for being a really sad day she pulled it off ok...however i remember on an interview she had a long time ago she said that singing is always an emotional experience for her...so its like in this case she should have went all out with her voice. But i'm not one to judge.
Why do you all complaining that she sucked? I wouldn't have sing it better if I was in a moment like this. Of course she was sad and couldn't hold her emotions back. I know she wasn't as strong as she use to be, but this was a very emotional moment. I really think she was great. ♥
Thank you Mariah and Trey. What you do here in Michael's honour is unbearably touching and beautiful. Your emotion and love show through. One of my favourite scenes ever!
gee whiz, it was a sad time for many people and that does include entertainers. I loved the way her emotions came thru during the song and I am not a big mariah fan, but in my opinion this was performed excellent.
People are so stupid this was a beautiful performance and she was trying to hold back tears that's why her voice was breaking. I'm not a big fan of Mariah but I think she did this amazingly well esecially considering Michaels body was right there it must have been so hard.
I cried all the way through the memorial as soon as they brought out that coffin it was suddenly all so real :(
R.I.P Michael you'll always be in my heart I love you
Omg.....she wore that dress to a memorial service .... with her big fake boobs hanging out .... HMMM. more trashy than reverential. and those flapping hand gestures ...looks like she's swatting flies away from her mouth. cause her "singing" stinks!!! Her lame performance was an embaresment to the Jackson family.
Doesn't it seem like there is always an explanation for why Mariah Carey's performances are sub-par? -- either she was sick, or she was tired, or the band made a mistake, or she could not hear herself in the monitor, or a background singer sang her part, or, in this case, she was overwhelmed with emotions. There is always some "reason" given to us for her sounding terrible live.
When will we accept the fact that Mariah Carey DOES not (or maybe CANnot) sing the way she used to?
mariah was so sad she said on twitter that she feels like she disappionted every1 she thinks she didnt sing good enough caz she tryed to hard not to cry.....r.i.p. mj
I think it's ridiculous how people are saying how shes terrible at singing or whatever. Its not about performing the best, shes not at her concert, shes at michaels memorial. Its about paying respect and celebrating his life which ofcourse is going to be an emotional event.
strepitosa Mariah con le lacrime agli occhi le ha fatte venire anche a noi, non importa cantare come ad X-Factor o America Idol sempre bisogna saper trasmettere e lei c'è riuscita! Wonderful
I love this song and I love Michael. Mariah always loved this too song and she still sang it well in spite of the circumstances. I cried...who wouldn't?
Thank you Mariah for singing this song. She was inspired by Michael like I was. I would have started to cry in the beginning if I were singing. I can't sing properly when I am emotional. Mariah sang beautifully. Thank you again.
I'm sorry that I wasn't able to pull it together and really do it right, but I was literally choked up when I saw him there in front of me," she tweeted. "One thing I know is, we will never really have to say goodbye to MJ. His legacy lives on through his music and the millions of people he inspired with his timeless music. He will be forever in our hearts."
''Cantare per me oggi era praticamente impossibile. Mi dispiace di non averlo fatto come avrei voluto, ma mi sono trattenuta a stento dal piangere. Ero letteralmente senza fiato quando ho visto la bara davanti a me'', ha scritto la cantante sul suo micro-blog.
''Qello che so e' che non riusciremo mai a dire davvero addio a Michael Jackson. Il suo ricordo vive attraverso la sua musica e i milioni di persone che ha ispirato. Sara' sempre nei nostri cuori''.
gee , Its amazing they can even perform or sing or give an speech for the deceased. I'm responding to the few kooky comments on this page. Death & wakes and funerals, to those who care , It's an emotional event. there are tears. Its hard to sing. Or talk. >Some people cant even attend funerals. This song is fine. Stop judging on PROS performing at a Memorial/funeral, there are emotions invovled. Try crying while talking or singing, it aint the same as when your are happy.
Easy for you to say. Have you tried singining a song at a funeral for someone you loved and looked up to? Try then, then try to go on about how she shouldn't be allowed to show emotion. Everyone just leave her alone about her voice already.
I heard that she's abused her vocal chords too much with her whistle register. She's damaged them really badly, so I heard. That's why she's not as good as she was in her prime. She's straining to much here, but she's still a successful artist, and one of the most famous on the planet. Her voice was amazing.
i was there!!
