The Brothers Karamazov (1969) (English subtitles). Part 1/3 (1/8).

[JayGatsbyOdysseus]

My favortrite book. I read the PEN award translation, circa '03. It is interesting that in this movie, Ivan's famous quote is translated as, "If there is no immortality, there is no virture." Often, it is quoted in the media as, "If there is no God, everything is permitted."

[warandcheese]

he was truly a great peruvian writer....

[Kazanskoe57]

Thank you RussoTuristo for putting it up here for everyone to watch & admire. :)

This film is quite something, I always enjoy it even though I've seen it like a hundred of times already. I can never read Dostoevski, it's too hard for me but I do love the movies.

I don't agree that the actors aren't right, they are... they're brilliant Russian actors & they're doing their job awesomely in this film, I especially like Lionella Pyryeva that played Grushenka,.. enchanting... all of it. Thumbs up!

[escobari]

you bernard!

[zytigon]

In the 'The reason driven life ' p158, Robert M. Price writes about 'The parable of the Grand Inquisitor' in Brothers Karamazov where Ivan explains to his brother Alyosha why he wants no more to do with the church. Even though it offers a ticket to salvation, Ivan cannot in good conscience accept it , because it will require his complicity in God's guilt. He will have to stop being indignant that "God" allows the terrible suffering of innocent children & make excuses for "God's" inaction etc

[mechwarreir2]

I LOVE YOU!!! will you marry me? Just kidding, but seriously I have a test on the entire 980 page book. I read the book but the book is confusing so I need the movie X).

[10WiseVirgins]

GENIUS MOVIE ever created by men!

You know DOSTOEVSKI- you know how to think.

"It is Dostoevski who taught me to think"

Einstein

[Hollywood1914]

Please, tell me where you downloaded it, please, because I already tried downloading this film with a torrent file but the torrent didn't the hole movie. So, please, tell me, and I will be very grateful with you.

[PyccoTypucmo]

@Hollywood1914

I've downloaded the video (good quality avi-files) from multiki(dot)arjlover(dot)net.

The English subtitles you can find on opensubtitles(dot)org. I've uploaded them there. ;-)

[Hollywood1914]

@PyccoTypucmo

Thank you.

[SrvntofGodJeremiah]

Love how it has 33 likes right now.. no one else like it! :)

[thejokersharleyquinn]

It's kinda distracting me that Ivan looks like Renfield in Bram Stoker's Dracula and Alyosha looks like a skinny version of The Albino in The Princess Bride. Lol. Not at all how I pictured them. =/ But I'm sure this movie will be awesome like the book and I will get over it.

[jagofar]

@thejokersharleyquinn Ivan should be 23, and Alosja should be quite handsome: it's just an epic fail.

I Hate it ...

[ThatGuyWhoSucksBoobz]

can anyone tell me which part is the one where Ivan tells the story of "the grand inquisitor" ?

[MrColclough90]

@ThatGuyWhoSucksBoobz It is not told in this movie. But the story by Ivan about the boy and the general with his hounds is told.

[sbalogh8]

One million thanks : )) This is Beautiful!!!!!

I send a big hug from Hungary : ))

[oipolloi1]

Спасибо! Thank you so much for uploading!

[PyccoTypucmo]

@oipolloi1

Don't mention it. ;)

[anusrodentum19]

Respect from Ireland. Spaciba!!!!!

[InsaneGnomeGirl]

YESSSSSSS! Subtitles! 8D This is awesome. My mental images of Dmitry and Ivan are a lot different but other than that it's pretty much spot on with the actors...

[oipolloi1]

@InsaneGnomeGirl

Agreed, I imagined both of them as looking a lot younger and 'adolescent' if that makes sense...

[TheSageAndTheMouse]

Through my influence I've been able to convert completely ignorant persons into thinkers, readers and philosophers. This is not a difficult task. If one garners great enthusiasm for things of worth, works of passion that infinitely out-span the ephemeral plastic repetitions we everyday encounter, if one is likewise able to have a keen eye that is trained for that which is everlasting, perdurable and of great worth, others will effortlessly follow suit, adopt a love of art, literature, thought!!

[Jitpring]

Hey, thanks a lot for uploading this! 

[ShadowBlah2]

Oh boy! Good deal having this here. I'd been looking for this. Thanks.

[StravMishkin2]

Dear friend! You don't need to see Dostojevsky through the glasses of Nietzsche;

such unique genies have another way and level of perception of each other than ours.

Dostojevsky is more than a pure thinker, writer, philosoph and psychologist; he has lived his own death and that's why can explain a lot of mysteries of human life.

He is a mystic full of original affective ideas and revelations. Freud has already discovered the hidden connection between Aeschulus-Shakespeare-Dostojev­sky.

[StravMishkin2]

Dear Russo Turismo! Mnoga Spasiba! It's a great achievement of Russian art film. The scenario is marvelously extracted from the book, Fyodor Pavlovich and Ivan are really spectacular; but the music is a little bit 'lighter' for such a unique masterwork, it had to be more expressive, dramatic and mystic, something in Mussorsgky spirit to penetrate to mysterious and universal essence of Dostoyevsky's philosophy. Please, can you download the rest of this film? Thanks a lot for your effort!

[1488bill]

@StravMishkin2 This version looks better than the one with Yul Brenner about the same time. The scenery and etiquette look naturally Russian. Do you know if this one follows the book a little more faithfully ? I never thought F.D. was a great thinker but a great writer-especially 'Notes from the Underground'. Like Pascal,he couldn't get past the fundamentalist dogma.A Nietzsche,a Goethe is a thousand times more subtle and penetrating.But Nietzsche admired this man...so I try to wrestle with FD

[sicknessguitar87]

THANK YOU!!! THANK YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!

[PyccoTypucmo]

@sicknessguitar87

Don't mention it. Dooooooo not meeeeeeeention it. :-)))))))