She's considers herself irish and therefore should be regarded as Irish - Northern Irish people have dual nationality - they can choose how to be regarded! As for her not being able to dance - Geri couldn't dance and she was in the Spice Girls and Sarah Harding is the WORST dancer I have ever seen! Thank god Nadine got in Girls Aloud - if she didn't they wouldn't be around today, her voice has been instrumental to their success!
When you add Nadine in Girls Aloud, it adds a sugar coat to a song then the song is not too harsh. Because Nadine's voice is not to make a song that harsh, but to sugar coat the song so that the record would be successful.
Dancing? Gerri didnt want her because she couldnt dance? DUH thats easy you just give them dancing lessons. You cant not put someone through coz they cant dance. Now she can dance!! Gerri cnt dance!!
She should of never of even been allowed to enter the british version if she saw herself as irish, but now her and her whole family have gone to america so she didnt see herself as very irish either lol. Dont get me wrong shes talentend and pretty and would be no GA without her.
Britain is not just British anymore which is the same as any other country. Ethnic diversity, you know? Your way of thinking is pretty close-minded, in my opinion. It shouldn't matter where you come from - if you have talent, you should be allowed to enter a talent show, wherever it's situated.
Really! then tell me why she lives beside me in Bridgend Co Donegal you asshole...and she was born just inside the border in the irish republic...just because you live in a stable it doesnt make you a horse!
Hi, just so you know, Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom but not Britain. They're quite separate! Check your passport or any other official document and I'm pretty sure it'll say 'The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland'. It's not possible to be both British and Irish unless you have duel citizenship. A lot of people aren't aware of this 'cause you don't learn much Irish history in school in Britain but now ya know! ;o) Wiki Great Britain and all shall be clear!
youre talkin shit!!!! popstars is for everybody!!!! and just cause shes livin in america it doesnt mean that she doesnt see herself as an real irish!"!!!
She is from Derry, Northern Ireland and if she was an athlete she would be competing on team GB, or NI for the Commonwealth Games.....She is also Catholic, which makes her Irish not British....She has got her family new life in LA , with business to run rather than leave them in a poor struggling, civil war damaged city...good for her.....
I know very few Irish Catholics, that are thrilled to be refered to as British... That is the whole point of the years of civil war, to be independent of the British etc....
The War of Independence was to achieve freedom from the British.Catholicism was the religion of the majority of nationalists,so for world favour the nationalists emphasised their Catholic faith,eg during the Eucharistic Congress 1932,as a means of distinguishing themselves from the British Empire.There were a minority of Catholic unionists,and Protestant nationalists.I'm just saying,being Irish and Catholic doesnt automatically make you a nationalist.The majority would be, but not in every case.
I am a practicing Catholic and English, so who am I dumb...I know plenty of English Catholics though, I am in the minority at my parish ....I know that in Ireland, if you are Catholic you consider yourself Irish, the whole point of the IRA campaign was to seperate Ireland from the UK and become a United Ireland....Nadine always says she is Irish...
All my family are Irish and Catholic, I was the first to be born outside Ireland so I know what you mean... BTW sorry for calling you a dumb fuck, I didnt mean it.
I like the fact that this show doesnt seem to have any real dramatics...like dramatic music and slow mo. Seems like a rela reality show...where as x factor has moved waaay beyond and made it into a soap opera...good or bad?? im not sure
LOL "Geri says you cant dance" a bit rich considering she was the only one in the Spice Girls that didnt go to dance school and still couldnt dance even after lessons! :@
Aww...I felt bad for her when she started crying.<3 Nadine is my fav in GA and they probably would not have gotten as far without her. And she sure can dance now. She was amazing in the Tangled Up tour.<3<3<3
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Wow. The judge is really "hands on" with Nadine, give her a hug and a smooch. I can't see Simon Cowell, a judge from American Idol, giving one of his girl contestants a friendly smooch. Is this just a British thing, or has this judge crossed the line?
lol .. and who was geri halliwell an ex spice gir? and the only one of them that could sing was melanie C, so she dont really have room to talk about anyones dancin, dont even know how she was a judge but ah well nadines amazing!! xxx
I am sure that Louis was talking crap when he said that about Geri...It'd be silly for her to say that someone as talented as Nadine shouldn't be in the final ten just because of her not-so-great dancing skills.
