)

  • obviously , these people have no taste in msuic . you dont clap to this music , you dont scream , and stop with the fuckin pitch . for this type of music , the sounds comes effortless . if you have to try to make your voice sounds good , it's already bad .

  • i agree it not a clap song heheheheh :P

  • it is Fantastic

  • nakakaantok!

    

  • The female has intonation problems.....singing just under the note pitch at times.

  • The song is amazing, Westlife can sing anything and the audience will enjoy, God bless you guys and THANK YOU!

  • I don't blame her, anyone who's singing while looking into Mark's eyes will have a big silly grin on the face.

  • love it too

  • she can sing whats wrong with you all??i bet she sing better than you who criticising her!!!

  • Dont know who u r or when this was done but u r sensational..

  • FYI Her name is Joanne Hindley... for those who dont know!!

  • She's off? She cant sing? When you say that your not just critcising her your critcising Westlife's judging abilities cause they were the judges and were the ones who chose her! 1. She CAN sing 2. Maybe she is flouncing around/smiling/grinning/ been happy because she is singing with WESTLIFE! Dont fill me with Bull shit and say you wouldnt cause you would. 3. Stop been JEALOUS twats! cause lets face it thats why your all hating/criticising her! Just shut up!!

  • do I detect some jealousy here? I think they (including the girl) sing it perfectly :)

  • She won a competition to sing with them as far as I remember. And the audience is WAY OFF with their clapping, I'm surprised they didn't stop and tell them to shut the fuck up

  • WHO IS SHE? Shes abit off in places and I dont like how shes flouncing about with that stupid grin, but it dont sound that bad!

  • @h4nn4hstone I'd be grinning and bouncing myself if I was given a chance to sing with Westlife on stage!

  • why is it never normal ppl who get to meet guys like them

  • too jazzy on the girl's end

  • dumbass audiance

  • the best westlife any kind of song you know hmp all handsome esp. shane... yummy...

  • Who is she? she is an a terrible singer... westlife they are fantastic.. loved

  • she messed up badly! terrible.. but the boys did an amazing job!

  • i think she has a fantastic voice and goes really well singing together with westlife :)

  • she can sing just a bit OA

  • the chick can't sing to save her life

  • She ruined the song. The boys did the good job. Edit edit edit the song! Remove her voice and I'll be pleased.:)

  • HAHA poplova. You must have the brains of a fish. Her name is already on the comments, but because you obviously have difficulty in reading a thread... Its Joanne Hindley. You obviously don't know how to do any research, Oh and your UK based so please use English words. not silly made up ones from over the pond.... dumbass and feck indeed. You may have not insulted me directly, but my comments were made because morons like you are good at criticising people who make the effort , twat :)

  • This is great, it is  LIVE song so the audience may well clap. You thick twat

  • She ruined the song!!!! its boring!!! its a damn crap!!!

    

  • Whats wrong with the song?

    its simply PERFECT... They did a very great job revising it...

    I Love WESTLIFE so much, in fact Ill be watching them for the first time at Manila, Philippines on September...

    They are the best band ever!

    NEVER SEE WRONG WITH THE SONG.......

  • screwing up a good song should be punishable by spending an afternoon with me.

  • Her name is Joanne Hindley/Shaw and whoever says she can't sing must be tone deaf. You don't get a job singing in the west-end by not being able to sing or get through to x-factor auditions, all the way to Sharon's abode by not being able to sing. And for those who will say she didn't get any further, X-factor is a money making machine and the judges make business decisions on who the public will like and who will help them to win, not necessarily the better singers get through.

  • @mememe4141 Everyone can sing even the tone deaf but you wouldn't want to listen to them. I googled to ensure I don't go where she's singing by mistake but unsuccessfully. The X-Factor judges are looking for a particular type of person they think will make it worthwhile financially - they're not singing experts. As your friend didn't get through they got that wrong but how you can think of her as one of the better singers I'll never know. Thank goodness I missed that series - she's dreadful.

  • @jude4jazz I never said SHE was the better singer, i'm generalising that it is a tv show about making money and who's face fits, not just about the best singer winning. If you think that Chico was a better singer than her who she got voted out for, i suggest you wash those ears out lol, like i said it's all about the money and who the judges think will get them a win. Have you seen some of the trash that have made it through to the live finals.

