Although this is really beautiful, the fact that it has such a strong vibrato makes it sound a lot less natural, and much more... rehearsed? I think that while it's technically better than a lot of versions of the songs, the real charm of it is it's feeling and the spontaneity of it...<3
True, it's more stabilized, but not better. Without Sally's shakiness in voice and imperfections she's not Sally. I think the English version is better, it gives way more emotion
@Fluteplayingbandgeek i agree 100%. this singer might be 'better,' but the original was perfect because of its marred qualities and imperfections. it fit the character, spirit of the movie, and theme of the song more than this.
This beautiful song makes me cry, even in the english version. Danny Elfman, plaese make more beautiful songs like this, and Tim Burton Plaese make more movies.
@NinjaNina9 They were going to but Tim Burton said no because he didn't want to turn the movie into a series. He felt turning it into a series of movies would ruin. Though the guy who did Coraline said he would make a sequel for Nightmare Before Christmas if Tim Burton does the story.
@cheraemen9996 Here are the lyrics in romaji (spelled out Japanese): Kaze ga sasayaita higeki no makuake wo tasukete agetai fukitsu na kiri no naka chikadsuiteru no yo ano hito wa kidsukanai setsunai kono kimochi ni kanawanu koi kodoku yo, kotaete futari no unmei wa machi no zawameki ni tokete shimaetara watashi ni wa dekinai yume mite mo kanau hi wa konai no todokanu hito sou watashi ni wa
It's nice to listen to the songs that u love in different languages. I love this one as well as the one in German, I hope to hear the one on French. All such beautiful languages! :)
in asia is feeling= sounds- and the complete video is synchron- more synchron than in any other languages, even german (I am german!) it´s much better impression!!
In Asian(:Chinese,K(C)orean,Japanese) Versions of TNBC, They Hired Professional Musical Actors and Actress' for Dub the Original Song. Maybe, The Singer in this Version is Musical Actress, too
man this song gets me in english, spanish even japanese the guy who wrote is a genius, Danny Elfman (i mean he even wrote the opening for THE SIMPSONS how cool is that?
she kinda sounds like an real life version of miku hatsune, she really actually DOES sound prettier in japanese. i think that almost ANY song sounds better in japanes
I doubt the lyrics are still the same, it's like national anthems when they're translated. I noticed the word "yume" which means "dream" so you tell it's not quite the same, but I'm sure the meaning's there.
I love Seiyuu. XD Just in general. They're incredible at nailing the character its self. Not just to fit the stereotype like many American voice actors do.
@MiniMoon10 NO it is the language barrier that does this. Without a good clue as to what is being said along with cultures ideas and ideals, both taking years to grasp even as a first language. You are left with only phonic and emotional adhereance, and some sense of timing. Thus you are given an illusion of stronger emotion and phonic (example of phonics is like when I listen to the kidnapping song in German and I can get pass the constant 'S' which may seem naturual as a German).
this song is actually a tad more depressing with the japanese translation. the sadness in the english is somewhat general bu the japanese meaning is persistently depressing
this is so cool. although i like the english version better. i guess its because im used to hearing it in english but whoever sung this version did a great job
no, im talking about a professional dub, rather than some fanboy with a cold who has to re-rhyme the entire song. no offense, he was still most excellent. and theres no dub on the second season themes.
No, there is a dub, now. You could go look in your local anime DVD selling store. :) Trust me! Adult Swim plays it every Saturday. And about the song... I remember this was my FAVORITE thing to listen to!! :) I still LOVE it!!! I was Sally one year for Halloween and I learned the song by heart so I could walk down the street at night singing a haunting melody. xD I did it, too!! I sang the song with my friend, Caitlin! :3
um... there is a professional dub. They showed it on TV, in fact, they finished the series... I don't know if Adult swim still shows it, but you can find the DVD's.
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp
@Riiko279 i agree with the 2nd and 3rd but the thing is that the voice for sally couldnt sing....so thats the reason that this verson sounds better....
For some reason, I've always thought that Aya Hirano would make a great Sally. XD If you don't understand why I think so, go watch "Misa no Uta". I just think her voice would be good as Sally.
