Haley Reinhart - I Who Have Nothing (Studio version)

[lyly7nily]

she should have won:(:(

[PandaPawez]

I prefer Mary Byrnes version(:

[ifreakforbleach]

I like it except for how scratchy her voice is

[dblubarry]

@ifreakforbleach thats what makes haley, haley. i love it.

[aungkyawthu22]

Haley! Why do you take all of my mind? I can't stop listening to your music. Haley! I love you.

[100flyingfish]

reminds me of James Hetfield

[kgb1773]

everything she sings just straight up gives me chills.

[emilyhalfacre1]

i had this song stuck in my head all day and its not-even catchy :P

[becka691]

she is a god.



[PanderflyLUV]

She's alright, but she lacks the power and passion in this song.

[233roz]

@PanderflyLUV What are you tone deaf and nuts

[kitteykatt17]

God. I love this song only cuz she did it.

[kbrod90210]

someone know if Haley will to make an album ??

[click4bio]

@kbrod90210 yess!!! she's in the process of making her debut album... She got signed by Interscope

[hollowhead86]

@click4bio

OMFG!! Are you serious??!!

[233roz]

@kbrod90210 She is working on it and recording now.

[ZetaChiGammaZeta1012]

@kbrod90210

Yeah she has a record deal with interscope records.

[bikermann42]

Yeah! "Classic moment with classic Haley".

Hit 'classic' in the reaction box!

[HidingInDarkCorners]

@HalienNation1 so I'm not going crazy?! I'm absolutely addicted to this song and I really doubt that's going to change anytime soon.

[HidingInDarkCorners]

I'm absolutely obsessed with this song and this girl and her voice. oh my god.

[HalienNation1]

@HidingInDarkCorners You have all the symptoms of a Halien -- welcome to the club -- the addiction that noone really wants to overcome.

[fantasmalness]

@jaska444 she sounds much, much, much better singing this song live. SO MUCH better. 

[galc905]

@jaska444 sorry YOU, cause Haley really has feeling when she sings, take a chance to listen to the live version of this song watch?v=QCvYTijYDfE&feature=re­lated is WAY better than who you are mentioning, who RUNS trying to sing the song a little bit different and ended singing really bad though having a great voice. As a musician, this is my opinion and I know many people will agree with this.

[233roz]

@jaska444 You must be sick , demented or intellectually challenged.

[jaska444]

@233roz How come? Because I have the courage to say that he was an idiot instead of following the hurd of people who can not think with their own brain and only say things because it "sounds nice" ???

[233roz]

@jaska444 Why don't you go somewhere where you will be wanted. Only Haliens come to these pages, so you do not fit the description. We only allow nice people here. You don't fill the bill. You are a sad sad dude and are not welcome. You have been flagged and deleted, and the internet police might be looking for you.

[n9zro]

I liked her AI Live version better, More raw energy and passion when she was in the fight ! She is a looker !

[MrDokajan]

I like how for this version the team actually put some effort to slightly change the lyrics and in the end the song's lyrics sounds adequate

[grissanchez100]

Shes awsome!

[jollokka1aqua]

Haley is amazing singer !<3 

[rcir2]

Hands down a great recording. This chick as it all. Clearly she's a winner.

[Crazy4guys10]

Best song of hers.

She has quite a voice.

[jazztori]

i think pia should have won the whole thing

[Laxeroc]

@Laxeroc Pia was boring. She sang the same power ballad type songs every week, despite the judges telling her to change it up. I think she got exactly what she deserved.

[MrNothing43]

im in love.

[pastorsito84]

Such a good artist

[animalbaran]

Haley should have won.... end of story.

[sarahmackeroni]

i love this! i love her!

[dillpicklezTM]

youtube needs to fix this... the video is only showing my views

[rjg0316]

This studio version is just a teaser of what she can do live! For sure have heard her live performances...truly amazing...You'll just want to hear her more live!

[reecedaring12]

Everytime i listen to this and she hits the word "adore" i get chills!!

[JBieberNSN]

She was so good when i saw her live. Studio versions are pretty boring compared to the real deal.

[bluewhale18]

I actually love both

Live and Studio

anything that Haley touches turns to gold

[KewlGirl357]

Press 1 over and over again

[CallieAnn111]

She's the only artist I prefer live over studio. Who's with me?

