Crime and Punishment. Theory of Raskolnikov

[cypnat22]

The book is a masterpiece !

[njherdfan]

This is exactly how I pictured Raskolnikov, but not Porfiry.

[StamfordLegend]

I didnt understand any of this... but it is the best thin1g ive seen ever! Beautiful! I love raskolnikov i wish he killed more jerks like ivanova! old soomka

[bragunovskoie]

The best Raskolnikov i´ve ever seen. He is handsome , by the way...( i´m not gay, just saying xD)

[TEXS713]

thats pretty much how i pictured raskolnikov (maybe a little younger) and razumihin. but porfiry is way of from what i imagined.

[TheFirerampage]

Best adaptation so far.

[14Srb88]

A title and video info in English,but whole video in Russia,doesnt make much sense now does it.....

[LiteraryWriter]

Like Wuthering Heights, the geometry in Crime and Punishment is staggering. The complex relations, the intellectual concepts, the descent of a superman into the abyss of self-discovery. How painful it must have been for Raskolnikov to come to grips with his own ordinary place in the great scheme of things. He is not a Napoleon, he is an average man, weak, pathetic. He crossed the line and killed not only an old woman, but  an innocent girl and her unborn baby. In the end, he killed himself.

[eXTreemator]

Hey, read this novel only in Russian. In English it loses its peculiar charm.

@LiteraryWriter

what are you talking about. He didn't kill himself.

[LiteraryWriter]

@eXTreemator He says it himself in the novel, that he did not kill the old woman, but himself. He killed the man as a moral being. As Dostoevsky believed, if there is no God, there is no man.

[CarboCraze]

@LiteraryWriter He did not kill himself. He was sentenced for 8 years in Siberia prison. He found his motivation to live in the end, when he realizes he look forward to life with Sonia -who moved to Siberia with him and without fail visited him regularly in the prison.

[f1ghtclub2k3]

actually Nietzsche read The Idiot also

[stuckonautomatic]

Some fail to realize that Dostoyevsky completely dismisses Raskolnikov's theory.

R. not only confesses because Petrovich has got him but for he seizes that there are no people who ought to have the right "to transgress the law in any way just because they happen to be extraordinary"--let alone that he is one of them.

D. makes a point about religion as the atheist R. becomes a christian in the end...yet I don't necessarily agree with D. that R.'s idea could only arise in an atheistic mind.

[gloi2]

hey guys i come back and fuck dostoevsky:)

[darknessoftheworld]

BEST RASKOLNIKOV!!!!

[holmsatlarge]

I think that John Hurt`s interpretation is superior.I can`t find it on y-tube.

[25473ali]

great great great dostoyevski

[Nekronn]

where can i get english subs for this?? can someone help me?

[AtomicBobBomb]

if you search "Crime and Punishment (1969)" you can find the whole film with english subtitles. I think this scene is somewhere in the beginning of the second half, but I could be wrong.

[slashblog]

Hahaha! so what! i love all rapists

[Trtmrtidesmrt]

He was a genius and you are one big idiot!

[perksy10001]

raped who? to write possessed or devils, what are you on?

[gloi2]

the shit was canceled in devils appeared in the possessed ,

[bohogirl10]

I love that guy...

[ZdravstvuyetFer]

Who is the director of this version???...and the year???

[Movzhuru]

Lev Kulidzhanov, 1969

[ZdravstvuyetFer]

Thanks!!!, the master Kulidzhanov!...and the great novel of the XIX century

[Elvuz]

This version is simply the best of all this book's adaptations. And for me that's matter of nature - the book is Russian, written in Russian, the protagonists are Russians, so the adaptation should be made by Russian in Russian language.

[TomMonty81]

New contemporary version of notes from the underground on youtube for free: v=SBmdCFS2cOg

Find all parts via my channel...

[mwmzms]

thank you so much for this!! Love Russian literature and art! And one of my favourites writers is Dostojewski, brilliant book and movie too!

[keven00009]

does anyone know what nikodem fomitch looks like, i can't seem to find a physical description, and i really need to know so that i can dress like him for my project due this wednesday, plz send me an e-mail if you know what he Physically looks like (i.e., to email me, just press reply next to the message up at the right.) thanks again!

[indianhillbilly]

i don't think this man is.