This is sooooo cute >w<
I love this song
Sonadownessfan13 2 weeks ago
does she call jack jakku or jack-kun like the honorifics?
Mangobitz 3 weeks ago
@Mangobitz 彼女は「ジャック」って言うね。
Kiyorocket 3 weeks ago
@Kiyorocket ???
Mangobitz 3 weeks ago
@Kiyorocket ああ、そう彼女は敬語を使用しないのですか?
Mangobitz 3 weeks ago
@Mangobitz I heard Jakku
KagamineSydmay 2 weeks ago
@Mangobitz I heard Jakku
KagamineSydmay 2 weeks ago
@KagamineSydmay Its how they say "Jack"
haiironoyuki39 1 day ago
Catherine O'Hara (English version), Yuko Doi (japanese) and Nina Hagen (German) were the best!
karlkrieger 1 month ago
I like it, but i like Amy Lee's verson better :)
SeptemberAlexandra 1 month ago
Although this is really beautiful, the fact that it has such a strong vibrato makes it sound a lot less natural, and much more... rehearsed? I think that while it's technically better than a lot of versions of the songs, the real charm of it is it's feeling and the spontaneity of it...<3
KawaiiCindyChan 2 months ago
this is is pretty good but i preffer the latin spanish version better than this one and the english one
kykOo0 2 months ago
Hmm.
Both English and Japanese sound amazing
Given Catherine O'Hara isn't a singer yet she rocked it
Yuko Doi sounds beautiful as well
TaleSpinTV1990 2 months ago
i like it better in japanese
DanceInTheDarkness1 2 months ago
When I figured out that Shock and Sally were voiced by the same woman in BOTH languages, I shat bricks. xDDD I seriously did a spit take.
PastaaaaaProductions 2 months ago
I Really Really Really love this Version!!
My favorite movie in all World combined with Anime XD wich also Love!
HappyKittymiau 2 months ago
i prefere the englishm it seems more innocent and had that gothic uneveness in it.
DarkAngelOfTorture 2 months ago
True, it's more stabilized, but not better. Without Sally's shakiness in voice and imperfections she's not Sally. I think the English version is better, it gives way more emotion
davydonutt 3 months ago 5
very beautiful....buta little to much vibrato.......too opera sounding...
Fluteplayingbandgeek 3 months ago
@Fluteplayingbandgeek i agree 100%. this singer might be 'better,' but the original was perfect because of its marred qualities and imperfections. it fit the character, spirit of the movie, and theme of the song more than this.
Mintyflip 2 months ago
¿La actriz que prestó su voz a la versión japonesa no es la misma que la de Kasumi de Dead or Alive?
alhec007 3 months ago
tiene una voz más vieja pero... creo que canta con más afinación que
Catherine O'Hara ¡¡ARRIBA JAPÓN LOS OTAKUS Y LA SALLY JAPONESA!! :3
ElfenDamaLied28 3 months ago
Hey, Japanese is pretty good!
MsKawaiiGirl 3 months ago
Ahhhh!!!! This is so awesome!!
xorinoa 4 months ago
check out my version of this please well it's really a jack and sally slideshow
on my account
TheMermaid212 4 months ago
Comment removed
TheMermaid212 4 months ago
WHAT IS THIS I DONT EVEN
Nvoy123 4 months ago
Beautiful!! *__*
nenfa96 4 months ago
die syncronstimme von ihr ist soooo schön in japanisch besser als die in deutsch oder englisch
EveJess94 4 months ago
¿Who sings this version? Please!♥><
gizzug95 4 months ago
Hello a question you do not know where I can find the lyrics of this song but in Japanese?
GoTiCaAnDrOmEdA 5 months ago 5
This beautiful song makes me cry, even in the english version. Danny Elfman, plaese make more beautiful songs like this, and Tim Burton Plaese make more movies.
chazmarepps4 5 months ago 3
@chazmarepps4 They are actually planning to make a sequel.
MITRWXS 5 months ago
@MITRWXS A sequel to the Nightmare Before Christmas?