Geri was the worst dancer in the Spice Girls and she's always said that she was the one who struggled the most. Plus, when Sarah had problems with her dancing Geri was the first to cheer her up and say there was nothing to cry about
Well atleast it was only the dancing that was being critizied. Though dancing shouldn't be as big of a deal so i personally wouldnt even think of critizing it
Exactly, even Nadine's worshipper Louis (and his assistant) saw that in the very first days.
I bet he just said that about Geri for a more dramatic moment and to make himself look like a hero - He's always been a twat and Geri was the nicest judge
Being a fan of the Spice Girls....I am absolutely shocked to hear that Geri said Nadine can't dance. For the love of God...Geri was the WORST dancer in the Spice Girls and even her solo efforts showed no improvement. What a jerk!!
Geri did that?!?! WHAAA!?!? im so glad Nadine made it
fastnsexy 10 months ago
Anyone who thinks Rihanna is more talented than Nadine has been brainwashed obviously. Rihanna has NO talent. Fact.
CartoonPropaganda 1 year ago
0:37 she was secretly flipping Louis the bird.
savemeharpo 1 year ago
its funny now if you look at any girls aloud tour video she is an amazing dancer!
rossmartino8 1 year ago
i could pull that girl no baw , she would be an easy grip for me ; )
TheDJscrue 1 year ago
everytime i look at nadines face I want to cum
TheMelfen 1 year ago
Nadine Coyle is a race traitor tramp.
GEORGE2B2B 1 year ago
thumbs up if your from derrry :D
NIALLinHD 1 year ago 4
she was a retard back then and she still a fuckin loser!
Iwillbetall 1 year ago
@Iwillbetall
Dear Aoife
Thats a little harsh coming from a girl
You must be a real Dublin scumbag
37zeus37 1 year ago
@Iwillbetall lol u jealous?
dazzlegal22 1 year ago
@dazzlegal22
clearly jealous.. of the girl that was so desperate for fame she lied about her age. Nah. Wouldn't really fancy being her!
Iwillbetall 1 year ago
@Iwillbetall dont be mean you jealous hater. grow up.
xbecxxx 10 months ago
at 0:37 is Nadine givin Louis the finger! haha
ERstat77 2 years ago 4
lol!!!! i would do that xxx
BigGrinKatiexoxo 1 year ago
Patrick you are catholic you prick
wolvesfansupermick 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate catholics
Patrick3183 2 years ago
You have a catholic name - You dumb fucker! LOL
tyrone71280 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cheryl Cole is soooooo much better than Nadine Fuckin Coyle
honestguy77 2 years ago
They are both as good as each other!! If Nad waz not in it, it would not be the same just like if Cheryl didn,t make it..
Polar379 2 years ago
its like i thought it was about the singing not the dancing
Lehcarxx 2 years ago
She's considers herself irish and therefore should be regarded as Irish - Northern Irish people have dual nationality - they can choose how to be regarded! As for her not being able to dance - Geri couldn't dance and she was in the Spice Girls and Sarah Harding is the WORST dancer I have ever seen! Thank god Nadine got in Girls Aloud - if she didn't they wouldn't be around today, her voice has been instrumental to their success!
emeraldpixie 2 years ago 4
Geri couldn't dance either... Nadine has become a very good dancer
emmyjo720 2 years ago 8
Nadine has improved her dancing so much over the 7 years
StarletDancer01 2 years ago 2
When you add Nadine in Girls Aloud, it adds a sugar coat to a song then the song is not too harsh. Because Nadine's voice is not to make a song that harsh, but to sugar coat the song so that the record would be successful.
irismey 2 years ago
Dancing? Gerri didnt want her because she couldnt dance? DUH thats easy you just give them dancing lessons. You cant not put someone through coz they cant dance. Now she can dance!! Gerri cnt dance!!
puzzlepony 2 years ago 7
you don't have to be a good dancer to know who can dance -.-' stupid people
Romeu021 2 years ago 2
"Geri Halliwell says you can't dance, Nadine, she does not want you in the group". . . ,
"WTF Geri Halliwell can't sing OR Dance".
