I usually let comments like this die of loneliness, but not this time. Shame on you, ohvnaq! I applaud people who are trying to do something positive with their lives. Whether or not you agree, immature comments like yours made here in cyberspace won't stop them; and thankfully success is the best response to all of you 'haters'. Now I know why the vids are green - they are reflecting the jealousy. But Our Girl is still her beautiful, successful and brown self! ;-)
What an incredibly talented person! She will be one of the greats...one of the best that AI has ever had...the #1 and #2 last year are embarrasingly bad compared to her! Can't wait for her first CD...in June!
I magee with everyone... She is absolutely amazing!! Anyone know what she's up to as of NOW ;-) July 2007... I hate this month..it's another birthday 52 the upside is know that I've retired I can do what ever I want and when ever I feel like it plus I get to spoil my grandbabies... and of course then give them back
Melinda I love you I love you you are the best. Everey morning before I go to work I listen to you and mostly this song. You are the world to me. I hope you will perform in Amsterdam I will certainly be there
Listening to Melinda reminds me of interviews decades ago with Sarah Vaughn. Two women with the most beautiful voices ever! Melinda is far too much for American Idol to handle! What a star! God give her success! She deserves it, such a lady!
I am a Jordin fan, however Melinda is a brillant singer, too good for Idol in fact. She will do much better not winning the competition and going on to her own career. Jordin really needed Idol to do well, which she certainly will. Blake will have a wonderful solo career. Jordin will (hopefully) follow in Kelly's footsteps, and Melinda will be a broadway sensation.
Yes I agree. But Melinda will make it big-just like all the others who lost. In fact, aside from Kelly and Carrie, what other winne made it big? So let all of the Melinda fans buy tickets for her first smash broadway show!
Melinda absolutely had the best voice. I really thought the final would be the best voice (Melinda) vs. the most original (Blake) with Melinda winning... Without Melinda there, I have to vote for Blake's originality over Jordin's cookie-cutter style.
LETS BOYCOT VOTING NEXT WEEK's FINAL TWO (2)...Lets stand up for Melinda and justice. DO NOT VOTE...DO NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL next week! Fuck the show! Its rigged....Just like last year and Taylot Hicks! Switch to NBC's America's got talent!
Be smart and post a constructive remark for ONCE IN YOUR LIFE. This is a SINGING contest, NOT a beauty contest!!!WHEN ARE GONNA STOP LOOKING AT JUST SOMEONE'S PHYSICAL APPEARANCE BEFORE JUDGING THEM????
Melinda is an artist whose voice is able to express an incredible range of emotions. She can elevate a song to an epic level that is deeply moving. She doesn't need superficial gimmicks to distract from vocal inadequacies that many celebrity performers (and American Idol contestants) require to attract attention.
Any little thing to say it's british. That song was in the movie musical "Oliver" made in Britain in the 60's. So Idol had to find something since they couldn't get Michael Jackson permission to use those songs by The Beatle. All Michael asked is that they let him perform that night - and Idol didn't want that. MJ may be strange, but I'll bet that would have been the best show Idol ever had with a guest performer.
I agree with all positive comments about her, it is great that I am not the only Melinda addicted. Vote for her this tuesday pleaseee!! You are gifted, unique, sensational, talented, beautiful, because your inner beauty makes you a woman that many men would love to be with, you are the sweetes girl in the world. Way to go Melinda!!! congratulations. You are loveley.
LuLu didnt say she didnt have anything special ,, go back and listen..she said she didnt know how far she would go but Melinda was really shining,, bigtime..I believe Lulu didnt want to commit to her feeling and seem bias but was so impress she would have called it Melindas to win
lulu said she doesn't have that extra something-fair enough but when someone has a voice like this forget image forget prancing about a stage forget costumes you have to appreciate the talent
ps-that little girl needs a good slap-totally ruined that show for me-man will she be embarrased in years to come-annoying little shite!
People are going to say what they want about Melinda, the bottom line is she is the best singer on this show. And as long as we keep voting for her who cares what the haters say. Melinda has God in her life guiding her through this and her beauty is glowing and shows with every song. He has bless her with this great gift. IT IS MELINDA'S TIME TO SHINE!!! VOTE FOR MELINDA ON TUESDAY'S
i dont deny she's got a great voice...but just that doesnt make a real star....there are thousands of people out there with great voices who cant make it because they lack either look or personality...i used to like Melinda but she got me a little tired of the same sort of songs.
Melindas take is that she chose to sing it about her relationship with God..If you take it from that...its so beautiful and her rendition is timeless., I have listened over and over and still memerized,,,shes the greatest Gift thats come to the AI stage, I dont even want to anaylis it, just feel her with my heart....