NinjaNina9 5 months ago
@NinjaNina9 They were going to but Tim Burton said no because he didn't want to turn the movie into a series. He felt turning it into a series of movies would ruin. Though the guy who did Coraline said he would make a sequel for Nightmare Before Christmas if Tim Burton does the story.
lwhatley 5 months ago
Can you put the romanji lyrics please??
QuirozAbiack 5 months ago
come vorrei essere Sally....<3
AngelsOnMyHeart 5 months ago
i personally like the original better :I she doesn't sound to sad.
sakuragirl202 6 months ago
suena hermoso en japones
QuirozAbiack 6 months ago 3
can somebody please post the lyrics for this please! :)
cheraemen9996 6 months ago
CoffeeOholic 6 months ago 6
@CoffeeOholic
Thank you so much! :D
cheraemen9996 6 months ago
I actually prefer the English version, it just sounds darker and sadder to me. Still, very cool.
RavenxRobin101 6 months ago
Comment removed
cheraemen9996 6 months ago 2
her voice is uber soft
chacragirl 7 months ago
ништяк!
MrGrombel 7 months ago
"Sayonara Jaku !... Hitoshi Jaku..." ♥
M0RFic 8 months ago
@M0RFic
What a shame!
Sayonara Jack...Itoshii Jack...
2007royroy 7 months ago
@2007royroy What a shame !
"Jack" in Japanese is "Jaku"...
Oh My God !
I've forgotten ONE letter and write Itooshii with a H, please kill me :'( !
WTF - -' ?!
M0RFic 7 months ago
@M0RFic its not that they changed his name :/ they can't just say that... even if they want to...its not their fault...
dingsdings2 6 months ago
This one is pretty good, too. But I still prefer the rendition that Amy Lee did.
CosplayCore 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bah,terrible japanese version,ahahah,make this looking like an anime XDD Sorry,can't take japanese seriously XDD
DurlindanaFaz88 8 months ago
@DurlindanaFaz88 Then...go, watch it english?
TheMindlessEmo 7 months ago
@XenonMan1
Japanese version is good.
but English version love!!XD
beautiful voice!!!
and i really love American movies :)
00sakuramochi00 9 months ago
this sounds pretty in Japenese
arcticFox102 10 months ago 3
Ah.... So pretty.....
enma421 11 months ago
It's nice to listen to the songs that u love in different languages. I love this one as well as the one in German, I hope to hear the one on French. All such beautiful languages! :)
TheSecretLifeOfBees1 11 months ago
i am Japanese,
i like it!!
but i love English ver!!!
00sakuramochi00 11 months ago
@00sakuramochi00
Funny really
I am American
I love it!
however I love the Japanese better than English.
XenonMan1 9 months ago
J'adore, que ce soit en français, en anglais ou en japonais cette chanson est magnifique!
sumomoamano 11 months ago
aww cute^^
MrsSally777 1 year ago
I love the English one, but this Sally sings a little better than Catherine O'Hara. She actually has vibrato, and sounds more like a musical actress.
phangirl91 1 year ago 47
@phangirl91 agree with you. and yes, she is Actually a musical actress. :3
geveente 1 year ago
@geveente She is? What's her name?
phangirl91 1 year ago
@phangirl91
I somewhere read that it's Yūko Doi (Japanese singing voice of Pocahontas :) )
Airanel 1 year ago
It does sound prettier in japanese!
animequeen567668 1 year ago
I like it in japanese, it has more feeling.
But it doesn't sound better BECAUSE it's in japanese.
This girl just knows how to sing better than the english speaker.
But the english version is more natural, and not everyone can sing, even in movies.
sydnieraquel 1 year ago 68
in asia is feeling= sounds- and the complete video is synchron- more synchron than in any other languages, even german (I am german!) it´s much better impression!!
1977Thanatos 1 year ago
Amy Lee's is still the best hands down lol.