[smorrill1959]

@CallieAnn111 I can't believe how much better she sings live! Most singers, it is the other way around! :-)

[CallieAnn111]

@smorrill1959 True dat (:

[nfried1]

@CallieAnn111 it isnt her voice its the studio people

[Divinenite]

omg how could you sound so good?! i wish i was a music producer, she'd be my top artist in the company

[TayTay5289]

funny how, we all say tht she is better than Lauren and Scotty and all them and deserved to win, when rly, its our fault for not voting........................­....I know I did :)

[xxblackonyxlovexx]

HOLY SHIT. She needs to get an album, like now.

[TayTay5289]

@xxblackonyxlovexx she does, its in stores now :)

[awsomekid630]

@TayTay5289 whats the name of the album?

[hannahmace1234]

I love this song.!!

[floodedtick]

Sorry for breaking you replay button : /

[joelritzwitt]

her live version of this gave me an erection. this didnt

[DaGavinX]

Ugh, Haley doesn't need that much effects. Just leave her do her thing naturally.

[CallieAnn111]

@DaGavinX yeah 

[beast1022]

DAM - havent listened to this version for few days - it is different BUT WOW HALEY GIVES HER ALL - HER VOICE IS JUST OUT-OF-THIS WORLD AWESOME - fact is this studio version is sooo much softer tha her AI version - STILL SHE HAS A VOICE LIKE NO OTHER!!! Haley WILL TAKE THE WORLD BY STORM - VOTE-VOTE-VOTE PPL!!!

[beast1022]

I AM UTTERLY W/O words here... 1st time listening to her studio version... her EP 'IF' it contains THIS version... OMG... NO WAY will there b enuf to go around the world!!! HALEY IS THE MOST BEAUIFUL EVER on AI... AI bashed her & look @ what she gives US... PURE PASSION w/all her performances... there WONT B another like her on AI!! Haley WAS the best AI EVER... nobody comes even close to her talent. I AM IN AWE!!!!

[renduke]

@beast1022 she should do herself a favor her live versions are always better....when she's live there is no one better no one...........this song is the best of her stuido but live is still better

[ninipiniluv]

i cant believe that scotty won... haley should have won! she was the best!

[luxurylass]

@ninipiniluv TELL THAT TO THE ASS KISSING HALIENS-- I GUESS THEY FORGOT TO VOTE HER

[JEP433]

i've been listening to this nonstop for 6 hours.. i'm being serious. hahaha.

[oldyeller1994]

@JEP433 so have i! haha shes my favoorite idol in years

[MarianaPecora]

goooooooooooooooooddd whyy????? fuck america.

[poseidonbluegurl]

1:34 gave me the most chills :) your amazing haley <3

[xXxPho3nix]

O.o lets all diss her for a bit of auto tune but allow our ears to be raped by gaga, current black eyed peas and the rest of the shit out atm

[Schaft96]

She should've been in the final 2 w/scotty I love her she is amazing auto tune or not

[MarianaPecora]

america is dead

[borce92]

bravo

[MusicSaysEverythinq1]

Her Voice Sounds 10x Better Livee. Its Still Sounds Amazing Studio Version. But I Think U can Really Feel The Love / pain In The Song And Her Voice.

[Yunginspirit]

@MusicSaysEverythinq1 - She's PERFECTION!!!

[renduke]

@MusicSaysEverythinq1 i agree she should have ALL her recordings done live...when she is live she has a rivetting passion second only to the Great Ray Charles.....her live i who have nothing should actually be nominated for a grammy it's that good

[dwl1124]

actually if you would listen to the live performance it sounds the same as here. its her voice....retard

[92024able]

at :35....sounds so weird

[jacobeb1]

I love this song and her live performance, but the studio version is dripping with AutoTune....

[quenquen411]

@jacobeb1 I wouldn't go as far to say autotune... she just has a raspy airy voice, and when she is in the studio... they do a studio cut, she is right up on the mic with the production quality sound, and you can hear all the wtf type richness, not autotune, we will have to agree to disagree... it's a whistle in her voice.

[quenquen411]

@jacobeb1 or autotune, lol

[ReinhartFan4Ever]

@jacobeb1

Who cares if it might sound AutoTune at some parts...she's still A-MAZ-ING!

[bluewhale18]

itunes guys

support our girl

[floresjanuary26]

Haley's is way better than Jordin Spark's version!

[keybee02]

In my opinion, she sings much better live.

[AutumnNatashaCole]

@keybee02 I completely agree.

[art11art12]

@keybee02 and in today's world that's a rare and beautiful talent!

