Every lineage's mook yan jong ling baat has some variations in the sequence of the techniques.Great Grandmaster Yip Man taught each student differently, according to their ability to understand the Wing Chun system.
I only know a little of wing chun, and of the little, there's a lot I like about it, but what I don't like is working with stationary arms to mimic a block. I'd much rather use arms that come out and return at real human speeds, and have them come out at random with no telegraph.
@rbt4rbt I rarely reply to comments, assuming viewers of this clip are familiar with Wing Chun. However many comments appear not made by people knowing enough Wing Chun. That's the reason of this reply:
Wing Chun is a comprehensive martial art training system, if not complete. Skills have to be built or trained systematically with patience by different methods.
1. Three forms for basic concept. Namely, "Siu Lim Tao" for fundamental concept, hand movements and internal strength, where the later is the most important; "Chum Kiu" for whole body force generation, linear and circular; "Biu Jee" for applying speed.
2. Wooden Dummy: applying combined movements and concepts with static reference, which is the non-moving dummy.
@xrl2008 Thank you for your patience with me. My admitted ignorance of stationary arms comes from me wanting challenging arms punched at me but were also safe. That is why I invented robot arms that do just that. I highly agree with you that having a block and counter strike sequence already practiced as a reflex, will be much faster in real life. You're a real gentleman having taken the time to help someone who should have studied wing chun more before opening my mouth. I will look into more.
@rbt4rbt I had the idea of a "perfect robot arm" when I was green in WC. But now I understand that arms are only of tactical use in real Kung Fu fighting. The real and true power comes from the maximum use of your whole body mass and reaction, which is, the strategical and decisive power of WC and KF in general.
For safety issue, find a good Sifu and friendly training partner(s). I believe most WC schools are friendly.
@xrl2008 No doubt power comes from the body, not just the arms. I've watched several videos on Sifu "real speed" training. So many were being "blocked" by punches that were not even going to reach anyway, or the telegraph is so obvious. For instance, yesterday my friend who is a boxing trainer was over and he said he can punch simultaneously as the other person started the punch. I said if that were true, it was ONLY because the other person gave a tel, otherwise it would be impossible or luck.
@Marriagison Not really. You can see everything the CGI person does so there for NOT useless. It would be useless if you couldn't see what the person was doing which isn't the case here.
you cant say this is modified there is noch orignal ving tsun there are just different styles some are good many are bad
DerLplayer 1 month ago
is this the style master ip man used? Just curious.
xxxLETSGOBANGxxx 1 month ago
Every lineage's mook yan jong ling baat has some variations in the sequence of the techniques.Great Grandmaster Yip Man taught each student differently, according to their ability to understand the Wing Chun system.
gaijinshinobi2241 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you can also see my wooden dummy 7 day's work,cost around 60 $ ;-)
01sidiropoulos 3 months ago
I only know a little of wing chun, and of the little, there's a lot I like about it, but what I don't like is working with stationary arms to mimic a block. I'd much rather use arms that come out and return at real human speeds, and have them come out at random with no telegraph.
rbt4rbt 4 months ago
@rbt4rbt I rarely reply to comments, assuming viewers of this clip are familiar with Wing Chun. However many comments appear not made by people knowing enough Wing Chun. That's the reason of this reply:
Wing Chun is a comprehensive martial art training system, if not complete. Skills have to be built or trained systematically with patience by different methods.
xrl2008 4 months ago
The methods or stages are:
1. Three forms for basic concept. Namely, "Siu Lim Tao" for fundamental concept, hand movements and internal strength, where the later is the most important; "Chum Kiu" for whole body force generation, linear and circular; "Biu Jee" for applying speed.
2. Wooden Dummy: applying combined movements and concepts with static reference, which is the non-moving dummy.
xrl2008 4 months ago
3. Chi Sao: training of usable actions and reactions with human training partners in highly real-life but yet safe fighting situation.
The "arms" you want are found in stage 3. :)
xrl2008 4 months ago
@xrl2008 Thank you for your patience with me. My admitted ignorance of stationary arms comes from me wanting challenging arms punched at me but were also safe. That is why I invented robot arms that do just that. I highly agree with you that having a block and counter strike sequence already practiced as a reflex, will be much faster in real life. You're a real gentleman having taken the time to help someone who should have studied wing chun more before opening my mouth. I will look into more.
rbt4rbt 4 months ago
@rbt4rbt I had the idea of a "perfect robot arm" when I was green in WC. But now I understand that arms are only of tactical use in real Kung Fu fighting. The real and true power comes from the maximum use of your whole body mass and reaction, which is, the strategical and decisive power of WC and KF in general.