AyanaLinval 1 year ago
The Asians Know how to put feeling into songs.
ninjagir165 1 year ago
she sounds better in Japanese.
man i love this language
if only i could speak it
/sigh
bamsgirl12345 1 year ago
Sally's voice is wonderful (and not badly acted either!) in Japanese. So pleasant <3
AjnosFTW 1 year ago 3
Why everything sounds so pretty in japanese?
SchneesturmWarrior 1 year ago 7
I LOVE this version and no I'm not Asian lol...I'm Black :)
I thought I would broadcast my race since everyone else is doing it lol >_^
technicolor87 1 year ago 5
@technicolor87 *Jumps on the band wagon*
Why yes! I am white!
Lolanimationcrew 1 year ago
@Lolanimationcrew Lol!! Awesome! Hey-did I mention I'm Black!? I want everyone to know this cause its VERY relevant! :D lol
technicolor87 1 year ago
@technicolor87 Yay!!!! Ethnicity!!!!!!!!!!
Lolanimationcrew 1 year ago
intrestinghow , both english and other peole form aorund the world could sing togheter (this is halloween is another example
liamnaruto 1 year ago
go japanese people! ( i may or may not be slightly japanese<3)
purplehairponcho 1 year ago
Nightmare before christmas+Japanese= :D
eminemjb127 1 year ago
this is so epic :D
littleAzukari 1 year ago
In Asian(:Chinese,K(C)orean,Japanese) Versions of TNBC, They Hired Professional Musical Actors and Actress' for Dub the Original Song. Maybe, The Singer in this Version is Musical Actress, too
Ps:i'm Asian too. :3
geveente 1 year ago
@geveente prove it! speak your language
Ragensu64 1 year ago
@Ragensu64 히히히힛, 보다시피 전 한국인이에요. ^3^ (hehhehheh, I'm Korean, As you can see.)
geveente 1 year ago
man this song gets me in english, spanish even japanese the guy who wrote is a genius, Danny Elfman (i mean he even wrote the opening for THE SIMPSONS how cool is that?
EDpowerfist 1 year ago
how beautiful (:
pweesa 1 year ago 4
^-^ 私はサリーを愛して
CatLover74747474 1 year ago
I'm learning Japanese, so I'm sure this will help in the future.
I think it's so beautiful in Japanese.
BlackVenomousRose 1 year ago 3
beautiful japonese version
Beebee7129 1 year ago
Kawaii no desu!!!! Arigotou
isabellalegara 1 year ago
Yay, I want to sing this one time. I love the japanese language. Who is the singer? Pleas answear somebody.
RavenPrincess13 1 year ago
beautiful, its just so beautiful
isabellalegara 1 year ago
is there a link i can go to to download this version of the song???
CosplayChroniclesPro 1 year ago
she kinda sounds like an real life version of miku hatsune, she really actually DOES sound prettier in japanese. i think that almost ANY song sounds better in japanes
sashagir 1 year ago
This is soo beautiful!!! I love this version and english :3 it's plus that I understand Japanese x)
bloody1scarlet1rose 1 year ago
i think it sounds beautiful in all versions =)
109876Bk 1 year ago 7
it sounds fun to sing my teeth hurt cause i cant... because i dano japanese. lmao but it sounds awesome in japanese ima try to sing it!!!
haleyluv111 1 year ago
Japanese and French Version THE BEST!!!
DisneySongFan100 1 year ago 3
ouaiiiiiii c'est vraii!
SuperZenifer 10 months ago
I doubt the lyrics are still the same, it's like national anthems when they're translated. I noticed the word "yume" which means "dream" so you tell it's not quite the same, but I'm sure the meaning's there.
Roleplayer008 1 year ago
so beautiful and ... and.. awesome! *Faves*
PikaPichuChan 1 year ago
Hauuuuuuu ~ ;_; ~
I love her voice in japanese!!!
SannyKeks 1 year ago
10000mal besser als in deutsch!!!!
KahoriHanari 1 year ago
Lol. I love how everybody instantly moons over this version just because it's in Japanese. Original voice and dubbing is still on top for me.
emberslave 1 year ago 6
I love Seiyuu. XD Just in general. They're incredible at nailing the character its self. Not just to fit the stereotype like many American voice actors do.