"I have overruled Geri Nadine. . . ", Well thank F, common sense has prevailed.
What an F'ng soap opera, imagine almost having your dreams dashed by a wrinkly talent free old chav like Geri F'ing Halliwell!
calicomoonchild 2 years ago 2
Stupid Geri Halliwell :@
OMG, Nadine is a year older than me in this video
And looks about ten years older
No offence to Nadine, I love her lots :)
I just look about seven
hannahriot15 2 years ago 3
Geri said that she could not dance....pot calling the kettle black. Nadine has more talent than all of the spice girls put together....
homaiya 2 years ago
who cares whether she is british or irish when you look as good as her
mallow443322 2 years ago
OMG shes just a baby
Bengu69 3 years ago
i dont even think he would even give a shit if nadine wasnt irish
but its alrite for him to say things like that about nicola
i hate gerri and louis
WE ALL KNOW GERI DANCES LIKE CIARA,BEYONCE,CHERYL AND PUSSYCAT DOLLS
girlsaloudfan121 3 years ago
after they turned the cammera off her and the ma rid the liven jesus out of him and then the da give him wan to:-))))))
jerryfrompsiloveyou 3 years ago
i cant believe how much nadine has changed from here, her hair is completly different and her accent
katielainespicer2 3 years ago
she can dance now shes awsome shes my favourite Go Nadine
ColourfulFunxx 3 years ago 3
lovely singer but then check out 'gypwin' on you tube as well
gypwin 3 years ago
i hate louis!
gcam85432007 3 years ago
At 0:44 listen to her! she is a great singer and i love her accent!
mrjuliansmith 3 years ago
She should of never of even been allowed to enter the british version if she saw herself as irish, but now her and her whole family have gone to america so she didnt see herself as very irish either lol. Dont get me wrong shes talentend and pretty and would be no GA without her.
WhoDaresWinzz 3 years ago
fuck off...it doesn't matter where ur from nd just cuz dey own a pub in america doesn't mean she thinks she's american now..fuck off ya retard
simongeasley 3 years ago 2
Ofcourse it matters why should an irish girl take the place of a british girl on a british talent show.
WhoDaresWinzz 3 years ago
FYI She's Northern Irish so that /is/ British.
ollytennant 2 years ago
I know but she sees herself as irish not British thats my point .
WhoDaresWinzz 2 years ago
Britain is not just British anymore which is the same as any other country. Ethnic diversity, you know? Your way of thinking is pretty close-minded, in my opinion. It shouldn't matter where you come from - if you have talent, you should be allowed to enter a talent show, wherever it's situated.
crisis1991 2 years ago
fyi nadine says she's irish
lambie1985 2 years ago
shes irish you twat!
223fox 2 years ago
Comment removed
ollytennant 2 years ago
She's Northern Irish fyi you double twat! Do some research before you unnecessarily insult me, you silly plum.
ollytennant 2 years ago
Really! then tell me why she lives beside me in Bridgend Co Donegal you asshole...and she was born just inside the border in the irish republic...just because you live in a stable it doesnt make you a horse!
223fox 2 years ago
What the hell? Since when? She's from Derry in NORTHERN Ireland. And yeah like I'm gonna believe that.
ollytennant 2 years ago
well then if shes from ireland what does that make her!..polish..typical english prick!
223fox 2 years ago
She's from Northern Ireland so is Northern Irish. TYPICAL IRISH FOUL MOUTH STUBBORN PRICK! Why are you arguing about this!? WTF! Get a life.
ollytennant 2 years ago
i dont know if this helps u but in an interview she did say she wanted eoghan to win coz he was from her ome town derry
lastakat 2 years ago
Exactly, which is in NORTHERN Ireland :)
ollytennant 2 years ago 2
try wikipedia-ing it doofus
ollytennant 2 years ago
Hi, just so you know, Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom but not Britain. They're quite separate! Check your passport or any other official document and I'm pretty sure it'll say 'The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland'. It's not possible to be both British and Irish unless you have duel citizenship. A lot of people aren't aware of this 'cause you don't learn much Irish history in school in Britain but now ya know! ;o) Wiki Great Britain and all shall be clear!
fifi298 2 years ago 3
Oh really. Cool thanks :)
♥
ollytennant 2 years ago
Cool. I knew it was part of the UK but i didnt no it was separate 2 Briatin. Thanks for the lesson. Lol!
doctorwho35 2 years ago
youre talkin shit!!!! popstars is for everybody!!!! and just cause shes livin in america it doesnt mean that she doesnt see herself as an real irish!"!!!