I absolutely agree..God bless her more for blessing us, millions of viewers, with her inspiring performance.. She has the voice of an angel..I feel closer to the Lord everytime I listen to her...
OK, first listening to. I don't care for the song, but her vocal is impeccable. I think I actually think her vocal is far better than the arrangement for the accompaning band. I said it before and will say it again, she could sing the phonebook and make it sound good.
"Boring?" Sad that folks like you can't appreciate true talent. Haley's "presentation" consisted of her laboring around the stage in ridiculously short shorts and high heels. Her singing was an atrocity. If you consider that true talent you are the exact reason why idiots like Britney Spears and Lindsay Lohan sell records.
oh but she was hot hot hot....and that's what entertainment is about. Seriously, I'd rather watch Haley than the boring and ugly Melinda...or Britney or Lindsay for that matter...but I'd listen to Melinda before going to sleep..thats for sure! lol
technically it is about a wife beater. the song is from the musical oliver, and this song is sung by the lead woman who is beaten terribley and thrown out by her lover of many years. and she sings that she'll always be there for him... it's pretty awfull in the musical, but that doens't mean she can't take it and make it her own. i think she does a great job with it. i don't know if it classifies as 'british invasion'... but she is SO good, i don't care.
No but I don't think the musicians realize it either. Also, it's from a musical. Just because it's British doesn't mean it was part of the pop music phenomena that was the British invasion.
I just can't get enough of her, very, very good!!!
tcevans1962 2 years ago
fabulous!!!!
Cissyskin 2 years ago
I love how the one girl is crying in the audience!
wannabesurfahgirl 2 years ago
Shut the hell down hater.s
Good song
duvy1234 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Didn't The Hulk and Shrek make it into this competition?
ohvnaq 3 years ago
I usually let comments like this die of loneliness, but not this time. Shame on you, ohvnaq! I applaud people who are trying to do something positive with their lives. Whether or not you agree, immature comments like yours made here in cyberspace won't stop them; and thankfully success is the best response to all of you 'haters'. Now I know why the vids are green - they are reflecting the jealousy. But Our Girl is still her beautiful, successful and brown self! ;-)
GriotLori 3 years ago 2
heheh relax, that joke is on the video quality not on Melinda.
ohvnaq 3 years ago
why are all of your videos green ????
jhstha 3 years ago
WOW
thehbss 3 years ago
i love it xx
xxxxno1lulufanxxxx 3 years ago
diva!
netvana 3 years ago 4
What an incredibly talented person! She will be one of the greats...one of the best that AI has ever had...the #1 and #2 last year are embarrasingly bad compared to her! Can't wait for her first CD...in June!
crazy4tudors 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what's up whit shreks
kadilec1984 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
when she sits on the stage she looks like fiona in shrek!^^ great singer thoug!
wchguy1 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ur right!
annikam07 3 years ago
this lady is blessed
timitrad 4 years ago 8
Melinda is amazing but is it only me or does she look green color in this video???
shopboy76 4 years ago 2
lol --- i know! some sort of alien- but i love her....
rockoshmucko 4 years ago 2
Thankyou for putting this on YouTube. I have only just found out I can see my best tv moments on this site so Im having a ball!!!!
Melinda is brill and I was bereft when she got voted out. I stopped watching after that.
shonagrais 4 years ago
they look green
urox10 4 years ago
A Nightingale sang in Berkeley Square....
It also sang on American Idol...!!
I may be right, I may be wrong,
But I'm perfectly willing to swear
That when you turned and smiled at me,
A nightingale sang in Berkeley Square.
thehbss 4 years ago
Ellas es la mejor participante de AI espero que saque un cd....
angr3 4 years ago
i love her she so shouls have won
sexytime1576 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
see how a hot chick loses a bet and has to strip in front of her classmates <b>(_stripAss.com_)<b>
ugiwuleogelar 4 years ago
She is my very favorite.
mangler 4 years ago
I magee with everyone... She is absolutely amazing!! Anyone know what she's up to as of NOW ;-) July 2007... I hate this month..it's another birthday 52 the upside is know that I've retired I can do what ever I want and when ever I feel like it plus I get to spoil my grandbabies... and of course then give them back
PhloxyFlowers 4 years ago
Love you Melinda!