PartyAkatsuki 1 year ago
amazing !!!!!! i love it <3<3<3<3
Yukixx44 1 year ago
this must be the best dubbed song of the entire dub movie.
the singing kept up with the rythme and the voice is very beautiful to boot.
the rest were kind of off
darklight436 1 year ago
Sally's Japanese voice actress is amazing.
AnarchistGoth 2 years ago 38
I know. They really captured the emotion!
RushindanoDensetsu 1 year ago
How pretty. The japanese found a very emotive voice for Sally. I love it.
Nahsaghara 2 years ago 27
also if i´m from germany, i like the japanese version the most, the voice is unbelieveable!
KumikuxManasama 2 years ago
Pretty!
I'd like to listen Corpse bride songs in Japanese!
LiseVertige 2 years ago 9
i love japanese !!
Inuyashalover920 2 years ago 8
her voice is so prety in jap
TheBumbleBeeKid 2 years ago 100
I love the english and jap versions!
thepenguinlover456 2 years ago 3
I love her voice X3
tobiswife 2 years ago 9
freaken awsome love inglish and japanese and sort of germon version
candytyson747565 2 years ago 5
This is such a melodic song. I like it!
SpyPalPeeWee 2 years ago 11
This is beautiful. The Japanese verison adds a little more depression to the song so u can see how sad Sally is.
MiniMoon10 2 years ago 218
@MiniMoon10 NO it is the language barrier that does this. Without a good clue as to what is being said along with cultures ideas and ideals, both taking years to grasp even as a first language. You are left with only phonic and emotional adhereance, and some sense of timing. Thus you are given an illusion of stronger emotion and phonic (example of phonics is like when I listen to the kidnapping song in German and I can get pass the constant 'S' which may seem naturual as a German).
DukeTravers 8 months ago
this is so cool! i like japanese and english tho. good job! =3
coraline233 2 years ago 10
whoa
it's better in Japanese.
as iss everything else.
Tiix3 2 years ago 4
I wouldn't say that
Shoryuji9 2 years ago 2
you, mam/sir, are completely wrong
Ulitmadusk 2 years ago
I likey!!!
Sims2loverxyz 2 years ago 7
this song is actually a tad more depressing with the japanese translation. the sadness in the english is somewhat general bu the japanese meaning is persistently depressing
guevashin 2 years ago 10
this is so cool. although i like the english version better. i guess its because im used to hearing it in english but whoever sung this version did a great job
Dionna1224 2 years ago
sally can be such a downer even if shes just caring loosen up girly!!!!!!
luv2sing1997 2 years ago
So fucking cool, even if it's in Japanese!!! :D
KawaiiChibiGirl101 2 years ago 6
I like the english better
iiinicka 2 years ago
250th rating person. :D
Saijigoku1 2 years ago
this is so very beautiful! :) lovely...
00Lady00Lolita00 2 years ago 6
can you add the japanese lyrics to this plz i want to sing this to someone
pinkchix2000 2 years ago
I don't like this version as much as English somehow.
KarakalLynx 2 years ago
DESU NOTO
Yuuki6Kuran 2 years ago
que tiene ke ver death note con todo esto??
darktwilight94 2 years ago
i like so much in japanese!! :D genial en japones!
trauermusik 2 years ago 3
She sounds so beautiful! ^w^
Konekosan01 2 years ago 7
Oh yes, she does!^^ I really like the japanese version.
sheloveschocolate93 2 years ago
this is actually really beautiful. now, why cant someone translate death note to english?! so annoying... but this is incredible.
MarcTaker 2 years ago
but...there IS an english dub for death note..
CascadaaXx 2 years ago
no, im talking about a professional dub, rather than some fanboy with a cold who has to re-rhyme the entire song. no offense, he was still most excellent. and theres no dub on the second season themes.
