What I can't understand is how, in remaking this song, no one seems to ever capture the deep meaning of the song and not change it so it loses that deep meaning. How can so many bands play it, but not one of them ever even makes it touch the soul and give you chills like the Beatles did? I'm sorry, but my thinking at this point is that the bands do it for publicity, not to honor the Beatles.
*covers ears and clicks mouse to go somewhere else* I love the Beatles which is why I am sorry I stumbled on this. These guys murder the original song! John and George are turning over in their graves...
I dont think its the matter of trying to be better than the beatles or trying to 'add up" to them, but more outta respect of a great band and a great song
idk i luv the lyrics and i luv da fray and i totaly luv da cover but what i dont know is y everyone is so thretened bands have always and will always do covers i mean they covered hips dont lie and no one complained y is this song so much more protected u hav to understand i honestly dont think the fray is trying to say they r better than the beatles i honestly just think they wanna have fun out there so letem besides anything that connects david cook and the fray i'm cool with
well personally i like it.. i mean most people probably want bands to stop making Beatles covers altogether, but thats because nothing they will ever do seems to be good enough. C'monIthought the Beatles were the best band ever! Of course nothing will ever be good enough :)ut they can at least try, this isn't terrible, at least to me
dang. people love to hate. I don't think they are trying to "disgrace" the beatles or do as well as them. They just like the song and wanted to play it. I hope that when I play in a coffee house and play "Yesterday" that everyone isn't think, "Geez! what a loser! trying to play the beatles! who does he think he is??!!!"
they actually did a pretty good job with this cover. And its just a performance, and stop acting likes The Beatles are sacred or something.. The video quality is just crappy
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
lol. are you saying that the fray is remotely close to having as much talent as The Beatles? The Beatles are one of the greatest bands to have ever existed. the fray is a lame ass band with little talent, and the lead singer sounds like he's whining the entire time, its one of the most nauseating bands out there.
im not the type to bitch at things for unessecary things but WTF! THIS IS FUCKING HORRIBLE! do they seriously think that they can make a good version of this? cuz thats horrible
wow. the fray is actually trying to make it seem like they have some knowledge of real music! lol. since when did it become cool to moan and whine while you sing?
LOL! sooo true. they dont do the beatles any justice with this song. I think they should just stick to their songs.....not that those are any better xD bottom line THE FRAY SUCKS
it was a cover they did for fun. you should check the fray out they did write their own songs and they wrote some pretty damn good ones too! so shut up.
This brings tears tears to my eyes, my two favourite bands, the fray the beatles and my favourite song.
InreallifePOSTS 1 year ago 2
Realm's cover is best.
quorthonbathory 1 year ago
ehh...ive never really liked the fray live...they are better in the studio
DeloreanFanatic 1 year ago
Why are people talking about Thrice on The Fray's video... *facepalm*
XxTheTrojanxX 1 year ago
@XxTheTrojanxX because thrice does a better cover?
Duzty17 1 year ago
MISLEADING AND BISEXUAL
backtothefuhta 2 years ago
The original is by miles the best the beatles were by far the most talented band to ever grace us,no one else can even come close:)
LearyCian94 2 years ago
Bleezychronic you must be joking, you cant compare this lousy band with thrice.
koristar 2 years ago
Is this a joke?
iwazhear77 2 years ago
who ever said THRICE had the best version is seriously mistaken
bleezychronic 2 years ago
u guys are all wrong....this cover blows every other cover out of the water....
bleezychronic 2 years ago
If you want a heavy version, check out the one by Thrice. Of all the covers I've heard, it's probably my favorite.
usedtohatecellphones 2 years ago
not bad but the origional is better
baseballkid0651 2 years ago
i sooo agree.... this sucks!?!?!?!!!!!
Djphsyco5 2 years ago
Comment removed
lOudMOuTH23 2 years ago
this is actually not that bad, most "eleanor rigby" covers suck sooo bad
fangsupkatie 2 years ago
I liked it ..
JohnLennon100 2 years ago
ehhh, it's ok...
nycgirl234 2 years ago
I rather like The Fray, but this isn't a patch on the original Beatles version!
ShandySteve 2 years ago
yuck...stick to grey's anatomy guys...leave beatles songs to paul and ringo...
mariobro1993 2 years ago
lol
holmes444 2 years ago
Would actually sound okay if the sound quality wasnt that bad...
aabgraba 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Panic version> this version
sorry
ritalinkid34 2 years ago
gross...John Lennon didn't get shot for this
jerkoftheyear145 2 years ago
wtf :|
sh4rko 2 years ago
grande bosta..
mais uma bosta estragando esse som..
ravelverbeke 2 years ago
What I can't understand is how, in remaking this song, no one seems to ever capture the deep meaning of the song and not change it so it loses that deep meaning. How can so many bands play it, but not one of them ever even makes it touch the soul and give you chills like the Beatles did? I'm sorry, but my thinking at this point is that the bands do it for publicity, not to honor the Beatles.
frylord333 2 years ago
i like it, they really made it fit their style
barimaphone 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this makes my ears bleed. panic at the discos wasnt that great but its a million times better then this.
technotarts 2 years ago
if you think this is remotely good and wouldn't mind a harder cover of it, you will love thrice's cover
shepcorioliseffect 3 years ago 2
*covers ears and clicks mouse to go somewhere else* I love the Beatles which is why I am sorry I stumbled on this. These guys murder the original song! John and George are turning over in their graves...