[indianhillbilly]

Raskolnikov was exceptionally handsome.

[spectralrealm]

umm does anyone know if there is a version of the same movie with sub-titles?? I would love to get this version of C&P but i saw it on amazon for like 60 dollars lol...and its not even with subs. Dam. I tried another version with John Hart..if i'm writing his name correctly..I order that one..seems to be okay, but this one looks even better.

[weirdchickwee]

DAMNIT i wish i knew how to read russian....my english version has a lot of lost in translation issues haha

[jazzmanEE]

Rasklonikov is back heh he he...

I dont think i wanna see C&P in movie form..it spoils the whole vision of the Dostoyevki masterpiece that i have in my head.

[batalion666]

I think "Match point" by Woody Allen has Dostoyvskis ideas.

[FoxDougan]

Shame that it was rubbish

[batalion666]

try also :"Castle" by Kafka,"Red Room" by Strindberg and "Journey..."by Celine.

[jazzmanEE]

"The Fall" by Camus is another existentialist masterpiece and of course "the Castle" which happens to be my favorite Kafka book.

[Sargathia]

finally Raskolnikov is portrayed as a normal, good looking blonde like he's described in the book; most film versions and representations show him as an unattractive weirdo

[sockhopskotch]

You mean Hurt, Glover, and Dempsey(I mean, wtf)didn't do it for you? lol.

[slavophile1]

He had dark hair in the book.

[spectralrealm]

I agree, although like here, in the book his hair was dark, dark brown not blonde. Anyways, yeah he is perfect for the role. ^_^

[glennbeckfan10]

@Sargathia

My thoughts exactly. I bought a Crime and Punishment comic book about 5 years ago and Rask looked like a lecherous and unkempt pedophile. He is clearly described as a strikingly handsome young man.

[EuNaoSei]

Best book ever.

[Ortzmet]

Does anyone know where one might obtain a copy of THIS particular film version of "Crime and Punishment"?

[edilonr]

In program eMule, find by "Преступление и наказание" and download the files:

"Преступление и н наказание - 1 серия_фильм 1969 г._ Достоевский Ф.М._ CD1_качество - 5"

and

"Преступление и н наказание - 2 серия_фильм 1969 г._ Достоевский Ф.М._ CD1_качество - 5"

[aibek]

its not free though..

[fernandorosdav]

"The ordinary people must lead a life of strict obedience and have no right to transgress the law because ... they are ordinary. Whereas the extraordinary people have the right to commit any crime they like and transgress the law in any way just because they happen to be extraordinary" to me thats dostoevsky most famous statement

[Manzeron]

i realy prefer the book...

[Jitpring]

Of course the book is better. It's one of the greatest ever written.

[ashkank2002]

Anyone knows where can I find this film? preferably with English subtitle? Thank you

[MariLynWells]

And where do you live?

[ashkank2002]

London

[MariLynWells]

Oh..I don't know..try to search it in internet shops...

[ashkank2002]

ok thanks

[MariLynWells]

Actually Nietzsche stole it)) He loved Dostoevsky very much

[caceter]

thats the dumbest thing ever heard,he was a philosopher you dumbfuck

[0x68]

Nietzsche did claim that Dostoevsky was the only psychologist with whom he was "en rapport," but it is very unlikely that he had any familiarity with Crime and Punishment. The only work of Dostoevsky's ever mentioned in Nietzsche's notes is The House of the Dead. Even a casual search will give you a tremendous amount of information about this subject, and I recommend you do so since it is clear that you have a superficial and erroneous conception of Nietzsche.

[MariLynWells]

Sorry, I told it in  a little ironic way. Dostoevsky predicted a lot of things, which happened after him.

[fernandorosdav]

Nietzche's "Beyong Good and Evil" was entirely inspired by Dostoevsky's "Posessed", it is Dostoevsky who began the existentialist movement, not Nietzche

[vidaest]

Actually, if you think about it, even Shakespeare exhibits certain existentialist ideas. Nietzsche and Kierkegaard might not have been the *fathers* of the idea as usually credited, but they established it philosophically.

[emhs08]

what language is this?

[Kalid0scop3]

Russian.

[Marhoff]

Ese es un libro maravilloso!

[MariLynWells]

Yeah, me too

[necrophallus]

Love it!