Kosovaluver 3 years ago
She is from Derry, Northern Ireland and if she was an athlete she would be competing on team GB, or NI for the Commonwealth Games.....She is also Catholic, which makes her Irish not British....She has got her family new life in LA , with business to run rather than leave them in a poor struggling, civil war damaged city...good for her.....
emmyjo720 2 years ago
being catholic doesnt make you irish...
AislingOwens 2 years ago 3
I know very few Irish Catholics, that are thrilled to be refered to as British... That is the whole point of the years of civil war, to be independent of the British etc....
emmyjo720 2 years ago
The War of Independence was to achieve freedom from the British.Catholicism was the religion of the majority of nationalists,so for world favour the nationalists emphasised their Catholic faith,eg during the Eucharistic Congress 1932,as a means of distinguishing themselves from the British Empire.There were a minority of Catholic unionists,and Protestant nationalists.I'm just saying,being Irish and Catholic doesnt automatically make you a nationalist.The majority would be, but not in every case.
AislingOwens 2 years ago
Catholics are cool.
They don't use condoms so I can get to fuck Nadine bareback.
rubusroo68 2 years ago
You dumb fuck, Im catholic and English
BristolCliftoniteGuy 2 years ago
So am I....
emmyjo720 2 years ago
I am a practicing Catholic and English, so who am I dumb...I know plenty of English Catholics though, I am in the minority at my parish ....I know that in Ireland, if you are Catholic you consider yourself Irish, the whole point of the IRA campaign was to seperate Ireland from the UK and become a United Ireland....Nadine always says she is Irish...
emmyjo720 2 years ago
All my family are Irish and Catholic, I was the first to be born outside Ireland so I know what you mean... BTW sorry for calling you a dumb fuck, I didnt mean it.
BristolCliftoniteGuy 2 years ago
I done her and Louis.EASY
danieljohnomalley 3 years ago
welll , booohooo Geri , she can dance know :) , she the bst 1 by far
nickthenextcr7 3 years ago 3
Nadine my idol :)!!!Love her!!!
Darkbaby57 3 years ago
I like the fact that this show doesnt seem to have any real dramatics...like dramatic music and slow mo. Seems like a rela reality show...where as x factor has moved waaay beyond and made it into a soap opera...good or bad?? im not sure
Alexanderdenman 3 years ago 5
0:39 nadine flips everyone off...lol
shariotoflove 3 years ago
LOL "Geri says you cant dance" a bit rich considering she was the only one in the Spice Girls that didnt go to dance school and still couldnt dance even after lessons! :@
allaniain 3 years ago 6
shes the lead singer in the band, true - they'd be no girls aloud without Nadine.
misselias 3 years ago 4
i hate the way they drag these thing out. Its not fair on the contestants cos its their hopes and dreams. Just tell em yes or no!!
bus140808 3 years ago 10
Aww...I felt bad for her when she started crying.<3 Nadine is my fav in GA and they probably would not have gotten as far without her. And she sure can dance now. She was amazing in the Tangled Up tour.<3<3<3
Bo0mbaby 3 years ago 17
Hey did anyone notice Louis trying to kiss Nadine onthe lips towards the end...that sly guy I tell you!!
letsnirvana 3 years ago
he did
JadeJellybaby444 3 years ago
im sure i would
TomEd171 2 years ago
haah her dad when louis tell her shes in XD
does i big sigh of relief and falls back in his chair haha aww
evertonGirlx 3 years ago
nadine looks just like her mom
candygirlcandie 3 years ago
shes well hot
stanopan 3 years ago
SHES TINY !