  • She's done ok for herself. She's appeared in the West-End, singing believe it or not. Gary Barlow of Take That has nothing better to do but waste his time recording duet's with her, oh and i know she does a lot of session singing. Not bad for someone you think is dreadful, eh? Now i can't sing to save my life and i'm no music mogul, but i don't think you get this far in the music industry being shite do you???? Your entitled to your opinion like everyone else on here so type away!!!!!

  • She totally mess up the song

  • this is worse than karoeke

  • Who is that girl??

  • Love it. Whats wrong with you all?

  • who the feck is this nobody who's performing with westlife?

  • @poplova she is better than you!!! she has a great voice, looks good and its live! Get real you thick cunt

  • @lordcurzon1 how about cutting down on the abuse. i'm not exactly insulting u am i? PLUS, u still haven't answered the question. so who's the thick cunt now dumbass

  • What the fuck is this? A gang bang?

  • Hayley Westenra, belissima!

  • I love Mark

  • @tracey65 I love Shane

  • wow really i think the key got her into that high note...had no choice...pulled it off ok i think

  • whos she?

  • who is that girl?? :/ man i think my eardrums popped with her singing

  • Who's the girl? Her voice is amazing.

  • i like it 

  • gsnda ng song

  • she is terrible

  • i love it

    

  • She sings horrible. She cannot sing well and is out of tune during the harmony at 2:06. Westlife did well, as always, and Mark's voice is the best.

  • she sings????????????? TAKE HER OUT!!!

  • this song is not a clapping song -.- and I don't like the way she sings.

  • @delilahdelacroix I agree completely. Rock from Montreal.

  • I agree that it's not a clapping song but the way she sings is okay. She sang it perfectly during her solo part. I just think their voices just didn't mesh well. :|

  • @delilahdelacroix You must be a single minded retard, she does a great job. Hoiw would you be singing with westlife? A pile of shit I would guess, she was brilliant.

  • @lordcurzon1 First of all do not insult me because I haven't insulted anyone okay? I just said I (as in me not in any other's opinion) I don't like the way she sings you like it then good I respect your opinion. Also I said about the audience this song is not a clapping son. So you don't like westlife that's your problem why are you watching a westlife video if you don't like them huh?

  • @delilahdelacroix Agree she is terrible and this audience clapping is garbage the orchestration is great. but the singing stinks and the clapping is in appropriate. you are correct delilahdelacroix i hate this trash more than you do. ROGHARM waiting for nasty e-mails. i will reply.

  • @rogharm I don't hate her. Hate is a strong word. Probably she sings great in other songs but in this for me I just don't like her.

  • westlife has brought her in to screw up that song !!!

  • ask her to go away !!!

  • Wow this is crap, check out Frank singing this.

  • @zensurfer7

    You know what, I'm sick and tired of people praising Westlife's swing covers it pisses me off, I completely agree with you man. No one sang the way Frank did, the only two singers who come close to the crooners of the past (Sinatra/Bennett/Torme/Nat-kin­g/Darin etc) in terms of the quality of voice and pronounciation/actual technique are guys like Michael Buble and Harry Connick Jr. There guys are medicore, their voices are tin-like. Robbie Williams also murdered this music.

  • shes got wondeful voice and looks.... westlife is only fame... theyre really famous by now.... 

  • had our first dance to this at our wedding

  • das mädel is ja schlimm :/

  • the intro is actually composed by Alan Silvestri, theme song to Steve Martin's, "Father of the Bride". This is still a great rendition and post, however, even if you found a girl with a great range, it would still sound out of place. Joanne's a pretty young girl with a future ahead of her but its impossible to pull this one off smoothly, given the logistics of the arrangement.

  • @gmhmillenio; You are absolutely right ,being a pianist Jerome Kern composed this in Eb, an easy key for males to sing to, including himself. He wrote it with the intention of sounding light and listful.Now if you were to incorporate a female into the mix, they sure as hell won't modulate into a different key tp accomodate her and throw the guys off. She has no choice but to cover it an octave higher and when 3:25 rolls around, it's too severe and it becomes a trainwreck, which occurs twice.