Backup #664 :)
linelu235 4 years ago
This is my fave melinda performance as it is so laid back, powerful and amazing all at once. It's absolutely fantastic. keep up the good work.
damostar03 4 years ago
Please record an album! I want to buy your music so I can always listen to it.....
anncarmen 4 years ago
Melinda I love you I love you you are the best. Everey morning before I go to work I listen to you and mostly this song. You are the world to me. I hope you will perform in Amsterdam I will certainly be there
bakboordsoefa 4 years ago
woooooooooooooooow!!! it's fantastic! I love it from Hungary!!!!!!!!
nupono 4 years ago
Listening to Melinda reminds me of interviews decades ago with Sarah Vaughn. Two women with the most beautiful voices ever! Melinda is far too much for American Idol to handle! What a star! God give her success! She deserves it, such a lady!
lilarose1941 4 years ago
superstar
padillow 4 years ago
I am a Jordin fan, however Melinda is a brillant singer, too good for Idol in fact. She will do much better not winning the competition and going on to her own career. Jordin really needed Idol to do well, which she certainly will. Blake will have a wonderful solo career. Jordin will (hopefully) follow in Kelly's footsteps, and Melinda will be a broadway sensation.
divingdolphin137 4 years ago
damm!!!no question...you should be the winner.....dreams really come true
djeanken 4 years ago
Yes, she really is POR MUCHO the true American Idol..
CamyZuniga 4 years ago
Yes, she really is indeed the true American Idol..
cuetie 4 years ago
can't just have enough of this lady. i rush to youtube daily just to watch her sing. she is the true american idol indeed!
ronkeakpe 4 years ago
??? lol
cassieNO1fan 4 years ago
AI is totally rigged! Melinda and Lekisha should have been top 2. Jordan should have been out with Blake!
scarlett24ca 4 years ago
Yes I agree. But Melinda will make it big-just like all the others who lost. In fact, aside from Kelly and Carrie, what other winne made it big? So let all of the Melinda fans buy tickets for her first smash broadway show!
piccadilly321 4 years ago
She is THE TRUE AMERICAN IDOL....Blake and Jordin will be competing for AMERICAN IDIOT...I will buy Melinda`s CDs
starswillcollide 4 years ago
Melinda absolutely had the best voice. I really thought the final would be the best voice (Melinda) vs. the most original (Blake) with Melinda winning... Without Melinda there, I have to vote for Blake's originality over Jordin's cookie-cutter style.
nytetime 4 years ago
LETS BOYCOT VOTING NEXT WEEK's FINAL TWO (2)...Lets stand up for Melinda and justice. DO NOT VOTE...DO NOT WATCH AMERICAN IDOL next week! Fuck the show! Its rigged....Just like last year and Taylot Hicks! Switch to NBC's America's got talent!
ckhuerckh 4 years ago
I agree. She was jacked.
yeatrip 4 years ago
chal804 - why do u watch clips with her if u can't stand her? I presume that u can't even pull 2 notes ot of your mouth so shut the f**k up!
signum201 4 years ago
She makes the album i ll be the one whos buying it..she gives me goospumps..what a voice what a girl!
undraaus 4 years ago
Be smart and post a constructive remark for ONCE IN YOUR LIFE. This is a SINGING contest, NOT a beauty contest!!!WHEN ARE GONNA STOP LOOKING AT JUST SOMEONE'S PHYSICAL APPEARANCE BEFORE JUDGING THEM????
cosmiclove78 4 years ago
so what!!!!!!!!!!????????
cosmiclove78 4 years ago
She sings from her beautiful heart. She carries a bright light within her. Touching
rudy712 4 years ago
she already WON! .^)
overtime2005 4 years ago
She will be the next American legend...boring? y'all are boring with your lame comments....she is more than incredible....
nyrinsf 4 years ago
I want her to win!!!!
lyssalu2006 4 years ago
She is excellent!!!!!!!!!!!!!
harcab 4 years ago
Melinda is an artist whose voice is able to express an incredible range of emotions. She can elevate a song to an epic level that is deeply moving. She doesn't need superficial gimmicks to distract from vocal inadequacies that many celebrity performers (and American Idol contestants) require to attract attention.
misterchangman 4 years ago
her voice is like silk... it's so smooth
chickydoo 4 years ago
melinda is a great singer
jenniferroses 4 years ago
Im so sorry, I feel this was her most boring and worst performance.:( I prefer her top 12 song choice: home...
thebigL90 4 years ago
*YAAWWN* Soooo Boring...Btw what was this song doing in the "British Invasion" week?
sherinesam 4 years ago
Any little thing to say it's british. That song was in the movie musical "Oliver" made in Britain in the 60's. So Idol had to find something since they couldn't get Michael Jackson permission to use those songs by The Beatle. All Michael asked is that they let him perform that night - and Idol didn't want that. MJ may be strange, but I'll bet that would have been the best show Idol ever had with a guest performer.
dustee 4 years ago
cuz u idiot....oliver is a british musical....and melinda is brilliant WOOOHOO!!