LadyJiraiya 3 years ago
lol, they could never play this song as good as the beatles, and the string quartet in the beatles is a stroke of genius
Willsibberz 3 years ago
They're in the wrong key and Isaac's voice doesn't suite the song.
Those are the only problems I have with this cover, I do love The Fray though :)
allyyyyyyyyyyyyyy 3 years ago
I prefer Thrices version
JABUUTY671 3 years ago 3
nu uu
tdaman123 3 years ago
A prefer Pain version. They did an awesome job!!!
Teresusca 3 years ago
this is an awsome cover ^_^
I <333333 the fray
LittleMissGerman 3 years ago
this cover isnt that good its decent but its bad at the same time
Frylockblake 3 years ago 2
ACtually Thrices Cover Is Better than this and yeah beatles Owns this song
Whensadmeetshappines 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the thrice cover sucks...not as bad as this one tho...sorry the fray...i like you...but this is quite suckish
kingddd133 3 years ago
Thrice is a good band though
Whensadmeetshappines 3 years ago 6
well ya thats true. but their cover of eleanor rigby im just not really in to
kingddd133 3 years ago
this is actually one of my favorite covers of this song :) beatles ^^
aqua1993 3 years ago
I dont think its the matter of trying to be better than the beatles or trying to 'add up" to them, but more outta respect of a great band and a great song
PriestessAura 3 years ago
idk i luv the lyrics and i luv da fray and i totaly luv da cover but what i dont know is y everyone is so thretened bands have always and will always do covers i mean they covered hips dont lie and no one complained y is this song so much more protected u hav to understand i honestly dont think the fray is trying to say they r better than the beatles i honestly just think they wanna have fun out there so letem besides anything that connects david cook and the fray i'm cool with
omfgiluvdissong 3 years ago
This proves... good music will always be good music, regardless of what decade it was made.
AdamShanklyUK 3 years ago
i LOVE this song!
muziklvr101 3 years ago
Not bad...
infiniteabyss09 3 years ago
wow...thrice did it 20x better!
NiksVideoLog 3 years ago
2 tru
Govanator12 3 years ago
this is coooool! if u like this song check out my version! not quite the same haha
SamWeber12 3 years ago
i love the fray. and this song. And I find the cover to be of terrible quality.
slisenberger 3 years ago
well personally i like it.. i mean most people probably want bands to stop making Beatles covers altogether, but thats because nothing they will ever do seems to be good enough. C'monIthought the Beatles were the best band ever! Of course nothing will ever be good enough :)ut they can at least try, this isn't terrible, at least to me
wickedluva 3 years ago
dang. people love to hate. I don't think they are trying to "disgrace" the beatles or do as well as them. They just like the song and wanted to play it. I hope that when I play in a coffee house and play "Yesterday" that everyone isn't think, "Geez! what a loser! trying to play the beatles! who does he think he is??!!!"
PenguinDefender 3 years ago
they actually did a pretty good job with this cover. And its just a performance, and stop acting likes The Beatles are sacred or something.. The video quality is just crappy
Renaaage 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol. are you saying that the fray is remotely close to having as much talent as The Beatles? The Beatles are one of the greatest bands to have ever existed. the fray is a lame ass band with little talent, and the lead singer sounds like he's whining the entire time, its one of the most nauseating bands out there.
cocaftw123 3 years ago
well, if you just read my comment, then you know thats not what i'm saying
people's opinions and tasts are different than yours. Get over it
Renaaage 3 years ago
im not the type to bitch at things for unessecary things but WTF! THIS IS FUCKING HORRIBLE! do they seriously think that they can make a good version of this? cuz thats horrible
calkal101 3 years ago
wow. the fray is actually trying to make it seem like they have some knowledge of real music! lol. since when did it become cool to moan and whine while you sing?
cocaftw123 4 years ago
I couldn't agree more
saxandpiano 4 years ago
LOL! sooo true. they dont do the beatles any justice with this song. I think they should just stick to their songs.....not that those are any better xD bottom line THE FRAY SUCKS
calkal101 4 years ago
Lets all just get this straight! NO ONE LIKES COVER SONGS!
GerlovesCami 4 years ago
it was a cover they did for fun. you should check the fray out they did write their own songs and they wrote some pretty damn good ones too! so shut up.
pujolsbaseball13 4 years ago
but very frankly THIS COVER SUX ASS which makes a statement about the frays live singing
catzsorool1995 3 years ago
yeah it might not be the best but you got to give them credit for trying. most bands would just say no because they would have done horrible anyways
pujolsbaseball13 3 years ago
Good Point
catzsorool1995 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
NOBODY should cover the beatles' songs but the beatles, especially a song like this. Fuck this band.
reallyocean 4 years ago
Awsome!
dandymandyduh 4 years ago
hahahaa awesome? are u like DEAF!??!!!??!?!
calkal101 3 years ago
well.. that wasn't very good at all.. although, i'm sure the quality doesn't do them any justice.. but even still
CaptainMarvel92 4 years ago
thats a really good song for them to cover
kinkygypsy 5 years ago
its not high sound quality its just very loud.
naryion 5 years ago
The fray *dies* The greatest thing to come out of my state (crap colorado) in a looooooooooong time
nezzerfoot 5 years ago