RememberSoCal 1 year ago
whatever wowzmonkeyz... just keepin it real
jlynnd1969 1 year ago
Her and MJ were best friends... D:
wowzmonkeyz 1 year ago
Beautiful. <3
Katherinehere123 1 year ago
for being a really sad day she pulled it off ok...however i remember on an interview she had a long time ago she said that singing is always an emotional experience for her...so its like in this case she should have went all out with her voice. But i'm not one to judge.
iiablaze 1 year ago
This was great, people just have very high expectations of her. If this were Miley, Taylor, Rihanna they would praise them!
alexstar15 1 year ago
Comment removed
CuteMocca 1 year ago
@CuteMocca like your mom!! dumb shit
youbshay 1 year ago
@youbshay You too
CuteMocca 1 year ago
@CuteMocca oohh plzz fuck offffff
youbshay 1 year ago
@youbshay Thanks alot. You can do that too o.o
CuteMocca 1 year ago
I don't get people who say this was a bad performance, I think it's amazing! :)
MissMusicFan1 1 year ago
Why do you all complaining that she sucked? I wouldn't have sing it better if I was in a moment like this. Of course she was sad and couldn't hold her emotions back. I know she wasn't as strong as she use to be, but this was a very emotional moment. I really think she was great. ♥
MariaTherese84 1 year ago
Mariah , Mariah , Mariah .
You are absoulty amazing , no lie .
Dont insult her for having such a strong love for Michael Jackson .
Shes someone that cant hide her feelings , but at the same time she is one of the most amazing singers in this whole world . Your amazing <3
musicislife832 1 year ago
This is an excellent tribute. Thank you Mariah.
10almartin 1 year ago
Thank you Mariah and Trey. What you do here in Michael's honour is unbearably touching and beautiful. Your emotion and love show through. One of my favourite scenes ever!
maputo95 1 year ago
Anche se la canzone non è stata eseguita al meglio (x colpa dell'emozione) rimani sempre la migliore!!!! <3
Pamela1988R 1 year ago
gee whiz, it was a sad time for many people and that does include entertainers. I loved the way her emotions came thru during the song and I am not a big mariah fan, but in my opinion this was performed excellent.
dhw314 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I think MC is having hard time surviving this song until the end.
tithay 1 year ago
iit really bad at the frist bit but went really good when she carried on singing :)
LOVE YA MARIAH
R.I.P MJ
kiranjit4life 1 year ago
mariah sucked... thank god tre still has a voice.
jlynnd1969 1 year ago
@jlynnd1969
you suck.
wowzmonkeyz 1 year ago
I don't know why everyone says she sucks now. i think this was beautiful anyway, RIP MJ<3
JM4LAJF 1 year ago
man she sucks.... That not the mariah i grew up with. I hate her new album. I miss the mariah from daydreamer to the start of her career. :-(
AAS248441 1 year ago
Her dress is not for these circumstances...
You're right, she fucked the song up
Choupachoupachoups 2 years ago
@Choupachoupachoups first of all she is upset cuz mj died duh!!
AngelifyFaith 2 years ago
I hate to say this... but she fucked this song up
alanrickman09876 2 years ago
poor Micheal Jackson he is the king of pop.
it must of been really hard for his kids that he died well he was getting old my mom cried alot when he died
180cutiegirl 2 years ago
mj no death. you death is fake
TheThekmbr 2 years ago
Thatt Was Beautiful ;
i Startedd Cryinqq . . .
R.i.P. Michael We Love Andd Miss You
LayyLayy25 2 years ago 5
I just bought this song. I love her version as well. I've yet to hear michaels.
RosesNightengales 2 years ago
to all those ppl dat are hating get likeher and stop hating on her sucess and dat was a beautiful performance from both performers
tyeishasmart8041 2 years ago 4
mariah carrey is an amazing singer. she was crying, so she cracked at the beginning. cut her some slack. u would do the same!!
Jaygensmommy 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Mariah! SHUT THE HELL UP ALREADY!!! MARIAH WENT DOWN HILL EVER SINCE SHE DIVORCED TOMMY AND LANDED ON HER KNEES! LOL! YOU SUCK BIOTCH!
NataliaCa82 2 years ago
she was crying before this thats why shes not as good as normal
nom46 2 years ago 16
@nom46 crying? she was obsessed with flipping her hair and showing her breasts. Not appropriate behavior for a memorial.
vistaprime 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
michael died of aids, his family said something different
victormanuel1976 2 years ago
@victormanuel1976 ur a loser
j3n09 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cant stand this women.
CharlieSlater 2 years ago
mariah carey, floped at the first bit but dun sick aftah dat .
theofficalmadone 2 years ago
I'm Sorry, she wa horrible! I lve mariah to death but that was some horrid stuff!
agovens 2 years ago
She cracked a little in the beginning but she is still an amazing singer.
songsinger20009 2 years ago 6
well she was crying this was a big deal for her
babygrrl467 2 years ago 14
i'd like mariah carey if she wasn't such a whore
COCOPUFF093 2 years ago
Michael would love it.. Rip
emokaj 2 years ago 5
People are so stupid this was a beautiful performance and she was trying to hold back tears that's why her voice was breaking. I'm not a big fan of Mariah but I think she did this amazingly well esecially considering Michaels body was right there it must have been so hard.
