Pussycat Dolls - Big Spender

[StExAholic]

WHAT. A. FAIL. O.o

[650michelle]

I don't why y'all keep saying that Nicole would have sang it better if in my opinion it would have been the same thing because either way they both joined why after plus u gotta admit melody has a stronger voice only problem is that she doesn't know how to control it

[pistolgeneration]

Sugar Motta did it better.

[BabyDrivesMeCrazy1]

I think she was the winner of a tv show a few years ago to become a Doll.

[xxPrincess2109xx]

totally covered from christina aguilera ! big dislike nobody can cover this lady !

[2123003291]

it was fine for her voice

[kyoyanmori]

0.0.... i dont think this is the song for her... etter leave this to nicole...that was not a feast for my ears.....ore like what the fuck was THAT!?... Why wasnt Nicole singing???!!

[crimsonhawk2010]

EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

[tenthmuse10]

now i understand why the other girls aren't usually allowed to sing anything other than back up to Nicole.

[vvpp14]

What the hell? she totally runnied the song. if nicole sang this song it would be hit!? she thinks she in tune.... gosh... total fail!

[asenboi]

What the fuck is this???

[cutiemama135]

one question...why?

[volleyrocker1]

This is comically horrid.

Strippers like this ruin wonderful musicals for me.

[salem8908]

why isn't Nicole singing!!!!!!???? : (

[AcaciaRaff]

If you look at the original done in Sweet Charity the dance and the meanings behind the dance are like a business transaction which is realistic and is way sexier than a bunch of hos stripping

[Belimeza]

Completely destroyed the song if you ask me.

[crazypianolady]

Oh dear...Not good. Overkill much?

[arriyonna1]

heyyy theres nicole at 1:37.!!!

[dizzyhf]

Comparing to watch?v=wyxtqXqbE_8 this was much more pleasant to my eyes, but REALLY awful to my ears.

[kevn101]

now i know why Nicole was lead.. lol that wasn't too good to be honest... and now i understand why Melody was so pissed lmao

[7TheMamiller]

Oh my.....*eye twitch*

[babyir0ck]

this was horrible. there voice is not good w/this songg .

[lovelyladyJstar]

this was their 1st perfermance as a singed group they talk about it in their episode of mtvs the diary of

[ianvon]

why did they even think of letting her sing and made robin and nicole as backups...geeezzz

[lizzqoesRAWRx3]

is it weird that i actually like this?

even though it was not the best performance, its actually refreshing to see someone else sing insted of nicole, even though i love nicole

[NuNi2693]

This is Melody Thornton and that doll owned it!

[anderzxx]

LMAO now i know why nicole sings all the songs

[Ivanildo16]

her voice looks like's christina aguilera's

[lovelyladyJstar]

@Ivanildo16 mel is pratically the black version of xtina except she is unfournately less famous 

[SilentFaces]

Im sorry i love the pussycat dolls but the girl they chose cannot sing that song. Period!

[lovelyladyJstar]

@SilentFaces um r u tone def melody is a great singer she does all the add libs on songs ones like buttons or i dont need a man if she wasnt good they wouldnt have picked her

[JackoJono]

@lovelyladyJstar .....ad libs don't make someone a good singer.. they have to be able to hold pitch and have good intonation (which she doesn't). ad libs are mainly vibrato, and so many amazing singers rarely even use vibrato- it doesn't define them as a songer.

[HKsWorld]

Lol and everyone is mad about Nicole always singing lead and that melody should sing lead more. Nicole is the only one that really can sing well (and carmit but she is gone), so stop whining about Nicole being the lead singer, she is the only one that can handle that spot

[HDan182]

WOW, someone other than Nicole singing for a change :\

[JeeBeee1000]

@HDan182 and now we know why Nicole is the one usually singing :)

[carmlog47]

Melody just doesn't know how to control her voice- at all. she just opens up and lets it out.

[danu289422]

i didnt like the voice of that gurl

[kitkatkayls]

WowSHITT

[nctr90]

MAN THIS SUCKS BALLS !!!

[datwhiitegurl]

2:03 looks like she's gotta take a dump.

[datwhiitegurl]

who is nicole scherzinger?

[2010MissCooper]

@datwhiitegurl The Lead .. amaZing singer ... Listen to

Nicole Scherzinger - I'll be your love

[binji01]

who are the people in the end?

[shane69999]

she is awful .... sings off key

i wont be going to see the PCD now... low assed quality. i bet she thinks she's world class too

[twinksidekick]

terrible!