For safety issue, find a good Sifu and friendly training partner(s). I believe most WC schools are friendly.
Glad to share.
xrl2008 4 months ago
@xrl2008 No doubt power comes from the body, not just the arms. I've watched several videos on Sifu "real speed" training. So many were being "blocked" by punches that were not even going to reach anyway, or the telegraph is so obvious. For instance, yesterday my friend who is a boxing trainer was over and he said he can punch simultaneously as the other person started the punch. I said if that were true, it was ONLY because the other person gave a tel, otherwise it would be impossible or luck.
rbt4rbt 4 months ago
Comment removed
legroulx1 5 months ago
you use endorphin
fandrewrosa 5 months ago
lol at trad and mod wing chun , very nice have you got the other sections please ?
badboybrendan 5 months ago in playlist More videos from xrl2008 2
If you are interested in purchasing your own Wing Chun Wooden dummy please visit shaolinhouse for the finest quality hand made wooden dummys.
ShaolinHouse 6 months ago
this guy is realy good
ommerl 7 months ago
Very good
vingtsun90 10 months ago
Dtudf,
sweepermonk 10 months ago
gta gung fu B-)
three0234 11 months ago
so this is the true dummy form? wow thanks man really nice:P so much gonna train on this
Alesandros356 1 year ago
useless camera angle
Marriagison 1 year ago
@Marriagison no becouse he does the same thing on bouth sides of the dummy...pay attention
Alesandros356 1 year ago
@Alesandros356
I dont need to pay attention I know the form and therefore know it repeats on both sides and this is still a useless camera angle.
Marriagison 1 year ago
@Marriagison ok mr. but if you do know it, then you do you come here and rage instead of go and watching somthing you dont know...?
Alesandros356 1 year ago
@Marriagison Not really. You can see everything the CGI person does so there for NOT useless. It would be useless if you couldn't see what the person was doing which isn't the case here.
ProTuner06 11 months ago
this is not the Taditional Wing Chun,this is the Modified Wing Chun
Krallify 1 year ago 8
@Krallify The "tradition" of Wing Chun is to evolve without sticking to a fixed way.
xrl2008 4 months ago 20
@xrl2008 That sounds kind of like a copp out for not knowing why the differences are there..
Ankoku15 2 days ago
Great! You should take advantage of the same 3d animation to create videos of it from other angles. Thanks!
crisbucek2 1 year ago
Great Vid. Clear and well demonstrated. Some people are belly aching ! Cant believe some people. Well done xrl2008
somersetkravmaga 1 year ago
haha...cool!
Chinesehero 1 year ago
nice vid but i cannot find the section 2....
razlee220875 1 year ago
thank you for the animated video will you be doing more? i would really love to see more of this
fightingfijian 1 year ago
vielen Dank...
Haigoers 2 years ago
nice animation, though this is not traditional wing chun performed, make one with the traditional dummy sets in action!
chrismist 2 years ago
very nice thanks for posting! cant wait for more!
xxdjcharlierockxx 2 years ago
GENIUS! Unbelivable work!
ffoecaf2006 2 years ago
awesome! do more! plz!
FionnMcc 2 years ago
ha, motionbuider with mocap data
kwang0429 2 years ago
nice but unless this is totally cgi - shouldn't the practitioner get a credit in all fairness and for posterity? (S)he is acting as a teacher......
Skellyman99 2 years ago 4
The real man behind is Sifu Donald Mak who has over 30 years of teaching experience.
xrl2008 2 years ago 10
wih thanks for the response. very nicely done.
Skellyman99 2 years ago
@xrl2008 I personally beleive it is Grandmaster Cheung direct student of Ip Man, who is or should be the real deal
sifuminus720 1 month ago
nice.
KOKUJINCHAN 2 years ago
Sweet.
Having some friends who are into 3D animation I do know that this represents a lot of work.
So double five points, one for the good wooden dummey form, and then for the work to make it an animated model.
I guess on your workstation you can rotate the mocie and look at it from any angel.
If you could motion capture someone doing his form, you coukd actually make a computer_sifu who corrects your form.
Grat work
silk
;-))
blacksilkblacksilk 2 years ago
amazing skills you have!!
Would be great if you could post a Siu Lim Tao, like Ip Man.
skoami 2 years ago