MarcTaker 2 years ago
No, there is a dub, now. You could go look in your local anime DVD selling store. :) Trust me! Adult Swim plays it every Saturday. And about the song... I remember this was my FAVORITE thing to listen to!! :) I still LOVE it!!! I was Sally one year for Halloween and I learned the song by heart so I could walk down the street at night singing a haunting melody. xD I did it, too!! I sang the song with my friend, Caitlin! :3
PrincessKairi124 2 years ago
lol, I love to sing it too :P
dusktribe 2 years ago
I think they mean the dub of the song.
Shippou011 2 years ago
um... there is a professional dub. They showed it on TV, in fact, they finished the series... I don't know if Adult swim still shows it, but you can find the DVD's.
catdemonninja 2 years ago
I hope "Coraline" will get dubbed in Japanese, too.
Sunzu49 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp
MARIELA2898 2 years ago
Is it just me, or did the english version sound congested?
HatakeSage 2 years ago
OMG!!! This is actually good! This is fantastic. The best dubbed over voice in TNBC!
HydraxSly202 2 years ago 4
Wooow, her voice sounds so beautiful in Japanese! Omfg, love. <3 (: It's so much better in Jap, no joke man.
foreverthesickestkit 2 years ago 6
i liked her voiced there.
0310Mille 2 years ago
Where can I get the Mp3 'cause i want it!!??
jemmytaveras 2 years ago
i can give you the mp3, if you want
VampireOnCemetery 2 years ago 2
Three things:
1) She sounds prettier in Japanese
2) This rocks
3) Asians rule
*cough*I'm Asian*cough*
...">>
Riiko279 2 years ago 125
they do:)
bloodplus55 2 years ago 4
@Riiko279
I agreee!!
まったく同感です。
and i'm not asian
アジア人じゃないよ!
日本が大好き!
Lalla89lau 1 year ago
@Riiko279 Asians DO rule. I'm not Asian.
kitkat062959 1 year ago 8
@Riiko279 HAHAHA i no right!!!
*cough*I'm also Asian*cough*
sherbertpandainspace 1 year ago
@Riiko279 im asian too who care
Ragensu64 1 year ago
@Riiko279 i agree with the 2nd and 3rd but the thing is that the voice for sally couldnt sing....so thats the reason that this verson sounds better....
harusohma153 1 year ago
@Riiko279
i agree but li the Fiona Apple version sounds more goth
Transylvaniaman 1 year ago
@Riiko279
i agree but like the Fiona Apple version sounds more goth
Transylvaniaman 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Riiko279
i agree but like the Fiona Apple version sounds more goth
Transylvaniaman 1 year ago
awesome!!! ^^ its so pretty!
JenRei87 2 years ago 6
I love it so Much.
0310Mille 2 years ago
:O Wow. It's beautiful!
thecuddliestwerewolf 2 years ago
I love how sorrowful Sally sounds in this. It slightly makes me want to cry.
Sunzu49 2 years ago 8
大好きです。可愛いサリー(*´д`*)
zakuro696 2 years ago
sayaonara, jack.
xAnnihilate 2 years ago 3
I think the German and English are best, but I will say that the girl that sang the Japanese dub has a beautiful voice. Absolutely lovely. ^-^
PhantomAlucard 2 years ago 7
cool
sasukezfan 2 years ago
YES I finally found Sally's song in Japanese! YAAAAY!
moonchild3131 2 years ago
i speak only english ....an yet i really like this she sings this so wellXD
bleachbabe03 2 years ago 2
beautiful.
SandPRODUCTIONS 2 years ago
For some reason, I've always thought that Aya Hirano would make a great Sally. XD If you don't understand why I think so, go watch "Misa no Uta". I just think her voice would be good as Sally.
KaizokuNoAnzu 2 years ago
sI, Tienes razón, Haya Hirano pudo haber sido buena para interpretar esta canción y doblar al japonés la voz de Sally...
oODarkSakuraOo 2 years ago
omg shes voicing sally?
oh misa no uta. that song is cool! i love death note xD
DNNear101 2 years ago
Hmm I know what you mean, she would, I'm a big fan of Death Note Myself :D
900Anime900 2 years ago
cool. I wanna watch this whole movie in Japanese now
RukisxGoldxPants 2 years ago