  • 65 people are freaks and they dont no what ther talkin about

  • they have the best boy band looks...soft, sensual , and blonde!!! much easier on the eyes .. than nsync , and bsb.......

  • considering how nervous she must have been she did ok. Give the girl a break.

  • The girl singing with westlife was chosen from several girls from the audience,and westlife had to pick the one they thought was best,the girl is not a professional singer,her wish was to sing with them for this one song,it was during xfactor,hope this is helpful.

  • nothing wrong at 3.25 it's pretty good ?

  • @imatildathe girl singing with westlife was chosen from several girls from the audience and westlife had to pick the one they thought was best,,the girl is not a professional singer,her wish was was to sing with them for this song,think this was during xfactor,hope this helps.xx.

  • this song would be better dedicated to mariah carey...

  • ahh who is she?

  • JUST THE WAAAAAAAAAAAAAY YOU LOOOK TOOONIGHT

    this song makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside

  • she ugly:{ :{

  • Let's appreciate in whatever way possible a talent that is expressed in a sincere & meaningful manner. It's a joyful one to see that touches hearts to those who appreciates music....A way of expressing life at it's best!

  • great duet...lovely voices..

  • wow .. a flirty move to shane !!!!!

  • this is a good version too. but to some haters out there, the original will always be the best.

  • wahh`'`!

  • Good song!!! I <3 Westlife! :)

  • all of u saying she f***ed it up clearly don't have an ear for music!

  • she's not a bad singer.. I've never heard of her but she's not a bad singer lol

  • @jenniferlm21 she is not a singer, they guys made an audition for their fans and and she got selected to sing with them =)

  • WHO IS SHE?????????????????????????

  • that girl is sucked!

  • Listen to Chad and Jeremy,s version

  • love the rod stewart version of this song, this chic spoils it.... plus, why is the audience clapping along? Suppose this is what you get when you mix a boyband with a different genre of music

  • The Chick Scares me...She Scare anyone else? I mean Wow...Who put her up to this?

  • i really miss the old days when those boy bands harmonize us people!!

    yeah love boy bands

  • i still think michael buble's one is better

  • who is she???

  • as if you do just clap to this song...

  • @MaryWalshy we were told to x

  • this song didnt not suite her at all 1:37 the guy is like laughing!

  • @lovetaylorlautner100 how can u say guuy? That's Shane Filan from Westlife! The greatest boyband! He is smiling in agreement , in amazement.

  • @TheThatgirl3 what are you talking about?

  • @lovetaylorlautner100 well, u said he was laughing because he didnt like her..not true.

  • great song . sung well by them all.. her voice is very good..and of course Westlife is the best

  • great song . sung well by them all.. her voice is very good..

  • go go go shane 'still i really really like you're voice since the first time i heard it...........

  • i love u mark ur the best in all go go

  • I`m so happy the bring our old goodies back so our young ones will hopefully pay attention:-))) Love it!!<3

  • Beyond awful! A great song murdered.

  • best~~~

  • She got laid that night for Fivesome.

  • she fucked it up, mostly in the beginning, and at 3:25 (horrid), this song doesnt need that high note/yell of hers the boys are good enough

  • @gmhmilenio well Shane seemed pretty blown away by her voice :P

  • @gmhmilenio dont be stupid... shes just trying to show her voice.. shes got powerful and good voice.... she had no other option.. her voice is 100% better than any of those of westlife...

  • @gmhmilenio dont be stupid... shes just trying to show her voice.. shes got powerful and good voice.... she had no other option.. her voice is 100% better than any of those of westlife... besides it was a GOOD HIGH NOTE... you envious and bad bad bad critic... jajajaj... youre misled....

  • Comment removed

  • @gmhmilenio WHat a dick head, you try singing this live.... total twat

  • @MrBOBBY0O6 what are you saying worst ? no one sing ? if you dont have something good to say just keep it. oh boy , maybe you should do some research to know who is the group you're talking about. you'll be the one who is embarased.

  • Men the worst group ive ever heard are this group hell?cuz their just bad no one sing in this group..the most embarrasing group its nt even funny

  • Who's the babe?