[CallieAnn111]

@keybee02 Imeant to like that sorry

[CallieAnn111]

@keybee02 Yupp

[LookingAtYouFool]

@keybee02

In interviews she has indicated the AI studio recordings were generally done in one take. I imagine when she puts out an album the tracks will be painstakingly perfected.

[angelica100rios]

@keybee02 lol i was just thinking that AND NO SINGER I CAN THINK OF SINGS GOOD LIVE :) lol

[gnarlyincubus]

@keybee02 That's because they do these studio recordings in 1 take. I think Haley's recordings turn out amazing considering they are recorded, edited, and produced in like 2 days!

[jkjklmnop1]

@Orangey222

I highly doubt they used an auto tune, though I'm sure she has enhancers and effects on her voice.. ;) It would be morally wrong to put auto-tune on Haley!!

[Crazyjrocksteehee]

the most amazing song in the world! the string instruments add intensity and feeling and emotion to the song(: best idol song!

[3131phil]

my favorite part of the live version was when she sings "the window pane", and then does her classic raspy growl,,,then the studio totally changes it...why???

[RightOfNowhere]

I love the way she sings.

I wish I could sing like that.

[Ascanian]

She is so damn gooooooooood! Her voice is impeccable! The Extremely few and far between have voice such as hers.

[travelerjb]

This girl has style, grace and class along with that edge you just can't train in a singer. You either have it, or you DON"T. The other contestants didn't have the charisma this girl has. Her dad and mom must be proud beyond measure. I am expecting great things from Haley in the coming years.

[PartyMixes2011]

For anybody who thinks she autotunes her voice, listen to her song "Blue" both live and studio version, its the best I've heard at changing pitches.

[MsDarion1994]

she blew jordan sparks out of the water :)

[shootingstar1314]

Haley was BY FAR THE BEST!! I cried when she got voted off because she is way better than Lauren!! Haley and Scotty should've been the final two! I LOVE U HALEY!!! (: 

[iWishiWereiMaginary]

There is no fucking autotune. Yes, I hear what you're talking about. NO, it's NOT autotune. It's just her voice. Why the hell would they want to autotune a MILLISECOND of this song?

God forbid dumbass "fans" come here to rant about something that has nothing to do with her gorgeous voice, anyway.

[Orangey222]

@iWishiWereiMaginary Dude, if you can't here the autotune from 1:33 to 1:37 then you must be deaf.

[iWishiWereiMaginary]

@Orangey222 If you can hear autotune, then you have must have a hearing problem.

[memyselfandemi]

Absolutely beautiful. (:

[Orangey222]

The autotune is fucking awful. Way to ruin a fucking amazing voice. Also, why are these mixed and edited so poorly? They honestly sound two dimensional...Jimmy Iovine should be ashamed of himself.

[bluewhale18]

@Orangey222 this is actually how her studio voice sounds

i know it's unbelievable, but believe it

the girls amazing

[Orangey222]

@bluewhale18 No, I mean her voice here has autotune on it (when it clearly doesn't need it.) Listen at 1:33 where it becomes obvious. She does have an amazing voice, so I can't comprehend why they would do that to these recordings.

[mcgeeestrang]

@Orangey222 no you're right, there definitely is autotune on this version and thats why i only watch the live version. the autotune takes away the raspiness of her voice(N) HALEY'S THE BEST AND THE SEXIEST:D

[mrjuansgreat]

@Orangey222 I use auto tune,thats not auto tune thats talent

[Orangey222]

@mrjuansgreat Oh Lord...

Look, fool, I know she's talented. She's my favorite contestant EVER to appear on the show (I usually can't stand to watch AI.) I really do appreciate her voice.

There...now have I proven that I'm a dedicated fan? It doesn't change the fact that there's goddamn autotune on her voice in this recording, and it makes it almost unbearable for me to listen.

[Crazyjrocksteehee]

@mrjuansgreat wow u just admitted u use auto tune! fail!

[hailyhunterr]

This is in the top 3 best idol performances AMAZING

[mohammadjj]

EPIIIIIC!

[imhereletsparty1]

**Jaw dropping!** 

[angel2942]

I'm a big James fan but when I hear Haley sing this song for the first time I was amazed and she was my second fav on AI her voice is angelic

[forevahiswifey123]

omg scotty beat HER!! SUTTIN WRONG HERE LOL

[vlin28]

Best best best ever

[saruhteee]

Newest Haley obsession. This girl is out of this world

[sorelsuareztube]

Her live performance chills me better.