XxfallenpetalsxX 3 years ago
no she can't but bless her she tries
AjAlexK 3 years ago 2
lmao
fejnifd 3 years ago
nadine is sooooo much nicerrr than rihanna
conway2k7 3 years ago 17
screw rihanna
Leppicon77 3 years ago 11
@conway2k7
no, rhianna is waaaaaaaaaay much more talented than nadine!
sweetcheeks275 1 year ago
Back then Nadine looked so innocent and sweet but now since 2005 she is a naughty biatch!
Zetara86 4 years ago
a hot naughty bitch
Leppicon77 3 years ago 7
She Wasn't That Excited! =|
lucyllew 4 years ago
yeah but she wasn't dat gud den
megabronagh 4 years ago
she wasnt dat excited!!!!! if i got thro i wud hav been histerical!! loser
blahx091 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow. The judge is really "hands on" with Nadine, give her a hug and a smooch. I can't see Simon Cowell, a judge from American Idol, giving one of his girl contestants a friendly smooch. Is this just a British thing, or has this judge crossed the line?
lovecuthbert 4 years ago
louis walsh is not british
mememee07 4 years ago 5
For fuck sake GB and the UK are different things.
Hodgey1989 3 years ago 6
Ha she cleverly stuck up her finger at him!
cailineire00 4 years ago 8
louis walsh is an ass. she can dance now.. and shes the most talented of the girls.... lets be honest.
jogamissbonito 4 years ago 10
Look at her now.......With Jesse..the hott gardener from DH...Who would have thought?
tigerishirish69 4 years ago
lol .. and who was geri halliwell an ex spice gir? and the only one of them that could sing was melanie C, so she dont really have room to talk about anyones dancin, dont even know how she was a judge but ah well nadines amazing!! xxx
Caitrionaxxx 4 years ago 7
I am sure that Louis was talking crap when he said that about Geri...It'd be silly for her to say that someone as talented as Nadine shouldn't be in the final ten just because of her not-so-great dancing skills.
Geri was the worst dancer in the Spice Girls and she's always said that she was the one who struggled the most. Plus, when Sarah had problems with her dancing Geri was the first to cheer her up and say there was nothing to cry about
CyPam 5 years ago
Stop bitching about Geri you immature lot
charmedreturnz 5 years ago
erm u cant sing and dance at the same time people.... n as for geri i think she rules n has sold millions or records so i cant be the only one, x
djmatty06 5 years ago
Nadine is the best!! she cant sing and dance!!!
Tuuperoinen 5 years ago
does it really matter geri..
haydemunch 5 years ago
nadine can dance and she is a fab singer so lol:P
madgirl132 5 years ago
Geri can't dance OR sing, Nadine is fab
gmd5 5 years ago
Well atleast it was only the dancing that was being critizied. Though dancing shouldn't be as big of a deal so i personally wouldnt even think of critizing it
mkr85 5 years ago
Did you see how Nadine gave Louis the middle finger when wiping a tear away?! Hahaha good one!
imogen1604 5 years ago
nadine rules :)
abbeynainsley 5 years ago
but she wasn't criticising nadine for no reason she wanted them all to look gr8, nadine isn't a very good dancer either anyway
Sugari 5 years ago
Exactly, even Nadine's worshipper Louis (and his assistant) saw that in the very first days.
I bet he just said that about Geri for a more dramatic moment and to make himself look like a hero - He's always been a twat and Geri was the nicest judge
CyPam 5 years ago
geri is the worst dancer I have ever seen... How dare geri to say that to nadine... But nadine has inprove inher dancing thats a good thing...
lllcuddlelll 5 years ago
Being a fan of the Spice Girls....I am absolutely shocked to hear that Geri said Nadine can't dance. For the love of God...Geri was the WORST dancer in the Spice Girls and even her solo efforts showed no improvement. What a jerk!!
fashionistakim 5 years ago 2
geri, you cant dance
learn before you say anything
;)xx
bonnieodonnell 5 years ago
Diney <3
amydunsta 5 years ago
Geri is an idiot
splitchick59 5 years ago
that was so good
cheryl01 5 years ago