crzy4mulans 4 years ago
I agree with all positive comments about her, it is great that I am not the only Melinda addicted. Vote for her this tuesday pleaseee!! You are gifted, unique, sensational, talented, beautiful, because your inner beauty makes you a woman that many men would love to be with, you are the sweetes girl in the world. Way to go Melinda!!! congratulations. You are loveley.
fuckingcool69 4 years ago
As long as she win this competition...
she deserve it!!!
chatrabbita 4 years ago
I don't know what to say! She's is simply AWESOME!!
manangalice 4 years ago
LuLu didnt say she didnt have anything special ,, go back and listen..she said she didnt know how far she would go but Melinda was really shining,, bigtime..I believe Lulu didnt want to commit to her feeling and seem bias but was so impress she would have called it Melindas to win
spiritinoneness 4 years ago
lulu said she doesn't have that extra something-fair enough but when someone has a voice like this forget image forget prancing about a stage forget costumes you have to appreciate the talent
ps-that little girl needs a good slap-totally ruined that show for me-man will she be embarrased in years to come-annoying little shite!
stedelicious 4 years ago
lol!!
MizzYoli 4 years ago
Melinda is amazing!!!
whitty4u 4 years ago
People are going to say what they want about Melinda, the bottom line is she is the best singer on this show. And as long as we keep voting for her who cares what the haters say. Melinda has God in her life guiding her through this and her beauty is glowing and shows with every song. He has bless her with this great gift. IT IS MELINDA'S TIME TO SHINE!!! VOTE FOR MELINDA ON TUESDAY'S
ttstith 4 years ago
This was a beautiful performance.
she looks like a very sweet person.
3plo 4 years ago
i dont deny she's got a great voice...but just that doesnt make a real star....there are thousands of people out there with great voices who cant make it because they lack either look or personality...i used to like Melinda but she got me a little tired of the same sort of songs.
iamreallyfree 4 years ago
Uh oh...don't dare do a slow song two weeks in a row!
sojourner06 4 years ago
Such control! Yes, she should win the competition. And second place should go to Jordin Sparks.
hetoimasai 4 years ago
Absolutely phenomenal.
embalyst 4 years ago
Melindas take is that she chose to sing it about her relationship with God..If you take it from that...its so beautiful and her rendition is timeless., I have listened over and over and still memerized,,,shes the greatest Gift thats come to the AI stage, I dont even want to anaylis it, just feel her with my heart....
spiritinoneness 4 years ago
I absolutely agree..God bless her more for blessing us, millions of viewers, with her inspiring performance.. She has the voice of an angel..I feel closer to the Lord everytime I listen to her...
GreatKM 4 years ago
She is Brilliant.
carltoncolville 4 years ago
OK, first listening to. I don't care for the song, but her vocal is impeccable. I think I actually think her vocal is far better than the arrangement for the accompaning band. I said it before and will say it again, she could sing the phonebook and make it sound good.
grandcarriage 4 years ago
don't make fun of them. shhhhh.. they may be special.
overtime2005 4 years ago
"Boring?" Sad that folks like you can't appreciate true talent. Haley's "presentation" consisted of her laboring around the stage in ridiculously short shorts and high heels. Her singing was an atrocity. If you consider that true talent you are the exact reason why idiots like Britney Spears and Lindsay Lohan sell records.
dork99l 4 years ago
man is haley atrocious! melinda is incredible!!! enough said...
berkeleygirlie 4 years ago
oh but she was hot hot hot....and that's what entertainment is about. Seriously, I'd rather watch Haley than the boring and ugly Melinda...or Britney or Lindsay for that matter...but I'd listen to Melinda before going to sleep..thats for sure! lol
iamreallyfree 4 years ago
Melinda may be the BEST singer I have ever heard!
sojourner06 4 years ago
I listened to this song several times, and don't see how you can interpret this as a song about a wife beater. BTW she is awesome
LFSCajun 4 years ago
technically it is about a wife beater. the song is from the musical oliver, and this song is sung by the lead woman who is beaten terribley and thrown out by her lover of many years. and she sings that she'll always be there for him... it's pretty awfull in the musical, but that doens't mean she can't take it and make it her own. i think she does a great job with it. i don't know if it classifies as 'british invasion'... but she is SO good, i don't care.
italiananikolita1212 4 years ago
She's an accomplished singer. Just that it's getting a bit boring, makes you crave something like Haley's presentation...
kimwatts 4 years ago
This is a song about a woman whose husband beats her. Does Melinda realize this?
strongthomas 4 years ago
No but I don't think the musicians realize it either. Also, it's from a musical. Just because it's British doesn't mean it was part of the pop music phenomena that was the British invasion.
TulseLuper 4 years ago