[MasterPiece7771]

She is the BEST American Idol contestant of all times along with Adam Lambert !!!

no one can sing like them live. just amazing!

[DroseATW1]

WOW her live was amazing.... but studio!!! rediculous she is the next american idol...

(for sure)

[dHoyhee10]

her live performances were really stunning,,but hearing the studio version of her songs gives you a perfect time to relax...

amazing..purely amazing..

[litotesone]

Simply, amazingly and beautifully profound. Her gifts will serve generations and longer still. Bravo!

[2numberz]

One of a kind, major beautiful pure voice.

[wetbobo]

This girl's voice is nothing short of chillingly cool ;-) I know compression does a lot to make her voice pop out into your ears on this particularly quiet recording, but damnit, just LISTEN to her voice and how damned PURE it sounds! It's simply gorgeous. I have to say, it's probaby the BEST voice in today's pop (if it were out there right now competing on radio) and isn't it refreshing to hear purity and great vocal range + great vocal control + great vocal (natural!) pitch + clarity? AhhhhH!

[skyterror963]

you know if haley was vote out suck it america she can sing better than anyone



[AventurasdeBolita]

Thumbs up if you think that the final 2 should be haley and james :)

[AventurasdeBolita]

Thumbs up if you think that the final 2 should he haley and james :)

[DaelynNicole24]

Would it be too much if I said that this song gave me goosebumps? -3

&&nd all you "Haley Haters", if you hate her so much, why did ya click on the video in the first place?

[namkrow33]

stupid autotune SUCKS and makes her sound like Miley cyrus

[bluewhale18]

@namkrow33 no autotune here my friend

her studio voice is actually incredible

i'm addicted

[vaneeez]

@bluewhale18 what about 2:15 :S it really sounds like autotune :(

[bluewhale18]

@vaneeez the songs finished by then?

[saruhteee]

@bluewhale18

No.... if you've ever watched her performances or heard her sing, you would know that that's simply the incredible range and versatility in her voice; not autotune, lol .

[xosamanthahunxo]

One question: Why the fuck did she lose!

[ThisIsEmilyyy]

SHE gives me goosies <3

[Mrscookiejonas]

she sang better live, but any ways i love her voice

[davan666]

@Mrscookiejonas it's bc singing in the studio is harder then singing live

[Mrscookiejonas]

she sang better live... i love her voice

[Brookeypoo5]

im a HUGE fan :) i love u haley!!!

[lieytAA]

I heard this 1000000 times

[Jaguarprowler]

Uniquely talented & beautiful Lady...her voice memorizes me so!  I need to hear more Haley in my future, before I have withdrawals. She will no doubt surpass the other two Idol contestants career-wise, as far as diversity goes (possibly Acting which I think she would be good at). I wish the Country bumpkins well in their own endeavors.

[thepapiulookin]

she is amazing!!! and I wont be watching AI this tuesday.. she is the true winner

[danaaax01]

Too much autotune... This doesn't show her growling and her real voice. The live performance was incredible. Listen to that instead! Still, it's a good recording but live was better.

I was totally waiting for a James and Haley final. ):

[lstrebe]

She even sounds better recorded if that's possible. WOW!

[lesdiie]

♥The Best! 

[awsomekid630]

why the fuck do we have 2 cuntry singers in final 2

[MarianaPecora]

so good, but short

[bluecastaway]

I was rooting for her and i was 100% sure she was going to the finale... Oh well guess that's the way life is for Haley... But definitely the dark horse of the competition and probably the most talented in the group... Support you all the way Haley... You are my American Idol :)

[howyoudoindirector]

@bluecastaway Right ON!

[masterhogan1]

reminds me of when chris daughtry finished third...he should as well. but he was 100 times more successful than taylor hicks and cathrine mcfee combined.

[bluewhale18]

unbelievable recording

i'm gonna miss this girl

[krizziaviloriaful]

bye.... haley :( by the way, you 3 are my bets... from the very start it's thia, pia, lauren, my scotty, and you..

[mxandadamlover]

Well she went home. There's no point in watching the Hee Haw finale next week. But I'm pretty sure in the real world she'll out sale both finalists.

[bornforriding]

@mxandadamlover we'll see about that.

shes great in the studio and on stage. she is gonna go far, and shes got some pretty bang'n legs. keep rocking those legs Haley!