I cried all the way through the memorial as soon as they brought out that coffin it was suddenly all so real :(
R.I.P Michael you'll always be in my heart I love you
x
xXxTHxSacredxXx 2 years ago 6
i love Mariah but this performance was pretty bad and i can't beleive she wore a dress like that to a memorial sevice.
R.I.P Michael i miss you
bflyness 2 years ago
Ergo the birth of a new word just for her shenanigans- skankadoodle
cincinubia 2 years ago
the background pictures made me tear up...
Marreez 2 years ago
Omg.....she wore that dress to a memorial service .... with her big fake boobs hanging out .... HMMM. more trashy than reverential. and those flapping hand gestures ...looks like she's swatting flies away from her mouth. cause her "singing" stinks!!! Her lame performance was an embaresment to the Jackson family.
vrishdediddle 2 years ago
gees! you made me laugh there! I totally agree..she's lost it
freakdoug69 2 years ago
thank you! that is what i said...lol on the fly thing
brunettminx 2 years ago
i love u mariah
all i want for chirstmas is u wow i love that song
yomonster12 2 years ago 2
she's looosinggg her voice...bad
kambayoka 2 years ago
wow are people stupid?????? how can she sing perfectly when shes basicly crying while singing the song.
get it straight.
Emochka88 2 years ago 2
it was light, at least we can hear it..
saipansolid670badass 2 years ago
i don't really like Mariah Carey in this song. her voice totally sucked!!! she's too light, its like she was whispering. :[
Lauren09Nicole 2 years ago
u IDIOT SHE WAS FUKIN CRYING AND SINGING
deetherookie 2 years ago 4
wow your are so fucking sad that you always have to be so full of shit!!! can you sing better than her, i know so shut your bitchy bad mouth
saipansolid670badass 2 years ago 2
so sad = ,(
marlene5965 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Doesn't it seem like there is always an explanation for why Mariah Carey's performances are sub-par? -- either she was sick, or she was tired, or the band made a mistake, or she could not hear herself in the monitor, or a background singer sang her part, or, in this case, she was overwhelmed with emotions. There is always some "reason" given to us for her sounding terrible live.
When will we accept the fact that Mariah Carey DOES not (or maybe CANnot) sing the way she used to?
YT2ndAcct 2 years ago
ur just jealous dat u cant sing like her
gabbyabby23 2 years ago
The LEGENDARY MARIAH CAREY !!!
PaNdeM0niuM 2 years ago
wow so fucking sad =[
JAJA94544 2 years ago
Absoluta!
RenerMeloo 2 years ago
mariah was so sad she said on twitter that she feels like she disappionted every1 she thinks she didnt sing good enough caz she tryed to hard not to cry.....r.i.p. mj
icecreamshoes13 2 years ago 2
A legend paying a beautiful and emotional tribute to another legend... that was really sad but inspiring, watching live.
Ueberbacker 2 years ago
it was a funeral for God sake..not some singing talent contest!!!!!!
ps : i love to hear the grieve through her voice..
darmaini 2 years ago
I think it's ridiculous how people are saying how shes terrible at singing or whatever. Its not about performing the best, shes not at her concert, shes at michaels memorial. Its about paying respect and celebrating his life which ofcourse is going to be an emotional event.
trishox 2 years ago 2
Also remember that she was the ONLY artist that did not get a sound check or practice of any sort. She only arrived that morning.
LauraLynne20 2 years ago
strepitosa Mariah con le lacrime agli occhi le ha fatte venire anche a noi, non importa cantare come ad X-Factor o America Idol sempre bisogna saper trasmettere e lei c'è riuscita! Wonderful
leluzzo82 2 years ago
this was so sad...
jenniferever713 2 years ago
aaaaaw so touching, the cry in her voice
drilljam 2 years ago
Gosh to sing while Michael was in that coffin...how heartbreaking..... :(
hibiscusfire 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This was very emotional.
I love this song and I love Michael. Mariah always loved this too song and she still sang it well in spite of the circumstances. I cried...who wouldn't?
Thank you Mariah for singing this song. She was inspired by Michael like I was. I would have started to cry in the beginning if I were singing. I can't sing properly when I am emotional. Mariah sang beautifully. Thank you again.
