Well, you can't possibly compare Rachel with Kelly Clarkson ... Obviously Kelly is a better singer. But, Rachel sings reallly well here .. Gotta giv her some credit
how is she better than the original?!? No doubt that she sings pretty well, but her voice is definitely not strong enough for this song. Kelly still own this song.
omg, i also LUV amy huang, but i LUV LIANG WEN YING 2 so sad tht she only got 2nd place in the contest!!!! i like ANNIE 2 btw my nickname is annie, and im annie of all of us
lol its okay. just make sure you get it right hte next time.most people dont even acknowledge the fact that taiwan and china are two COMPLETELY different places....
Two complete different places with same race - CHINESE! The most important is that we are chinese, im chinese from Malaysia too, i love my own country but i love who i am! IM CHINESE!!! Malaysian born Chinese!! Chinese is second bigger population in Malaysia!!
Nice! :)
katarinamarkovic93 2 weeks ago
不虧是英文系的 發音真好 !
Vincent26911121 1 month ago
文音高音爆發力不夠~~沒有將because of you的經典唱出 ~~miu則有~~不光只是說這首~其他就不一定~
beck520520 2 months ago
梁文音 就是紅
nickytl 8 months ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
差miu一點 不過已是超班
beck520520 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
台式英文 梁文英唱歌太會拖音了 而且錯露百出 不耐聽 園唱聲音比較沙啞比較有感覺
d6665412 1 year ago
不错,很好(:有味道,虽然跟原唱很像。 英语发音不错。 加油!
不管是英语或华语,都很好(:
Whackyourasshole 1 year ago 4
不會八
朱是唱的不錯
但英文發音很糟糕
ph92800 1 year ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@ph92800 聽起來比梁文音好= =
beck520520 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
還是朱俐靜比較強耶@@
beck520520 1 year ago
她對歌曲的深情最吸引人,聽她唱歌寒毛都會站起來..拍拍手
fireflying123 1 year ago 11
最動人的就是她的感情,聽她唱歌寒毛都會站起來拍拍手
fireflying123 1 year ago 7
of coz because she is a degree holder i love rachel ^^
maxdemon1208 1 year ago 3
文音超會唱!!!人又美~~~~
RyO531 1 year ago 8
雖然唱的是同一首歌,但是無法比較,因為這個影片在中間斷掉了,我不知道她有沒有唱後面難度最高的部分。
good373844 1 year ago
不太好聽 原唱最好
yongyong93080 1 year ago
文音 的感情投入得十分好,
唱歌不是比用力....
感情絕對才是感動人的要素!
RyO531 1 year ago 19
she can sing it the other style anyway...not bad...a gd try~
kiyeonshi 2 years ago 6
she can speak english really well
KayKrazie 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
Come on~~please listen to the version of Miu~~And you,ll see who is better~Omg~~the champion is far better than this second prize
beck520520 2 years ago
你们很会批评哦?不如你唱一唱然后上载去youtube吧?
你懂什么是唱歌吗?唱歌不代表唱得像原唱一样就代表他很专业,而是唱出自己的风格。
为什么周杰伦不是那么帅但是那么出名?因为咬字不清是他的风格。别人怎么模仿,到最后还不是一句模仿周杰伦
tiduschen 2 years ago 18
喜欢文音唱的,细腻、柔和、宏亮,丝丝入扣
NekaSunny 2 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
舒服不代表好聽
梁文音唱過的好歌不少
但絕不包含這首
wale068 2 years ago
為什麼朱俐靜唱歌一定要這麼用力
文音的版本比較舒服
peter60207 2 years ago 14
為什麼永遠不要與原唱相比?
原唱就一定是完美, 無懈可擊的嗎?
能夠出唱片專輯的, 不代表有那麼實力
十之八九跟歌唱實力不成正比的
wale068 2 years ago
一個是現場演唱, 一個在錄音室裡怎麼比?
梁文音唱歌要看歌詞, miu演唱情緒舖陳比較完整.....我比較喜歡miu的版本
wale068 2 years ago
@wale068 Miu 誰 ?
j00612 8 months ago 4
@j00612 miu就是朱俐靜拉沒看超偶喔
k51907 7 months ago
WEN YIN JIA YOU!!!!!!!!!!
memoriesinmyhead 2 years ago 4
If Liang is the original and Kelly did a cover, you people will criticize Kelly sings not strong enough COMPARE WITH LIANG
If Liang sings like Kelly than you people will criticize Liang just follow the original without no personal style
What do you want then?!
Comparison is really meaningless!!!
and unfair to both
axtscti 2 years ago 13
I think Miu sings better~but her performance is also great
beck520520 2 years ago
her english is not up to standard yet. she is not tht gd here. but i m still a fan of her(: Jiayou Rachel Liang Wen Ying!
gabriellasexwithtroy 2 years ago 7
Big merit to Rachel Liang as a new young Asian singer to have such a remarkable voice and performance here.