[xTelha]

Melody, give Nicole her mic back, u cant sing darling.

[CodeXero]

@xTelha lol Amen

[2010MissCooper]

@xTelha Dont we all agree ... their is no comparison of Melody & Shirly, She sounds so week ... Listen to this though!

Nicole Scherzinger - I'll be your love

[Nicksims3]

OMG Melody voice is horrible

da nojo de ouvir

[CaptainVideo15]

i think this was their first performance...right?

Cuz Kimberly said that their first lead singer was Melody and their first live performance as a music group was on MTV singapore...

[imsopimp13]

no thats kaya jones,carmit nicole ashley and kim and jessica and melody singubg

[Smaug0z]

horrible.. esto sacan al aire? fuera de joda, ahora cualquiera se deja garchar y la sacan en tv... espantoso

[Rubyiio]

how come one melody is singign and two y are therer soo many?

[thegrammarfairy]

oh thank GOODNESS she got back on the pitch 1:17

[LadyMorana]

hahhahaahhaha, true :)))

[ThePinkOracle]

Actually Mel was added to the group before Nicole. But they werent sure she would be lead they just knew they wanted her vocals in the group. Yep Robin performs here too.

[dihpcd]

Lindaaa!!!!!

[djuwell]

nicole was as a back dancer

[daviieejay]

Yeah she must have been nervous. Plus she was only like 18 or 19 when she sang this. I still love her =)

[LatinaPCD]

Oh people please!it was melodys 1st time doing a live performance is MTV PEOPLE!!we all know she has improved so much since 2004!yes her voice is shaky but i love her!

[jackiechristine89]

started off really rough but at least she got better

[MellyTV]

where is nicole??

[estela007]

@MellyTV nicole is here too, but she only dance this time

[amycatcharlie]

I love Melody, but it is very clear why she was not picked to be lead. I don't think I would love PCD as much if Nicole wasn't lead....her voice is just much more attracting.

[DanielFuscoMusic]

I went to three Pussycat Dolls tour concerts they were AMAZING BUT???? I did notice that melody is the one who has to try the hardest in the group on songs were she sings the chorus with Nicole or sings a solo aometimes, BUT??? at the same time Nicole just kinda sways and walks most of the time while singing and since Melody isn't lead she dances hard just like the other three girls in back do and at the same time she has to sing, she is the one who has to try the most and yes she succeeds!

[divadancerw]

wow im doing a solo to this song & this girl sucksss

[iwilsing4u]

this was to low for her

[NewYorkDoll2]

who's the girl at 2:18?

it looks like michelle branch,,but then again i don't think so..

if so, it'd be so cool cuz i luv pcd(nicole) and also michelle

[jojomamaNZ2468]

OMG for once Nicole sat back and let Melody have some spotlight. Shes probably just nervous. I have seen her perform this song live and she was BEYOND AMAZING!!

Ya can judge all ya want on video but when you hear her sing in person you just get mesmerized by her talent

[jojomamaNZ2468]

OMG for once Nicole sat back and let Melody have some spotlight. Shes probably just nervous. I have seen her perform this song live and she was BEYOND AMAZING!!

Search on youtube : Big Spender - live - Auckland New Zealand. Ya can judge all ya want on video but when you hear her sing in person you just get mesmerized by her talent

[al3j00]

I love when Mel sing this song...

;)

[touretteslover]

her singing sucks...its awful

[thrillkillkitten]

good god what a complete trainwreck!

shit singer, shit choreography--and they all look like trannies!!!

[LDTJ16]

O.k. first of all this was when the Pussycat Dolls were barely becoming a singing group. Melody was still young she was the "baby doll" and she was nervous. She is awesome regardless of what anybody says! She could have easily been lead. For proof of her vocal ability watch the following video: The Pussycat Dolls - Big Spender live @ Heineken Music Hall in Amsterdam 9 February

[314679]

now, Melody should be lead singer because as she has progressed since this performance, she has improved dramatically and she is the current best singer in the band and better than Nicole Scherzinger live, so they should consider that!!

[halakhalife]

i think she sounds here

[Outsiderira]

the worst performance of big spender I've seen.

[iwilsing4u]

melody's comfort is in the high range she not a low range singer but high is better en sexier anyway melody still owns nicoles ass

[atagirlhiya]

this wuznt that good on the vocals part...and she usually does really good

[eduard4191]

Melody is awfull and dosnt know dance....She dont desearve be call a Pussycat Dolls..