Michael love forever.
hibiscusfire 2 years ago
I'm sorry that I wasn't able to pull it together and really do it right, but I was literally choked up when I saw him there in front of me," she tweeted. "One thing I know is, we will never really have to say goodbye to MJ. His legacy lives on through his music and the millions of people he inspired with his timeless music. He will be forever in our hearts."
MariahCareyLive 2 years ago 7
Mariah, I was glad to see you performing, just like MJ you are a true legend
MARIACLASS 2 years ago
''Cantare per me oggi era praticamente impossibile. Mi dispiace di non averlo fatto come avrei voluto, ma mi sono trattenuta a stento dal piangere. Ero letteralmente senza fiato quando ho visto la bara davanti a me'', ha scritto la cantante sul suo micro-blog.
''Qello che so e' che non riusciremo mai a dire davvero addio a Michael Jackson. Il suo ricordo vive attraverso la sua musica e i milioni di persone che ha ispirato. Sara' sempre nei nostri cuori''.
MariahCareyLive 2 years ago
@MariahCareyLive hai capito inglese
weatherfreak123 9 months ago
fear gripped my soul, one tear fell from closed lids ^ and my heart sank..
Goodbye Michael..
athoughtactually 2 years ago
Sad eyes appeared on my door steps 12 days ago, asking for a place to rest alone,
You slept through the nights in a lifeless phase, and sat through the days with an empty gaze.
Yesterday, you asked that I walked with you, but when I got to the door you asked me to stay.., Those were your last words.
I sat by the window and watched you, your robe calling to the dead air floating on burnt grass, and the curtains waved a lazy goodbye..
As your shadow faded,
athoughtactually 2 years ago
gee , Its amazing they can even perform or sing or give an speech for the deceased. I'm responding to the few kooky comments on this page. Death & wakes and funerals, to those who care , It's an emotional event. there are tears. Its hard to sing. Or talk. >Some people cant even attend funerals. This song is fine. Stop judging on PROS performing at a Memorial/funeral, there are emotions invovled. Try crying while talking or singing, it aint the same as when your are happy.
ScooBeeDooBeeDoo 2 years ago
Well, at least we know now why she usually mimes... I also wish she'd quit that stupid habit of drawing in the air with her right hand!
butagirluk 2 years ago
really touching
Ueberbacker 2 years ago
Mariah's voice is different, but it's still spectacular. Beautiful and emotional tribute.
Cote1980 2 years ago 4
all of the perfomers are emotional at that time even Usher shed a tear...but that's not a good excuse not to sing good....
it only shows that MS MC is really loosing her voice...she's not the same MC that i looked up to...c",)
vladjustin 2 years ago
Easy for you to say. Have you tried singining a song at a funeral for someone you loved and looked up to? Try then, then try to go on about how she shouldn't be allowed to show emotion. Everyone just leave her alone about her voice already.
ladyphoenix420 2 years ago
she's just emotional. beautiful singing mariah and trey. rip mj
princessamellia 2 years ago 3
she is good at singing she actually sorda sounded like micheal jackson wow
PunkGirl0989 2 years ago
HER VOICE REALLY SUCKS NOWADAYS! sad
dreamingirl 2 years ago
Comment removed
dreamingirl 2 years ago
Her voice is definitely damaged. She was an amazing artist, but she has busted up some of those chords through time.
glenedward 2 years ago
NOTHING... :))
yanniaquino 2 years ago 2
she is emotional while singing..
its VERY good.....♥
yanniaquino 2 years ago 3
nothing is wrong with her voice silly!!
she is emotional!!!!!!
SelevsekTa 2 years ago
Perfeita! ♥
GabrielFerrari8 2 years ago
I heard that she's abused her vocal chords too much with her whistle register. She's damaged them really badly, so I heard. That's why she's not as good as she was in her prime. She's straining to much here, but she's still a successful artist, and one of the most famous on the planet. Her voice was amazing.
jordandavis92 2 years ago
Comment removed
jordandavis92 2 years ago
I'm crying! You sang far right! I Love You!
RenerMeloo 2 years ago 2
The sound was awesome!
JKayC63 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She sounds HORRIBLE.
chilito91 2 years ago
not it is not. the sound quality of this video is crap. same with teh video.
caonabismo 2 years ago
Never cared for her version of the song but I'm glad that let her perform it. R I P Michael.
lomc02 2 years ago
beautiful, to remember michael this way.........for ever.
raymondGER 2 years ago
2:35-2:41 was her best vocals.
uluvbs 2 years ago 2
An excellent performance for an excellent superstar!
despassos 2 years ago 4
mamma mia mariah sei la migliore!!!!!....grazie mille....m sto emozionando!
mariahsara 2 years ago 2
Wonderful!!!! Emozionata Mariah si vede,però grande!!!
NAPOLITK 2 years ago 2