Joy Goswami reciting to protest Nandigram mass killing.

[surajit94]

joy its a piece of shit try to tell d truth and dont confuse Gujrat with Nandigram you can do all dis on stage as cpm is in power dont forget d 72-77

[arijeetanubis]

congress er haat theke 70 doshoke bachiye chilo CPM....aj tader haat theke bacchacche abar COngress..shashok bodlay..shoshon ta noy...

perhaps etai gonotontrer niyom..

[dyuti89]

i'm not against industralization, but i'm against this govt that let this anarchism continue for 11 months, and finally,let this massacre happen.hasbo na kadbo bujhte pari na jokhon amader PM 'bodla' newar kotha bolen.achha apnara nahoy cpm, kintu tar ageo to apnara manush, etogulo manusher rokto jhorlo, tate kono heldol nei apnader? shilpa obossoi dokrkar, kintu tar jonno ei hingshar proyog kano?

[singadi]

I fail to understand why the ppl of bengal still vote or CPM. When other states have gone miles ahead they are still in a mess within their own states killing innocent poor peasants. Shame on CPM and their supporters.

[prolaykundu]

Joy Goswami ki 'intellectual' se proshongo thak... tini industrialisation'er pokkhe na bipokkhe seta bishoi noi... it is of state machinery and goons of ruling gentry shooting to kill 'downtroddens'.. let industrialisation happen but not by killing peasants. And when same Joy reads out poetry against Modi-Gujarat riots, we listen in apt silence, then why not now!!!None speak a word about Lakshman Seth, the don of Haldia...

[Radhikaranjan]

3. WB is India's densest state (> 900 ppl/ sq. km.). No one wants to curb that for obvious reasons. How do we deal with unemployment and smaller-by-the-day land holdings?

4. The politicians are a curse on our destiny. We are in the hands of remarkably mediocre people. Can Bengal MPs argue in the parliament? Can they even talk in English or Hindi?

[nijoflik]

Some one has taken this video in a nice mobile phone. Farmers of Nandigram do not have mobile phones, they are never going to have one in next 100 years. Because they have a small piece of land and that land will be divided into smaller pieces in the generations to come. The "intellectuals" have money to educate their children and they will go to other state/countries to take up jobs. And the people of Nandigram will remain poor forever. Intellectuals of Bengal you have done your duty.

[sudipbanerjee]

Few pepole are very worried about a "nice" mobile phone which can record a vedio. The are also worried about poor peasants of Nandigram who have small lands which "will be divided into smaller pieces in the generations to come". These people use a pseudo name for posting a comment on Youtube & take two weeks time to reply back (most probably for consulting what to write with fellow comraders).

[nijoflik]

Sudip,

I want my state to prosper and I want it for all, not only for intellectuals. Industrialisation is the only way to do it. In case you want to reply do it with some logic and make it a proper discussion forum. If you only hurl abuses that will only reflect poorly on you.

[sudipbanerjee]

Which type of logic you are talking about? That Binoy Kongar type? Take of your mask first & then talk to me.

[Radhikaranjan]

1. We need entrepreneurship, not 'industrialization'. Revoke the 44th amendment.

2. If WB is run by poets, we will have very bad governance. Text-weaving is no solution. Instead of telling others what they cannot do, the focus should be on what you can do.

[sudipbanerjee]

So...friends come be a pimp & let's gun down poor peasants to secure a bright future for "generations to come". Joy - Henceforth please take a go ahead from Alimuddin st. before reciting a poem else these worried people will become so proactive that they will wear a police uniforms & "Chappals" & make your life "hell".

[rakhalbalak]

I am dissapointed by Joy goswami.He has played in to the hands of the mindless naxals and mamata banerjee and others who want to hamper the Development of Bengal.Shame , shame.

But we will triumph and we will have the industry!

Shame on joy goswami!

[nknath]

Son Rakhal Son

Rakhal Sajar age

Garu chine ja

Budha baglar baro garu seta dekhe ja

Narakhdak janoar CPM ke dis support

Chok ta khule dek ekbar orai durnitir janak

Desher manus ke khun kore hoi na re development

CPM er mato manob satru pabi na e deshe kahon

Onek hoechhe ebar tui vulta sudhre phel

CPM ke mon theke puro muchhe phel

[rajuujra]

chrom atlami....

[topaz1958]

This will become a precious historical item

[kolkata300]

Thnx Joy...at least u are not a double standard

[udayan726]

Congrats, Joy. You were the only intellectual who spoke out against the Dhantala Mass Rape. Read about you in Udayan Namboodiri's "Bengal's Night Without End" and became your fan. Wonder where your boss, Sunil Gangopadhyay, is today. Is he hiding in some hole like Saddam Hussien? Or in Pakistan like Dawood Ibrahim?

[nijoflik]

Please do not drag Sunil into this. How much do you know about him, how much have you read from what he had written. You know what, people like you will probably not hesitate to say the same things about Swamiji, when your political interest is hurt. Sunil is neither a politician, nor he likes to make use of the pain and suffering of the innocent people for his own benefit.

People like you are dragging the whole state down. Shame on you.

Joy, please also recite, "he mor durghaga desh".

[udayan726]

You are like those Bengalis whose fatal attraction for Marxism-Leninism has resulted in the present desertification of the state in the first place. Now you want the people's faith for another chance. Have you ever wondered why no other state in India has welcomed these treacherous Communists? I will tell you why. After they called Subhas Chandra Bose a "dog" and betrayed the motherland during the Chinese invasion, they became untouchable in the rest of the country.

[topaz1958]

Sunil is a great poet. But what prevents him from coming out against Nandigram. I heard he takes to the streets at the request of his local MLA for CPI-M. But how about standing up for humanity ?

[sudipbanerjee]

nijoflik

What u r trying to tell? Joy is not also a policeman. The day when he was protesting Nandigram mass killiing, I was present there. I recorded the video on my mobile. There he compared Budhha with Narendra Modi. Don't u think he did the right thing? Or should he ask u for urs advise before raising his voice? Don't forget still there are few people who are nt really influenced by goebbel's "Big lie" theory.