It's already big credits to her people start considering comparisons with a world legend singer like Kelly.
Let's give your thumb up for such talented promising voice :)
vanceleehc2 2 years ago 14
Well, you can't possibly compare Rachel with Kelly Clarkson ... Obviously Kelly is a better singer. But, Rachel sings reallly well here .. Gotta giv her some credit
Kwonzz 2 years ago 4
compare not complete
有學會一件事嗎?永遠不要與原唱相比
mandyfd510 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
Too far to complete with Kelly Clarkson.
CSYNCTP 2 years ago
compete...
not complete
tvvluver37 2 years ago 5
how is she better than the original?!? No doubt that she sings pretty well, but her voice is definitely not strong enough for this song. Kelly still own this song.
rbwilly168 2 years ago 15
We all know that Kelly owns this song, but for a Taiwanese, I think LWY sang really well. I am sure there r many people who agree with me.
siqi246 2 years ago 22
She really sings well! Great looks. Hope that she'll have another CD soon.
siqi246 2 years ago 10
文音超令女!!!
唱歌又好好聽!!!
有實力有樣^^
mcchan999 2 years ago 57
she is the best. better than original singer.
chauyuan 2 years ago 2
yay! good asian with good english! whee~
YaoLeong 2 years ago 12
omg, i also LUV amy huang, but i LUV LIANG WEN YING 2 so sad tht she only got 2nd place in the contest!!!! i like ANNIE 2 btw my nickname is annie, and im annie of all of us
xyirumaproductionsx 2 years ago
there's definitely only one kelly clarkson.
neways she sings really good too tho. her english is pretty for good.
hnubno 2 years ago 4
i prefer hers to Kelly's!!!
Dimgues 2 years ago
for a china person singing an english song like that is already a great accomplishment! :D
BAM, LIANG WEN YING OWNS.
xiiaoMALTcandy 2 years ago
shes from taiwan, not china. GOSH.
TappyMonkey 2 years ago
okay SORRY I DIDN'T KNOW THAT.
LOL;x
i must go improve on my geog! xD
xiiaoMALTcandy 2 years ago
lol its okay. just make sure you get it right hte next time.most people dont even acknowledge the fact that taiwan and china are two COMPLETELY different places....
TappyMonkey 2 years ago 4
Two complete different places with same race - CHINESE! The most important is that we are chinese, im chinese from Malaysia too, i love my own country but i love who i am! IM CHINESE!!! Malaysian born Chinese!! Chinese is second bigger population in Malaysia!!
wonbin3699 2 years ago 3
這首歌的感情雖然文音沒有表達出來~~
可是唱得很有自己的味道^^
相信文音用這首歌去比美國偶像~~一定也會得到評審的青睞!!
pili78919 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
去美國偶像 肯定馬上被淘汰
因為她的英文咬字很破 歌聲也很一般
加上美國評審也較重實力與公正
不會亂搞包庇與亂吹捧
tea550 2 years ago
it depends........somehow i feel like as if asian singing contests' judges are tougher....
luvkk831 2 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
美國like a shit ! Shitty US
angeltimsss 2 years ago
where'd you get this? - are there other xing guang bang 2's reneditions of other songs?
jwangphp3 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not very good
yvette74731 3 years ago
那伴奏是Kelly Clarkson的原聲呢.....原唱聲音太有爆發力所以合在一起的時候變奇怪了....可惜!
Capricieuse1989 3 years ago 9
好像不够爆发力。可能是我本来就爱原唱的版本吧!
可是还是非常有特色。
文音诠释得很棒呢!!!
fionawong1986 3 years ago 14
wen yin sing so good in this English songs!!
vnie86 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
She's only good when she sings alone. She sucks when she does duets.
somkit 3 years ago
wow so pretty :)
BlackMoonGoddess 3 years ago 8
文音的高音始终是最好的
lilevebabee 3 years ago 14
文音是最棒的!!!!
gamercab 3 years ago 17
i think i fall in love with her hahah
manaelixer 3 years ago 20
I am afraid
alow3 3 years ago
非常同意hippokings16的話
這首歌一開始真的迷倒我..
最喜歡文音這些歌
mandy92510 3 years ago 20
big range big range this song the range is so big, after heard wen ying sang more big so great
danaitykane41 3 years ago 13
文音有些發音真的很迷人
hippokings16 3 years ago 48
good!!^^
hippokings16 3 years ago 15
我覺得梁文音的英文還不錯, 有一些發音還蠻吸引人的, 像"around".
Jcxzero 3 years ago 26