[jant0]

I love u melody!

u r great!!!!!!!

:D

[johnghetto19]

Lol This was definitely not melody's best performance, her voice wasn't on key with the song at all. This is nothing a few vocal lessons cant fix though.

[Radael08]

melody perfect in the performace

[SweetShakiraL]

well i think Melody was the only 1 who could sing this song nice, i mean if nicole sang it then it would sound really wierd, its just not nicole's song:P

[xkris10x33]

wow she deffinately shouldnt have even tried to sing this song... she butchered it

[PussyCatDomination]

it was theyre very first live act....so it normal that melody doesnt sounds that good!!!!!

[SweetShakiraL]

:O thats melody!!

[Brittow]

who cares about the singing

[swaggHEAD]

first of all Melody wasn't pick to be lead. She was pick to add vocal strength to the group after Robin picked Nic to be lead.

[xoXthewaywewere]

is robin antin there

[WCotteG]

melody is better singer than nicole, this is just not a song for her.. and if u notice melody sounds very different in others songs like beep, bite the dust or takin over the world, songs in which melody sounds great!

[ipodfreak24]

that is a disgrace to the show....this shouldnt have happened

[DarkSiteOfAngel]

i think that was amazing..not her best....but she just started here...soo....

[moochogastrue]

i can see why nichole is the lead singer...

[fofob]

omg was that meldoy in the beginning? wtf she is usually so good...

[oftaja]

this would have bin awesome if they had time to prepare them selves:/

[bwaybabex2x]

... and this is why pussycat dolls and broadway do not mix. horrible.

[GodDamIt06]

not one of melody's best..but i've seen her live in vegas...and she has an amazing voice. this video didn't prove that. too bad =(

[Riceball103]

looks like they are in asia, like hk or sth ^^

[japanimechick]

the lead singer can't really sing

[nsdotnet]

No, that's not Asia. This performance is from 2004. That's Melody singing lead.

[ANGELLOZANOMYLOVE]

wow this performances sucked i think it would of been better with Nicole and by the way u could hear her in the back up voice and she looked fine

[caterpillar1989]

tnk god nicole was lead...

[spikydoudou89]

Pour une fois que nicole est dériére ... I love Melody!!!

[GeorgieBabe26]

Aw they only been together for a week by this performance (:

[PlayaHalfLong]

Hahaha, I thought so too! I so love their burlesque style, without it getting really nasty like exposing stuff. This is classic stuff, I love them!

I really think this is Melody's worst performance ever. But the crowd looks really big and she seemed really nervous. Can't wait for them to perform this kind of Burlesque style again! Will they do it again?

[Deadhuntah]

The first singing, fucking lame, my fucking dog would do it better, she sounds like a men, no normal sound at all

[ConnorMT082492]

I think Melody was a bit insecure!

[DominicanBlackBoi]

she was nervous u can tell it in her voice thats why she sound so shaky

[bella1281]

um... that girl can't sing for shit.

[jockyoudior]

oh my god! never seen a so bad performance before.. weird!

[nsdotnet]

This performance was really last minute. They barely had time to pick a song and rehearse.

[legend5790]

@nsdotnet Im sorry no matter if it was last minute or not they should of choosen somebody that can give this song some justice mind u im a fan od the dolls but this was just awful

[KleinerTomii]

@jockyoudior oh my god, u've seen just a few ones. This one is one of the better things. PCD is always one of the girl groups with permanent performances, it's always good, there a worse ones.

[leomed315]

@jockyoudior i HATE when they make melody sing. esp for the Burlesque pieces. she doesn't have a classic enough voice for it! she sounds so stupid! ugh

[TatianaOnegina]

malody did very well but i think she was very nervous to perform for such a big audience, she never was a lead singer as i remember

[raisaoc]

uma pergunta nessa apresentação estao todas Dolls?

[juandamylee12]

Pelo que conta, estão todas sim.

[DominicanBlackBoi]

this wasnt melody worst performace but it was good to see nicole in the background

[DominicanBlackBoi]

wow i was lookin for this thx so much

[andrewgaonawashere]

wow...even tho melody sucked in this performance, it was refreshing to see nicole do sum backround time

[britishxxx]

better without nicole :]

[NewYorkDoll2]

not at all

[dirrtyboy9]

in this performance... are all the actual PCD includin CArmit?

[xmenVicente]

nice...who were those two who apeared at last

[GeNubian]

cool